Second Helpings

by Dylan Morrison

Sam Adelson has spent over a decade pouring his heart into Silverman's Deli, the beloved Cleveland institution his family has run for seventy-five years. So when a scathing review tanks his business, Sam develops some strong feelings about the critic responsible. Fantasies involving expired clam juice may be involved.

Then Jake Thompson walks through the door—Sam's first love, the one who got away. Reconnecting after twelve years feels like coming home, and having Jake around makes even the chaos of saving the deli feel manageable. But Sam’s fought to move on from the disaster that tore them apart, and now pretending it never happened is becoming more impossible every day.

As Sam falls harder than he ever meant to, Jake's past begins to catch up with both of them. Some recipes are worth perfecting, even when the first attempt was a disaster—Sam just hopes this one doesn't blow up in his face...

Warm, funny, and delectably swoony—a second-chance romance with found family, a chaotic deli dog named Pastrami, and all the comfort-food you could ever want. Perfect for fans of Casey McQuiston and TJ Klune.

Genres: Romance, Contemporary, LGBT, Queer, M M Romance, Cozy, Second Chance

291 pages, Kindle Edition

Expected publication May 21, 2026

Reviews

[Sara · Rating 3 out of 5]

So, I stumbled across this book from a Tumblr recommended post by the author, whose username was familiar to me from fandom circles. His latest m/m romance was available on NetGalley, the post said, and I have a NetGalley account, I said, and, listen. I am also a fanfiction writer, and I am currently working on my own original m/m romance. Let's see how the pros do it!

Second Helpings is a second-chance romance between Jake, a guy who's always about to do something but then doesn't get to do it, and Sam, an uber-demisexual who has only liked one guy ever. (Not precisely shade, as I've also been guilty of writing accidental demisexuals, but a thirty year old gay guy who has had sex before and enjoyed it and yet seems to never have really tried seeking it out since his teens...unusual, I'm just saying.) They get together through a series of trials and tribulations while being surrounded by a likable cast at a deli that reminds me of The Bear without the misery.

One thing I love about writing reviews is that I think deconstructing why I do or don't like something makes me a better writer. This is my excuse for complaining. Here are my complaints:

⭐️ Hearth, the magazine that published the negative review is listed as being roughly in the same class as The New Yorker and Harper's Bazaar. Those are very different magazines: the former a stalwart of American journalism and the latter a fashion magazine that last I looked was verging on catalog-y. They do not themselves share a class.
⭐️ Related: Jake's column was about eviscerating high-end restaurants. As the columnist, Jake's job would have been to visit these restaurants on the publication's dime, including all travel as there is no way he was only reviewing restaurants in the Los Angeles metro area. One month Jake brings them a review about a random small-time deli in Cleveland, Ohio that the magazine did not send him to review. And his editor was like...Okay, sounds great? We'll print it, no further questions? Bruh.
⭐️ So, Jake spent a decade in LA as, I guess, a kept boy/sugar baby to an older celeb? But one who couldn't control his own money? While he also simultaneously had a POPULAR OPINION COLUMN WITH NAME RECOGNITION IN A NEW YORKER-LEVEL NATIONAL PUBLICATION? How in the fuck did he get that job? Did I miss further details about his journalism career? Man, what the hell?
⭐️ And yet somehow, through circumstances we aggravatingly never get a clear picture of, all of this leads to him being back in Cleveland afterward so destitute that his appearance is about one missed meal away from full starving Dickensian orphan? WAIT, I JUST REALIZED IT WAS NEVER REALLY MENTIONED WHETHER HE STOPPED DOING THE COLUMN? WHAT HAPPENED TO THAT?????? That was a real job!!! In his big apology column it's mentioned that he'll never work for that magazine again, but this is all MONTHS later, presumably with multiple issues in between?? Oh my god
⭐️ I've read published novels before by writers who came up in fandom and always rolled my eyes when others called them "fanficcy". But, alright! This one has tells, holy shit! But see this is helpful, because it's made me more aware of what I want to avoid. Like italics overuse. Man, you get so used to seeing them tilting themselves all over AO3 but there's a reason they don't show up as much in published novels. It looks wack as hell on a page and also you shouldn't need to tell me what word to emphasize in a sentence that often.
⭐️ God, I know it can be hard to write characters that suck, especially when they're your POV character. But it was BONKERS how Sam low-key never did anything seriously wrong ever. So he told some stupid lies as a teenager, big deal. His house getting overrun by the worst classmates ever during a party was not the natural consequence of that, although the way he let everybody destroy the place was pretty pathetic. The accident that was the lynchpin upon which his guilt complex was staked? Girl, none of that was his fault either! He was preventing Jake from drunk-driving, he drove very carefully, and the other car hit HIM! His godawful parents then fob off Saint Sam to his aunt, where he's taken away from everyone he knows but decides to just nobly dedicate himself to the deli life running the family business while having no days off or personal needs ever. He's not even selfish with his OWN DOG. And then ultimately his alleged biggest flaw is that he won't ask for help? But then like he does and it's fine?? Dude.
⭐️ All of the above makes Jake, who does make huge fuck-up mistakes, look TERRIBLE by comparison. Considering Sam's paths diverging in a wood are life-partnering with either: Jake, the only guy he's ever liked whose choices have hurt him immeasurably, or the deli, where I guess he can fuck the white herring salad if he ever gets too hard up, I would not have blamed him had he chosen the latter.
⭐️ Especially because the romance, for at least the first half of the book, was not that compelling. They were just hooking up when they were teenagers, which happens real quick, but romance is never discussed, at least not in a timely fashion, so all we ever know is that they were having sex. When Jake re-enters his life, they settle quickly into a relationship so middle of the road friendly that Jake becomes almost equivalent to one of the members of the staff in terms of their connection with each other. I didn't think the romance was that compelling in the second half either, but at least Sam got to experience desire. What did they even like about each other?!
⭐️ At one point it seems to be suggested that Sam has always cooked for Jake, including frequently back in high school. What?! They weren't dating, but Sam, a teenage boy, was having his FWB over at his house and cooking for him with some regularity while living with his parents and also being parentified to look after his little sisters and also Jake had his own house to eat at this whole time? Maybe that was just awkward writing, but god it threw me.
⭐️ This one is just a personal thing that bugs me: I just find it unbelievably depressing when children keep going back to beg for scraps from their shitty parents. Neither Sam nor Jake should have ever bothered with their parents again, sorry. Especially in a narrative that leans so heavily on the found family. Fellas, please love yourselves.

Wow, there is a LOT of text behind that spoiler tag, so much that the three star I put in seems like it was overly generous. The thing is, this book was very readable! I finished it in two sittings and at no point did I ever really want to drop it, the experience of reading it was enjoyable. I don't want to sound mean, though that train has probably already left the station, but I understand why writers like this get big in fandom. There's a hell of a lot to be said for a very easily readable style with tropes that appeal to a wide audience. Anyway, three stars because I'd feel like a dick putting less, but also if you're able to turn your brain off and not think about the actual logistics of real life this is a good read!

My thanks to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC.

[ivanareadsalot · Rating 5 out of 5]

I would like to thank NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.

Second Helpings was so cuuuute! Both MCs were precious, there was some plotty melodrama, and every character was a c h a r a c t e r…even Sam's dog, who I loved so soooo much!

Sam and Jake's return to love from a disastrous life-changing past made me squirm and cry for them both, while simultaneously raging against the adults who'd failed them.

But what stayed with me the most was the "youth-saving+sanctuary for black sheep" vibe that made Silverman's Deli feel like warmth, safety, and home. Sam's greatest inheritance was the artisanal skillset that'd been passed down through generations, which inevitably ended up shaping his body, heart, and mind when he'd needed a safe place to land.

And 17yo Sam needed Silverman's Deli in a way that IS STILL CHOKING ME UP AS I WRITE THIS REVIEW!

Listen, I know that this was fiction, but that fact did not stop how big my feelings were for Sam when he was a kid. Ultimately, Dylan Morrison did an outstanding job with all the characterizations, because of how BEAST-MODE ANGRY I was at Sam's parents.

Sam had all my sympathy and tears from page 1 all the way through to the end. His childhood vulnerability hit me hard, and fortunately Sam had Silverman's Deli AND an endgame auntie to help him through the worst of it.

I was emotionally dialled in from the beginning, and I think part of that had to do with the way Sam and Jake's backstory was revealed using a present-past, back and forth narrative style. This usually trips me out, but in this instance I found every chapter really impactful, especially since their teen years were attention-grabbing chest-kickers.

The past chapters burned me alive, and the present ones healed me. Alongside the bevy of characters, Morrison's evocative narrative style and tone also brought Cleveland's West 9th St + red brick wall deli aesthetic, a hankering for pastrami sandwiches AND Pastrami, the pierogi-loving emotional support doggo, alive for me! I love it when a book gives me nostalgia AND food cravings!

The plot was typical for restaurants staving off urban gentrification and shady real estate developers, but I was intrigued and locked in nonetheless! The story kicked off with a "Kiss of Death" article written by a prat to basically take down Silverman's Deli with lies about food quality. There was m a y b e a sentence or two about the Deli being an acquisition target, but most of the "business" tension came from Sam overseeing the deli alone, while suffering the backlash from the toxic review that had devastated the deli's usual "busy to bursting" traffic to basically nil. His anxiety had some new flavour to it though, as he was assuming the reins from his aunt in like an "ownership" pressure test until she got back into town. So the review was harmful on so many levels and it could not have come at a worse time for Sam…not that there would ever be a good time for a vicious, business-destroying take.

And thennnnnnnnn
Jake Thompson walks through the door
and he immediately gave the kind of "complicated high school ex drama"
I Could read forever.
Pastrami, as romantic and snacky as ever, rebuilt the bridge to their new beginning with his doggy charm and his nose for edible things in pockets.
Sam was understandably crashing out, but also heart eyes because Jake was never not a babe.
And Jake, predictably, proceeded to enchant everyone with his adorable, sunshiney, ballet dance teacher self.

S e a t e d

Give me more!

Jake and Sam, then and now, were lovable sweetlings with the kind of quirky chemistry, easy friendship, and refreshing romantic energy that was enjoyable to read! I could not stop smiling!

And Even though
It was obvious
What the twist was going to be,
I stayed present for how it all went down.
Because it was their moment
And not about me.

Overall, I loved how much Jake and Sam's emotional journey resonated with me. I love that I held my breath through all the hiccups and the heartaches, and that I craved the foooood, and Pastrami's soothing snuffles. I was pretty much a fan of everything this "high school sweethearts to happily ever after" romance served up. Except for Sam's parents, who I will be mad at forever.

Happy to have discovered Dylan Morrison through this endearing romance, and I'm looking forward to whatever comes next because Second Helpings was really lovely!

[Sushmitha · Rating 2 out of 5]

Thanks for the ARC, Netgalley!

I am really tempted not to review this book because I did not find very many redeeming parts about it. I hate leaving negative reviews especially before the book comes out.

Things I liked: the premise, the side characters, the background/set up, the descriptions.

Things I struggled with: I did not enjoy the writing style of the author, not sure if it’s because it’s an ARC or something else but this felt tedious to read. I found myself wanting to skip ahead to move the plot along. (Spoilers ahead) the two major plot points being resolved for no reason, the plot hinging on a decades long miscommunication, the two characters having no growth at all, the two characters who are not teenagers anymore, still acting with the emotional maturity of a teenager, and generally all the dialogue were not for me. I did not like the two MMCs. We learn nothing redeeming about Jake other than he helps out sometimes. I finished this book begrudgingly. I don’t think we get enough flashbacks to see how these characters really care about each other or their redeeming qualities.

Edit: after a few more minutes of reflection, there are more things I truly hated. The text was rambling, the inner monologue was just story narration adding nothing to current plot; some of the plots literally led nowhere —- why was Jake starving, what really happened in the previous toxic LA relationship, what happened to his job, how did his boss approve a column about a restaurant he had never been, and then approve the opposite opinion a few weeks later? What happened to all these parents? How were there not police charges involved with the accident? Why introduce all these side characters with so much detail IF THEY SERVE NO PURPOSE? I genuinely feel that this had almost no romance in it— they hooked up in highschool, without much preamble or explanation, seemed that they were just the only two gay guys each other knew, Jake does some horrendous shit and never apologizes, and then shows up ten years later, only to fuck things up more(?) and yet there is no romance again! And then they break up and get back together again without resolving anything??? Okay, rant done.

Sorry, but it’s a 1.5/5 for me, rounded up to 2, since I feel 1 stars are mean.

[Dísir · Rating 2 out of 5]

It’s a bad review from a premier food magazine that starts the downward slide of Sam Adelson’s very prized, very traditional family-run deli into looming administration. And despite Silverman’s deli being an immovable institution on a block of newly revamped shops, the retro-vibe and the unchanged menu serving equally old-timers can’t survive on nostalgia alone.

As though things aren’t complicated enough, a teenage hookup/friend hurtles back into his life after many, many years at the same time. One would think he’s all over it, but a life-changing incident that turned everything inside out back when Sam was seventeen has made it impossible to move on properly from there.

Jake Thompson on the other hand, now walks with a cane, and apparently, is just coming off a toxic relationship with a celebrity—he isn’t exactly in a good place, but neither is Sam really. The initial awkwardness doesn’t take long to dissipate as Jake and Sam learn each other again. Inevitably their brief but significant history is revealed in the tracking back and forth between past and present. Neither of them is quite done with making mistakes though, and that is the present-day conflict that carries the rest of the story to its climax and eventual conclusion.

But for a simple-ish and straightforward plot, the execution of it is anything but: it’s rambly, too filled with internal monologues and over-extended introspection that too often halt the action rather than contribute to its forward momentum. Some of it is gently amusing of course, in the rom-com bright and preppy way, but I can’t exactly get a handle on the both of them nonetheless. The writing style isn’t for me personally—everything felt too hyper and partially hysterical—and I ended up skimming too much just to try to get to the end.


*ARC by the publisher via Netgalley

[Toni Gower · Rating 4 out of 5]

I was so lucky to receive this ARC by Dylan Morrison. Thank you so much to netgalley and stormbooks_co for selecting me to review this copy!

This was such a fun LGBTQIA+ romance read that had me hooked from start to finish.

The story follows Sam, who runs his families deli while his Aunt Deb is away. Things don’t run very smoothly when a dreaded ‘kiss of death’ review is published about Silverman’s Deli, putting added pressure on Sam to keep the family business afloat. At its heart, the main storyline focuses on Sam’s personal growth as he tries to rescue his families deli.

I loved watching Sam’s character growth throughout this book. Seeing him gain confidence, ask for help, step outside of his comfort zone, and open himself up to love was incredibly satisfying. This second-chance romance also carried a darker history between Jake and Sam from their high school days. The past was revealed slowly over the chapters, which I found really engaging and kept me reading to uncover what had happened between them and what topic they were avoiding while rekindling their romance.

I loved Jake—he was flamboyant, confident, and brought out such a fun, lighter side of Sam. In turn, Sam grounded Jake, making him more level-headed, which made their dynamic feel balanced and believable.

One of my favourite parts of this book was the strong family feel among all the workers in the deli. Each worker had a distinct personality, making them memorable and adding so much warmth to the story. The deli itself created such a cosy atmosphere and made this a lovely comfort read.

Overall, I highly recommend this read! The character growth was brilliant, the second-chance romance trope was executed superbly, and the characters were incredibly lovable.

[Cass · Rating 3 out of 5]

I received a free e-arc from NetGalley in exchange for an honest opinion.

The story itself was pretty good. Seeing these two reconnect was heartwarming, and I was definitely rooting for them as they got together. The found family of the deli was also wonderful. I have never worked in an environment like that, and I wish I have because they genuinely cared about each other. Pastrami was also such a wonderful dog, and I desperately wish she had more page time. I am a sucker for fictional dogs with fun names.

However, what makes this book just okay instead of great is that Morrison does not appear to have done any research beyond food names. These aren't minor issues either, but some that should be common knowledge and take you out of the plot. For example, in the first few chapters he claims that finals are going on for Case Western Reserve in March. Not only does this not make sense for the majority of colleges, but a quick google search showed they wouldn't start until the very end of April at the earliest. Morrison also claims that Sam is a stickler for health code rules, and yet Pastrami (as much as I love her page time) is constantly breaking them by being behind the counter at the deli.

Even apart from the lack of research, the plot is a little bit too flexible at times. Things that should have been more important barely get page time, while things that have a big buildup end up kind of fizzling out.

While I did enjoy reading this book, in the end it feels rushed. I liked Jake and Sam, I liked seeing them get back together. I liked the atmosphere of the deli and how everyone interacted. I just think that all of this could have been improved if a little more time went into working on this book before it reached publication.

[Anisha Choudhury | A Literary Autopsy · Rating 4 out of 5]

Disclosure: I received an Advance Review Copy (ARC) from NetGalley and Storm Publishing in exchange for an honest review.

In Second Helpings , Dylan Morrison delivers a contemporary romance that is as comforting as a warm bowl of matzo ball soup. Set against the backdrop of a legacy Cleveland deli, this story is a poignant exploration of second chances, the weight of family expectations, and the messy beauty of first loves.

The Narrative Impact:
Sam Adelson is the heart of this book, and my protective instincts for him were at an all-time high. Watching him pour his soul into Silverman’s while navigating a crisis—both professional and emotional—was deeply moving. Jake Thompson’s re-entry into his life after twelve years provides a high-tension slow burn that is filled with pining and the undeniable gravity of teenage history.

The Anatomy of the Support System:
While the parental figures in this story left me wanting to yell at people's faces, the extended support system provided a necessary steadying force. The cast surrounding the deli—Sam's sister Luce, Silverman's staff, the incredible trio of Aunt Deb, her wife Talya, and their best friend Joanie—are absolute standouts.
Deb, in particular, serves as the only adult who truly understands Sam’s quiet strength.
The "Grumpy Steady x Chaotic Anxious" dynamic between our leads is handled with sincerity, proving that even when the first attempt was a disaster, some recipes are worth the effort of perfecting.

The Verdict:
Despite the chaos and the trauma Jake brings back into Sam’s life, the HEA feels earned through a boatload of good food and genuine growth. It is a sweet, cozy, and vibrant story that reminds us that sometimes, coming home is the only way to move forward.

[Elysha Smith · Rating 3 out of 5]

Second Helpings is a second chance romance, following Sam, a deli owner whose restaurant is struggling after a scathing review. Enter Jake, his ex from high school who recently moved back to town. However these two have an emotional history.

This is a book that I really wanted to like more than I actually did.

Starting out with what I liked, I did like Sam He has an interesting back story from his initial time with Jake. I loved how it was also shown through flash backs! I loved Sam’s character development throughout the story as well. He was funny and endearing and you can see he’s trying his best to figure everything out.

I also loved the ensemble cast, especially all the deli employees. They were all super fun and added to the story! Pastrami the dog was also great. I also did love the disability rep with Jake.

I do wish the book had gone into more of Jake’s story. There were some gaps in his backstory (his time in LA), that I think would have fleshed out the story better with more background on him. I had a hard time trying to sympathize with him or understand his story when only seeing it from Sam’s POV.

There was some other plot holes and inconsistencies that took me out of the book at times as well (e.g. Sam being a stickler for food safety and yet having his dog behind the counter). I also won’t spoil anything but the twist in the book did not surprise me and I found the ending to hand wave a lot of previous parts.

Thank you to the NetGalley and Storm Publishing for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

[Quilted.reads · Rating 5 out of 5]

I love the theme o this book. The story follows Sam Adelson who’s been running his family’s deli, Silverman’s for years and clearly pours everything he has into it. When a brutal review starts hurting the business, he’s already stressed and frustrated and then his past walks right back into his life. Jake, his first love the one who got away suddenly shows up after twelve years, and everything Sam thought he had under control starts to unravel.What I enjoyed most was the second chance romance. Sam and Jake have a lot of history, and you can feel that in every interaction. Their relationship isn’t just sweet it’s complicated and very real. There’s clearly something unresolved between them, and I liked how the story doesn’t just ignore that for the sake of romance. It actually leans into the messy parts of reconnecting with someone who once meant everything to you.The tone of the book was another highlight for me. It’s funny without trying too hard, and there are a lot of small, chaotic moments especially involving the deli and the dog, Pastrami that made it feel lively and genuine. At the same time, it still deals with deeper themes like moving on, facing the past, and figuring out what really matters.Overall, I thought this was a really enjoyable read. It’s heartfelt, a little dramatic, and full of personality. If you like second chance romances with humor and a strong sense of found family, this is definitely one I’d recommend.

[Alyssa · Rating 3 out of 5]

ARC review
Rating: 3.5

This was a cute read, with themes of second chance, forgiveness, growth, grief, guilt. The book follows Sam Adelson who runs his family’s deli, they received a bad review which causes big problems for the deli but Sam doesn’t let this stop him from trying to keep the deli open. But one day, Jake who was Sam’s first love ends up at the deli they haven’t seen each other in 12 years, an incident took place when they was teenagers this caused a massive rift with both of there family’s with Sam taking the blame to protect Jake. Which causes Sam’s mum to drop him off with his aunt who owned the Deli, Jake got injured badly that night of the accident which caused him not to be able to continue his dance. But with all this happening they both thought that neither of them wanted to see or talk to each other again. But now they have final seen each other after all this time, it is awkward at first as there is a lot of unsaid things that took place that night of them both blaming them self for the way everything ended. Their relationship isn’t just sweet and amazing, it is complicated and real. This book actually leans into messy parts of reconnecting with someone, that means a lot to you. The way it was written was so good, and the found-family vibes with everyone at the deli, I loved. The only thing I wished we got was a duel pov book, so that we got Jake’s pov.

[Emerson Mullins · Rating 3 out of 5]

2.5 stars rounded up

I thought Jake and Sam were cute together, especially the fact that they were friends before anything more happened. I enjoyed the switch between past and present and how it gave more context to their previous relationship. I thought the suspense of finding out the reason for them not keeping contact was well constructed. However, I was a bit frustrated because it really seems like Sam’s wrongdoings were exaggerated; yes, there were certain issues that were due to his actions, but the main issue BETWEEN Sam and Jake which led to Sam moving away actually didn’t seem to be his fault (at least to my understanding).

Considering this is a second chance romance, I was excited for them to start up their relationship again. However, when that moment finally came, it fell flat to me; I would’ve liked more insight on them actually getting back together. Additionally, there wasn’t a lot of build up with them getting back together. There was so much inner monologue that I felt like the romantic aspect was put on the back burner (cooking pun intended). Yes, there were some mentions of little things here and there between Sam and Jake that contributed to their chemistry, but it’s like they all of a sudden said “yes, we’re back together”.

Lastly, I found myself skimming to get to the end of the book. Like I said, there was a lot of inner monologue and readdressing of items that were already touched upon.

Thank you to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC!

[Alison · Rating 4 out of 5]

Three and a half stars.

Sam Adelson is struggling to keep his family-owned restaurant, Silverman's Deli, open after a vicious review by a famous restaurant critic. more known for bringing down Michelin-starred restaurants than 75 year-old delis in Cleveland. The worst of it is that Sam knows most, if not all, of the review is lies, he's scoured the receipts and there is no record of anyone ordering the particular combination of dishes that were reviewed. Furthermore, he knows there aren't rats or cockroaches.

Then one day a blast from Sam's past walks in the door. Jake Thompson. Sam's childhood sweetheart. A man Sam hasn't seen or heard from in over ten years, although Sam may have cyber-stalked Jake a little in that time. But rather than attack Sam for what happened all those years ago Jake seems more inclined to want to be friends ... or maybe more.

Gradually the reader learns what happened all those years ago, can this couple get over the events of the past and make a life together?

I really enjoyed this, I liked Sam and Jake, but I felt the inevitable conflict was obvious from the start which is why this is a three and a half star review.

I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley.

[Cori Samuel · Rating 4 out of 5]

Lovely second chance romance, though I enjoyed it as a comfort read more than the plot making relatable sense.

It's a single POV story, and Sam is an entertaining character to be in the head of: he's devoted to his family-run deli, his small but dedicated staff, and his "are you sure Health & Hygiene would approve this" deli dog, Pastrami. He's gently humorous, and has done some hard work growing-up, which can't always be taken for granted in a twenty-something guy. And he was in love with Jake, Before Things Happened and they spent over a decade apart.

Note, this is closed door spice, and apparently I've read too many bonking books, because I'd forgotten books sometimes do that and was a bit surprised. Much as I liked Sam, I do wish we'd seen Jake's POV too, because a chunk of the plot revolves around some, to me, inexplicable actions; and while that is mostly revealed and processed, there are bits that still don't really add up, and I would very much have liked them to.

Still, this book is a (fairly) low stress good time, and recommended if that's what you're in the mood for.


Rating: 15/20
This review is based upon a complimentary advance reading copy provided by the publisher.

[Eva Edge · Rating 3 out of 5]

Second Helpings by Dylan Morrison is a well-written, fast-paced second-chance romance that shines in its atmospheric deli setting but struggles to establish a deep emotional connection between its leads.

The story follows Sam and Jake as they navigate their past and present amidst a likeable cast of characters in a "found-family" deli environment. While the prose is strong and the story flows effortlessly, the execution is hampered by excessive internal monologues and over-extended introspection. Because the story is told solely from Sam’s perspective, Jake’s true feelings remain largely a mystery, leaving the romance feeling one-sided and underdeveloped.

For a second-chance plot, the first half lacks the sentimental or "cute" moments that make a reader truly root for a couple. Their history feels more like a teenage hookup than a compelling foundation for a lifelong bond. It’s a classic case of "Too much head, not enough heart!" However, if you enjoy comforting, quick reads with a great supporting cast and a cosy workplace vibe, this offers a pleasant, albeit fleeting, experience. A solid 3 "comforting" stars for a book you’ll finish quickly but might not remember long after.

[Jo B · Rating 4 out of 5]

I was hesitant going into this one because first off, I have left the world of food service behind and didn’t know if I wanted to dive into a book set there. Secondly, I wasn’t sure how to feel after the first time jump back and forth.
I am so glad I stuck with it. These characters are delightful - and they’re people that I’ve definitely met in my time in restaurants as well. Morrison did such a great job of creating two main characters who were absolutely permanently altered by trauma but in the most real and human way possible.
Sam and Jake felt well rounded and multi dimensional, and I loved them.
Morrison also wrote the tension of wondering what happened between them in high school and then the heartbreak of finding out what it was so well. I was in tears multiple times. The secondary kind of plot twist was also foreshadowed so subtly but with such good craftsmanship.
The ending really delivered as well, wrapping up not only Sam and Jake’s story but the various stories that we got to see from the supporting cast along the way.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the eARC!

[Caleb Byrum · Rating 3 out of 5]

“Warm, funny, and delectably swoony—a second-chance romance with found family, a chaotic deli dog named Pastrami, and all the comfort-food you could ever want. Perfect for fans of Casey McQuiston and TJ Klune.”
ARC Review: Second Helpings By Dylan Morrison
Rating: 3.5 Stars
Genre: Romance, Queer
Format: ebook ARC
Publication: May 21st, 2026 From Storm Publishing
Thoughts: Focusing on a deli owner reconnecting with his first love amidst a business crisis. A funny and adorable romance that’s as cheesy as it gets (i mean that in a good way) It’s adorable and quirky in all the best ways and your sure to fall in love with Sam & Jake. My favorite character has to be the dog—although i may be biased. An absolutely swoon worthy read that’s sure to make you care about the beautiful creative characters Dylan Morrison constructs for this heartwarming story! The characters are adorable and although being contemporary is skillfully adds in grief and guilt in a way that tugs on your heartstrings yet keeps you engaged throughout the beautiful story that plays out in front of you!!

[Nana_Rea · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is the second book from Dylan Morrison that I have read. Turns out M/M romance, food and cooking are absolutely my drag.
Sam and Jake met in high school, hooked up (their words not mine) tragedy strikes and they lose touch. Twelve years later, as fate would have it, Jake moves in behind the deli that Sam manages.
The story follows them as they dance around their feelings, all the things they should have said, all the wrong assumptions that were made and of course the repercussions of their secrets and lies. It is a story that encourages you to do something different with the things you have, the people you know and the recipes you love. A reminder that change doesn’t negate tradition.
My only issue with this book was; I wanted more, lots more! Jake’s previous relationship was mentioned many times, even Sam expressed a desire for more details, but alas! this did leave me feeling a bit cheated but overall, while it was rather predictable, that serves to make it a safe and comforting read, no great drama and a satisfying ending.
Would absolutely recommend.

[Krista H · Rating 3 out of 5]

Second Helpings is set against the backdrop of a family deli and blends second-chance romance with themes of forgiveness and growth. Sam, still carrying the weight of mistakes he made as a teen, has a strained relationship with his family, while Jake is seemingly trying to rebuild after a toxic relationship. Their shared history is complicated by past trauma, but the story centers on the possibility of making things right.

The found-family elements and sense of community add a comforting layer to the story, and there’s something genuinely sweet about watching these two awkwardly navigate their way back to each other. However, much of the emotional development stays a bit surface-level and isn’t furthered by the closed-door spice. They could definitely use a bit more chemistry. Still, it’s an easy, comforting read that leans into warmth and redemption, even if it doesn’t fully reach its emotional potential.

Thanks for #NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC.

[Seamus M · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for this ARC in return for an honest review.

What can I say, I have a lot of time for this book. It was deeper and more emotionally touching than I anticipated, in a way I really enjoyed. It continued to keep me guessing almost to the very end, and the character development was pretty good!

I would say this is a low spice romance, which in no way is reflected in the rating, but, you might want to know.

The weaving through of their backstory was done excellently, giving a great context just at the right time to explain actions and decisions of characters in a meaningful way.

My only note, and it is small, is on conflict resolution. I feel there was more scope to explore this in greater detail. These two spent so long avoiding talking about anything, that I needed more when they finally did.

Would not hesitate to recommend, add it to your TBR.

[Steph · Rating 3 out of 5]

Second chances, forced proximity, little bit of spice.

Sam’s world is blown apart when Jake walks through the door of his deli. Sam is already dealing with the fallout of a horrible (and false) review and a loss of customers. Jake is someone he never expected to see again, a lost love from high school. They immediately feel a spark and start to rekindle their friendship which leads to more. But past mistakes and current betrayals haunt their reunion.

I really liked Sam as a character. Poor guy had terrible parents but landed on his feet at his aunts deli. He’s just trying to make it a success. Also the food he makes sounds delicious. Not as big of a fan of Jake. Lots of forced proximity romance as Jake moved into the apartment building behind the deli. Not a lot of spice. Good twist near the end.

[Daan Jansen · Rating 3 out of 5]

There’s something about romances set around food that just instantly feels comforting to me (I mean… I called this profile Bookmenus for a reason after all 😉)!

So when this one popped up on my screen, it was a complete no-brainer, I just had to give it a try. And thank god my instinct was right, because Second Helpings by Dylan Morrison absolutely leans all the way into that deli vibe. If you didn’t think craving sandwiches, second chances, and emotional stability all at once was possible… well, take a seat and let me tell you a thing or two 🤤

We follow Sam, who’s trying to keep his family deli alive when Jake, his first love and biggest unresolved feeling, suddenly reappears in his life. Which is already messy in that very “we never really dealt with this, did we?” kind of way on its own, but add lingering tension and one extremely lovable deli dog named Pastrami, and you’ve definitely got a recipe for disaster (in the best way possible) 🫯

What I loved most is how easy it is to fall into this book. It’s cozy and has that addictive “just one more chapter” energy that quietly turns into three hours gone. The chemistry between Sam and Jake really shines in the quieter moments, but it’s definitely there throughout.

I did wish for a bit more depth in some areas, especially when it came to backstory and emotional unpacking, which occasionally felt a little rushed or not fully developed. But even so, it still delivered a really comforting, enjoyable reading experience overall! 🤭

[bookswithbull · Rating 4 out of 5]

Sam & Jake. Cute, sweet, and funny!! Sam and Jake were neighbors in high school until a tragic event tore them apart. Over a decade later, Sam is working in his family’s deli when it gets a terrible review wiping out their customer base. As if things couldn’t get any worse, Jake then walks back into his life.
I loved the humor with which Sam’s character was written and his chaotic thinking. I enjoyed his character development throughout the story. Jake and Sam work well together, balancing out one another. The found family theme with the deli employees was sweet and the dog, Pastrami, was definitely a highlight! All of the supporting characters were lovely. Such great female supporting characters who actually had personality and plot. A fun read!

Thanks to NetGalley, the author, and Storm Publishing for giving me an ARC of the book.

[ReneeReads · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book sounded really cute so I knew I wanted to give it a shot. Once I started reading I decided to check out some of the early reviews and saw that the overall rating wasn't great which gave me a bit of pause, but I continued reading and I ended up finishing it in one sitting. This was a great novel that was much deeper than I thought it would be. I think the characters are great and I love the restaurant family. I wish that the "secret" had come out sooner than it did because I hate a third act breakup but I think it was resolved in a good way and I think it made Sam and Jake stronger in the end. I love that the dog's name is Pastrami and he is just the cutest.

Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing for access to the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

[Tara Batt · Rating 4 out of 5]

Read as an ARC from NetGalley

I don’t normally like second-chance romances, but there was something refreshing about this one - likely for me because the conflict wasn’t centred on them being in a queer relationship.

Told through a past/present single POV, bonus points with the reveal not being dragged out.
I actually started getting heart palpitations when it first clicked for me why they went their separate ways.

Young Sam and Jake broke my heart - did I tear up a little? Yes. Was I rooting for their HEA? Also yes.

The side characters were well fleshed out for the length, I enjoyed the writing style and extra points for there being a dog.
Overall, a really cute well paced little romance.

[Han. · Rating 4 out of 5]

What an absolute stunner! This book was a lot of fun. With meddling aunts and an eccentric neighbour, a therapy dog with an adorable personality and staff who hilarious and wholesome! And even though it was written in a 3rd person single pov, it was easy for me to read and understand (sometimes I struggle with 3rd person povs), it also has a few different timeline chapters which I'm an absolute sucker for! I love a second chance roromance! A closed door romance with hints! And then some more difficult themes to contend with as well but my goodness, the happily ever after was a hard earned one! I really enjoyed it! 🥰

[Giada · Rating 3 out of 5]

Arrivare al 50/60% è stata una faticaccia immensa, un po’ tipo andare in salita dopo che è tutto il giorno che stai camminando e fa un caldo atroce e sei stanco morto, però poi per fortuna dopo quel 50/60% (non ricordo esattamente, me ne sono accorta che ero già al 70%) le cose cominciano ad andare molto meglio e il resto della storia vola via in un attimo.
Il plot twist era annusabile più o meno da subito quindi non ha fatto alzare troppo la votazione, ma almeno siamo riusciti a sfangarcela con tre onestissime stelline, che come sappiamo sono il mio “godibile, mi ha intrattenuta, ma non sarà un nuovo pezzo di quel puzzle che è il mio essere”.

[Susanne · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is Dylan's best book yet. Sam and Jake meet in high school but after an unfortunate circumstance, Sam is sent to live with his aunt who owns Silverman's Deli, and they lose contact with each other. 13 years later Sam now runs the Deli and Jake walks in. They need to clear the air and get over a terrible betrayal. Can they?! Dylan is a master of displaying a character's thoughts and does a great job of showing us how Sam struggles with everything going on. A fantastic story of love and overcoming life's obstacles, whether real or imagined.
Thanks to Netgalley, Storm Publishing, and Dylan Morrison for the free ARC. All opinions are my own.

[Alicia · Rating 4 out of 5]

I'm always surprised when my rating of a book is higher than the book's average, because usually it goes the other way (I'm stingy with five-star reviews). But I found this book charming and highly readable. I guess Dylan Morrison's style simply works for me. I don't always like multiple-timeline stories, but I thought the approach succeeded here. I might have liked a few more threads played out/tied off, but all in all, I gobbled this up and will gladly come back for more by this author.

My thanks to the publisher/NetGalley for an advance copy of this book.

[JANELLE · Rating 3 out of 5]

A second chance romance.

After some teenage problems, Sam is sent to live with his aunt and eventually starts managing her deli. He still feels guilty about an accident that crushes his high school boyfriend's dreams and believes it's all his fault. Then there is a damning restaurant review that puts him in overdrive to save the deli. And in walks, Jake, his high school boyfriend, and stirs up all kinds of emotions. It's an interesting story of love, forgiveness and growing up.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for a temporary, digital ARC in return for my review.

[Ines · Rating 3 out of 5]

Second Helpings is a warm, cozy read with a charming deli setting and a tender second-chance romance at its core. The found-family vibes and gentle humor make it easy to enjoy, even if the premise feels familiar. While the emotional beats are sweet, they don’t always hit as deeply as they could, and the chemistry could use a bit more spark. A solid comfort read—pleasant, but not quite unforgettable.

3,5 stars.