What do you think?
Rate this book
Reign of the Empire #2
Star Wars: Edge of the Abyss (Reign of the Empire)
Set in the year before the first season of Andor, the sequel to The Mask of Fear.
The second installment in the Reign of the Empire series follows Bail Organa, Mon Mothma, and Saw Gerrera (along with their allies and enemies) thirteen years after the events of The Mask of Fear as they navigate the Empire's nigh-unbreakable chokehold over the galaxy.
The second installment in the Reign of the Empire series follows Bail Organa, Mon Mothma, and Saw Gerrera (along with their allies and enemies) thirteen years after the events of The Mask of Fear as they navigate the Empire's nigh-unbreakable chokehold over the galaxy.
325 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 15, 2026
About the author
Rebecca Roanhorse
61 books10.7k followersRebecca Roanhorse is a New York Times bestselling and Nebula, Hugo, and Locus Award-winning speculative fiction writer. She has published multiple award-winning short stories and novels, including two novels in The Sixth World Series, Star Wars: Resistance Reborn, Race to the Sun for the Rick Riordan imprint, and the epic fantasy trilogy Between Earth and Sky. She has also written for Marvel Comics and games and for television, including FX’s A Murder at the End of the World, and the Marvel series Echo for Disney+. She has had her own work optioned by Amazon Studios, Netflix, and AMC Studios.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews
September 19, 2026
The publishing team at Lucasfilm and Random House made an interesting choice in releasing a trilogy written by three different authors. Alexander Freed did a phenomenal job with The Mask of Fear, the first entry in the Reign of the Empire series last year. As such, Rebecca Roanhorse had big shoes to fill with Edge of the Abyss. Thankfully, she did an admirable job!
One thing I really enjoyed was that the writing styles were quite a bit similar. The team did a good job of making sure they blended really well. This book captures the political thriller and spy thriller elements that were present not only in book 1, but also in Andor, of which this trilogy is an excellent companion!
This book is much shorter and faster paced than it's predecessor. The Mask of Fear was approximately 450 pages long, and Edge of the Abyss is a brisk 300 pages, only 2/3 of Freed's books' length. However, this does help the book feel propulsive and read very quickly.
Book 1 was very much pitched as Mon Mothma's book, that also had a large cast of other characters. This book was pitched as Saw's book, and at the beginning it starts that way, but this book is a really balanced ensemble book.
I loved quite a bit of the twists and reveals in this book. There's a particular scene where a character is talking to another character, whose identity we don't know. I had a guess of this character's identity, but they used a phrase that made me realize who it was and it was just handled excellently!
This book also gives us some insight into Leida and Leia, who are two very different characters and seem to develop oppositely. It's incredibly interesting watching their worldviews develop, even despite the short time on the page they have.
The book has even more thematic and storybuilding ties to Andor than book 1 did, from characters like Anto Kreegr to planets like Ghorman. Roanhorse did a great job of making the connections not feel forced or too cheaply done.
One criticism I have of the book is that the climax was way too small scale and too anti-climactic for what was promised. The book is a lot like some Andor episodes in that way. However, had Roanhorse not only devoted about 30-50 more pages to expanding the climax (maybe making it more of a 'heist' story?) then it would have been most excellent!
Another critisism I have is that by being an ensemble book, we don't really get as much of development to Saw Gurrera as we got for Mon Mothma in book 1. Saw maybe doesn't need that development, but I think it would have made the book feel more special.
One criticism I do have is that the art team decided to include Luthen Rael on the cover, and while he is in the book, it is in an extremely limited capacity. I worry that might give people the wrong impression and might make people disappointed in the book.
I also am still not the biggest fan of the Chemish character, although I liked Chemish's story just a bit more here than in book 1.
Back to things I liked, there is a subplot about a character who is sent to an imperial prison and a lawyer being assigned to her, but that lawyer is being influenced by both Bail Organa and Saw Gurrera without knowing it. That was probably the best element of the book.
Overall, I did quite enjoy this book. I still believe that book 1 was quite a bit better, so it's not as good by comparison. However, I did have quite a fun time with this one. It does feel a lot like the transition episodes of Andor, which might not be the best episodes of Andor, but are still quite good. 8.5 out of 10!
One thing I really enjoyed was that the writing styles were quite a bit similar. The team did a good job of making sure they blended really well. This book captures the political thriller and spy thriller elements that were present not only in book 1, but also in Andor, of which this trilogy is an excellent companion!
This book is much shorter and faster paced than it's predecessor. The Mask of Fear was approximately 450 pages long, and Edge of the Abyss is a brisk 300 pages, only 2/3 of Freed's books' length. However, this does help the book feel propulsive and read very quickly.
Book 1 was very much pitched as Mon Mothma's book, that also had a large cast of other characters. This book was pitched as Saw's book, and at the beginning it starts that way, but this book is a really balanced ensemble book.
I loved quite a bit of the twists and reveals in this book. There's a particular scene where a character is talking to another character, whose identity we don't know. I had a guess of this character's identity, but they used a phrase that made me realize who it was and it was just handled excellently!
This book also gives us some insight into Leida and Leia, who are two very different characters and seem to develop oppositely. It's incredibly interesting watching their worldviews develop, even despite the short time on the page they have.
The book has even more thematic and storybuilding ties to Andor than book 1 did, from characters like Anto Kreegr to planets like Ghorman. Roanhorse did a great job of making the connections not feel forced or too cheaply done.
One criticism I have of the book is that the climax was way too small scale and too anti-climactic for what was promised. The book is a lot like some Andor episodes in that way. However, had Roanhorse not only devoted about 30-50 more pages to expanding the climax (maybe making it more of a 'heist' story?) then it would have been most excellent!
Another critisism I have is that by being an ensemble book, we don't really get as much of development to Saw Gurrera as we got for Mon Mothma in book 1. Saw maybe doesn't need that development, but I think it would have made the book feel more special.
One criticism I do have is that the art team decided to include Luthen Rael on the cover, and while he is in the book, it is in an extremely limited capacity. I worry that might give people the wrong impression and might make people disappointed in the book.
I also am still not the biggest fan of the Chemish character, although I liked Chemish's story just a bit more here than in book 1.
Back to things I liked, there is a subplot about a character who is sent to an imperial prison and a lawyer being assigned to her, but that lawyer is being influenced by both Bail Organa and Saw Gurrera without knowing it. That was probably the best element of the book.
Overall, I did quite enjoy this book. I still believe that book 1 was quite a bit better, so it's not as good by comparison. However, I did have quite a fun time with this one. It does feel a lot like the transition episodes of Andor, which might not be the best episodes of Andor, but are still quite good. 8.5 out of 10!
October 4, 2026
Really enjoyed the 2nd part of the trilogy. A good story, interesting new characters and the ones we already know are written very well. Got quite some echo's from Andor and it surely didn't forget the first book. A job well done!
September 22, 2026
I always take notes when I read to help with writing my reviews. I was so engrossed with this book I took exactly zero notes, lol. I have been reading Star Wars novels since dinosaurs roamed the earth and the OG Thrawn trilogy has always stood atop the pantheon. When I tell you the Reign of the Empire series is challenging for the top spot, please understand what a gargantuan undertaking that is. Edge of the Abyss is everything I want in a Star Wars novel. If you’re a fan of the Andor TV series and you haven’t started this series yet, you are missing out on your next obsession.
September 14, 2026
From my Substack:
In ‘Reign of the Empire: Edge of the Abyss’ Star Wars characters burn their pasts for a brighter future
‘Twas the night before Rebellion in the newest Star Wars book, Reign of the Empire: Edge of the Abyss by Rebecca Roanhorse — out this week from Random House Worlds.
Set about a decade after the first book — The Mask of Fear — and a year before the events of Andor, Edge of the Abyss again follows the three disparate figures who become the architects of the Rebellion against the Empire. Mon Mothma, Bail Organa, and Saw Gerrera are the same but different after a decade under Imperial rule. They’ve hardened, certainly, and have been challenged and pushed to the point where they realize something has to give. Their usual methods of resistance and undermining the Empire have brought them far, but in this book, all three characters face moments of doubt and indecision. And all of them, perhaps none more so than Saw Gerrara, are forced to confront how their sacrifices and dirty deeds for “the cause” have affected those around them.
As the second book in the trilogy, Edge of the Abyss had the unenviable task of expanding the story and characters established in the first book while balancing the need for a tentative conclusion and an enticing cliffhanger. I had little doubt in Roanhorse’s capabilities, especially considering I recently revisited Resistance Reborn — a story gap filler (positive) between The Last Jedi and The Force Awakens. Her newest Star Wars entry actually exceeded my expectations with masterful character work and simmering political tension.
Like the first novel, Edge of the Abyss has a large cast of characters — all with conflicting goals and motivations. Their individual ideas of resistance, stability, and peace frequently clash, especially as their storylines converge into the overarching plot of the book. And what an ambitious, well-paced plot it is: What will it take for Mothma, Organa, and Gerrera to cross the line into outright rebellion? When will they learn that they are stronger together?
Edge of the Abyss isn’t about the moment the Rebel Alliance is formed, but rather it adds to the growing list of “small” moments with big impact and consequences. For Mothma, it’s about trying to chip away at the Empire’s political power and its campaigns of disinformation and propaganda. This Mothma still believes in legislative power and political scheming as a way to funnel funds to charities and resistance efforts via Luthen Rael (he and Kleya have small but intriguing roles in this book).
For Organa, he’s moved past his obsession with exonerating the Jedi. Instead, he tries to balance making a difference through small acts and a steadfast dedication to keeping his family safe. The touching moments between him and Breha, and a few with Leia, are beautiful and bittersweet, considering their fates.
And then there’s Saw Gerrera. He has turned his trauma into fuel for his righteous cause. And he’s determined to fight the oppressors by any horrific, violent means necessary, even if it means burning down the galaxy in the process.
Beyond the trilogy’s main players are new and returning characters who arguably represent the book’s most important messages. There’s a soon-to-be mother trying to move on from her violent past. Her lawyer husband is an idealist who still believes justice is possible. There’s a wannabe rebel who wants to be taken seriously in his resistance methods. There’s the galaxy’s biggest pop star, who uses her propaganda-laced music and ties to a COMPNOR officer to hide her efforts to help resistance fighters.
Then there’s Chemis, who was introduced in the first book as a young apprentice learning the ways of spycraft. A decade later, they’re a full-blown undercover ISB agent sent to Ghorman to infiltrate a student action group. Chemish has the most compelling, heartbreaking, and hopeful story in this book. I cannot wait to see how their story continues in the last book.
The only complaint I have about Edge of the Abyss is that it was over too soon. There are few Star Wars books I read as fast as this one. I couldn’t help it — the multi-POV chapters were short, but each one packed a punch. I didn’t favor one POV over the others — all of them were engaging and quickly converged despite their many degrees of separation.
The book’s setting is enticing on its own — we’re only a few years away from A New Hope, and there’s already so much simmering tension between the disorganized rebel “factions.” Mothma, Organa, and Gerrera are barreling toward pivotal moments that will change their lives and the future of the galaxy. But while the other characters’ stories have relatively minor impacts on the larger story, their perspectives are much more relatable. Each one is just trying to do what is right for themselves, their family, and their friends. They want peace and justice, and through their journeys in this book, learn that it’s never too late to choose a better path.
All of these words to say, Edge of the Abyss is an excellent book. It does so many things right in its storytelling — not just for the Reign of the Empire trilogy but for Star Wars books overall. It’s perfect for Andor fans, of course, but also for fans craving more mature, raw, and realistic Star Wars storytelling. And just like Andor, you’ll be haunted by the poignant prose and political thrills in Edge of the Abyss. You’ll be thinking about this book, its characters, and its message long after you turn the last page.
In ‘Reign of the Empire: Edge of the Abyss’ Star Wars characters burn their pasts for a brighter future
‘Twas the night before Rebellion in the newest Star Wars book, Reign of the Empire: Edge of the Abyss by Rebecca Roanhorse — out this week from Random House Worlds.
Set about a decade after the first book — The Mask of Fear — and a year before the events of Andor, Edge of the Abyss again follows the three disparate figures who become the architects of the Rebellion against the Empire. Mon Mothma, Bail Organa, and Saw Gerrera are the same but different after a decade under Imperial rule. They’ve hardened, certainly, and have been challenged and pushed to the point where they realize something has to give. Their usual methods of resistance and undermining the Empire have brought them far, but in this book, all three characters face moments of doubt and indecision. And all of them, perhaps none more so than Saw Gerrara, are forced to confront how their sacrifices and dirty deeds for “the cause” have affected those around them.
As the second book in the trilogy, Edge of the Abyss had the unenviable task of expanding the story and characters established in the first book while balancing the need for a tentative conclusion and an enticing cliffhanger. I had little doubt in Roanhorse’s capabilities, especially considering I recently revisited Resistance Reborn — a story gap filler (positive) between The Last Jedi and The Force Awakens. Her newest Star Wars entry actually exceeded my expectations with masterful character work and simmering political tension.
Like the first novel, Edge of the Abyss has a large cast of characters — all with conflicting goals and motivations. Their individual ideas of resistance, stability, and peace frequently clash, especially as their storylines converge into the overarching plot of the book. And what an ambitious, well-paced plot it is: What will it take for Mothma, Organa, and Gerrera to cross the line into outright rebellion? When will they learn that they are stronger together?
Edge of the Abyss isn’t about the moment the Rebel Alliance is formed, but rather it adds to the growing list of “small” moments with big impact and consequences. For Mothma, it’s about trying to chip away at the Empire’s political power and its campaigns of disinformation and propaganda. This Mothma still believes in legislative power and political scheming as a way to funnel funds to charities and resistance efforts via Luthen Rael (he and Kleya have small but intriguing roles in this book).
For Organa, he’s moved past his obsession with exonerating the Jedi. Instead, he tries to balance making a difference through small acts and a steadfast dedication to keeping his family safe. The touching moments between him and Breha, and a few with Leia, are beautiful and bittersweet, considering their fates.
And then there’s Saw Gerrera. He has turned his trauma into fuel for his righteous cause. And he’s determined to fight the oppressors by any horrific, violent means necessary, even if it means burning down the galaxy in the process.
Beyond the trilogy’s main players are new and returning characters who arguably represent the book’s most important messages. There’s a soon-to-be mother trying to move on from her violent past. Her lawyer husband is an idealist who still believes justice is possible. There’s a wannabe rebel who wants to be taken seriously in his resistance methods. There’s the galaxy’s biggest pop star, who uses her propaganda-laced music and ties to a COMPNOR officer to hide her efforts to help resistance fighters.
Then there’s Chemis, who was introduced in the first book as a young apprentice learning the ways of spycraft. A decade later, they’re a full-blown undercover ISB agent sent to Ghorman to infiltrate a student action group. Chemish has the most compelling, heartbreaking, and hopeful story in this book. I cannot wait to see how their story continues in the last book.
The only complaint I have about Edge of the Abyss is that it was over too soon. There are few Star Wars books I read as fast as this one. I couldn’t help it — the multi-POV chapters were short, but each one packed a punch. I didn’t favor one POV over the others — all of them were engaging and quickly converged despite their many degrees of separation.
The book’s setting is enticing on its own — we’re only a few years away from A New Hope, and there’s already so much simmering tension between the disorganized rebel “factions.” Mothma, Organa, and Gerrera are barreling toward pivotal moments that will change their lives and the future of the galaxy. But while the other characters’ stories have relatively minor impacts on the larger story, their perspectives are much more relatable. Each one is just trying to do what is right for themselves, their family, and their friends. They want peace and justice, and through their journeys in this book, learn that it’s never too late to choose a better path.
All of these words to say, Edge of the Abyss is an excellent book. It does so many things right in its storytelling — not just for the Reign of the Empire trilogy but for Star Wars books overall. It’s perfect for Andor fans, of course, but also for fans craving more mature, raw, and realistic Star Wars storytelling. And just like Andor, you’ll be haunted by the poignant prose and political thrills in Edge of the Abyss. You’ll be thinking about this book, its characters, and its message long after you turn the last page.
August 24, 2026
The Empire’s rule has spread during its decade long dominance of the galaxy and its long hand crushes all defiance and stomps any signs of insurrection. Senators Mon Mothma and Bail Organa have changed their tactics but still fight the Emperor in their own way. Meanwhile, Saw Gerrera devises a plan to set a comrade free after falling in the hands of the enemy. On the planet Ghorman, the Student Action Alliance (SAA) raises its voice against the Empire’s attacks on planets sovereignty and constant meddling. Not to be caught off-guard, the Imperial Security Bureau (ISB) sends an agent to the capital city of Palmo to infiltrate the group and report any signs of escalation.
In early 2025 Star Wars released The Mask of Fear, the first in a trilogy of books under the Reign of the Empire collection. Now, a year and a half after Alexander Freed’s masterpiece, Rebecca Roanhorse delivered another classic with Edge of the Abyss, the middle chapter in the series that depicts the Empire’s ascend and those who put their lives on the line to stop them. Edge of the Abyss picks up thirteen years after the events of the first book, and one year before season one of the Andor TV series.
Senator Bail Organa had shifted his strategy for combating Emperor Palpatine. No longer a permanent fixture on the Senate, Bail preferred to work behind the scenes as he was no longer focused on preserving the Jedi’s legacy and instead ran his own spy network which sometimes led him to have to cross paths with Saw Gerrera, although they had diverting views on how to deal with similar situations. For his part, Saw and his partisans were on the run after a busted attack on Inusagi led to the capture of Nankry, returning from The Mask of Fear. Mon Mothma still believed that change could be achieved without violence and that using her position as senator was the best way forward. Mom to soon-to-be teenager Leida, Senator Mothma faced constant battles at work and at home with her daughter and husband, Perrin Fertha.
Author Rebecca Roanhorse captures the voice of these classic characters and is able to write a story that feels natural for where they would be at this time period while simultaneously setting them up for when we meet them again in Andor. Edge of the Abyss excels in giving readers a captivating story where you feel connected to characters on both sides of the conflict. You feel Chemish struggles as she spends time with the people of Palmo, but I also wanted her to complete her mission. Kara and Nankry’s intertwined history provides for some difficult choices. It gives readers a spy and political story that can be enjoyed by fans who might not necessarily seek out those types of books. Chapters are just long enough to convey what the author and the story require while not overburdening the reader. Same as The Mask of Fear, fans of the political side of Star Wars will quickly fall under the spell of the book and devour it as quickly as possible. It’s a story that feels natural in the Star Wars galaxy while exhibiting parallels to past and current real world situations and human issues.
Same as Catalyst (by James Luceno) enriches Rogue One, I believe Edge of the Abyss will enrich the experience of watching Andor. We get to experience how the political movement on Ghorman changes as the Empire moves in and squashes signs of rebellion, and how they use propaganda to accomplish this. Rebecca Roanhorse delivered a powerful book with a statement on how oppressive governments use all the tools in their toolbox to keep the pressure on those they deem lesser than them. News feeds used to discredit, security forces planted inside protests, expulsion of foreign students, etc.
But there are those who will fight to the end, with all the tools they have, even if it means giving up their lives.
In early 2025 Star Wars released The Mask of Fear, the first in a trilogy of books under the Reign of the Empire collection. Now, a year and a half after Alexander Freed’s masterpiece, Rebecca Roanhorse delivered another classic with Edge of the Abyss, the middle chapter in the series that depicts the Empire’s ascend and those who put their lives on the line to stop them. Edge of the Abyss picks up thirteen years after the events of the first book, and one year before season one of the Andor TV series.
Senator Bail Organa had shifted his strategy for combating Emperor Palpatine. No longer a permanent fixture on the Senate, Bail preferred to work behind the scenes as he was no longer focused on preserving the Jedi’s legacy and instead ran his own spy network which sometimes led him to have to cross paths with Saw Gerrera, although they had diverting views on how to deal with similar situations. For his part, Saw and his partisans were on the run after a busted attack on Inusagi led to the capture of Nankry, returning from The Mask of Fear. Mon Mothma still believed that change could be achieved without violence and that using her position as senator was the best way forward. Mom to soon-to-be teenager Leida, Senator Mothma faced constant battles at work and at home with her daughter and husband, Perrin Fertha.
Author Rebecca Roanhorse captures the voice of these classic characters and is able to write a story that feels natural for where they would be at this time period while simultaneously setting them up for when we meet them again in Andor. Edge of the Abyss excels in giving readers a captivating story where you feel connected to characters on both sides of the conflict. You feel Chemish struggles as she spends time with the people of Palmo, but I also wanted her to complete her mission. Kara and Nankry’s intertwined history provides for some difficult choices. It gives readers a spy and political story that can be enjoyed by fans who might not necessarily seek out those types of books. Chapters are just long enough to convey what the author and the story require while not overburdening the reader. Same as The Mask of Fear, fans of the political side of Star Wars will quickly fall under the spell of the book and devour it as quickly as possible. It’s a story that feels natural in the Star Wars galaxy while exhibiting parallels to past and current real world situations and human issues.
Same as Catalyst (by James Luceno) enriches Rogue One, I believe Edge of the Abyss will enrich the experience of watching Andor. We get to experience how the political movement on Ghorman changes as the Empire moves in and squashes signs of rebellion, and how they use propaganda to accomplish this. Rebecca Roanhorse delivered a powerful book with a statement on how oppressive governments use all the tools in their toolbox to keep the pressure on those they deem lesser than them. News feeds used to discredit, security forces planted inside protests, expulsion of foreign students, etc.
But there are those who will fight to the end, with all the tools they have, even if it means giving up their lives.
October 9, 2026
9.2/10
I absolutely adore the politics of Star Wars. It was done very well in Andor, but unfortunately is not addressed nearly enough in the rest of the media. The Reign of the Empire series fixes this, with Edge of the Abyss even surpassing Mask of Fear in my opinion. Edge of the Abyss takes place pretty soon before the first season of Andor (I think) and a decade after The Mask of Fear, and it does a pretty good job at combining the original characters that were introduced in the first book with the other well-known main characters of that book along with some characters central to the story of Andor. What this book surprisingly does very well (aside from the politics and espionage and showcasing the manipulative tactics of the Empire) was the character writing. Almost every original main character had great arcs with very good emotional development, none of them feeling flat or uninteresting. The characters seen in other Star Wars media were also portrayed very well, aside from one exception: Mon Mothma. Mon is one of my favorite characters during the earlier years of the Empire, so this was a bit disappointing for me. She doesn’t really accomplish anything in this book, and her intellect felt surprisingly low for how intelligent she is supposed to be. But she isn’t as focused on in this book as she was in the first, and the rest of the cast more than make up for this hole. There are two main plot points in the novel, and while neither seem to have much weight and meaning in the grand scheme of the Rebellion, both are interesting at least and resolved very well, with impactful emotional moments at their climax. I also really enjoyed how all of the characters and their stories overlapped in some way, showcasing some pretty good story writing. All in all, this book is not perfect, but it gives me more of the aspects of Star Wars I love and crave more of in a well-written fashion.
I absolutely adore the politics of Star Wars. It was done very well in Andor, but unfortunately is not addressed nearly enough in the rest of the media. The Reign of the Empire series fixes this, with Edge of the Abyss even surpassing Mask of Fear in my opinion. Edge of the Abyss takes place pretty soon before the first season of Andor (I think) and a decade after The Mask of Fear, and it does a pretty good job at combining the original characters that were introduced in the first book with the other well-known main characters of that book along with some characters central to the story of Andor. What this book surprisingly does very well (aside from the politics and espionage and showcasing the manipulative tactics of the Empire) was the character writing. Almost every original main character had great arcs with very good emotional development, none of them feeling flat or uninteresting. The characters seen in other Star Wars media were also portrayed very well, aside from one exception: Mon Mothma. Mon is one of my favorite characters during the earlier years of the Empire, so this was a bit disappointing for me. She doesn’t really accomplish anything in this book, and her intellect felt surprisingly low for how intelligent she is supposed to be. But she isn’t as focused on in this book as she was in the first, and the rest of the cast more than make up for this hole. There are two main plot points in the novel, and while neither seem to have much weight and meaning in the grand scheme of the Rebellion, both are interesting at least and resolved very well, with impactful emotional moments at their climax. I also really enjoyed how all of the characters and their stories overlapped in some way, showcasing some pretty good story writing. All in all, this book is not perfect, but it gives me more of the aspects of Star Wars I love and crave more of in a well-written fashion.
September 12, 2026
It could have been great.
September 16, 2026
The characters in this book felt quite some distance from their previous-book and later-tv/movie counterparts, especially Mon Mothma, who behaves like a cruel teenager not yet in control of her emotions for a good 80% of the novel.
I found this book lacked the maturity I'd expect from one aimed at adults and there is a strange lack of consistency that makes me think maybe it was originally written to be set earlier in the timeline. Leida reads like a much younger child, there is no mention of Vel even though by this point she'd have been only a few months away from leading the mission on Aldhani, and the addition of Luthen and Kleya feels quite tacked on in a way that seems like they were never meant to be there in the first place.
All in all, I did not enjoy this at all and I wish I hadn't splurged on pre-orders for both of the UK special editions as well as a digital copy.
I found this book lacked the maturity I'd expect from one aimed at adults and there is a strange lack of consistency that makes me think maybe it was originally written to be set earlier in the timeline. Leida reads like a much younger child, there is no mention of Vel even though by this point she'd have been only a few months away from leading the mission on Aldhani, and the addition of Luthen and Kleya feels quite tacked on in a way that seems like they were never meant to be there in the first place.
All in all, I did not enjoy this at all and I wish I hadn't splurged on pre-orders for both of the UK special editions as well as a digital copy.
October 11, 2026
Last year’s opening book to the Reign of the Empire trilogy, “The Mask of Fear”, landed at just the right moment to be scarily relevant and was also written by one of my favorite Star Wars authors (Alexander Freed) who knocked it out of the park again. The book felt like a worthy precursor to “Andor” and set the bar high for the rest of the trilogy which would be written by other authors. I was worried about that last part because the other authors had a high bar to clear. I felt better after reading and enjoying Rebecca Roanhorse’s “Resistance Reborn”, which made me think I would have a better chance of enjoying Mask of Fear’s follow-up “Edge of the Abyss”. And while it does not clear or even reach Mask of Fear’s high bar, I do think Roanhorse did a good job.
The book takes place a year before Andor Season 1 and serves as a prequel to that, and a sequel to not only Mask of Fear but also “Rebel Rising” (the Jyn Erso prequel book). One of the main (and best) conflicts follows one of Saw Gerrera’s Partisans from Rebel Rising getting captured after a pivotal scene from that and how Saw, Bail Organa, and other Rebels have to prevent her from divulging critical information about the assorted Rebel groups. Another storyline follows Chemish, a supporting character from the last book (who honestly I forgot existed because they were often right next to the more interesting character of Haki) being sent to Ghorman to investigate student movements. We also get an expanded look at Anton Krieger, a character that doesn’t even appear in person on Andor yet whose dilemma provides a massive moral dilemma in the first season. Finally there’s Mon Mothma’s story about… her family issues from Andor, her daughter’s musical idol and a charity concert getting hijacked by the Empire?
So yeah, Roanhorse expands the number of storylines and POV characters in comparison to what Freed did in the last book, all the while being only 2/3s to 3/4s the length of that book. With the book spending time devoted to too many characters and their plots, including Mon’s lackluster storyline, in a shorter book, I did find Edge of the Abyss to suffer a bit in a quality downgrade. Before in the last book, all of the storylines worked in showing how the future Rebel leaders were struggling in the face of the new regime and regime supporters trying to come to terms with whether they should hitch their wagons to the regime. A good part of this book felt less than focused in comparison, and instead of a relevant and timely book felt more like a transitional book trying to connect multiple projects together instead of telling a story that is something more impactful.
That said, despite really not caring for Mon’s storyline and not quite getting the point of the pop star character beyond seeing how the Empire was trying to influence the Galaxy’s youth, the rest of the story holds up. Chemish and the Ghorman students, while not the returning character I’d have wanted (Haki was just a better written character) and perhaps a redundant conflict (given how well Andor Season 2 handled the lead-up to the Ghorman Massacre), I did think had a fairly compelling take on spies falling for their marks and losing faith in their fascist governments. Krieger’s storyline helps establish him as a loser out of his depth and makes his ultimate fate in Andor even sadder because of how it feels like an inevitable end for such a sad sack. And everything about the captured Partisan, be it Saw’s and Bail’s angle or the moral dilemma of returning but retired Partisan, Karama, was much more in line with what I was hoping for. It was good to see Saw’s further descent into his ideological extremes and Karama adds a compelling and tragic angle to her tale of getting dragged back into Saw’s sphere of influence and getting her innocent lawyer husband mixed up too. All this feels much more like something I’d wanted in Reign of the Empire and would have seen in Andor. Speaking of Andor, the book did noticeably pick up when Luthen and Kleya made appearances at the start of the second half which was thrilling, as was a brief appearance by ISB Major Partagaz. Roanhorse did a good job capturing these three’s characteristics from the show to the point I swore I was reading these characters’ lines in the actors’ voices.
I won’t lie and say that “Edge of the Abyss” isn’t a step down after the last book. But that said I think Rebecca Roanhorse does get a lot right with matching the tone of the previous part of the trilogy and I just think she needed another 100 pages or so to bring home a number of storylines. Overall I’d say this feels more like a weaker story arc of Andor which is still saying a lot. Hopefully the final book of the trilogy can bring everything home.
The book takes place a year before Andor Season 1 and serves as a prequel to that, and a sequel to not only Mask of Fear but also “Rebel Rising” (the Jyn Erso prequel book). One of the main (and best) conflicts follows one of Saw Gerrera’s Partisans from Rebel Rising getting captured after a pivotal scene from that and how Saw, Bail Organa, and other Rebels have to prevent her from divulging critical information about the assorted Rebel groups. Another storyline follows Chemish, a supporting character from the last book (who honestly I forgot existed because they were often right next to the more interesting character of Haki) being sent to Ghorman to investigate student movements. We also get an expanded look at Anton Krieger, a character that doesn’t even appear in person on Andor yet whose dilemma provides a massive moral dilemma in the first season. Finally there’s Mon Mothma’s story about… her family issues from Andor, her daughter’s musical idol and a charity concert getting hijacked by the Empire?
So yeah, Roanhorse expands the number of storylines and POV characters in comparison to what Freed did in the last book, all the while being only 2/3s to 3/4s the length of that book. With the book spending time devoted to too many characters and their plots, including Mon’s lackluster storyline, in a shorter book, I did find Edge of the Abyss to suffer a bit in a quality downgrade. Before in the last book, all of the storylines worked in showing how the future Rebel leaders were struggling in the face of the new regime and regime supporters trying to come to terms with whether they should hitch their wagons to the regime. A good part of this book felt less than focused in comparison, and instead of a relevant and timely book felt more like a transitional book trying to connect multiple projects together instead of telling a story that is something more impactful.
That said, despite really not caring for Mon’s storyline and not quite getting the point of the pop star character beyond seeing how the Empire was trying to influence the Galaxy’s youth, the rest of the story holds up. Chemish and the Ghorman students, while not the returning character I’d have wanted (Haki was just a better written character) and perhaps a redundant conflict (given how well Andor Season 2 handled the lead-up to the Ghorman Massacre), I did think had a fairly compelling take on spies falling for their marks and losing faith in their fascist governments. Krieger’s storyline helps establish him as a loser out of his depth and makes his ultimate fate in Andor even sadder because of how it feels like an inevitable end for such a sad sack. And everything about the captured Partisan, be it Saw’s and Bail’s angle or the moral dilemma of returning but retired Partisan, Karama, was much more in line with what I was hoping for. It was good to see Saw’s further descent into his ideological extremes and Karama adds a compelling and tragic angle to her tale of getting dragged back into Saw’s sphere of influence and getting her innocent lawyer husband mixed up too. All this feels much more like something I’d wanted in Reign of the Empire and would have seen in Andor. Speaking of Andor, the book did noticeably pick up when Luthen and Kleya made appearances at the start of the second half which was thrilling, as was a brief appearance by ISB Major Partagaz. Roanhorse did a good job capturing these three’s characteristics from the show to the point I swore I was reading these characters’ lines in the actors’ voices.
I won’t lie and say that “Edge of the Abyss” isn’t a step down after the last book. But that said I think Rebecca Roanhorse does get a lot right with matching the tone of the previous part of the trilogy and I just think she needed another 100 pages or so to bring home a number of storylines. Overall I’d say this feels more like a weaker story arc of Andor which is still saying a lot. Hopefully the final book of the trilogy can bring everything home.
September 24, 2026
The wait was (reasonably) long, but so worth it. This is an unmissable sequel to The Mask of Fear.
While I loved Alexander Freed's book, there I had to make an effort to reconcile the versions of Bail Organa and Mon Mothma he presented with the ones I knew. I still think his characterizations were interesting and suitable to the period he was working with, but I much preferred to see them here, already almost grown into the leaders of the rebellion.
I appreciated the author's complex portrayal of Mon Mothma as a career woman struggling to be a caring mother. It was established in the previous book that Mon had been on the fence about having a child and had decided the time was past, considering her cooling relationship with her husband, and that Leida was an oops baby. Here, we see that, while Mon loves her daughter, she doesn't understand Leida, and she hasn't grown into her role as a mother—not helping matters is the fact that Perrin is not a good partner to coparent with, and yet he does hit on some harsh truths when he points out that Mon tends to make everything about her work. We see her trying and failing, we see what happens when motherhood isn't fully chosen, and when the weight of it all falls squarely on the woman, and I would not have trusted this portrayal to a man.
In contrast, I loved the glimpses to the Organas that we got (although not enough! but can they ever be?). Bail and Breha are similarly invested in their duties, but they fully chose Leia and they make it their job to understand her, to listen to her, to care about her interests, which is why their jobs don't ever feel like a threat to Leia. I just love them so much.
One of my complaints of The Mask of Fear was that we didn't get much from Saw's perspective. That was definitely present here, and I so appreciated it. The author did a great job of portraying Saw as a complex person rather than a caricature, and showing us how he gets to become the person we see in Andor and Rogue One.
Overall I think Roanhorse did a great job of bridging the gap with The Mask of Fear and connecting the threads that will lead to the events of Andor. Personally I could have used a lot less of Chemish and a lot more of Bail Organa, but I know I'm biased; it was a compelling story, faster paced than Freed's, with a few nice twists and cameos, and I kind of wish it'd been longer!
While I loved Alexander Freed's book, there I had to make an effort to reconcile the versions of Bail Organa and Mon Mothma he presented with the ones I knew. I still think his characterizations were interesting and suitable to the period he was working with, but I much preferred to see them here, already almost grown into the leaders of the rebellion.
I appreciated the author's complex portrayal of Mon Mothma as a career woman struggling to be a caring mother. It was established in the previous book that Mon had been on the fence about having a child and had decided the time was past, considering her cooling relationship with her husband, and that Leida was an oops baby. Here, we see that, while Mon loves her daughter, she doesn't understand Leida, and she hasn't grown into her role as a mother—not helping matters is the fact that Perrin is not a good partner to coparent with, and yet he does hit on some harsh truths when he points out that Mon tends to make everything about her work. We see her trying and failing, we see what happens when motherhood isn't fully chosen, and when the weight of it all falls squarely on the woman, and I would not have trusted this portrayal to a man.
In contrast, I loved the glimpses to the Organas that we got (although not enough! but can they ever be?). Bail and Breha are similarly invested in their duties, but they fully chose Leia and they make it their job to understand her, to listen to her, to care about her interests, which is why their jobs don't ever feel like a threat to Leia. I just love them so much.
One of my complaints of The Mask of Fear was that we didn't get much from Saw's perspective. That was definitely present here, and I so appreciated it. The author did a great job of portraying Saw as a complex person rather than a caricature, and showing us how he gets to become the person we see in Andor and Rogue One.
Overall I think Roanhorse did a great job of bridging the gap with The Mask of Fear and connecting the threads that will lead to the events of Andor. Personally I could have used a lot less of Chemish and a lot more of Bail Organa, but I know I'm biased; it was a compelling story, faster paced than Freed's, with a few nice twists and cameos, and I kind of wish it'd been longer!
September 22, 2026
"Over a decade into the Empire’s reign, life under Imperial rule has become routine. The days of the Republic have long passed into memory—if they are remembered at all.
Within the Senate, Mon Mothma and Bail Organa face dwindling influence, for there is no difference between the will of the Emperor and the direction of his Empire. Bail increasingly shifts his focus to support clandestine resistance efforts, knowing a successful fight against the Empire will come from beyond the halls of power. Meanwhile, Mon Mothma sees one chance to take a stand when she makes a horrifying discovery about the lengths the regime will go to weaponize truth and loyalty. The Empire’s newest target: the next generation raised under the Emperor’s ever deepening shadow, including Mon and Bail’s daughters.
Across the galaxy, disparate rebel factions are rendered outcasts, branded criminals, and pitted against each other. On Ghorman, an idealistic student group seeks to make meaningful change, unaware of the ISB agent who seeks to sabotage them from the inside. Leaders like Saw Gerrera and Anto Kreegyr squabble and bargain to survive one more day against the crush of Imperial might. Trust is rare and betrayal quick. A distracted, disorganized resistance is one that is easy to snuff out. There are few heroes . . . and no alliances.
When one of Gerrera’s partisans is captured by the Empire, time is running out for senators, outcasts, spies, and all those that desire a better tomorrow. What the prisoner knows could help the Empire eradicate any whisper of resistance, end any rebellion before it can truly begin—and ensure that the Empire’s truth is all the galaxy will ever know."
Within the Senate, Mon Mothma and Bail Organa face dwindling influence, for there is no difference between the will of the Emperor and the direction of his Empire. Bail increasingly shifts his focus to support clandestine resistance efforts, knowing a successful fight against the Empire will come from beyond the halls of power. Meanwhile, Mon Mothma sees one chance to take a stand when she makes a horrifying discovery about the lengths the regime will go to weaponize truth and loyalty. The Empire’s newest target: the next generation raised under the Emperor’s ever deepening shadow, including Mon and Bail’s daughters.
Across the galaxy, disparate rebel factions are rendered outcasts, branded criminals, and pitted against each other. On Ghorman, an idealistic student group seeks to make meaningful change, unaware of the ISB agent who seeks to sabotage them from the inside. Leaders like Saw Gerrera and Anto Kreegyr squabble and bargain to survive one more day against the crush of Imperial might. Trust is rare and betrayal quick. A distracted, disorganized resistance is one that is easy to snuff out. There are few heroes . . . and no alliances.
When one of Gerrera’s partisans is captured by the Empire, time is running out for senators, outcasts, spies, and all those that desire a better tomorrow. What the prisoner knows could help the Empire eradicate any whisper of resistance, end any rebellion before it can truly begin—and ensure that the Empire’s truth is all the galaxy will ever know."
September 30, 2026
A good and very personable companion piece to the Andor series. I appreciated the exploration of the Empire and how they are attempting to influence the Imperial youth through song and culture. These deeper dives into the inner workings of the Imperial society are always very much appreciated. It was nice to see Ghorman starting to appear on the Empire's radar, setting up that arc in Andor season 2. I also loved seeing a more 'court room' drama (even though it was more the pre-court lawyer work) plotline as again, that is something that obviously would happen in the world of Star Wars, but you don't see until you get a more grounded political drama like Edge of the Abyss.
The gripes I have with this story are largely that the ending landed a bit flat. The final set piece could have been expanded out more, even if the endings for each character remained the same. Some of the characters pictured on the cover weren't in the story all that much, and even our main trio (Saw, Bail, and Mothma) took a bit of a back seat. That's not inherently bad but it did feel like we lacked a bit from them at times. In saying that, I did very much enjoy the original characters that took more centre stage here.
The gripes I have with this story are largely that the ending landed a bit flat. The final set piece could have been expanded out more, even if the endings for each character remained the same. Some of the characters pictured on the cover weren't in the story all that much, and even our main trio (Saw, Bail, and Mothma) took a bit of a back seat. That's not inherently bad but it did feel like we lacked a bit from them at times. In saying that, I did very much enjoy the original characters that took more centre stage here.
September 17, 2026
Revolution is not for the sane- Saw Gerrera
I absolutely ate this book up in 2 days. Edge of the Abyss book 2 in the Reign of the empire trilogy is a action and quickly paced book with a huge main focus on Saw Gerrera this time around but still giving us plenty of time with Mon & Bail.
We really delve into the complexity , messy and violence of Saw's character even more with references to his long deceased sister and the pain he is still carries to her passing, Their is no redemption arc for Saw but more giving the reading more understanding of his POV and why he continues to fight.
This series continues to be a fantastic companion piece to both seasons of Andor and rogue one , With a surprise character appearance or two and a large chunk of this book taking place on Ghorman and so we see the beginnings of the ISB work on the planet and unsettling the Gore citizens.
Rebecca Roanhorse did a fantastic job capturing these classic characters while also writing an important story in the days of rebellion that feels very relatable to the real world , Plus the representation in the book with a pov coming from a non binary character is just as important to be giving readers.
A moment click in this book for me is that we really do see the difference in Mon and bail's different marriages and there for how both leia and Leida are growing into young women. Bail and Breha share everything in their marriage and are able to trust one another and take every challenge on as Husband and wife on together but omg Perrin is the most frustrating man to read about. The way he turns everything into a competition with Mon raising Leida and then behaves as he is a victim.
Truly I loved my time with this book but I do wish we had gotten a longer book but cannot wait for book 3 of the trilogy hopefully next year:)
4.5 stars out of 5
I absolutely ate this book up in 2 days. Edge of the Abyss book 2 in the Reign of the empire trilogy is a action and quickly paced book with a huge main focus on Saw Gerrera this time around but still giving us plenty of time with Mon & Bail.
We really delve into the complexity , messy and violence of Saw's character even more with references to his long deceased sister and the pain he is still carries to her passing, Their is no redemption arc for Saw but more giving the reading more understanding of his POV and why he continues to fight.
This series continues to be a fantastic companion piece to both seasons of Andor and rogue one , With a surprise character appearance or two and a large chunk of this book taking place on Ghorman and so we see the beginnings of the ISB work on the planet and unsettling the Gore citizens.
Rebecca Roanhorse did a fantastic job capturing these classic characters while also writing an important story in the days of rebellion that feels very relatable to the real world , Plus the representation in the book with a pov coming from a non binary character is just as important to be giving readers.
A moment click in this book for me is that we really do see the difference in Mon and bail's different marriages and there for how both leia and Leida are growing into young women. Bail and Breha share everything in their marriage and are able to trust one another and take every challenge on as Husband and wife on together but omg Perrin is the most frustrating man to read about. The way he turns everything into a competition with Mon raising Leida and then behaves as he is a victim.
Truly I loved my time with this book but I do wish we had gotten a longer book but cannot wait for book 3 of the trilogy hopefully next year:)
4.5 stars out of 5
October 29, 2026
I actually read this earlier, but neglected to list it...so here's the delayed reaction: excellent, if not quite as impressive as the first volume. I particularly enjoyed the sections covering Bail Organa, who has proved to be one of my favourite characters from the prequel era...but I also give the author credit for making more out of Saw and his complicated feelings for his fellow rebels. He is clearly more than a simple zealot, and this book runs with that fact.
October 18, 2026
Reign of the Empire is shaping up to be a top trilogy in the Star Wars library of novels. I was admittedly skeptical at not committing to Alex Freed penning the whole trilogy, but Roanhorse puts out some seriously good content here.
A shorter but much more interconnected story than its predecessor, Edge of the Abyss excellently melds the political intrigue and atmosphere of Andor with some extremely compelling character work. Getting actual insight on into one of the thousand cuts that eventually culminated in the Ghorman massacre was riveting stuff. Really everything involving Ghorman, the Ghor, and Chemish were the highlights here, but there wasn’t a single plot line I disliked.
An excellent and quality addition to the Star Wars canon.
A shorter but much more interconnected story than its predecessor, Edge of the Abyss excellently melds the political intrigue and atmosphere of Andor with some extremely compelling character work. Getting actual insight on into one of the thousand cuts that eventually culminated in the Ghorman massacre was riveting stuff. Really everything involving Ghorman, the Ghor, and Chemish were the highlights here, but there wasn’t a single plot line I disliked.
An excellent and quality addition to the Star Wars canon.
September 25, 2026
Space Taylor Swift destabilizes the Galactic Empire
October 13, 2026
I wish there wasn’t as much of a timeskip between the last book and this one, we end months out from the start of Andor which limits what development Luthen, Saw, and Mon can even get.
Anto Kreegyr’s POV is by far the most interesting given it provides more development to his in passing mentions in Andor - but unfortunately it is also the shortest (or at least feels like the shortest)
The story has an interesting premise around youth propaganda that I think was executed pretty well.
Anto Kreegyr’s POV is by far the most interesting given it provides more development to his in passing mentions in Andor - but unfortunately it is also the shortest (or at least feels like the shortest)
The story has an interesting premise around youth propaganda that I think was executed pretty well.
September 18, 2026
Even more so than the first book in this loose Star Wars trilogy, this middle volume reads like a love letter to Andor, delivering more of that show's deep dive into the specific mechanisms of imperial control and the burgeoning resistance network. It also includes a number of characters and locations from the Disney+ series: appearances from Luthen, Kleya, and Partagaz, major plots involving Mon and her family, Bail, and Saw, another storyline set on Ghorman, and even an important arc for the hapless Anto Kreegyr (who was mentioned a lot on that program, but only shown once as a static hologram).
It's set in 6 BBY, one year before the start of Andor and thirteen years after the previous novel, The Mask of Fear. But whereas that title tracked the swift descent into fascism following the events of Revenge of the Sith, this one finds the authoritarian empire in full swing and its various opponents struggling to act on what they recognize as oppression without necessarily declaring themselves openly against it. The immediate crisis kicks off when one of Saw's lieutenants gets captured amidst his latest terrorist strike, and he knows it's just a matter of time until the emperor's torturers extract a confession, which would implicate Bail and certain other allies as well. Meanwhile a popular singer is being forced to include propaganda in her music to shape loyalty to the government among the galaxy's youth (which Mon opposes as both a woman of principle and a mother), and an agent of the ISB is infiltrating a student protest movement but growing conflicted over their superiors' new push towards coercive entrapment instead of responding to existing threats.
That's a sprawling constellation of concerns, but they mostly connect nicely with one another as key developments unfold. A few figures do return from the last book, but it's been so long for them that the work generally stands on its own, although it's obviously in conversation with the larger canon and the moments looming right ahead for everyone. Kreegyr's carelessness sets him on the path that will ultimately doom him, while Kleya gets an ironic early lesson from Luthen on not leaving captives behind. I wouldn't say that this is quite on the level of Andor itself, but it's one of the rare pieces of the franchise that feels like it's taking up the gauntlet thrown by Tony Gilroy to tell serious adult stories about the cost and means of organized rebellion. I give it four-and-a-half stars, rounded up.
[Content warning for ableism, gun violence, and gore.]
Like this review? Find more of my writing on:
--https://www.goodreads.com/lesserjoke
--https://letterboxd.com/lesserjoke
--https://lesserjoke.home.blog
Or check out these ways to support me, if you'd like:
--https://ko-fi.com/lesserjoke
--https://patreon.com/lesserjoke
It's set in 6 BBY, one year before the start of Andor and thirteen years after the previous novel, The Mask of Fear. But whereas that title tracked the swift descent into fascism following the events of Revenge of the Sith, this one finds the authoritarian empire in full swing and its various opponents struggling to act on what they recognize as oppression without necessarily declaring themselves openly against it. The immediate crisis kicks off when one of Saw's lieutenants gets captured amidst his latest terrorist strike, and he knows it's just a matter of time until the emperor's torturers extract a confession, which would implicate Bail and certain other allies as well. Meanwhile a popular singer is being forced to include propaganda in her music to shape loyalty to the government among the galaxy's youth (which Mon opposes as both a woman of principle and a mother), and an agent of the ISB is infiltrating a student protest movement but growing conflicted over their superiors' new push towards coercive entrapment instead of responding to existing threats.
That's a sprawling constellation of concerns, but they mostly connect nicely with one another as key developments unfold. A few figures do return from the last book, but it's been so long for them that the work generally stands on its own, although it's obviously in conversation with the larger canon and the moments looming right ahead for everyone. Kreegyr's carelessness sets him on the path that will ultimately doom him, while Kleya gets an ironic early lesson from Luthen on not leaving captives behind. I wouldn't say that this is quite on the level of Andor itself, but it's one of the rare pieces of the franchise that feels like it's taking up the gauntlet thrown by Tony Gilroy to tell serious adult stories about the cost and means of organized rebellion. I give it four-and-a-half stars, rounded up.
[Content warning for ableism, gun violence, and gore.]
Like this review? Find more of my writing on:
--https://www.goodreads.com/lesserjoke
--https://letterboxd.com/lesserjoke
--https://lesserjoke.home.blog
Or check out these ways to support me, if you'd like:
--https://ko-fi.com/lesserjoke
--https://patreon.com/lesserjoke
October 2, 2026
4.5 stars
This book was a LOT better than the first one in this series. The first one was fine but sometimes a bit of a slog; it was a lot longer, and I don’t enjoy Alexander Freed’s writing style as much. This shorter book plus Rebecca Roanhorse’s style meant it felt a lot more active and tense than the first one, while not sacrificing character development.
You could easily read this as a standalone without the first book, and if you like Andor, I would recommend it. It has a lot of the same feel as Andor (without him being present yet)—spy thriller, a bit of political thriller (but not bogged down in that), exploration of the motives of characters like Mon, Bail, Saw, Anto Kreegyr, and several minor characters. It does a better job than other things I’ve seem or read at showing complexity in Saw’s character, and I love how it balances both home life and political life for Mon and Bail (sometimes with sweet effect, sometimes with sad poignant effect).
The minor characters include a group of students who are exploring whether to add violence to their protests, an ISB agent who’s undercover with them, and a galactic pop star who’s embroiled with more than just music. It was interesting to see which ways their stories went. This book got me successfully interested in the minor characters much more than the first book did.
January LaVoy did a fantastic job as narrator, and I highly recommend the audiobook.
This book was a LOT better than the first one in this series. The first one was fine but sometimes a bit of a slog; it was a lot longer, and I don’t enjoy Alexander Freed’s writing style as much. This shorter book plus Rebecca Roanhorse’s style meant it felt a lot more active and tense than the first one, while not sacrificing character development.
You could easily read this as a standalone without the first book, and if you like Andor, I would recommend it. It has a lot of the same feel as Andor (without him being present yet)—spy thriller, a bit of political thriller (but not bogged down in that), exploration of the motives of characters like Mon, Bail, Saw, Anto Kreegyr, and several minor characters. It does a better job than other things I’ve seem or read at showing complexity in Saw’s character, and I love how it balances both home life and political life for Mon and Bail (sometimes with sweet effect, sometimes with sad poignant effect).
The minor characters include a group of students who are exploring whether to add violence to their protests, an ISB agent who’s undercover with them, and a galactic pop star who’s embroiled with more than just music. It was interesting to see which ways their stories went. This book got me successfully interested in the minor characters much more than the first book did.
January LaVoy did a fantastic job as narrator, and I highly recommend the audiobook.
September 30, 2026
Much better then the first. The interconnecting stories were handled well. Yuelin and Karma's was probably the best.
September 28, 2026
I liked this one way more than the first book. I think the writing was better and the characters were more interesting. It also had a good mix of politics, intrigue, and action. Plus, we're starting to see more of the Andor characters coming into play.
September 22, 2026
As a huge Andor fan I couldn’t help but love this book. I preferred it to Mask of Fear since it is closer in the timeline to the show.
I did feel the ending was a bit rushed, but otherwise I enjoyed the slow burn.
I would have loved a few chapters from Kleya’s POV but oh well. It was great to even see her in the book.
Mon Mothma’s storyline was my favorite, but I was surprised how invested I got in the characters that originated in this series such as Chemish and Karama.
Genuinely my only complaint is that it was too short.
I did feel the ending was a bit rushed, but otherwise I enjoyed the slow burn.
I would have loved a few chapters from Kleya’s POV but oh well. It was great to even see her in the book.
Mon Mothma’s storyline was my favorite, but I was surprised how invested I got in the characters that originated in this series such as Chemish and Karama.
Genuinely my only complaint is that it was too short.
September 30, 2026
I don't know if Rebecca Roanhorse fully captured Saw's voice. In Andor he comes off as a crazed and paranoid vet whose eyes always dart around like an animal who's been backed into a corner, but here he seems way more focused and sane. I thought it worked just fine because I assumed this was a younger Saw who's hot off the clone wars but this book apparently takes place one year before Andor's first season so his lacking dialogue really stand outs. There were however some great moments that really tapped into his revolutionary mindset, mainly in his scenes with Kara. They're not unlike Saw's scenes with Wilmon in Andor.
Chemish's storyline read like an early draft of what was essentially just Syril's story in Andor season 2: An ISB agent undercover on Ghorman trying to find evidence of agitators only to become sympathetic to a growing insurgency just when it's too late to save them. The difference in this book's case is that this was primarily told as a forbidden love story that I unfortunately was never really sold on. Chemish's inner conflict was too similar to Syril's and that could've been fine if Roanhorse made their romance interesting but the love interest's writing was also just too vanilla. Maybe if Fennro came off as more radical and a passionate bleeding heart and not just as a sweet idyllic boy than this would be a better storyline. It would've also helped if his Ghorman background was fleshed out. The Andor show really went out of its way to make Ghorman feel like a fleshed out world of artisans and scholars but that doesn't feel present at all in Fennro's character or this book's depiction of daily Ghorman life.
I would've killed for more of the Leida and Leia dynamic. Mon and Bail's teenage daughters, who have polar opposite stances on arts and politics, butting heads while their parents plot their rebellious activities could've been slotted so easily into this anthology-like format. We got a little bit of Leida and Leia's relationship and it was great. Seeing them through Mon's eyes was a great development for her too. The shame she has for her daughter's shallowness as well as feeling shame towards her own desire for Leida to be more like Leia is a great insight into her character. Also I still hate how similar Leia and Leida's names are. Makes it look like Mon stole it from Bail and Breha but just added a letter.
Mon's characterization overall was a great expansion on what was established in Andor. Her being torn between being a good mother and a good person, and wondering if those two things are mutually exclusive in a world where being an empire bootlicker is not only the norm but the cool new thing among youths, is a masterful demonstration of what makes the character so compelling.
Quanaliko should've gotten more play too. Her character was maybe the most intriguing from a conceptual standpoint. A pop star who uses her fame as a cover for her arms dealing who then has to maintain her cover by dating a famous Imperial and allowing him to write her lyrics, is a great foundation. It really adds to that "hiding in plain sight" aspect that made the spycraft of Andor so fun. But the plot sadly kinda drops her after the halfway point and by the end she's unceremoniously killed and I get that that's part of the story's point, but Quanaliko's story felt unfinished because it felt like she was introduced like twenty minutes ago.
But I do really like what she represents in the larger story of the growing Rebellion. Her death is what led to the Empire cracking down on protests. Because of her fame and status as a pro-Imperial who was killed by anti-Imperial students, the galaxy had no issue with the slow suppression of free speech.
Yulien and Nankry's storyline started off so well and I was really hoping we'd get to see actual courtroom drama in a Star Wars setting or really see the legal proceedings of Nankry's trial but that plot also just ended abruptly. Roanhorse seemed to put all the content of this storyline into the suspenseful question of whether Kara will choose to kill Nankry or not but I think that was the least interesting route to go. Fleshing out Nankry's trial would've really scratched that "political intrigue" itch that the book's missing.
Despite how little he was in it, Luthen was handled really well. Roanhorse seems to really be aware of how cool he is so anytime he enters the story it's done in the best way possible. The buildup to his surprise introduction was masterful, and the twist that he was behind Nankry's assassination was a great way to end the book. This really gives me the hope that Roanhorse can capture Luthen and Kleya's voice in their own novel because it feels like there's a lot that can still be told about them and how they built the Axis network.
I have a lot of criticisms but I still really enjoyed this. Despite my issues with the underdeveloped characters and how crammed the overall package feels with all these different plot threads and perspectives, each storyline still had something really great in it. All my criticisms essentially boil down to me wishing that this was way longer.
Chemish's storyline read like an early draft of what was essentially just Syril's story in Andor season 2: An ISB agent undercover on Ghorman trying to find evidence of agitators only to become sympathetic to a growing insurgency just when it's too late to save them. The difference in this book's case is that this was primarily told as a forbidden love story that I unfortunately was never really sold on. Chemish's inner conflict was too similar to Syril's and that could've been fine if Roanhorse made their romance interesting but the love interest's writing was also just too vanilla. Maybe if Fennro came off as more radical and a passionate bleeding heart and not just as a sweet idyllic boy than this would be a better storyline. It would've also helped if his Ghorman background was fleshed out. The Andor show really went out of its way to make Ghorman feel like a fleshed out world of artisans and scholars but that doesn't feel present at all in Fennro's character or this book's depiction of daily Ghorman life.
I would've killed for more of the Leida and Leia dynamic. Mon and Bail's teenage daughters, who have polar opposite stances on arts and politics, butting heads while their parents plot their rebellious activities could've been slotted so easily into this anthology-like format. We got a little bit of Leida and Leia's relationship and it was great. Seeing them through Mon's eyes was a great development for her too. The shame she has for her daughter's shallowness as well as feeling shame towards her own desire for Leida to be more like Leia is a great insight into her character. Also I still hate how similar Leia and Leida's names are. Makes it look like Mon stole it from Bail and Breha but just added a letter.
Mon's characterization overall was a great expansion on what was established in Andor. Her being torn between being a good mother and a good person, and wondering if those two things are mutually exclusive in a world where being an empire bootlicker is not only the norm but the cool new thing among youths, is a masterful demonstration of what makes the character so compelling.
Quanaliko should've gotten more play too. Her character was maybe the most intriguing from a conceptual standpoint. A pop star who uses her fame as a cover for her arms dealing who then has to maintain her cover by dating a famous Imperial and allowing him to write her lyrics, is a great foundation. It really adds to that "hiding in plain sight" aspect that made the spycraft of Andor so fun. But the plot sadly kinda drops her after the halfway point and by the end she's unceremoniously killed and I get that that's part of the story's point, but Quanaliko's story felt unfinished because it felt like she was introduced like twenty minutes ago.
But I do really like what she represents in the larger story of the growing Rebellion. Her death is what led to the Empire cracking down on protests. Because of her fame and status as a pro-Imperial who was killed by anti-Imperial students, the galaxy had no issue with the slow suppression of free speech.
Yulien and Nankry's storyline started off so well and I was really hoping we'd get to see actual courtroom drama in a Star Wars setting or really see the legal proceedings of Nankry's trial but that plot also just ended abruptly. Roanhorse seemed to put all the content of this storyline into the suspenseful question of whether Kara will choose to kill Nankry or not but I think that was the least interesting route to go. Fleshing out Nankry's trial would've really scratched that "political intrigue" itch that the book's missing.
Despite how little he was in it, Luthen was handled really well. Roanhorse seems to really be aware of how cool he is so anytime he enters the story it's done in the best way possible. The buildup to his surprise introduction was masterful, and the twist that he was behind Nankry's assassination was a great way to end the book. This really gives me the hope that Roanhorse can capture Luthen and Kleya's voice in their own novel because it feels like there's a lot that can still be told about them and how they built the Axis network.
I have a lot of criticisms but I still really enjoyed this. Despite my issues with the underdeveloped characters and how crammed the overall package feels with all these different plot threads and perspectives, each storyline still had something really great in it. All my criticisms essentially boil down to me wishing that this was way longer.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 22, 2026
"Over a decade into the Empire’s reign, life under Imperial rule has become routine. The days of the Republic have long passed into memory—if they are remembered at all.
Within the Senate, Mon Mothma and Bail Organa face dwindling influence, for there is no difference between the will of the Emperor and the direction of his Empire. Bail increasingly shifts his focus to support clandestine resistance efforts, knowing a successful fight against the Empire will come from beyond the halls of power. Meanwhile, Mon Mothma sees one chance to take a stand when she makes a horrifying discovery about the lengths the regime will go to weaponize truth and loyalty. The Empire’s newest target: the next generation raised under the Emperor’s ever deepening shadow, including Mon and Bail’s daughters.
Across the galaxy, disparate rebel factions are rendered outcasts, branded criminals, and pitted against each other. On Ghorman, an idealistic student group seeks to make meaningful change, unaware of the ISB agent who seeks to sabotage them from the inside. Leaders like Saw Gerrera and Anto Kreegyr squabble and bargain to survive one more day against the crush of Imperial might. Trust is rare and betrayal quick. A distracted, disorganized resistance is one that is easy to snuff out. There are few heroes . . . and no alliances.
When one of Gerrera’s partisans is captured by the Empire, time is running out for senators, outcasts, spies, and all those that desire a better tomorrow. What the prisoner knows could help the Empire eradicate any whisper of resistance, end any rebellion before it can truly begin—and ensure that the Empire’s truth is all the galaxy will ever know."
Within the Senate, Mon Mothma and Bail Organa face dwindling influence, for there is no difference between the will of the Emperor and the direction of his Empire. Bail increasingly shifts his focus to support clandestine resistance efforts, knowing a successful fight against the Empire will come from beyond the halls of power. Meanwhile, Mon Mothma sees one chance to take a stand when she makes a horrifying discovery about the lengths the regime will go to weaponize truth and loyalty. The Empire’s newest target: the next generation raised under the Emperor’s ever deepening shadow, including Mon and Bail’s daughters.
Across the galaxy, disparate rebel factions are rendered outcasts, branded criminals, and pitted against each other. On Ghorman, an idealistic student group seeks to make meaningful change, unaware of the ISB agent who seeks to sabotage them from the inside. Leaders like Saw Gerrera and Anto Kreegyr squabble and bargain to survive one more day against the crush of Imperial might. Trust is rare and betrayal quick. A distracted, disorganized resistance is one that is easy to snuff out. There are few heroes . . . and no alliances.
When one of Gerrera’s partisans is captured by the Empire, time is running out for senators, outcasts, spies, and all those that desire a better tomorrow. What the prisoner knows could help the Empire eradicate any whisper of resistance, end any rebellion before it can truly begin—and ensure that the Empire’s truth is all the galaxy will ever know."
September 22, 2026
"Over a decade into the Empire’s reign, life under Imperial rule has become routine. The days of the Republic have long passed into memory—if they are remembered at all.
Within the Senate, Mon Mothma and Bail Organa face dwindling influence, for there is no difference between the will of the Emperor and the direction of his Empire. Bail increasingly shifts his focus to support clandestine resistance efforts, knowing a successful fight against the Empire will come from beyond the halls of power. Meanwhile, Mon Mothma sees one chance to take a stand when she makes a horrifying discovery about the lengths the regime will go to weaponize truth and loyalty. The Empire’s newest target: the next generation raised under the Emperor’s ever deepening shadow, including Mon and Bail’s daughters.
Across the galaxy, disparate rebel factions are rendered outcasts, branded criminals, and pitted against each other. On Ghorman, an idealistic student group seeks to make meaningful change, unaware of the ISB agent who seeks to sabotage them from the inside. Leaders like Saw Gerrera and Anto Kreegyr squabble and bargain to survive one more day against the crush of Imperial might. Trust is rare and betrayal quick. A distracted, disorganized resistance is one that is easy to snuff out. There are few heroes . . . and no alliances.
When one of Gerrera’s partisans is captured by the Empire, time is running out for senators, outcasts, spies, and all those that desire a better tomorrow. What the prisoner knows could help the Empire eradicate any whisper of resistance, end any rebellion before it can truly begin—and ensure that the Empire’s truth is all the galaxy will ever know."
Within the Senate, Mon Mothma and Bail Organa face dwindling influence, for there is no difference between the will of the Emperor and the direction of his Empire. Bail increasingly shifts his focus to support clandestine resistance efforts, knowing a successful fight against the Empire will come from beyond the halls of power. Meanwhile, Mon Mothma sees one chance to take a stand when she makes a horrifying discovery about the lengths the regime will go to weaponize truth and loyalty. The Empire’s newest target: the next generation raised under the Emperor’s ever deepening shadow, including Mon and Bail’s daughters.
Across the galaxy, disparate rebel factions are rendered outcasts, branded criminals, and pitted against each other. On Ghorman, an idealistic student group seeks to make meaningful change, unaware of the ISB agent who seeks to sabotage them from the inside. Leaders like Saw Gerrera and Anto Kreegyr squabble and bargain to survive one more day against the crush of Imperial might. Trust is rare and betrayal quick. A distracted, disorganized resistance is one that is easy to snuff out. There are few heroes . . . and no alliances.
When one of Gerrera’s partisans is captured by the Empire, time is running out for senators, outcasts, spies, and all those that desire a better tomorrow. What the prisoner knows could help the Empire eradicate any whisper of resistance, end any rebellion before it can truly begin—and ensure that the Empire’s truth is all the galaxy will ever know."
September 19, 2026
I hate to say it but this one just didnt do it for me. Which is really sad considering Roanhorse's previous Star Wars novel i have read upwards of 5 times and always love.
While the drama between Mon and her family was fun, and the early rebel factions were interesting, the overall storyline for this one just didnt really engage me.
I dont mind a political drama in Star Wars if done well, but with the reread of book 1 and reading this one, it honestly just kept putting me to sleep and I just couldn't really enjoy it.
Its going for the Andor vibe, with the early actions of the leaders of the Rebels. And while some of it is very interesting. The overall plot and nature of this trilogy so far just isn't doing much for me.
While the drama between Mon and her family was fun, and the early rebel factions were interesting, the overall storyline for this one just didnt really engage me.
I dont mind a political drama in Star Wars if done well, but with the reread of book 1 and reading this one, it honestly just kept putting me to sleep and I just couldn't really enjoy it.
Its going for the Andor vibe, with the early actions of the leaders of the Rebels. And while some of it is very interesting. The overall plot and nature of this trilogy so far just isn't doing much for me.
September 30, 2026
I was not impressed with this book. I feel like nothing really happened with the plot to advance the story. The pop star character was an obvious nod to Taylor Swift that seemed irrelevant.
I thought that having two of the good guys having the last names of “honor” and “integrity” seemed a bit on the nose and out of place.
I get that one of the main characters, Chemish, is non-binary but it made for very confusing reading with the weird grammar of the pronouns, that got annoying, and everyone who met Chemish seemed to automatically know they didn’t like being referred to as he or she. Seemed unrealistic and a bit forced.
I thought that having two of the good guys having the last names of “honor” and “integrity” seemed a bit on the nose and out of place.
I get that one of the main characters, Chemish, is non-binary but it made for very confusing reading with the weird grammar of the pronouns, that got annoying, and everyone who met Chemish seemed to automatically know they didn’t like being referred to as he or she. Seemed unrealistic and a bit forced.
October 23, 2026
I need the next book ASAP. Rebecca did her thing!!
September 17, 2026
So much has happened to the big dawg Anto Kreegyr here damn! Need the third book immediately!!!
October 24, 2026
Great sequel book, the ending was showing similarities to the end of season two of Andor. The goat came in, showed up in the last 20 minutes and went completely beast mode!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews