What do you think?
Rate this book
Blacktail
A wolf sets out on an epic journey of revenge in this one-of-a-kind dark fantasy—the long-awaited second novel from the author of The Library at Mount Char.
The wolf Blacktail is faithful to his Forest God, but in these times, faith is not enough. His world is besieged by men. Soon his territory will be overrun, and then there will be nowhere left to go. When his mate, a house dog, is killed, Blacktail rebels. He invades the house of her owners, seeking vengeance.
Blacktail’s fury catches the notice of an ancient and terrible feline witch, who makes an offer. What if Blacktail could end the human race responsible for the death of his family and for the destruction of the natural world, altogether? To do so, Blacktail must find and wake the Forest God. Only He might stand against the plague of men. Blacktail knows that his north woods are dwindling to nothing. He sees no other choice.
As Blacktail journeys farther from his wild home and deeper into the world of man, he encounters strangers—animal, mortal, and otherworldly—who, for their own reasons, want to help Blacktail rid the world of humans. Along the way, it becomes clear that he is more than just a wolf. The Forest God is sleeping, yes. But what will be the price of waking him?
The wolf Blacktail is faithful to his Forest God, but in these times, faith is not enough. His world is besieged by men. Soon his territory will be overrun, and then there will be nowhere left to go. When his mate, a house dog, is killed, Blacktail rebels. He invades the house of her owners, seeking vengeance.
Blacktail’s fury catches the notice of an ancient and terrible feline witch, who makes an offer. What if Blacktail could end the human race responsible for the death of his family and for the destruction of the natural world, altogether? To do so, Blacktail must find and wake the Forest God. Only He might stand against the plague of men. Blacktail knows that his north woods are dwindling to nothing. He sees no other choice.
As Blacktail journeys farther from his wild home and deeper into the world of man, he encounters strangers—animal, mortal, and otherworldly—who, for their own reasons, want to help Blacktail rid the world of humans. Along the way, it becomes clear that he is more than just a wolf. The Forest God is sleeping, yes. But what will be the price of waking him?
288 pages, Hardcover
First published September 1, 2026
About the author
Scott Hawkins
8 books3,615 followersI'm forty-nine and I live in the Atlanta suburbs with my wife and a whole bunch of dogs.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 479 reviews
May 16, 2026
Fucking hell.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
11 years since the wonderful The Library at Mount Char.
This is a very different book from TL@MC and also from almost every other book I know.
It does have strong vibes of Watership Down and The Plague Dogs, both by Richard Adams. The focus is on a particular wolf/dog half-breed, the eponymous Blacktail. And there is definitely an element of the chaotic/weird mythology that we saw in TL@MC. There is mention of the tiger Nobununga, and there are large scale mythology-level events/conflicts that echo the climax of TL@MC. But it's very definitely a different book without a single human point-of-view (that I remember).
Speaking of point-of-view: the book's written in an unusual style that's part fairytale/story telling and we do slide from one point-of-view to another in-paragraph on occasion. Also, we're given a handful of minor points-of-view alongside the main one (Blacktail).
It's an engaging tale that takes us in unexpected directions. It's at many times pretty gory with violence from and against animals. Although there's an over-riding "humans bad" message, it's delivered from an animal point-of-view and the harsh justice can seem ... harsh ... given the reader's greater (or different) understanding of the various encounters.
Like TL@MC there's a deeply uncompromising thread running through the story with harsh justice dispensed, the good/innocent suffering as they're variously steamrollered by chance, malice, or in the name of a greater cause.
The net effect is touching, horrifying, and entertaining. In many places it's impossible - as with any well written account of animals suffering because of our deeds - to not be moved. But the undercurrents of humour, and the wildly unpredictable paths Hawkins' imagination takes us down, mean that this is far from a mawkish look at animals enduring the cruelty of men.
It's one of those books I'll have to sit with to fully understand my feelings about it - but there's zero doubt that it's a 5* read, so I can hit the rating button right now.
You should all get excited for this book and hope that Mr Hawkins doesn't keep us waiting 10 years for another one.
It's very definitely a stand-alone though, so you'll not be left hanging. It's a completely complete story that has left me satisfied and with plenty to think on.
Join my Patreon
Join my 3-emails-a-year newsletter #prizes
.
Join my Patreon
Join my 3-emails-a-year newsletter #prizes
.
This is a very different book from TL@MC and also from almost every other book I know.
It does have strong vibes of Watership Down and The Plague Dogs, both by Richard Adams. The focus is on a particular wolf/dog half-breed, the eponymous Blacktail. And there is definitely an element of the chaotic/weird mythology that we saw in TL@MC. There is mention of the tiger Nobununga, and there are large scale mythology-level events/conflicts that echo the climax of TL@MC. But it's very definitely a different book without a single human point-of-view (that I remember).
Speaking of point-of-view: the book's written in an unusual style that's part fairytale/story telling and we do slide from one point-of-view to another in-paragraph on occasion. Also, we're given a handful of minor points-of-view alongside the main one (Blacktail).
It's an engaging tale that takes us in unexpected directions. It's at many times pretty gory with violence from and against animals. Although there's an over-riding "humans bad" message, it's delivered from an animal point-of-view and the harsh justice can seem ... harsh ... given the reader's greater (or different) understanding of the various encounters.
Like TL@MC there's a deeply uncompromising thread running through the story with harsh justice dispensed, the good/innocent suffering as they're variously steamrollered by chance, malice, or in the name of a greater cause.
The net effect is touching, horrifying, and entertaining. In many places it's impossible - as with any well written account of animals suffering because of our deeds - to not be moved. But the undercurrents of humour, and the wildly unpredictable paths Hawkins' imagination takes us down, mean that this is far from a mawkish look at animals enduring the cruelty of men.
It's one of those books I'll have to sit with to fully understand my feelings about it - but there's zero doubt that it's a 5* read, so I can hit the rating button right now.
You should all get excited for this book and hope that Mr Hawkins doesn't keep us waiting 10 years for another one.
It's very definitely a stand-alone though, so you'll not be left hanging. It's a completely complete story that has left me satisfied and with plenty to think on.
Join my Patreon
Join my 3-emails-a-year newsletter #prizes
.
Join my Patreon
Join my 3-emails-a-year newsletter #prizes
.
Want to Read
January 30, 2026ur telling me the author of library at mount char is releasing another book after TEN YEARS?? and it’s like a funky wolf pov?? we used to pray for days like these
September 8, 2026
What the hell was this 😭
(in a mostly positive way, more thoughts to come)
(in a mostly positive way, more thoughts to come)
June 16, 2026
4.5 ⭐️ An absolute unexpected delight! A unique work of speculative fiction that is such a breath of fresh air! So much was packed into a relatively short book but it never felt rushed. Instead there was an episodic or dreamlike quality to each chapter especially as we got closer to the end. The ending was the main reason I knocked half a star off. It was fine but it didn’t have me glued to the page like the rest of the book.
TW Cruelty & violence against animals are main themes and are portrayed liberally. If graphic depictions turn your stomach stay away!
TW Cruelty & violence against animals are main themes and are portrayed liberally. If graphic depictions turn your stomach stay away!
Currently Reading
September 14, 2026Blacktail is a story about a half-wolf living in wilderness encroached by humans. He wants a peaceful life but upon experiencing human violence, Blacktail responds with rage and revenge, calling on the sleeping Forest God to help him bring down humanity and their dominion.
The story is entirely told through animals perspective and is very dark and violent. AND this book is totally weird.
Lets get into it :)
Many thanks to NetGalley, Crown Publishing and the author, Scott Hawkins for an early ARC.
Publication date: September 1, 2026
The story is entirely told through animals perspective and is very dark and violent. AND this book is totally weird.
Lets get into it :)
Many thanks to NetGalley, Crown Publishing and the author, Scott Hawkins for an early ARC.
Publication date: September 1, 2026
August 6, 2026
Blacktail is a wolf whose world is being slowly eroded by the encroachment of men. He meets a domesticated dog who becomes his mate. Learning she is pregnant, he makes plans to help her escape from her owners so that they can live together in the wild. Before the plan can be implemented both his mate and their puppies are killed, sending Blacktail into a rage. He quickly enacts revenge against her human owners and finds himself fleeing for his life. Blacktail then meets an ancient cat who convinces him to continue his war against humanity by waking the Forest God. His goal is nothing less than the eradication of humans. He meets animals along his journey and reminds them that their true nature does not consist of being subjugated to humans, but rather being part of the hunt.
This book is very thought provoking and is told completely from the perspective of Blacktail and other animals. While there are a few humans in the story who treat animals with love and kindness, most are presented as cruel and sadistic. Sections of the book are emotionally difficult to read due to descriptions of violence committed against the animal characters or toward one another. The other major theme of the book centers around the frequent lack of concern for how the growth of human infrastructure negatively impacts natural habitats. Something as simple as the building of roads can have significant consequences for the life of animals.
Blacktail is a story that will linger with me for some time. Recommended for fans of folk horror and dark fantasy.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance reading copy of this book.
This book is very thought provoking and is told completely from the perspective of Blacktail and other animals. While there are a few humans in the story who treat animals with love and kindness, most are presented as cruel and sadistic. Sections of the book are emotionally difficult to read due to descriptions of violence committed against the animal characters or toward one another. The other major theme of the book centers around the frequent lack of concern for how the growth of human infrastructure negatively impacts natural habitats. Something as simple as the building of roads can have significant consequences for the life of animals.
Blacktail is a story that will linger with me for some time. Recommended for fans of folk horror and dark fantasy.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance reading copy of this book.
Want to Read
May 8, 2026Omg, OHH MAH GAWDDDD. You know sometimes I would randomly think "Library at Mt Char was such a banger, has he written anything else yet?", and then I would check and it would just be that darn Linux manual. NOT TODAY, I'm so excited.
Want to Read
July 8, 2026Dear Mr. Hawkins,
I’ve waited 11 years for this.
Thank you.
How dare you.
But mostly thank you.
I’ve waited 11 years for this.
Thank you.
How dare you.
But mostly thank you.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Review in the July 2026 issue of Booklist and on the blog: https://raforall.blogspot.com/2026/07... (link live on 7/8/26 at 7am central)
4.5
Three Words That Describe This Book: animal point of view, dark fantasy quest/journey, nature is not happy with us
First things first, this is not Library at Mount Char, it is very different but it is also very good. It is lyrical and fairytale/mystical. But it is also practical in many ways.
Blacktail, a wolf who is out for revenge against all humans, is the main narrator. He is not the only narrator, but he is the main one. No humans get the pov, only animals.
This book makes us humans look VERY bad. All of us. And Hawkins meters out judgement and punishment on all humans through Blacktail and there is no mercy. None. I cannot stress this enough. Even humans who we readers think don't deserve to die, will be brutally hunted by Blacktail. Animals are hunted too, but it all makes sense through Blacktail's world view-- which is very clear to readers.
To see him react to seeing "car" kill animals and leave them on the pavement -- killing just for fun and not a reason. To see the way he looks at houses, people's impact on the land. His reaction to pets who he calls slaves. How the animals work, interact and communicate and the spirits and witches that bind them all. It is riveting and original.
I also loved that Hawkins uses Blacktail's journey to break the story into vignettes. Each of his stops/passing through a new territory, gives readers the chance to meet new animal characters. The rhythm of this keeps the story moving at a good pace.
There is one "good human" here and kudos to Hawkins for sticking with the POV and Blacktail's sense of right and wrong because wow is it uncomfortable for the human reader.
Seething with rage and seeking vengeance -- appetite for revenge not satiated, only growing. This is a violent, in your face revenge novel.
The storytelling has a mystical/dark fairy tale feel.
Very similar to Watership Down by Adams in the storytelling, the dark fantasy, the environmentalism, but it is dark and filled with blood thirsty revenge of Pearl by Josh Malerman. A great mix of the two.
I thought about Lord of the Rings as well. Frodo's quest seems impossible but it is dire. Many will help or hurt him along the way.
4.5
Three Words That Describe This Book: animal point of view, dark fantasy quest/journey, nature is not happy with us
First things first, this is not Library at Mount Char, it is very different but it is also very good. It is lyrical and fairytale/mystical. But it is also practical in many ways.
Blacktail, a wolf who is out for revenge against all humans, is the main narrator. He is not the only narrator, but he is the main one. No humans get the pov, only animals.
This book makes us humans look VERY bad. All of us. And Hawkins meters out judgement and punishment on all humans through Blacktail and there is no mercy. None. I cannot stress this enough. Even humans who we readers think don't deserve to die, will be brutally hunted by Blacktail. Animals are hunted too, but it all makes sense through Blacktail's world view-- which is very clear to readers.
To see him react to seeing "car" kill animals and leave them on the pavement -- killing just for fun and not a reason. To see the way he looks at houses, people's impact on the land. His reaction to pets who he calls slaves. How the animals work, interact and communicate and the spirits and witches that bind them all. It is riveting and original.
I also loved that Hawkins uses Blacktail's journey to break the story into vignettes. Each of his stops/passing through a new territory, gives readers the chance to meet new animal characters. The rhythm of this keeps the story moving at a good pace.
There is one "good human" here and kudos to Hawkins for sticking with the POV and Blacktail's sense of right and wrong because wow is it uncomfortable for the human reader.
Seething with rage and seeking vengeance -- appetite for revenge not satiated, only growing. This is a violent, in your face revenge novel.
The storytelling has a mystical/dark fairy tale feel.
Very similar to Watership Down by Adams in the storytelling, the dark fantasy, the environmentalism, but it is dark and filled with blood thirsty revenge of Pearl by Josh Malerman. A great mix of the two.
I thought about Lord of the Rings as well. Frodo's quest seems impossible but it is dire. Many will help or hurt him along the way.
September 3, 2026
Damn! Watership Down grew up and got nasty.
Fans have been waiting a loooooooooonnnnnggg time for this, a new book from the author—well, co-author—of, you know the book, The Complete Linux Shell Programming Training Course.
It is magnificent.
I went in mostly blind, ignoring the book flap and previews but not dodging advance knowledge that it's narrated by a wolf (a half-wolf, really), but the book reveals its nature quickly. By the end of Chapter Two you'll know exactly what you're in for, should you continue.
Did you read The Library at Mount Char? Do you remember it well? Do you remember the oven? Because this new book is all oven. It's been seven years and I remember so many things from Mount Char, but what brought me back to it most acutely was the sense of dread, fascinating, captivating dread and horror that this story also produced.
It's brutal, to animals and humans alike, and when I tried to look the book up on https://www.doesthedogdie.com/ my computer starting screaming and crying and I had to turn the power off.
It's propelling, horrific, and undeniable in its examination of humanity's relationship with animals and nature, both individually and collectively. It's weird and unpredictable fantasy from an obviously stable and intelligent mind.
I kind of hope that there's another 10 years until Hawkins' next book comes out, because I will immediately put aside all other books when it does and I have a lot of lingering reading to work through.
Fans have been waiting a loooooooooonnnnnggg time for this, a new book from the author—well, co-author—of, you know the book, The Complete Linux Shell Programming Training Course.
It is magnificent.
I went in mostly blind, ignoring the book flap and previews but not dodging advance knowledge that it's narrated by a wolf (a half-wolf, really), but the book reveals its nature quickly. By the end of Chapter Two you'll know exactly what you're in for, should you continue.
Did you read The Library at Mount Char? Do you remember it well? Do you remember the oven? Because this new book is all oven. It's been seven years and I remember so many things from Mount Char, but what brought me back to it most acutely was the sense of dread, fascinating, captivating dread and horror that this story also produced.
It's brutal, to animals and humans alike, and when I tried to look the book up on https://www.doesthedogdie.com/ my computer starting screaming and crying and I had to turn the power off.
It's propelling, horrific, and undeniable in its examination of humanity's relationship with animals and nature, both individually and collectively. It's weird and unpredictable fantasy from an obviously stable and intelligent mind.
I kind of hope that there's another 10 years until Hawkins' next book comes out, because I will immediately put aside all other books when it does and I have a lot of lingering reading to work through.
January 23, 2026
My hopes and prayers have been answered. September can’t come soon enough.
September 4, 2026
Read Etna instead
September 3, 2026
Blacktail is such a unique Dark Fantasy story. Admittedly, not something I would typically gravitate towards, however, I've heard such great things about Scott Hawkins writing, I had to jump on board for his latest work.
This story follows a wolf named Blacktail, in a world beseiged by men, who sets out on a journey of revenge for the death of his mate.
The entirety of the story is told via a cast of animal characters. I know books like this exist, but this is the first one I've ever read. I'm generally super sensitive to animal content, so never really dare, but this kept me captivated.
The tone is that of a Dark Fable, and while I feel like the meaning went way over my head, I was enamored by the quality of the writing and the uniqueness of the content.
I loved how we followed Blacktail on this journey, and it felt like every place he stopped, the other animals he encountered, he was always learning something new. Through those experiences it almost felt like little vignettes. I enjoyed that.
I'm truly in awe of how Hawkins made these characters feel so stunningly realistic. Here I am reading from a perspective of a squirrel like, yeah, that makes sense.
So, while I wouldn't chose to the lead the discussion in book club on this one, I still had a great time with it. It did make me feel a little simple. LOL
Thank you to the publisher, Crown Publishing, for providing me with a copy to read and review. This was certainly a unique reading experience!
This story follows a wolf named Blacktail, in a world beseiged by men, who sets out on a journey of revenge for the death of his mate.
The entirety of the story is told via a cast of animal characters. I know books like this exist, but this is the first one I've ever read. I'm generally super sensitive to animal content, so never really dare, but this kept me captivated.
The tone is that of a Dark Fable, and while I feel like the meaning went way over my head, I was enamored by the quality of the writing and the uniqueness of the content.
I loved how we followed Blacktail on this journey, and it felt like every place he stopped, the other animals he encountered, he was always learning something new. Through those experiences it almost felt like little vignettes. I enjoyed that.
I'm truly in awe of how Hawkins made these characters feel so stunningly realistic. Here I am reading from a perspective of a squirrel like, yeah, that makes sense.
So, while I wouldn't chose to the lead the discussion in book club on this one, I still had a great time with it. It did make me feel a little simple. LOL
Thank you to the publisher, Crown Publishing, for providing me with a copy to read and review. This was certainly a unique reading experience!
September 1, 2026
I've struggled so much with how I could possibly even describe Blacktail, let alone my feelings and criticisms of it. I cannot describe how disappointed I was in this experience. Scott Hawkins is not afraid to alienate a reader. He will write events that are inexplicable, strange, and off-putting. This aspect of his writing persists in Blacktail, but in a much more confusing, disgusting, and difficult-to-accept way. Everything from the line-by-line writing to the characters to the world-building is significantly worse, and despite the amount of sex and violence, more immature. It's a crazy comparison, but I legitimately felt like I was reading the Warrior Cats series by Erin Hunter, just with more dog sex.
A young wolf named Blacktail is the last of his kind in the forest he calls home. Encroachment from the world of men shrinks his territory every year, and these men bring weapons that no wolf can counter. The wolf follows a scent down from the mountain and into the territory of men, meeting a house dog named Renren. He offers to take her away from her world and into his, but before he can, Renren is killed by humans. Blacktail fills with a rage he has never felt before and swears vengeance on all humankind, starting with Renren's owners.
His fury calls out to an ancient feline witch, The Great Kitty Mother, who believes Blacktail might finally fulfill a long-held desire for the animals of The Hunt. She offers him the opportunity to kill the human race if he can find and wake the ancient Forest God. Blacktail's bloodlust is not sated, so he agrees. His journey takes him across hundreds of miles and encounters with strangers who all seek the same goal: the end of the human race and the rise of the Forest God.
I wrote a very long review about Blacktail, so if you'd like to read my in-depth thoughts with many evidentiary quotes, check out my blog, A Literary Apothecary, through the link below.
https://aliteraryapothecary.com/2026/...
There are a LOT of characters in Blacktail, but they aren't overwhelming. Each set of characters is typically featured for only a single chapter as they meet and influence Blacktail, and then they disappear from the story. I did like the personification of the animals. Lower, prey animals refer to hunters as Lord, and Blacktail is considered the Lord of his forest as the apex predator on the mountain. I especially liked some of the characterization of marking behavior. Wolves mark using poetry and lyricism.
Blacktail himself is a character that I feel conflicted about. I found him likable at first. He's young, and he's unsure about his belief in the Forest God. He's certainly not devoted to him, even once he begins his journey to wake the god. Many of the characters that he runs across are devout, and Blacktail does begin to adopt these beliefs. However, halfway through the novel, there's a very jarring pivot in Blacktail's beliefs and he becomes a deeply entrenched, dogmatic despot for The Forest God and The Hunt.
Blacktail's actions are also confusing in their morality. I don't know what kind of character he's supposed to be, but Blacktail regularly abuses his power to rain violence down upon others. He kills innocents over and over, and the narrative never really interrogates it. It's incredibly easy to hate Blacktail by the end of the story, and I'm not sure if the audience is supposed to hate him.
There is a significant problem that marred the reading experience for me and was incredibly distracting. The number of times urine or urinating is mentioned is truly unacceptable. After a while, it felt like Hawkins couldn't think of any other way to express fear except by someone pissing. I actually counted how many mentions of piss there were because it was starting to become genuinely shocking. There are sixteen mentions of "piss," three mentions of "urine," four mentions of "wetting oneself," and 4 mentions of "pee." That's twenty-seven mentions of urine in some way or another. That's one mention every ten pages!
The other thing that was fairly uncomfortable to read about was the amount of dog horniness contained in these pages. The actual sex itself isn't necessarily described in graphic detail, but the insinuation is still more than I would prefer. It's natural. Sex is natural. However, I can hold all of those opinions and still be uncomfortable reading about how pleasurable sex was for an animal.
There are some passages of prose that I enjoyed, and overall the writing maintains a level of gravitas that makes the story feel like a fable or myth. That works quite well with the way the story is framed. The dialogue between characters is more noble than everyday vernacular. All of that contributes to making the world of the animals feel much different and antiquated compared to the modernity of the humans in the novel.
The pacing of the story is a bit odd. This is structured less like a traditional novel and more like The Odyssey, with several vignettes following a central character through an overarching journey. That's not necessarily a bad thing. Some of the vignettes are more enjoyable than others, but they do contribute to the overall plot and development of Blacktail as a character. It does mean that the book is very segmented, and Blacktail can occasionally feel like a very different character between chapters.
The world-building of Blacktail is one of the highlights. The Library at Mount Char had so many fantastic concepts, and this book is no different. This author is entirely unafraid of his own ideas, and it makes the world entirely unique.
I did also enjoy many of the more supernatural elements, to a point. Cats in this world are essentially witches, able to weave spells, literally. All cats are of a coven who serve one known as The Great Kitty Mother. Their magic is literally able to affect the world. Heaven exists, Hell exists, angels exist. Again, this book has never met an idea that it turned away. That's all quite fun, and this level of absurdity is totally acceptable and expected to me. The absurdity that I couldn't abide lay with the themes.
The section on themes ended up being incredibly long and detailed, so this is going to just be the basics, but I deeply elaborated on them in my longer review. There will be some spoilers in this section.
Renren is the female dog that Blacktail mates with. When she falls pregnant, he offers to take her away from her home and into the woods with him to start a wolf pack. Renren agrees to this, but before she's able to leave with him, she dies. Renren's death is not tied to any human action that is evil. Her owners take her to the vet to be spayed, and as is the case with many dogs, the vet aborted her and Blacktail's puppies to perform the procedure. There was an issue with the surgery, and Renren dies from internal bleeding.
I'm not accusing the author of any specific political leanings, but there is a certain reading of this story that is anti-abortion. The dog fetuses are always referred to as Blacktail's children or his puppies. They're described as being murdered by humans. These are the talking points and language that anti-abortion activists use to try to make pregnant people seeking abortions feel guilty and to enact legislation banning abortion access.
There are two factions that are warring within these pages: The Hunt and Reason. The Forest God is of The Hunt and believes that all creatures should follow the laws of the natural world. The Christian God is of Reason, which has allowed humanity to think and create tools that subvert The Hunt, like weapons, traps, cars, etc. Blacktail's journey to embrace The Hunt and wake the Forest God is the core of the story, and as I've said, each vignette provides a deeper exploration of the principles of The Hunt.
My problem with this entire concept is that The Hunt makes no sense. Humanity, without Reason, falls into a very particular spot in the hierarchy of The Hunt. We don't have sharp teeth or claws. We specifically evolved Reason to build our arsenal of tools. The logic of The Hunt doesn't allow for that. How would a rabbit ever rise up against a wolf? It's impossible. So, within the philosophy of the Forest God, some creatures are just better and more powerful than others, and the ones who don't have power should simply submit to those who do. Attempting to counter oppression goes against the natural order and must be punished with near eradication.
The chapter about Mercy, more than anything else in the book, filled me with confusion, anger, and disappointment. Mercy is a human woman who feeds the animals of the forest, and she takes in any stray, hurt, or lost animals to nurse them back to health and provide a good home for them. Obviously, these animals love and want to protect Mercy. Blacktail, with darkness and vengeance in his heart, vows to kill Mercy and all those who protect her because they are violating the natural order.
This is a very difficult scene to witness because Blacktail is explicitly in the wrong here. This human was no threat to him and was causing no harm to him or any other animals. Among the crowd of animals is a beagle named Babykins. While the other animals are attempting to hold off Blacktail, Babykins runs to Mercy to try to warn her about Blacktail, telling her to run. Blacktail fatally injures the beagle, but keeps him alive to watch as he mauls Mercy, an act of abject cruelty.
Babykins keeps yelling for Mercy to run, and Blacktail allows her to, trying to prove to Babykins that Mercy never really cared about the animals. She does run from the room, and Blacktail turns to the beagle, expecting him to be heartbroken that his mother has left him to die, but all Babykins feels is relief. He would rather his mother, whom he loves deeply, survive than try to save him.
And then, Mercy comes back for him.
The love and fearlessness of Mercy as a protector is something that touches Blacktail deeply, and he lets her live. I thought this was going to be a turning point for Blacktail as he realized that humans are not an emotionless, evil monolith. They can love and protect just as fiercely as he was able to, and perhaps his quest is not as righteous as he believed. However, this event doesn't affect him beyond the last two pages of this chapter. Blacktail literally never mentions any deeper thoughts about the confrontations with Mercy.
Blacktail's belief and dogma do not eventuate in the world becoming a paradise for the Animal, predator or prey. So, in that way, was his quest doomed? Is this a tragedy in disguise? Is the audience supposed to differentiate the consequences for Blacktail—that being a happy, peaceful ending with his loved ones—and the consequences for those he left behind: starvation and overpopulation? What in the hell is this book trying to say?
Everything about it thematically is so confused, and I became very quickly frustrated with the book as a whole. If you're trying to make a point, make it. Interrogate it. Have your protagonist grapple with the implications of his stance. I just need something that indicates what all of this was for. The worst answer, in my opinion, is that it's for nothing. This doesn't mean anything. It's just a story, and anything you're trying to read into it is overthinking.
I have no idea if I recommend Blacktail or not. It was a difficult, slow read with little to no reward at the end, and the plot rose to a level of ridiculousness that didn't feel engaging or interesting. It was like the Sharknado of books, except that Sharknado is aware of its own ridiculousness.
I did not like Blacktail.
Don't forget you can read the full review on my blog, A Literary Apothecary, through the link below.
https://aliteraryapothecary.com/2026/...
Trigger Warnings
Animal death, animal cruelty, blood, abortion, death of a child, cannibalism, car accident, death, starvation, murder, medical content, violence.
Does the Dog Die?
A young wolf named Blacktail is the last of his kind in the forest he calls home. Encroachment from the world of men shrinks his territory every year, and these men bring weapons that no wolf can counter. The wolf follows a scent down from the mountain and into the territory of men, meeting a house dog named Renren. He offers to take her away from her world and into his, but before he can, Renren is killed by humans. Blacktail fills with a rage he has never felt before and swears vengeance on all humankind, starting with Renren's owners.
His fury calls out to an ancient feline witch, The Great Kitty Mother, who believes Blacktail might finally fulfill a long-held desire for the animals of The Hunt. She offers him the opportunity to kill the human race if he can find and wake the ancient Forest God. Blacktail's bloodlust is not sated, so he agrees. His journey takes him across hundreds of miles and encounters with strangers who all seek the same goal: the end of the human race and the rise of the Forest God.
I wrote a very long review about Blacktail, so if you'd like to read my in-depth thoughts with many evidentiary quotes, check out my blog, A Literary Apothecary, through the link below.
https://aliteraryapothecary.com/2026/...
There are a LOT of characters in Blacktail, but they aren't overwhelming. Each set of characters is typically featured for only a single chapter as they meet and influence Blacktail, and then they disappear from the story. I did like the personification of the animals. Lower, prey animals refer to hunters as Lord, and Blacktail is considered the Lord of his forest as the apex predator on the mountain. I especially liked some of the characterization of marking behavior. Wolves mark using poetry and lyricism.
Blacktail himself is a character that I feel conflicted about. I found him likable at first. He's young, and he's unsure about his belief in the Forest God. He's certainly not devoted to him, even once he begins his journey to wake the god. Many of the characters that he runs across are devout, and Blacktail does begin to adopt these beliefs. However, halfway through the novel, there's a very jarring pivot in Blacktail's beliefs and he becomes a deeply entrenched, dogmatic despot for The Forest God and The Hunt.
Blacktail's actions are also confusing in their morality. I don't know what kind of character he's supposed to be, but Blacktail regularly abuses his power to rain violence down upon others. He kills innocents over and over, and the narrative never really interrogates it. It's incredibly easy to hate Blacktail by the end of the story, and I'm not sure if the audience is supposed to hate him.
There is a significant problem that marred the reading experience for me and was incredibly distracting. The number of times urine or urinating is mentioned is truly unacceptable. After a while, it felt like Hawkins couldn't think of any other way to express fear except by someone pissing. I actually counted how many mentions of piss there were because it was starting to become genuinely shocking. There are sixteen mentions of "piss," three mentions of "urine," four mentions of "wetting oneself," and 4 mentions of "pee." That's twenty-seven mentions of urine in some way or another. That's one mention every ten pages!
The other thing that was fairly uncomfortable to read about was the amount of dog horniness contained in these pages. The actual sex itself isn't necessarily described in graphic detail, but the insinuation is still more than I would prefer. It's natural. Sex is natural. However, I can hold all of those opinions and still be uncomfortable reading about how pleasurable sex was for an animal.
There are some passages of prose that I enjoyed, and overall the writing maintains a level of gravitas that makes the story feel like a fable or myth. That works quite well with the way the story is framed. The dialogue between characters is more noble than everyday vernacular. All of that contributes to making the world of the animals feel much different and antiquated compared to the modernity of the humans in the novel.
The pacing of the story is a bit odd. This is structured less like a traditional novel and more like The Odyssey, with several vignettes following a central character through an overarching journey. That's not necessarily a bad thing. Some of the vignettes are more enjoyable than others, but they do contribute to the overall plot and development of Blacktail as a character. It does mean that the book is very segmented, and Blacktail can occasionally feel like a very different character between chapters.
The world-building of Blacktail is one of the highlights. The Library at Mount Char had so many fantastic concepts, and this book is no different. This author is entirely unafraid of his own ideas, and it makes the world entirely unique.
I did also enjoy many of the more supernatural elements, to a point. Cats in this world are essentially witches, able to weave spells, literally. All cats are of a coven who serve one known as The Great Kitty Mother. Their magic is literally able to affect the world. Heaven exists, Hell exists, angels exist. Again, this book has never met an idea that it turned away. That's all quite fun, and this level of absurdity is totally acceptable and expected to me. The absurdity that I couldn't abide lay with the themes.
The section on themes ended up being incredibly long and detailed, so this is going to just be the basics, but I deeply elaborated on them in my longer review. There will be some spoilers in this section.
Renren is the female dog that Blacktail mates with. When she falls pregnant, he offers to take her away from her home and into the woods with him to start a wolf pack. Renren agrees to this, but before she's able to leave with him, she dies. Renren's death is not tied to any human action that is evil. Her owners take her to the vet to be spayed, and as is the case with many dogs, the vet aborted her and Blacktail's puppies to perform the procedure. There was an issue with the surgery, and Renren dies from internal bleeding.
I'm not accusing the author of any specific political leanings, but there is a certain reading of this story that is anti-abortion. The dog fetuses are always referred to as Blacktail's children or his puppies. They're described as being murdered by humans. These are the talking points and language that anti-abortion activists use to try to make pregnant people seeking abortions feel guilty and to enact legislation banning abortion access.
There are two factions that are warring within these pages: The Hunt and Reason. The Forest God is of The Hunt and believes that all creatures should follow the laws of the natural world. The Christian God is of Reason, which has allowed humanity to think and create tools that subvert The Hunt, like weapons, traps, cars, etc. Blacktail's journey to embrace The Hunt and wake the Forest God is the core of the story, and as I've said, each vignette provides a deeper exploration of the principles of The Hunt.
My problem with this entire concept is that The Hunt makes no sense. Humanity, without Reason, falls into a very particular spot in the hierarchy of The Hunt. We don't have sharp teeth or claws. We specifically evolved Reason to build our arsenal of tools. The logic of The Hunt doesn't allow for that. How would a rabbit ever rise up against a wolf? It's impossible. So, within the philosophy of the Forest God, some creatures are just better and more powerful than others, and the ones who don't have power should simply submit to those who do. Attempting to counter oppression goes against the natural order and must be punished with near eradication.
The chapter about Mercy, more than anything else in the book, filled me with confusion, anger, and disappointment. Mercy is a human woman who feeds the animals of the forest, and she takes in any stray, hurt, or lost animals to nurse them back to health and provide a good home for them. Obviously, these animals love and want to protect Mercy. Blacktail, with darkness and vengeance in his heart, vows to kill Mercy and all those who protect her because they are violating the natural order.
This is a very difficult scene to witness because Blacktail is explicitly in the wrong here. This human was no threat to him and was causing no harm to him or any other animals. Among the crowd of animals is a beagle named Babykins. While the other animals are attempting to hold off Blacktail, Babykins runs to Mercy to try to warn her about Blacktail, telling her to run. Blacktail fatally injures the beagle, but keeps him alive to watch as he mauls Mercy, an act of abject cruelty.
Babykins keeps yelling for Mercy to run, and Blacktail allows her to, trying to prove to Babykins that Mercy never really cared about the animals. She does run from the room, and Blacktail turns to the beagle, expecting him to be heartbroken that his mother has left him to die, but all Babykins feels is relief. He would rather his mother, whom he loves deeply, survive than try to save him.
And then, Mercy comes back for him.
The love and fearlessness of Mercy as a protector is something that touches Blacktail deeply, and he lets her live. I thought this was going to be a turning point for Blacktail as he realized that humans are not an emotionless, evil monolith. They can love and protect just as fiercely as he was able to, and perhaps his quest is not as righteous as he believed. However, this event doesn't affect him beyond the last two pages of this chapter. Blacktail literally never mentions any deeper thoughts about the confrontations with Mercy.
Blacktail's belief and dogma do not eventuate in the world becoming a paradise for the Animal, predator or prey. So, in that way, was his quest doomed? Is this a tragedy in disguise? Is the audience supposed to differentiate the consequences for Blacktail—that being a happy, peaceful ending with his loved ones—and the consequences for those he left behind: starvation and overpopulation? What in the hell is this book trying to say?
Everything about it thematically is so confused, and I became very quickly frustrated with the book as a whole. If you're trying to make a point, make it. Interrogate it. Have your protagonist grapple with the implications of his stance. I just need something that indicates what all of this was for. The worst answer, in my opinion, is that it's for nothing. This doesn't mean anything. It's just a story, and anything you're trying to read into it is overthinking.
I have no idea if I recommend Blacktail or not. It was a difficult, slow read with little to no reward at the end, and the plot rose to a level of ridiculousness that didn't feel engaging or interesting. It was like the Sharknado of books, except that Sharknado is aware of its own ridiculousness.
I did not like Blacktail.
Don't forget you can read the full review on my blog, A Literary Apothecary, through the link below.
https://aliteraryapothecary.com/2026/...
Trigger Warnings
Animal death, animal cruelty, blood, abortion, death of a child, cannibalism, car accident, death, starvation, murder, medical content, violence.
Does the Dog Die?
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Somehow this was the perfect combination of Open Throat + Princess Mononoke + Monstress, and it’s like yeah, no wonder I loved it.
I thought I knew what this book would be about (a wolf on a quest), but then it took on a whole new direction, and the second half really evolved into a magnificent feat of craft. Since it’s mostly written from the perspective of animals, it can feel a bit surreal at times (much like Open Throat) to the point that it almost feels like reading a children’s book, but the content is so dark and violent and intense that the surrealism adds to the horror and fantasy of it all. As far as fantasy goes, I like that this leans into fabulism and abstraction, that we know the shape of some of the “magic,” but if you look too closely you don’t really have a lot of details to fall back on. You’re not supposed to look too close but rather inspect it from the macro, use the aerial view to get the full picture.
What I did not expect and what drove the whole thing home, was the religious tone that grew louder and louder as the book went on. It reminded me so much of the cats in Monstress and the Forest God (ha, yes) of Princess Mononoke, and yet it was so different than both of those. I would love to hear more from the author about what influenced him specifically because coming from a Christian background it all felt very Jesus-y…but not in a preachy way. The point of it wasn’t Christianity or Jesus, that was just used as a vessel (though never mentioned or spoken of directly) to create something else.
It’s a wonderful allegory, in part because it feels so episodic, as if you’re reading a twisted children’s book that tells bible stories about how humans are wicked and heaven is a Far Hill in spring. It speaks to the power of nature, how we should be returning to nature, and it also forces you to reckon with how humans interact with nature and animals as a whole. (Again, Princess Mononoke.) At one point I forgot that animals aren’t sentient and this book is actually being written by a human because holy cow, that ending.
Overall, this was such a surprising gem, and even though I dragged my feet picking it up, I knew my gut instinct was right to request it from NG because it has wormed its way into my brain and I fear it will not let go.
I thought I knew what this book would be about (a wolf on a quest), but then it took on a whole new direction, and the second half really evolved into a magnificent feat of craft. Since it’s mostly written from the perspective of animals, it can feel a bit surreal at times (much like Open Throat) to the point that it almost feels like reading a children’s book, but the content is so dark and violent and intense that the surrealism adds to the horror and fantasy of it all. As far as fantasy goes, I like that this leans into fabulism and abstraction, that we know the shape of some of the “magic,” but if you look too closely you don’t really have a lot of details to fall back on. You’re not supposed to look too close but rather inspect it from the macro, use the aerial view to get the full picture.
What I did not expect and what drove the whole thing home, was the religious tone that grew louder and louder as the book went on. It reminded me so much of the cats in Monstress and the Forest God (ha, yes) of Princess Mononoke, and yet it was so different than both of those. I would love to hear more from the author about what influenced him specifically because coming from a Christian background it all felt very Jesus-y…but not in a preachy way. The point of it wasn’t Christianity or Jesus, that was just used as a vessel (though never mentioned or spoken of directly) to create something else.
It’s a wonderful allegory, in part because it feels so episodic, as if you’re reading a twisted children’s book that tells bible stories about how humans are wicked and heaven is a Far Hill in spring. It speaks to the power of nature, how we should be returning to nature, and it also forces you to reckon with how humans interact with nature and animals as a whole. (Again, Princess Mononoke.) At one point I forgot that animals aren’t sentient and this book is actually being written by a human because holy cow, that ending.
Overall, this was such a surprising gem, and even though I dragged my feet picking it up, I knew my gut instinct was right to request it from NG because it has wormed its way into my brain and I fear it will not let go.
August 7, 2026
Though I love when authors show us range, but woof– someone needs to do a mental health check on Hawkins. (Or needs a literary mentor to get him back on a more confident track.)
Man, that sounds awful. But let me talk through my worry.
It’s been 10 years since The Library at Mount Char was released so I was expecting something spectacular to be brewing.
It starts off strong but plot wise, and surprised by the level of anthropomorphism because I went in blind. Unfortunately, I was bored 1/2 way through. It was like he was in an adventure hamster wheel and forgot his destination.
I don’t want to rain on this completely- my favorite thing was the communication by pee smells.
It felt like cats vs. dogs connected through short stories. Semi-poetic, preachy and repetitive.
I’m so sad this was not a TBR win, but hoping will still see cool things from Hawkins in the future.
Man, that sounds awful. But let me talk through my worry.
It’s been 10 years since The Library at Mount Char was released so I was expecting something spectacular to be brewing.
It starts off strong but plot wise, and surprised by the level of anthropomorphism because I went in blind. Unfortunately, I was bored 1/2 way through. It was like he was in an adventure hamster wheel and forgot his destination.
I don’t want to rain on this completely- my favorite thing was the communication by pee smells.
It felt like cats vs. dogs connected through short stories. Semi-poetic, preachy and repetitive.
I’m so sad this was not a TBR win, but hoping will still see cool things from Hawkins in the future.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 12, 2026
Blacktail is a strange, brutal, and moving dark-fantasy novel. Hawkins takes the familiar idea of a revenge story and turns it into something much more mythic and unsettling, following Blacktail, a wolf whose grief and anger lead him on a journey involving ancient powers, the Forest God, and a growing war between the natural world and humanity.
What I liked most is how Hawkins tells the story entirely from animal perspectives. The animals have their own ways of understanding humans, technology, religion, and the world around them, which gives the novel a wonderfully strange atmosphere. There’s also an unusual mix of dark humor and disturbing moments that feels very much in keeping with Hawkins’ style.
The book can occasionally feel deliberately bizarre, and the pacing may not work for everyone. But the ideas about nature, humanity, revenge, and the consequences of destroying the world around us give the story more depth than a simple revenge tale.
Overall, Blacktail is weird, dark, imaginative, and unlike much else I’ve read. It won’t be for everyone, but if you enjoy dark fantasy, folk-horror atmosphere, unusual animal protagonists, it’s definitely worth checking out.
What I liked most is how Hawkins tells the story entirely from animal perspectives. The animals have their own ways of understanding humans, technology, religion, and the world around them, which gives the novel a wonderfully strange atmosphere. There’s also an unusual mix of dark humor and disturbing moments that feels very much in keeping with Hawkins’ style.
The book can occasionally feel deliberately bizarre, and the pacing may not work for everyone. But the ideas about nature, humanity, revenge, and the consequences of destroying the world around us give the story more depth than a simple revenge tale.
Overall, Blacktail is weird, dark, imaginative, and unlike much else I’ve read. It won’t be for everyone, but if you enjoy dark fantasy, folk-horror atmosphere, unusual animal protagonists, it’s definitely worth checking out.
June 14, 2026
4.5
First and foremost thank you to NetGalley and Crown Publishing for the eARC of this novel!
I was ecstatic when I found out that Hawkins had written another book, as I absolutely loved The Library at Mount Char. And let me just say, Blacktail did not disappoint. Another genre blender FTW. This book is just as weird, fantastical, horrific and humorous as TLaMC but on a totally different level. Its blatant and obvious message will be appreciated by many (if you can stomach it).
In this story we follow a wild wolf called Blacktail during his epic, revenge driven journey and it’s pretty much all gas no breaks the entire time. I laughed, I gasped, I teared up…
Just as I was hoping, it’s woven with strange mythical fantasy vibes, set in the real world, with rich atmosphere and hilarious dialogue. The best part is that it’s all told from animal perspective and set in the wild.
This story was engaging from beginning to end and is not your typical dark fantasy book. Its graphic, vividly rendered gore lends the novel a horror like quality that I found to be incredibly effective. This is an unflinching and well executed tale of what would happen if animals decided that they’d had enough of us humans and our narcissistic claim on all the animals, lands and resources. I appreciated how unflinching and deliberate the message was. There were even a few parts of this that had me clutching my pearls and momentarily wanting to defend a few of the humans. It’s freakin brutal.
Honestly the only part that didn’t fully resonate with me was the ending. It felt a little rushed and didn’t quite bring everything together the way I expected but overall I absolutely loved this reading experience.
There’s so much more to unpack and take away but man this was good. The writing is beautiful. Animal loving horror fans need to read this.
Thank you Scott Hawkins for delivering another wild and unpredictable novel. Please don’t make us wait another 10 years again though?
First and foremost thank you to NetGalley and Crown Publishing for the eARC of this novel!
I was ecstatic when I found out that Hawkins had written another book, as I absolutely loved The Library at Mount Char. And let me just say, Blacktail did not disappoint. Another genre blender FTW. This book is just as weird, fantastical, horrific and humorous as TLaMC but on a totally different level. Its blatant and obvious message will be appreciated by many (if you can stomach it).
In this story we follow a wild wolf called Blacktail during his epic, revenge driven journey and it’s pretty much all gas no breaks the entire time. I laughed, I gasped, I teared up…
Just as I was hoping, it’s woven with strange mythical fantasy vibes, set in the real world, with rich atmosphere and hilarious dialogue. The best part is that it’s all told from animal perspective and set in the wild.
This story was engaging from beginning to end and is not your typical dark fantasy book. Its graphic, vividly rendered gore lends the novel a horror like quality that I found to be incredibly effective. This is an unflinching and well executed tale of what would happen if animals decided that they’d had enough of us humans and our narcissistic claim on all the animals, lands and resources. I appreciated how unflinching and deliberate the message was. There were even a few parts of this that had me clutching my pearls and momentarily wanting to defend a few of the humans. It’s freakin brutal.
Honestly the only part that didn’t fully resonate with me was the ending. It felt a little rushed and didn’t quite bring everything together the way I expected but overall I absolutely loved this reading experience.
There’s so much more to unpack and take away but man this was good. The writing is beautiful. Animal loving horror fans need to read this.
Thank you Scott Hawkins for delivering another wild and unpredictable novel. Please don’t make us wait another 10 years again though?
September 6, 2026
3.5 stars
As a Warrior Cats fan, Blacktail, in some ways, felt very familiar. I would be surprised if Hawkins hasn’t read that series, because the similarities are often striking. That said, this book is undoubtedly much darker and more violent than the beloved children’s series. It follows a half-wolf (and perhaps demigod?) named Blacktail who develops mystical powers and a cult following after he kills a family of humans responsible for the death of his mate.
I found myself intrigued throughout this book; it has a lot of wacky humorous moments, hallucinatory magic, and gruesome acts of violence. Hawkins raises questions of nature, the human/non-human divide, vengeance, and morality. But at the same time, I’m not sure I walked away from this book with much of . . . anything. No strong emotions toward the characters, no lingering interest in the plot, no clear message or moral takeaway, no ruminations on its murky themes. Perhaps I would feel differently if I didn’t already have significant exposure to the world of literary animal studies.
I recommend this book for those looking for a unique tale, with a strong warning for violence involving both human and nonhuman animals.
September 14, 2026
This review literally explains how I feel but better than I could ever write it: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
This is one of the most imaginative books I have ever read while also being one of the most thematically confusing. I understand that the POVs are through the eyes of animals, but unless things have changed without my knowledge, animals can’t read, and that’s where this book loses me. Since humans are going to be the ones reading this book, I have to assume the messaging is ultimately meant for them. But what, exactly, was the message?
That animals are just as bad as humans? That spaying and neutering is evil and having multiple children is the way to go? That a blood-borne pathogen and lack of “purity” will lead to the demise of humanity? That serial killers who kill with a knife are worthy of becoming elevated beings, but a woman who rescues animals deserves to be mauled? That reason, logic, and science need to be wiped off the face of the Earth?
I am genuinely at a loss as to what the author was trying to convey to the humans reading this book. When I finished Tender Is the Flesh, I felt sick at how humans use and abuse animals. I finished this book feeling like, “They’re just like us, and not in a good way.”
Blacktail’s introduction comes on the heels of the death of his mother and littermates, and while he does make a name for himself, he is also incredibly lonely. Enter Renren, a dog who lives outside her owner’s house without any shelter and is constantly chained. I genuinely thought this section was lovely and incredibly well written. I felt that punch to the gut and genuine sadness as the inciting moment occurs, and I could understand Blacktail’s grief and rage. And then he does what any egotistical man would do: he makes it about himself and does something diametrically opposed to how Renren behaved. The book even states “ ‘What they did to me was a sin against the hunt. It was an abomination.’ “ Not what they did to her, nope me. Using sin in a book about animals was also when my red flag system turned on.
This was when a book I thought would be five stars immediately dropped to four. And then kept dropping the further along I read.
The book anthropomorphizes its animals so heavily and then tells us, essentially, that we can’t view their actions through a human lens because they’re still animals. Pick a lane. Viewed purely as an animal, Blacktail’s actions make sense. Viewed through the lens in which these animals believe in marriage and refer to themselves as husband and wife, those same actions become deplorable. You can’t have it both ways.
Even with those misgivings, I was still on board and enjoying the story, and THAT scene was truly fantastic. Then the truly impactful novella ended, and it seemed the author decided they wanted a full-length book instead and downhill the book went for me.
As the story shifts from Blacktail’s POV to that of the creatures he encounters on his quest to awaken the Forest God, it becomes increasingly religious. What I had initially brushed off as “animal POV,” despite feeling uncomfortable with it, becomes much harder to ignore when yet more commentary about the evils of spaying and neutering is introduced. Again, who is the messaging in this book for if not the humans reading it? And what message are we supposed to take from it? The ending then seems to prove the humans right anyway. So, what was the point?
We have an entire chapter where Blacktail is shown that humans can love animals enough to risk their own lives for them, and then it is followed by a chapter in which an innocent couple is mauled to death. Transparently, I still loved the whole scene. But it left me wondering what the point of the previous chapter was. If we flip the narrative, then humans killing animals “just because” isn’t necessarily a big deal, because apparently it isn’t a big deal when animals do it either. It’s just survival of the fittest, right?
I also can’t say the religious overtones did much to quell my feelings. Blacktail being conceived through some sort of immaculate conception was not on my bingo card, but I guess it should have been considering he is constantly referred to as Lord. Once we move past his POV, the story is essentially him roaming from place to place gathering disciples and healing animals, at one point even giving a chihuahua his balls back. Oh, and he can’t forget the matchmaking. Apparently, healing an animal isn’t enough of a thank-you to a devout believer; Black Tail also needs to find him a mate.
“‘Oh, and I almost forgot. Last night I heard a female calling to me from just over the mountain. You see that one, there, just south of the sun? She’s in much the same hell as you were, though not quite so deep. Not yet, anyway.’
Chester thought on this for a moment.
‘Calling to you … as I once called?’
‘O Lord, receive me in my penitence….’
‘Yes. The same. Can you help her? I’d do it myself, but I think I’ve little time left. She might make a mate for you, Chester. In time you might even start a pack.’”
I guess females of every species will always be seen as less than and as property. It’s also interesting that despite same-sex relationships being well documented in the animal world, not a single one is represented in this book. Considering how heavily the author anthropomorphizes the animals by giving them concepts like marriage, religion, morality, monogamy, and social hierarchies, the absence is glaring. If the goal was truly to portray animals as they are, why selectively reproduce human social conventions while leaving out a behavior that exists across so many animal species? But it sure does love to present straight husband and wife relationships. It further adds to my feeling that the book isn’t really interested in exploring animal behavior so much as using animals to selectively reinforce a particular view of humanity.
Another religious overtone I noticed is that, even in this fantasy world, suicide is treated as a sin because it goes against the Forest God’s directives. The argument that all of this is meant to show the absurdity of religion doesn’t satisfy me because there is no foil, no contrast to any of the beliefs and actions carried out by this religion. There is no interrogation after each vignette closes. No alternative worldview presented to challenge it. When there is nothing else to compare it to, absurdity becomes the norm. Whether intentional or not, these patterns are present in the text, and the book doesn't give me enough evidence to interpret them as satire rather than as part of its actual worldview.
If you’re looking for a book where animals rise to the top of the food chain and treat humans the way humans treated them, this will probably be for you. The body horror is excellent, and I do love a good revenge plot.
Unfortunately for me, I couldn’t help but notice everything else.
But hey, at least the “right” god was in charge.
This is one of the most imaginative books I have ever read while also being one of the most thematically confusing. I understand that the POVs are through the eyes of animals, but unless things have changed without my knowledge, animals can’t read, and that’s where this book loses me. Since humans are going to be the ones reading this book, I have to assume the messaging is ultimately meant for them. But what, exactly, was the message?
That animals are just as bad as humans? That spaying and neutering is evil and having multiple children is the way to go? That a blood-borne pathogen and lack of “purity” will lead to the demise of humanity? That serial killers who kill with a knife are worthy of becoming elevated beings, but a woman who rescues animals deserves to be mauled? That reason, logic, and science need to be wiped off the face of the Earth?
I am genuinely at a loss as to what the author was trying to convey to the humans reading this book. When I finished Tender Is the Flesh, I felt sick at how humans use and abuse animals. I finished this book feeling like, “They’re just like us, and not in a good way.”
Blacktail’s introduction comes on the heels of the death of his mother and littermates, and while he does make a name for himself, he is also incredibly lonely. Enter Renren, a dog who lives outside her owner’s house without any shelter and is constantly chained. I genuinely thought this section was lovely and incredibly well written. I felt that punch to the gut and genuine sadness as the inciting moment occurs, and I could understand Blacktail’s grief and rage. And then he does what any egotistical man would do: he makes it about himself and does something diametrically opposed to how Renren behaved. The book even states “ ‘What they did to me was a sin against the hunt. It was an abomination.’ “ Not what they did to her, nope me. Using sin in a book about animals was also when my red flag system turned on.
This was when a book I thought would be five stars immediately dropped to four. And then kept dropping the further along I read.
The book anthropomorphizes its animals so heavily and then tells us, essentially, that we can’t view their actions through a human lens because they’re still animals. Pick a lane. Viewed purely as an animal, Blacktail’s actions make sense. Viewed through the lens in which these animals believe in marriage and refer to themselves as husband and wife, those same actions become deplorable. You can’t have it both ways.
Even with those misgivings, I was still on board and enjoying the story, and THAT scene was truly fantastic. Then the truly impactful novella ended, and it seemed the author decided they wanted a full-length book instead and downhill the book went for me.
As the story shifts from Blacktail’s POV to that of the creatures he encounters on his quest to awaken the Forest God, it becomes increasingly religious. What I had initially brushed off as “animal POV,” despite feeling uncomfortable with it, becomes much harder to ignore when yet more commentary about the evils of spaying and neutering is introduced. Again, who is the messaging in this book for if not the humans reading it? And what message are we supposed to take from it? The ending then seems to prove the humans right anyway. So, what was the point?
We have an entire chapter where Blacktail is shown that humans can love animals enough to risk their own lives for them, and then it is followed by a chapter in which an innocent couple is mauled to death. Transparently, I still loved the whole scene. But it left me wondering what the point of the previous chapter was. If we flip the narrative, then humans killing animals “just because” isn’t necessarily a big deal, because apparently it isn’t a big deal when animals do it either. It’s just survival of the fittest, right?
I also can’t say the religious overtones did much to quell my feelings. Blacktail being conceived through some sort of immaculate conception was not on my bingo card, but I guess it should have been considering he is constantly referred to as Lord. Once we move past his POV, the story is essentially him roaming from place to place gathering disciples and healing animals, at one point even giving a chihuahua his balls back. Oh, and he can’t forget the matchmaking. Apparently, healing an animal isn’t enough of a thank-you to a devout believer; Black Tail also needs to find him a mate.
“‘Oh, and I almost forgot. Last night I heard a female calling to me from just over the mountain. You see that one, there, just south of the sun? She’s in much the same hell as you were, though not quite so deep. Not yet, anyway.’
Chester thought on this for a moment.
‘Calling to you … as I once called?’
‘O Lord, receive me in my penitence….’
‘Yes. The same. Can you help her? I’d do it myself, but I think I’ve little time left. She might make a mate for you, Chester. In time you might even start a pack.’”
I guess females of every species will always be seen as less than and as property. It’s also interesting that despite same-sex relationships being well documented in the animal world, not a single one is represented in this book. Considering how heavily the author anthropomorphizes the animals by giving them concepts like marriage, religion, morality, monogamy, and social hierarchies, the absence is glaring. If the goal was truly to portray animals as they are, why selectively reproduce human social conventions while leaving out a behavior that exists across so many animal species? But it sure does love to present straight husband and wife relationships. It further adds to my feeling that the book isn’t really interested in exploring animal behavior so much as using animals to selectively reinforce a particular view of humanity.
Another religious overtone I noticed is that, even in this fantasy world, suicide is treated as a sin because it goes against the Forest God’s directives. The argument that all of this is meant to show the absurdity of religion doesn’t satisfy me because there is no foil, no contrast to any of the beliefs and actions carried out by this religion. There is no interrogation after each vignette closes. No alternative worldview presented to challenge it. When there is nothing else to compare it to, absurdity becomes the norm. Whether intentional or not, these patterns are present in the text, and the book doesn't give me enough evidence to interpret them as satire rather than as part of its actual worldview.
If you’re looking for a book where animals rise to the top of the food chain and treat humans the way humans treated them, this will probably be for you. The body horror is excellent, and I do love a good revenge plot.
Unfortunately for me, I couldn’t help but notice everything else.
But hey, at least the “right” god was in charge.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 12, 2026
You know when you’re in one of those lucid dreams that you are too invested in, and want to know where it leads but you don’t want it to end?.
Then when you wake up, something in you have changed?
This book was that. it is one of the most beautiful books I’ve ever read and this will stick with me for so so long 😭 😭
Maybe until the old lords of the forest awaken, the guardians of the temples come down and the lands breath again with the old names and the whispers of magic turn to full chanting ❤️.
Maybe until Fenrir breaks his chains, and the wolves swallow the sun and the moon. and The long winter begins.
Then when you wake up, something in you have changed?
This book was that. it is one of the most beautiful books I’ve ever read and this will stick with me for so so long 😭 😭
Maybe until the old lords of the forest awaken, the guardians of the temples come down and the lands breath again with the old names and the whispers of magic turn to full chanting ❤️.
Maybe until Fenrir breaks his chains, and the wolves swallow the sun and the moon. and The long winter begins.
Read
September 8, 2026Who’s a Good Boy, A Theological Inquiry
BWAF SINISTER SELECTION
TL;DR: Blacktail is Watership Down with the mercy cut out and the teeth left in. Hawkins gives the animals a language, a grievance, and a theology, then lets them write scripture in blood and urine. It is funny the way the Old Testament is funny and merciless the same way. Amongst the best horror novels of the year, and the strangest.
The wolves in this book compose verse in urine and the verse is good. A lynx named Hate reads one such poem on the boundary of a wolf’s country in the first pages and sneers at it, because a lynx marks his ground with something like Mine, leave or die, and wolves have to make a production of everything, and by the end of the prologue there is a new mark on a rock in the lynx’s own valley and the lynx is not the one who wrote it. That is the whole method of Blacktail in small. Scott Hawkins gives the beasts a language, the language of the hunt, the one true tongue known to every creature that has ever eaten or been eaten, and then he lets them use it the way beasts would, and the reader who came for a talking animal story finds he has been handed a scripture.
The wolf of the title is a halfwolf, last of his line on a nameless northern hill, his mother shot by hunters who took nothing from her body and left it to rot. Two years on, following a scent across the black road where the squirrels keep a death cult in honor of Car and their flattened dead line the shoulder, he comes to a black dog on a chain in a yard. Her owners put her in Car and take her to the den of pokes-with-metal-sticks and she comes home hollowed, and the book’s word for it is abomination, a sin against the hunt. What Blacktail does in the house after that is the premise on the jacket. What the book does with it is the reason the book exists. An ancient house cat, first among witches and long in traffic with hell, hears the thunder of his footfalls in the den of man’s pleasure and sends him south to find the Forest God, who has slept since before men gave their worship to a god of reason.
Hawkins writes plain. His sentences are short and unlovely and mostly true and he does not reach for the lyric when a beast can say the thing in six words. The beauty is in the vocabulary of the beasts, the book’s great invention: Car, House, gunshots, food-rocks, the metal birds, the waters-of-madness, the magic acorns that bring sleep. A highway seen through a wolf’s eye becomes a river of light that must be forded like water. A leash becomes a circle of stony gray earth traced in a yard, and beyond that circle all the world. Ordinary human objects arrive as atrocities. The author never says so. The reader has been made to stand where the animal stands and look up at them. It is the oldest trick of the beast fable, and Hawkins, who nods to Adams outright by way of a rabbit god’s name, takes it where it always belonged, which is horror.
And it is funny. The fact wants stating, because a book this pitiless has no goddamned business being funny and this one is, in the gap between the gravity of its subject and the fact that its prophets bear names like Snooky-Ookums and Miss Prissy Pants. The witch disciplines her cougar bodyguards with a spell called the Farts of the Dragon. A fox named Trap-Slipper waves his hindquarters at a truckload of bloodhounds and shouts insults about their mothers. None of this is relief from the horror. It is the horror’s other face. The rabbit dying under the lynx’s claw in the prologue makes a joke at his killer’s expense and then asks whether this is all there is, and the lynx says yes, it is hard, and snaps his neck. The book holds both registers in one paw and puts neither down.
When the dread comes it comes two ways. The first is the supernatural, and there is a sequence early on in which two bloodhounds are hauled across the threshold by a master who sees only blood and see what he cannot, a small annex of hell built from a charm of binding wound together with one of pain and one of forgetfulness, and a house cat on the windowsill licking his paw and explaining the workmanship. That scene is the coldest thing in the book and the cold comes from the cat’s courtesy. The second kind of dread is the plain kind, and it is worse. A dog driven out to a desert by the woman who fed him from her hand, certain for days that she would come back for him, learning that hell is hunger and then that hell is also burning and then that hell is also laughter. A hiker on a mesa telling the wolf that stalks her that he is a good boy, a nice doggie. Hawkins never escalates these. He sets them down the way he sets down rabbit dung on a trail and moves on.
Blacktail himself stays opaque even in his own chapters, a hunter who lost his taste for language early and is taken for thickheaded by everyone including himself, his eyes in the book’s own figure the flat surface of a lake beneath which much moves and is not seen. The book is built as a series of stations, a prologue and nine chapters with names like Dominion and Mercy and The Fire of God, each a fable complete in itself, and in the best of them the hunter is seen through the eyes of something that fears him or needs him or both. The pace is that of a walk south through a shrinking world, unhurried in the mountains and quick as a bite in the houses of men, and it does not sag. The one chapter that argues against the book, in which a fat beagle with a stump for a tail and a priest who is a terrier stand between the wolf and a woman who feeds the whole forest from her porch, is the best chapter in it, because Hawkins lets the beagle make his case in full and gives it weight. A lesser book would have cut that chapter. A lesser book would have needed its wolf to be correct.
Under all of it is the argument the witch makes to the wolf on a moonless night in the foothills, that the hunt is not a creature or a place but the thing that happens whenever one creature touches another, the feeding and the stomping both, and the argument a lesser cat makes to a severed head, that the hunt is eternal and can afford to be patient. The book takes this seriously as theology. It has a demon’s bargain and a crow who damned himself for his people and a god of lost things who comes to a lost child from under the bed, and it never winks. More than once the scale pulls back to eternity, to the sun gone dim and the last stars fading and a severed head still insisting that she was just a dog, and a chapter away a chipmunk is regarding a blueberry.
Scott Hawkins published The Library at Mount Char in 2015 and did not publish another novel for eleven years. That first book, about a girl and a handful of other orphans raised in a library by a man called Father and set each to a catalog, was called wholly original and resistant to categorization. The acknowledgments of Blacktail thank a houseful of dogs by name, the short-termers included, and the book’s tenderness toward starvelings makes more sense for it. But the telling detail is from an interview given not long after Mount Char, in which Hawkins described an earlier unpublished novel told entirely from the point of view of dogs and wolves. It was not quite hysterical animal rights propaganda, he said, but you could see the hysterical animal rights propaganda camp from there. Blacktail is that book come back with the propaganda burned out of it. It does not plead for the beasts. It gives them teeth and a god and lets them decide.
The grit in the meat is that the animals’ slang now and then runs a size too modern for the mouths that carry it, a sammich here, a my bad there, and that the last movement covers ground at a speed the earlier chapters did not train the reader for. These are small, the kind of thing found on a third reading, after the first two have gone by in a sitting each.
What stays is the mark the wolf leaves on the house before the snow starts, three lines that are the most frightening prayer in recent fiction, not quoted here because they should be come upon in their place. What stays is a rabbit under a claw asking if there is nothing more, and the answer he gets. What stays is the mark on the rock at the end of the prologue, written by something that was supposed to be a puppy. This is wolf land. None other may hunt here.
BWAF SINISTER SELECTION
TL;DR: Blacktail is Watership Down with the mercy cut out and the teeth left in. Hawkins gives the animals a language, a grievance, and a theology, then lets them write scripture in blood and urine. It is funny the way the Old Testament is funny and merciless the same way. Amongst the best horror novels of the year, and the strangest.
The wolves in this book compose verse in urine and the verse is good. A lynx named Hate reads one such poem on the boundary of a wolf’s country in the first pages and sneers at it, because a lynx marks his ground with something like Mine, leave or die, and wolves have to make a production of everything, and by the end of the prologue there is a new mark on a rock in the lynx’s own valley and the lynx is not the one who wrote it. That is the whole method of Blacktail in small. Scott Hawkins gives the beasts a language, the language of the hunt, the one true tongue known to every creature that has ever eaten or been eaten, and then he lets them use it the way beasts would, and the reader who came for a talking animal story finds he has been handed a scripture.
The wolf of the title is a halfwolf, last of his line on a nameless northern hill, his mother shot by hunters who took nothing from her body and left it to rot. Two years on, following a scent across the black road where the squirrels keep a death cult in honor of Car and their flattened dead line the shoulder, he comes to a black dog on a chain in a yard. Her owners put her in Car and take her to the den of pokes-with-metal-sticks and she comes home hollowed, and the book’s word for it is abomination, a sin against the hunt. What Blacktail does in the house after that is the premise on the jacket. What the book does with it is the reason the book exists. An ancient house cat, first among witches and long in traffic with hell, hears the thunder of his footfalls in the den of man’s pleasure and sends him south to find the Forest God, who has slept since before men gave their worship to a god of reason.
Hawkins writes plain. His sentences are short and unlovely and mostly true and he does not reach for the lyric when a beast can say the thing in six words. The beauty is in the vocabulary of the beasts, the book’s great invention: Car, House, gunshots, food-rocks, the metal birds, the waters-of-madness, the magic acorns that bring sleep. A highway seen through a wolf’s eye becomes a river of light that must be forded like water. A leash becomes a circle of stony gray earth traced in a yard, and beyond that circle all the world. Ordinary human objects arrive as atrocities. The author never says so. The reader has been made to stand where the animal stands and look up at them. It is the oldest trick of the beast fable, and Hawkins, who nods to Adams outright by way of a rabbit god’s name, takes it where it always belonged, which is horror.
And it is funny. The fact wants stating, because a book this pitiless has no goddamned business being funny and this one is, in the gap between the gravity of its subject and the fact that its prophets bear names like Snooky-Ookums and Miss Prissy Pants. The witch disciplines her cougar bodyguards with a spell called the Farts of the Dragon. A fox named Trap-Slipper waves his hindquarters at a truckload of bloodhounds and shouts insults about their mothers. None of this is relief from the horror. It is the horror’s other face. The rabbit dying under the lynx’s claw in the prologue makes a joke at his killer’s expense and then asks whether this is all there is, and the lynx says yes, it is hard, and snaps his neck. The book holds both registers in one paw and puts neither down.
When the dread comes it comes two ways. The first is the supernatural, and there is a sequence early on in which two bloodhounds are hauled across the threshold by a master who sees only blood and see what he cannot, a small annex of hell built from a charm of binding wound together with one of pain and one of forgetfulness, and a house cat on the windowsill licking his paw and explaining the workmanship. That scene is the coldest thing in the book and the cold comes from the cat’s courtesy. The second kind of dread is the plain kind, and it is worse. A dog driven out to a desert by the woman who fed him from her hand, certain for days that she would come back for him, learning that hell is hunger and then that hell is also burning and then that hell is also laughter. A hiker on a mesa telling the wolf that stalks her that he is a good boy, a nice doggie. Hawkins never escalates these. He sets them down the way he sets down rabbit dung on a trail and moves on.
Blacktail himself stays opaque even in his own chapters, a hunter who lost his taste for language early and is taken for thickheaded by everyone including himself, his eyes in the book’s own figure the flat surface of a lake beneath which much moves and is not seen. The book is built as a series of stations, a prologue and nine chapters with names like Dominion and Mercy and The Fire of God, each a fable complete in itself, and in the best of them the hunter is seen through the eyes of something that fears him or needs him or both. The pace is that of a walk south through a shrinking world, unhurried in the mountains and quick as a bite in the houses of men, and it does not sag. The one chapter that argues against the book, in which a fat beagle with a stump for a tail and a priest who is a terrier stand between the wolf and a woman who feeds the whole forest from her porch, is the best chapter in it, because Hawkins lets the beagle make his case in full and gives it weight. A lesser book would have cut that chapter. A lesser book would have needed its wolf to be correct.
Under all of it is the argument the witch makes to the wolf on a moonless night in the foothills, that the hunt is not a creature or a place but the thing that happens whenever one creature touches another, the feeding and the stomping both, and the argument a lesser cat makes to a severed head, that the hunt is eternal and can afford to be patient. The book takes this seriously as theology. It has a demon’s bargain and a crow who damned himself for his people and a god of lost things who comes to a lost child from under the bed, and it never winks. More than once the scale pulls back to eternity, to the sun gone dim and the last stars fading and a severed head still insisting that she was just a dog, and a chapter away a chipmunk is regarding a blueberry.
Scott Hawkins published The Library at Mount Char in 2015 and did not publish another novel for eleven years. That first book, about a girl and a handful of other orphans raised in a library by a man called Father and set each to a catalog, was called wholly original and resistant to categorization. The acknowledgments of Blacktail thank a houseful of dogs by name, the short-termers included, and the book’s tenderness toward starvelings makes more sense for it. But the telling detail is from an interview given not long after Mount Char, in which Hawkins described an earlier unpublished novel told entirely from the point of view of dogs and wolves. It was not quite hysterical animal rights propaganda, he said, but you could see the hysterical animal rights propaganda camp from there. Blacktail is that book come back with the propaganda burned out of it. It does not plead for the beasts. It gives them teeth and a god and lets them decide.
The grit in the meat is that the animals’ slang now and then runs a size too modern for the mouths that carry it, a sammich here, a my bad there, and that the last movement covers ground at a speed the earlier chapters did not train the reader for. These are small, the kind of thing found on a third reading, after the first two have gone by in a sitting each.
What stays is the mark the wolf leaves on the house before the snow starts, three lines that are the most frightening prayer in recent fiction, not quoted here because they should be come upon in their place. What stays is a rabbit under a claw asking if there is nothing more, and the answer he gets. What stays is the mark on the rock at the end of the prologue, written by something that was supposed to be a puppy. This is wolf land. None other may hunt here.
July 21, 2026
makes me want to reread warrior cats
September 16, 2026
4.25/5
Format: Paperback ARC
Spoilers: None
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for sharing an ARC with me!
The Library at Mount Char was a surprise favorite for me earlier this year in my book club, so I was incredibly excited for Blacktail. This tells the story of our eponymous half breed wolf who is left alone in this world after the death of both his parents at the hands of humans. After experiencing yet another great loss, he is called upon to seek the Forest God to try to reclaim nature from man, taking us on a wild dark fantasy trip told from the perspective of animals.
Much like Mount Char, you can expect some fantastically fun weirdness. We have the animals musings on and interpretation of men and their machines. We have a squirrel death cult, and a coven of witch cats led by the Old Kitty Mother. Blacktail will often encounter animals who have a message for him, and introduce themselves by names like "Mr. Snooky Ookums," and then lay down some heavy lore on them. There is definitely a heavy side of whimsy to this one.
This stands in stark contrast to the violent nature of Blacktail, and his interactions with mankind. We get vivid descriptions of the steps he takes in his crusade against mankind, and rage a violence is always teetering on the edge of our whimsical moments. I can honestly say this is one of the most unique books I've read - I can't remember reading anything like it.
I loved some of the themes in this one. Most explored is th nature of man's impact on nature, and the inevitable outcomes of what happens to the natural world when ecosystems are out of balance (whether by man or animal). We also explore rage, loss, and death throughout the book along with the natural themes discussed.
In terms of downsides, I do think there is a bit of a slow start, and I will say that, in agreement with some other reviews I have seen, there are some repetitive actions and descriptions in here that don't serve much of a purpose over time (including frequent references to animal urination). While it is all part of painting the picture of what the creatures are doing, it does get a bit too much in certain spots. However, once this book hits its groove, the story is a slow burn escalation that keeps you turning pages.
If you loved the library at Mount Char, then this is definitely worth a try. if you like weird dark fantasy with a side of whimsy, then I think this might be perfect for you. And if you are willing to go along for one of the most unique rides I've taken with a book in awhile, I think you will be greatly rewarded.
Format: Paperback ARC
Spoilers: None
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for sharing an ARC with me!
The Library at Mount Char was a surprise favorite for me earlier this year in my book club, so I was incredibly excited for Blacktail. This tells the story of our eponymous half breed wolf who is left alone in this world after the death of both his parents at the hands of humans. After experiencing yet another great loss, he is called upon to seek the Forest God to try to reclaim nature from man, taking us on a wild dark fantasy trip told from the perspective of animals.
Much like Mount Char, you can expect some fantastically fun weirdness. We have the animals musings on and interpretation of men and their machines. We have a squirrel death cult, and a coven of witch cats led by the Old Kitty Mother. Blacktail will often encounter animals who have a message for him, and introduce themselves by names like "Mr. Snooky Ookums," and then lay down some heavy lore on them. There is definitely a heavy side of whimsy to this one.
This stands in stark contrast to the violent nature of Blacktail, and his interactions with mankind. We get vivid descriptions of the steps he takes in his crusade against mankind, and rage a violence is always teetering on the edge of our whimsical moments. I can honestly say this is one of the most unique books I've read - I can't remember reading anything like it.
I loved some of the themes in this one. Most explored is th nature of man's impact on nature, and the inevitable outcomes of what happens to the natural world when ecosystems are out of balance (whether by man or animal). We also explore rage, loss, and death throughout the book along with the natural themes discussed.
In terms of downsides, I do think there is a bit of a slow start, and I will say that, in agreement with some other reviews I have seen, there are some repetitive actions and descriptions in here that don't serve much of a purpose over time (including frequent references to animal urination). While it is all part of painting the picture of what the creatures are doing, it does get a bit too much in certain spots. However, once this book hits its groove, the story is a slow burn escalation that keeps you turning pages.
If you loved the library at Mount Char, then this is definitely worth a try. if you like weird dark fantasy with a side of whimsy, then I think this might be perfect for you. And if you are willing to go along for one of the most unique rides I've taken with a book in awhile, I think you will be greatly rewarded.
September 3, 2026
A.R.C. Read
I can say it's highly creative
Animal suffering!
Trigger Warnings:
I really thought I'd love this book but I could not get into it and stay into it because I was constantly pushed out of the emotional devastation by all of the urine -poetry and otherwise- feces, fart jokes, and random outburst about sex. The religious zealotry and casual violence felt right at home in the narrative but the rest just made me repeatedly put the book down and think "why tf is that in there? what did that add to the scene/characters?" and I couldn't ever find an answer past 'shock value' I guess?
Things I did enjoy:
* I was engaged with the content of the book. There are lots of things for the reader to figure out or interpret for themselves and I love that. I love knowing there are things I won't have caught and I'll find out when talking to another reader, they can point things out to me and vice versa. Love that.
* I enjoy morally questionable/complicated characters. I really liked the coyote. I don't need heroes, I need compelling characters -that's exactly what I got in this book.
* I liked the way Blacktail was introduced. Going through Hate and Guile's eyes let Blacktail be smart without being arrogant, fierce not overpowered, young not naïve. If those scenes had been done through Blacktail's POV he would have been an insufferable character.
* That cover art. Every time I see it I think "oh what's that?!" Love the wolf, blood, lettering, and use of negative space.
Things that rubbed me wrong through the majority of the book but have a place in the narrative:
* The hypocrisy in both the relationships and society structure:
* The animal relationships are highly anthropomorphized -like having husbands and wives- even though the animals hate everything about the humans and repeatedly reason with themselves that their own violence is good and aligned with The Hunt while the Human's violence is bad and aligned with The Reason... the animals are veeery human-like. The animals exhibit senseless violence repeatedly.
* There's a lot of classism included in the anthropomorphic stuff -like titles of Lord, coven structures, and slaves/the subjugated- and hierarchy that determines if one animal's life must be given up in order to speed along the story of "their betters" a.k.a. predators. Sounds to me like the prey are subjugated to the predators -never to rise up unless, lest they upset their dogma and become like Humans who were "lesser predators" that rose to the top...
Things I flat out didn't enjoy at all:
* Poop and pee galore. So many fart jokes. So much talk of sex between animals. I felt like it was dropped into the middle of an intense scene and if it was meant to be comedic relief or whimsy then it was lost on me. The only thing I experienced was immersion breaking and confusion.
* Sometimes characters sound old-timey and then two paragraphs later they sound very modern.
Overall I don't know how to rate this. It was such a close miss, but definitely a miss for me.
I can say it's highly creative
Animal suffering!
Trigger Warnings:
I really thought I'd love this book but I could not get into it and stay into it because I was constantly pushed out of the emotional devastation by all of the urine -poetry and otherwise- feces, fart jokes, and random outburst about sex. The religious zealotry and casual violence felt right at home in the narrative but the rest just made me repeatedly put the book down and think "why tf is that in there? what did that add to the scene/characters?" and I couldn't ever find an answer past 'shock value' I guess?
Things I did enjoy:
* I was engaged with the content of the book. There are lots of things for the reader to figure out or interpret for themselves and I love that. I love knowing there are things I won't have caught and I'll find out when talking to another reader, they can point things out to me and vice versa. Love that.
* I enjoy morally questionable/complicated characters. I really liked the coyote. I don't need heroes, I need compelling characters -that's exactly what I got in this book.
* I liked the way Blacktail was introduced. Going through Hate and Guile's eyes let Blacktail be smart without being arrogant, fierce not overpowered, young not naïve. If those scenes had been done through Blacktail's POV he would have been an insufferable character.
* That cover art. Every time I see it I think "oh what's that?!" Love the wolf, blood, lettering, and use of negative space.
Things that rubbed me wrong through the majority of the book but have a place in the narrative:
* The hypocrisy in both the relationships and society structure:
* The animal relationships are highly anthropomorphized -like having husbands and wives- even though the animals hate everything about the humans and repeatedly reason with themselves that their own violence is good and aligned with The Hunt while the Human's violence is bad and aligned with The Reason... the animals are veeery human-like. The animals exhibit senseless violence repeatedly.
* There's a lot of classism included in the anthropomorphic stuff -like titles of Lord, coven structures, and slaves/the subjugated- and hierarchy that determines if one animal's life must be given up in order to speed along the story of "their betters" a.k.a. predators. Sounds to me like the prey are subjugated to the predators -never to rise up unless, lest they upset their dogma and become like Humans who were "lesser predators" that rose to the top...
Things I flat out didn't enjoy at all:
* Poop and pee galore. So many fart jokes. So much talk of sex between animals. I felt like it was dropped into the middle of an intense scene and if it was meant to be comedic relief or whimsy then it was lost on me. The only thing I experienced was immersion breaking and confusion.
* Sometimes characters sound old-timey and then two paragraphs later they sound very modern.
Overall I don't know how to rate this. It was such a close miss, but definitely a miss for me.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This review (and many others) plus essays and booklists are now available on my blog!
A lone wolf, Blacktail's life is forever changed when he falls in love with a pet dog who soon dies at her owners' hands. After taking his vengeance and going on the run to escape the humans hunting him, a mysteriously powerful feline witch sends him on a quest to wake the Forest God, whose reawakening will bring the end of humanity and return dominion over the world to the beasts. On his epic journey, Blacktail will face many foes and make many allies, leaving legends in his wake that restore hope to animal-kind.
To be honest, I was not a Warrior Cats kid and I haven't read any of the books, but I have heard a lot about it from friends and I feel like I can say with great confidence that this book is like Warrior Cats for adults in the best way possible. It really is an odyssey—even with the book being fairly short, Blacktail's journey feels expansive and epic in a super compelling way. Strictly speaking, most of the book is just travel and usually I get pretty sick of the kind of episodic storytelling you get in travel narratives where it's just *meet character* *fight scene* *conversation* because there's a lack of cohesion, but Hawkins did a great job making each section feel like narrative beats contributing to Blacktail's character development and not just stepping stones towards the conclusion of the journey.
I read and enjoyed Scott Hawkins' debut, The Library at Mount Char, but I enjoyed Blacktail a lot more and found it to be a more well-constructed story. The Library at Mount Char is so unique that that alone makes it enjoyable, and there is a sense of order to the chaos, but I wouldn't say you emotionally connect with the characters and it is kind of senselessly violent/disturbing. I'm not precious about disturbing subject matter in my books (in fact, I prefer it), but in The Library at Mount Char at times it feels like it's just for shock value. Compare that to Blacktail, where the violence feels so genuine and inherent to the world that it almost isn't disturbing because you have such a strong sense that among the animals this is the accepted way of things. It's the way of the hunt, and in the context of Blacktail's search for the Forest God, it's sacred. I also sympathized a lot more with the characters in Blacktail than the characters in Mount Char. They aren't human, and yet at their core the struggles that they face are familiar: Loss, abandonment, ambition, abuse, imprisonment, alienation, and fear. Hawkins does a good job striking a balance between making the perspectives, thought processes, and beliefs distinct enough that the narrators truly feel like animals, while also tying in emotions and conflicts that parallel human experiences enough for the reader to relate to them. I had kind of mixed feelings about the ending because it didn't really loop back around in the way I might have hoped, but it didn't detract from my overall reading experience so I'm not mad about it.
I was a little torn between giving this four or five stars, but I teared up while reading it and I feel like I'll be thinking about it for a while so I'm happy to round up. Clearly, Scott Hawkins has established himself as a really unique and innovative storyteller, so I look forward to reading whatever he comes up with next!
Thank you to Scott Hawkins and Crown for this ARC in exchange for my full, honest review!
Happy reading!
A lone wolf, Blacktail's life is forever changed when he falls in love with a pet dog who soon dies at her owners' hands. After taking his vengeance and going on the run to escape the humans hunting him, a mysteriously powerful feline witch sends him on a quest to wake the Forest God, whose reawakening will bring the end of humanity and return dominion over the world to the beasts. On his epic journey, Blacktail will face many foes and make many allies, leaving legends in his wake that restore hope to animal-kind.
To be honest, I was not a Warrior Cats kid and I haven't read any of the books, but I have heard a lot about it from friends and I feel like I can say with great confidence that this book is like Warrior Cats for adults in the best way possible. It really is an odyssey—even with the book being fairly short, Blacktail's journey feels expansive and epic in a super compelling way. Strictly speaking, most of the book is just travel and usually I get pretty sick of the kind of episodic storytelling you get in travel narratives where it's just *meet character* *fight scene* *conversation* because there's a lack of cohesion, but Hawkins did a great job making each section feel like narrative beats contributing to Blacktail's character development and not just stepping stones towards the conclusion of the journey.
I read and enjoyed Scott Hawkins' debut, The Library at Mount Char, but I enjoyed Blacktail a lot more and found it to be a more well-constructed story. The Library at Mount Char is so unique that that alone makes it enjoyable, and there is a sense of order to the chaos, but I wouldn't say you emotionally connect with the characters and it is kind of senselessly violent/disturbing. I'm not precious about disturbing subject matter in my books (in fact, I prefer it), but in The Library at Mount Char at times it feels like it's just for shock value. Compare that to Blacktail, where the violence feels so genuine and inherent to the world that it almost isn't disturbing because you have such a strong sense that among the animals this is the accepted way of things. It's the way of the hunt, and in the context of Blacktail's search for the Forest God, it's sacred. I also sympathized a lot more with the characters in Blacktail than the characters in Mount Char. They aren't human, and yet at their core the struggles that they face are familiar: Loss, abandonment, ambition, abuse, imprisonment, alienation, and fear. Hawkins does a good job striking a balance between making the perspectives, thought processes, and beliefs distinct enough that the narrators truly feel like animals, while also tying in emotions and conflicts that parallel human experiences enough for the reader to relate to them. I had kind of mixed feelings about the ending because it didn't really loop back around in the way I might have hoped, but it didn't detract from my overall reading experience so I'm not mad about it.
I was a little torn between giving this four or five stars, but I teared up while reading it and I feel like I'll be thinking about it for a while so I'm happy to round up. Clearly, Scott Hawkins has established himself as a really unique and innovative storyteller, so I look forward to reading whatever he comes up with next!
Thank you to Scott Hawkins and Crown for this ARC in exchange for my full, honest review!
Happy reading!
September 15, 2026
I haven’t been this mesmerized by a fantasy novel since Piranesi, though the two are very different books.
This one draws inevitable comparisons to Watership Down, but it also captures some elements of Erin Hunter’s Warriors series for young readers. Of course, this is far from a kids’ book. It swings between moments of idyllic joy and humor to horrific blood-soaked scenes. It’s a little bit Tolkien and a little bit Gaiman, a little Old Testament and a little pagan magic. But Hawkins has crafted something wholly unique, and it won’t be leaving my head anytime soon.
This one draws inevitable comparisons to Watership Down, but it also captures some elements of Erin Hunter’s Warriors series for young readers. Of course, this is far from a kids’ book. It swings between moments of idyllic joy and humor to horrific blood-soaked scenes. It’s a little bit Tolkien and a little bit Gaiman, a little Old Testament and a little pagan magic. But Hawkins has crafted something wholly unique, and it won’t be leaving my head anytime soon.
September 7, 2026
I was slightly disappointed when I heard Hawkins’ new book was supposedly nothing like his first, The Library at Mount Char, which was such a dizzingly unique reading experience. I got the impression Blacktail was more of a naturalist thriller in the vein of Call of the Wild, but it ended up being exactly like Mount Char, not in content per se, but for its idiosyncratic, unrelenting, satirical, mythic, and apocalyptic qualities; a concoction one can now say is distinctly “Hawkins-esque” because I honestly have not read another author who is writing books like this.
It’s grisly, shocking, and it will change the way you look at your pets forever. Highly Recommended.
It’s grisly, shocking, and it will change the way you look at your pets forever. Highly Recommended.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 479 reviews