What do you think?
Rate this book
Shadows Over Mountain Meadows: A look at the 1857 massacre and its long afterlife
A wagon train accepted a promise of safety.
What followed was one of the most devastating betrayals in American history.
Mountain Meadows was not an accident. It was a choice.
In September 1857, more than one hundred men, women, and children traveling through southern Utah were killed after surrendering under a white flag. For generations, the truth of what happened in that high mountain valley was buried beneath silence, fear, and blame shifted onto others. This non-fiction book brings the full story into the open.
Shadows Over Mountain Meadows is a deeply researched, carefully written historical account of the Mountain Meadows Massacre and its long aftermath. Drawing on primary documents, survivor testimony, trial records, government reports, and the full confession of John D. Lee, this book reconstructs not only how the massacre happened, but why it was allowed to remain hidden for so long.
This is not a sensationalized retelling. It is a sober examination of human fear, authority, loyalty, and moral collapse.
Inside this book, readers will
• The five-day siege that preceded the massacre
• The decision to use a truce as a weapon
• How women and children were deliberately targeted
• Why only the youngest children were spared
• The creation and endurance of a false narrative
• The delayed pursuit of justice and its limits
• The lives of the survivors and their descendants
• The long struggle over memory, blame, and accountability
• The role of silence, obedience, and fear in shaping events
• How the massacre continues to echo in modern history
This book does not attempt to excuse the crime. It does not seek easy villains or comforting conclusions. Instead, it confronts the massacre as a human tragedy shaped by real people making catastrophic decisions under pressure.
Shadows Over Mountain Meadows also follows the story beyond the killing field. It traces how the event was remembered, misremembered, denied, debated, and finally memorialized. It examines how communities protect themselves, how truth is delayed, and how history eventually resurfaces.
Written with respect for the victims and clarity for the reader, this book is intended for those who want more than a headline or a simplified explanation. It is for readers who believe that understanding the past honestly is the only way to prevent its repetition.
This is not just a story about what happened in 1857.
It is a story about what people are capable of when fear overrides conscience.
What followed was one of the most devastating betrayals in American history.
Mountain Meadows was not an accident. It was a choice.
In September 1857, more than one hundred men, women, and children traveling through southern Utah were killed after surrendering under a white flag. For generations, the truth of what happened in that high mountain valley was buried beneath silence, fear, and blame shifted onto others. This non-fiction book brings the full story into the open.
Shadows Over Mountain Meadows is a deeply researched, carefully written historical account of the Mountain Meadows Massacre and its long aftermath. Drawing on primary documents, survivor testimony, trial records, government reports, and the full confession of John D. Lee, this book reconstructs not only how the massacre happened, but why it was allowed to remain hidden for so long.
This is not a sensationalized retelling. It is a sober examination of human fear, authority, loyalty, and moral collapse.
Inside this book, readers will
• The five-day siege that preceded the massacre
• The decision to use a truce as a weapon
• How women and children were deliberately targeted
• Why only the youngest children were spared
• The creation and endurance of a false narrative
• The delayed pursuit of justice and its limits
• The lives of the survivors and their descendants
• The long struggle over memory, blame, and accountability
• The role of silence, obedience, and fear in shaping events
• How the massacre continues to echo in modern history
This book does not attempt to excuse the crime. It does not seek easy villains or comforting conclusions. Instead, it confronts the massacre as a human tragedy shaped by real people making catastrophic decisions under pressure.
Shadows Over Mountain Meadows also follows the story beyond the killing field. It traces how the event was remembered, misremembered, denied, debated, and finally memorialized. It examines how communities protect themselves, how truth is delayed, and how history eventually resurfaces.
Written with respect for the victims and clarity for the reader, this book is intended for those who want more than a headline or a simplified explanation. It is for readers who believe that understanding the past honestly is the only way to prevent its repetition.
This is not just a story about what happened in 1857.
It is a story about what people are capable of when fear overrides conscience.
528 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 19, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
June 22, 2026
Mountain Meadows Detailed
This book is very well researched and contains a lot of information. However I found it extremely repetitive. The chapters leading up to the massacre outline the factors that contribute to the Mormons committing the massacre. These chapters could have easily been summarized and condensed. Similarly after the massacre Hicks talks about the children that survived. I don’t know how many times he mentions that the children could have recognized clothing and other items looted from the wagons. Again, this part of the book was very repetitive.
If you’re looking for a detailed account of Mountain Meadows I would recommend this book. I am a non-Mormon living in an area with a large Mormon population. I found this book interesting and informative.
This book is very well researched and contains a lot of information. However I found it extremely repetitive. The chapters leading up to the massacre outline the factors that contribute to the Mormons committing the massacre. These chapters could have easily been summarized and condensed. Similarly after the massacre Hicks talks about the children that survived. I don’t know how many times he mentions that the children could have recognized clothing and other items looted from the wagons. Again, this part of the book was very repetitive.
If you’re looking for a detailed account of Mountain Meadows I would recommend this book. I am a non-Mormon living in an area with a large Mormon population. I found this book interesting and informative.
Displaying 1 of 1 review