The worst book I read this year. I bought this book because I am very intrested in the idea of Alchemy and the book itself was stunning. But upon reading it, I can say that I actually know less about Alchemy than before reading the book itself.
There dosent appear to be any form of linear structure, no over arching narrative, no themes to be explored. This book is compiled of random concepts of Alchemy and provide an extremely piss poor dialog of said concepts.
Most of the chapters are filled with pictures with horrible context of what is going on within the pictures, but there is no analysis. No explanation of the symbolism, just a vague abstract connotation sidelining a very confusing photo.
The author essentially, never takes the abstract art contained within Alchemical works and distill's the art into applicable understanding. To put simply, if you ask someone to translate Spanish into English, but they use Spanish and no English in order to explain what they are saying. That's not translating, thats not conveying an understanding of the material, that's parroting.
Its similar to takeing an abstract painting, and just labeling the surface level observations, but never explaining them or placing any form of interpretation. It makes me question if even the author comprehended what he wrote if he never put ANY observstions down.
"the essence of God is like a wheel, the more one looks at the wheel, the more one learns about it its shape, and the more one learns, the greater pleasure one has in the wheel" The author quoted someone at the start of the chapter and yes this is the exact quote. (misspellings and all) I understand what this quote is trying to imply, but this has to be the worst quote I have ever read in my entire life. There has to be a translation or cultural implication that does not translate well, because from my vantage point, this put me over the edge after reading around 500 pages of this dribble.
I read some reviews arleady, it appears that the general consensus is that many readers have no idea what this book is or what it may be trying to say. This has not stopped the book from receiving an astonishing 4/5 stars but I believe this occurred because people believe that if they dont understand what was written, it must be too far advanced for them. I could not disagree more.
The context of my rating, which expects a book to have a somewhat obvious beginning, middle, end, general reach ability for a wide audience, exploration of a theme/idea, and simply enjoyablity, this book deserves a 1/5.
No concept was explained and not a single average reader would be able to get something out of this confusing mess. Maybe im wrong, maybe an advanced philosophical Alchemist understood this book perfectly and im simply too "uninitiated" to ever grasp even a morsel of sheer complexity laid out in the symbolism contained within this book. Maybe this is on par with an advanced physics textbook and im just an idiot who can barely put 2 and 2 togther. Either way, for the 99% of uninitiated people, my review should keep you away from this book. For that 1% niche of modern day Alchemist's, please, be my guest, take a read and let me know if even you got something out of it.