Girl of Sea and Starlight

by Toni Cabell

When the grumpy captain of a fishing boat rescues a dying seal from the sea, she never expects the creature to shift into a handsome selkie prince who immediately proposes marriage.

Lainey stopped believing in the benevolence of the starry host when she was very young, preferring to trust in her skills rather than stardust and magic. She’s as good a sailor as any, and she can shoot her pistol and throw her dagger as well as any man in her village. Her life is almost perfect… well, except for her missing cat… and her tantrums, which have been worsening of late.

Arrendale has waited years for this moment, when at long last he can gaze upon his fiancée, promising her not only his protection but his undying love. Imagine his surprise when his beloved has no notion they’ve been betrothed since she was an infant… and even worse, she attempts to toss him overboard.

How can the crown prince of an undersea kingdom convince this grouchy girl his intentions are entirely honorable—and both their lives are forfeit if she doesn’t accept his blasted furry hide and his kiss!

Girl of Sea and Starlight is a clean, gender-flipped reimagining of The Fisherman and the Selkie, with romance, battles, pirates, elves, and trolls. Fans of The Princess Bride, Pirates of the Caribbean, and The Chronicles of Narnia will love this adventurous, humorous, and inspirational tale of selkie love, human grit, and answered prayers.

Praise for Girl of Sea and

"A delightful blend of fantasy, romance, humour, and adventure, Girl of Sea and Starlight sweeps readers into a magical selkie tale where a fiercely independent captain and a devoted sea prince must navigate destiny, danger, and an unforgettable love story.” (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ The Wishing Shelf)

"I just ADORED this story!!! Every single thing about it completely swept me away! Lainey is hands down one of the coolest FMCs I’ve read in a long time." (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Heidi, Goodreads)

"I am so in love with this unique spin on an arranged marriage fairytale. This book feels like fairytale favorites, Ella Enchanted and Frozen, with the magical worlds, the magical bonds, and the FMC not knowing her magic." (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ BookishVibesClub, Goodreads)

"A must read if you love fantasy books, fairytale retellings (little mermaid vibes), and books with Christian themes. As a Christian myself I loved seeing all the little nods to God and creation and prayer. ( ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Liv, Goodreads)

Genres: Fantasy, Romantasy, Romance

414 pages, Kindle Edition

Published August 1, 2026

About the author

I write Clean, Closed Door Fantasy Romance for teens, new adults, and adults.

My novels have won Silver and Bronze Medals in The Wishing Shelf Book Awards, two Gold Medals in the Global Book Awards, and multiple B.R.A.G. Medallions.

Click my website link below to join my newsletter and receive a Free Novella!

https://tonicabell.com/

Reviews

[Suri (suriscozyreads) · Rating 5 out of 5]

I just discovered a new favorite series!

I loved everything about this story and world building. It was such an easy fantasy read and I didn't want to put it down. Lainey and Arrendale were such a cute and fun couple. I love it when he falls first and so much harder! Their arranged marriage was set 18 years before the book started (prologue) and it sets the stage for all the adventure that is to come. I loved all the characters and without giving spoilers, you need to keep an open mind. So much happens and there's so many twists and turns.

I can't imagine the pressure Lainey felt at just 18 to find out everything the way she did. I believe she handled all the sudden pressure better than I would have!

This is such a fantastic and entertaining story. The characters will draw you in, the magic will be so fun to see, and the love is so tender that you won't feel like you get enough.

I am so excited to continue this series and see book 2's couple find their way to each other!

[Kyrie Wang · Rating 5 out of 5]

Toni Cabell has crafted another addictive blend of adventure, suspense, and no-spice romance in a magical land. I greatly enjoyed the pirates and hidden identity elements of this story, as well as the supporting cast that made the world feel lived in. The pacing allowed for both action and calmer moments with banter/humor. Although I felt Prince Arrendale (MMC) was a tad too perfect, he complemented the feisty FMC well. I was rooting for them all the way about a third of the way in. A wonderful read for lovers of high-seas adventure, court intrigue, and swoony romantasy!

I received an ARC. All opinions are my own.

[Le Cy · Rating 3 out of 5]

A nice, wholesome read that elicited a strong sense of nostalgia, Girl of Sea and Starlight is the first book in a clean romantasy series featuring loveable characters, a fantastical world, and sweet romances.

"I'm betrothed to an imbecile!"
Lovely. My bride had progressed from physical assault to name calling.

The first thing I noticed going into this was how much I loved Toni's humour. Especially in the first couple of chapters, there were several lines that had me chuckling to myself! Right off the bat, I was super intrigued by the prologue. The whole atmosphere made the book feel very fairytale-like, and I loveee the arranged marriage trope, so I knew going into this that I was going to have a good time

Lainey's hair needed to be as unrestrained and free as her spirit.

I had a fun time with the overarching plot. It's very classic fantasy, with an evil kingdom to defeat and a reluctant heroine who has just discovered her magic, with some lovely themes of found family and faith woven throughout. While it isn't exactly groundbreaking, it is safe, comforting, and "cosy," if you will, so I think this could be a great read when you're craving something nostalgic! The characters were all very likeable, and I especially liked that Blandon ended up being a more complicated character rather than simply being evil for the sake of being evil. I love that we get to see more of him in the sequel.

She was every star in the sky and port in the storm and shelter on the beach. Lainey was my home.

I had my doubts about the age gap going into this (I don't usually enjoy age-gap romances all that much), but those concerns were quickly dispelled by how sweet the romance ended up being. Arrendale and Lainey were incredibly adorable, and I loved how tender they were with each other, constantly reassuring one another through their heart bond even when they were apart. That said, I did find that their romance progressed a little too quickly for my liking. Even though Arrendale had known about their arranged marriage for 18 years, it seemed like he had never really had the chance to bond with or get close to Lainey beforehand. Because of that, his sudden affection for her felt a little... I don't know, out of place? Unfounded? I would've loved to see their feelings develop more gradually instead of jumping straight into love after just a handful of interactions.

"Half a lifetime with you will be packed with so much love and adventure and amazing kisses that no selkie prince could ever live a happier, better life than me."

The writing definitely leaned quite young on the YA spectrum, almost veering into middle grade at times. While it ended up being a little too young for my personal taste, I can absolutely picture myself eating this up as a fifth grader haha! Overall, this was an enjoyable and comfortable read, and I'm definitely looking forward to continuing The Lunar Chronicles series.

[Aubrey Hedman · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book starts of beautiful and strong, so much intrigue. Truly showing the harsh realities of circumstances that cause certain decisions to be made that can result in something beautiful. The slow burn romance, wrestling with circumstances that are just trust upon you, and learning to embrace the path set out for you are just a couple of the experiences in this story.
The character development is charming and the setting is absolutely enthralling. Fans of all things pirates and sea faring will absolutely love Girl of Sea and Starlight.

So thankful for my gifted copy of this book from the author!!! 🫶🏻🫶🏻

[K.M. · Rating 5 out of 5]

I've grown fond of Toni Cabell books, and she's now an author I often recommend. This is a book I will be suggesting and gifting for a long time.

This gender-flipped reimagining of The Fisherman and the Selkie has a little something for nearly everyone. Adventure, clean romance, sweet moments and thoughts on faith and how it shapes our actions. I found myself instantly rooting for Arrendale and pleased with Lainey's feisty side.

The arranged Marriage/marriage of necessity trope gets a fresh take; not only does he fall first, he chooses her in a relationship neither asked for. As the story progresses and their bond grows, choice and faith shine through.

Willa the cat is a delight, and I loved the magical community around this couple.

This is also a perfect read for mothers and daughters to share together.

A favorite quote:
"I realized there might be valid reasons for concealing a princess's identity, but a massive reveal on her eighteenth birthday out to be outlawed."

[Thoroughly Clean Indies]

{371 print pages}

There’s a point in chapter 25 at which Arendelle’s evil twin brother pretends to be him and acts amorously towards Lainey. (It stays clean.) He tries to kiss her more than once but it doesn’t actually happen at any point. Suspicious characters always step in when things start moving in the wrong direction, and Lainey herself feels somewhat unsettled without knowing why, but you should be aware of the plot piece in case any of this still makes you uncomfortable.

Genre: Fantasy, gender-flipped fairy tale retelling [of The Fisherman and the Selkie], adventure
Tropes: Marriage of convenience, girl discovers she’s royalty, evil twin, grumpy x sunshine
Writing style: Dual POV, 1st person, past tense
Character- or plot-driven: Both

Clean level:
• 1 minimally-described mouth kiss from a character to someone he has no connection to
• 6 mouth kisses between married characters
◦ 1 with a minimal paragraph-long description and a couple-lines-long recall from the other character’s perspective
◦ 1 with a few sentences of minimal description total
◦ 1 minimally described and preceded by a thumb stroking cheek and lips causing a tingling down to her toes; they need to “catch [their] breath” afterward
◦ 1 minimally described over about a paragraph and preceded by his hands buried in her hair and including her pulling his head down for more
◦ 1 lightly described
◦ 2 with the barest description
◦ 1 instance of kissing barely described
◦ 1 quick peck
• 1 instance of chaste kissing all over face (at the end of a wedding ceremony)
• 1 forehead and 1 cheek kiss barely described
• 2 forehead and 2 hand kisses without description
• 1 desire to smooth away a wrinkle between the eyes with a kiss, passing thought
• 1 thought of “dusting” face and lips with kisses
• 2 instances of desire to kiss
• 1 quick thought of kissing “her full, inviting mouth,” “pillowy lips”
• “enjoyed the feel of her...body crushed against my chest”

I previously read Part 1 as a novella in a limited-time anthlology the author participated in, in mid-2025, so I enjoyed getting the conflict dealt with more thoroughly after the initial head-to-head with the evil twin brother.

As after Part 1 Lainey and Arrendale are seperated for all but a moment before the last chapter of Part 3, there’s no real time for her feelings to build to the love she ends up deciding she has for him. Distance makes the heart grow fonder is real, but love is built on time spent together, which they barely get. This isn’t a complaint about the plot, but I do wish we could have seen the couple bond more after the wedding. I hope that even though there will be different protagonists in book 2 we’ll get to see more of how this couple interacts when the relationship is settled.

Lainey is a no-nonsense, fiercely loyal kind of person prone to literally stormy emotions, for very good reason. Having been kept in the dark all her life about who she is and who the people in her childhood village actually are and what kind of a world she’s actually living in, she struggles with being all of eighteen years old and suddenly thrust into an extreme leadership role she has had zero preparation for (aside from captaining a ship), automatically expected to overcome the “self-centeredness” (for lack of a better term) everyone naturally needs to grow out of. But she actively — in real time — rallies all her fortitude to take on this tremendous responsibility despite the unfairness of her forced circumstances.

Arrendale is sweet and gentle, and completely devoted to Lainey simply because he has known all his life that she would be his wife. Even without knowing her, he is determined to love and cherish her as though he’d chosen her for himself. And what a beautiful idea to have the two of them bound to each other to the extent of literally feeling each other’s emotions — a concretization of how a husband and wife’s wellbeing are dependent on each other; how what one experiences automatically affects the other; how the other’s feelings, dreams, and needs are — in a way — their own as well.

*There is a bonus scene linked at the end of the book. It includes 1 “searing” mouth kiss minimally described over about a paragraph; and 1 instance of kisses to knuckles, palm, and wrist setting off “a surge of tingles”; all between two characters with absolutely no connection.

____________________________________

Then someone whispered Arrendale and I made a handsome couple, and I lost it. The pictures on the wall rattled in their frames and fell; the end tables and plant stands toppled over, dumping their contents on the floor. Pillow cushions spun in the air, along with hats, scarves, and someone’s cane.

But she didn't believe in magic? Did she think temper tantrums are a law of physics that makes things fall over or fly everywhere?

Humans were odd creatures. They were so concerned with proprieties they missed the larger truths staring them in the face. I would never, ever, do anything to harm Lainey or compromise her virtue. But I supposed they didn’t know me well enough to recognize that particular truth.

Unfortunately, that's just the way reality works. We know that we're safe, but others have no way of knowing that. The truth exists but it certainly isn't staring them in the face.

“Because everyone is going to expect us to spend our nights together and to kiss each other. It’ll look really peculiar if we don’t.”

Why? It's an arranged marriage and everyone knows it. Also, there's no law that says happy, committed couples have to be physically affectionate in public.

I held Rydon and Arrendale partly responsible for what happened, since they knew about my temper and triggered me anyway.

I mean, it's not like they did it on purpose or even knew it was happening and could have prevented it.

Even though I’d already seen Blandon’s goblin form, my heart literally froze at the sight of row after row of gruesome, gray monsters marching toward us.

I'm pretty sure if it had literally frozen she'd have died.

“You’re going to have to be a better man if you want to win her affections.” “Even if I stop pirating tomorrow, she’d never have me. No woman would.” [...] “I’m going to find a way to break my curse, and I’m going to convince that lovely young pixie to marry me.”

Wait, so which is it? You are going to convince her to marry you, or you can’t? You've got to settle on one or the other.

Favorite Quotations:
• I kicked off my boots, one of which spun in the air, smacked into the main mast, tap danced across the wooden deck, and then leapt onto the opposite rail, where it tottered. “Oh no you don’t!” I screeched at my wayward boot, which turned itself upside down, waggled back and forth like a petulant toddler sticking out its tongue, and then flopped harmlessly onto the deck.
• I realized there might be valid reasons for concealing a princess’s identity, but a massive reveal on her eighteenth birthday ought to be outlawed.
• “Hope is never false, Lainey[.]”
• “Have faith,” whispered Omega, placing her hand on my shoulder. “It’s kinda hard, Megs, when everything I thought I knew wasn’t real to begin with. I have goblins and pirates and leaky portals and dying stars to worry about. And now my husband, whom I barely know but really want to see again, has vanished. My faith isn’t big enough or deep enough or strong enough for all of that.” “That’s the thing, Lainey.” [...] “Your faith doesn’t have to be big or deep or strong. You just need a teardrop full,” she nodded at my damp cheeks, “or a seed full.” I recalled her gift of the orchid seed when I was attempting to open a portal for the first time, and sniffed. “I don’t see how that’s nearly enough.” “On your own, it’s not,” replied Omega. “But you have all of us to help you, and the stars above to protect you.”
• “I gave up my last vestiges of hope many years ago, when His Eminence murdered my father. Frankly, acceptance is a whole lot less painful.” “No, you’re wrong,” I insisted[...]“How am I wrong?” asked Blandon, who for once wasn’t snarling, sneering, or snapping at me. “Accepting evil is more painful, because you wind up doing things that hurt your heart, and bit by bit, that chips away at your stardust until nothing’s left but ashes.”


(I received a free ARC of this book from the author and am gratefully—voluntarily—leaving a review.)

[Sarah Nolan · Rating 4 out of 5]

This lovely tale based on The Fisherman and the Selkie was a magical, whimsical, and touching adventure!

Lainey and Arrendale together is absolute perfection! The setting of the sea, pirates, magical creatures both good and bad, made this story so heartwarming and fun. There is just something about selkies and the sea that I always love reading about in stories. Selkies are one of my favorite magical creatures! The found family is so sweet, and the backstory of some of our main characters will have your heart breaking but hoping all at the same time. I can’t wait for what’s next in this series! (And I have my own theory about the love story the next installment might be about 😉).

Romantic Content: 🫑 Closed Door

CW: Death of Parents/Loved Ones in the Past, Anxiety, Secrets

[Janessa Shepard · Rating 3 out of 5]

This book follows a feisty captain as she discovers her true identity as the queen of her people and betrothed to a Selkie Prince. It's full of action and adventure while also taking the time to teach important, real life lessons. These are some notes I took during my read. There are spoilers!

The plot is immediately intriguing! The prologue had my hooked on the story and the world. I'm excited to see how the magic affects their relationship—it'll make both characters have less of a choice than they would've without it. I bet that will lead to a lot of frustration and maybe even resentment.

I like that Lainey is blind sided by this arrangement, but it also doesn't feel completely realistic, especially since she's still around the people who know her situation. Why was she kept in the dark about such an important matter? I'm sure that will be revealed, but it feels a bit off initially. I like Arrendale's outlook on the situation—to love her and be loyal to her no matter what—and I'm really glad he has a POV.

The writing style feels very fairytale to me. I picture turquoise seas and bright skies while reading this. It's to the point—a little simplistic but not in a bad way. It feels like a story I would want to grow up with. I would personally categorize this more as middle grades lit than YA lit. I really do enjoy it but it's a little too simple for me now. I can imagine myself reading this to a future child, though!

Because of the simple writing the pacing feels a little fast, but it works with the tone of the story for the most part. I will say I think Lainey grows too fond of Arrendale a little too soon. There is a small time jump that accounts for that, but that means the reader doesn't fully understand her change of heart. I wish there were more scenes with them showing their characters so we could understand that shift. Arrendale's thoughts about Lainey are adorable but also seem a bit unfounded. They don't really know each other but he's completely smitten. More focus on him noticing her actions and personality would've really helped grow their relationship.

I found Blandon to be the most interesting character, and I'm excited to know there will be more of him in the future. The truth of his past was heartbreaking to discovered and added a lot of depth to his character. I honestly found myself hoping that he would be a love interest. He is certainly the most complex character, which draws me to him more than the others.

The Christian allegory is very well done. The Morning Star is there to answer prayers when the characters need Him. He reminds them to put their trust in Him and gives them strength. The message is clear and concise, which is especially great for a younger audience.

Overall, I think this book has a great foundation. The characters are lovable and the plot is exciting. However, it's missing some meat—the pacing is too fast, making it feel like we're skipping over important character and plot moments. I think this would be great for a young audience (9-13), but might not hit the mark with older readers.

[Jennifer (Yodareads) Bishop · Rating 5 out of 5]

I want to thank Toni Cabell for this ARC (Advanced Reader Copy) of Girl of Sea and Starlight.

What would it be like to turn eighteen and immediately have a seal turned into a handsome prince declare his intention to marry you? Would you immediately say yes? Or make a run for it? In this wonderful gender swapped reimagining of the Fisherman and the Selkie, Lainey is faced with such a preposterous declaration. Girl of Sea and Starlight by Toni Cabell not only explores this interesting notion, but also dives into what it would be like to find out one day that everything you thought you knew about the world was a lie and that fairytales are in fact real. As Lainey works through this, Arrendale (handsome selkie prince mentioned before) is trying to woo her and save her from the evil goblin king and his army. Will they succeed in restoring some order to the land? Will Arrendale be able to show her his intentions are true?

I really enjoyed this book! While it definitely had a bit of cozy vibes, it still had the action and adventure that I love in a good seafaring book. I haven’t read many books (potentially any) that had Selkies as a main character which was such a fun and interesting new perspective! The nuances of what it would be like to shapeshift, but have to keep your pelt somewhere safe is something I’d never really thought about. It was also really cool seeing how Cabell decided to depict so many of the fairytale creatures we’ve all seen time and time again. It’s always refreshing to have a new perspective!

While Lainey and Arrendale were our two main POVs (points of view), we did get a bit of insight into some of the other characters as well that helped round the story out even more. Not only did we get to see redemption in some of the characters who made some questionable decisions, we got to see the process of emotions that always goes along with it. There was even quite a bit about working through anxiety and frustration and learning how to control emotions which is such a detrimental thing for all of us as we grow up.

When it comes to worldbuilding, I’m always a sucker for a good seafaring journey. I don’t know why, but I love books that include ocean travel. This was one that did not disappoint here. We got to see battle on the water, navigating through tight water channels, and even what can happen during storms. There was also exploration on land of different cities and landscapes.

One other thing I want to mention is that I could see a strong hint of faith throughout the book. I always enjoy seeing how authors will incorporate that into their works. Life really is so much better when leaning on God and to see authors that encourage readers by putting hints towards that in their books is so beautiful.

Girl of Sea and Starlight is a clean fairytale retelling that explores discovering who you are, faith, and trusting those around you. It is definitely a more romantic book, however there is no cursing, only mild kissing, and mild violence. This is a great book for anyone who loves reading about pirates, mythical creatures, and the human desire to overpower any obstacle. I cannot wait to continue this series when the next book comes out!

[Billy Buttons · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Wishing Shelf Book Awards
EDITORIAL REVIEW
2nd June 2026
TITLE: Girl of Sea and Starlight
AUTHOR: Toni Cabell

Star Rating: 5

“A delightful blend of fantasy, romance, humour, and adventure, Girl of Sea and Starlight sweeps readers into a magical selkie tale where a fiercely independent captain and a devoted sea prince must navigate destiny, danger, and an unforgettable love story.”
The Wishing Shelf

REVIEW
Toni Cabell’s Girl of Sea and Starlight is the sort of fantasy that knows exactly what it wants to be: adventurous, romantic, funny, and wonderfully heartfelt. From the moment grouchy fishing captain Lainey hauls what she thinks is a dying seal onto her boat, the story sweeps readers into a world of selkies, magic, royal secrets, and destiny gone delightfully wrong. The gender-flipped fairy tale premise feels fresh, and Cabell wastes no time throwing her stubborn heroine into absolute chaos.
Lainey is easily the standout here. She’s practical, independent, fiercely capable, and completely unimpressed by magic, royalty, or handsome princes. Watching her react to Arrendale’s dramatic arrival—and even more dramatic marriage proposal—is an absolute joy. Their dynamic crackles with humour, especially because Arrendale has spent years dreaming about his future bride, while Lainey would quite happily throw him straight back into the ocean.
What makes the novel particularly engaging is the balance between light-hearted romance and larger stakes. Beneath the banter and awkward betrothal lies a fascinating fantasy world filled with selkie kingdoms, political alliances, fading magic, and looming threats. Cabell gradually reveals these layers without slowing the pace, making the world feel rich while keeping the focus firmly on the characters.
The alternating perspectives work especially well, allowing readers to understand both Lainey’s outrage and Arrendale’s sincerity. Arrendale could easily have become an overly perfect romantic hero, but his earnestness, patience, and occasional cluelessness make him surprisingly endearing. The humour lands consistently, often emerging naturally from the clash between his romantic expectations and Lainey’s determination to resist every single one of them.
Overall, Girl of Sea and Starlight is a charming, family-friendly fantasy romance packed with adventure, magic, and plenty of heart. Fans of fairy-tale retellings, slow-burn relationships, and spirited heroines will find a lot to enjoy here. It’s an entertaining start to a story that combines swashbuckling action with sweetness and humour, leaving readers eager to see how Lainey and her persistent selkie prince navigate the storms still ahead.
A ‘Wishing Shelf’ Book Review
www.thewsa.co.uk

[Chad Barrus · Rating 5 out of 5]

I received a ARC copy of this book from the author and though a review wasn’t required to receive the book, I wanted to offer my honest, voluntary impression of it upon finishing it.

Toni has written a book which will keep you turning the pages as fast as you can to find out what happens next!

Lainey is getting ready to celebrate her 18th birthday unaware of the momentous changes this milestone is going to make in her life up to that time of being the captain of a sailing ship! She and her first mate spot something in the water and as they get closer realize it’s a seal tied down to a piece of wood floating in the ocean!
She dives in to cut the seal loose thinking it’s dead but finds it isn’t and brings it aboard only to find out it’s not a normal seal but one that can shape shift as it turns into a human and speaks! She finds out he is a selkie prince and what he tells her is unbelievable! They return to port where she confronts her aunt only to find all he told her is true because her aunt and her first mate were there!

Thus starts Lainey’s new life as she realizes she has a past kept hidden from her for 18 years and now must assume her role as the new queen of what remains of their country with this selkie prince as her husband!

An exciting tale of disbelief, treachery, deception, hidden knowledge to protect her and now becoming aware of who and what she is and the part this selkie prince will play in it all!

Being chased by first pirates, one in particular who has a relationship with her husband as well as trying to control powers she is just gaining by turning 18, Lainey is overwhelmed and unsure who to trust or believe since so much has been hidden from her for good reason but still hidden from her! Then as if that isn’t bad enough there are now goblins to contend with!

Follow their adventures and how what his mother did has caused the rift between his brother and him and also involved goblins in the mix!

It’s a story of action, adventure, friendship, forgiveness, understanding and redemption! It’s a story that will stay with you as you look towards the next book entitled Girl of Wings and Starlight which tells of how a girl was able to help a despised pirate find the courage to change his life after so long!

I wholeheartedly and enthusiastically recommend this book as one I know you’ll enjoy and love as much as I have! If you love stories of a person who refuses to give up on his mate, who initially despises him and slowly changes because of what feelings emerge as they are together then you need to read this book!

Forgiveness is paramount if we are to achieve what we want to become in this world! Get caught up in this book!You’ll love it and be so glad you decided to read it believe me!

[Elizabeth Lavender · Rating 5 out of 5]

“None of us are what we seem. We all hide our true selves from everyone else, sometimes even from ourselves. Only the stars above know what’s truly in our hearts.”
Lainey discovers in one day she indeed has no idea who she is. In that time, Lainey goes from holding simply the title of captain of the Portstara ship in the quaint Starsdale Cove to being bestowed the titles of queen, portal mage, knight, champion of the Four Corners and last but not least bride to a selkie prince. They’re all roles that would have been great to know about before now, so she wouldn’t be in a state of perpetual shock upon learning each new revelation. There’s especially the one that her new husband can transform from a seal to a man at a whim. In contrast, Arrendale did know this day would come, and he had it going much differently. He envisioned finally holding his beautiful bride, pledging his love and protection to her, and that she would undoubtably return his affection. Instead, reality delivers a crushing blow for his expectations to the day. He’ll have to win Lainey’s heart by showing her that the wedding promise he made are from his heart to her heart and not just part of a betrothal treaty from years ago.
After all everything is at stake, and so they have to believe the stars can shine brightly again. Lainey finds herself searching for a piece of her old life to grip, one with no magic, dwarves, pixies, and evil goblins for starters. Perhaps most of all no realm that everyone is counting on her to save them from the world ending, from the last star dying. What’s more it won’t happen with a blade or gun that she knows how to handle, but with magic that she doesn’t have a clue how to use it. Everyone else says otherwise though. Just have a little faith they say, like as small as an orchid seed. See the way to a restored kingdom. But Lainey’s eyes spy an unsurmountable goblin and pirate army blocking the path. She is a woman scared out of her mind of failing those she cares for and being their death because she doesn’t have a plan for this one. It’s too big for her. In truth, despite all the preparation Arrendale has done for all these years, deep down he shares her fears.
Yet they’re not alone in their journey. It’s a familiar, age-old fear that creeps its way into every heart at some point. It’s the unconquerable goblin army in whatever its form that makes the spirit drop in defeat for a moment. It’s the feeling that our meager resources are too little for the task before us. It’s the need to see the plan in every detail for taking care of the goblin army in our way. Yet, instead we’re urged, just like Lainey and Arrendale, to have a little faith and it will be enough. We’re reminded that the enemy isn’t nearly as powerful as what we have imagined because we have an army of our own that fights for us. We’re reassured that when we’re called to the field, we’re always equipped with what we need for the battle before us. We’re comforted that we don’t need to see the entire plan, just know it’s already written and we can trust it. Finally, we’re promised, just like Lainey and Arrendale, with a little faith we’ll see the impossible made possible as there is one Starry Host who excels in that realm.

[Tori · Rating 5 out of 5]

Rating: 5/5
I received an eARC for my honest opinion.

From the moment I started Girl of Sea and Starlight, I had a feeling this was going to be one of those books I wouldn't want to put down, and I was right. It completely swept me away into a beautifully imagined world full of adventure, mystery, and characters I couldn't help but become attached to. Toni knows how to write an amazing book that is clean and still gives the readers all the feels.

What I loved most was watching the main character grow throughout the story. She wasn't someone who had all the answers, and that's what made her journey so compelling. Every challenge she faced helped shape her into someone stronger and more confident, and I found myself cheering her on every step of the way. Her courage wasn't about never being afraid it was about choosing to keep moving forward despite her fears, and I really appreciated that. I thought Prince Arrendale was perfect for Lainey. Where she is feisty and hot headed, Arrendale is calm, respectful, and understanding. The banter between the character and I mean all the characters was top notch.

The world-building was another standout for me. It felt rich and immersive without ever becoming overwhelming. I loved slowly uncovering the secrets alongside the characters, and there were several moments that genuinely surprised me. The relationships were just as memorable as the adventure itself. Whether it was friendship, family, or the bonds that formed through shared experiences, every connection felt meaningful. Those quieter moments gave the story so much heart and made the bigger emotional scenes hit even harder.

I would like to thank Toni Cabell for the opportunity to review this book.

[Jasmine · Rating 3 out of 5]

Girl of sea and starlight 🌊✨
When Lainey a captain of her own ship finds and rescues what she thinks is a seal on her 18th birthday her world is flipped upside down. After meeting Arrendale secrets are revealed, magic is unleashed and roles are given. There is a higher purpose for her one she hesitates to follow but with family and friends to guide her she’s able to see the bigger picture. I loved the faith themes in this book. How Lainey learns to put her full trust in the “morning star”. It felt like I was reading verses from my Bible through out the story.

Arrendale and Lainey have a special bond. One that shares feelings and thoughts even when faraway from each other. Though this was interesting and propelled the story I would’ve liked to see them together more as they navigated their new found marriage. I found the back to back captures and rescues a little much. Overall was a good book.

“I was alone and losing hope with every step I took. You are not alone, little star, not now, not ever. “Morning Star? Is that you?” I silently asked. Ask, and you shall receive. “But I need to save a lot of people, and my magic isn’t strong enough.” Do not doubt, but believe. My provision is awesome, and it is all you will ever need.


🏴‍☠️ arranged marriage
✨faith themes
🏴‍☠️ unique magic system
✨found family
🏴‍☠️hidden identity
✨slow burn romance
🏴‍☠️ strong fmc
✨clean, no spice
🏴‍☠️fairytale
✨selkie shifter mmc

[Angela Brannon · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this young adult tale of arranged marriage and fated mates. Crown Prince Arrendale of the selkie kingdom of Navarlee has been betrothed to Crown Princess Marvalaine of Falstaria However, Falstaria fell to the goblins not long after and the princess vanished. Arrendale has been searching for her ever since, especially as her 18th birthday approaches and the magic of the bargain rears its ugly head.

Lainey is a young fishing boat captain in a remote village who loves the sea. When a seal is discovered bound to a board and left adrift to die, she has her men rescue it. To her surprise, the seal transforms into a young man who says he is a selkie shifter prince. He declares that he is her betrothed and that they must marry to save the world. Understandably, Lainey is underwhelmed.

From this point the action takes off and I could not put the book down. The worldbuilding is so good and the characters are so well drawn. I loved Lainey as she has to go from being a simple human fishing boat captain to learning she is a magical princess surrounded by her hidden court of magical beings of every species. As danger threatens on every side, Lainey and Arrendale must reconcile their differences and battle the dark forces that threaten their very world. I can’t recommend this enough to young adult readers or adults that love clean and cosy epic fantasies. I can’t wait to read the next book in the series and see how this saga plays out.

[Jennie Jae · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was such a fun and surprising book! There is so much story packed into the pages including fantastical creatures like the MMC who is a selkie (seal-shifter) Prince, star-based magic and faith system, pirates, hidden identities, battles, an arranged marriage, voyages through oceans, rivers, lands, and portals, the found-family type love of a ship’s crew and home community, a young but intelligent and feisty FMC, and the portrayal of a most loyal and steadfast romantic love that will warm your heart.

There is also an underlying message about the importance and power of prayer and trusting that God will give you exactly what you need when you need it if you reach out to Him in faith.

It has dual points of view between the MMC and the FMC which was written really well and with distinct voices distinguishing them. It was really fun to get to see inside their minds and know what they were truly thinking and watching their relationship develop over the course of the book. I honestly never knew what kind of characters we would meet or where the story was going to take me from one chapter to the next. This was truly an epic adventure that kept me turning the pages to see what was going to happen!

Thank you to the author for the eARC. The opinions expressed in this review are my own and given willingly.

[Michaela (Reading in the Heartland) · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars

I really enjoyed this no spice Christian YA fantasy. There is romance, portals, a Princess, a selkie shifter, an arranged marriage, magic, and more. This book was originally a novella in a collection and starts out similarly but then takes us into a world and adventure all its own.

In this gender flipped retelling of The Fisherman and the Selkie, Lainey, a human ship captain, rescues a seal, only to find out he’s actually a selkie shifter, and a prince, and her betrothed! She is thrust into a world of magic and fantasy and high stakes. While this forced proximity, only one bed, reverse grumpy/sunshine romance starts out strong on the romance portion, it gives way to elevated young adult fantasy tones - I can totally picture having this book on my shelves for my kiddos to read later on when they are teens. It does a great job with the world building.

I’m excited to continue with this series! We’ve been set up so well for it. After everything we’ve gone through, I can’t imagine what Cabell has in store for us next! The romance in this book is just kisses, intimacy level 2. 4.5 stars rounded up to 5.

Content Warnings: Loss of Family, Murder, Injuries

I received an eARC of this book from the author and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.

[Yugie Caroline · Rating 5 out of 5]

She was betrothed to him since she was seven days old. For the next 18 years he would remain fiercely loyal and committed to their betrothal, never once ever considering any other female to pass the time. He had been hers from the very start.

Now, that alone earns the book a solid four-star rating from me. Because a loyal and committed hero is everything to me, and any story carrying that trope already has earned big points from me. The remaining star to complete the coveted 5 stars was earned by this book by its engrossing plot, excellent storytelling, fantastic world-building, and a hodgepodge of adorable supernatural characters that I had fun imagining in my mind as I read about them. I wish someone could draw them up into visual art because it would be so nice to see what the dryads, trolls, elves, and pixies all look like!

When I got to the end of the book, I was immensely relieved to know the series is just beginning, because I haven't gotten enough of this world of the Four Corners!

I'm immensely thankful to the author for allowing me to be amongst the early readers of a free review copy of this book. I write this honest review voluntarily. It was a great book, and I want everyone to know that!

[Paula · Rating 5 out of 5]

Girl of Sea & Starlight by Toni Cabell is an exciting clean fantasy that begins with adventure and suspense never slowing down. The first book in The Starlight Chronicles Series has a type of role reversal in the beginning. Lainey is captain of the ship not knowing her true identity but already she has a take charge personality. I love that the grumpy captain is a woman when often it is a male. Arrendale has a dangerous sibling but that is not all trying to put an end to both, who were betrothed when Laney was a week old. I appreciated hat this even was shared in the prologue. Together they are definitely stronger than apart. Is that how marriage should be, even if it is arranged? What an adventurous story the book continued to be.

I expected a strong heroine having read some of Toni Cabell’s previous books. However, I didn’t expect the twisty turns this story has. Now I can hardly wait for book two to read what new surprises the author’s has in store. Girl of Sea & Starlight is a true jewel of a story. I highly recommend it to all fans of marvelous world building, wonderfully written plots and fully developed interesting characters.

[Jo|Ruth Reads · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a unique read! An arranged marriage between a sea captain and a selkie prince?! I was instantly pulled in!

Lainey is living her life as a captain, coming up on her 18th birthday. For most, that's a special milestone, but her birthday signifies something greater...her true identity and the life she has been meant to lead all along. Add in the selkie prince she saved, who instantly proposes to her, and needless to say, her world is turned upside down. Between navigating a new relationship with Arrendale and trying to live out her destiny, she may find that she has to rely on something far greater than her own might. In doing so, her future could be greater than she imagined, provided the two can work together toward a future that helps them both.

I loved the banter with this one. Arrendale's attachment to Lainey and the community itself was fun to be around. I look forward to the next one in the series. I think I can guess who it may revolve around!

I received a complimentary copy. This review reflects my honest opinion.

[Cilla · Rating 5 out of 5]

Lainey's life seemed very ordinary, sure she was a captain of her boat but she just lived in a small isolated village and was looking forward to her birthday. However, from the moment she rescued a seal - that someone had cruelly strapped to a raft and left to die - her life was never the same. She discovers that not only was the seal not a seal - rather he was a Selkie, and no ordinary Selkie, he was the crown prince AND her betrothed, tethered by magic that will kill them both if she refuses to honour the betrothal contract, but she has rare portal magic (that she can't control), that her fellow villagers aren't human, rather they are different Faerie folk that had been glamoured to look human, the loyal remnants of a destroyed kingdom. Add in that their hiding place is no longer hidden and they have to all flee for their lives from multiple enemies and it is no wonder Lainey is grumpy! This book is a great start to a new series and I look forward to the next book. I received an ARC but this review is my own.

[blush_and_bookmarks · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was such a sweet read, and I thoroughly enjoyed every page. The pirate adventure paired with faith elements was such a fun combination and made the story stand out.

Lainey was an absolute firecracker—spunky, fierce, and full of personality. I loved watching her navigate the adventure and live up to who she didn’t even know she was. Arrendale was the ultimate green flag on the high seas. He was kind, patient, protective, and everything you could hope for in a hero. The two of them complemented each other so well and made such a great duo you couldn’t help but root for.

There were several moments I didn’t see coming, which kept me eagerly turning the pages. I always appreciate a story that can surprise me while still delivering heartfelt moments.

Overall, this was a clean, enjoyable read from beginning to end. If you’re looking for a sweet pirate romance with faith woven throughout, lovable characters, and an engaging adventure, this one is definitely worth picking up.

[Ashley Henderson · Rating 4 out of 5]

Lainey is a Captain of her own boat and has a first mate that has been by her side her whole life, but she has a soft spot for anyone or anything that needs help. She sees what seems to be a seal tied to a raft and dying. So what does Lainey do, she dives onto the ocean to save the poor creature. Little does she know that she has now met for the second time, her betrothed husband Prince Arrendale. Airedale is a selfie prince that has the ability to shift to many animals. But can he shift Lainey to believe that he is her soon to be husband? He must because his twin brother is a pirate and after his birth right of being first born that was stolen from him and given to Arrendale by their mother.

Not only that, Lainey has been kept int he dark by her Aunt Sona who she really is and how she belongs in this world.

There is lots of adventure, slow burn love, and war among them to last many life times! This a a clean, slow burn love story book.

[Laura Fincher]

"Sea to land, fur to flesh, pebble to pearl, two hearts bound now as one."

This was a super fun adventure across the sea! It reminded me a lot of Narnia because of the wide variety of mythical creatures and biblical symbolism. There is more romance, though, which is always a plus in my book!

The story follows Lainey and Arrendale from their first meeting years before they are arranged to be married. It's a really beautiful tale of how a divine force can bring love between people, and in turn offer hope and healing to a broken and dying world.

I loved the witty banter, swoony moments, and action!

4/5 stars

Read if you enjoy:
Found Family
Arranged Marriage
He Falls First
Biblical Symbolism
Unique World Building

*Thank you so much to Toni for my complimentary copy! All opinions expressed are my own.

[Sam Readsfantasyandromance · Rating 5 out of 5]

Selkies, pixies, elves, wizards and more appear in this well-written Christian fantasy. Lanie’s situation is understandably frustrating and Arrendale is the steady, patient counterpart that she needs to navigate an identity so secret even she didn’t know what she was. Everyone around her did, though! The large and charming cast of magical side characters was managed well. The author does a great job of reminding readers what we need to know as characters come in and out so I didn’t feel lost.

I appreciated that Arrendale is strong but not infallible, patient but not a pushover. Most importantly, he loves Lainey. His brother’s situation is a shade darker than my usual tastes but meaningful and appropriate for the broader story.

The ebook also comes with beautiful chapter illustrations! I would definitely recommend this story to anyone who enjoys Christian fantasy romance.

[Kitty Elder · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book has a little bit of everything you love in fantasy. You have ship captains, and pirates. A heroine who prefers pants and swords to fancy dresses and jewelry. There’s a hidden paranormal world, and all sorts of different paranormal creatures, all showcased with amazing world building. Of course you have a couple villains and a hero to go along with the heroine. Let’s not forget a dash of romance and danger. And there’s an underlying theme of faith and overcoming life’s obstacles. This book reminds me a lot of CS Lewis‘s Narnia series. I am eagerly looking forward to the next book in the series.
I received an ARC from the author, but all opinions and the review are mine alone.

[Nicole Wright · Rating 5 out of 5]

I am a big fan of All of Toni’s stories and this one doesn’t disappoint!
I consumed this story quickly as I fell in love with the strong and determined Lainey as she nears her 18th birthday, the MC Arrendale is as green a flag as a MMC can be, I loved him from the moment we met him.

The dual POV’s told the story perfectly between both of the MC’s POV’s, I love the back the forth where we as the reader were allowed to get into their minds as we watch Lainey’s outrage to the arranged marriage that she has no idea about nor any say in. Arrendale stays calm and collective through most of his dealings with Lainey and her hesitation towards him.

This book took me back to my childhood love of selkies.

[Wendy · Rating 5 out of 5]

More than a 4 less than a 5 rounded up.
This is what I like in books about strong women, they are most often terrified and overwhelmed but what makes them strong is the way they, inspite of that, do what needs doing and fight what needs fighting.
There’s shifters, magic, family drama, swoony kisses, banter, and tears. And there’s more to come. I’ll be looking forward to the next chapter in this story.

Human girl, selkie prince hottie McShifter, he falls first, lots of scheming and stopping the oppressors. There are Christian themes and it’s one adults can read and pass on to the teen/tween readers without worry.
Down with the goblin king!!

I was blessed with an ARC. The thoughts are all mine.

[Alura Heindel · Rating 5 out of 5]

Coming-of-age? Hidden Royal? Shape-shifting Selkie Princes? This book has them all! And it’s amazing! Arrendale’s sunshine is the perfect mix with Lainey’s grumpy. And I loved how protective Arrendale is of his wife. And that ending!!! This was a late into the night read for me, and I regret nothing! I am eagerly awaiting the second book in the series! If you love stories with Arranged Marriages, High Sea Adventures and He Falls First, then you’ll love this book!

My favorite quote from this book:
I quickly leaned over and sealed his lips with mine, silencing Arrendale with a kiss. “You’re not off the hook yet, selkie prince.” “Oh, Lainey,” breathed Arrendale, his luminous, velvety brown eyes brightening.

I received an ARC from the author. All Opinions are my own.

[LoghanJoy · Rating 4 out of 5]

🌟🌟🌟🌟.25

The world-building and magic system were definitely some of my favorite parts, and I loved the characters. Lainey and Arrendale's arranged marriage was such an interesting setup, and I loved the yearning they both had for each other.

My one wish is that we had gotten more of them together! I wanted to know so much more before they were separated for so long. I would have loved more time to see them actually get to know each other and grow closer.

Overall, I really enjoyed the world, the magic, and the characters, and I'm definitely looking forward to seeing more of this world!

Thank you so much to Toni Cabell for the ARC! I really enjoyed getting to experience Lainey and Arrendale's story.