Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Alchemy of Desire #1

Binding the Baron

Rate this book
An heiress on the run.

Diana Chester was never supposed to have magic. No women are. So when she inherits it instead of her cousin, she runs, seeking refuge above a potion shop. Until an infamous and irresistible alchemist proposes a marriage of convenience. Accepting him may be the only way she can live her life in the light once more.

A notorious alchemist searching for a wife.

Royal Alchemist Temple Grant is a metal magician who can bend iron with his hands. But after the king gives him a title, he needs a lady to help him navigate the icy social circles of the city’s elite. Diana Chester, the mouse of a marquess’s cousin will do perfectly. She needs someone to keep her safe, and while Temple can’t cast glamours like the rest of the ton, he can do that.

A convenient binding, complicated by passion, made almost impossible by a city divided.

Temple never expects Diana’s kiss to call to the life-giving heat in his core. And Diana never hoped to find love in the shadows. Love can bind them, but it might not be enough to bridge their dueling worlds.

Binding the Baron /i> is book 1 in a spicy interconnected standalone historical romantasy series.

330 pages, Paperback

First published December 17, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Charlie Lane

58 books195 followers
Charlie writes Regency romance that's lighthearted and hot. Her books have a little bit of angst, a lot of laughs, and a whole lot of heart and heat.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
71 (35%)
4 stars
85 (42%)
3 stars
35 (17%)
2 stars
8 (4%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews
Profile Image for KelseyreadsHR.
561 reviews16 followers
December 22, 2025
I really enjoyed this book. A historical fantasy romance that blended these two genres perfectly for a HR lover.

There were so many aspects of this book that drew me in and worked for me. It delved more into how transcendents and alchemists talent/magic works as the story goes on and as the characters learn more. So it doesn’t feel like info dumping in the beginning.

A marriage of convenience where Temple and Diana have to learn to trust one another with their secrets. For Temple, the last time he did so he was branded a traitor and Diana hadn’t ever had anyone she could confide in. I loved how this was explored and that realization that comes from only thinking of your family as the one you grew up with to others that become important and part of your life along the way.

After reading Til Death Duke Us Part, I thought this one might go more into depth on ring binding and I was right. Getting to see what goes into the ring making and the binding process. Providing an additional layer of connection that helped build trust and also have a lot of intense passionate encounters.

Diana’s secret also raised the stakes with her safety, vulnerability and longevity of her relationship with Temple.

There was a bit where Temple’s possessiveness of Diana made me wonder if a line would be crossed. But I held on and as that plot line progressed, those thoughts weren’t realized. I also missed that there was another prequel novella for this series, Naughty for Sir Nicholas, which is available in the anthology How the Belle Stole Christmas. It wasn’t required to enjoy this but Nicholas was a secondary character in the second half. So I’ll go back and read his story.

Overall, I’m excited for this series and what else is to come.

Binding the Baron is the first book in the historical fantasy romance series Alchemy of Desire.

There are five open door encounters.

I received an advance reader copy via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for sara ࿐ྂ.
195 reviews29 followers
December 19, 2025
˗ˏˋ꒰☕꒱ 𝟯.𝟮𝟱 𝗦𝘁𝗮𝗿𝘀
↠━༻◆༺━↞

ᴺᵒʷ ᵖˡᵃʸᶦⁿᵍ; [ 𝘽𝙞𝙣𝙙𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝘽𝙖𝙧𝙤𝙣 ] [ 𝗖𝗵𝗮𝗿𝗹𝗶𝗲 𝗟𝗮𝗻𝗲 ]
1:07 ——◦———— -4:05
↠ⁿᵉˣᵗ ˢᵒⁿᵍ ↺ ʳᵉᵖᵉᵃᵗ ⊜ ᵖᵃᵘˢᵉ

» 。° .• {🌻} ༄
Binding the Baron is set in historical London during the reign of King William, where magic and potions run society. We follow Diana and Temple as they both navigate their new lives, hiding secrets in hopes to survive while also building better lives. And that results in the love potion that changes both of their lives.


༄ {🥬} .• ° 。«
I thought Binding the Baron was a good read! I loved the magical world building with the backdrop of England. It just made for a cozy and easy read. The magical terms aren’t hard to understand and are defined before the story even begins. I appreciated the definitions, or I would have gotten lost.

» 。° .• {🌻} ༄
I did think the plot would be different, so I am surprised with what happened. Since there is a marriage of convenience (it’s in the synopsis so this isn’t a spoiler) I thought that the whole story would be Diana and Temple actually falling in love with one another and that neither of them would spill their respective secrets. I thought that their secrets would be revealed later on in the series, but I can see that Charlie Lane has a different direction planned. I would think that this would be a good stand-alone novel, since everything was wrapped up at the end. I’m curious to see what the rest of the series is like.

.。༅:*゚𝐂𝐡𝐚𝐫𝐚𝐜𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐬 ꒱

{💜} ·˚ 𝗗𝗶𝗮𝗻𝗮 ˊˎ
༻————↠
Diana is a great protagonist. She loves reading and learning about different subjects, just because she doesn’t have anything else to do as a woman in historical England. Knowledge is power, and she lives that out during this whole book. She also went through a lot of character development: building her confidence, overcoming being hidden for her entire adult life, and standing up against an abusive cousin.

{💜} ·˚ 𝗧𝗲𝗺𝗽𝗹𝗲 ˊˎ
༺————↞
Temple was also a good character, though I liked him less than Diana. He is the definition of a family man and describes himself as a “gentleman.” Sometimes though, I felt he was a little possessive of Diana and paranoid about her wellbeing. Most of the time, he was a civilized guy who took care of Diana while also learning about how to let go of unnecessary responsibilities.


↠━ {🌻} 𝐎𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐥𝐥 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 ━↞
Overall, Binding the Baron was a good story. I thought the plot was going to go in a different direction and because of the ending, I’m curious to see how Charlie Lane turns this into a series.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an arc copy!


{☕} ––––———–––––———–┊༄


» 。° .• 𝐩𝐫𝐞-𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐝 ༄
༻————↠
I saw the cover and I had to read it! I didn't know this was the start of a new series either so I'm excited to see if I like it!
Profile Image for Shyames.
418 reviews32 followers
December 5, 2025
Spicy Bridgerton meets fantasy and magic. And it works.

It features Transcendents (nobles who wield magic) and alchemists (who perform wonders but are denied the title of "magic"). Of course, the consensus is that magical talents can only be inherited by males, which isn't surprising given the setting is right before Queen Victoria ascends the throne.

When Diana's grandfather dies, she inherits the magic instead of her male cousin. This subverts the established world order, and Apollo is definitely not amused, setting out to get her and forcing her to run. Temple, an exiled alchemist, is introduced as a man who betrayed his brethren by revealing their secrets to the King, motivated by a desire to share knowledge rather than hoard it. Both Diana and Temple need to figure out their place in the world while also navigating the connection that forms between them.

I enjoyed this one very much. It features a lot of action, a touch of politics, spilled secrets, and resourceful women who consistently come to the rescue. While the world remains dominated by men, women like Lady Guinevere push through the constraints, using their talents to help lost girls and ensure their safety. The world itself is a compelling reflection of 19th-century England, with magic and alchemy interwoven to highlight the existing social disparities very well.

Both Diana and Temple undergo significant character development, though I dare to say Diana's is the more extensive arc. This is not to say something is wrong with Temple, he was simply more developed from the start. Diana, having been hidden from the world throughout her childhood, is experiencing many things for the first time. She truly comes into her own, especially toward the end of the book, finding the confidence to trust her feelings and capabilities. While Temple is perhaps a bit hardheaded, he will undoubtedly do everything to save his girl, even if it costs him everything.

If you enjoy romance in a fantasy setting, this is an excellent choice. The narration flows enjoyably, and when the action peaks, it's hard to set the book aside. I was afraid it would end in a cliffhanger (given the "Book 1" annotation), but fortunately, it closes this story arc nicely, while the second book appears to be planned around Apollo.

Thank you to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for an advanced copy.
Profile Image for Lucina.
943 reviews70 followers
March 16, 2026
2.5 stars

I'm honest: This was absolutely boring. The insta-love and insta-lust didn't help in the slightest. I didn't feel a connection to the characters, no chemistry between the characters aside from the first scene in the library that was really nice, and I was not interested in the side story at all. I was just not invested throughout the story. It seems like cozy romances are just not for me. I need more angst, more yearning. This had nothing and additionally it didn't really give me a HR vibe. I'm interested in Apollo's story which was the only reason I finished this novel.
Profile Image for Gloria Pastorino.
Author 83 books59 followers
December 30, 2025
I ADORE this new world created by Lane!!! And her writing is always wonderful. (more to follow!)
Profile Image for Mariahs_BookNook.
360 reviews3 followers
January 19, 2026
Gut rating: ⭐⭐
CAWPILE rating: 2.43 stars
Spice: Open door
ARC publication date: December 19th 2025

Tropes: Georgian era, Greek mythology, dual POV, dark secrets, alchemy, "who hurt you?", marriage of convenience

Quote: “If I am Temple, then I am a temple to Diana.”

My synopsis
1837 England - a world divided between the high society with Transcendent magic and the working class with Alchemist craft. Only men inherit this power, or so they thought...

When 32yo Lady Diana Chester seeks out a love elixir in Lady Guinevere's potion shop, it's not to find a husband but rather to get rid of one. A task urgently needed with the dark secret she hides - her impossible inheritance of her family's transcendent powers. But instead of her scheming cousin Apollo (the heir and her betrothed) drinking the elixir and falling in love with another, a handsome stranger accidentally drinks it.

For 30yo alchemist Temple Grant, his new title as the Royal Alchemist (aka the King's lapdog) has launched his family into high society but without the respect and acceptance he needs. On the hunt for a wife, Temple finds himself pulled under the spell of Diana thanks to the elixir he unintentionally drank. When Apollo discovers Diana's secret, she must go into hiding, with Temple following like a lovesick puppy offering her marriage to escape her cousin. Can Diana truly give herself to a man while keeping her secret safe?


My review
The story started off so intriguing with a fantastical world and an action packed plot that twisted in ways I wasn't expecting. I loved Temple's big loud family and the Greek mythology interwoven into the story, especially his name being Temple because "he was made to worship her".

However, around the halfway mark the book crumbles into just spice, losing the intricate plot and becoming silly events that didn't make sense to the world or the characters. The insipid Apollo's redemption arc felt wrong for the story, too. The book really dropped the potential for this to be about overcoming the misogynistic world, and instead came out rather flat.

With thanks to the Publishers and NetGalley for providing me with this ARC.


Trigger warnings: Physical abuse, sexual content, misogyny, sexism, classism, stalking, injury detail, alcoholism, incest, infidelity, death, drug abuse, suicide attempt, cursing, blood, confinement
Profile Image for Tina Miles.
494 reviews11 followers
January 31, 2026
I love this! I really like the world Lane has created and the characters who inhabit it. I read the two prequels which were excellent also. I enjoyed this story. It’s a cute story and I really liked the steamy parts too. There aren’t too many steamy scenes but they are well written. Lots of sexual tension which builds nicely to an HEA. Looking forward to the next book.
Profile Image for MaReads Books.
103 reviews3 followers
December 5, 2025
A cozy romantasy where a marriage pact turns into fate, full of banter, yearning, secret magic, and a hero who falls first and falls hard.

4,5⭐️/5 — 2🌶️/5 (4 chapitre/27)

👰🏼‍♀️ Arranged marriage
❤️‍🔥 He falls first (and hard)
✨ She has secret magic
💀 Touch her and die vibe
🔥 I would burn the world for you vibe

I picked up Binding the Baron expecting a light historical romantasy… and it ended up being exactly that, but better.
A short novel (just 250 pages!) that manages to feel complete, charming, and surprisingly rich.

The premise is simple but addictive:
-He must find a wife by order of the king, to save his family after a mistake he made.
-She must escape a marriage arranged with her cousin, a dying grandfather’s wish she refuses to honor.
They strike a bargain: she helps him navigate society, he shields her from danger.
A marriage of convenience becomes the perfect solution… but only if Diana does not fall in love. Because if she lowers her guard, Temple might uncover her secrets… and she fears he could kill her for them.

✨ A cozy romantasy vibe with stakes that matter
I loved the tone : court politics, witty tension, romantic chemistry, and a heroine trying to outmaneuver her own fate.
The worldbuilding isn’t heavy, but it’s woven in smartly: alchemy, noble expectations, power structures, transcendence magic, all present without ever slowing the story.
Despite the short page count, the pacing felt right.
We get:
-moments of individual growth
-scenes where they negotiate partnership
-glimpses of the broader world
It never feels rushed which is rare for a novella-length romantasy.

👩🏻 Diana: determined, self-aware, resisting her own desire
I adored her.
She’s clever, fiercely self-protective, and convinced that marrying Temple would ruin her,even though she’s been drawn to him since the first moment.
Her refusals, not once but three times, were perfect: not dramatic, but rooted in logic and fear.
And when she finally lets herself want things, voice her desires, claim her choices, it’s so satisfying.

« She should not encourage him. But she could not quite let him go, either. »

« She wanted to study him, to learn more about the alchemists if he’d let her, to perhaps, learn more about herself as well.»

« I do not need a gentleman to coddle me, Temple. I need an alchemist to forge me anew. »



🧔🏻Temple: a hero who falls first, fast, and respectfully
Temple is perfect.
Handsome, direct, a gentleman with sharp wit, and very obviously obsessed with Diana in the best possible way.
What I loved most is how he loves:
-he prepares her for every step (first kiss, meeting his family)
-he explains instead of demanding
-he protects, but never cages
-he accepts who she is without hesitation, especially when he discovers her transcendent abilities
His “obsession” never crosses the toxic line.
It’s patient, tender, attentive, love as presence and devotion rather than possession.
More MMCs should be written like him.

« —Are there any ladies you like? Any you can see yourself getting to know?
One. And he had no idea who she was. And his interest in her was probably entirely manufactured. »

« She was a puzzle, and he was going to piece her together. »

« I’ll kill a thousand men before I let one of them touch you. »

« Hell. He was... He might be a little bit... in love. »

« Touch her and I will delight in separating the iron from your blood. »

« I will tear this world apart with my hammer and hands before I let anyone, including the king, hurt you. Do you understand? »


Binding the Baron is a delightful surprise, a cozy, romantic, alchemy-tinged marriage-of-convenience story where:
✔ the hero falls first

✔ the heroine resists for reasons that make sense

✔ the banter sparkles

« Your glamour’s gone. You look better without it. »

« —Who are you?
—A shiny new baron. What do you think? Do I make a good one?
—You make an indecent one.  »

✔ the worldbuilding enhances the romance instead of overshadowing it

For only 250 pages, it delivers everything I want in this trope. I loved it, and I’ll definitely read whatever comes next in this world. Highly recommend if you want tension, tenderness, and a hero who actually deserves the girl.

Thank you Charlie Lane and NetGalley for sending me this ARC in exchange of an honest review.
Profile Image for Erin Arkin.
1,964 reviews372 followers
December 1, 2025
3..5 stars

Charlie Lane’s Binding the Baron is a wonderful debut to the Alchemy of Desire series, offering a truly unique blend of historical romance and magical fantasy. Set on the cusp of Queen Victoria’s reign, this book is an unputdownable story that weaves together meticulous historical ambiance, an intriguing magical underworld, and a marriage of convenience romance. Lane has done an exceptional job of proving that these three genres don’t just coexist, they elevate each other.

The novel introduces us to a hidden, glamorous side of 19th-century London, where two magical factions are at odds. Our protagonist is Diana Chester, a young woman who, in a twist of fate, inherits her dying grandfather’s transcendent magic—a power that should have gone to her male cousin. Because this magic is deemed an "aberration" for a woman to possess, Diana is immediately thrust into danger, forcing her to run for her life as her cousin plots to steal her power, no matter the cost.

Diana’s flight from West London leads her directly into the path of Temple Grant, Baron Knightly. Temple is a disgraced alchemist , exiled from his society and desperately working to restore his family’s honor after a past transgression. To regain favor and standing, the King mandates that Temple must secure a marriage from the "glamoured" society—a society Diana happens to belong to.

This necessity leads to a high-stakes "convenient binding." For Temple, it’s a political necessity; for Diana, it’s a shield against the threats of her vengeful cousin. What starts as a calculated, transactional alliance quickly ignites into something far more complicated, driven by desire and the discovery that they are both pawns in a greater, city-wide conflict. Their love story must navigate the class divisions and the dueling factions that threaten to tear their fragile worlds—and their marriage—apart.

The strength of Binding the Baron lies in the compelling and satisfying character development. Diana begins her arc defined by the constraints of her gender and societal expectations. She is initially running from her power, but her marriage to Temple forces her to confront the inheritance she possesses. Her arc is about embracing her strength and recognizing that her "aberrant" magic is actually her greatest tool for survival. She evolves from a hunted debutante into a fiercely protective heroine who uses her intellect and newfound power to claim her own destiny.

Temple offers a wonderful arc of redemption. He carries the heavy weight of his family’s disgrace, which has made him guarded and rigidly focused on duty. His initial view of Diana is purely a means to an end. However, Temple’s protective instincts and deep respect for Diana blossom into genuine, undeniable desire. His arc is a journey of learning to forgive himself, prioritizing his emotional truth over political necessity, and realizing that his ultimate redemption lies in binding himself to Diana, not just legally, but completely. Their marriage-of-convenience setup is perfectly executed, allowing the romance to be well-paced, believable, and utterly heartfelt—with a delicious "he falls first" dynamic.

What makes this book truly exceptional is the seamless integration of its three core components. The historical fantasy setting provides a charming backdrop of elegant society and strict manners, which heightens the drama of the forbidden magic. The magic system, centered around alchemists, metal might, and transcendent glamours, is detailed and feels woven into the fabric of London itself, giving the world a unique steampunk flavor. This is all anchored by an emotionally resonant romance that makes the high stakes feel intensely personal. This successful blend ensures the story is exciting, intriguing, and impossible to put down.

Binding the Baron is a charming, thrilling, and ultimately satisfying read. Charlie Lane not only demonstrates an understanding of the historical setting but also a flair for creative world-building. I thoroughly enjoyed this world and its characters, and I will definitely be picking up more books in the Alchemy of Desire series and by this author in the future.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Nicole Heron.
155 reviews1 follower
December 1, 2025
Thank you to NetGallery and Charlie Lane for the opportunity to read this ARC copy.

Rating: 3.7/3.8

If you like Bridgeton both series and the books meets fantasy and magic then this might be the book for you.

I liked how the author brought a unique perspective on bringing to life a magical system set in Victorian England. It’s very rare you come across a fantasy romance book like this one and will say it was a great debut novel for Charlie Lane!

Premise:

We are set in Victorian England, just before Queen Victoria’s reign where there seems to be two magical fractions divided by some form of conflict. We meet our FMC, Diana Chester, a young women who inherits her dying grandfathers magic, but there’s a twist Diana should not have inherited the magic….her male cousin should have. It’s giving sexism…I know shocker for 19th Century England 😂. We explore Diana coming to grips with this sudden power whilst also facing dangers of possessing such magic.

We, unsurprisingly, have plots to steal such power from her, which causes Diana to run for her life right into the arms of the sexy Baron, Temple Grant Baron Knightly, our MMC. We find that our Baron is a disgraced alchemist from high society who is trying to restore his family’s honour and favour of the more prestigious members. To regain favor and standing, the King mandates that Temple must secure a marriage from this high society.

This is where Diana comes in and somehow finds herself "convenient bound” to Temple. For Temple, it’s a political necessity; for Diana Temple acts as that protection from her cousin. Of course what starts off as a forced and transactional marriage turns into acceptance, clarity and romance. Their love must fight its way through the divided factions within this magic society but can their love overcome it all? That’s a question I will let you guys figure out for yourselves.

What drew me into the book was the character development throughout. Diana is forced to navigate through a society where sexism, constraints and societal expectation goes hand in hand for a women in 19th Century England. But despite everything she becomes this fierce character and I believe her marriage to Temple made her strength more.

What I also liked if this he falls first them in the book. It’s very rare I will reads these types of book but I feel that it was well written and I enjoyed every bit of reading how much he falls head over heels for Diana.

The introduction to the unique magical system and factions of this system was well done and I liked how it’s was nicely incorporated with the historical background of Victorian England alongside bringing this nice fantasy element to it. The magic system, centres around alchemists, and transcendent glamours, which I do feel is detailed l, however, I felt there needed to be more explanations as to the system. There were times that I hade more questions than answers give but I assume this will be delved into the other books.

I will also say that there were times that the incomplete sentences annoyed me but that is a me problem.

Overall, I did enjoy this novel and found it to be a charming, intriguing and magical read which I would recommend people to read, especially if you love historical fiction meets fantasy
Profile Image for Tracy Emro.
2,162 reviews64 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
December 11, 2025
In an alternate late-Georgian era England, where transcendent powers are weld by the titled men of the ton and the men of the gentry practice alchemy, something strange happened when Lady Diana Chester’s grandfather passed away and his powers transferred to Diana instead of her cousin Apollo, the new Marquess of Fordham. She is shocked by the discovery and keeps it secret and tries to find a way to transfer the power to Apollo, whom she is supposed to marry. She goes to great lengths to end the betrothal, including purchasing a love potion, which part of is accidently ingested by alchemist, Temple Grant – a favorite of the king. She is able to salvage most of the potion and has Apollo take it and obsess over his mistress. But that doesn’t negate the effect the potion had on Temple, who was immediately smitten and asked her to marry him, and she can’t deny she is attracted to him too, but she has no time for a tryst and slips away, sure the potion will wear off with no long-lasting effects. The next day she is confronted by Apollo who has learned the truth and tries to kill her to gain the power, forcing her to run for her life. She isn’t sure what to do and makes her way back to the potion shop, where she finds safe-haven and an unexpected protector in the form of Temple Grant.

Temple Grant performed a service for England and King William rewarded him with the title of Baron Knightly and the position of Royal Alchemist. But the honor didn’t make his life better as the king assumed it would, in fact it made things worse – he and his family were ostracized by his fellow alchemists and shunned and belittled by the ton – leaving him adrift between two worlds. Add to that the king wants him to marry into the ton and has tasked him with an impossible mission. When he meets Diana and accidentally ingests a drop of her love potion, he believes she would make the perfect wife for him – too bad she doesn’t agree, telling him the potion is responsible for his proposal. But even after the potion should have worn off – he still wants her. She finally agrees when he offers her something she needs, protection from her cousin. It is the perfect solution, she gets protection and he gets the bride the king has ordered him to take – falling in love was never part of the bargain – until it was…

I really enjoyed this fun and quirky story; it is well written and nicely paced with wonderful characters. I loved Diana and Temple, they had an incredible connection, and their banter was highly entertaining. The story is filled with amazing characters, laugh-out-loud moments, a completely redeemable villain, steamyish love scenes, magic, found family, some nail-biting moments and finally a lovely ending with the promise of HEA. I will admit that I didn’t really understand the magic system, and even now, I still don’t understand and the story did drag a bit – but the story was fun, nonetheless. This is the first book in a new series, and I am happy to recommend this title for anyone who enjoys historical romantasy!

*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that I requested and was provided to me by the publisher/author. All opinions in this review are my own. *
404 reviews13 followers
April 20, 2026
There is something undeniably charming about a romance that dares to step just slightly beyond the bounds of tradition, and Binding the Baron does so with a quiet confidence that feels both refreshing and indulgent. What begins as a tentative venture into unfamiliar territory quickly unfolds into a richly woven tale that marries the elegance of historical romance with the intrigue of fantasy.
Set against a distinctly Regency–Victorian backdrop, the novel introduces a world where societal expectations remain rigid, yet magic simmers just beneath the surface—dangerous, coveted, and not always understood. The integration of alchemy and transcendent abilities is handled with a deft touch; rather than overwhelming the reader, it reveals itself gradually, allowing the story to maintain its emotional core without sacrificing its sense of wonder.
At the heart of the narrative are Diana and Temple, whose union begins not with sweeping declarations, but with necessity. Their marriage of convenience carries all the familiar hallmarks of the trope—guarded trust, reluctant partnership, and unspoken longing—yet it is elevated by the depth of their individual burdens. Diana, burdened by a secret that places her in grave danger, is a heroine of quiet resilience. Her journey from fear to self-assured strength is particularly compelling, lending the story a satisfying emotional arc. Temple, in contrast, is steady and resolute from the outset—a man shaped by exile and expectation, yet softened by a devotion that feels both immediate and unwavering.
Their romance unfolds with a gentle, deliberate pace. There is heat, certainly, but it is tempered by tenderness and an undercurrent of yearning that feels far more intimate than overt passion alone. Temple’s early devotion and Diana’s gradual surrender to both trust and affection create a dynamic that is deeply satisfying, offering readers a love story that feels earned rather than imposed.
The world itself is equally engaging. The divide between aristocratic “Transcendents” and working-class alchemists mirrors the rigid class structures of the era, while also providing a clever commentary on power—who holds it, who is denied it, and how it can be reclaimed. The glimpses into ring binding and alchemical processes add texture to the narrative, grounding the fantastical elements in something almost tangible.
If the novel has any fault, it lies only in its brevity. Just as the characters fully come into their own, the story draws to a close, leaving a lingering desire for more time within this enchanting world. Yet perhaps that, too, is part of its charm—it leaves the reader eager, rather than sated.
Ultimately, Binding the Baron is a delightful and imaginative addition to the genre. With its blend of soft romance, subtle magic, and character-driven storytelling, it offers a comforting yet compelling escape—one that will particularly appeal to those who enjoy their historical romance with a touch of the extraordinary.
Profile Image for Fanosse23.
743 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
December 13, 2025
As an ardent admirer of Charlie Lane’s captivating storytelling, I was utterly enchanted by the sequel to this series, Till Death Duke Us Part. Lane’s latest venture, however, takes a bold departure from traditional historical romance, diving into an enthralling tapestry interwoven with historical fantasy, shimmering glamours, clandestine societies, and the looming shadow of a meddlesome king.

Prepare to be swept into a world where transcendent magic courses through the veins of titled men, passed from eldest son to eldest son—a legacy of power and peril. Yet beyond the glittering façade of nobility lies a contrasting realm: alchemists, laboring men who wield the raw force of the earth, shaping metals with the heat of their very bodies. These dynamic worlds collide, their divergent beliefs sparking conflict until an unexpected alliance shifts the tides of fate.

Set against the backdrop of Queen Victoria’s impending reign, Lane weaves a tale of forbidden love, deceit, and magical intrigue. In a shadow-draped West London chamber, Diana Chester’s life shatters with a revelation—she’s inherited her grandfather’s transcendent magic. This inheritance marks her for death, as the magic rightfully belongs to her male cousin, who covets her power with dangerous fervor. Fleeing for her life, Diana’s path crosses with Temple Grant, Baron Knightly—a disgraced alchemist prince haunted by his family’s fall from grace.

Exiled yet fiercely determined to reclaim his honor, Temple navigates the dazzling and treacherous world of West London. To regain the king’s favor, he must secure a royal alliance, and Diana, with her noble blood and enigmatic charm, becomes the perfect candidate. But their union, born of necessity and cloaked in secrets, blossoms into a love both fierce and forbidden—a romance as beautiful as it is doomed.

Lane’s masterful prose breathes life into a narrative where the might of metal clashes with the ethereal glow of glamours. Diana and Temple stand on opposing sides of a fractured society, their hearts tethered by a love that defies political machinations and magical boundaries. Their chemistry crackles, a forbidden spark intensified by their contrasting worlds and the ever-present danger lurking in the shadows. You will fall in love with Temple and root for this impossible love story to triumph.

Through gothic drama, mesmerizing magic, and heart-pounding romance, Charlie Lane crafts a story that will capture you from start to finish. This tale of a marriage of convenience, twisted by real and perilous emotions, is a triumph—a bewitching blend of history and fantasy that lingers long after the final page. Intrigued and enchanted, I eagerly await the next installment in this mesmerizing series.

I received an ARC (advanced review copy) for free and am sharing my thoughts voluntarily.

Profile Image for Elizabeth Connor.
1,474 reviews41 followers
December 29, 2025
Thanks to the author and Netgalley for an ARC of this book. It’s a bit of a departure from Lane’s usual books, but she still brings her signature storytelling ability. This time, it’s a historical romance set in an imaginary past in which the ton has “transcendant” powers that allow them to do things like cast “glamours,” and the working class guild of alchemists have the ability to shape metals in a way that’s magical, but no one is permitted to use that word. Members of the ton have “magic,” but the commoners don’t. And only men have any of these abilities, magical or not. So, aside from the supernatural abilities, things are pretty much the same.

Diana is first introduced to us as she attempts to find a love potion to administer to her cousin Apollo so he will fall in love with someone else and release her from their betrothal, which neither of them really wants, but which her grandfather made them promise as his deathbed wish. Unfortunately, Temple—recently elevated to Royal Alchemist and given the title of Baron Knightly—mistakenly takes in just a drop of the potion as Diana tackles him and attempts to stop him. The love potion is a temporary thing, but Temple can’t seem to shake his obsession with Diana and searches to find her identity. Meanwhile, Diana continues to search for ways to prevent the impending marriage. I won’t say more about the plot because I want it to remain a mystery.

I will, however, share a particular quote that I enjoyed. For background, alchemists carry heat in their bodies that allows them to forge metal without access to their actual forge. Obviously, they can do more in the presence of their forge, but their powers are not too limited by their proximity to one. This quote stood out to me, a reaction Temple had when Diana told him there was nothing she could do, and her cousin could destroy her. “His hands clenched and unclenched, hammers becoming blades becoming hammers.”

I loved this story and the characters within it. I loved the way Diana and Temple’s relationship deepened over time, turning into love when both entered the marriage for different reasons. I loved their desire to want to protect one another, even if it meant their own destruction. And I loved how Apollo tried to redeem himself in the end. Overall, I loved the book and I’m looking forward to more set in this fantastical historical world.
Profile Image for Havok.
145 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
December 12, 2025
Binding The Baron was honestly such an adorable surprise. I went into it thinking it would just be a cute little romance outside my usual reads, but it completely won me over with its charm. Author Charlie Lane created a story that feels like a warm cup of tea on a rainy day, cozy and comforting, yet sprinkled with just enough magic and mischief to keep you smiling the entire time.

Diana and Temple were genuinely delightful together. Their interactions had this soft slow burn energy that felt playful, tender, and filled with the kind of chemistry that makes your heart flutter. Every moment between them carried a mix of curiosity and affection, as if they were slowly learning how to orbit around each other without even realizing they had already fallen. The passion was there, absolutely, but it was wrapped in gentleness, understanding, and that sweet kind of yearning that makes you grin like an idiot.

The world itself added an extra layer of charm. Alchemists being underestimated and others hid behind glamour gave the story just the right touch of whimsy and heart. I loved watching those small sparks of vulnerability break through, reminding us that real love never needs to be disguised. It grows in honesty, in shared secrets, in the way two people choose each other even when the world tries to convince them otherwise.

Diana was such a lovable main character. She had this perfect blend of determination, sweetness, and quiet power that made her easy to connect with. Temple was the perfect balance to her, a man who carried his own strenght, yet, softened beautifully in her presence. Together, they felt like two puzzle pieces that had been waiting for each other all along.

By the end, I found myself wishing the book had more pages because I genuinely wanted to stay with them longer. Binding The Baron was cute, heartwarming, and full of magical romantic sweetness, and it reminded me how comforting it can be to step into a world where love is both soft and powerful. I am so glad I picked it up, and now I definitely want more stories like this.
Profile Image for Karolina.
41 reviews9 followers
December 8, 2025
One drop of potion, one knight to the rescue.

I love Regency romances, add some magic to it and I'm hooked. The story is told from two POVs. Temple Grant, Baron Knightly and Diana Chester. Both characters were well fleshed out and easy to root for.

Knightly is a very apt name for Temple; he is very selfless, always trying to protect those he loves. He risked everything to save people's lives. Ostracized by alchemists who care more about money than how many people could die because of their actions, he tries to find his place in the ton. His family was hilarious. Especially little Jax and the "Hell" twins. Even when they lost everything they didn't blame Temple and always wanted what is best for him.

After the death of her grandfather Diana receives his magic power which should only go to the male heir of the title. In his final moments he forces her and her cousin Apollo to promise that they will marry. Despite her promise Diana will do anything to stop the wedding. I really liked her, she was brave, curious and enthusiastic about whatever she studies.

World building was well done and the use of magic was very innovative. I loved that we learn about the lore through Diana's studies and not through some prolonged explanations from the author. Although the story is more focused on characters then action, it is still a fast paced and exciting story. I couldn't stop reading. I would finish it in one sitting if I had time.

Overall, it was a wonderful romance with great chemistry between the characters. I would recommend this book to people who love magical Regency romance where love conquers all obstacles.

Many thanks to the publisher and NetGally for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Hannah.
221 reviews9 followers
March 27, 2026
i loved the whole historical fantasy vibe 🏰✨, it felt like bridgerton but with magic 🔮, it totally worked 😌

The whole world with transcendents and alchemists was really interesting 🔮, especially how magic is meant to be inherited by men and then diana just completely flips that 👀 by inheriting it instead of her cousin
Diana and Temple were so good together 🫶 loved their dynamic so much, especially the way their relationship builds through trust and secrets 🤫 the marriage of convenience aspect 💍 worked really well and didn’t feel rushed, you could actually see how their connection developed 😭
The whole ring binding 💍 and alchemy 🔮 side of things added such a cool layer to the story, it didn’t feel like info dumping either, it kind of unfolded as you learned more with the characters which i really liked 🫶

i also liked how diana’s situation kept raising the stakes 😬 especially with her safety and everything going on with Apollo, it kept the tension going the whole time 🔥

Temple’s character was really interesting too 👀 there were moments where i was like okay are we crossing a line here????? 😭 but it never actually went there and i liked how that played out
the story had a bit of everything ✨ action 🔥 secrets 🤫 politics 👑 romance 💕 magic 🔮 and i loved seeing women like lady guinevere pushing against the constraints of the world they’re in 👑

tropes ✨
marriage of convenience 💍
historical fantasy 🏰✨
forced proximity 🤝
magic and alchemy 🔮
found family 🫶
forbidden vibes 🚫
strong female lead 👑
secrets and lies 🤫

historicalfantasy magicandalchemy marriageofconvenience forcedproximity foundfamily forbiddenromance strongfemalelead secretsandlies bridgertonvibes romantasy
Profile Image for BookForAHeart.
353 reviews25 followers
December 4, 2025
👑 A Match Made in Magic & Mayhem: Binding the Baron Review! 👑

If you're looking for a historical fantasy romance that hits all the sweetest notes—with a side of high-stakes, city-dividing drama—look no further! This book is pure catnip! 😻 I couldn't put it down. The whole vibe is luxurious Victorian society meets secret, powerful magic, and it’s just chef's kiss. 💋

Meet Diana Chester, our accidental magical heiress! She inherits transcendent power that marks her as an "aberration" and suddenly has a terrifying cousin hunting her down. Diana has to vanish, and fast! She's vulnerable, but oh-so-intriguing.

Enter Temple Grant, Baron Knightly. Swoon alert! 🚨 He’s an alchemist prince who has fallen from grace and needs a serious political rebound. The King demands a proper wife to restore his favor, making Diana the perfect, convenient solution. Their partnership is built on necessity and secrets—the ideal foundation for a disastrously beautiful romance! 💔

The real thrill here is the division in London. Diana is tethered to the shimmering, glamorous world, while Temple is bound by the rigid laws of metal. They are literally on opposite sides of the social and magical spectrum, which only makes their shared spark of desire that much more intense and forbidden. 🔥 Their chemistry is off the charts, but their love story is complicated by political intrigue and the fate of their entire city.

This gorgeous tale of a marriage of convenience twisted by real, dangerous feelings is an absolute triumph. It’s gothic, it’s magical, it’s dramatic, and it’s impossible not to binge! Grab your coziest blanket and dive in! 🌙📖
Profile Image for Elizgangsta.
200 reviews24 followers
December 17, 2025
Diana grew up in the Ton, where the eldest boy inherits the power of a transcendent after the current holder's death. However, things take an unexpected turn when Diana gains the power instead of her cousin Apollo, whom their dying grandfather wished for her to marry. To protect her secret and avoid marriage, Diana concocts a love potion to make Apollo fall for his mistress. But a handsome stranger accidentally drinks it.

Temple, the king’s alchemist, betrayed his kind to save lives and has since been exiled with his family. Now, he works for the king to provide for them, riddled by guilt over their losses. Tasked with finding a bride from the Ton by the king, Temple accidentally consumes the love potion and is convinced he has found his perfect match.


My thoughts on the book:

I really enjoyed this book! It was an easy-to-understand fantasy with unique powers I haven't encountered in other stories. With the transcendence being able to create glamours on themselves and their surroundings and alchemist being able to control specific metals.

I liked both main characters and their connection.
I do wish Diana had been braver earlier, but I understand that she’s in a time when women had little power or say.
Temple’s large family added depth, with each character feeling distinct and memorable. I do enjoy a grumpy mc!
Apollo was obnoxious and the worst, but I’m looking forward to his story next.
The reason for a 4-star rating instead of 5 is that some parts felt a bit disjointed and interrupted the flow, but overall, I loved the story!

Thank you NetGalley and BookBuzz.net for this eARC. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Krista Nicole.
352 reviews28 followers
December 6, 2025
If you’re looking for exciting, Bridgerton style romantasy, with plenty of magic interwoven into the regency era of history, check out this book!!

You follow a FMC, who after the death of her grandfather, inherits the power that was meant for her cousin as usually the male line is the one who inherits the power along with the title. As things start to fall apart and her cousin finds out she is who got the power and not him, she must flee for her life and along the way she meets the MMC, an alchemist who’s been raised up in society due to his help to the king but cast out by his own alchemist people. While they get closer, they each keep their own secrets to protect themselves, but secrets tend to have a way of always coming out!

This book was an exciting adventure into one of my favorite eras of history! I loved getting to read about a fun magical system while still getting to see the pair navigate through high society and the rumor mill of the ton! There was also plenty of tension and banter between the pair and I love how the FMC Diana puts both the MMC and any other characters who doubt her in their place with her words. I also really liked the dichotomy between her unfeeling family from the upper class versus how welcoming and happy the MMCs family is, and that money and status doesn’t always mean you’re happy, and usually ends up with just added pressure. Overall I really enjoyed this book and would love to read more stories in this world from this author! My rating 4.6/5!

Thanks to the author and R&R book tours for the gifted copy, all opinions given are my own!
Profile Image for Winnifred D..
960 reviews36 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
December 15, 2025
Tropes: class difference; MFC/MMC with special powers; marriage of convenience
Steam level: 3
Language: some "f-bombs", if that offends you.
First in a series.

This is a sweet, sexy HR/fantasy mashup by a talented writer. Charlie Lane knows how to turn a phrase and create endearing MC's; Temple and Diana's bond is a great example of how effective she is at creating believable romantic chemstry, even in a make believe realm. The world building is fairly strong, with the clash of status between Alchemists and Transcendents at the forefront of the plot, although I did feel a bit confused at times in the opening chapters. There is a description of both groups before the book starts, but maybe a prologue featuring key scenes with each of the MC's would have been a good way to delineate the way this steam-punk-like society had split, as well as cutting down on some of the occasional "telling instead of showing" bits. The info-dump is thankfully kept at a minimum, though, and the plot moves along fairly well, especially when the action heats up around the 75% point.

If you are a reader of HR's, as I am, many of the beats/tropes here will be familiar. Admittedly I'm not a fantasy reader (more into sci-fi), but the writer does a nice job of weaving in fact and fiction, with references to mythology, history, and science throughout.

Romance is the centerpiece here, and based on that, this is a solid 4 stars from me.

I read an advanced reader copy of this book thanks to Net Galley and the author. This is my honest, voluntary review.
Profile Image for Robin.Bookish.Escape.
293 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
December 17, 2025
“My body is yours. Your protection and your pleasure.”

This historical fantasy romance is a steamy stand-alone that is a part of an interconnected series set in Victorian era London that is a Bridgerton like story but filled with fantasy and magic, banter and yearning, love potions and binding rings, a magical blacksmith and alchemists… all during a time when the patriarchy is ruling everything, will soon be shown the true meaning of power.

This story follows Diana, who despite the notion that magic is passed through the males in the family (called Transcendents), inherits the magic after the death of her grandfather which infuriates her male cousins and sets them on a path for her destruction. In comes Temple, an alchemist (someone who is denied the title of magic wielder but can perform some sensational spectacles) who has been exiled from his colleagues for sharing their knowledge and secrets with the King rather than hoarding it. Together they must navigate their places in the world all while attempting to trust themselves and their magnetic connection which may ignite everything they know and cost them everything.

Well written with lots of action and whimsical magic woven through out. I appreciated how the strength of women and is at the forefront of this story despite the Victorian era that it is set in. That is to say, that although men still run the world as in the real world, the feminine power is showcased in a way that shows just how magnificent it can be.

“Touch her and I will delight in separating the iron from your blood.”
Profile Image for Jennifer.
32 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
December 12, 2025
Binding the Baron is Bridgerton meets magic and alchemy. Diana unexpectedly inherits magic that should never fall to a woman, placing a target squarely on her back as Apollo, her cousin and betrothed, decides he must take her life to gain the magic everyone believed would be his when their grandfather died. She slips into hiding in a potion maker’s shop, where the story blooms with delightful side characters. Before disappearing, she has a chaotic encounter with the king’s alchemist, Temple, and accidentally doses him with a love potion. Convinced he’s still enchanted, Temple searches for her the following day, only to uncover the truth of her situation. His solution is equal parts bold and practical: a proposal that protects her and conveniently fulfills his own requirement to wed, a declaration made by the king.

This story is simply fun. The chemistry between Diana and Temple sparks in all the right ways, and their banter practically glows. I loved that they’re older, clever, and deeply curious about one another and each other's interests. While the stakes rise now and then, the book still carries a cozy, comforting vibe.

I’d happily recommend this to anyone who adores romantasy, cozy fantasy, or a delightfully spirited read. And I’m already eager to see what unfolds for Apollo in the next installment.

Thank you to NetGalley and Charlie Lane for the advance copy. I thoroughly enjoyed it!
393 reviews1 follower
January 2, 2026
Before I started reading the book I didn't think I would like it because I usually read historical romance and have never wanted to read romantasy or fantasy even if it is in a historical setting. As I was reading this novel, I found myself enthralled with the story and I didn't put it down until I reached the end of the book. Temple Grant is the King's royal alchemist and has been recently given a title, Baron Knightly and now the King expects him to find a wife. He meets Lady Diana Chester when he pours himself a drink of whisky which Diana has laced with a love potion in an attempt to get her cousin Apollo to ingest and fall in love with any woman who wasn't her so that she would not have to marry him. Apollo is the current Marquess of Fordham but he did not inherit the magical powers from their grandfather when he died. After Apollo finds out the magic transferred to Diana, he tries to force her to transfer the powers to him. Diana goes into hiding and after Temple is given a deadline for finding a wife, he decides to pursue Diana. I am enchanted with this new series- it has everything a reader of the genre would want- its fast paced, sexy, has intrigue, mystery and a HEA. I have been a fan of Charlie Lane's since I first encountered her books and cannot wait until the next story is published so I can read it.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and I am voluntarily leaving this review.
Profile Image for Veronica.
19 reviews
February 6, 2026
Binding the Baron is such a unique, lovely book. I was unsure what to expect from a Victorian Fantasy, but it's a pleasant mishmash of typical Victorian historical romance of class clashes and repressed women, with a lot of magic. I loved the idea of Transcendents, Alchemists, and Potion makers in a Victorian Society that is still trying to keep nobles at the top, despite their transcendent magic not being powerful compared to the other magic wielders.

Diana, a transcendent noblewoman, is desperate with a deadly secret. She has accidentally inherited transcendent magic, something so rare that she could be put to death. She needs to escape her desperate and increasingly violent cousin, her fiance. One night she accidentally gives a love potion to the wrong man, Temple, the new Royal Alchemist, an imposing outsider. And thus begins a swoonworthy and delightful romance which is also surprisingly deep, in which Temple, a very practical man cannot help but fall for the enchanting Diana. Their romance, especially Diana's inner doubts, gave me all the feels. I loved that Temple falls first, and he courts her while she hides at Lady Godiva's Potion Shop.

Diana blooms and then shines when her tiny world opens and she finds an "Alchemist to forge (her) anew." It's quite clever that Diana's existence is necessary for Queen Victoria's rise.

There is a HEA that sets up a second book with a very surprising couple.
Profile Image for Neeha.
116 reviews4 followers
February 26, 2026
Binding the Baron is set in a fascinating, magic-driven reimagining of late-Georgian England, where society is split between the transcendents (the aristocrats) and alchemists (the gentry/tradesmen). It’s such an interesting setup, I just had to pick it up.

The story starts with a love potion. Diana, our heroine, is desperate to make her fiancé fall in love, but with anyone but her. Temple, a newly titled alchemist, is forced into elite society by the King and needs to marry to solidify his status. When he ends up drinking the potion meant for the unfortunate cousin, it sets off a series of events that Diana had just not planned for.

Our main leads, Temple and Diana, were adorable together. Their relationship progressed fluidly from strangers to friends to something deeper.
The standout element for me, of course, was its unique magic system. Kudos to Charlie Lane for crafting such an intriguing and immersive world.

That said, while I loved the plot, the writing leaned towards a very short, clipped style, and unfortunately, I couldn’t gel with it. It made my reading experience feel a bit disjointed at times, pulling me out of the story. Also, the second half focused more on the steamy scenes than the plot. This could have been a great read, but it ended up falling short.

Overall, I may not have been the right reader for this one, though I enjoyed the story, world-building, and the romance. I just wish the writing style had landed better for me.
Profile Image for Amy.
238 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
December 18, 2025
Binding the Baron by Charlie Lane opened my eyes to a new genre of paranormal historical romance. I have read paranormal contemporary romance, but holy smokes!! This paranormal romance is hot in more ways than one.

Lady Diana Chester is an interesting and multifaceted character. I found myself liking her a lot and cheering her on. I appreciate a heroine who doesn’t just accept her lot in life. She develops a spiritedness about her that she doesn’t always seem to feel, but it helps her get through some pretty bleak times.

Temple…oh Temple. He’s a bit of a tragic hero at first. As he hits his stride in the story, oh my goodness! Many times in the book I would have been happy if he could just hop out of the pages and give my own irl hero some advice about how to treat a lady to make her feel like she’s “the one.”

I’m looking forward to the next book in the series, but let’s just say that Apollo, Diana’s cousin and main villain in this story will need an amazing redemption arc! I was not too pleased with his behavior for the vast majority of Diana and Temple’s story.

I was barely able to put this book down. I have a feeling it’s going to be a very bingeable series!

Please do pay attention to the author’s trigger warnings. They are there for a reason.

I received an ARC. The opinions expressed above are mine.
26 reviews1 follower
December 19, 2025
I picked this book up because of the blurb. Romantasy meets Bridgerton, that combination convinced me. And the book delivered.

What stood out was the pacing. It was very easy to stay engaged. At the same time, the worldbuilding unfolds naturally as the plot progresses rather than being dumped all at once. One of my favourite aspect was the way the author explored social divisions, especially power dynamics and gender roles. I liked how inequality existed on both sides. Even among the alchemists, who I felt more enlightened, women are still pushed aside. That contrast made the world layered and realistic.

The romance worked really well for me too. The courtship, the shift in trust and the power dynamics between the two leads were handled well. Both characters are powerful in their own ways, yet kind and grounded. Neither felt overshadowed by the other, which I liked. I also loved the sense of hope felt through the story, that change is possible, that women don’t have to keep shrinking themselves to fit into systems designed to please men. And just a quick FYI for readers, this book does contain spice, so whether that’s something you actively enjoy or prefer to avoid, it’s good to know before going in.

Overall, Binding the Baron was an engaging read that blends romance, fantasy and social commentary really well. I’d definitely continue with the series.
Profile Image for Cassandra.
2,995 reviews26 followers
December 9, 2025
Charlie Lane is a favorite author for me. I have enjoyed everything I ready by her so I was excited to see this in NetGalley. I was also a little unsure as I am not a huge fantasy book fan but I trusted my favorite cinnamon roll author. The magic aspect is fairly simple and it adds additional layers to the sexism and classism that existed during that time. I liked the magic seemed science based which the author confirmed in her notes at the end of the book.

Our characters, Diana was scared and rightfully so of a few different things. The potential physical abuse from her family but they also dimmed her life. She is a natural reader and researcher, she loved learning and exploring subjects. It was nice to see this not just through the books but her work in the garden. Temple, dare I say this is the grumpiest most "alpha" man I have read by this author. I think it might also be his role as the alchemist as the side affects of his work. And he was very prOtecT which was nice and he never WAVERED! He didn't doubt Diana nor his feelings for her and it was nice cause it meant no third act break up.
Profile Image for Bookish.Helen.
296 reviews27 followers
December 30, 2025
I really loved Charlie Lane’s earlier series, The Art of Love, so I was excited to read her new foray into fantasy linked with historical romance. I genuinely wanted to like this book more than I did. For several reasons, I found it hard to get through, and if I didn’t adore this author so much, I would’ve abandoned it before finishing.

The thing that distracted and aggravated me to no end was the incomplete sentences. I understand the impact of a sentence fragment for emphasis or to convey a certain tone or mood, but using them repeatedly with no apparent purpose just made me a bit crazy.

The magical elements were original and interesting — and I did enjoy those — but they were fairly limited. The book mainly read as a historical romance, and while that’s my current favourite genre, I wanted to see more fantasy incorporated.

The characters felt a bit flat to me, and I didn’t feel much chemistry between the mains, which made it harder for me to settle into the story. Overall, this one didn’t work for me, though I know it has for many other readers. 2.5 stars, rounded up to 3.

I received an advanced copy of the book for free and am leaving this review voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews