In this sweeping, suspenseful journey, a woman discovers she is connected to a murder committed before she was born—and she has the victim’s memories.
Paloma is grieving the loss of her enigmatic mother when she discovers a book in her effects that explores the phenomenon of young children who remember their past lives. Flipping through the pages, she finds that she was one of the children, interviewed about her memories of a man’s brutal murder when she was only four years old. But there’s someone else who is having memories of the same man’s death.
For years, Dante has been reliving the details of a murder that occurred before he was born. When he stumbles upon a reincarnation research team, he reaches out for help but instead meets Paloma, whose memories are eerily similar to his. They quickly realize that their lives—and love stories—are more interwoven than they could have imagined. Now, they must work together to uncover the truth about their last deaths or fall prey to the same violent end that haunts them in life after life.
What ensues is a gripping tale of reincarnation, memory, and fate that spans from the sun-drenched streets of modern Los Angeles to the colonial-era Caribbean Sea. Each remembered life and forgotten history proves pivotal in Paloma and Dante’s search for answers, but only time will tell if they can escape their fate . . . or if their story is destined to end tragically once again.
Wendy Heard is the author of books for adults and teens, including You Can Trust Me and She's Too Pretty To Burn. Wendy lives in Los Angeles, her hometown, and she enjoys haunting local bookstores and spending time with her little rescue dogs. You can hear more from Wendy through her newsletter at www.wendyheard.com.
A very unique take on true love, soul mates, fate, and what was always meant to be, regardless of time, space, or circumstances.
This was such an extraordinary take on past lives, and while I was expecting more of a thriller than a love story, so to speak, it was a good read, if slow at times. Overall, I enjoyed it and how original the whole story was.
*ARC provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
This is one of a growing number of novels that mysteriously start off with an intriguing premise or with interesting characters only to drop into a void of inertia a bit over halfway through. It almost feels as if the author has run out of ideas and is simply marking time until the final section. In addition, Wendy Heard has chosen to add in about six or seven short chapters taking place in the 1600s, which go nowhere and simply muddy the issue of reincarnated souls, needlessly taking away from the main storyline. That unfortunate void appears right on time just after halfway through the book when nothing much of interest happens and the story stalls annoyingly. Not good at all.
I wanted to love this so badly. And that's why I stuck with it when quite frankly it probably should have been a DNF. The premise was SO intriguing at the beginning but I soon realized that this book was suffering from a huge pacing issue. It just dragged and dragged and unfortunately there was never any payoff. I'm bummed because it really had potential, it was a unique concept.
This was an interesting book. There's some suspense and romance and a lot of mystery. I liked the reincarnation element to the book. The characters were interesting, and clean book not smutty.
I received an advanced copy from NetGalley and Bantam publishing in exchange for an honest review. I have never read a book like this, in a good way! It immediately captured my attention. The FMM is intriguing, she’s strange, and she makes you want to know more. This book is about reincarnation if I had give it a blanket statement. It’s about soulmates, mistrust, isolation, family and love. My only gripe is I feel the story had incredible build and ending was rushed. I also think maybe I didn’t want it to end. Some loose ends left that leave us to wonder, but overall, yes to this one! Thank you!
"How the Story Always Ends" was original and fascinating. I don't think I'm giving anything away by saying that it involves reincarnation, and a sort of "Dead Again" situation. I liked that there was no attempt to explain or convince anyone about reincarnation; it was presented as factual within the world of the book because it was clearly happening to the main characters. That's good because a bunch of pages of explanations and then someone saying, "No, I can't believe it!" would have been really boring. I also appreciated that there were not too many past lives, and that each one was vivid, interesting, and easy to keep track of. (So NOT like The Years of Rice and Salt by Kim Stanley Robinson.) I loved the main character Paloma, who owned one chair and a custom-made small bed because she didn't want anyone getting comfortable coming over to her place and insinuating themself into her life. Maybe someone so prickly and spoiled would be hard to get along with in real life, but in the book her point of view made her easy to identify with. In fact I found her adorable. As the book progresses, Paloma begins to think that the reason she doesn't want closeness with anyone in her life is not because of her family or trauma but because of the past lives.
The book was a thriller because Paloma soon discovers that she can remember the past life of someone who was murdered, and the murder was never solved. In addition, an unknown bad actor begins sending threatening letters to Paloma warning her not to keep investigating her past life/lives. Could this person be the murderer? There were plenty of possible suspects who at times seemed friendly and at times sinister, from Paloma's one night stand Laura who turned against her, to the reincarnation researcher Andres, to the calm and seemingly perfect fellow reincarnation subject Dante (also a POV character), to another character who knew the past life people. So that all kept me guessing. This novel was also a love story because it followed the theme of true love bringing people together throughout multiple lifetimes, romantically and otherwise. Love was a powerful force but also kind of everyday, so it didn't seem like the doomed lovers were having it that much better than I ever had it even though they were part of an epic cycle. I thought the romantic parts were genuinely sweet/emotionally realistic/sexy/tragic or whatever they were supposed to be in the moment. And well, of course the novel was speculative fiction too because of the reincarnation. I also want to say that in the book, Paloma and Dante and their past lives take us to a lot of different locations including NYC, LA, some town in Washington State, and a 17th(?) century sailing ship. All of the locations were really sharp and felt true.
Wendy Heard was really good at misdirection and suspense because as soon as we met Dante
I did have some doubts about the ending, it felt a little bit rushed to me. I felt a general inner cry of "Why did it have to go down like that?" But I still closed the cover (okay, there was no cover, it was an ebook) feeling satiated yet thoughtful, and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this book to anyone.
I gratefully received a free ARC of this book from Netgalley via Bantam in exchange for this honest review. I got an ungrammatical email (perhaps written by AI?) from Bantam saying that I was pre-approved for this book because I had read and liked some books by Blake Crouch that were similar to this one. (Yeah, I guess so? I'm kind of thinking Belinda Bauer is a bit similar.) But that was fun because it was just like when you have to write a query letter saying dear so and so, my book is similar to this book you represent--except the shoe is on the other foot now and something nice is happening to me!! I had read another book by Wendy Heard that I really liked called "The Kill Club" so I definitely wanted to read this one. Anyway, I hope Bantam/Ballantine/Dell will pre-approve me for another book someday because this one was great! I'm sorry I criticized your email.
I love all things past lives, reincarnation, magical life moments and deja vu. So when I discovered this on Netgalley the other night I put in an immediate request and - granted!
I desperately wanted to read this the moment I read the synopsis. Who wouldn’t be intrigued with:
“A gripping tale of reincarnation, memory, and fate that spans from the sun-drenched streets of modern Los Angeles to the colonial-era Caribbean Sea. Each remembered life and forgotten history proves pivotal in Paloma and Dante’s search for answers, but only time will tell if they can escape their fate . . . or if their story is destined to end tragically once again.”
It reads as a thrilling murder mystery, and is utterly addictive. Plan to have time to read this as straight through as possible to learn the backstory and fate of both Paloma and Dante, as they unfold the pages of their history together. A third enigmatic character weaves in and out of each of Paloma and Dante’s lives, and you’ll be consistently guessing who it may be and what impact they may have on the conclusion. If you enjoy twisting turns and surprise revelations, this book has them.
I absolutely loved this. A gripping, puzzling novel of loving and losing someone during each lifetime, all while a third presence haunts you along the way. If you enjoyed books such as Addie Larue, Our Infinite Fates, and recently The Everlasting, but also enjoy the thrill of a movie like Final Destination (I’m dating myself here but gosh did I think of that movie so many times as I read this book) then you should surely pick this one up. Due out January 2027, with a recent cover reveal that is gorgeous.
Sending a gracious thank you for the Netgalley approval!
Reincarnation is a hot topic for people — some believe, some don’t. I’ve read many accounts of children that believe they were different people at one time. Depending on the source, believing is sometimes hard to do.
Paloma has nightmares. Horrible nightmares that are so vivid and real. As a child, her father got her a dog to try to keep the nightmares away. As an adult, Paloma struggles. She tends to cut herself off from the world, having one night stands, never spending the night with someone, and a life spent mostly on the road.
When her mother dies, Paloma is given a book about children and reincarnation. On the marked page, Paloma realizes that this part of the novel is about her. At one time her mother took her from Spain to Los Angeles to meet with doctors researching reincarnation and past lives. Paloma has no memory of it, but she wants to know more.
Meanwhile in Hawaii, a young man named Dante has dreams as well. When Paloma reaches out to the doctors at UCLA, the doctor reaches out to Dante to have him come to Los Angeles to see if his and Paloma’s stories line up at all. Their searches lead them to spend time in Los Angeles sharing information and undergoing past-life regression hypnosis. What happens next is almost unbelievable.
So many things to love about this suspense novel. First, the characters are vivid and real. Both Dante and Paloma are described so well, they almost feel like friends. Second, this tale of two lives that are intertwined through time is quite the story. It’s not only suspense in this life, there is suspense in past lives as well. It’s a gripping storyline that carries you from the 17th century through the present time. Tales of love and loss, and the question of whether or not our souls live on when we pass.
I flew through this book. I couldn’t put it down with how engaging it was. I definitely recommend it to those who enjoy twisty, dark stories. This one has some love and sunshine woven through it, still it is dark at times.
I could not put this one down. I literally stayed up way past my bedtime to finish this book. Very Cloud Atlas, Sea of Tranquility- esque. I liked the way it was written with different timelines interspersed throughout the main story. Those little vignettes intrigued me and kept me wanting to learn more about what the heck was going on. Very fun read from start to finish.
Paloma’s mother is dead, so she can’t answer the questions that crop up when a mysterious book about children who remember past lives is uncovered. The most confusing part is that Paloma herself is in the book though she has no memory of it. Contacting the original researcher has Paloma investigating both her life and more than one murder in a mystery spanning multiple lives.
Paloma finds herself feeling lost and alone after her mother dies and leaves her a mysterious book that may be about her. Is the secret her mother had been hiding really true? Did Paloma have dreams of being another person? Is there such a thing as reincarnation or is all this just another way for her mother to have a dramatic ending. As Paloma searches for answers she may have inadvertently awoken a murderer who will do anything to silence her. Such an interesting premise that gets lost in the first 2/3 of the book and picks it back up at the end in a very shocking and satisfying ending. The beginning 2/3 seems to have either glossed over things too quickly, or struggled to find it's shape, choosing to focus more on the sexual parts of the love story instead of the heart of it all. This is an easy read so if you love stories about reincarnation then this would be a good one for you.
Wow! My first book by Wendy but definitely not my last!! A very different take on soul-mates !! I really thought I knew where this book was going but the twist towards the end had me gagged!! I didn’t know what was gonna happen. If I had to describe this book I’d say at its core it’s about grief and loneliness. Paloma our fmc is kinda black cat coded? Definitely a little darker!
I read 50% of this book in one sitting and next half in another. The ending to me wasn’t rushed; but not what I expected but I think that was the point!
This one has such an interesting premise and the beginning of the book started off amazing!! I was immediately hooked, but unfortunately this one just didn’t really hold my interest. About midway it lost me and the more I read on the less interested I was.
I think a part of it for me is that I thought this one would be a suspenseful thriller and it wasn't really. I think I ended up not being quite the right audience for this story.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing a free ebook copy in exchange for an honest review. This book is expected to be released January 5, 2027.
Well written, absorbing and original. It explores love in all forms, reincarnation, mysterious deaths and healing from damage. Two people, one a damaged heroine, my favorite type when they are resilent and in her case a talented musician, come together when they both share memories of a man that was murdered 20 yrs ago. They investigated and find other lives that connnect them over the generations. Loved it
I totally fell in love with this book. I was intrigued by the synopsis and captivated by the characters and plot. A story about reincarnation, but murdery? Count me in!
The MC, Paloma, is a bit rough around the edges, and that's exactly what drew me to her. She comes from a broken home, growing up with her mother who put herself before raising her child. Paloma became almost traumatically comfortable on her own. That said, she has confidence and a sense of humor, which makes it easy enough to find company when she so desires. I adored the supporting characters, both past and present.
The plot moves quickly keeping you invested, wanting to know more. I was so immersed in the story that I didn't expect the twist. The ending is founded in fate versus choice and it was satisfying. I am curious about one aspect, though there may not be an answer.
Suffice to say I will be recommending How the Story Always Ends to anyone who will listen to me. I'm also looking forward to discussing it once its published (JANUARY 5, 2027) and others have had the opportunity to read it. I think this would be a great book club book or buddy read, because there is so much to discuss, from who done it, to fate, curses, memory, and the ending of the story.
I had high hopes for this book as the plot description held great anticipation. Unfortunately, this book fell way short for me. The author’s presentation of the story and characters just did not resonate with me. It seemed to plod a great deal. Others seem to enjoy the book so I will leave it you to decide if it is worth a read.
I received a free Kindle copy of this book courtesy of publisher with the understanding that I would post a review on Goodreads, Net Galley, Amazon and my nonfiction book review blog.
This is a story about not just reincarnation but remembering those past lives. I believe in both fate and soul mates and was so happy to see this book at this point of my life.
Paloma's mother took her from Spain to UCLA to research what the 3 year old was talking about. She was talking about things she should have known nothing about,
I found the book fascinating. I devoured it. And I hope against hope that she (and I) are right. Maybe someday I'll have the nerve to be regressed.
Thank you Net Galley for the invite to read this. Paloma's mom has passed away and left her a mysterious book. Paloma is curious and skeptical as it deals with children remembering past lives. She learns she was one of the children and meets up with one of the researchers, Andres, in hopes of getting her questions answered. Here she meets Dante, who also experienced what Paloma did regarding past lives. As they investigate their connection to Ethan and Charlotte, more memoires start to reappear connecting and tying them together in several lives. An intense bond/love between them forms again; however, it seems each time they meet, it results with the same tragic ending: death. As they try to stop it happening again, they are faced with new information, making them wonder who they were and who they can trust. This was a compelling and engaging read. I thought the story was the perfect blend of mystery and romance as it kept me on my toes while also tugged at my heartstrings each time they met a tragic fate. I love the idea of souls being reincarnated together, seeing how the connections affect their lives, and the consequences that can result. Overall, I think the author did a good job of executing this concept as the characters and timelines were nicely fleshed out. I also enjoyed the constant twists and turns of figuring out who was who in the past life. If you are looking for a unique read that blends suspense, multiple timelines, and romance, this is a good choice for you. I am rating this 3.5 stars, but rounding up to 4 as I enjoyed my time reading it.
I went into How the Story Always Ends really intrigued by the premise. The combination of reincarnation, psychic visions, shared memories, and a mystery surrounding Paloma’s childhood immediately pulled me in. The beginning had me genuinely invested. I wanted to understand the connection between Paloma, Dante, Ethan, and the events of the past.
I also enjoyed the historical elements, particularly the storyline involving Cristo and Ismael. There were some really interesting themes woven throughout the book surrounding identity, gender, love, and the idea of souls carrying connections across different lives. The concept of “one soul in two bodies” was especially intriguing.
Unfortunately, as the story progressed, I found myself becoming increasingly overwhelmed by the number of characters, timelines, reincarnations, and interconnected relationships being introduced. What initially felt mysterious and compelling eventually became difficult for me to keep track of, and I felt the story was becoming more complicated than I personally needed it to be.
There is a really creative and ambitious idea at the heart of this story, and I can see it working very well for readers who enjoy complex, layered reincarnation mysteries. Unfortunately, the increasing complexity lost me along the way.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Paloma has strange dreams. She dreams of being a man; she sees his murder. The dreams are so vivid; why is she tormented by them? When she opens a book that her mother left her, she has more questions. She travels to LA in search of answers and meets Dante, a man dreaming the same dreams.
Through glimpses into the past, several other lives are revealed. Each of these ends tragically. Can souls be reincarnated? Is every soul reincarnated, or only the ones experiencing tragedy? What a deeply engrossing story! Wendy Heard's characters, Paloma and Dante, are drawn together by either fate or personal chemistry. As their story progresses, readers question the concepts of destiny and reincarnation. The pace of the story is perfect, and nothing is left unanswered.
Even after the final page is read and the book is closed, this story will haunt you. And that is the sign of a very good book. I recommend this book to fans of thrillers, suspense, and the supernatural. This book twists you around in all the best ways.
WOW. Paloma’s mom passed a year ago and she’s still handling her posthumous affairs. The attorney hands her a folder of her medical records from when she was a child that she had no recollection of.
At the age of 5, Paloma was brought to Charlotte Ludlow’s office after having memories of a murder victim. Charlotte spearheaded research on reincarnation science alongside Andres.
As Paloma revisits her past and those of others, she goes back to Los Angeles where it all started. There, she meets Dante who also had memories of a murder before he was born.
Together, they uncover the cold case of their own deaths.
Wendy Heard, I was unfamiliar with your game…the concept of this book and the execution was *chef’s kiss* I couldn’t put this book down. Reincarnation, fate, soul mates all wrapped up in a suspenseful, thrilling novel. This book will have you on the edge of your seat and start to question your own beliefs in theories of things we cannot see. This is a must read.
I really enjoyed the way this book blended a murder mystery with reincarnation and past lives. It was such an interesting concept and definitely not your typical mystery.
Paloma and Dante are both haunted by memories of the same murder, even though it happened before either of them should have been able to remember it. I loved watching their stories intertwine as they tried to figure out how their past lives connected to the present and what really happened.
There were so many twists and turns, and I was here for all of them. Every time I thought I had something figured out, the story pulled me in another direction. It was captivating, intriguing, and honestly hard to put down.
Thank you NetGalley and Ballantine Publishing for the eARC.
How the Story Always Ends is a story about fate, complex love, and reincarnation. The plot of this story was captivating and I was so curious to see how the premise was going to be explained and then eventually how it would be tied up. I think the author did a great job of capturing the unique personalities of both the main characters, Dante and Paloma, but also the large amount of side characters that are intertwined in their story. The inclusions of different POVs and storylines was just the perfect amount. They didn't take away from the story, they were short, and they added depth to the ever-growing plot.
This story of reincarnation drew me in immediately. A small child who has dreams and memories that seemingly fit a past life is the subject of a study. Paloma discovers she was that small child and goes on a quest to find out about the study and the outcome. But was she murdered in a past life and is the killer still out there warning her away from finding out the truth? Some gaps in the storytelling but overall a fast interesting read. The characters are well developed and I liked the past life stories and would have liked more of the historical content. A solid read.
Oh Wendy Heard, the plot twist genius that you are.
While cleaning out the house of her late mother, Paloma finds a book about children who appear to be reincarnations. More surprising: Paloma was one of them, appearing to have the memories of a murdered man, including the memories of said murder. And yet another surprise: she's not the only one.
As she and Dante try to figure out how they have these memories and why (and possibly try to solve a murder), things keep happening that make them question if they should have ever met in the first place.
It started a bit slow, but once it picked up, I couldn't stop reading. Thanks, NG!
When Paloma was a small child she started saying strange things to her mother. She described herself as Charlotte and would tell things that happened in Charlotte’s life. She even saw Charlotte’s husband being murdered. Years later after Palomas mother dies she finds an envelope telling her all these details as Paloma remembers none of it. Her mother had tracked down the mysterious Charlotte and a group of researchers that had interviewed Paloma. Paloma wants badly to know if she was reincarnated as that is the conclusion they came to. A very interesting concept. This was an arc from Netgalley and comes out in January. How The Story Always Ends by Wendy Heard. 3 stars
How the Story Always Ends is an interesting take on reincarnation and soulmates. It starts out strong with the first part focusing on Paloma, whose recently deceased mother leaves her a book on children's accounts of memories of past lives where Paloma was briefly mentioned as a child with past-life memory. Paloma remembers none of this and is determined to find out more.
The middle parts really dragged for me. The pacing slows down, and the chapters about ancient past lives were somewhat boring and took away from the main plot. Also, there was a main detail that never got resolved.
In short, this was a good read but has some flaws. Thanks to NetGalley and Bantam for the ARC.
Thank you, Ballantine, for providing the copy of How the Story Always Ends by Wendy Heard. Reincarnation is fascinating, so this book’s premise grabbed me right away. It raised more questions about reincarnation nd karma than it answered. The story was intriguing, and I loved how Paloma and Dante joined forces on the investigation. The older timelines were unnecessarily long and detailed, which made the book feel really long, especially once I knew what was going on. No spoilers, but there was one scene that made the whole book for me because it was so touching! 4 stars
For once I'm happy to have taken a chance on a random NetGalley book that landed in my inbox! Although it was pitched for fans of "Dark Matter", I'd say the vibe matches something like "Tomorrow x3" a lot better. The slow-burn/platonic relationship and LA setting reminded me of "Hollywood, Ending". The 1600's ocean voyage reminded me of "Isola". The character connections spanning hundreds of years reminded me of "Homebound". I can see this being very broadly popular. Don't overthink the concept and let the book take you where it wants to take you!
Paloma and Dante have always had unusual skills that began as children. They have vivid memories of past lives and now they have been brought together as adults to find out why and who the murderer was. Short chapters that switch between Paloma and Dante as they navigate their memories and their attraction to each other and what it means in this life. Reincarnation and romance plus a mystery of nightmares. My thanks to the publisher for the advance copy.