For fans of Starling House,Play Nice, and Practical Magic comes a biting, layered, and haunting debut following one woman from a long line of psychics who will do anything to save her family legacy and the haunted house she grew up in from an entity threatening to destroy everything she's built.
Every house has its secrets.
Charley Bryde is miserable in a house filled with magic. The only woman in a long line of famous psychics to not inherit the family gift, she spends her days inside Crimson House, the coveted family mansion in Memphis, Tennessee, living in the shadows of her talented older sister, Miranda. But when a shocking tragedy scatters the Brydes across the globe, Charley is forced to grow up on her own, and fast. As the money runs dry and Charley's ownership of Crimson House is put at risk, she's left with no other option; turn the manor into a haunted attraction and start representing the family brand with lies, cons, and expertly read tarot cards to make ends meet.
When a skeptic starts targeting Charley for the fraud that she is, she'll stop at nothing to save the family legacy. But the skeptics' arrival cracks something open in Charley that the Brydes wanted to remain buried. Deep. And when Miranda shows up unannounced after eight years away, the two will come to realize that Crimson House, and their own family, hold secrets even the greatest psychics couldn't foresee. Secrets that will threaten to destroy them.
Melissa Anderson Sweazy is a screenwriter, podcaster, and filmmaker based in Memphis, Tennessee. Her creative sweet spot is haunted houses and haunted people, best evidenced by YOU CAN SEE ME IN THE DARK, her monthly true ghost story podcast with listeners around the globe. The Sisters of Crimson House is her debut novel.
I’ve just finished The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy and I don’t really know what I just read, but I can’t stop thinking about it.
It’s a gothic mystery / dark family drama set around Crimson House, which is basically an old, unsettling house packed with secrets, tension, and generations of things nobody ever bothered to say out loud. From the start, everything feels slightly off in that “this family definitely needed therapy decades ago” kind of way.
The story follows the sisters connected to the house, and it’s just messy in a very deliberate way. Secrets, strained relationships, buried truths, and that constant feeling that no one is being fully honest with anyone else. Every time I thought I had a handle on what was going on, the story shifted again and I just had to go with it.
The atmosphere is easily one of the strongest parts. It’s so vivid and heavy that it practically clings to everything. I found myself getting properly immersed in the gloom of Crimson House, to the point where even normal house noises started feeling slightly suspicious. Probably fine. Probably.
The sisters themselves are brilliantly complicated. I kept changing my mind about them the whole way through. One moment I’d sympathise with one of them, the next I’d question everything they’d ever said. It felt like being stuck in a group chat where everyone is typing “it’s fine :)” and you absolutely know it is not fine at all.
Melissa Anderson’s writing is incredibly atmospheric and sharp. It’s beautiful in places, tense in others, and constantly shifting between emotional and unsettling without ever feeling forced. It really pulls you in and refuses to let the tone stay comfortable for too long.
Overall, I finished this feeling slightly unsettled, impressed, and still turning parts of it over in my head.
Thank you NetGalley, Sourcebooks, and the author Melissa Anderson for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Memphis, Tenessee. A woman is born into a family of psychics but never inherited their supernatural abilities while her sister Miranda is strongly gifted with such abilities. After a tragedy, Charley has a hard time keeping up with the house so she turns it into a haunted-house attraction and pretends to have psychic abilities. But.. the house is not a simple house, there is something sinister at its core.
*Just getting through my earlier ARCS*
This book is also featured on BOTM!
Many thanks to NetGalley, Sourcebook Landmark and the author, Melisa Anderson Sweazy for an early copy.
Many thanks to Sourcebooks Audio for an early ALC.
Narrator: Ann Marie Gideon Duration: 10 hours 42 minutes Speed: 1.75-2.25x, varies
Dripping with Southern Gothic horror, magic, and searing wit, THE SISTERS OF CRIMSON HOUSE grabbed my hand and would not let go. I fell in love with the tragic Bryde family and know you will too— but be sure to read with *all* the lights turned on!
I’d give The Sisters of Crimson House 3.5 stars. The story follows the Bryde family, a psychic and magical family brought together largely because of their grandmother’s influence and legacy. The family dynamics were easily the most interesting part of the book, especially since nearly everyone has some kind of unique talent — except for Charley, who often feels like the outsider among them.
The beginning was definitely slow, and it took a while for the story to really pull me in. There’s a lot of setup with the family history and relationships, which made the pacing drag at first. However, once the plot started moving, the story became much more engaging. The mystery, magic, and family tension all started to come together in a way that kept me interested.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read with an intriguing magical family at its center, even if it took some patience to get there. If you like stories about complicated families, hidden abilities, and supernatural elements, this one is worth checking out.
Charley lives with her psychic sister, Miranda, and they come from a long line of famous psychics… But Charley does not have the gift. Eventually, a tragedy happens, and Charley is living alone in the house. When she runs out of money, she feels her only option is to turn the house into a haunted attraction and feign her own psychic abilities.
With a skeptic hot on her trail, and then Miranda returning home, things at Crimson House come to a head, forcing the sisters to confront their family secrets. I loved the gothic vibes from Crimson House and the complexity of the characters. There’s a nice tension woven in, and overall, this was a fabulous read I’m still thinking about.
Charley Bryde is the only woman in a family of psychics who got absolutely nothing from the supernatural inheritance except the mortgage, and somehow SHE is the one everybody expects to keep the haunted mansion alive. Every other Bryde woman gets visions, spirits, magical abilities, mysterious family importance. Charley gets bills and resentment. Honestly, if I were her, I would also be fake-reading tarot cards for tourists and daring the ancestors to complain.
Crimson House has been the center of this family’s whole psychic mythology for generations, and Charley has spent her life standing next to women who were treated like they had been personally selected by the universe. Miranda, especially, was the gifted one. The shiny one. The sister who could channel spirits while Charley was basically standing off to the side like, cool, I guess I’ll handle logistics. You can feel how long that wound has been festering.
Then everything goes to hell. A terrible family tragedy blows the Brydes apart, Miranda disappears, the family scatters, and Charley is left trying to keep Crimson House standing while also keeping herself from completely unraveling. The money starts disappearing, the house is slipping away, and she turns the place into a haunted attraction because apparently capitalism has now entered the ghost business. Fake scares in a real haunted house. Tarot readings from the only non-psychic Bryde. Truly no one is doing irony like this family. And then Sy shows up to expose her as a fraud.
Sir. Technically, yes. She is lying. Congratulations on the journalism. Unfortunately, you have picked the one fake psychic currently living in a house that is very much NOT fake-haunted, so maybe hold your little clipboard loosely. Charley already has enough problems without some skeptic sniffing around her family history, and naturally his arrival starts cracking open exactly the stuff everybody worked very hard to bury.
Then Miranda comes home after EIGHT YEARS, and I need to stress how wildly unacceptable this is in sister time. You do not vanish for nearly a decade, reappear in the haunted family mansion, and expect one difficult conversation to cover it. Charley is furious. Charley is relieved. Charley still loves her. Charley also clearly wants to throw her into a decorative cabinet. Every scene between them has that very specific sister energy where the fight is about one thing but also somehow about every Christmas since childhood.
And Miranda is hard to deal with because she has spent her whole life being the gifted one everyone protected, while Charley became the person who stayed and handled the fallout. So whenever Miranda starts talking about protecting Charley, I am right there with Charley thinking, interesting strategy, disappearing for eight years and leaving her with the family haunted house. Bold.
Meanwhile Crimson House is getting angrier, which honestly feels earned. This family has dumped grief, lies, betrayal, old magic, and unspoken resentment into the walls for generations and then acted shocked when the building develops a personality disorder. Every room feels like it knows something. Every hallway feels like it is waiting for someone to admit the truth. At some point I stopped thinking of it as a haunted house and started thinking of it as the only Bryde family member willing to escalate.
The family secrets kept me in it because every time I thought I had a handle on what happened, another little piece slid into place and made everybody look worse. The timeline hopping took me a minute, and there were stretches where I wanted someone to stop speaking in ominous half-sentences and just explain the damn family history in chronological order. But once it started locking together, I was fully in the mess.
What got me was Charley realizing how much of her whole identity came from being the one who supposedly had nothing. She grew up believing magic was proof of worth, and because she did not have it, she made herself useful instead. Useful enough to keep the house. Useful enough to keep the family name alive. Useful enough to survive being left behind. That hurt. No joke. Moving on.
The Sisters of Crimson House lands at 3.5 stars for me. I wanted the story to sink its claws in a little sooner, but once the family secrets, the hauntings, Sy, Miranda, and the old Spectacular mess all started colliding, I was seated. Charley is messy and defensive in ways that made sense. Miranda is gifted and withholding in ways that made me want to shake her. Crimson House is basically an unpaid therapist with structural damage.
Whodunity Award: For Making the Only Fake Psychic in the Family the One Person Most Willing to Call Everyone Else on Their Bullshit
Huge thanks to SOURCEBOOKS Landmark and NetGalley for the ARC, and for inviting me into a house where the tarot readings are fake, the ghosts are real, and every Bryde woman thinks “I kept this from you to protect you” is a complete sentence. Please get these people a therapist before the wallpaper starts giving testimony.
Thank you to Source Landmark and Netgalley for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
Oh, how I wanted to love this. It was the perfect set up for the season; spooky house, psychic sisters, and a mystery to unravel that spanned generations. And then, it just didn’t work. The family dynamic was tough to read, with a heavy dose of the animosity between the sisters. I didn’t quite understand the underlying premise which was either something to do with the absent sister and some entity that entered her, or something about the family itself being cursed. The characters themselves felt held back from the storyline as well. As soon as we started to get to know one of the sisters, we jumped back in time. This one had tons of potential, but between the characters being distant and the uneven pacing, I struggled to finish it.
The Sisters of Crimson House tells the story of the Bryde Family and the history of their time at Crimson House. Theirs is a family with generations of women with psychic powers that are legendary in the city of Memphis. That is until Charley is born without her hand being marked with the star shared by all the women in her lineage.
The book's opening pages quickly draw the reader in with a scene from the family's annual Halloween Spectacular gathering and their powerful psychic ability on display. Unfortunately, the pace only slows from here and drags throughout the rest of the book. The central premise of family secrets that are slowly revealed is promising, but the narrative seems scattered.
An interesting theme that runs throughout the book that I wish had been better woven into the main narrative is the focus on tarot cards and the various meanings that arise when a reading is done.
Overall this is a good book that could have been better.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advance reading copy.
Charley comes from a family of psychics but never inherited their gift, so she turns her family’s mansion into a haunted attraction to keep it afloat. When her sister returns after years away, family secrets start coming to light.
The Sisters of Crimson House started off strong for me. I was drawn into the atmosphere and felt like I was actually inside Crimson House. However, the frequent time jumps left me feeling a bit lost at times and made it harder to stay immersed. Overall, I enjoyed the concept, but I wish the story had flowed a little more smoothly.
This book was so moving and I just ate it up. I really love southern gothic books, there is just something about them that I love so much. I really enjoyed that this book was about a family of psychics and had dual timelines. I really felt for Charley because she was the one without the gift when everyone around here did. I also admired how entrepreneurial she was by turning the house into an attraction. The pacing was really well done, it was more fast paced than I typically expect from this genre, but it didn’t distract from my enjoyment at all. This book was a delight to listen to on audio, and I also followed along in the hardback. The narrator did such an amazing job bringing the story to life and adding that extra element of enjoyment.
Soooo this one… 😬 I hate when a book and I just don't vibe, especially when everyone else is loving it.
I went in expecting ALL the spooky gothic goodness with a dash of supernatural vibes, but this leaned a little too cozy for my mood. It had some serious Charmed vibes, which I loved, but the pacing was just a bit too slow for me, and honestly, I felt like I was constantly wondering WTF was going on. 🤣
HOWEVER, the audiobook narrator did a fantastic job! Honestly, listening to the audio is probably the reason I stuck with this one until the end. 🎧
Charley Bryde has spent her life living in the shadow of her psychic family, especially her gifted older sister. When tragedy threatens their beloved Crimson House, Charley turns the family mansion into a haunted attraction to keep it afloat. But between a skeptical newcomer, her sister's unexpected return, and long-buried family secrets, Charley discovers there's much more hiding behind Crimson House's doors than she ever imagined.
Not every book is going to be our cup of tea, and that's okay! But tell me… am I missing something here, or did anyone else feel this way?
🧹🪄🧙 A charming, atmospheric, and delightfully unpredictable read that delivers rich Practical Magic vibes. While its complex structure demands high concentration and a bit of patience, its inventive plotting and strong character dynamics make it a rewarding experience for attentive readers.
Key Takeaways: Atmospheric & Unpredictable: Masterfully captures a cozy, supernatural ambiance with sharp, unexpected plot twists and dialogue. Jarring Timelines: Non-linear structural shifts can temporarily disrupt narrative flow and cause brief confusion. Underused Ensemble: Strong supporting characters would benefit from having their own designated point-of-view chapters. Requires Focus: Complex exposition means important details are easy to miss, rewarding close attention and second reads.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I liked it. I wanted to love it but it fell a little short for me.
This is a gothic tale of two sisters who come from a family of gifted psychics. There’s a spooky mansion, some witchcraft, tarot and some fun side characters. Oh, and also ghosts. Things got a little confusing at times, but I enjoyed the story for the most part.
The Sisters of Crimson House is a southern gothic horror that dives into the occult and follows Charley, a woman from a family of psychics who harbor a legacy and a dark secret.
To say that I loved this novel would be an understatement. If you're a fan of The September House and Practical Magic, THIS ONE'S FOR YOU.
The book starts at a pivotal moment in the story and if I'm being fully transparent, it took me a little while to adjust to the third person narrative. There is a bit of a dual timeline as well which caused me to backtrack just a bit. This would be the only reason to dock half a star of what would be for me, a five-star read.
The struggles that Charley goes through as the "black sheep" of the family, keeping the legacy and the family house afloat after the tragedy(ies) was something that I could understand and resonate with. Being a sister myself, the relationship between Charley and Miranda simply broke my heart in the best way. Their journey was something filled with unconditional love, and it reflected the complications of protecting the people who matter the most.
I absolutely loved the Crimson House and it haunts. It brought me back to my love of haunted houses and ghosts who roam around stuck in the in-between. This book will definitely leave you feeling uneasy, spooked and eager for more!
Overall, this was wonderfully written. You can tell this book was written from a place of love. As a debut novel, Melissa Sweazy did a fantastic job, and I would absolutely read any of her future work.
Thank you so much to NetGalley, SOURCEBOOKS Landmark and Melissa Anderson Sweazy for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
I enjoyed the storyline and the characters. I think the pacing keep me interested. I got the audio of the book and it was done by a master. I felt so immersed into the story and cared about the characters which is a sign of a good narration.
Thank you Sources Books for the chance to listen to this one!
I loved the creepy gothic vibes, and the chilling atmosphere of Crimson House. The dual timelines in Charley’s POV unraveled the story of what haunts her and her family at the perfect pace. The narration portrayed the creepy mood and scary scenes perfectly. This is a great read for fans of creepy thrillers or horror looking for a spooky Halloween read. Thank you, @sourcebooks.audio, @libro.fm, @bookmarked, and @melissaasweazy for the gifted ebook and ALC.
Read this for bookstore book club! A good read to get me in the spooky mood this week. I enjoyed the characters but I wish the characterization dug a bit deeper. The plot was intriguing but there was some elements that I was confused by. If they were to adapt this, I’d watch!
The Sisters of Crimson House took me out of my comfort zone, which is exactly what I’ve been trying to do as a reader and listener. Challenge myself, and explore stories I might not normally choose.
I finished this a couple days ago, and I am still thinking about the incredible atmosphere of the story. From the very beginning, I was completely drawn into the mystery of the house and the women connected to it. The setting feels alive, full of history and a lingering sense of mystery, which made the experience truly immersive.
What resonated with me most was the relationship between the sisters. Their bond felt authentic and complicated, and I found myself deeply invested in their journey as they uncovered secrets that had been hidden for far too long. The story does a beautiful job of balancing the suspense of a mystery with the emotional weight of family and grief.
Melissa Anderson Sweazy, is a brand new author to me, but boy does she have gift for descriptive writing. She creates a balanced, reflective pace that allows the tension to build naturally, and I loved the challenge of piecing together the clues. A few twists genuinely surprised me, which made the payoff even more satisfying.
I listened to the audiobook narrated by Ann Marie Gideon, and she brought a wonderful touch to the story. Her narration was clear, and she captured the mood perfectly, especially during the more somber or eerie moments. While I wouldn’t call this a traditional horror novel, it definitely explores darker themes, making it a perfect choice for anyone looking for a moody, spooky-season read.
If you love gothic mysteries, rich settings, and stories about the complicated ties of family, I highly recommend adding this one to your list. It was a heartfelt and memorable read that kept me guessing until the very end.
4.5🔮 Thank you to Sourcebooks Audio, LibroFM, and the author for this #giftedARC. As always, my thoughts and opinions are my own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Sadly, this missed the mark for me. I didn’t know what was going on, everything was just so confusing, and this time around, I didn’t like it. It’s probably a me thing because there are plenty of people who really enjoyed it apparently. This air of mystery the book wanted to give off didn’t really hit for me for some reason. It’s not quite a horror book, I feel like it’s trying to do that but I don’t think it’s succeeding very well. The atmosphere is probably the one thing this book did semi-right. It’s supposed to be its strength, its main attribute, and I feel like I could see it. I can acknowledge potential when I see it. However, that’s just it. I can see potential, not a well defined situation. The air of mystery I previously mentioned was just a bit too much for me. It just got confusing, there’s a lot of going back and forth, we’ve got secrets, a family that’s got something going on that we as readers are supposed to be invested in. If there’s one thing that’s memorable though, it’s the characters. The Brydes have that something that keeps you engaged amongst all the confusion. But that did not prove to be enough this time, I’m sorry to say. The writing was also just fever dream-y, it didn’t really gel with me right. And I’m sure this book has its audience, in fact I know it does, I’m not sure that audience includes me. It was just… forgettable. And in this situation it’s really not hard to forget this book, all information retained from this novel was already very much scattered around in my brain as I was reading it. Most of it is already gone, wiped out of my mind. But there was potential. And I believe this is this author’s debut novel? And while I wasn’t the biggest fan, there are probably double the amount of fans of this book out there. I’d give this a low three star, middle of the road book, wouldn’t necessarily recommend, it wasn’t really for me. Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
A slow‑burn paranormal with lots of timeline jumps, The Sisters of Crimson House had an intriguing premise, but the pacing didn’t fully work for me. It was very slow.
Ann Marie Gideon delivered a strong narration, but something about it just didnt work.
This book sounded so much better in theory than it turned out to be. I struggled to care about any of the characters, and the alternating timelines made the story feel choppy and disjointed. The setting and concept were fun, but it definitely left a lot to be desired and I gave up just over halfway through.
Most haunted-house novels begin with an arrival: somebody inherits, somebody buys, somebody takes the caretaking job against advice. The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy begins with somebody who has been inside eight years and cannot afford to leave. Charley Bryde is twenty-two, her grandmother three months dead, the third-storey turret under a blue plastic tarp she keeps forgetting to secure, and the city has just wrapped the porch in caution tape because those stairs will eventually kill a guest. The ghosts are not the problem. The ghosts are the revenue.
That position is what separates The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy from the fifty other Southern gothics published this autumn. The Bryde women have been Memphis royalty for four generations: each born with a Seeker's Star scarred into her palm, each with a different gift, each putting on an annual Halloween demonstration the city's wealthy paid serious money to attend. Charley is the only Bryde born with a blank hand. She reads tarot in a hotel bar, cold-reads well enough that nobody asks, and runs a ghost-tour outfit with two friends to service a mansion that eats every dollar it generates.
The Sisters of Crimson House Is Really a Book About Money
Sweazy's best decision is to treat the supernatural as a line of business with a cash-flow problem. Tickets are fifty dollars. Twenty sell, then two hundred, and the difference is one catastrophic morning-television appearance and a post on a social network that will be dead within the decade. Wine comes cheap via a bartender at the Peabody. A local anchor gets a comped seat because she used to be a client. There are not enough chairs for the audience, and the fire marshal is a running joke with genuine teeth.
None of this is played for quirk; it is the pressure of the plot. A haunted house that has to pay for itself behaves differently from one that merely broods, and in The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy every choice Charley makes is legible as a business decision taken by someone with no other options. When her sister comes home after eight years abroad, Charley's first coherent thought is that the great Miranda Bryde is the only Bryde who can reliably sell a ticket.
Inside Crimson House, Melissa Anderson Sweazy Keeps the Lights On
The neighbours are the other pressure. Howard and Peyton Lovell live next door in a gleaming Victorian stuffed with china and prop books whose price tags are still on the spines, and Howard chairs a nonprofit founded, in his own words, to save the street from people like her. Their offer is generous. Their tone is a warm hand on the arm and the suggestion that Charley is being saved from herself. It is a precise satire of preservation as a polite method of removal, and Sweazy is good enough not to make them monsters: they are people who believe a work of art should not be left with a child.
Then there is the escalation engine of The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy, which is genuinely elegant. Lines begin appearing on Charley's palm, one at a time, cut into the skin and bleeding. Each new line switches on another woman's gift: first the dead who have always walked these halls become visible, then she can do what her sister does, then what her grandmother did, then something nobody in the family ever managed. The mark she has grieved her whole life is assembling itself, and every instalment costs blood. A clean structure for a horror novel: a progress bar you do not want filled.
The Sisters of Crimson House Earns Its Best Scene on Live Television
One sequence justifies the book. Charley and her sister go on a local morning show to plug the revived Halloween event, opposite a co-host who has decided they are frauds and possibly Satanists. Mid-interview a new line opens on her palm and she can hear exactly what he is thinking about her. What she does with that, on air, is funny and ugly and entirely in character, and it sells out the show.
The other pleasure of The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy is the deck. Charley reads with her mother's cards, and at one point they stop behaving: the Tower is Crimson House with lightning striking the turret, the Death card has acquired a rider with her sister's hair. Then she looks again and they are ordinary cards, and the skeptic across the table saw nothing. Sweazy is very good at the horror of being the only witness.
Where Melissa Anderson Sweazy Gives Ground
Four things keep The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy from the top of the pile.
The romance and the plot run on one engine. Every line on Charley's palm appears when Sy Prescott, the skeptic chasing a hundred-thousand-dollar prize for disproving her family, touches her hand. The book has to keep manufacturing contact, so the attraction reads as mechanism rather than feeling. His shift from believing her family destroyed his to kissing her in her grandmother's study takes two scenes. One chapter carries the entire mythology. Late on, an aunt sits Charley down and explains the entity, the day of her birth, why her sister was made its keeper, and why the outcome was fixed. Everything before has been better at showing than telling, so the seminar feels like a different book. The middle sags on eviction logistics. Letters, the neighbourhood council, offer, counter-offer, the same argument on the same lawn. The climax reaches for a gun. After three hundred pages of restraint, the resolution arrives as a gunshot, and the aftermath of who fired it is settled a year later in two paragraphs of mutual agreement not to press charges. Read It If, Skip It If
The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy knows precisely who it is for.
Read it if:
You want a haunted house with a ledger, and a heroine whose supernatural crisis is also a small-business crisis. Sisters who love and resent each other in equal measure is your engine. You like a gothic that is funny on purpose.
Skip it if:
You need mythology delivered in pieces, not in one conversation. Slow-burn attraction between antagonists is a hard no. A first half of tours, letters and family history will lose you. Content Notes
An elderly woman murdered in a bath, her hand mutilated. Strangulation. A stabbing in front of an audience. A gunshot wound causing permanent paralysis. A woman pushed into a bonfire. The poisoning of an innocent. A body weighted and sunk in a river. A skull concealed in a wall. A child struck by a car. Drowning. Parental death and long grief. Repeated possession. Drink-driving. A care-system childhood, and child neglect. Frequent profanity.
What Stays With You
The grandmother's gift was psychometry, the claimed ability to hold an object and read the life that passed through it, and Sweazy uses it better than the showier powers in the family. When Charley inherits it, the visions arrive as full-body occupancy: inside someone else's fear, at someone else's window, watching a car roll down a driveway with its lights off. Sweazy, a Memphis screenwriter, films these rather than describing them, and they are the most frightening pages here.
What stays is not the entity, a woman in black with a sword who does her job. What stays is the arithmetic. Charley spends the novel begging for the mark that proves she belongs to her family, and the book is honest enough to let her have it and then present the bill. The Sisters of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy has a saggy middle and one chapter of pure explanation, and it is still the sharpest haunted-house debut of the season, because it knows the scariest thing about an inheritance is what came attached.
After reading the book's details I was excited to have the opportunity to read and provide an honest review of The Sisters Of Crimson House by Melissa Anderson Sweazy from NetGalley and SOURCEBOOKS Landmark.
Frankly this has not been the easiest book to read. The plot is fairly simple. Two sisters, Miranda and Charley, born into a family having psychic abilities come together after many years of inner turmoil with each other to save their family's home and reputation as well as each other's lives. What seemed to be a "very straight forward" story turned out to be anything but that.
The story jumps between past and present timelines which are identifiable only by the Chapter headings with calendar dates. The dialogue was at times confusing with respect to which character was speaking and to whom. Focusing on dialogue to bring characters to life was a good choice especially in terms of relatability however I would have preferred both the characters and the plot unfold at the same time together.
For me Sweazy overused the secrecy aspect of her story. I believe I was two thirds into the book before any real mention began to reveal the mystery at the heart of the story. That's quite a bit of reading without knowing what's going on for my liking. I'm not an author but it seems common sense to me that you would want to give your readers an idea to your plot long before the closing chapters.
Struggling through the slow paced story when combined with a lack of significant details to push the story forward was a definite impediment to a satisfying reading experience. If not for my stubborn belief that there is always a purpose behind an author's choices I would have put The Sisters Of Crimson House in my "books I did not finish" pile.
Thank you Landmark & Netgalley for providing an early copy in exchange for an honest review! :)
🌟 2/5 Stars
I unfortunately did not enjoy this nearly as much as I was expecting to. I wouldn't even say that I disliked it but it was a rough read. I was bored out of my mind for majority of the book and I pushed through hoping it would get better and more interesting. It did... in like the last 8%, which doesn't help its case. I was speeding through books on the side while trying to get through this and it felt like a chore each time I decided to open it up and continue. Slooooow is an understatement, things are happening but it feels like it takes so much time to get anywhere meaningful. I already lost interest by the time it started doing anything interesting, which was past the halfway point. The constant switching timelines also made the already slow pacing feel even worse. I enjoyed the characters and Miranda and Charley's dynamic, I thought the conclusion was really nice. It's not a terrible debut and I would urge anyone who's really interested in this kind of book to give it a chance. Just because it didn't work for me doesn't necessarily mean it's bad, I did like what it was trying to do.
A twisting, turning saga full of deeply buried secrets, magic born of blood, and the extent we’ll go to in the name of family. I found myself immersed.
I received a free copy from Sourcebooks Landmark via Netgalley in exchange for a fair review. Release date September 29th, 2026.
I'm back to trawling through Gothic house horror. In The Sisters of Crimson House, Charley is the only one without a gift in her family of psychic women. After a catastrophic Halloween party leaves her family in ruins, Charley is left to mourn—until a prying skeptic disturbs old family secrets.
This book dabbles with several elements, like the sinister Crimson House crumbling despite Charley's best efforts, Charley gaining the psychic powers she always wanted, and a minor romance plotline with Cy the skeptic. But the heart of the story Charley's bitter jealousy that her medium sister is special and she is not. The Sisters of Crimson House asks what if Charley was more special, and she had magic powers too. Besides the meanspirited jealousy, the other story elements don't have the strength to drive the narrative. The romance is barely there, Charley's cool magic powers are backgrounded except for a few visions, and the house and the general setting don't have much in the way of brooding atmosphere. It's not even about family, since most of Charley's was killed in the flashback chapters. If the book isn't going to commit to the horror, I'm not sure why we're here.
The overall pacing focuses more on the questions than the answers, with the actual reveals left very late. This is a book that's content to noodle around asking what if... there was a sinister curse on the Bryde family... what if... Charley could have powers too... without pulling any triggers for a very long time. We're not focused on the consequences of these developments, we're focused on the mere possibility. In the end, Sisters of Crimson House only has one big reveal to play. And some of the plot points in the interim were flawed—I was baffled by the concept that Charley could be "evicted" from the house her family owns by the HOA. Fined to death, yes, condemned by the city, yes, but evicted like a renter?
In the end, I think this book never quite commits to any of its component genres. It's not a horror story, or a romance, or a mystery, or even a novel about messy family. Without the direction of genre, Charley's jealousy isn't compelling enough to hold up the entire book. For a different take on modern, grimy, horror-tinged fantasy, I think Holly Black's Charlie in Book of Night addresses these themes better.
Join us for for an evening where we peer through the vail and invite the passengers within to share knowledge, delight, and entertainment…”
🍂
The Sisters of Crimson House by: Melissa Anderson Sweazy is pitched as The Fall of The House of Usher meets Practical Magic ✨
The beginning and opening of this starts with such a bang and a WHOLE vibe. As you get your flier of The Spectacular held at Crimson House hosted on Halloween night. The first chapter is us among the crowd as we watch the spectacular happen. A family filled with magic as they put it on show. But not some magician type show, one challenging the dead.
I LOVED how it opens. I loved every second we got any of the Bryde family lore and any of the discriptions of Crimson House.
However, for me, as the story continued it lost me. There’s going to be a kind of mystery that takes place and maybe some will enjoy it but I just wanted more of the family and what we get in the fist chapter and the chapters that took place in the past. I wanted the spooky elements and what I felt while being in the beginning of this story.
I could see a certain kind of reader really enjoying this more than I did. However, I am not that reader. Although I didn’t predict the ending and where the story went, it didn’t really make me feel surprised or excited to keep uncovering it personally.
I also didn’t feel to connected with the characters and I’m sure that effected how I felt reading this as well.
If you enjoy a spooky atmosphere, a family drama steeped in lore and magic, with a mystery to uncover than this might just be one worth trying for you. 🩶
Thank you to the publisher, Sourcebooks, for my gifted ARC copy. 🩶✨
Thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the gifted ebook.
My Review
How cool would it be to have a psychic sister and come from a family filled with psychics? Well, maybe not quite as cool if you're Charley, the one person in the family who didn't get the gift. I really enjoyed that part of her character because she has always felt like the outcast while her sister Miranda is the psychic one. There is already so much friction between these sisters, and then you add their family history and Crimson House into everything.
This did start a little slow for me, and it took me some time to really get into the story. But once things started picking up, I was sucked right in. I wanted to know what happened between Charley and Miranda, what their family had been hiding, and exactly what was going on inside Crimson House. I really enjoyed the mix of family secrets, psychics, tarot, and the creepy house itself. There was a lot happening between these sisters, and watching everything start to come out kept me reading.
Would I Recommend?
Yes. If you enjoy creepy houses, psychics, tarot, family secrets, and complicated relationships between sisters, I think you'll have fun with this one. Just give it a little time in the beginning because once it picked up, it completely pulled me in.
Perfect book for spooky season! This is southern gothic reading with paranormal elements. Set right around Halloween. Perfect reading for anyone who likes to sync up reading time with real world time. This is the story of the Bryde sisters. The sisters are blessed with gifts that allow them to heal, predict the future, find lost souls and even communicate with the dead. Tarot reading is a daily thing for this family. Starts with the annual Halloween Spectacular that displays the talents of multiple generations of this family. The family is feared a little bit but mostly respected until that fateful Halloween night. Flash forward a few years and Charley is trying to hold onto the family house, The Crimson House, on the earnings of an early twentysomething. Most of her relatives scattered after that night including her beloved older sister Miranda. Charley leans heavily into the family reputation as conduits to the spiritual world and offers ghost tours of the house and readings. Things unravel even further when Miranda returns. Added into the mix is a skeptic who hunts those who make false claims about supernatural abilities.
Charley is struggling in so many ways. She is a typical twentysomething but also not. She is the one Bryde sister without magical bilities, She is really good at faking it. She struggles with guilt and grief along with how to keep food on the table and pay the bills. She has some great friends who run the ghost tours. These are great side characters. Charley is relatable. She is young and flawed, but anyone who grew up in that family would be! Told through Charley's perspective in past and present. We see events leading up to that Halloween and time after. These women are complicated. There is a reason Charley doesn't have abilities and many reasons for the actions of the other women. It is layered and filled with trauma. Very unsettling and atmospheric. Not scary or gory. Just al the spooky elements I want in a fall book. The mystery underneath everything is complex. You have to be willing to accept supernatural elements. The why behind everything made me feel for these women. At times each of them appeared to be a terrible sister, aunt, grandmother,etc, but as the onion layers were peeled and motives and actions explained, they were relatable and oh so very human and fallible.