Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

I Disagree: Winning Arguments Without Losing Friends

Rate this book
NATIONAL BESTSELLER The outspoken liberal voice on the Fox News show The Five shows us how to stay true to our values, find common ground, and communicate with confidence when engaging across political and social divides.

“A helpful guide to engaging with those who think differently from you—and doing it in a thoughtful and civil way.”—Katie Couric


Imagine you’re sitting down to Thanksgiving dinner, knowing it’s going to get heated. One uncle is ready to argue about politics, another relative has very different views, and you usually try to stay out of it, even though you have strong opinions yourself. Conversations like these have split some families up. Now imagine that dinner table debate broadcast daily to millions.

Welcome to the world of Jessica Tarlov, an unflappable liberal voice on Fox News Channel’s The Five. When you’re outnumbered four to one on a daily basis, you better know your stuff. When you’re outnumbered four to one on the highest-rated show on cable news, you better have your beliefs on lockdown.

In the conservative fishbowl of The Five, Tarlov is no stranger to navigating thorny, often contentious debates with poise, authenticity, and conviction. In this riveting guide, Jessica Tarlov shows us how she does it. Because at some point or other, we all face disagreements—whether with colleagues, family, or friends—and want to walk away with both our values and our relationships intact.

Tarlov models an important and accessible route to building bravery for these conversations. She demonstrates that navigating contentious situations is a skill that requires radical honesty, knowing how to engage with numbers and statistics, understanding when to listen and when to talk, and articulating the common threads that unite us all. Tarlov has honed these skills with practice, and here, she reveals her tools of the trade for the first time. She also explores the future of coalition building, the policies that will animate voters, and a politics we can all feel better about.

Whether you find yourself at a charged debate with the in-laws, or in a tricky conversation with your boss, Jessica Tarlov will prepare you to stand up for what you believe in, even if it means standing alone—and why standing alone doesn’t mean standing apart.

Audible Audio

Published September 15, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jessica Tarlov

3 books22 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
172 (31%)
4 stars
238 (43%)
3 stars
117 (21%)
2 stars
17 (3%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews
Profile Image for Jennifer.
496 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 19, 2026
I went into this book with a different perspective than many readers because I regularly watch Jessica Tarlov on The Five. While I don't always agree with every position she takes, I've always respected the way she carries herself. Being the lone liberal voice at that table can't be easy, especially when conversations get heated, interruptions happen, and emotions run high. No matter where you fall politically, it's hard not to appreciate someone who consistently shows up prepared and willing to engage.

What I enjoyed most about this book wasn't the politics—it was the communication. Jessica shares how she learned to stand her ground, articulate her beliefs, and participate in difficult conversations without losing herself in the emotion of the moment. Her discussion about speaking with students at Columbia and answering questions about handling disagreement really resonated with me. So many people today either avoid tough conversations altogether or immediately become defensive when challenged. Jessica offers a different approach.

The biggest takeaway for me was the importance of knowing what you're talking about. Do your homework. Know your facts. Stick to your key points. Listen as much as you speak. And most importantly, understand that disagreement doesn't have to mean disrespect.

The book is incredibly well written, which wasn't surprising. Jessica comes across exactly as she does on television—intelligent, thoughtful, prepared, and confident. You can tell she has spent years refining these skills in some very public arenas.

Whether you agree with Jessica politically or not, I think there is value here for anyone who wants to become a better communicator, advocate for themselves more effectively, or learn how to navigate difficult conversations without damaging relationships.

In a world where everyone seems to be talking and very few people are actually listening, this book feels timely.

Congratulations to Jessica on a book that is not only informative, but genuinely useful. This is one I'll be recommending to friends.
Profile Image for Cindy.
899 reviews34 followers
July 5, 2026
I went back and forth on my views of this book as I read it but by the end I was very glad I did. At first I thought it was written for a more young adult - high school, college and early career audience - but that changed as I kept reading and learned more. I didn’t always love her points at the end of each chapter but that also changed as the topics went deeper the further I read. I do think it could still use one more edit - there were a number of times she repeated a sentence just a few pages apart - not a big deal but noticeable. By the end I was completely taken with her perspective and I have already started following her podcast. We need more people like her who are willing to talk to each other and respect each other and even love each other even if they recoil at some of their views. That’s the way we get this country back on track.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an early release in exchange for a fair and honest review.
Profile Image for Dude Who  Reads.
157 reviews1 follower
October 14, 2026
I wanted to like this book more than I did because I agree wholeheartedly with the premise. Our country desperately needs people who can disagree without treating the other side as the enemy, and we need to get much better at actually talking to people across the aisle.

Unfortunately, I Disagree mostly left me thinking Tarlov is good at telling me, not showing me. Tarlov spends much of the book talking about the importance of being in the room, hearing the other side, dropping your guard, and opening minds. All worthwhile ideas. But I kept wondering what any of that actually looks like when it succeeds.

That question became increasingly difficult for me to ignore when she discussed her role on The Five. She seems to view simply being at the table as a form of progress. But by her own admission, she hasn’t really changed anyone’s mind. The show consists largely of people talking over one another, delivering their predetermined bullet points, and moving on to the next topic. Her conservative cohosts frequently mock her positions rather than seriously engage with them. So what exactly is being accomplished? At times, it felt less like a story about how to thrive in hostile territory and influence people and more like a guide to surviving it.

She even says at one point that she needs smart people to disagree with her. Fair enough. But then… The Five?

One anecdote particularly crystallized my problem with the book. Tarlov tells a story about a trans woman at a Democratic event who thanked her because her conservative parents in Alabama watch Fox News, and perhaps hearing Tarlov advocate for trans rights might someday help them understand their daughter and speak to her again. It’s a touching hope. But it’s also just that: a hope. Did anything change? Did the parents reconsider their beliefs? Did the relationship improve? We don’t know. And of course Tarlov made an impact on the trans woman attending a Democratic event. That’s not exactly the audience this book is supposedly about reaching.

Compare that with something like Dale Carnegie’s How To Win Friends And Influence People, where the principles are accompanied by concrete examples demonstrating how and why they work. That’s what I found missing here. I don’t need every anecdote tied up neatly with a bow, but give me the time someone reconsidered a position because of one of these conversations. Give me the conservative who made Tarlov rethink something. Give me a contentious exchange that ended somewhere different from where it started.

I also found some of Tarlov’s arguments surprisingly broad for someone who places so much emphasis on data and critical thinking. She argues, for example, that “executive presence” is often code used against women who don’t look or act the part. Bias absolutely exists, but I’ve spent two decades in corporate America and have heard “executive presence” used countless times about men who weren’t polished enough, politically savvy enough, or capable of operating at the level expected of senior leadership.

Similarly, pointing out that tech leadership is overwhelmingly male is worth discussing, but what does the qualified candidate pool look like? How much of the disparity is discrimination, how much is pipeline, and how do the two interact? Those questions don’t eliminate bias—they make the analysis stronger. Too often the book paints in broad strokes when the subject deserves more scrutiny.

At another point, we learn that women who speak more softly may be perceived as more likable, while women who speak firmly may be perceived as more competent or respected but less likable. Is that uniquely a gender phenomenon, or is some version of that simply true of human beings? A stern, aggressive man generally isn’t winning Mr. Congeniality either. Again, there may very well be a gender disparity worth examining, but the book often seems more interested in arriving at the point than interrogating it.

The generational analysis bothered me for similar reasons. Gen Alpha supposedly wants peace and will “likely live in the suburbs.” Gen Alpha is generally defined as people born from roughly 2010 onward. We’re making confident predictions about the adult lifestyle preferences of people who are currently children? As someone obsessed with critical thinking, I need a little more skepticism about what a 10-year-old says they’ll want when they’re 35.

By the latter portions, the book also becomes increasingly preachy and generic. Stop obsessing over pronouns and talk about grocery and prescription-drug prices. Democrats need to vote this way. Candidates need to talk about that. Some of it is perfectly reasonable political advice, but little of it feels particularly new, and at times the book reads like a seventh-grade social studies textbook, complete with the helpful tips box at the end of the chapter.

There’s also an odd contradiction running through the entire thing. Tarlov acknowledges the faults of her own party and argues that liberals need to lower their guard and genuinely engage with conservatives—but admits she doesn’t know whether the other side will reciprocate. Well… yeah. That’s kind of the entire problem. If productive disagreement requires two willing participants, what happens when one side isn’t interested in the exercise?

How do you actually break through to someone who thinks you’re an idiot? How do you know when engagement is productive rather than performative? What happens when civility and good faith aren’t reciprocated? And at what point does participating in something like The Five stop being an exercise in productive disagreement and start making you complicit in the clown show?

There are interesting observations throughout, and I still think Tarlov is an intelligent and engaging voice. But too much of the book feels idealistic rather than tested. Being in the room is not inherently influential. Having the conversation is not inherently progress. And surviving four people yelling past you every week doesn’t mean anyone is listening.

If you’re going to hand me a playbook, eventually I want to know whether any of the plays worked.

Profile Image for Elizabeth Jorgensen.
Author 4 books158 followers
November 10, 2026
I’m not into politics, but I saw Jessica on Andy Cohen, and he seemed like such a fan that I decided to check out her book. I listened to the audiobook, and wow—I loved it. The way she used data to frame political issues made it so interesting, even for someone who usually avoids the topic.

Anyone interested in data should read this book. And honestly, I wasn’t particularly interested in data either, but she made me curious. That says a lot.
Profile Image for Steve Peifer.
574 reviews36 followers
September 27, 2026
I really like and respect Jessica Tarlov; she is so bright and articulate, and the courage and good nature she brings to a challenging work environment is inspiring.

The theme of the book is how you can engage with your political opponents and maintain a civil discourse while standing your ground. It’s good stuff. She weaves in her history and it’s honest, touching and funny.

However.

I start thinking about how toxic Fox is and all I could think about is this:

At least Mussolini made the trains run on time.

There is just a lot of how swell and supportive the co hosts are off camera, and I just can’t help the hundreds of millions of dollars Fox had to pay out for deliberately lying and then they didn’t seem so swell.

It didn’t ruin the book. You should read the book. I understand her gratitude and understanding what being on Fox has done for her career. And I think she provides an important service by providing an alternative to the usual party line.

Does the end justify the means? I wonder if that question keeps her up at night.

I still recommend the book.
16 reviews3 followers
October 14, 2026
She has a very unique literal ‘seat at the table’ and gives really interesting perspectives and insights. Towards the end she raises some really good thoughts on moving our country forward from this mess that I hope political strategists take note of.
However, it felt like it jumped all over the place and back again - definitely not in sequential order - and I could never figure out how/why it was structured as it was. That said, I listened to it as an audiobook and am more of a visual reader so perhaps it would have been easier for me to follow the layout if I’d read it as printed copy.
Profile Image for Donniesands.
160 reviews3 followers
October 25, 2026
I was pleasantly surprised to enjoy Tarlov’s life perspective and anecdotes. I was more looking for more focus on how to have good discussions with people. Some of the advice feels a bit too basic and maybe this is more a good intro to making good arguments. I don’t always agree with her but I think she’s very reasonable and refreshingly so.
Profile Image for Susan.
988 reviews5 followers
November 10, 2026
I expected to like this book a lot more than I did. I wasn't expecting to hear advice from a 42 year old. Maybe I am not her target audience being a 74 year old liberal woman. She came off as somewhat of a know-it-all, and I think she is quite full of herself. I respect what Tarlov does on Fox & Friends, but simply cannot understand being good friends with such hateful people. I believe that Jessica is on the right side of history as she recognizes what a devastating impact Trump has made on our country. I'm hoping she continues to learn ... she is a bright young lady.
Profile Image for Lori Johnson Warner.
55 reviews
October 12, 2026
I heard Jessica Tarlov on an interview and was intrigued about what it’s like to be the lone liberal on Fox’s The Five. She and I share a live for data and facts, and she weaves her points through her personal experiences and helps draw a map for better human connection, healthy debate, and shared vision and goals.
28 reviews
November 3, 2026
I respect that Jessica Tarlov holds her own as a liberal on the conservative Fox News program “The Five”. She has worked hard to hone her skills and her memory. Found some of her tips to be helpful, including looking for common ground, being vulnerable (be intentional about what you want to share), know your facts, and lighten up with humor.
Profile Image for Azim Tejani.
157 reviews2 followers
November 9, 2026
This is a damn good book and ought to be required reading for everyone over 50.
Profile Image for Demetri Papadimitropoulos.
1,094 reviews168 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 27, 2026
The Denominator, the Dinner Table, and the Last Word
Jessica Tarlov’s “I Disagree” turns statistics, television combat, and family life into an unexpectedly persuasive argument for staying in the room without surrendering the point
By Demetris Papadimitropoulos | August 27th, 2026

During an exhausting election season, pregnant with her second daughter and preparing for television as if every segment might decide the republic, Jessica Tarlov receives an intervention from Dana Perino. Tarlov has been cramming every usable statistic into every available minute, determined not only to make her case but to finish it. Perino reminds her that democracy is not resting on her shoulders. Then comes the sentence that ought to trouble a book called “I Disagree: Winning Arguments Without Losing Friends”: she does not have to win every argument. It is good advice for Tarlov and inconvenient advice for the subtitle, which spends the rest of the book being quietly argued with.

Even without the subtitle, one quickly gathers that Tarlov relishes rebuttal. As the liberal co-host of “The Five,” she is professionally outnumbered: four colleagues, one dissenting chair, millions of viewers, airtime measured in breaths. She begins “I Disagree” by promising techniques for keeping one’s footing in hostile conversation. The book gets stranger, and better, when winning starts to look like an incomplete ambition. What good is the last word if everyone has begun arranging their lives so they never have to hear one another again? Tarlov never becomes indifferent to victory. She simply discovers that some victories are too expensive.

Much of the book traces how Tarlov acquired her particular ease with conflict. Her parents treated argument as ordinary household weather. Sports followed, then Bryn Mawr, graduate study at the London School of Economics, polling, research at Bustle, television, marriage and motherhood. In outline, the sequence could resemble a résumé with unusually good jokes. Long before she could disagree before millions, she lived in a family where contradiction did not send anyone packing. Her public persona is not presented as armor invented for television so much as a domestic habit turned up to broadcast volume.

Early on, her father gives competition its ethic. When the girls’ basketball team at Tarlov’s school is repeatedly assigned inferior game times, he presses the administration until the schedule changes. He likes a fight, but he wants the fight attached to something. Tarlov learns how to compete in public; from him she learns why. Winning without a reason beyond the win itself is only noise with a scoreboard.

Tarlov likes being right too. She says so with enough self-mockery to compare herself to Tracy Flick, the ferociously industrious overachiever of Alexander Payne’s film “Election.” Yet her confidence looks less like temperament alone once the book has shown us what holds it up: obsessive preparation, quantitative training, colleagues who respect the role she plays, an employer that protects her seat, a family in which disagreement was not a rehearsal for banishment. Televised composure has infrastructure.

Rooms, however, do not distribute that infrastructure evenly. Tarlov’s chapter on women and authority is alert to the shadow argument many women conduct while making the stated one: too loud, too cold, too ambitious, too emotional, overly polished, insufficiently polished. She also concedes that her own workplace has often given her unusual cover. A cable panel with assigned chairs and a contract is not the same arena as a meeting where the person interrupting you also writes your performance review. The difference matters because conversational technique cannot decide who has the power to end the conversation.

If Tarlov has a comic intellectual fetish, it is the denominator. Plenty of books about difficult conversation put most of their faith in empathy; she wants the sample size. She explains framing, averages, polling margins and the danger of turning one vivid case into a theory of the world. Sometimes she makes quantitative reasoning sound easier than it is. Her numbers are most persuasive, though, when they are permitted to betray their owner. Tarlov’s professional reputation depends partly on having the right statistic ready at the right moment; the book improves whenever preparedness also means being available for correction.

Pressed to test her own doctoral theory about which kinds of political scandals damage candidates, Tarlov spends years acquiring the statistical tools to do it properly. The findings refuse to cooperate. That episode is more persuasive than any list of debating tips because the data does not rescue her from somebody else’s mistake. It spoils her own neat idea. For Tarlov, a useful statistic should be capable of ruining your afternoon.

At sentence level, “I Disagree” has the clip of someone accustomed to watching a producer count down just outside her eyeline. The prose is brisk, speech-shaped and deliberately unceremonious. Short declaratives do much of the work. Rhetorical questions and comic side glances keep the research from setting like plaster. Tarlov moves easily from regression models to dating, from polling to television makeup, from workplace bias to bedtime logistics. The writing rarely lingers over an image for its own sake. It likes movement, timing, the clean landing. When that pace slows, as it does around her father’s illness, an image such as a wheelchair at a wedding suddenly has room to stay.

Perhaps that ease explains how the book carries research without sounding burdened by it. Adam Grant’s “Think Again” is a useful tonal cousin: both writers prefer the seminar with the door open. Tarlov, though, is more autobiographical, more partisan and more eager for the bell to ring. A study may be followed by a joke; a statistical principle may share space with pastrami. She does not confuse solemnity with seriousness, which is useful in a book suspicious of people who mistake moral volume for moral force.

A less appealing television habit follows. Tarlov likes to land a point, and then sometimes supplies landing instructions. A vivid anecdote becomes an interpretation, which becomes a takeaway, sometimes followed by a question for the reader. For a handbook meant to be reopened chapter by chapter, the template is practical. Read straight through, it can feel as though a good scene has been fitted with both a caption and an explanatory plaque. The reader is almost never confused; sometimes she is accompanied to the exit after already putting on her coat.

Designed in three parts, the book does more than sort its material into bins. Part I assembles the speaker: family, ambition, voice, presentation. Part II brings in statistics, criticism, polling, fear, gendered disadvantage and vulnerability. Part III carries those habits into electoral life. What matters is that the sequence also corrects itself. Confidence seems less self-sufficient after the book has spent time with bias, exhaustion and the possibility of being wrong. Part II is not merely an equipment upgrade for the woman Part I introduced; it places conditions around her certainty.

In Part III, the person being addressed begins to change. The early chapters could speak to someone facing an uncle, coworker, friend or boss. The later ones increasingly address somebody invested in how Democrats select candidates, frame cultural disputes, define moderation and assemble a winning coalition. Tarlov clearly believes interpersonal and electoral persuasion sit on the same continuum. Perhaps they do. But a reader who entered for Thanksgiving-dinner advice can suddenly find herself seated at a strategy meeting.

Making the book more partisan also gives it friction it badly needs. Tarlov has beliefs, and the whole experiment would be meaningless if she did not care whether any of them prevailed. The trouble is that her inventory of prescriptions for party repair is thinner than her account of what makes persuasion possible in the first place. Candidate selection, coalition management and cultural positioning receive crisp answers where earlier chapters had room for ambiguity. The farther “I Disagree” travels into campaign strategy, the more familiar its shelves begin to look.

Illness then changes the scale. Tarlov’s father develops tongue cancer and eventually dies. Her wedding takes place while he is gravely ill; her mother grips his wheelchair as celebration and approaching bereavement occupy the same room. Tarlov is usually eager to turn experience into use, but these pages improve when they resist conversion. No amount of preparation can make loss behave like a problem with a sufficiently good data set. That failure of mastery carries unusual force after hundreds of pages showing how much mastery preparation can buy.

The table has been sitting in plain sight all along, though her father’s decline changes what we notice about it. First it is the family table, where Tarlov learns that argument does not cancel love. Then comes the studio table, where dissent is a job. Later it becomes the imagined civic table, where the question is less who speaks than who is still permitted to remain while speaking against the room. By the holiday appendix, dinner has returned. The table is an arena, certainly, but also evidence of continued membership: you can be furious with the people around it and still be expected for dinner.

Rarely does that pressure feel more concrete than after a contentious political panel, when a transgender woman from Alabama approaches Tarlov and tells her that her conservative family no longer speaks to her. They watch Tarlov on television. The woman does not share every position Tarlov has taken, but she values the presence of someone who can enter her parents’ political world, disagree with much of it and refuse to treat the people inside as untouchable. What she wants is not a better rebuttal. She wants the possibility of going home. Tarlov cannot give her that, of course. Her presence has merely made estrangement seem, for a moment, less final.

Of Amanda Ripley’s “High Conflict,” the useful comparison lies in the difference. Ripley examines systems that let conflict swallow identity; Tarlov does not particularly want to escape disagreement. She enjoys it too much. Her preferred state is conflict that remains vigorous without becoming total, curiosity without surrender, exposure without conversion. The posture is less peacemaking than reconnaissance with manners. Calling Tarlov a bridge-builder would be too placid for someone who plainly enjoys making the bridge shake.

Put the model outside the studio and its limits become easier to see. Imagine the hostile boss rather than the professional co-host, the abusive relative rather than the uncle who merely votes differently. Some rooms offer no meaningful protection for continued engagement. Some people can quarrel and report back to work the following morning; others risk livelihood, safety or family recognition. Tarlov sees these asymmetries most clearly when she writes about gender, but her faith in staying in the room sometimes travels beyond the rooms her evidence can secure. Sometimes the correct conversational technique is an exit. The book would be stronger if it drew that boundary instead of leaving readers to infer it from exceptions.

Our easiest response to disagreement is increasingly logistical: mute, unfollow, skip dinner. “I Disagree” eventually becomes interested in that withdrawal, especially when separate media worlds make an argument over conclusions feel like an argument over what happened at all. Tarlov’s answer is stubbornly ordinary. Keep encountering people. She does not promise that proximity produces agreement. She suggests something smaller: sustained exposure can make certain caricatures harder to maintain. That modesty suits the evidence better than any promise about changing minds.

Under all the tips, polls and campaign prescriptions, Tarlov herself remains the strongest case for the method. She is combative without being joyless, occasionally overcertain, delighted by the clean statistic and candid about the exhaustion produced by treating every exchange like a final round. A lesser guide might offer the tranquil wisdom of someone who claims to have transcended conflict. Tarlov offers the more entertaining sight of someone who enjoys winning enough to discover its limits from the inside.

Looked at whole, “I Disagree” lands at 83/100, or 4/5 stars. Its prose is lively rather than formally daring, its chapter template repeats itself, and its final partisan destination cannot sustain the depth of every prescription it offers. But the quantitative intelligence is real, the voice holds, and the family material keeps the practical advice tethered to consequence. The guide is most persuasive when its tidy categories start misbehaving: evidence rebukes certainty, vulnerability complicates performance, winning is demoted by the cost of being alone.

Only in the epilogue does “losing” fully displace “winning” as the more serious verb. Tarlov turns from campaigns and polls toward loneliness, including the kind people manufacture themselves when avoiding friction becomes easier than remaining available to one another. Politics still matters; it simply finds itself competing with a father’s hand, a marriage, children, friendship, ordinary kindness. A lost point and a lost person belong to different systems of measurement.

So “I Disagree” begins with the problem of keeping your chair while nearly everyone around the table thinks you are wrong. By the end, the clever rebuttal matters less than what follows it: after the poll, after the segment, after each person has enjoyed the last word they were determined to have. The chairs are still there. The question is who comes back tomorrow.
11 reviews
November 15, 2026
I became familiar with Jessica while listening to Raging Moderates as I don’t watch Fox News. I really enjoyed listening to her and throughly enjoyed this book!
Profile Image for Tom.
72 reviews4 followers
October 12, 2026
I really like Jessica Tarlov. I think she wrote a good book here, but it is hard to really figure out what this book was after reading it. It was part instruction manual, part memoir, but I'm not sure how well everything connected in the book. The tips for how to disagree were good, but that was only maybe the first 1/3 of the book. I found the ending of the book rather lackluster as well. I also found the appendix about how to convince MAGA people to change their minds not convincing to those in the cult of Rump. So that was actually a turn-off. I really feel like facts don't matter to the red hats. Anyway, was it worth the read, sure. Would it be better than a 3-star book, no.
Profile Image for Paulina Kristin.
34 reviews
October 27, 2026
there were moments when i felt the author was a bit self-aggrandizing with name dropping and accomplishments, but at the same time i recognize it may be a bit of internalized misogyny. so on second thought - heck yeah, i love to see smart women succeed, louder for the people in the back!! her approach to politics and debating is refreshingly logical and factual in a world of emotions and cherry-picked talking points. my only regret was listening to the audiobook instead of buying a physical copy that i could annotate and come back to easily for refreshers. now i want to arm myself with some good stats to thoughtfully, articulately, and credibly disagree.
Profile Image for Jaclyn Gruenbaum.
227 reviews4 followers
September 21, 2026
Couldn’t care less about the how to argue part. Was more interested in Jessica’s anecdotes.
Profile Image for Steve Wilhoit.
19 reviews
November 16, 2026
Why did I rate this book so highly? Because (A) it is so well written and (B) it shows a keen ability to express opinion while respecting those she doesn't necessarily agree with.

Her stats-based method in arguments is so sound, in my opinion. And she does show the ability to vary her overall view if the facts call for adjustment.

I like that this book is very current, written before the recent elections, but with a feel on the needs of candidates to understand current society, for better or for worse. Much of that has now played out.

In short, we can have our views while being aware that even those who may disagree on some issues are human beings as we are. This gives us an opportunity to search for hybrid solutions.

There are some in governmental circles and even some we may encounter in our every day life who have tried to and oftentimes taken advantage of the public with rhetoric and misinformation. Some have done this and continue to attempt to do this for personal gain. Others are subsequently misled.

That being said, my opinion and yours can be different at times. That's okay. What isn't okay is intentional misinformation whatever the issue may be. We should always learn from each other and express our thoughts in a human way.

The author does an extraordinary job of documenting information while in turn listening to even those she may not agree with on specific issues. There's a way to have an articulate and respectful conversation. Tarlov does a great job of putting that into practice on-air and in this book.



Profile Image for Laurie Shook .
327 reviews52 followers
November 12, 2026
I'm glad I read I Disagree: Winning Arguments Without Losing Friends by Jessica Tarlov. Tarlov is a most unlikely media personality who serves as the lone liberal on the Fox News show "The Five." A self-professed "data geek", she got into polling and political work and earned a PhD in Government from the London School of Economics and Political Science. She parlayed that into a career in political commentary on TV and is a podcast co-host on "Raging Moderates." This book is a memoir chock full of advice and chapter-ending tips to apply the lessons to your life and debates with others of differing opinions.

It takes a thick skin to enter a room where you're outnumbered, out-argued, and calmly sharing facts day after day. I wish there were more brave souls like Jessica willing to do this. If we were, we could escape our current echo chambers that keep us from listening to differing viewpoints and being open to change.

NGL, her voice is grating in audiobook format, a fact she addresses in the book. I found it helpful to pair the audiobook for speed with the ebook for retention. Rating: 3.75 stars
Profile Image for Frank.
74 reviews36 followers
September 23, 2026
I’ve gotten into plenty of political arguments. I can’t think of many that made anything better.

That’s why Jessica Tarlov’s I Disagree hit home for me. She makes a strong case for what she believes, often in a room full of people who disagree with her. I admire that. But the book also made me think about the conversations I’ve had where I came prepared with facts and left frustrated that none of them seemed to matter.

Her discussion of motivated reasoning stuck with me. When a fact threatens something we believe deeply, we can find a way around it without even noticing. I can name people who do that. I’d rather not think about the times I’ve done it myself.

I know people on the right who would get something out of this book. I know people on the left who would, too. Some of them might even be annoyed by the same parts. Good. I was. Tarlov made me ask what I’m trying to accomplish when I argue with someone I care about. If I’ve said my piece but neither of us wants to have dinner together afterward, what did I win?

I really enjoyed this book. I’m still going to speak up when something matters to me. I may ask a few more questions first.
Profile Image for Amy.
346 reviews5 followers
November 14, 2026
#IDisagree #NetGalley
My husband has been watching The Five for years. There was a voice I would hear from time to time that just grated on my nerves. Little did I know I was listening to Jessica Tarlov, a woman who would eventually impress, engage, and inspire me. Her explanation of "vocal fry" is actually important! And that voice? It led me straight to Raging Moderates. What a great podcast!

But back to the book. Ms. Tarlov is smart, strong, and articulate. How else could she hold her own with her buddies on The Five?

This book became personal for me. I live with a devout Republican who believes Trump can do no wrong. I came to this book hoping to understand him better and, more importantly, to learn how we might engage in peaceful disagreement. Jessica Tarlov gave me hope.

I came away with a much better understanding of where we are, how we got here, and, most importantly, how we can shift the conversation toward something more productive. I took tons of notes while reading: sections I want to revisit, podcasts to listen to, books to read, and people to follow. What an education!

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for sharing this wonderful book with me.
Profile Image for Marc Pressley.
88 reviews1 follower
October 26, 2026
Overall, I enjoyed reading about the author's experiences in life and as the lone liberal on Fox's The Five. She brings up a number of good points, and I admire how she advocates for understanding "the other side" (no matter which side you're on) and treating people with respect, even while disagreeing with them. On general principles, I find way more we can agree on than disagree.

And yet, by the end of the book, I'm mildly underwhelmed. What does it all boil down to? Don't take yourself too seriously, treat other people the way you'd like to be treated, be authentic (charming if possible), and actively listen. If we all did that, we wouldn't have nearly the problems we do now. We could have honest discussions where people could be open to good ideas and agree on what makes a bad idea. That would be great. A more appropriate title might have been "Staying Calm Under Stress." Or maybe "Don't be a Troll." I don't know.

At any rate, it's entertaining, provokes a little thought, and is generally worth the read. I just wouldn't go into it looking for life-changing advice.
Profile Image for Jasmine Hall.
226 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 14, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for providing me with the advance copy. I am getting into the habit of reading some political books that are not too extreme. Jessica Tarlov has been something that I enjoyed to watch. She is the lone liberal voice on The Five and sometimes it is not easy. Jessica talks about communication and how she was able to do it every weekday on The Five and she gave us some pointers. One of my favorite was her talking about her doing her homework before she spoke which is true because sometimes, I love to speak without thinking straight. This would be great for a communications class.
321 reviews11 followers
October 4, 2026
I am not a Fox viewer, so the first time I saw Jessica Tarlov was as a guest on a YouTube podcast. When I learned about her book and her challenging work on Fox, I had to read it. Any help with dealing with family and friends on the opposite side of the aisle seemed to be worth a listen, and it was. Jessica' s strengths with research, evidence, data and communication are the framework of her book and her voice. Her strategies come down to knowing the facts, and having the ability to hone her responses in a way that she is heard. It was a hard book to tackle in our current time of division and brave of Tarlov to tackle. I'm glad she did.
1 review
September 27, 2026
I initially wanted to get the book because I love the Raging Moderates podcast. I wasn’t familiar with her background or other work and had only watched clips of The Five. I downloaded the audiobook which she narrates.

I found her engaging and enjoyed how she wove stories from her life into the points she was making. I did not expect to learn so many practical tips that I will incorporate into conversations with my MAGA family members. I know that if I had a hard copy, it would be full of highlighted pages. I loved the book.
Profile Image for Lisa Davidson.
2,096 reviews32 followers
October 5, 2026
I aspire to have a fraction of the patience of Jessica Tarlov. But at least after this book, I can see where she's coming from. She's truly a rational, empathetic person, but her basis for being able to do what she does is a focus on communication.
Tarlov is incredibly intelligent but that wouldn't go very far if she didn't also make a point of doing her research. This isn't going to make me start listening to podcasts, but I am really impressed with her.
Thanks to NetGalley for letting me read this
Profile Image for jngarz.
200 reviews3 followers
October 7, 2026
This book was recommended by a member of my fiancé’s family. I don’t watch Fox News, or any cable tv anymore, for that matter. I had seen Jessica in clips online, so I sort of knew who she was. I really enjoyed reading her perspective and her overall antidotes. I would recommend this book to anyone with an open mind. Unfortunately, I fear the people who “need” to read this, won’t, due to who Jessica is, and a bias that is held against her and what she believes. If your worldview has the capability for flexibility, I would also recommend this read!
326 reviews2 followers
October 8, 2026
Huge Jessica Tarlov fan, both on The Five where she holds her own as the lone liberal at the table and on her podcast Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway. She is the epitome of prepared, informed, and persuasive. Of course, no surprise that I enjoyed this book, and it's well worth a listen, but I wish it had been twice the length with deeper dives. It felt a little short and like, this is what I can get out there because I'm incredibly busy, which she certainly is. That's the main reason for my 3.75-star rating. Seriously though, for folks not familiar with Tarlov, she is incredible!
Profile Image for Heather.
74 reviews
October 6, 2026
I really enjoyed the book and think it is so timely in its message of how to disagree better. We absolutely need voices like Jessica’s demonstrating that you can humanely and civilly disagree and work towards something better together at the same time. I think I was expecting more of a toolbox than it was, but still really appreciated learning about her and her experiences speaking her voice in many situations where she was surrounded by people who thought very differently than her.
Profile Image for Guida Brown.
396 reviews
October 18, 2026
This is one of those books that I wish I could require everyone I know to read. Tarlov knows what she’s talking about when she tells us how to “stay true to our values, find common ground, and communicate with confidence when engaging across political and social divides.”

It’s written very much like an oral conversation, so there were some parts I had to reread in order to understand, but the outcome was well worth the effort.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews