Discover a BRAND NEW gripping Scottish crime series from bestselling author Daniel Sellers. If you love Marion Todd and Matt Brolly - this is for you! An ancient Scottish castle.
A storm setting in for Christmas.
A killer on the loose.
Investigating a suspicious death at ancient Dumfala castle on the remote Isle of Mull is not what DI Anna Vaughan had planned this Christmas. But when she receives the call on Christmas Eve, she is duty bound to make the treacherous trip to investigate.
But it soon becomes clear the estate's obsessive owner, Robert Fairlie, is more concerned with safeguarding his lucrative contract for a hit American TV show to be filmed at the castle than with the death of one of his employees. And as Anna turns to the locals for answers, she’s instead faced with an eclectic cast of suspects who seem no more welcoming than Fairlie himself…
Trapped on the estate and cut off from mainland by a fierce winter blizzard, Anna and local DS Lachlan McKay are left completely on their own to catch the killer and untangle the web of secrets that have shrouded this isolated community for years. The question is, can Anna uncover the truth before more people lose their lives?
DI Anna Vaughan was a little pleased to receive the call on Christmas Eve to the Isle of Mull, to Dumfala Castle, where a suspicious death had occurred. Her partner, Nick's mother was staying - Nick wasn't pleased but Anna said she'd be as quick as she could. Her arrival where she linked up with local DS Lachlan McKay, was the beginning of a stressful, strange and traumatic few days, especially as the storm gathered force, with wind, rain and snow stopping the ferries, even the helicopter, from arriving. Anna & Lachlan, and a few constables, were on their own.
Robert Fairlie, owner of Dumfala Castle & the surrounding estate, was a vindictive, cruel man, completely disliked by everyone surrounding him. He wanted everything kept quiet, didn't want the police there, disapproved of it all. When a second death occurred, Anna could see the absolute danger but Fairlie didn't believe her. The wildness of the Isle of Mull, the castle seemingly balanced on the edge of the cliff, the strangeness of the people concerned - Anna and Lachlan were stuck, having to work it out themselves. But could they? Would they stop a dangerous killer before more died?
The Isle of Mull Murders is the 2nd in The Scottish Highland Killings series by Daniel Sellers and I enjoyed it very much, the same as I did the first. Gritty, intense, chilling (in more ways than one), there was always the tension of danger around every corner. The weather and island were characters themselves. Anna is an intelligent, determined woman, an excellent person to have on your side. I love the cover too - it has atmosphere! Highly recommended.
With thanks to NetGalley & Boldwood Books for my digital ARC to read and review.
Daniel Sellers (https://www.danielsellers.co.uk/) is the author of ten novels. The Isle of Mull Murders was published last September. It is the 77th title I’ve completed reading in 2026.
I received an ARC of this book for free through https://www.netgalley.com, and I am voluntarily leaving this review. All opinions expressed are entirely my own. Due to scenes of violence, I categorize this novel as R.
DI Anna Vaughan is on Christmas vacation when she is called to the remote Isle of Mull off the Scottish coast. There has been a suspicious death at the ancient Dumfala Castle.
The owner of the castle, Robert Fairlie, is not at all cooperative. He has a contract with an American film studio for the castle to be the set for the next season of a hit American TV show. Fairlie sees this as his chance to restore Dumfala to its full glory. While he somewhat regrets the death of an employee, his biggest concern is the pending TV deal.
It seems that Fairlie hasn’t met anyone he hasn’t offended, so there are many suspects to choose from. Vaughan discovers that there has been vandalism at the castle, along with threatening notes. She and a handful of local constabulary begin investigating, though there is no clear evidence as to who is behind it all.
Fairlie is the last of three siblings. His older brother died in a climbing accident years earlier. His sister died more recently due to health problems. He has inherited the estate and is obsessed with restoring the castle.
A severe winter storm has cut the island off from the mainland. It is left to Vaughan and her officers to discover who is behind the death.
I enjoyed the 5.5+ hours I spent reading this 266-page mystery. It is a good mystery and, typical of British mysteries, the guilty party is not exposed until near the end of the novel. I have had the opportunity to read one other novel by Mr. Sellers, The Knapdale Murders. I have enjoyed both of his novels. I like the chosen cover art. I give this novel a rating of 4 out of 5.
The Isle of Mull Murders is an atmospheric murder mystery, that brings us the dread of isolation, dangerous cliffs and bumpy roads of Scotland.
DI Anna Vaughan did not expect to spend her holiday season solving a series of damages and acts vandalism to the The Dumfala Estate. When the owner, Robert Faurlie, doesn't want to press charges or even admit that such acts are occurring, Anna leaves him be. When a murder happens in the estate, Anna is called back to help solve the murder. But first she must figure out the secrets that the people who live at the estate hold and who had a strong motive to kill.
This was a wonderful and intense read. I really felt like I was at Dumfala House and I was surrounded by such beautiful views and the cold windy weather. The fact that the castle was so isolated and somewhat hard to get to made the mystery much more eerie and dangerous. I enjoyed DI Anna a lot. She was precise, smart and diligent without ever getting annoying or pushy. James, Gina Fairlie's brother was such a diva, said it like it was and didn't care who's feeling got hurt. I liked him a lot. And the real story behind the murder plus the back story of what happened that set off the current events was delightful. Holding grudges and keeping secrets can turn deadly! Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for this eARC. All opinions are entirely my own.
I must admit, i choose this book because (a) I love me a good crime plot and (b) my Scottish ex always told me that I would really LOVE Mull, if I got the chance to visit it (not yet Brian, not yet!). So it had me intrigued.
It has to be said that this is an excellent setting for a book like this. I could easily visualise the castle and the surrounds, I understood what it was like living in a small, island community (I live on a slightly larger island myself in a semi-rural community) so that was a really good part of the story. The author did a great job of letting me "see" everything by the way he described it all.
Anna Vaughan is tasked with solving the case of a mysterious death on the Isle of Mull. It is Christmas Eve so it isn't the best timing in the world, however, she avoids spending too much time with her mother-in-law this way - I always enjoy little pops of humour in books like this! Unfortunately for Anna, she runs into the obnoxious owner of Dumfala Castle and he proves to be super difficult and unhelpful. Then the weather closes in, and when you are on a small island with limited options for getting anyone on or off it, it adds to the complexity of the case. Anna, with the help of local police, carries on as best she can.
Good, solid crime thriller. I enjoyed it. I am looking forward to reading other novels by this author.
If you love Marion Todd and Matt Brolly’s tight, atmospheric crime writing, this one’s right up your street.
A brutal storm cutting everyone off from the mainland? It’s the perfect, chilling setup. DI Anna Vaughan definitely didn’t plan to spend her festive break trekking out there for a suspicious death, but duty calls on Christmas Eve – and it doesn’t take long to see nothing here is straightforward.
The castle’s wealthy, obsessive owner Robert Fairlie cares far more about protecting his big-money American TV deal than the fact one of his staff is dead. And the locals? They’re just as guarded, every last one of them hiding something. Trapped alongside local DS Lachlan McKay with no backup coming, Anna has to unpick years of buried secrets if she’s going to catch a killer before they strike again.
Atmospheric, tense and packed with great characters – exactly the kind of gripping winter mystery you want to curl up with.
A suspicious death is reported on the remote Scottish Isle of Mull and Detective Inspector Anna Vaughan is appointed the Senior Investigating Officer. If this was murder, rather than a fatal accident, can she catch the killer?
The Isle of Mull Murders is a regular British police procedural set in Scotland. Nothing was special about this book and I think it is an OKAY 3 star read. Everything was ordinary about this police procedural. The plot was average with the usual finger pointing to who the bad guy actually was. The investigation plodded along at a steady but dull pace. There was no WOW! Factor and it became simply a case of it being nice having a book “on-the-go” for me.
My Kindle highlights have saved 2 amusing little quips which made me smile…
Nick groaned. ‘How early can we start drinking?’ ‘Dunno,’ she said. ‘After breakfast?’
… and for the height of laziness, which staggers my belief…
I thought about going along there, but I’d have to walk and it’s over a mile, so I rang Etham, who came as quick as anything.
… The scene setting on this remote island which is the second-largest of the Inner Hebrides, off the west coast of Scotland was very good indeed, making me feel as though I was there. This is the second book I have read from Daniel Sellers, the other being Murder in the Gallowgate, which he wrote in 2022. Sadly his storytelling/writing has not improved in those 4 years in my opinion, with both books getting 3 stars from me. Although The Isle of Mull Murders is the 4th in the Detective Inspector Anna Vaughan series, it is nice to note that Lola Harris, from Murder in the Gallowgate, has a small part to play as a returning character.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher Boldwood Books for passing me an ARC on the understanding that I post a review.
An island, a castle, a blizzard and a murder at Christmas-time. This was twisty and captivating and the narrator was on point. A good second instalment.
I didn’t enjoy this book as much as I expected based on the hype and ratings. For most of the read I was leaning toward two stars, but the ending (although predictable) was slightly stronger than the rest, so I raised the score to three.
The characters felt cold, unrealistic, and for me they were unlikable. Dialogue reads poor, lacks depth and complexity, and comes across as unconvincing. Anna is presented as a dedicated professional sacrificing Christmas with family to investigate murders. Yet, given her indifference for ruining the plans and her poor occasional communication with her partner, it reads more like she was waiting for any excuse to escape family tension with her mother in law. That angle could have added depth, but instead it feels hollow and emotionless, more like filler than genuine development. I didn’t catch any feeling for any character or for the story itself.
The writing style feels closer to a TV script than a novel. It is full of scenes that add nothing. For example, the whole episode of Anna and her colleague eating mince pies is irrelevant, and the level of detail such as “She rolled the foil container up and tossed it into a small waste bin” is completely unnecessary.
Some plots were extremely obvious. Margaret’s affair with Robbie and Angus’s death not being an accident were clear long before the reveal. The castle is described nicely and the isolation of the island is atmospheric, but the blizzard is introduced only as scenery, never as a genuine source of danger. Characters keep traveling by boat and car as if conditions were mild, with only sporadic mentions of snow.
For me, the book failed to build tension or thrills. The setting had potential, but the execution left me detached.
Advance copy provided by Boldwood Books via NetGalley.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Thanks to Boldwood Books and Netgalley for this eARC.
The Isle of Mull Murders is a brisk, atmospheric whodunit that leans into the rugged beauty and quiet menace of Scotland’s west coast. Daniel Sellers crafts a mystery that feels both classic and contemporary—rooted in tight procedural work, but driven by the emotional undercurrents of a small community where everyone knows more than they admit.
The island’s cliffs, coves, and weather‑beaten roads create a sense of isolation that amplifies every threat. Sellers uses the landscape to heighten tension—storms rolling in at the wrong moment, remote houses that feel a little too quiet, and a community whose calm surface hides old grudges. The setting gives the book its texture and its unease.
DI Scott Cullen and his team anchor this story with steady, grounded professionalism. Cullen’s sharp instincts and dry humor balance the darker elements of the investigation. Sellers writes him as a detective who sees through people quickly but still understands the emotional weight of the job. His interactions with locals—some cooperative, some evasive—add friction that keeps the investigation taut.
The case begins with a death that seems straightforward, but Sellers quickly reveals deeper layers: hidden relationships, long‑buried conflicts, and motives shaped by jealousy, desperation, and pride. The suspects feel real—flawed, defensive, and shaped by island life. Sellers avoids melodrama; instead, he lets tension build through small inconsistencies, shifting alibis, and the way people talk around the truth.
This novel moves with purpose. Short, focused chapters keep the momentum tight, and each clue shifts the investigation in meaningful ways. Sellers excels at procedural clarity—readers always understand what the detectives know, what they suspect, and what they’re missing. The final reveal lands cleanly, with just enough surprise to satisfy without feeling contrived.
Sellers threads the story with subtle themes:
- Community loyalty vs. personal truth - How isolation shapes behavior - The weight of reputation in small towns - The quiet dangers of resentment left to simmer
These elements give the novel emotional depth beyond the mechanics of the case.
The Isle of Mull Murders is a tightly written, atmospheric Scottish mystery that blends procedural precision with the brooding beauty of island life. Sellers delivers a story that’s smart, grounded, and quietly gripping—perfect for readers who enjoy community‑rooted crime fiction, steady detective work, and settings that feel alive.
The Isle of Mull Murders is the second book in a gritty Scottish procedural by Daniel Sellers. Released 12th Sept. 2026 by Boldwood, it's 266 pages and is available in hardcover, paperback, audio, and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links throughout. For Kindle Unlimited subscribers, this book is currently included in the KU subscription library to borrow and read for free. The other book in the series is also currently available on KU.
This is a brooding, windswept, and very atmospheric novel set in a remote area of Scottish highlands. DI Anna Vaughan and her colleagues are called in after a series of increasingly threatening vandalisms on an estate. The irascible estate owner Robert is singularly unhelpful and obsctructive, sending them away without a resolution. They're called back after a murder, and set to untangling the convoluted hidden stories of the estate's residents.
It's a nice classic mystery setup: isolated setting, no help immediately available, limited suspect pool, and -everyone- is hiding -something-. The writing is "tartan noir" and while it's certainly not derivative, fans of Marion Todd, Bill Kitson, and Alex Finlay will enjoy this one as well. It's the second book in the series, but works fine as a standalone. The denouement and resolution are satisfying and well constructed, albeit bleak.
The unabridged audiobook has a run time of 7 hours 43 minutes and is capably read by Karen Bartke. She has a warm well modulated alto voice in this read and does a good job of delineating the male and female characters of a range of ages and accents (most Scottish). Sound and production quality are high throughout the read.
Four and a half stars. Uncommonly good. It would be a good choice for public or home library acquisition, as well as for a binge/buddy read.
Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.
Some mysteries pull you in because of their setting, and The Isle of Mull Murders is one of those stories where the landscape does half the talking. Dumfala Castle, perched on the rugged Isle of Mull and wrapped in a Christmas blizzard, creates the kind of tension that settles in your bones long before the investigation begins.
DI Anna Vaughan’s holiday plans dissolve the moment she’s called out to the castle on Christmas Eve. The death she’s sent to examine is met with an unsettling mix of indifference and inconvenience from Robert Fairlie, the estate’s owner, whose obsession with protecting his upcoming American TV contract overshadows everything else. It’s clear from the start that Anna has stepped into a world where cooperation is optional and secrets are plentiful.
With the storm cutting off access to the mainland, Anna and DS Lachlan McKay are left to navigate a tight‑knit community that seems determined to keep its past buried. The locals are prickly, evasive, and far from welcoming, each one offering just enough truth to keep Anna moving while never quite revealing what matters. The blizzard traps everyone together, heightening the claustrophobia and sharpening every suspicion.
The atmosphere is wonderfully done — cold corridors, old stone, and the relentless storm pressing against the windows. The sense of isolation amplifies every twist, and the partnership between Anna and Lachlan brings a grounded warmth to the investigation as the danger escalates.
Moody, tense, and steeped in winter menace, The Isle of Mull Murders delivers a satisfying blend of classic whodunnit energy and modern psychological suspense. It’s a perfect pick for readers who love mysteries set in remote places where the weather is as dangerous as the killer, and where every shadow feels like it might be hiding the truth.
With thanks to Daniel Sellers, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
With thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the free ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Daniel Sellers’ The Isle of Mull Murders delivers an atmospheric Scottish noir setting, but struggles to break out of some well-worn crime fiction tropes.
DI Anna Vaughan receives a phone call on Christmas Eve to go and investigate a suspicious death at Dumfala Castle. Much to the annoyance of her husband Nick, she is soon sailing to the island to take up her position as lead detective.
Anna is a duty-bound, professional investigator and is a strong female lead in a mostly male plot. I really enjoyed how she managed to unravel the mystery as the book progressed, and the way she dealt with the obnoxious owner of the castle.
Robert Fairlie is an unwelcoming figure. He is rude, obnoxious and only interested in the money an American TV producer has offered him to use the castle in the next series of their hit show (think Game of Thrones). Rather than focusing on the death of one of his employees his main concern is safeguarding this lucrative contract.
The setting is the highlight of the book. The Scottish Highlands are described perfectly in all their glory. It is the perfect place for a winter tale and really ties in with the claustrophobia caused by no one being able to leave the island.
Although the plot does flag in places, there is just enough at the end of each chapter to keep you wanting to read on. However, the investigation does rely on convenience and coincidental discoveries rather than good detective work. While the atmosphere does remain tense, it is quite easy to figure out some of the plot twists and to guess the killer’s identity before the climax which was a little disappointing.
It’s a solid read if you're looking for an immersive Scottish setting, but as a thriller, it doesn't offer much that you haven't seen before.
The scene is set. It’s Christmas, there’s an old castle on an idyllic Scottish island, and a snow blizzard is closing in. On Christmas Eve, DI Anna Vaughan receives a call to attend a suspicious death. Once she arrives, it soon becomes clear that this is not going to be a straightforward case. With the weather deteriorating, Anna and local DS Lachlan McKay find themselves stranded, with a murder mystery to solve and a growing list of suspects.
This is a tense and gripping mystery, cloaked in suspicion and confusion. The author has created a stunning setting that adds enormously to the atmosphere and keeps the reader on edge. The plot is complex and ominous, the murders mount up, and Anna is faced with an increasingly baffling investigation.
Mr Sellers is a master storyteller, creating a wonderfully dramatic and atmospheric narrative. This second book in the Scottish Highland Killings series is even better than the first. He has a real talent for creating well-crafted, believable characters, even the unpleasant and disturbing Robert Fairlie, who seems to have upset just about everyone he comes into contact with! There are plenty of red herrings, twists and turns to keep the reader guessing. Hints of something altogether more sinister add to the sense of unease, and I found myself wanting to discover more about the painting mentioned in the story. I felt very much a part of the unfolding drama and found it difficult to put the book down.
The revelation of the killer and their motive came as a huge surprise, and certainly wasn’t what I had expected. Yet, when the truth emerged, I could understand what had driven them to their actions.
The ending was a welcome release from the tension, bringing a charming and satisfying conclusion to the story. I am most definitely looking forward to the next instalment in this excellent series.
The Isle of Mull Murders by Daniel Sellers is the second book in the excellent The Scottish Highland Killings series and I have enjoyed reading both of these books. This chilling crime thriller is set in the heart of the Scottish highlands.
When a storm is setting in for Christmas and there is a Killer on the Loose!.
An investigation of a suspicious death is happening at the ancient Dumfala castle which is on the remote Isle of Mull, and D.I. Anna Vaughan is looking forward to her Christmas and having some time off. But, when she receives the call on Christmas Eve, she is duty bound to make the treacherous trip to investigate.
But it soon becomes clear, the estate's obsessive owner, Robert Fairlie, is more concerned with safeguarding his lucrative contract for a hit American TV show to be filmed at the castle than with the death of one of his employees. Anna turns to the locals for answers, she’s instead faced with an eclectic cast of suspects who seem no more welcoming than Fairlie himself…
Now, Anna is trapped on the estate and cut off from mainland by a fierce winter blizzard, Anna and local DS Lachlan McKay are left completely on their own to catch the killer and untangle the web of secrets that have shrouded this isolated community for years.
The big question is . . . . . . Can Anna uncover the truth before more people lose their lives?
WoW, this book was full of twists and turns throughout that will have you turning the pages over to read what happens next. It was an addictive read and very fast paced. I really enjoyed reading this latest book within this series.
I highly recommend The Isle of Mull Murders by Daniel Sellers. Another 5 ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ read from start to finish.
Big Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for my Arc.
This is the first time I have read a book by this author, and it was a page-turner for me. This is the 2nd book in the series; I didn't realise when I started it, but it read extremely well as a standalone.
The Isle of Mull is a great setting for a murder; it is set off from the mainland, the weather can definitely hamper getting to and from the island, and this makes for a great location for a murder.
The story was great from the start: a suspicious death, but from the title you know it is going to be a murder. The story begins tragically, and to be fair, this sense carries through the story. Just as DI Anna Vaughan is getting ready to spend Christmas with her husband and mother-in-law, she is called to investigate a death at Dumfala Castle. Once there, she meets the owner, Robert Fairlie, obnoxious, rude, and a character you immediately don't like.
Added to the unlikeable Fairlie, there are a few other key characters. These are wary and not altogether truthful or forthcoming. A small community with secrets that have to be pried out by Anna. With the isolation of the island, the rumours around the castle, and then the fact that it is in the middle of winter, the weather, the author gives an air of suspense and distrust throughout the novel.
This is an isolated location, with secrets that provide some good background; the suspicious and sinister vibes add to the story. A murder mystery, a police procedural and, to a certain extent, an air of psychological thriller. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and will be looking out for more by this author. It is one I would definitely recommend.
This was a fantastic read. This was book 2 in the The Scottish Highland Killings series and was thoroughly enjoyable. I am loving this series. Anyone who enjoys Crime Fiction/Police Procedurals should check out this great series.
It would also make a fabulous, gritty and murderous festive read because DI Anna Vaughan is called out to investigate a suspicious death on Christmas Eve. And the setting is absolutely captivating. The tension hits you immediately as the suspicious death is on the Isle of Mull, in an isolated community and the challenge to just get onto the island is enormous. The weather is turning for the worst, a storm is brewing. Ferries to the island are being cancelled. It is a dangerous operation right from the start.
And then we meet the island's residents, a cast of characters, including the vindictive and cruel Robert Fairlie who I took a dislike to immediately. I love a small community setting, where the gossip is rife and memories are long. You are never quite sure who's side to be on, if anyone's. DI Vaughan is well constructed character. She is enigmatic, fearless and authoritative.
The writing is wonderful and intense. This is mirrored by the title of the chapters which gives us a time stamp throughout the book, from the time before Vaughan heads up the island and then as we follow the investigation. Full of twists and turns and totally unputdownable.
I love the wildness of the Scottish setting, the strangeness of the residents on the island, the dark and foreboding atmosphere. I am already looking forward to the next book in the series.
Thank you to Boldwood and Netgalley for the chance to read this eARC.
Gratitude to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC.
My first book by Daniel Sellers and my introduction to his Scottish Highland Killings series.
This is a solid criminal case and, for me, a refreshing change from the increasingly fashionable mysteries where amateur detectives of varying degrees of competence somehow find themselves solving crimes. Here, the investigation is handled by professionals: no-nonsense detectives following established procedures, albeit in an environment that is anything but cooperative.
The setting is one of the book's strongest elements. Sending DI Anna Vaughan and DS Lachlan McKay to the Isle of Mull on Christmas Eve, only to have them confronted by a winter storm and cut off from the mainland, creates an immediate sense of isolation. The storytelling moves with much the same relentless quality as the weather outside.
Most of the action takes place within a single day, which keeps the pace brisk. It is not quite a breakneck thriller, but there are plenty of tense moments, and the feeling of being trapped with a killer steadily builds.
Interestingly, although the case itself is handled according to modern procedures, the castle, the storm and the isolated group of suspects give the story the atmosphere of an old-fashioned whodunit. You almost expect the doors to be locked, the characters to gather around the table, and the question to become not whether one of them is the killer, but which one.
A well-executed police investigation wrapped in a classic isolated-castle mystery atmosphere.
Investigating a suspicious death at ancient Dumfala castle on the remote Isle of Mull is not what DI Diana Vaughn had planned this Christmas. But when she receives a call on Christmas Eve, she is duty bound to make the treacherous trip. But it soon becomes clear the estates obsessive owner, Robert Fairlie, is more concerned with safeguarding his lucrative contract for a hit American TV show to be filmed at is castle than the death of one of his employees. And as Anna turns to the locals for answers, she's instead faced with an eclectic cast of suspects who seem more welcoming than Fairlie himself.
This story has been descriptively written. At first, it looks like this was going to be a straight forward case. Robert Fairlie, the employer of the man that died, doesn't want any publicity as he has a huge contract with an American TV filming a series at the castle. Of course, we get a storm and bizarre events. I was pulled into the story after reading the prologue. The characters are believable and well-developed. This is turning into a good series.
Published 12th September 2026
I would like to thank #NetGalley #BoldwoodBooks and the author #DanielSellers for my ARC of #TheIsleOfMullMurders in exchange for an honest review.
The Isle of Mull Murders by Daniel Sellers is an enticing mystery, almost a locked room as all the people involved were isolated on an island. The lead investigator is Anna Vaughn and she admits to being stuck. Some of these people were decidedly unlikable, but that didn’t make them murderers. There had been a lot of “antics” at the castle and a friend of hers, Lora, had been hired to look into it. She got fired after a few days but first she had made some suggestions, few of which were implemented. Then she called Anna, who came out to the island to look at the incidents personally. She found the owner of the castle, long abandoned, called Robbie to be more than unpleasant. He was a ill-tempered bully. The others, although not as unpleasant, seemed to respond to him and turned themselves negative.
This was a good mystery. It was all about jealousy, revenge, insecurity, and greed. Someone was purposefully torturing Robbie and he refused to admit it and deal with it. The plot was good; interesting. The police characters ran the gamut of how much the reader got to know them. The inhabitant of the island were distant and quiet. The past played heavily. It was a good read.
I was invited to read The Isle of Mull Murders by Boldwood Books. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #Netgalley #BoldwoodBooks #DanielSellers #TheIsleOfMullMurders
Would you trade a peaceful Christmas for a killer's company, cut off from the world by a blizzard? DI Anna Vaughan doesn't get much choice in the matter.
Daniel Sellers has outdone himself, sweeping me into a howling storm on the Isle of Mull, trapped alongside Anna beside a castle that seems to groan under the weight of its own secrets. The waves crash, the wind never lets up, and the isolation presses in until you can practically feel the cold seeping through the pages.
Sellers paints this world with such rich, atmospheric detail that the castle itself becomes a character, brooding and claustrophobic, holding everyone around it hostage to the storm and to each other.
And what a cast he's assembled. Every single person on that estate earns their place, each one a little more suspicious than the last, and I found myself second-guessing my theories right up to the end. Just when I thought I had it figured out, the ending pulled the rug out from under me completely. I did not see it coming.
Atmospheric, tense, and utterly absorbing, this is the best one yet (and I was so glad to see Lola again). Roll on Anna's next case on the shores of Loch Fyne. Oyster anyone?
My thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC. All views are my own.
Robert Fairlie is determined to restore Dumfala Castle, his family's ancestral home on the Isle of Mull. A lucrative contract with an American television company to use the castle as a filming location for a Game of Thrones type series would provide the funds he needs to complete the restoration. But a series of escalating acts of violence, mysterious threats, and unauthorized leaks of the show's plot lines put the agreement at risk. On a previous visit DI Anna Vaughan has tried to convince Fairlie to report the problems but he, a stubborn and unpleasant man, refused. Then an employee is murdered and Anna returns to Mull to investigate. There are many suspects for Anna and a local officer to interview but their search is hampered by a blizzard that isolates them…and the killer.
The Isle of Mull Murders, the second in an excellent series, can be read as a standalone thriller. Anna is a strong, decisive character but Dumfala Castle, looming on the edge of the sea, dominates. It has a bolted trap door, crumbling parapets, a hidden tunnel and more. Add a howling winter storm and you have a compulsively readable and well plotted thriller. I look forward to the next in this series. 5 stars.
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books and Daniel Sellers for this ARC.
Thank you NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the opportunity to read "The Isle of Mull Murders" in exchange for my honest opinion.
The prologue of this book takes place in July 1980 when Angus Fairlie has a accident while climbing Maiden. Angus was a 19 year old home from Oxford.
The story continues at the Dumfala Estate in Mull where DI Anna Vaughan goes to visit Robert Fairlie about incidents that have happened at the castle. Robert who is being paid a lucrative amount by a TV company to use the castle and estate doesn't want anything investigated for fear of losing the contract. His life's ambition is to restore the castle and he needs the money to do so. Strange things continue to happen and Robert continues to forbid Anna from investigating.
When there is a suspicious death at the castle, he can no longer prevent the police from investigating. He continues to be difficult and uncoperative. He seems a bit mad and obsessed.
Woven through the interesting story are descriptions of the scenery, the rugged area, decriptions of the travel difficulties in bad weather - leaving the reader feeling as if they were there along with DI Vaughan as she investigates.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨ 4.5 stars rounded down to 4 for goodreads
The Isle of Mull Murders by Daniel Sellers 🏰🔪
This one had me hooked from start to finish! 👀
Set on the remote Isle of Mull, with an isolated castle, a raging winter storm and a whole lot of secrets, this was exactly the kind of murder mystery I love. The atmosphere was SO good, and the writing made it incredibly easy to picture everything around me.
I genuinely felt like I was right there alongside DI Anna Vaughan, piecing together the clues and trying to work out what the hell was going on. 😂🔎
And the best part? I COULD NOT GUESS THE KILLER! 👏 Every time I thought I had it figured out, I was wrong. There were twists, secrets and enough suspicious characters to keep me questioning everyone.
It was brilliantly written, gripping, atmospheric and kept me turning the pages because I needed to know what happened next.
If you love a good murder mystery where you can play detective from the comfort of your sofa, add this one to your TBR! 🔪📖
4.5⭐️ — thoroughly enjoyed this one!
Have you read it? Did you manage to work out who the killer was? 👀
DI Anna Vaughan is called out right before Christmas to investigate a suspicious death at a remote Scottish castle. The owner of the castle and manor, Robert Fairlie, who is also the employer of the man who died, is adamant about avoiding all publicity due to the huge contract he has with an American crew to film a series at the castle. With limited resources and manpower due to the holiday and a massive winter storm, Anna must figure out who wanted the man dead and why. When bizarre events continue to happen at the castle, Anna fears for Fairlie's safety.
I love Scottish mysteries, especially those by writers who are skilled at describing the countryside, in this case, seaside, and the architecture of the castles and manor buildings. Daniel Sellers does exactly that, make it easy to picture how treacherous the cliffs around the castle are, especially during a snowstorm. The characters are well portrayed and their actions believable. The mystery was solved in a way that made sense with no loose ends. Overall, a quite satisfying mystery.
The Isle of Mull Murders was a solid read for me. It’s one of those books that you keep reading, but at your own pace. It was not so fast paced that you could not just sit back and enjoy the book. It is nice to have books like that sometimes. A psychological tale of revenge, with a multitude of characters, any of which could be the killer. But the way the killer goes about tormenting the main character, the owner of the castle is quite spiteful. It’s not until the end where you find out who the killer is and why they did it that it all comes together. A couple of little secrets to go along with the story which make for an interesting read. Lots of suspicious characters which is good to distract you from picking the killer too early. I thoroughly enjoyed this book, the first I have read from Daniel Sellers, but definitely will not be the last. While I took a little longer to read the book, it was because I was enjoying it and wanted to make it last longer until I got to the end! A five star read from me for sure.
A murder mystery set in Scotland - nothing could be finer to my way of thinking. Great descriptive writing can’t help but make you feel as if you are traipsing all over the Dumfala Estate with its rhododendrons, dense woodland and beautiful sea view out to the other islands. Aye lads and lassies it is a true wonderment and as waves smash against the walls of the manor house and things go bump in the night and sometimes the day as well - just what you would expect in a ruined Scottish castle. This is a finely crafted story that twists, turns and centers on the nasty man who owns it all and really, how can you not love a story that has a town called Tobermory.
The very competent Detective Inspector Anna Vaughn inhabits most pages and she is a most pleasant companion as we explore the Estate with her colleagues, delve into the crimes, and try to unravel the mystery and ultimate murder. Well told, well done, time very well invested.
Many thanks to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for a copy. All opinions expressed are mine.
“The Isle of Mull Murders” is the second book in Daniel Sellers’ Scottish Highland Killings series. This book follows “The Knapdale Murder” that released 8 months ago.
This time, DI Anna Vaughan is called in on Christmas Eve. Now, this may sound tragic, but her mother-in-law is back with Anna and her husband. You would have to read the first book to get a real picture of the relationship. Let’s just say, DI Vaughan would rather deal with a dead body, even if her mother-in-law is a little more contrite this time around.
As tends to happen in mysteries, a storm traps everyone together. Let me just say, if you plan on killing someone at a remote location, check the weather first.
The mystery is fun. The characters are great. This series has been a joy and I’m so glad they have already announced the third book is already scheduled to be released soon.
Thank you to NetGalley and the Publisher for providing an ARC for an unbiased review.
Anna is spending Christmas at the cabin with her husband and, unfortunately, her mother-in-law. When she gets a call to attend to a murder investigation on the Isle of Mull, she’s happy to go. A man has fallen to his death from an old castle, but he was stabbed first. The owner of the main house and the castle, Robbie, is a petty tyrant, always belittling, bossing, and throwing temper tantrums. His one dream is to restore the castle, and he is not happy that a mere murder might ruin his plans. The setting is atmospheric: cold corridors, winds, a snow storm that strands everyone. When Robbie is killed, everyone who knew him, and especially worked for him, is a suspect because everyone hated him. The ending is definitely a twist and I did not guess the murderer. I loved everything about this book…the mystery, the foreboding setting, the suspicious characters, and the snow storm. Thanks to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the ARC.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this ARC.
I really enjoyed The Isle of Mull Murders. The remote Isle of Mull, ancient castle and winter blizzard make a brilliant backdrop for a murder investigation.
DI Anna Vaughan is called to investigate a suspicious death at Dumfala Castle just as the weather cuts the island off from the mainland. With a killer still at large and a very unwelcoming group of suspects, Anna and DS Lachlan McKay have plenty to uncover.
I enjoyed the claustrophobic atmosphere, the mix of characters and the secrets hiding beneath the surface of the isolated community. There are plenty of twists and red herrings to keep you guessing.
I did work out parts of the plot, which is why this is a four star read, but I still really enjoyed following the investigation.
A strong start to a new Scottish crime series with a fantastic setting. I’ll definitely be reading more.