What do you think?
Rate this book
Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle
When Pax McKell’s brother Lennox asks her for help to fund his hairbrained scheme to renovate a tumbledown Scottish castle, she fears it will only end in disaster.
But a lifetime of sister guilt, complicated family relationships and a general sense of malaise are enough for her to ignore her instincts. The castle in question, Dunaire Castle, was the seventeenth-century home to their ancestor, the Earl George McKell, so Pax can understand Lennox’s romantic notion that they should be the rightful owners and the ones to love it back to life.
Slowly and in ways Pax could never have expected, Dunaire Castle begins to reveal its secrets; secrets and choices that have shaped the lives of generations of her family. As the McKell story opens up to her, Pax realises that it’s in her hands to change the course of history and with it the course of her own life – if only she can work out how…
But a lifetime of sister guilt, complicated family relationships and a general sense of malaise are enough for her to ignore her instincts. The castle in question, Dunaire Castle, was the seventeenth-century home to their ancestor, the Earl George McKell, so Pax can understand Lennox’s romantic notion that they should be the rightful owners and the ones to love it back to life.
Slowly and in ways Pax could never have expected, Dunaire Castle begins to reveal its secrets; secrets and choices that have shaped the lives of generations of her family. As the McKell story opens up to her, Pax realises that it’s in her hands to change the course of history and with it the course of her own life – if only she can work out how…
260 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 19, 2026
About the author
Jane Lovering
44 books235 followersJane Lovering was born in Devon, England but, following extradition procedures, now lives in Yorkshire. She has five children, four cats, two dogs and doesn't believe in housework so the bacteria and dust are approaching sentience and now rank among the pets. Incidentally, she doesn’t believe in ironing either, and the children all learned self-defensive cookery at early ages. She works in a local school and also teaches creative writing, which are extreme ways of avoiding the washing up.
Published since 2008, she writes romantic comedies which are often described as ‘quirky’. One day she's going to find out what that means. Jane is a member of the Romantic Novelists' Association and has a first class honours degree in creative writing. In 2012, her novel Please Don't Stop the Music won the Romantic Novel of the Year Award by the RNA.
Published since 2008, she writes romantic comedies which are often described as ‘quirky’. One day she's going to find out what that means. Jane is a member of the Romantic Novelists' Association and has a first class honours degree in creative writing. In 2012, her novel Please Don't Stop the Music won the Romantic Novel of the Year Award by the RNA.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews
July 19, 2026
Pax knows she and her brother have bitten off more than they can chew when she sees their ancestral castle—the castle that is little more than a ruin and that they have just bought. But the ruin holds far more secrets than she could have bargained for...
Now, here's what I expected from the cover and the description: a present-day castle that has some issues but also a lot of potential, probably a romance, and oh, did I mention the present day? But it turns out that there is very little of the present day here: In very little time at all, Pax finds herself whisked off to another dimension...or at least another time.
Time-slip books are not something I've ever gravitated towards (though castle books are), and I'm honestly not sure this is one I'd have gone for if I'd realized that that was the direction it would go. Pax tumbles into something weird at the beginning of the book, and there was a while where I still thought that she'd get back to the present day sooner rather than later, but as it turned out...that was not to be. As it also turned out, I didn't really mind; it was a week when I desperately needed something light to read, and this fit the bill quite well. Pax isn't alone in the past—there's a group of archeological misfits with her, plus a whole bunch of people from the long-dead past who can't see the present-day group.
It makes for something quirky and a bit absurdist. I liked the characters—not all of them are fully fleshed out, but they do a remarkable job of being adults about the situation in which they've found themselves. There's a romance, but it's pretty low-key; much more of the book is really just figuring out what on earth is going on and of course how they get themselves out of their predicament. Go into it for the whimsy (and also to be grateful that you live in the present day) and with an open mind.
Somewhere between 3 and 4 stars; rounding up because it was a right-time, right-place kind of read for me.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
Now, here's what I expected from the cover and the description: a present-day castle that has some issues but also a lot of potential, probably a romance, and oh, did I mention the present day? But it turns out that there is very little of the present day here: In very little time at all, Pax finds herself whisked off to another dimension...or at least another time.
Time-slip books are not something I've ever gravitated towards (though castle books are), and I'm honestly not sure this is one I'd have gone for if I'd realized that that was the direction it would go. Pax tumbles into something weird at the beginning of the book, and there was a while where I still thought that she'd get back to the present day sooner rather than later, but as it turned out...that was not to be. As it also turned out, I didn't really mind; it was a week when I desperately needed something light to read, and this fit the bill quite well. Pax isn't alone in the past—there's a group of archeological misfits with her, plus a whole bunch of people from the long-dead past who can't see the present-day group.
It makes for something quirky and a bit absurdist. I liked the characters—not all of them are fully fleshed out, but they do a remarkable job of being adults about the situation in which they've found themselves. There's a romance, but it's pretty low-key; much more of the book is really just figuring out what on earth is going on and of course how they get themselves out of their predicament. Go into it for the whimsy (and also to be grateful that you live in the present day) and with an open mind.
Somewhere between 3 and 4 stars; rounding up because it was a right-time, right-place kind of read for me.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
July 22, 2026
What a great read - I was instantly hooked! Good story and very easy to follow, very likeable characters and a Scottish castle (what else does one need?). I thorougly enjoyed the time travel aspect and loved that we’re getting a glimpse into life back in 18th century Scotland with a teeny tiny bit of history lesson. It’s easy to get lost in the story – perfect to escape our own life for a bit.
This was the first books I’ve read by this author and it sure won’t be the last. Can’t wait to see what else she has in store.
Thank you to Boldwood Books, Jane Lovering and NetGalley for this ARC!
This was the first books I’ve read by this author and it sure won’t be the last. Can’t wait to see what else she has in store.
Thank you to Boldwood Books, Jane Lovering and NetGalley for this ARC!
August 2, 2026
⭐ 3.5
Oh, este libro fue bueno, la historia fue fácil de seguir y los personajes encantadores.
Todo se centra en Pax y en cómo, con su hermano compraron un castillo en las colinas escocesas y ella por cosas del destino termina en Escocia en pleno siglo 17 con un grupo de arqueólogos que ya tenían meses perdidos, hasta allí lo del viaje del tiempo me gusto ¿porque? porque la autora lo explico de muy buena manera, hay veces donde explican cada metodología, cada ley física que uno medio se pierde si no sabes del tema pero acá me gusto ya que como dije fue fácil.
Tanto ella y los arqueólogos NO saben porqué están allí solo que saben que están allí con un propósito, y sin decir mucho de la trama el propósito fue bueno, uno que se ve venir al principio pero entendible.
Mi único pero es que me lo venden o etiquetan como romance cuando de verdad no lo es, porque no vi nada de chispa o química entre el “interés amoroso” y nuestra protagonista, sus escenas eran más platónicas que románticas y eso me dejo con un final que aunque los disfrute no me terminó de convencer.
Para pasar el tiempo estuvo genial, y si te gustan los libros con viajes en el tiempo con propósitos, este libro seguro te gustara.
********
Oh, this book was good, the story was easy to follow and the characters were charming.
It all centers on Pax and how she and her brother bought a castle in the Scottish hills, and how, by a twist of fate, she ends up in 17th-century Scotland with a group of archaeologists who had already been missing for months. Up to that point, I liked the time-travel aspect—why? Because the author explained it really well. Sometimes they explain every method and every law of physics, and you can get a bit lost if you’re not familiar with the subject, but I liked it here because, as I said, it was easy to follow.
Neither she nor the archaeologists know why they’re there, they just know they’re there for a purpose. And without giving too much of the plot away, the purpose was good, one you can see coming from the start but is still understandable.
My only complaint is that they market it or label it as a romance when it really isn’t, because I didn’t see any spark or chemistry between the “love interest” and our protagonist; their scenes were more platonic than romantic, and that left me with an ending that, even though I enjoyed it, didn’t quite convince me.
It was great for passing the time, and if you like books about time travel with a purpose, you’ll definitely enjoy this one.
📌 I received an e-arc through netgalley, and this is my honest opinion/review of it.
Oh, este libro fue bueno, la historia fue fácil de seguir y los personajes encantadores.
Todo se centra en Pax y en cómo, con su hermano compraron un castillo en las colinas escocesas y ella por cosas del destino termina en Escocia en pleno siglo 17 con un grupo de arqueólogos que ya tenían meses perdidos, hasta allí lo del viaje del tiempo me gusto ¿porque? porque la autora lo explico de muy buena manera, hay veces donde explican cada metodología, cada ley física que uno medio se pierde si no sabes del tema pero acá me gusto ya que como dije fue fácil.
Tanto ella y los arqueólogos NO saben porqué están allí solo que saben que están allí con un propósito, y sin decir mucho de la trama el propósito fue bueno, uno que se ve venir al principio pero entendible.
Mi único pero es que me lo venden o etiquetan como romance cuando de verdad no lo es, porque no vi nada de chispa o química entre el “interés amoroso” y nuestra protagonista, sus escenas eran más platónicas que románticas y eso me dejo con un final que aunque los disfrute no me terminó de convencer.
Para pasar el tiempo estuvo genial, y si te gustan los libros con viajes en el tiempo con propósitos, este libro seguro te gustara.
********
Oh, this book was good, the story was easy to follow and the characters were charming.
It all centers on Pax and how she and her brother bought a castle in the Scottish hills, and how, by a twist of fate, she ends up in 17th-century Scotland with a group of archaeologists who had already been missing for months. Up to that point, I liked the time-travel aspect—why? Because the author explained it really well. Sometimes they explain every method and every law of physics, and you can get a bit lost if you’re not familiar with the subject, but I liked it here because, as I said, it was easy to follow.
Neither she nor the archaeologists know why they’re there, they just know they’re there for a purpose. And without giving too much of the plot away, the purpose was good, one you can see coming from the start but is still understandable.
My only complaint is that they market it or label it as a romance when it really isn’t, because I didn’t see any spark or chemistry between the “love interest” and our protagonist; their scenes were more platonic than romantic, and that left me with an ending that, even though I enjoyed it, didn’t quite convince me.
It was great for passing the time, and if you like books about time travel with a purpose, you’ll definitely enjoy this one.
📌 I received an e-arc through netgalley, and this is my honest opinion/review of it.
July 29, 2026
I've enjoyed previous reads by Jane Lovering, so I requested this without reading the blurb, and I have to say I loved the little time-slip surprise!
Pax has been dragged to Dunaire Castle by her brother, Lennox, who has bought the castle, seeing as it was a part of their heritage. Filled with ideas of renovating it and turning it into a hotel, and somehow reclaiming their ancestral home, he doesn't realise Pax has disappeared.
And she does, in the most surreal way!
Falling down stairs and ending up in 18th-century Scotland with four others from the present, trapped in the past, Pax learns so much about her own history, and ends up... well, I shall not say because I'm not about spoilers!
There is romance, but it is very slow; however, the entire premise of the story kept me turning the pages, and I finished this in a day!
Many thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for an ARC.
Pax has been dragged to Dunaire Castle by her brother, Lennox, who has bought the castle, seeing as it was a part of their heritage. Filled with ideas of renovating it and turning it into a hotel, and somehow reclaiming their ancestral home, he doesn't realise Pax has disappeared.
And she does, in the most surreal way!
Falling down stairs and ending up in 18th-century Scotland with four others from the present, trapped in the past, Pax learns so much about her own history, and ends up... well, I shall not say because I'm not about spoilers!
There is romance, but it is very slow; however, the entire premise of the story kept me turning the pages, and I finished this in a day!
Many thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for an ARC.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I picked this up expecting a Scottish castle, a romance, and perhaps a little Outlander-flavoured magic.
What I got instead was five people trapped three hundred years in the past, hiding in a cellar, slowly unraveling while trying to figure out how to get home.
The writing is incredibly easy to read. I flew through this book in a day and a half because it was effortless to pick up, impossible to get lost in, and easy to return to after a break. The pacing is excellent, the character work is strong, and every member of the cast felt distinct enough that I genuinely cared what happened to them.
The time travel aspect is the true heart of the story. Being thrown centuries into the past is terrifying, and the book captures that uncertainty well. The characters spend much of the novel balancing on the edge of panic, confusion, and despair as they try to make sense of an impossible situation. Their emotional journeys and personal struggles felt far more important than the romance.
This is marketed as a romance, but for me the romance was by far the weakest part of the book. It moves at a glacial pace and remains extremely chaste throughout. Normally I enjoy a slow burn, but I still need some tension, longing, chemistry, or anticipation. Here, most of the relationship develops while the characters are hiding together in a damp cellar, exhausted, frightened, unwashed, and struggling to survive. There was plenty of forced proximity, but none of the romantic energy that usually makes that trope work for me.
The ending also didn't quite land. Much of the story focuses on the mystery and characters confronting aspects of their lives they aren't happy with. Instead of earning those changes, however, many of their problems are ultimately solved through a timeline shift that hands them a version of life where everything has already worked out. I found that deeply unsatisfying.
The romance suffers particularly from this choice. After spending the entire book slowly realizing they might have feelings for each other, the characters arrive in a reality where they're already together and moving in with one another. Instead of feeling rewarding, it felt like the story skipped the part I actually wanted to read.
Still, despite my frustrations with the romance and the ending, I enjoyed the reading experience itself. The writing is smooth, the characters are engaging, and the time-travel premise kept me turning pages.
If you're looking for a historical time-slip story with strong character work and a touch of romance, this may work very well for you. If you're looking for a swoony Scottish romance full of chemistry, tension, and yearning, you may want to adjust your expectations.
What I got instead was five people trapped three hundred years in the past, hiding in a cellar, slowly unraveling while trying to figure out how to get home.
The writing is incredibly easy to read. I flew through this book in a day and a half because it was effortless to pick up, impossible to get lost in, and easy to return to after a break. The pacing is excellent, the character work is strong, and every member of the cast felt distinct enough that I genuinely cared what happened to them.
The time travel aspect is the true heart of the story. Being thrown centuries into the past is terrifying, and the book captures that uncertainty well. The characters spend much of the novel balancing on the edge of panic, confusion, and despair as they try to make sense of an impossible situation. Their emotional journeys and personal struggles felt far more important than the romance.
This is marketed as a romance, but for me the romance was by far the weakest part of the book. It moves at a glacial pace and remains extremely chaste throughout. Normally I enjoy a slow burn, but I still need some tension, longing, chemistry, or anticipation. Here, most of the relationship develops while the characters are hiding together in a damp cellar, exhausted, frightened, unwashed, and struggling to survive. There was plenty of forced proximity, but none of the romantic energy that usually makes that trope work for me.
The ending also didn't quite land. Much of the story focuses on the mystery and characters confronting aspects of their lives they aren't happy with. Instead of earning those changes, however, many of their problems are ultimately solved through a timeline shift that hands them a version of life where everything has already worked out. I found that deeply unsatisfying.
The romance suffers particularly from this choice. After spending the entire book slowly realizing they might have feelings for each other, the characters arrive in a reality where they're already together and moving in with one another. Instead of feeling rewarding, it felt like the story skipped the part I actually wanted to read.
Still, despite my frustrations with the romance and the ending, I enjoyed the reading experience itself. The writing is smooth, the characters are engaging, and the time-travel premise kept me turning pages.
If you're looking for a historical time-slip story with strong character work and a touch of romance, this may work very well for you. If you're looking for a swoony Scottish romance full of chemistry, tension, and yearning, you may want to adjust your expectations.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 22, 2026
Told in the first-person Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle from Jane Lovering uses a time slip scenario to head back into time between 2026 and 300 years prior, 1720, when Lennox (Lenny) and Pax, (Perdita), buy what was their family Castle, Dunaire Castle, now a ruin perched on the edge of a crumbling cliff, built in the fifteenth century by the McKell family.
Pax is not amused by what she has gone and done; Lenny is overjoyed at finally owning what was once the family stronghold. He has grand plans for creating a wonderful Hotel from the ruins and she can only see disaster looming.
Seeking shelter from a torrential downpour, she stands under the remains of an old staircase and finds herself sliding uncontrollably down a seep incline, only to come to her senses in another place, another century, entirely, being observed by what she assumes must be members of the missing Archaeological team that vanished from the Archaeological dig at the Castle ruins several months ago.
What she is doing there, and more importantly why are they all here, three hundred years ago, trying to survive, trying to return home and trying to understand what exactly is going on is something Pax does not feel up to coping with or understanding.
As the storyline unfolds each member of the team, Pax included seem to be forced to face their demons, work out what is going to happen once Earl George McKell arrives and is readying the men of the household to go to War, to support James, the man Scots truly believed should be King.
Jane Lovering has taken a fascinating concept, wrapped it in modern trappings, woven a plausible tale based in the history of Scotland, which while entertaining falls a little short. Issues, both relating to the personal life of the tiny community are often laboured over with the finale, as that is what it is, becoming almost one step too far.
For readers who enjoy generalised, somewhat quirky historic fiction Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle will be an enjoyable read.
Pax is not amused by what she has gone and done; Lenny is overjoyed at finally owning what was once the family stronghold. He has grand plans for creating a wonderful Hotel from the ruins and she can only see disaster looming.
Seeking shelter from a torrential downpour, she stands under the remains of an old staircase and finds herself sliding uncontrollably down a seep incline, only to come to her senses in another place, another century, entirely, being observed by what she assumes must be members of the missing Archaeological team that vanished from the Archaeological dig at the Castle ruins several months ago.
What she is doing there, and more importantly why are they all here, three hundred years ago, trying to survive, trying to return home and trying to understand what exactly is going on is something Pax does not feel up to coping with or understanding.
As the storyline unfolds each member of the team, Pax included seem to be forced to face their demons, work out what is going to happen once Earl George McKell arrives and is readying the men of the household to go to War, to support James, the man Scots truly believed should be King.
Jane Lovering has taken a fascinating concept, wrapped it in modern trappings, woven a plausible tale based in the history of Scotland, which while entertaining falls a little short. Issues, both relating to the personal life of the tiny community are often laboured over with the finale, as that is what it is, becoming almost one step too far.
For readers who enjoy generalised, somewhat quirky historic fiction Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle will be an enjoyable read.
August 9, 2026
⭐️⭐️✨ (2.5 Stars)
I do enjoy a good time-travel story when it's done well, so I was really looking forward to Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle. A Scottish castle, family secrets, and a touch of time travel sounded like a wonderful combination. Unfortunately, this one just wasn't the right fit for me.
I also felt the book was marketed a little differently than what it actually delivered. I was expecting more of a romance, but the story focuses much more on the mystery surrounding the castle and five people trapped three hundred years in the past as they try to survive and find a way home.
I struggled to connect with the characters. While they were well written, I never became emotionally invested in them, which made it difficult to fully immerse myself in the story.
The highlight for me was definitely the Scottish setting. Jane Lovering brings Dunaire Castle and its surroundings to life beautifully, and the atmosphere was my favourite part of the novel. The writing flows well, and the mystery kept me turning the pages to see how everything would unfold.
Unfortunately, the ending didn't quite satisfy me. After spending so much time building up the mystery, it felt rushed, and I was left wanting a stronger, more complete conclusion.
While this wasn't the story I was expecting, I think readers who enjoy time travel, family mysteries, and historical fiction may enjoy it more than I did.
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Jane Lovering for the ARC. As always, these are my honest thoughts.
I do enjoy a good time-travel story when it's done well, so I was really looking forward to Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle. A Scottish castle, family secrets, and a touch of time travel sounded like a wonderful combination. Unfortunately, this one just wasn't the right fit for me.
I also felt the book was marketed a little differently than what it actually delivered. I was expecting more of a romance, but the story focuses much more on the mystery surrounding the castle and five people trapped three hundred years in the past as they try to survive and find a way home.
I struggled to connect with the characters. While they were well written, I never became emotionally invested in them, which made it difficult to fully immerse myself in the story.
The highlight for me was definitely the Scottish setting. Jane Lovering brings Dunaire Castle and its surroundings to life beautifully, and the atmosphere was my favourite part of the novel. The writing flows well, and the mystery kept me turning the pages to see how everything would unfold.
Unfortunately, the ending didn't quite satisfy me. After spending so much time building up the mystery, it felt rushed, and I was left wanting a stronger, more complete conclusion.
While this wasn't the story I was expecting, I think readers who enjoy time travel, family mysteries, and historical fiction may enjoy it more than I did.
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Jane Lovering for the ARC. As always, these are my honest thoughts.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
In this fascinating new historical fiction novel, readers follow Perdita McKell as she stumbles into her brother Lennox’s scheme to renovate the seventeenth-century Dunaire Castle, the home of their ancestor Earl George McKell. However, the castle chooses to reveal its secrets in some fascinating ways, and Perdita learns how the castle shaped the lives of generations of her ancestors and how she can change the course of history for her ancestor and herself. Pulling readers into a beautiful Scottish setting at the height of the English Civil War, Lovering immerses readers in Perdita’s family history as she learns about her family’s secrets and relationship to the castle. Immersive and fascinating, readers will love the unique plot points and complicated dynamics between characters in this novel. The setting is incredibly detailed and pulls readers into the castle’s community under George McKell and Lennox’s dreams of renovating it. The characters are the emotional heart of the story and really highlight the abruptness of the main plot twist and the challenges it presents from Perdita in particular. Entertaining, emotional, and complex, fans of Jane Lovering will absolutely love the dynamics between characters and the vibrant setting of Dunaire Castle in her latest novel.
Thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the advance copy.
Thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the advance copy.
July 20, 2026
When Pax McKell reluctantly agrees to help her brother, Lennox fund his ambitious plan to restore Dunaire Castle, she expects little more than financial stress and family conflict. Instead, the castle begins to reveal the hidden history of their ancestor, the Earl George McKell, uncovering long-buried secrets that have shaped generations of the McKell family. As the past slowly comes to light, Pax finds herself questioning not only her family's history but also the direction of her own life.
The Scottish setting was easily the highlight of the novel. Dunaire Castle and its surrounding landscape were vividly described, creating a wonderful sense of place that added plenty of atmosphere to the story. I also enjoyed the historical mystery and the way the family secrets gradually unfolded, revealing how the choices of previous generations continued to influence the present. However, I found the pacing quite slow, particularly in the first half of the book. While Pax's personal journey was interesting, I never felt fully invested in all of the family dynamics, and the story took a while to build momentum. Some of the revelations were satisfying, but they didn't have quite the emotional impact I had hoped for. Overall, an enjoyable read.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The Scottish setting was easily the highlight of the novel. Dunaire Castle and its surrounding landscape were vividly described, creating a wonderful sense of place that added plenty of atmosphere to the story. I also enjoyed the historical mystery and the way the family secrets gradually unfolded, revealing how the choices of previous generations continued to influence the present. However, I found the pacing quite slow, particularly in the first half of the book. While Pax's personal journey was interesting, I never felt fully invested in all of the family dynamics, and the story took a while to build momentum. Some of the revelations were satisfying, but they didn't have quite the emotional impact I had hoped for. Overall, an enjoyable read.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Despite her reservations, Perdita McKell agrees to help her brother Lennox buy and renovate an old Scottish castle that had belonged to their ancestors. Taking shelter from a storm Perdita, known as Pax, finds herself tumbling down a set of stairs into a cellar and tumbling back in time. I’ve read almost all of this author’s books and she has played with time in at least a couple of them. I like this slightly mystical time-slip aspect and she does it very well.
Pax finds herself with a mystery to solve and a whole new way of life to get used to. Like many of the author’s heroines, Pax is a resourceful woman and determined to get to the bottom of what has happened and what she needs to do to put things right. I enjoyed reading about her adapting to her circumstances along with four other inadvertent time travellers and getting to know them too. Unlikely as it seemed, love began to blossom in the past but what would happen when – or if – Pax got back to her own time?
A historical novel, a mystery and a romance all rolled up in one, Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle is another quirky, funny and enjoyable read from Jane Lovering.
Pax finds herself with a mystery to solve and a whole new way of life to get used to. Like many of the author’s heroines, Pax is a resourceful woman and determined to get to the bottom of what has happened and what she needs to do to put things right. I enjoyed reading about her adapting to her circumstances along with four other inadvertent time travellers and getting to know them too. Unlikely as it seemed, love began to blossom in the past but what would happen when – or if – Pax got back to her own time?
A historical novel, a mystery and a romance all rolled up in one, Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle is another quirky, funny and enjoyable read from Jane Lovering.
July 22, 2026
Rating: 3.5⭐
When I requested this book from NetGalley, I thought I was going to read a cozy romance set in Scotland with a kilted hero. It never crossed my mind that it would turn out to be a time-slip novel with only a touch of romance. But I didn't mind at all because this book completely made my day. It follows a woman who unexpectedly finds herself transported to 17th-century Scotland, where she uncovers long-buried family secrets while navigating an unfamiliar world and forging unexpected connections.
The characters are well developed and genuinely interesting, making it easy to become invested in their journeys. The narration flows effortlessly, and the plot kept me engaged from beginning to end. Even though I'm usually a bit reluctant to pick up time-travel books, this one never felt confusing or overwhelming. I especially loved the vivid historical descriptions, which brought the Scottish setting and its history to life.
If you enjoy atmospheric Scottish settings, time-slip stories, family secrets, and character-driven historical fiction with a light romance woven throughout, I'd definitely recommend giving this book a try.
When I requested this book from NetGalley, I thought I was going to read a cozy romance set in Scotland with a kilted hero. It never crossed my mind that it would turn out to be a time-slip novel with only a touch of romance. But I didn't mind at all because this book completely made my day. It follows a woman who unexpectedly finds herself transported to 17th-century Scotland, where she uncovers long-buried family secrets while navigating an unfamiliar world and forging unexpected connections.
The characters are well developed and genuinely interesting, making it easy to become invested in their journeys. The narration flows effortlessly, and the plot kept me engaged from beginning to end. Even though I'm usually a bit reluctant to pick up time-travel books, this one never felt confusing or overwhelming. I especially loved the vivid historical descriptions, which brought the Scottish setting and its history to life.
If you enjoy atmospheric Scottish settings, time-slip stories, family secrets, and character-driven historical fiction with a light romance woven throughout, I'd definitely recommend giving this book a try.
June 5, 2026
I was immediately intrigued by the premise - a woman falls in her family’s Scottish castle and wakes up in the seventeen hundreds? Sign me up. 🏰✨
What I found was much more historical fiction than romance, with a strong focus on Scottish history, daily life, and the experience of being thrown into another time. The descriptions of the castle, coastline, and countryside were incredibly vivid, and it’s clear Jane Lovering has a real love for the setting and history.
For me, the pacing was a little too slow, and I struggled to connect with the story as much as I wanted to. I kept waiting for the plot and romance to take center stage, but both remained fairly understated throughout. That said, readers who enjoy immersive historical fiction, detailed settings, and time-slip stories may have a very different experience. This one wasn’t quite for me, but I can absolutely see it finding the right reader.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. 📚
What I found was much more historical fiction than romance, with a strong focus on Scottish history, daily life, and the experience of being thrown into another time. The descriptions of the castle, coastline, and countryside were incredibly vivid, and it’s clear Jane Lovering has a real love for the setting and history.
For me, the pacing was a little too slow, and I struggled to connect with the story as much as I wanted to. I kept waiting for the plot and romance to take center stage, but both remained fairly understated throughout. That said, readers who enjoy immersive historical fiction, detailed settings, and time-slip stories may have a very different experience. This one wasn’t quite for me, but I can absolutely see it finding the right reader.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. 📚
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This modern day, time travelling romance begins when Pax McKell’s brother, Lennox, ropes her into helping to fund his harebrained plan to restore a crumbling Scottish castle. The castle, Dunaire, once belonged to their ancestor, the seventeenth-century Earl George McKell, so Pax gets why Lennox is drawn to the idea of bringing it back to life. As the rain starts to fall she seeks shelter in the ruins and suddenly, Dunaire Castle starts to share its long-buried secrets—choices and events that have shaped generations of McKells. As the family’s story unfolds, Pax realizes she holds the power to rewrite their history and her own—if only she can figure out how.
I found this to be a fun read with plenty of comical moments but also a tenderness as Pax comes to terms with why she feels as she does. If you like your romance with a sprinkle of time travel and humour then you will enjoy this novel. With thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for a copy of this book in exchange for a review.
I found this to be a fun read with plenty of comical moments but also a tenderness as Pax comes to terms with why she feels as she does. If you like your romance with a sprinkle of time travel and humour then you will enjoy this novel. With thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for a copy of this book in exchange for a review.
July 27, 2026
A Jane Lovering novel is always a treat - I know I'll have an interesting situation, and awkward (but relatable) characters who overcome their demons to find their place in the world. And there will be something different...
In this case, it's a timeslip. And it was beautifully done. Perdita (known as Pax) goes to help out her brother Lennox at the castle that once belonged to their ancestors, which he wants to renovate. It's a tumbledown place, and a team of archaeologists working there have disappeared... and discovers for herself where they disappeared to.
It's a timeslip novel and she's plunged straight into 18th-century Scotland, along with all the smells and sounds and difficulties of being invisible to the inhabitants - except for a dog and the Laird himself, one of Pax's forebears.
But how are they all going to get home? Between them, they realise that something is wrong and they need to fix it - but what, and how? (These are the lost secrets!)
Loved the setting, the camaraderie between the characters and the developing romance. Very enjoyable.
In this case, it's a timeslip. And it was beautifully done. Perdita (known as Pax) goes to help out her brother Lennox at the castle that once belonged to their ancestors, which he wants to renovate. It's a tumbledown place, and a team of archaeologists working there have disappeared... and discovers for herself where they disappeared to.
It's a timeslip novel and she's plunged straight into 18th-century Scotland, along with all the smells and sounds and difficulties of being invisible to the inhabitants - except for a dog and the Laird himself, one of Pax's forebears.
But how are they all going to get home? Between them, they realise that something is wrong and they need to fix it - but what, and how? (These are the lost secrets!)
Loved the setting, the camaraderie between the characters and the developing romance. Very enjoyable.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Perdita, better know as Pax, is visiting Dunaire Castle which she is helping her brother Lennox buy with the intention of turning the ruins into a hotel. Centuries before it had been in their family, but they had fallen on hard times and it had suffered accordingly. When a storm hits she falls down into the cellar, knocking herself out, when she awakes things are totally different.
I've really enjoyed other books by this author and this one is added to the list. Your enjoyment of this book depends upon your expectations: if you're hoping for a romance this is only a minor part of the story so don't expect too much of this, if you enjoy timey wimey stories, more so. I don't want to go into details as it'd give the story away, but it is an interesting take on the timeslip trope and I ended up loving it.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley, however this did not influence my review of the book.
I've really enjoyed other books by this author and this one is added to the list. Your enjoyment of this book depends upon your expectations: if you're hoping for a romance this is only a minor part of the story so don't expect too much of this, if you enjoy timey wimey stories, more so. I don't want to go into details as it'd give the story away, but it is an interesting take on the timeslip trope and I ended up loving it.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley, however this did not influence my review of the book.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I was intrigued by the premise of the story. I got more than I expected. The writing was uncomplicated and easy to read. At the same time, some of the conversations, especially those between Pax and Lachlan, had an unexpected depth of emotion. It was easy to get lost in the story.
One of the things I really liked was the mix of characters. History nerds all, except for Pax, yet their experience and backgrounds were diverse. Their camaraderie and friendship happened quickly, but quite naturally, a result of the situation in which they find themselves. Their interactions, and sometimes disagreements, added a bit of humor and sensitivity to the story. They also are precursors to the twists and turns of that keep the story interesting.
One of the underlying themes I picked up in the story, was the importance of history. Especially for Pax who paid little attention to the stories her father would share of her family history. Spending time at the castle makes her question that indifference. Spurred by the things she's learning from the members of the archeological dig, she starts to listen and to learn. I think it helped Pax understand herself more and to feel connected to something, a feeling that had been lacking in her life.
I'm always up for reading a story set in Scotland. This one was an enjoyable, easy read that was both engaging and entertaining.
Thank you to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for a copy of this book. The thoughts and opinions are my own.
One of the things I really liked was the mix of characters. History nerds all, except for Pax, yet their experience and backgrounds were diverse. Their camaraderie and friendship happened quickly, but quite naturally, a result of the situation in which they find themselves. Their interactions, and sometimes disagreements, added a bit of humor and sensitivity to the story. They also are precursors to the twists and turns of that keep the story interesting.
One of the underlying themes I picked up in the story, was the importance of history. Especially for Pax who paid little attention to the stories her father would share of her family history. Spending time at the castle makes her question that indifference. Spurred by the things she's learning from the members of the archeological dig, she starts to listen and to learn. I think it helped Pax understand herself more and to feel connected to something, a feeling that had been lacking in her life.
I'm always up for reading a story set in Scotland. This one was an enjoyable, easy read that was both engaging and entertaining.
Thank you to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for a copy of this book. The thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 20, 2026
3.5
The writing is really good, it's easy to follow, draws you in, and keeps you hooked in the story.
Pax times travel 300 years in the past, for reasons unknown to her... and as she is trying to figure out a way to get back to her time, she meets other people who have the same fate as her. The plot of the story, it was good and interesting, but at times I found my self nnot caring enough for the whole reason they were there... I couldn't sense the urgency. However, the story from the past was interesting.
I do not know if this will be consider a spoiler: In terms of time traveling, is has the mecanic as in 'Back to the Future' (same timeline: different outcome for everyone but the time travelers).
The romance in this book is sub plot, I do enjoy how the author always integrates romance to the plot, while focusing mainnly on other themes and the characters development through out the story.
The writing is really good, it's easy to follow, draws you in, and keeps you hooked in the story.
Pax times travel 300 years in the past, for reasons unknown to her... and as she is trying to figure out a way to get back to her time, she meets other people who have the same fate as her. The plot of the story, it was good and interesting, but at times I found my self nnot caring enough for the whole reason they were there... I couldn't sense the urgency. However, the story from the past was interesting.
I do not know if this will be consider a spoiler: In terms of time traveling, is has the mecanic as in 'Back to the Future' (same timeline: different outcome for everyone but the time travelers).
The romance in this book is sub plot, I do enjoy how the author always integrates romance to the plot, while focusing mainnly on other themes and the characters development through out the story.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I am yet to read a Jane Lovering book that I didn't like, so when I saw this on Netgalley, I requested it immediately.
While reluctantly looking around the ruins of the McKell ancestral family castle with her brother, Pax falls 300 years into the past. She also runs into a group of archaeologists who had fallen into the same pocket of time. Together they must work out why they're there and what they have to do to get back to their own time.
For a book with a fantastical premise (time travel), the descriptions of everyday life in the castle, in the 18 century Scotland are very grounded and domestic. The reactions of the people who are trapped in the wrong time feel realistic too (the terror, overlaid with a fragile layer of practicality).
I really enjoyed this. Thank you to the publisher for the review copy on Netgalley.
While reluctantly looking around the ruins of the McKell ancestral family castle with her brother, Pax falls 300 years into the past. She also runs into a group of archaeologists who had fallen into the same pocket of time. Together they must work out why they're there and what they have to do to get back to their own time.
For a book with a fantastical premise (time travel), the descriptions of everyday life in the castle, in the 18 century Scotland are very grounded and domestic. The reactions of the people who are trapped in the wrong time feel realistic too (the terror, overlaid with a fragile layer of practicality).
I really enjoyed this. Thank you to the publisher for the review copy on Netgalley.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book, given to me by Boldwood Books via Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
“Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle”, by Jane Lovering, is a both fun, entertaining and heartwarming time-travel story, with great characters and a dog that grows on you.
Pax, Lachlan and the other characters are interesting, each with their own difficult life story. The time travel is an opportunity to grow, change ans learn.
The romance happens quickly in the very peculiar circumstances; in a way, flirting might help mitigate the despair of the situation they’re in.
I enjoyed Pax’s relationship with her ancestor.
There are some very funny moments throughout the story.
I liked that kindness coud be found in both different periods in several characters.
Cellar Dog is a wonderful addition, from the shy, fearful animal in the beginning to the smart, devoted companion later. I loved its epilogue.
“Lost Secrets of the Scottish Castle”, by Jane Lovering, is a both fun, entertaining and heartwarming time-travel story, with great characters and a dog that grows on you.
Pax, Lachlan and the other characters are interesting, each with their own difficult life story. The time travel is an opportunity to grow, change ans learn.
The romance happens quickly in the very peculiar circumstances; in a way, flirting might help mitigate the despair of the situation they’re in.
I enjoyed Pax’s relationship with her ancestor.
There are some very funny moments throughout the story.
I liked that kindness coud be found in both different periods in several characters.
Cellar Dog is a wonderful addition, from the shy, fearful animal in the beginning to the smart, devoted companion later. I loved its epilogue.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
An intriguing mystery with a sprinkle of romance! Pax is at the site of Dunaire Castle in Scotland with her older brother Lenny. The castle is just ruins but once belonged to their family and Lenny has bought the site with the intent of rebuilding the castle and turning it into a hotel. However, a storm hits and Pax takes cover in the ruins, falling down the stairs into the cellar .... and 300 years into the past. Between her and four others who've ended up in the same situation, they have to figure out how to get back to their own time. An interesting look at life in the early 1700's, a blossoming romance, and meeting her ancestor made for a great story.
Thanks to Netgalley, Boldwood Books, and Jane Lovering for the free ARC. All opinions are my own.
Thanks to Netgalley, Boldwood Books, and Jane Lovering for the free ARC. All opinions are my own.
July 19, 2026
Lost Secrets at the Scottish Castle was a breath of fresh air! The story developed in a way I could never have imagined but was delivered in Jane’s inimitable way. I simply loved everything about it.
Perdita, known affectionately as Pax, was a brilliant protagonist who was a fascinating character. Despite being raised in the knowledge that her family came from privileged stock, she had never really felt advantaged. Except for the riding lessons and good schooling. What she had felt was overshadowed by her brother’s voracious thirst for knowledge of their family history
.
There’s a terrific supporting cast in this novel that reminded me of Jane’s ability to seamlessly blend the everyday with a more imaginative reality. The scenes set in the castle itself created a true sense of place, and I could almost smell the smouldering peat and feel the cold damp air chilling me to the bone.
Of course, Jane’s heroines must overcome awkward comedic moments before they find an opportunity for romance, and Lost Secrets at the Scottish Castle delivered brilliantly on that front. Her story's arc was perfectly satisfying, and the conclusion left me with a warm sense of joy and hope for Pax and her family’s future.
If you like your books to be warm, humorous and a little out of the ordinary, Jane Lovering’s latest should be right up your street. I think it’s brilliant.
Perdita, known affectionately as Pax, was a brilliant protagonist who was a fascinating character. Despite being raised in the knowledge that her family came from privileged stock, she had never really felt advantaged. Except for the riding lessons and good schooling. What she had felt was overshadowed by her brother’s voracious thirst for knowledge of their family history
.
There’s a terrific supporting cast in this novel that reminded me of Jane’s ability to seamlessly blend the everyday with a more imaginative reality. The scenes set in the castle itself created a true sense of place, and I could almost smell the smouldering peat and feel the cold damp air chilling me to the bone.
Of course, Jane’s heroines must overcome awkward comedic moments before they find an opportunity for romance, and Lost Secrets at the Scottish Castle delivered brilliantly on that front. Her story's arc was perfectly satisfying, and the conclusion left me with a warm sense of joy and hope for Pax and her family’s future.
If you like your books to be warm, humorous and a little out of the ordinary, Jane Lovering’s latest should be right up your street. I think it’s brilliant.
August 6, 2026
When I first picked up this book, I didn't realise that it was a timeslip novel but I like those anyway so I got immersed in the world of Pax and Lennox and their castle in Scotland very quickly!
Having lived in Scotland for a while in the 90's, I really love any books set there and this one didn't disappoint at all. Naturally enough, there are some brooding Scottish fellas in the story, one of whom catches Pax's eye and another one who comes to be very central to the story in a completely different way.
I don't want to give the story away so I will stop here.
Suffice to say that this is a cosy book that will have you wanting to book a trip to Scotland, post haste ;)
For me, right now, this was the perfect read.
4.5 stars.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books.
Having lived in Scotland for a while in the 90's, I really love any books set there and this one didn't disappoint at all. Naturally enough, there are some brooding Scottish fellas in the story, one of whom catches Pax's eye and another one who comes to be very central to the story in a completely different way.
I don't want to give the story away so I will stop here.
Suffice to say that this is a cosy book that will have you wanting to book a trip to Scotland, post haste ;)
For me, right now, this was the perfect read.
4.5 stars.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books.
July 7, 2026
ARC from NetGalley
The idea of a book based on Scottish Castle had my interest peaked from the start. As we meet Pax and her brother Lennox as they explore their newly purchased castle previously owned by their ancestors, Pax seems as though she is going through a life crisis period and is only here to please her brother. However, the stories actually purpose brings us back in time where Pax and four members of an archaeological research group find themselves back in time to correct history. I love the full circle moments we see at the end and the way this story was different than just ghosts or trying to fit in to the past. Cute little read.
The idea of a book based on Scottish Castle had my interest peaked from the start. As we meet Pax and her brother Lennox as they explore their newly purchased castle previously owned by their ancestors, Pax seems as though she is going through a life crisis period and is only here to please her brother. However, the stories actually purpose brings us back in time where Pax and four members of an archaeological research group find themselves back in time to correct history. I love the full circle moments we see at the end and the way this story was different than just ghosts or trying to fit in to the past. Cute little read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 21, 2026
Thanks to Boldwood and NetGalley for the ARC of this book. My views are totally my own.
I love Jane Lovering’s books and although this one is different from her other books, (with a time-slip theme) , it is still beautifully written with fabulous characters whose journey engaged my interest from the beginning. I would have given this 5 stars except that I thought the ending was too brief. I wanted more of the romance, more explanation of what the new timeline was and more time with the MFC and MMC.
But it’s still 4.5 stars. Well done JL. A beautiful, emotionally satisfying and historically authentic story.
I love Jane Lovering’s books and although this one is different from her other books, (with a time-slip theme) , it is still beautifully written with fabulous characters whose journey engaged my interest from the beginning. I would have given this 5 stars except that I thought the ending was too brief. I wanted more of the romance, more explanation of what the new timeline was and more time with the MFC and MMC.
But it’s still 4.5 stars. Well done JL. A beautiful, emotionally satisfying and historically authentic story.
August 13, 2026
This is a witty and light time-slip story about Pax, who buys an old, ruined castle with her brother and soon discovers that it holds a strange secret. Instead of staying in the present day, Pax suddenly finds herself in another time, along with a group of unusual archaeologists. I enjoyed the fun characters and the strange situations they find themselves in. The story has a little romance, but the main focus is on solving the mystery of what has happened and finding a way back. It is a fun, unusual, and easy read, especially for readers who enjoy castles, mystery, and a touch of fantasy.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
July 13, 2026
I did enjoy reading this book.
This book starts with Pax who is in Scotland helping her brother Lennox to buy and rebuild a family castle. While checking out the castle Pax falls back 300 years in time, where she meets 4 others who also fell back into time. There is a subtle romance, figuring out why they are their and if they can change the future, missing their current lives while also not enjoying their current lives. I felt the romance was not fully developed and I wish we could've seen more of how life played out when they came back to current times.
This book starts with Pax who is in Scotland helping her brother Lennox to buy and rebuild a family castle. While checking out the castle Pax falls back 300 years in time, where she meets 4 others who also fell back into time. There is a subtle romance, figuring out why they are their and if they can change the future, missing their current lives while also not enjoying their current lives. I felt the romance was not fully developed and I wish we could've seen more of how life played out when they came back to current times.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Time travel aficionados will love Jane Lovering's latest novel! Perdita McKell falls into the cellar of her family's castle ruin...and is swept back in time. Fortunaely, she immediately encounters a group of "missing" archeologists who had been transported slightly earlier in time. Of course, there are many adventures to be had in merry ol' Scotland. As with all Lovering books, there's a satisfying ending, albeit a little too brief for my liking.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A great concept and nicely written story. Characters are clear if a bit 2 dimensional, and missing depth.
The romance is a nice addition to the plot, but definitely isn't the predominate arc for the book, and I did feel a little robbed with the way the ending seem to jump past the main development of the relationship.
Overall if felt rather like a YA story, with the main characters being in their 30s.
The romance is a nice addition to the plot, but definitely isn't the predominate arc for the book, and I did feel a little robbed with the way the ending seem to jump past the main development of the relationship.
Overall if felt rather like a YA story, with the main characters being in their 30s.
June 13, 2026
I’m a fan of time travel romance and I had high hopes for this book. The story is interesting and Lovering puts you right in that castle with her descriptive writing. Unfortunately the romance was sadly lacking for me and the reading was a bit slow which is why this book received a 3 star rating. Thank you to #BoldwoodBooks and #Netgalley for a copy of the book for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Excitement abounds when three people trapped in a castle in the 1700s are joined by several times over granddaughter of the earl of the castle. Their tough task is to somehow figure out what they need to do to return to current time. A pleasurable novel.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of the book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of the book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews