Still reading, but some fascinating data so far on the conflation of statistics and long-term academic success (I.e. schools where the author shows that astronomical HS graduation rates and aspirational missions to prepare students for post-secondary success do not actually translate to college attendance and graduation rates.) In fact, he further shows that this data holds true nationally, as only a third of students will actually graduate with a bachelors degree. So if missions aren’t being achieved, then are they missions at all or false north stars?
As a parent, I’ve thought a lot about my role. At some point, we’re less of a guide and more of an advisor. And as miserable as it is to watch it happen, I want my kids to navigate hurdles so that they’re better positioned to problem solve through life without me. Those hard moments have been where I know I have learned what better looks like, and I’m endlessly grateful for the teachers/mentors/advisors that cared enough and gave me the space to help me grow. To help me achieve what I’m capable of, and what a realistic outcome is for me. I want to trust our public institutions and teachers to hold students to standards that challenge them to achieve that potential, but don’t guarantee it. Success isn’t a one-size-fits-all scenario, and I think that’s a healthier, more balanced way to view education.
I want to thank CL Kallis for exploring things that are hard for us all to think about, and for challenging us to be both realistic and rigorous. Failing isn’t the failure, but never truly trying certainly is.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This book started with a punch in the face and ended with a kick in the butt! It is everything we teachers cannot say! It does lay blame, rightfully so, but a few paragraphs later, they outline how each stakeholder can hold up their end of the bargain.
As the dedication says, it is for teachers, parents, administrators, and students. As this is a new book, it'll be interesting to see how it is received. This could be a big one!