2.5 ★— 2025 seems to be shaping up as a tentative return for dystopian romances, and To Cage a Wild Bird is very much a throwback to the fast-paced, action-filled YA titles that dominated the 2010s.
The story is set in Dividium, a very on-the-nose name for the war-torn, decimated world where the plot unfolds. Unfortunately, that same genericness carries over into nearly every other aspect of the book.
Our heroine, Raven Thorne, is your classic cookie-cutter early-twenties main character just trying to keep her younger brother safe while surviving as part of the vulnerable underclass of her world, forced to walk on eggshells to stay alive. When her brother is taken to Endlock Prison, she jumps into action, allying with a rebel group who promise to help rescue him, but only if she goes undercover as a prisoner herself to free one of their own.
Raven is the typical protagonist of this genre. She’s brave, hardened, and smart, which are all the usual traits you’d expect her to have. The only truly interesting angle is her backstory as a bounty hunter who captured criminals for money. That could have been such a fascinating internal dilemma, especially once she’s thrown into Endlock alongside people she has personally put there.
But the book barely explores this beyond a couple of scenes, which felt like a true missed opportunity for more interesting conflict. Instead, Raven’s time in prison and the whole undercover mission feel just as underwhelming and predictable as the book overall.
The prison setting itself had potential. There’s a ranking system for prisoners, and the wealthy pay to hunt the highly ranked ones. The more hunts you survive, the higher your rank and the more danger you’re in. It’s a genuinely cool concept! Yet all this is treated so shallowly that I kept wondering how such a cool world-building idea could have been executed in such a lackluster manner.
The romance just continued in bolstering this feeling. Raven’s relationship with the guard MMC, Vale, has zero build-up. I wouldn’t call it slow burn at all, because it’s basically insta-love. They meet once, and by their third scene together, he’s suddenly calling her “little bird” and acting protective, and then boom, they’re in love.
Vale himself is barely a character. Beyond a few scraps of backstory, there’s nothing to him. No personality, no depth. Honestly, I found myself wishing Raven would end up with August, a character who was far more fleshed out and had many more interactions with her.
In the end, I’d sum this book up as predictable, slightly trashy comfort food. It might work if you’re craving some smutty, 2010s-style dystopian nostalgia with a bit of action thrown in. But don’t expect anything groundbreaking.
🎧Audiobook Note
🎙️Narration Style: Solo
The narrator did a great job emoting and giving distinct voices to the characters. I didn’t love the raspy tone she used for Vale, but otherwise, her cadence was soothing and pleasant, making for a very enjoyable listening experience.
________________
Thank you to NetGalley, Random House Worlds UK, Transworlds Publishers for the ARC, and HarperAudio Adult for providing the ALC, both in exchange for an honest review.