This volume low-key made me cry. I don’t know why, but somehow all the characters came back, including past ones we haven’t seen for ages. It felt so nostalgic. I mean, I read Bungo Stray Dogs about four years ago, and it completely changed my life. It made me fall in love with reading, and it pushed me toward classics without making me feel intimidated by them. I read Crime and Punishment like it was a piece of cake, and honestly, that still feels unreal to me. I never imagined I could do that one day.
The fact that I’ve kept reading classics over and over just because of Bungo Stray Dogs and the influence it had on my love for literature is so impressive to me. I’m genuinely proud of how a manga can do that to someone. How a story can do that. How something this unique can change your life.
Yes, it has its ups and downs, but once you read the first volume, that first experience is so amazing, so fresh and new. I just loved it. I love Bungo Stray Dogs. I’ve been reading the light novels, all the side manga versions, watching the anime and the movies. I’ve consumed so much BSD content and all the book references that now I feel like I understand literature better. I know my reading style, I know what kind of books to choose.
But even though all that is true, the plot has been pretty weak lately, and I haven’t really been enjoying it. Especially in this volume, where they keep bringing in themes about God, power, the divine, and destroying God. I really don’t like those themes. They feel unreal and unrealistic. I mean, come on. Something divine, something as powerful as God, and you just casually build a plot around destroying it? I hate that.
I’ve come across many stories with similar plots, and I always end up disliking them. It feels disrespectful in a way. Beliefs and deeper meanings get neglected, and I don’t support that. I don’t feel comfortable reading it. Every time the story goes in that direction, I just think, is this really all you’ve got? When it could have done so many things better.
And Atsushi, oh my God. You blink, you die. If you don’t blink, you still die. But don’t worry, Atsushi will save you. He was cool for once in this volume, but still. Come on.
We still haven’t reached the end, and I honestly feel like it’s getting close. They were so close in this volume. I don’t know how many volumes we have left until everything is over, and that thought is heartbreaking. It gives you goosebumps if you’re attached to these characters.
I started this series when I was a teenager, and now I’m in my twenties. That’s a huge difference. The impact Bungo Stray Dogs had on me is real. When I first found it, watched the first episode, and read the manga, I was at one of the lowest points in my life. And it made me happy. This world, this story, these characters made me happy. They helped me discover new authors, new books, and fall deeper in love with literature. They opened the door to so many amazing works throughout literature history. And That kind of impact is rare.
*This review is for Bungo Stray Dogs as a whole, not just this volume. I will add the same review under every volume.*
BSD is good, but not great. I like the character designs and the art is amazing. But it's way too overhyped in my opinion. There are some things I didn't like or found pretty dumb.
1. Everyone is a genius syndrome: 10 characters or even more have an insanely high IQ. if everyone is a chess god playing mind games, then nobody actually is. At some point it stops being 'clever' and starts being exhausting. Like let someone actually miscalculate ONCE without it being part of some bigger plan. BSD intelligence is stylized, exaggerated, plot driven, "genius aura", and characters know things because the story says so. So when someone says "Dazai has an IQ of 200" That number means basically nothing. Just "Please believe he is very smart." Same with Ranpo. An IQ of 200+ is not even useful in real world context. Authors use it like a power level. I prefer characters with realistic intelligence. Because they could exist, you could meet them, and you wouldn’t realize what they're doing until it’s too late. That’s way scarier than an IQ stat pulled from someone’s ass. Actually, where do BSD IQ numbers even COME from?? Asagiri did not run these characters through a Wechsler test. There is no in universe scene where Dazai sits down with a psychologist, Mori hands out scantrons, or Ranpo speedruns Mensa. IQ in BSD functions like "This character is very smart, please clap." Dazai's IQ is 200, Fyodor's is 200 (people argue about Dazai's and Fyodor's IQ, but I really don't care if it's 200 or 215), Ranpo's is 215, Mori's is 175+, Ango's is 170+, a lot of people say Chuuya's is also secretly 150+. So what does "smart" even mean anymore? It becomes a badge, a hierarchy, a fandom flex instead of a special skill/trait and something demonstrated. If everyone is a genius, no one is. There’s no contrast.
2. plot armor thicker than concrete: some characters should’ve been dead five arcs ago. I don't actually mind the plot armor that much, but sometimes it's a bit ridiculous. It gets a bit annoying when every loss is secretly a win in disguise.
3. Fake ugliness: This is the one that bothers me the most. BSD talks about the dark, ugly sides of humanity but then makes them hot, tragic, romantic, and conveniently justified. That’s not ugliness that’s aestheticized suffering. BSD wants to say "Look how ugly and broken humans are." But everyone is hot, everyone is exceptional, everyone has poetic trauma. So the ugliness is symbolic, sanitized, controlled. It’s shown from a distance. The characters are extremely competent, hyper talented, admired by the narrative, rarely truly powerless. They’re bad at living in a romantic way.
4. The female characters are badly written: not necessarily offensively bad but thin. They’re underdeveloped compared to the men, their trauma is glossed over, they rarely drive the plot in a way that isn’t immediately overshadowed, and when they are competent the narrative doesn’t linger on their inner world the same way it does with the guys. Meanwhile the male cast gets internal monologues, philosophy dumps, elaborate mind games and mythologized suffering.
5. The tragic backstory inflation: people don't like when someone complains about this, and I think all the backstories are interesting, but practically every character has the most insane past ever. Everybody’s parents are dead, abused, betrayed, experimented on, orphaned, shot, drowned, and emotionally obliterated. What bothers me is that for a lot of characters (especially female ones) we get a tragic past, one flashback, maybe one emotional speech, and then it’s never meaningfully addressed again. No long-term consequences, no behavioral patterns that actually complicate the plot, no messy coping, regression, or contradictions. It’s always maximum suffering, minimum specificity. Abuse. Experiments. Dead family. Betrayal. Rinse, repeat. Nuanced backstories would be things like loving parents who still fucked you up unintentionally, doing something morally wrong by choice and having to live with it, being privileged but empty, being loyal to the wrong people for too long, slow corruption instead of "one horrific event", failure without a villain to blame. BSD almost never does that. It prefers "Something horrible happened TO me" instead of "I made a decision that shaped who I became." And that’s why it all feels glamorized. If the character is a victim of extreme circumstances, the narrative can always go "see? not their fault." Nobody has to sit in the discomfort of agency. That’s also why characters like Dazai get sanitized by the fandom. If his past is framed as 'he was broken and saved" then people can pretend he was secretly good all along when the whole point should’ve been that he’s functional, charming, and still morally fcked. BSD could have been so much stronger if it trusted quieter uglier human flaws instead of trauma shock value. Less "experimented on as a child" and more "I chose wrong and kept choosing wrong."
6. The characters are not relatable: You always see many people being like "I kin Dazai" but in my opinion, they are not relatable at all. BSD characters don’t feel like people, they feel like concepts wearing drip. The constant galaxy brain IQ, hyper optimized trauma, perfectly timed suffering, flawless execution of plans…creates distance. You’re not watching someone LIVE, you’re watching someone perform a role the author assigned them. Real people misread situations, act out of insecurity, get lucky instead of smart, regret things that weren’t "necessary", fail in boring embarrassing ways. BSD characters almost never do that. Even their breakdowns are aesthetic. Even their mistakes are "actually part of the plan." That kills relatability HARD. You can always relate in theory. But it’s surface level "I relate to their trauma" or "I relate to feeling lost" and not "I recognize this person’s thought process" or "I’ve made that exact dumb choice" That’s why they feel unreal. It also ties back to the IQ thing. When everyone’s a genius the story stops being about human limitations. You can’t project yourself into someone who’s always five steps ahead, because most of us are just trying to survive step one without tripping over our own shoelaces. BSD wants you to admire its characters. It rarely lets you recognize yourself in them.
7. Sometimes the story also can be straight up boring. Not all the time, but enough that you start checking how many chapters are left like "okay… are we done cooking or what?" To me, early arcs were meh, middle arcs slapped, later arcs felt like Asagiri just kept stacking twists because of escalation addiction.
BSD’s biggest crime is that it pretends to be deeper than it is. It wants to be profound, literary, morally complex, but it rarely commits to letting characters genuinely fail, rot or face consequences. It’s not bad. It’s just overhyped. Dazai especially feels more like a concept and less like a person. Everything in BSD is so glamourized. It refuses to make anything actually genuinely uncomfortable. Nobody is allowed to be truly pathetic, cruel, or wrong without the story going "actually, this was all justified." Like. Let someone be ugly and stay ugly. Also the overhyping of characters is wild. The fandom treats them like they’re the most complex beings ever written when half their personality is: smart, sad, hot, morally ambiguous (but not really). Everyone likes something different, of course, but instead of epic despair, operatic suffering, genius masterminds above consequence, I prefer just people being messy. So yeah. BSD isn’t trash. But it’s not the literary holy text people act like it is. It’s a stylish, sometimes fun, sometimes frustrating series that thinks it’s deeper than it actually commits to being. It's interesting, dramatic, fun at times. But relatable? Grounded? Human? Nah.
Important: If anyone ever reads this, don't take this review too seriously. I was just bored and decided to write a long review. Nothing against BSD or people who enjoy it. I actually used to be a huge BSD fan from like 2020 to 2024. And I glazed it a LOT, so I know how much people in the fandom exaggerate. I would give it 2 or 3 stars for how enjoyable it had been for me. The time in the fandom had been fun, but the story and characters itself are not something I like that much.
I fell in love with the BSD universe because of the complex characters and their different beliefs. The Decay of Angels was an amazing inclusion in the story, and each member had a unique goal to fulfill.
For example, Fyodor wants to purify the world and erase the "sin" of ability users, while Fukuchi wants to create a single unified state to bring all of humankind together. These are fascinating ideas to think about.
While I love the complexities of these characters, the execution of the story often drags on and feels unbelievable. There are not enough lasting consequences, too many fake-out deaths, and I believe too many characters have been added. I have been disappointed by the current storyline, but I will continue to read the series for the characters.