Interesting premise and argument. I think her argument about talking being uniquely human would have benefited from discussing bird communication and how it differs from human language, instead of only considering dogs and chimps. What songbirds and parrots do is more analogous, in some ways, than how those other species communicate. This was only discussed in one chapter, and I didn't even think it was that critical for her overall point, but it was the first non-intro chapter and it hung over the whole book for me.
This book reminded me how much we tend to take talking for granted. MacDonald shows that every chat, self pep-talk, or bedtime story is an active brain training. From baby babble to conversations that keep us sharp in later years, she reveals that talking shapes what we notice, steady our emotions, and keeps our minds agile.
I read (and think) a lot about language, and sometimes end up complaining about the language used about language. I found Noam Chomsky absolutely imcomprehensible. Many of the books I read for a class on the theory of translations seemed impractical and straining to be erudite. Others, like this, are lightweight. There were some interesting ideas here, but I skimmed a lot because there seemed to be more words than needed.
4.5⭐️! this book is so accessible to a general audience while still conveying important research on language! i would highly recommend, even to people who aren’t interested in developmental psychology or language learning!
This book is chock full of amazing info and ideas. I tried to go slow to savor all the wisdom. Really enjoyable and accessible review of research. Great use of stories and anecdotes to keep the readers attention. Highly recommended