What do you think?
Rate this book
Through the Green Glass Door
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC REVIEW:
5⭐
WOW!!!
🍃 Everything about this book is so well thought out, well planned, developed, and written. I'm genuinely blown away with this world, the magic system, the history of the Fates and the Creator and the steward magic. The idea of a portal fantasy is unique and one I haven't seen done a lot, and so captivating.
✨ The Christian themes were so wonderfully present throughout the book! The Creators do clearly resembled the Holy Trinity, and the energy renewal reminded me of manna in the old testament. It was brilliant!
💚 Scout, our FMC, was an easy character to root for. She's just a normal girl with normal likes and dislikes who is thrown into this different world, alone and with magic. She's confident in herself and strong-willed. Despite her confusion and feelings of isolation and discomfort, she pressed on. Her strength was admirable. Since she was new to the world and didn't know ANYTHING, she had to learn a lot. It was a nice way for me as the reader, to learn things as people told her them for the most part (Alaric's pov definitely helped)
🍃 Speaking of... Alaric, the MMC, is everything you could want, honestly. He's fierce and mysterious and a fire-steward for Pete's sake. And in the words of Scout, "he's hot". Literally and figuratively 😉🤭 But besides that, I really felt for him. He's an outcast and most everyone treats him awfully 😭 I wanted to yell at them that "he's not your enemy!!!!!". I also love his bond with Mireille--the healer oozed comfort.
✨The "imprint" idea?? LOVE 😘 Like the way they felt so drawn together was amazing, their chemistry and tension was so good. I also love how he can read minds, there were a couple scenes where she thought about him and he was like 😏😏😏 LOLLLL it just adds another layer to their building relationship
💚Also the magic system and world 🤯🤯🤯 how the different factions each have different gifts and specialties, their traditions, how they harness magic, and the channeling magic were so cool. SO in depth.
🍃The writing was witty and easy to understand and it's just so well written overall. The author really knows how to write characters with depth.
✨All the characters invoked feelings. Like you either loved em or hated him and that's exactly how a book should be. It was so easy to get sucked into this story and this world, I literally could not put this book down! Like I could gush about this book for days, oh my goodness, y'all.
💚I wanna write so much but I can't spoil anything 🤭🤭. Just know that I was shocked and sad at the end. can't wait for book 2!
5⭐
WOW!!!
🍃 Everything about this book is so well thought out, well planned, developed, and written. I'm genuinely blown away with this world, the magic system, the history of the Fates and the Creator and the steward magic. The idea of a portal fantasy is unique and one I haven't seen done a lot, and so captivating.
✨ The Christian themes were so wonderfully present throughout the book! The Creators do clearly resembled the Holy Trinity, and the energy renewal reminded me of manna in the old testament. It was brilliant!
💚 Scout, our FMC, was an easy character to root for. She's just a normal girl with normal likes and dislikes who is thrown into this different world, alone and with magic. She's confident in herself and strong-willed. Despite her confusion and feelings of isolation and discomfort, she pressed on. Her strength was admirable. Since she was new to the world and didn't know ANYTHING, she had to learn a lot. It was a nice way for me as the reader, to learn things as people told her them for the most part (Alaric's pov definitely helped)
🍃 Speaking of... Alaric, the MMC, is everything you could want, honestly. He's fierce and mysterious and a fire-steward for Pete's sake. And in the words of Scout, "he's hot". Literally and figuratively 😉🤭 But besides that, I really felt for him. He's an outcast and most everyone treats him awfully 😭 I wanted to yell at them that "he's not your enemy!!!!!". I also love his bond with Mireille--the healer oozed comfort.
✨The "imprint" idea?? LOVE 😘 Like the way they felt so drawn together was amazing, their chemistry and tension was so good. I also love how he can read minds, there were a couple scenes where she thought about him and he was like 😏😏😏 LOLLLL it just adds another layer to their building relationship
💚Also the magic system and world 🤯🤯🤯 how the different factions each have different gifts and specialties, their traditions, how they harness magic, and the channeling magic were so cool. SO in depth.
🍃The writing was witty and easy to understand and it's just so well written overall. The author really knows how to write characters with depth.
✨All the characters invoked feelings. Like you either loved em or hated him and that's exactly how a book should be. It was so easy to get sucked into this story and this world, I literally could not put this book down! Like I could gush about this book for days, oh my goodness, y'all.
💚I wanna write so much but I can't spoil anything 🤭🤭. Just know that I was shocked and sad at the end. can't wait for book 2!
December 16, 2025
This was one of those stories that pulls you through the pages and quietly refuses to let go.
Through The Green Glass Door is a portal fantasy with rich element magic, a perfectly balanced grumpy sunshine dynamic, found family, and writing that feels almost lyrical at times. The descriptions were so vivid and intentional that I didn’t just read this book, I stepped into it. Every setting felt alive, textured, and real, like I could reach out and touch it.
The magic system was immersive without being overwhelming, woven naturally into the world rather than dumped on the page. If you love portal fantasies, magic that feels elemental and powerful, and are needing a unique new adventure this one is absolutely worth your time.
I cannot wait to see what happens next!
Through The Green Glass Door is a portal fantasy with rich element magic, a perfectly balanced grumpy sunshine dynamic, found family, and writing that feels almost lyrical at times. The descriptions were so vivid and intentional that I didn’t just read this book, I stepped into it. Every setting felt alive, textured, and real, like I could reach out and touch it.
The magic system was immersive without being overwhelming, woven naturally into the world rather than dumped on the page. If you love portal fantasies, magic that feels elemental and powerful, and are needing a unique new adventure this one is absolutely worth your time.
I cannot wait to see what happens next!
February 28, 2026
Through the Green Glass Door is a phenomenal read that takes you on a beautifully written ride through portals, different worlds, and characters. The characters are captivating and every turn of the page makes you want to read faster just to know whats going to happen next. I love that this book envelops you into this beautiful place and feelings within the book! A well written beautiful master piece! If you havent read it yet you definitley should! You wont be disappointed!
March 5, 2026
Didn’t grab me like I thought it would but the ending made sure I’d check out the sequel!
Review of advance copy received from Author
If you are looking for a YA portal fantasy with a reluctant heroine and elemental gifts, and of course with a love story thrown in, this might be your next read. Katie Zeliger creates a world I want to visit and can't wait to read more about in the next book.
Scout is dragged to England to spend the summer with her great-aunts who she doesn't remember. She assumes this summer between high school and college will be boring.
Boy is she wrong.
Her family has some mysterious history she begins to slowly uncover while she's there - but the greenhouse and the pantry are strictly off-limits, and Aunt Zelda doesn't even want her looking at a photo album. There's also something about a secret book...and her eccentric aunties, though completely opposite in personality, seem united in not telling her everything she wants to know. She learns more than she bargained for when she somehow ends up stepping into another world where people have elemental gifts and she catches the attention of one fire-stewarding man in particular.
The girl who didn't think she'd ever belong anywhere finds people she feels like she belongs with but has to decide if it's worth the risk.
Scout comes across as a genuine teenage girl, with all the emotions and confusion that comes along with it. She's relatable and likeable, as are her parents, aunties, and other characters in the book. My favorite part of the story was seeing how the people in the other world used their elemental gifts (and one or two other things that happen there that that I don't want to spoil!). The villain is crafted in such a way that makes even the reader's heart fill with dread when thinking about her. I was invested in the characters and what happened to them - and might have laughed or gasped out loud more than once.
I appreciate that the ending, while clearly not the end of the whole story, came at a good stopping point. That being said, this story will still be living in my head rent free until the sequel comes out because I am emotionally invested in the main characters and the worlds they're from (both our world and the world created by the author).
I recommend this book to people who are looking for an exciting story involving fantasy, alternate universes, elemental gifts, romance (actual romance, not smut), and plot twists. It's not high fantasy but it's fun and exciting.
Notes from a grammar nerd/editor: I read this book before it was proofread, and there were several times grammatical errors pulled me out of the story. However, the story itself was constructed well enough that I didn't have any trouble getting back into it. I expect the errors will be caught in proofreading, so I have hope this will not be a problem for future readers!
I gave this book four stars because it is a very enjoyable story with believable characters and lots of excitement (especially in the second half). While not life-changing, this book did hook me. I would probably re-read and I do recommend it to anyone who enjoys this genre.
Scout is dragged to England to spend the summer with her great-aunts who she doesn't remember. She assumes this summer between high school and college will be boring.
Boy is she wrong.
Her family has some mysterious history she begins to slowly uncover while she's there - but the greenhouse and the pantry are strictly off-limits, and Aunt Zelda doesn't even want her looking at a photo album. There's also something about a secret book...and her eccentric aunties, though completely opposite in personality, seem united in not telling her everything she wants to know. She learns more than she bargained for when she somehow ends up stepping into another world where people have elemental gifts and she catches the attention of one fire-stewarding man in particular.
The girl who didn't think she'd ever belong anywhere finds people she feels like she belongs with but has to decide if it's worth the risk.
Scout comes across as a genuine teenage girl, with all the emotions and confusion that comes along with it. She's relatable and likeable, as are her parents, aunties, and other characters in the book. My favorite part of the story was seeing how the people in the other world used their elemental gifts (and one or two other things that happen there that that I don't want to spoil!). The villain is crafted in such a way that makes even the reader's heart fill with dread when thinking about her. I was invested in the characters and what happened to them - and might have laughed or gasped out loud more than once.
I appreciate that the ending, while clearly not the end of the whole story, came at a good stopping point. That being said, this story will still be living in my head rent free until the sequel comes out because I am emotionally invested in the main characters and the worlds they're from (both our world and the world created by the author).
I recommend this book to people who are looking for an exciting story involving fantasy, alternate universes, elemental gifts, romance (actual romance, not smut), and plot twists. It's not high fantasy but it's fun and exciting.
Notes from a grammar nerd/editor: I read this book before it was proofread, and there were several times grammatical errors pulled me out of the story. However, the story itself was constructed well enough that I didn't have any trouble getting back into it. I expect the errors will be caught in proofreading, so I have hope this will not be a problem for future readers!
I gave this book four stars because it is a very enjoyable story with believable characters and lots of excitement (especially in the second half). While not life-changing, this book did hook me. I would probably re-read and I do recommend it to anyone who enjoys this genre.
February 3, 2026
4,5 stars, rounded to 5
Through the Green Glass Door is a Christian YA portal fantasy and the debut novel of Katie Zeliger.
As a Chrisitan I was a bit hesitant at first because of the worldbuilding explained in the glossary, since the world behind the portal was created by three sisters. The author assured me that this book has no LDS background, so I gave it a chance and didn’t regret it!
As far as these creators go - this book is the first in a series (trilogy?) and not everything is explained yet. There are a couple of things - [minor spoiler] like the assumption that the main character’s family is cursed or that her relatives are witches - that could make a Christian uncomfortable. As far as this first book goes I was personally fine with what was presented, but I’m hoping to see a few clarifications and especially a bit more obvious Chrisitan content in the sequels, since it is promoted as Christian fiction.
That just as an information for my fellow Christian readers who try to be discerning about what they read.
As far as the story goes - I enjoyed this book immensely and was immediately invested in the story. Scout was a relatable main character and her reluctance about visiting her (unknown) great aunts alone for her summer, including her 18th birthday, was more than understandable.
But instead of moping around she tried to make the best of the situation, to get to know her relatives and to learn more about her family’s history.
Once she “falls” through the portal she’s completely on her own. She has to learn whom to trust while getting along in an unknown world with unknown rules and new sides to herself.
There’s a lot going on in this magical world with a dark history which seems to be catching up with the people Scout is learning to call friends.
I loved the mystery and how we learn bit by bit what happened especially to Alaric before Scout arrived.
While I did love Alaric as a character and thought there was a lot of potential between him and Scout as a couple, I’m generally not a big fan of fated bonds or mind reading. It makes the emotional connection look forced instead of giving the reader the chance to see it grow. It also seemed a bit presumptuous of Scout to think Alaric was romantically interested in her so early in the book. As a reader I saw no real sign of that besides his inner conflict because he (in contrast to Scout herself) was aware of the bond they involuntarily shared and it felt to me like her assumption came out of nowhere. So let’s see where this romance goes. So far it was my least favorite part of the book, but I really enjoyed the rest and since I loved both characters I didn’t mind too much.
I’m eager to learn more about both sides of this magical portal and am already looking forward to reading the sequel of this wonderful debut!
* Thank you to the author for letting me read an advanced copy of this book. I leave this review voluntarily and the expressed opinions are my own.
Through the Green Glass Door is a Christian YA portal fantasy and the debut novel of Katie Zeliger.
As a Chrisitan I was a bit hesitant at first because of the worldbuilding explained in the glossary, since the world behind the portal was created by three sisters. The author assured me that this book has no LDS background, so I gave it a chance and didn’t regret it!
As far as these creators go - this book is the first in a series (trilogy?) and not everything is explained yet. There are a couple of things - [minor spoiler] like the assumption that the main character’s family is cursed or that her relatives are witches - that could make a Christian uncomfortable. As far as this first book goes I was personally fine with what was presented, but I’m hoping to see a few clarifications and especially a bit more obvious Chrisitan content in the sequels, since it is promoted as Christian fiction.
That just as an information for my fellow Christian readers who try to be discerning about what they read.
As far as the story goes - I enjoyed this book immensely and was immediately invested in the story. Scout was a relatable main character and her reluctance about visiting her (unknown) great aunts alone for her summer, including her 18th birthday, was more than understandable.
But instead of moping around she tried to make the best of the situation, to get to know her relatives and to learn more about her family’s history.
Once she “falls” through the portal she’s completely on her own. She has to learn whom to trust while getting along in an unknown world with unknown rules and new sides to herself.
There’s a lot going on in this magical world with a dark history which seems to be catching up with the people Scout is learning to call friends.
I loved the mystery and how we learn bit by bit what happened especially to Alaric before Scout arrived.
While I did love Alaric as a character and thought there was a lot of potential between him and Scout as a couple, I’m generally not a big fan of fated bonds or mind reading. It makes the emotional connection look forced instead of giving the reader the chance to see it grow. It also seemed a bit presumptuous of Scout to think Alaric was romantically interested in her so early in the book. As a reader I saw no real sign of that besides his inner conflict because he (in contrast to Scout herself) was aware of the bond they involuntarily shared and it felt to me like her assumption came out of nowhere. So let’s see where this romance goes. So far it was my least favorite part of the book, but I really enjoyed the rest and since I loved both characters I didn’t mind too much.
I’m eager to learn more about both sides of this magical portal and am already looking forward to reading the sequel of this wonderful debut!
* Thank you to the author for letting me read an advanced copy of this book. I leave this review voluntarily and the expressed opinions are my own.
March 26, 2026
I inhaled this book.
For the first 30%, it’s more of a cozy, slow start in the beginning. For the other 70%? I made the mistake of reading it as I was going to bed because I finished it at THREE in the morning.
Scout's just graduated high school, and is at a loss on what to do with her life because she's done whatever was told was best for her. Those next steps are Yale, go into STEM, and become just like her mom (which is a complicated relationship). I wouldn't refuse Yale, but I know many high schoolers wrestle with the same thoughts Scout does: "What is my own path?"
Consistently throughout the book, hardly any character wants to tell Scout the truth. You can feel her frustration. Even though I’m in my late twenties, I understood Scout interjecting, being occasionally abrasive, and asking hard questions because otherwise no one would tell her anything. TLDR: the name “Scout” is quite poignant.
Once she accidentally steps through the portal into Landow, it’s over for you. Enjoy the ride, because I felt that’s where the author shined. The world building, lore, powers, and factions were interesting concepts with its own well-placed limits and consequences. What does it mean to live in a world where powers are normal, and what would it look like when people want to selfishly take it for themselves?
Also, thank goodness, the romance was earned. In fact, I gravitated towards Alaric’s POV. Maybe it’s due to being older and seeking something more literary, or maybe it’s due to the absolute YEARNING on this man.
I'd say comps to this story are Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe meets Avatar the Last Airbender.
Note: I read it on my kindle, but purchased an experience box from the author's website that had a lot of themed goodies and a signed paperback. (Would recommend, I think she only has a couple left!)
For the first 30%, it’s more of a cozy, slow start in the beginning. For the other 70%? I made the mistake of reading it as I was going to bed because I finished it at THREE in the morning.
Scout's just graduated high school, and is at a loss on what to do with her life because she's done whatever was told was best for her. Those next steps are Yale, go into STEM, and become just like her mom (which is a complicated relationship). I wouldn't refuse Yale, but I know many high schoolers wrestle with the same thoughts Scout does: "What is my own path?"
Consistently throughout the book, hardly any character wants to tell Scout the truth. You can feel her frustration. Even though I’m in my late twenties, I understood Scout interjecting, being occasionally abrasive, and asking hard questions because otherwise no one would tell her anything. TLDR: the name “Scout” is quite poignant.
Once she accidentally steps through the portal into Landow, it’s over for you. Enjoy the ride, because I felt that’s where the author shined. The world building, lore, powers, and factions were interesting concepts with its own well-placed limits and consequences. What does it mean to live in a world where powers are normal, and what would it look like when people want to selfishly take it for themselves?
Also, thank goodness, the romance was earned. In fact, I gravitated towards Alaric’s POV. Maybe it’s due to being older and seeking something more literary, or maybe it’s due to the absolute YEARNING on this man.
I'd say comps to this story are Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe meets Avatar the Last Airbender.
Note: I read it on my kindle, but purchased an experience box from the author's website that had a lot of themed goodies and a signed paperback. (Would recommend, I think she only has a couple left!)
Review of advance copy received from Author
4.5 ⭐️
I've recently realized that portal fantasy is not my favorite type of fantasy, simply because I prefer to fully submerse myself in a different world, and I don't like knowing the characters could stumble out of that new world back into this one at any time (which is probably why The Horse and His Boy was my favorite of the Narnia books, because it didn't have that element). With that said, I thoroughly enjoyed this portal fantasy. Let me tell you why.
I found Scout (the FMC) to be relatable and realistic. Her character immediately pulled me into the story, and there were enough mysterious elements surrounding her and her aunties to keep me invested right from the start. I also enjoyed her struggles once she "fell" through the portal, and the way she learned and grew through them.
Alaric (the MMC), is a troubled character, but one I felt compassion for. I liked that his character took time to soften, to reach the point he did by the end of the book. If it had happened more quickly, I think it wouldn't have felt right. He has a lot of trauma haunting him, and reasons to keep walls up. But there were always little glimmers of someone else, someone who yearns for love and connection, underneath the fiery (literally) exterior.
The world building, descriptions, and overall storytelling were great, and I think fans of portal fantasies will appreciate this one (and even not-so-portal-fantasy fans, like me 😉). A solid debut! I look forward to the second book, especially after that ending!
I've recently realized that portal fantasy is not my favorite type of fantasy, simply because I prefer to fully submerse myself in a different world, and I don't like knowing the characters could stumble out of that new world back into this one at any time (which is probably why The Horse and His Boy was my favorite of the Narnia books, because it didn't have that element). With that said, I thoroughly enjoyed this portal fantasy. Let me tell you why.
I found Scout (the FMC) to be relatable and realistic. Her character immediately pulled me into the story, and there were enough mysterious elements surrounding her and her aunties to keep me invested right from the start. I also enjoyed her struggles once she "fell" through the portal, and the way she learned and grew through them.
Alaric (the MMC), is a troubled character, but one I felt compassion for. I liked that his character took time to soften, to reach the point he did by the end of the book. If it had happened more quickly, I think it wouldn't have felt right. He has a lot of trauma haunting him, and reasons to keep walls up. But there were always little glimmers of someone else, someone who yearns for love and connection, underneath the fiery (literally) exterior.
The world building, descriptions, and overall storytelling were great, and I think fans of portal fantasies will appreciate this one (and even not-so-portal-fantasy fans, like me 😉). A solid debut! I look forward to the second book, especially after that ending!
Review of advance copy received from Author
First review and read of 2026.
What a wonderful book! I really like it when writers use the hook of that side of the family you don't know, a side that holds more mysteries than answers. Scout is one of the most sensible and realistic protagonists I've read in a Portal Fantasy story. How far would you go to return home?
Characters
This, for me, was one of the strongest points of the story. The secondary characters really had presence, but without overshadowing the main ones. Scout deals (without giving away any spoilers) with one of the most real problems for a young woman about to graduate: following or rebelling against the expectations of others. Although she was sometimes compliant, she brought out her inner warrior in many scenes.
On the other hand, Alaric remained a mysterious figure for most of the book. Although I wanted to know more about his past, I appreciated that not everything was revealed because it would have been too much information. Also, I really enjoyed the interplay between the two narratives at the end of the book. The author knows what she's doing!
By the way, I'm already eager to see more of the true villain in the sequel. Finally, not someone morally gray, but purely evil, based on what they showed. This is going to get interesting 🔥
Worldbuilding
There was very interesting lore from the beginning. The concept of this new world is different from others I've read, however, I felt they explained more than demonstrated how things worked. I was more intrigued by the family secrets.
SPOILER Section:
Romance
Strangers-to-lovers, slow burn, dreams, no spice, communication. I'll leave it to your imagination to go read it 💗😉
Conclusion
I'll definitely be waiting for the sequel. There's so much potential in the unexplored elements. Also, something tells me there's going to be a lot of yearning in the next entry. It's for everyone looking for a breath of fresh air in this Portal Fantasy area. Thanks for the Arc! Also, congratulations on the debut 🔥🎉😄
Characters
This, for me, was one of the strongest points of the story. The secondary characters really had presence, but without overshadowing the main ones. Scout deals (without giving away any spoilers) with one of the most real problems for a young woman about to graduate: following or rebelling against the expectations of others. Although she was sometimes compliant, she brought out her inner warrior in many scenes.
On the other hand, Alaric remained a mysterious figure for most of the book. Although I wanted to know more about his past, I appreciated that not everything was revealed because it would have been too much information. Also, I really enjoyed the interplay between the two narratives at the end of the book. The author knows what she's doing!
By the way, I'm already eager to see more of the true villain in the sequel. Finally, not someone morally gray, but purely evil, based on what they showed. This is going to get interesting 🔥
Worldbuilding
There was very interesting lore from the beginning. The concept of this new world is different from others I've read, however, I felt they explained more than demonstrated how things worked. I was more intrigued by the family secrets.
SPOILER Section:
Romance
Strangers-to-lovers, slow burn, dreams, no spice, communication. I'll leave it to your imagination to go read it 💗😉
Conclusion
I'll definitely be waiting for the sequel. There's so much potential in the unexplored elements. Also, something tells me there's going to be a lot of yearning in the next entry. It's for everyone looking for a breath of fresh air in this Portal Fantasy area. Thanks for the Arc! Also, congratulations on the debut 🔥🎉😄
January 12, 2026
Thank you so much, Katie Zeliger, for the opportunity to read and review an ARC of your debut fantasy!
I had a great time reading this. I will definitely be grabbing a copy for my shelves once it releases. Through The Green Glass Door travels from the US to the UK where during a summer visit with her aunties, Scout, a college bound senior in HS, discovers family secrets and accidentally slips into another world altogether.
The story gave me a bit of the nostalgia of Narnia while being fresh with elemental magic and Christian themes woven into the narrative. I loved her storytelling and feel like the author did an excellent job building a creative new world and magic system. I stayed up way too late to finish reading this and had to ruminate over the last several chapters all day before I could formulate thoughts for this review. That kind of ending is the best, and I am so excited for her to continue this series because I am already itching for book two.
You will definitely want to grab this.
And, the cover art is absolutely stunning!!
Well Done & Congratulations Katie on your Debut!
💖 no spice
🤭 minimal (if any? I can’t remember) explicit language
C/TW: death, murder, loss of a loved one, mild war themes, corrupt leaders, drugging
I had a great time reading this. I will definitely be grabbing a copy for my shelves once it releases. Through The Green Glass Door travels from the US to the UK where during a summer visit with her aunties, Scout, a college bound senior in HS, discovers family secrets and accidentally slips into another world altogether.
The story gave me a bit of the nostalgia of Narnia while being fresh with elemental magic and Christian themes woven into the narrative. I loved her storytelling and feel like the author did an excellent job building a creative new world and magic system. I stayed up way too late to finish reading this and had to ruminate over the last several chapters all day before I could formulate thoughts for this review. That kind of ending is the best, and I am so excited for her to continue this series because I am already itching for book two.
You will definitely want to grab this.
And, the cover art is absolutely stunning!!
Well Done & Congratulations Katie on your Debut!
💖 no spice
🤭 minimal (if any? I can’t remember) explicit language
C/TW: death, murder, loss of a loved one, mild war themes, corrupt leaders, drugging
Review of advance copy received from Author
Family secrets abound and once everything comes to light who knows where things will end?
Scout is a great FMC, as someone who is just graduating high school she has her more immature tendencies, but the spunk and compassion for others more than makes up for it.
Case and point: "Have you ever heard of the bystander effect?" She crossed her arms defensively over her chest. "It's when everyone sees something bad happen and thinks someone else will do something to help, so no one does anything?" She answered. "I refuse to let that happen."
Read that again, just in case it didn't sink in the first time because, that's a trait more of us should get behind.
A solid read if you enjoy:
Portal Fantasy
Found Family
Slow Burn Romance (push and pull)
Magic Classes based on the Elements (fire, earth, water, wind)
Hot take? But I love the representation of sweet elderly women. Aunt Effie and Manter Mireille are such soft and wise women I wish more people had in their lives. And although Aunt Zelda is a bit standoffish, I think she brings a counterbalance to Effie that's needed.
Ends on a cliff hanger, but everything wraps up nice enough to not be too desperate for immediate answers.
I received this book as an ARC.
Scout is a great FMC, as someone who is just graduating high school she has her more immature tendencies, but the spunk and compassion for others more than makes up for it.
Case and point: "Have you ever heard of the bystander effect?" She crossed her arms defensively over her chest. "It's when everyone sees something bad happen and thinks someone else will do something to help, so no one does anything?" She answered. "I refuse to let that happen."
Read that again, just in case it didn't sink in the first time because, that's a trait more of us should get behind.
A solid read if you enjoy:
Portal Fantasy
Found Family
Slow Burn Romance (push and pull)
Magic Classes based on the Elements (fire, earth, water, wind)
Hot take? But I love the representation of sweet elderly women. Aunt Effie and Manter Mireille are such soft and wise women I wish more people had in their lives. And although Aunt Zelda is a bit standoffish, I think she brings a counterbalance to Effie that's needed.
Ends on a cliff hanger, but everything wraps up nice enough to not be too desperate for immediate answers.
I received this book as an ARC.
January 17, 2026
This was such a fun story! It follows a recent high school graduate who visits her aunts for a summer, and accidentally goes through a portal to another world. I loved the cast of characters and how the story unfolded! There were so many tiny twists and turns throughout. I think any high school student would love this book!
Language: none
Violence: mild terror and wounds
A few very brief mentions of drunkenness, Vivid dreams and terrors, A family thought to be cursed, as they are bonded to a greenhouse as gatekeepers of the portal. The family is thought to be witches by the town but they are not and explicitly says those practices are wrong. There are some traditions/rituals/ceremonies from the fantasy world, nothing violent or creepy.
💕Romance: There is a romance thread as the book progresses, and one kiss at the end of the story. It’s very cute and sweet.
My Age Rating: 14+
I really liked this whimsical tale! I believe it’s going to be a series, as the book ended on a cliffhanger! If Through the Green Glass Door interested you, go check out Katie Ziegler’s page! This book releases on January 26th.
Language: none
Violence: mild terror and wounds
A few very brief mentions of drunkenness, Vivid dreams and terrors, A family thought to be cursed, as they are bonded to a greenhouse as gatekeepers of the portal. The family is thought to be witches by the town but they are not and explicitly says those practices are wrong. There are some traditions/rituals/ceremonies from the fantasy world, nothing violent or creepy.
💕Romance: There is a romance thread as the book progresses, and one kiss at the end of the story. It’s very cute and sweet.
My Age Rating: 14+
I really liked this whimsical tale! I believe it’s going to be a series, as the book ended on a cliffhanger! If Through the Green Glass Door interested you, go check out Katie Ziegler’s page! This book releases on January 26th.
Review of advance copy received from Author
If you are looking for a good up and coming fantasy book this one is great! My friend @overbookedandunderpaged gave me the amazing opportunity to beta read her book! It was such a great fantasy and I can’t wait for it to come out!
The story was so in depth and well thought out! I was drawn to the world and wanted to learn more about what was happening and its secrets. The writing made all the scenes so picturesque and you felt like you were there in the story! It was also unlike anything that I have read yet in my reading journey. It was so great to have a story that felt unique!
The characters were well developed and you felt connected to their stories! I also can’t wait to see more from the FMC and MMC🤭 (trying not to spoil literally anything lol)
I would say more but I don’t want to give too much away about the story before the release date! Seriously go check this author out and her book! She also has some amazing aesthetic posts on her page that helps you get an ever better idea of the vibes for the story!
The story was so in depth and well thought out! I was drawn to the world and wanted to learn more about what was happening and its secrets. The writing made all the scenes so picturesque and you felt like you were there in the story! It was also unlike anything that I have read yet in my reading journey. It was so great to have a story that felt unique!
The characters were well developed and you felt connected to their stories! I also can’t wait to see more from the FMC and MMC🤭 (trying not to spoil literally anything lol)
I would say more but I don’t want to give too much away about the story before the release date! Seriously go check this author out and her book! She also has some amazing aesthetic posts on her page that helps you get an ever better idea of the vibes for the story!
January 2, 2026
Oh man, what a journey with this book! I have to admit, it took me a while to get invested. Whether it was just my busy life season or a lack of interest in a modern day girl with an attitude (I get plenty of that in real life), I’m not sure, but once she went through the portal into the “mirror world” - I was hooked!
You definitely get attached to the main female character, Scout, and the main guy, Alaric. Their outcast style bond makes them an interesting pair that you root for as they try to figure out what is going on in their lives and who to trust as they try to find out the truth, while fighting for their lives.
I felt like this story was a good mix of Divergent and Avatar the Last Airbender with just a small touch of X-men thrown in - at least those are the fandoms I know that I can compare it to. But an original take on pieces of those stories that was well done.
The main downside - now I have to wait for the sequel!
You definitely get attached to the main female character, Scout, and the main guy, Alaric. Their outcast style bond makes them an interesting pair that you root for as they try to figure out what is going on in their lives and who to trust as they try to find out the truth, while fighting for their lives.
I felt like this story was a good mix of Divergent and Avatar the Last Airbender with just a small touch of X-men thrown in - at least those are the fandoms I know that I can compare it to. But an original take on pieces of those stories that was well done.
The main downside - now I have to wait for the sequel!
Review of advance copy received from Author
Rounded to 4⭐️
Portaaaalll fantasyyyy ahhhhh!!!
I loved how atmospheric this book is. Before entering the other world, the mystery builds and we only get bits and pieces, but that really only adds to the moments things come together!
I loved the market and other indications of the world’s colliding or the thin spaces that allowed them to kinda merge.
Glimpses into MMC Alaric’s world, Landow, were my favorite. He and several elements to the story rather reminded me of Zuko and Avatar: the Last Airbender.
My biggest thing, I wish there had been a bit more development in some areas.
Like her dad telling Scout more or she found something before she even met them, or we’d gotten more glimpses into conversations or her spending time with them so we felt what happened between them a little deeper. Like Scout’s reaction didn’t quite seem… as justifiable?
Also with Moss, I wish we’d gotten more interaction with her since she and Rhydian are who Scout grows closer too but I dunno, certain things didn’t hit me as I think they were supposed to? Admittedly, my attention was kinda divided with holiday goings-ons so maybe I was just distracted.
There are so many unique aspects I loved: how families worked and their connections. The different powers and lore.
The ending was amaaaazing!! Several things I wasn’t expecting! I was glad that it ended with definitely wanting more but it’s not such a cliffhanger to be angry the next book isn’t out yet, ha!
A great debut from the author, who shared ARC’s and I’m so glad to be on the team for! I was not required to give a positive review, all opinions are my own.
Portaaaalll fantasyyyy ahhhhh!!!
I loved how atmospheric this book is. Before entering the other world, the mystery builds and we only get bits and pieces, but that really only adds to the moments things come together!
I loved the market and other indications of the world’s colliding or the thin spaces that allowed them to kinda merge.
Glimpses into MMC Alaric’s world, Landow, were my favorite. He and several elements to the story rather reminded me of Zuko and Avatar: the Last Airbender.
My biggest thing, I wish there had been a bit more development in some areas.
Like her dad telling Scout more or she found something before she even met them, or we’d gotten more glimpses into conversations or her spending time with them so we felt what happened between them a little deeper. Like Scout’s reaction didn’t quite seem… as justifiable?
Also with Moss, I wish we’d gotten more interaction with her since she and Rhydian are who Scout grows closer too but I dunno, certain things didn’t hit me as I think they were supposed to? Admittedly, my attention was kinda divided with holiday goings-ons so maybe I was just distracted.
There are so many unique aspects I loved: how families worked and their connections. The different powers and lore.
The ending was amaaaazing!! Several things I wasn’t expecting! I was glad that it ended with definitely wanting more but it’s not such a cliffhanger to be angry the next book isn’t out yet, ha!
A great debut from the author, who shared ARC’s and I’m so glad to be on the team for! I was not required to give a positive review, all opinions are my own.
January 4, 2026
A Debut book that did not feel debut! TTGGD will keep you turning pages as you join Scout on her adventure and discover this new magical world alongside her. I swear the book got better and better as it went. It went from this is cute and whimsical to oh wait, this story has DEPTH. Well thought out and put together story that will have you foaming for book 2!
Well done, Katie!
Well done, Katie!
Review of advance copy received from Author
3.5 ⭐️
I received an ARC from the author. All opinions are my own.
Elements, energy, imprints, portals, family secrets, reluctant female heroine, Chosen One probs...this story has something for every fantasy lover! I enjoyed the dynamic of the FMC and her aunts (snarky and sweet, prickly and precious), and I liked that the real world portion of the story was set (mostly) in England.
I received an ARC from the author. All opinions are my own.
Elements, energy, imprints, portals, family secrets, reluctant female heroine, Chosen One probs...this story has something for every fantasy lover! I enjoyed the dynamic of the FMC and her aunts (snarky and sweet, prickly and precious), and I liked that the real world portion of the story was set (mostly) in England.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Scout's world is turned upside down when she tumbles through a portal into another world. A portal which has claimed her as its keeper against her will.
I enjoyed elements of the story very much. I love the greenhouse portal, and adored Scout's eccentric aunts. I also enjoyed the magic system and the layers of intrigue.
I am not a huge fan of the instant bond kind of romance and wish Alaric and Scout could have found each other differently, but that is just personal preference.
While it was not my personal favourite story, Through the Green Glass Door will definitely appeal to readers who like their fantasy with a dash of romance, strange worlds near our own and ancient mysteries to unravel.
(I received an ARC from the author)
I enjoyed elements of the story very much. I love the greenhouse portal, and adored Scout's eccentric aunts. I also enjoyed the magic system and the layers of intrigue.
I am not a huge fan of the instant bond kind of romance and wish Alaric and Scout could have found each other differently, but that is just personal preference.
While it was not my personal favourite story, Through the Green Glass Door will definitely appeal to readers who like their fantasy with a dash of romance, strange worlds near our own and ancient mysteries to unravel.
(I received an ARC from the author)
April 13, 2026
Ahhhhhhhhh!
This story hooked me from the beginning. Katie does such an amazing job. Man this book was so good. Twists and turns, jaw dropping moments, a SLOOOW BURN. I have no words right now other than I am anxiously awaiting book two! The ending has adrenaline pumping through my body! Thus the scream at the beginning of this review. 😂
This story hooked me from the beginning. Katie does such an amazing job. Man this book was so good. Twists and turns, jaw dropping moments, a SLOOOW BURN. I have no words right now other than I am anxiously awaiting book two! The ending has adrenaline pumping through my body! Thus the scream at the beginning of this review. 😂
Review of advance copy received from Author
I’ll be the first to admit that I am not a big fan of fantasy, but this book was AMAZING! Scout stole my heart from the get go, and her spunky aunts had be giggling like a child. This book is a showstopper!!
January 24, 2026
I really liked some things about this one. Loved the magic system. Loved the portal aspect and the building up to it. Liked the characters. The romance was definitely lacking and was really really slow moving. Overall I enjoyed it as curious about where the story is headed.
February 3, 2026
THIS BOOK IS SO GOOD!!!!!
10/10 I highly recommend it. I can’t wait for the next one!!
10/10 I highly recommend it. I can’t wait for the next one!!
February 12, 2026
This was a captivating story. I also loved seeing how it has changed and grown since I beta read it last year. Scout is our FMC, she lives in the real world, though her entire world gets rocked when she must go spend the summer with her two estranged aunties who act just like you would expect for two eccentric aunties. And I loved meeting both of them. My favorite type of character is the “good guy” who is trying to overcome a stereotype and that is exactly who Alaric is. He is a fire steward living in Landow. He isn’t fully trusted by everyone because of his power. This story was well done and entertaining. It is part of a duology so we know there's plenty more to come and I can hardly wait.
February 28, 2026
Stars: 3.5
Big congrats to Katie on her debut novel! Through the Green Glass Door is full of secrets, tension, suspense, elemental magic, threats, found family, and more. Katie created an interesting world and magic/gift system which I liked. I also enjoyed her descriptive writing; I could really picture the story in my head. This is an interesting, unique read!
This is a slow-build, slower-paced story (emphasis on history of land/people, including flashbacks and dreams), and I get why. This is book one of a duology, so the main conflict and resolution will take place in book two – maybe that’s where some depth will come, too. It’s still engaging, but honestly, the action didn’t really pick up until the last quarter of the book or so. If you don’t like cliffhangers, I would wait to read this until the duology is complete.
At times, the story felt jumpy or disjointed. It also felt like lack of communication, stubborn secrecy, and/or miscommunication drove some of the conflict (personally, not my favorite tropes); I would have loved for more listening and talking things out to allow for depth (rather than mistrust) to grow in relationships. I wanted more conversations between Scout and Alaric, too. Some parts of the story, characters, and relationships felt wide but not necessarily deep (if that makes any sense…).
Overall, I enjoyed reading Through the Green Glass Door, and I’m excited to see what Katie does in book two to conclude everything!
Content: violence/death (not overly graphic), abuse (physical, mental, s*xual) in a character’s past - not described in too much detail, danger/peril, clean romance, clean language but 2 instances of using God’s name in vain, magic seen as a gift
I received an advance review copy from the author, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Big congrats to Katie on her debut novel! Through the Green Glass Door is full of secrets, tension, suspense, elemental magic, threats, found family, and more. Katie created an interesting world and magic/gift system which I liked. I also enjoyed her descriptive writing; I could really picture the story in my head. This is an interesting, unique read!
This is a slow-build, slower-paced story (emphasis on history of land/people, including flashbacks and dreams), and I get why. This is book one of a duology, so the main conflict and resolution will take place in book two – maybe that’s where some depth will come, too. It’s still engaging, but honestly, the action didn’t really pick up until the last quarter of the book or so. If you don’t like cliffhangers, I would wait to read this until the duology is complete.
At times, the story felt jumpy or disjointed. It also felt like lack of communication, stubborn secrecy, and/or miscommunication drove some of the conflict (personally, not my favorite tropes); I would have loved for more listening and talking things out to allow for depth (rather than mistrust) to grow in relationships. I wanted more conversations between Scout and Alaric, too. Some parts of the story, characters, and relationships felt wide but not necessarily deep (if that makes any sense…).
Overall, I enjoyed reading Through the Green Glass Door, and I’m excited to see what Katie does in book two to conclude everything!
Content: violence/death (not overly graphic), abuse (physical, mental, s*xual) in a character’s past - not described in too much detail, danger/peril, clean romance, clean language but 2 instances of using God’s name in vain, magic seen as a gift
I received an advance review copy from the author, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews