What do you think?
Rate this book
Ceaselessly Yours: A Love Story Inspired By The Great Gatsby
Nic Caraway thought she’d be a bestselling author by now, but instead she’s back in Selah Falls helping at her mom’s bookstore. Running into Jay Gatsby, the boy who shattered her heart ten years ago, is the last thing she expects. Now Nic must figure out what a fresh start looks like and whether Jay has any place in it.
Jay Gatsby has everything he once thought he wanted except the girl who inspired it all. Coming home to Selah Falls brings him face to face with Nic, and old feelings hit harder than he ever planned for. Now Jay has to decide if becoming a great author means anything without the chance to rebuild something real with her.
Will Nic and Jay find their way back to each other, or will they let their love story stay buried in the past?
Ceaselessly Yours is a heartfelt small town second chance romance about childhood sweethearts. Perfect for readers who enjoy a clean no-spice story filled with cozy bookstore charm and all the sweater weather feels.
Jay Gatsby has everything he once thought he wanted except the girl who inspired it all. Coming home to Selah Falls brings him face to face with Nic, and old feelings hit harder than he ever planned for. Now Jay has to decide if becoming a great author means anything without the chance to rebuild something real with her.
Will Nic and Jay find their way back to each other, or will they let their love story stay buried in the past?
Ceaselessly Yours is a heartfelt small town second chance romance about childhood sweethearts. Perfect for readers who enjoy a clean no-spice story filled with cozy bookstore charm and all the sweater weather feels.
- GenresRomance
227 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 23, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
March 14, 2026
an eventful small town second chance romance story
Initial thought:
A light bookish second chance romance
Very easy to read and get hooked on
Book overview:
After 10 years apart their parent brings them back together with the hope of them forgiving each other and given their love story another chance
Failed author Nic comes back to her home town to help her mother heal after hurting her leg. What she didn’t know was that she will bump into her first and only love Jay.
Her turn bring up a lot of hurt that she will have to deal with to move on in her life. Is she ready?
Successful author Jay is invited to come and support a non existing writing competition back is his small town from New York. He didn’t think that coming back will have him bump into the one who got away “nic” will she give him a chance to right his wrong ?
Read the story to find out
Initial thought:
A light bookish second chance romance
Very easy to read and get hooked on
Book overview:
After 10 years apart their parent brings them back together with the hope of them forgiving each other and given their love story another chance
Failed author Nic comes back to her home town to help her mother heal after hurting her leg. What she didn’t know was that she will bump into her first and only love Jay.
Her turn bring up a lot of hurt that she will have to deal with to move on in her life. Is she ready?
Successful author Jay is invited to come and support a non existing writing competition back is his small town from New York. He didn’t think that coming back will have him bump into the one who got away “nic” will she give him a chance to right his wrong ?
Read the story to find out
December 25, 2025
When Love Returns
This book is a cute and heartfelt second-chance love story. The characters feel genuine, and their emotional journey makes the story easy to enjoy. It’s a warm and comforting romance that I would definitely recommend.
This book is a cute and heartfelt second-chance love story. The characters feel genuine, and their emotional journey makes the story easy to enjoy. It’s a warm and comforting romance that I would definitely recommend.
January 2, 2026
I loved this book! Such a genuine love story and easy to read!
May 26, 2026
I really wanted to love this book; however, it really didn’t work for me. Let’s start with what I enjoyed: the FMC and MMC were likable and gave us something to root for. Their second chance story felt as innocent as the town they’re from. The writing could have been tighter but the author does have a way with words. I enjoy alternating POV novels and that was a strong suit of this one; however, I noticed that the inner monologues of these two sounded identical. I wish they each had a distinct voice. I chalked the similarities up to them being from the same place.
For me, the plot struggled. There were so many areas where the conversations jumped over and past things that could have been explored and lent to a more satisfying story. And there important goals that the characters let go of so easily.
The author is inspired by The Great Gatsby but the story really wasn’t. I don’t mind that, btw. The author threw in some GG-esque twists at the end that really didn’t serve the story that she was actually telling. Is a twist really a twist when it’s not relevant to any main character? I felt that had she revised those areas out and explored some of the good bones she had from her own imagination, it would have been more enjoyable.
Lastly, this is billed as a Christian romance. It’s clean and sweet but the characters’ faith played a very small part in their lives. Not what I expected from a Christian romance.
For me, the plot struggled. There were so many areas where the conversations jumped over and past things that could have been explored and lent to a more satisfying story. And there important goals that the characters let go of so easily.
The author is inspired by The Great Gatsby but the story really wasn’t. I don’t mind that, btw. The author threw in some GG-esque twists at the end that really didn’t serve the story that she was actually telling. Is a twist really a twist when it’s not relevant to any main character? I felt that had she revised those areas out and explored some of the good bones she had from her own imagination, it would have been more enjoyable.
Lastly, this is billed as a Christian romance. It’s clean and sweet but the characters’ faith played a very small part in their lives. Not what I expected from a Christian romance.
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews