What do you think?
Rate this book
The Knife Maker of Venice
A young Englishman captured by slavers must survive the snakepit that is seventeenth-century Venice.
1604. As pirates seeking slaves to sell in the markets of North Africa terrorise the coasts of Europe, headstrong Richard Sheriff and his sister Elizabeth are torn from their Devonshire home and thrust into a waking nightmare.
Richard's skills as a blacksmith see him fetch a high price, but the pirate captain has other plans for Elizabeth and once they are separated, Richard has no idea of his sister's fate. They must both learn to survive on a deadly voyage into the unknown.
Sold into servitude in glittering, vicious city of secrets, he is apprenticed to a knife maker. Richard's talents soon win him renown... but haunted by his sister's absence, he vows never to stop looking for her, knowing she would do the same for him.
First he must survive that city of ghosts. Will the siblings live to see each other again, or will they join the myriads lost to Venice, where life is cheap, profit is all, and escape nigh-on impossible?
A powerful historical adventure perfect for fans of Kate Mosse, Ken Follett and Robert Harris.
Reviews for THE KNIFE MAKER OF VENICE
'A page-turner of the highest order, perfect for fans of Conn Iggulden, Dan Jones and Giles Kristian' Daily Express
'A proper edge-of-the-seat page-turner... vivid and gripping. A superb novel' Elizabeth Chadwick
'Thick with tension, ablaze with fear and thrilling action, yet driven by a love so strong, I couldn't look away. Gilman has created a mighty evocation of seventeenth-century Venice.' Kate Furnivall
'An unforgettable adventure' Clare Whitfield
'Relentless suspense against the backdrop of a stunningly realized Renaissance-era Venice' Boyd and Beth Morrison
'Fantastic... A dark, compelling story that cuts through like a blade [and] grips from the very first page.' S.W. Perry
1604. As pirates seeking slaves to sell in the markets of North Africa terrorise the coasts of Europe, headstrong Richard Sheriff and his sister Elizabeth are torn from their Devonshire home and thrust into a waking nightmare.
Richard's skills as a blacksmith see him fetch a high price, but the pirate captain has other plans for Elizabeth and once they are separated, Richard has no idea of his sister's fate. They must both learn to survive on a deadly voyage into the unknown.
Sold into servitude in glittering, vicious city of secrets, he is apprenticed to a knife maker. Richard's talents soon win him renown... but haunted by his sister's absence, he vows never to stop looking for her, knowing she would do the same for him.
First he must survive that city of ghosts. Will the siblings live to see each other again, or will they join the myriads lost to Venice, where life is cheap, profit is all, and escape nigh-on impossible?
A powerful historical adventure perfect for fans of Kate Mosse, Ken Follett and Robert Harris.
Reviews for THE KNIFE MAKER OF VENICE
'A page-turner of the highest order, perfect for fans of Conn Iggulden, Dan Jones and Giles Kristian' Daily Express
'A proper edge-of-the-seat page-turner... vivid and gripping. A superb novel' Elizabeth Chadwick
'Thick with tension, ablaze with fear and thrilling action, yet driven by a love so strong, I couldn't look away. Gilman has created a mighty evocation of seventeenth-century Venice.' Kate Furnivall
'An unforgettable adventure' Clare Whitfield
'Relentless suspense against the backdrop of a stunningly realized Renaissance-era Venice' Boyd and Beth Morrison
'Fantastic... A dark, compelling story that cuts through like a blade [and] grips from the very first page.' S.W. Perry
512 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 13, 2026
About the author
David Gilman
47 books445 followersDavid Gilman was raised in Liverpool and educated in Wales. By the time he was 16 he was driving a battered 1946 Ford, ferrying construction workers in the African bush. A variety of jobs followed in different countries: fire and rescue, forestry work, JCB driver, window dresser and professional photographer in an advertising agency. He served in the Parachute Regiment’s Reconnaissance Platoon and then worked in publishing. In 1986 he turned to full-time writing. He has written many radio and television scripts including several years of ‘A Touch of Frost’. In 2007 his ‘Danger Zone’ trilogy for YA was sold in 15 countries. The first in the series – The Devil’s Breath was long listed for the CILIP Carnegie Medal and won the French Prix Polar Jeunesse. He also writes for younger children. MONKEY and ME has been nominated for the Carnegie Medal. ‘MASTER of WAR’ is the first in a series of HF for adults that follows the fortunes of Thomas Blackstone during the 100 Years’ War. The 7th volume - 'SHADOW OF THE HAWK' is published in February 2021.
A new contemporary thriller series - THE ENGLISHMAN - was published in 2020 to critical acclaim. The second book in The Englishman series will be published in early 2022.
A new contemporary thriller series - THE ENGLISHMAN - was published in 2020 to critical acclaim. The second book in The Englishman series will be published in early 2022.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews
September 7, 2026
What a page turner! Absolutely gripping and engrossing from the off. A masterpiece in storytelling. It’s full of grittiness, intrigue, suspense and emotion.
Set in 1604, the scene is set when English blacksmith Richard Sheriff and his sister Elizabeth are wrenched from their Totnes home and the sanctity of the river Dart, by pirates seeking slaves to sell in North Africa.
A horrendous sea voyage follows, where both have to survive in different ways to ensure they stay alive and well during the deadly voyage.
Eventually sold as an enslaved worker to a master knife maker in Venice, Richard soon shows his talents and wins renown for his craftsmanship and creativity. Meanwhile Elizabeth is facing impending marriage to the slaver who took them, John Challoner.
What happens next will test them both to the limits of human endurance. In the city of ghosts where life is cheap and power, corruption and profit prevail over all else, can the siblings find each other once more and escape to a free life?
Brilliantly constructed, full of adventure, tension, descriptive scene setting and oozing historical drama. Loved it!
Set in 1604, the scene is set when English blacksmith Richard Sheriff and his sister Elizabeth are wrenched from their Totnes home and the sanctity of the river Dart, by pirates seeking slaves to sell in North Africa.
A horrendous sea voyage follows, where both have to survive in different ways to ensure they stay alive and well during the deadly voyage.
Eventually sold as an enslaved worker to a master knife maker in Venice, Richard soon shows his talents and wins renown for his craftsmanship and creativity. Meanwhile Elizabeth is facing impending marriage to the slaver who took them, John Challoner.
What happens next will test them both to the limits of human endurance. In the city of ghosts where life is cheap and power, corruption and profit prevail over all else, can the siblings find each other once more and escape to a free life?
Brilliantly constructed, full of adventure, tension, descriptive scene setting and oozing historical drama. Loved it!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I had previously read a novel by this author, so I already knew I enjoyed his writing style. This historical fiction opens with a prologue set in 1594, before the main story begins in 1604.
Richard Sherriff is a trainee blacksmith in Totnes, Devon. His master recognises his potential, but Richard is young, impulsive, and has a habit of speaking out when he should keep quiet. Which lands him in trouble, but when he does speak out it is because he is seeing a wrong being done to someone.
While things settle down, Richard is sent back to his sister Elizabeth’s home near the River Dart. It is there that John Challenor unexpectedly arrives. Beth hasn’t seen him for years and had believed he was dead. They had once been courting, and John had wanted to marry her. Now he stands on her doorstep, telling her to pack her belongings because he will protect her. But protect her from what?
John Challenor is essentially a pirate. He robs ships sailing the seas and also captures people to sell into slavery. During this visit, he takes all the townspeople aboard his ship, men women and children, if they survive the crossing, they all become slaves, their futures suddenly uncertain. Beth is kept in separate quarters, away from the other captives. What follows is a brutal sea voyage, attacks from other vessels, and the eventual sale of the prisoners.
The ship initially stops in Tunis, but Challenor is soon forced to move on, and they eventually arrive in Venice, where he owns a grand house. He wants Beth to marry him, but after everything she has witnessed, could she ever agree? She has already suffered the heartbreak of losing her brother when he is sold to another owner.
Richard is sold to a blacksmith, where he learns to craft exquisite knives that wealthy customers will pay a fortune for. Unfortunately, it is his owner who profits from his remarkable talent rather than Richard himself.
I wasn’t entirely sure this story would capture my attention, but it did from the very first page. The short, punchy chapters kept the pace moving, and despite being almost 500 pages long, I flew through it. I really enjoy this author’s writing style. He doesn’t over-describe every scene, yet he creates such an atmospheric picture of Venice, with its maze of narrow alleyways, that I felt as though I was walking through the city alongside the characters.
I loved both Beth and Richard. Their bond as siblings is one of the novel’s strengths, having looked out for each other since childhood. There are plenty of twists and turns throughout the story. Richard has no idea where Beth is living, only that she is with Challenor. As someone begins seeking revenge against Challenor, the danger steadily increases.
The corruption throughout Venice is rife, and everyone has to be extremely careful about who they trust. Slaves remain bound to their owners until their owner’s death. Richard’s owner is an exceptionally wealthy woman with powerful connections, and under her ownership he becomes an outstanding knife maker.
The novel is packed with action, but what impressed me most was how authentic it all felt. Through vivid descriptions of the sights, smells, and winding streets, the author brings every setting to life. The stark divide between the wealthy and the poor is portrayed convincingly, as is the bleak reality facing women sold into slavery unless they possess a valuable skill.
This is a thoroughly researched historical novel, with fascinating period details woven naturally into the story. Combined with memorable characters, plenty of action, and an engaging plot, it made for a compelling read that I thoroughly enjoyed.
If you enjoy historical fiction I would highly recommend this. An easy 5⭐️ read.
Richard Sherriff is a trainee blacksmith in Totnes, Devon. His master recognises his potential, but Richard is young, impulsive, and has a habit of speaking out when he should keep quiet. Which lands him in trouble, but when he does speak out it is because he is seeing a wrong being done to someone.
While things settle down, Richard is sent back to his sister Elizabeth’s home near the River Dart. It is there that John Challenor unexpectedly arrives. Beth hasn’t seen him for years and had believed he was dead. They had once been courting, and John had wanted to marry her. Now he stands on her doorstep, telling her to pack her belongings because he will protect her. But protect her from what?
John Challenor is essentially a pirate. He robs ships sailing the seas and also captures people to sell into slavery. During this visit, he takes all the townspeople aboard his ship, men women and children, if they survive the crossing, they all become slaves, their futures suddenly uncertain. Beth is kept in separate quarters, away from the other captives. What follows is a brutal sea voyage, attacks from other vessels, and the eventual sale of the prisoners.
The ship initially stops in Tunis, but Challenor is soon forced to move on, and they eventually arrive in Venice, where he owns a grand house. He wants Beth to marry him, but after everything she has witnessed, could she ever agree? She has already suffered the heartbreak of losing her brother when he is sold to another owner.
Richard is sold to a blacksmith, where he learns to craft exquisite knives that wealthy customers will pay a fortune for. Unfortunately, it is his owner who profits from his remarkable talent rather than Richard himself.
I wasn’t entirely sure this story would capture my attention, but it did from the very first page. The short, punchy chapters kept the pace moving, and despite being almost 500 pages long, I flew through it. I really enjoy this author’s writing style. He doesn’t over-describe every scene, yet he creates such an atmospheric picture of Venice, with its maze of narrow alleyways, that I felt as though I was walking through the city alongside the characters.
I loved both Beth and Richard. Their bond as siblings is one of the novel’s strengths, having looked out for each other since childhood. There are plenty of twists and turns throughout the story. Richard has no idea where Beth is living, only that she is with Challenor. As someone begins seeking revenge against Challenor, the danger steadily increases.
The corruption throughout Venice is rife, and everyone has to be extremely careful about who they trust. Slaves remain bound to their owners until their owner’s death. Richard’s owner is an exceptionally wealthy woman with powerful connections, and under her ownership he becomes an outstanding knife maker.
The novel is packed with action, but what impressed me most was how authentic it all felt. Through vivid descriptions of the sights, smells, and winding streets, the author brings every setting to life. The stark divide between the wealthy and the poor is portrayed convincingly, as is the bleak reality facing women sold into slavery unless they possess a valuable skill.
This is a thoroughly researched historical novel, with fascinating period details woven naturally into the story. Combined with memorable characters, plenty of action, and an engaging plot, it made for a compelling read that I thoroughly enjoyed.
If you enjoy historical fiction I would highly recommend this. An easy 5⭐️ read.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The Knife Maker of Venice is a pulse-pounding historical epic adventure by David Gilman that takes readers on a journey they will certainly not forget in a hurry.
1604 and the world for brother and sister Richard and Elizabeth Sherriff is turned on its head in a heartbeat. Thrust into a nightmare from which there is no escape, they are captured by slavers and torn from their existence in their Devonshire home and catapulted into a world of danger, jeopardy and fear. While Richard fetches a high price due to his skills as a blacksmith, the pirate captain has nefarious plans for Elizabeth and when the two siblings are cruelly wrenched apart, they cannot help but wonder whether they will ever see one another ever again.
Having been sold as a servant in Venice, Richard’s talents see him apprenticed to a knife maker. Yet, burning at the back of his mind is the thought that his sister is out there all alone and at the mercy of the shadiest, cruellest and most sadistic of characters. Vowing to find Elizabeth whatever the cost, as Richard finds himself having to stay wary in the city of ghosts, he is adamant that he will see his sister again. But will he survive the many obstacles standing in his way? Or will Richard and Elizabeth be forever forced to pay the price for another’s man greed and avarice?
Andrew Taylor and Ken Follett fans will be completely gripped by David Gilman’s The Knife Maker of Venice. Atmospheric, enthralling and vividly written, this is historical fiction at its most exciting and enjoyable. With characters that leap off the pages, twists and turns galore and plenty of shocks and revelations to keep readers burning the midnight oil, David Gilman’s The Knife Maker of Venice is guaranteed to thrill and delight.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
1604 and the world for brother and sister Richard and Elizabeth Sherriff is turned on its head in a heartbeat. Thrust into a nightmare from which there is no escape, they are captured by slavers and torn from their existence in their Devonshire home and catapulted into a world of danger, jeopardy and fear. While Richard fetches a high price due to his skills as a blacksmith, the pirate captain has nefarious plans for Elizabeth and when the two siblings are cruelly wrenched apart, they cannot help but wonder whether they will ever see one another ever again.
Having been sold as a servant in Venice, Richard’s talents see him apprenticed to a knife maker. Yet, burning at the back of his mind is the thought that his sister is out there all alone and at the mercy of the shadiest, cruellest and most sadistic of characters. Vowing to find Elizabeth whatever the cost, as Richard finds himself having to stay wary in the city of ghosts, he is adamant that he will see his sister again. But will he survive the many obstacles standing in his way? Or will Richard and Elizabeth be forever forced to pay the price for another’s man greed and avarice?
Andrew Taylor and Ken Follett fans will be completely gripped by David Gilman’s The Knife Maker of Venice. Atmospheric, enthralling and vividly written, this is historical fiction at its most exciting and enjoyable. With characters that leap off the pages, twists and turns galore and plenty of shocks and revelations to keep readers burning the midnight oil, David Gilman’s The Knife Maker of Venice is guaranteed to thrill and delight.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
As a fan of historical fiction, the blurb for The Knife Maker of Venice immediately caught my attention. I had not read anything by David Gilman before, but the premise intrigued me enough to give it a try. I'm pleased to say that the story delivers exactly what the synopsis promises.
The novel begins at a fairly slow pace, focusing on introducing the characters and establishing the setting of early seventeenth-century Europe. During a time when slavery was widespread, the story follows a young English boy who is captured and sold into slavery in Venice. While the opening chapters are heavily focused on world-building, the plot gathers momentum in the second half as the action and intrigue begin to unfold.
The central characters, Richard and Elizabeth, are particularly believable. Their sibling bond feels genuine, and it is easy to become invested in their journey. Both characters make difficult and sometimes drastic decisions in order to protect one another, highlighting the strength of their relationship and making them easy to root for.
Although the pacing is somewhat slow at the beginning, requiring a little patience, the payoff comes in the latter part of the book. The final sections are fast-paced, action-packed, and filled with tension, providing an exciting conclusion to the story.
One of the novel's greatest strengths is its sense of realism. The events, setting, and social conditions felt authentic and believable, creating an immersive portrayal of seventeenth-century Europe. It is clear that the novel is well researched, with historical detail woven naturally throughout, adding depth and authenticity to the reading experience.
The novel begins at a fairly slow pace, focusing on introducing the characters and establishing the setting of early seventeenth-century Europe. During a time when slavery was widespread, the story follows a young English boy who is captured and sold into slavery in Venice. While the opening chapters are heavily focused on world-building, the plot gathers momentum in the second half as the action and intrigue begin to unfold.
The central characters, Richard and Elizabeth, are particularly believable. Their sibling bond feels genuine, and it is easy to become invested in their journey. Both characters make difficult and sometimes drastic decisions in order to protect one another, highlighting the strength of their relationship and making them easy to root for.
Although the pacing is somewhat slow at the beginning, requiring a little patience, the payoff comes in the latter part of the book. The final sections are fast-paced, action-packed, and filled with tension, providing an exciting conclusion to the story.
One of the novel's greatest strengths is its sense of realism. The events, setting, and social conditions felt authentic and believable, creating an immersive portrayal of seventeenth-century Europe. It is clear that the novel is well researched, with historical detail woven naturally throughout, adding depth and authenticity to the reading experience.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
📖 Book Review
Title: The Knife Maker of Venice
Author: David Gilman
If you love historical fiction with grit, danger, and raw emotion, The Knife Maker of Venice is an absolute must-read ⚔️🔥
Set against the brutal realities of the 17th century, this story wastes no time throwing you into chaos. What begins on the English coast quickly spirals into a harrowing journey of capture, survival, and separation that feels both immersive and deeply unsettling.
Richard is a compelling protagonist—flawed, headstrong, and fiercely loyal. His determination to find his sister Elizabeth drives the entire story, and that emotional core hits hard. Their bond adds a powerful layer to the narrative, making every hardship feel personal and every moment of hope feel earned.
And the setting… Venice. 🖤
Not the romanticised version—but a darker, more dangerous city filled with corruption, intrigue, and survival at any cost. The atmosphere is thick with tension, and you can almost feel the grit, the fear, and the desperation of those trying to carve out a life there.
This is not a gentle read. It’s intense, often brutal, and unflinchingly honest about the realities of the time—slave trade, violence, and human endurance. But that’s exactly what makes it so gripping.
✨ Gritty
✨ Emotional
✨ Action-packed
✨ Deeply immersive
A powerful story of survival, resilience, and the lengths one will go to for family.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Title: The Knife Maker of Venice
Author: David Gilman
If you love historical fiction with grit, danger, and raw emotion, The Knife Maker of Venice is an absolute must-read ⚔️🔥
Set against the brutal realities of the 17th century, this story wastes no time throwing you into chaos. What begins on the English coast quickly spirals into a harrowing journey of capture, survival, and separation that feels both immersive and deeply unsettling.
Richard is a compelling protagonist—flawed, headstrong, and fiercely loyal. His determination to find his sister Elizabeth drives the entire story, and that emotional core hits hard. Their bond adds a powerful layer to the narrative, making every hardship feel personal and every moment of hope feel earned.
And the setting… Venice. 🖤
Not the romanticised version—but a darker, more dangerous city filled with corruption, intrigue, and survival at any cost. The atmosphere is thick with tension, and you can almost feel the grit, the fear, and the desperation of those trying to carve out a life there.
This is not a gentle read. It’s intense, often brutal, and unflinchingly honest about the realities of the time—slave trade, violence, and human endurance. But that’s exactly what makes it so gripping.
✨ Gritty
✨ Emotional
✨ Action-packed
✨ Deeply immersive
A powerful story of survival, resilience, and the lengths one will go to for family.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
2.5 or 2.75 stars
This was fine! I expected to love it more, but unfortunately, the pacing, the length, the complicated plot, and the overwhelming number of characters ultimately lowered my rating.
Even though these issues hindered my enjoyment and I considered DNFing it, I kept reading because I was invested in seeing if Elizabeth and Richard would be reunited. Their sibling relationship was the heart of the story, it was emotional, moving, and beautifully wholesome. They cared deeply for each other, and seeing them constantly worry about how the other was doing kept me engaged. I also enjoyed the historical timeline; the discussions surrounding slavery and the realities of how people were treated and where they ended up were quite interesting.
The pacing, however, was a bit slow. I enjoyed the first half much more than the second because it focused heavily on Elizabeth and Richard’s POVs. The second half introduced perspectives from several new characters I just wasn't interested in, I came for Elizabeth and Richard! The plot became so convoluted and crowded with side characters that I lost track of what was happening and ended up skimming quite a bit. I didn't enjoy having to follow so many people just to understand their relation to the main cast. By the end, the only characters who actually stuck with me were Elizabeth, Richard, Martin, and John.
Nonetheless, if the synopsis sounds great and you think it’s up your alley, go for it, you won't be disappointed!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This was fine! I expected to love it more, but unfortunately, the pacing, the length, the complicated plot, and the overwhelming number of characters ultimately lowered my rating.
Even though these issues hindered my enjoyment and I considered DNFing it, I kept reading because I was invested in seeing if Elizabeth and Richard would be reunited. Their sibling relationship was the heart of the story, it was emotional, moving, and beautifully wholesome. They cared deeply for each other, and seeing them constantly worry about how the other was doing kept me engaged. I also enjoyed the historical timeline; the discussions surrounding slavery and the realities of how people were treated and where they ended up were quite interesting.
The pacing, however, was a bit slow. I enjoyed the first half much more than the second because it focused heavily on Elizabeth and Richard’s POVs. The second half introduced perspectives from several new characters I just wasn't interested in, I came for Elizabeth and Richard! The plot became so convoluted and crowded with side characters that I lost track of what was happening and ended up skimming quite a bit. I didn't enjoy having to follow so many people just to understand their relation to the main cast. By the end, the only characters who actually stuck with me were Elizabeth, Richard, Martin, and John.
Nonetheless, if the synopsis sounds great and you think it’s up your alley, go for it, you won't be disappointed!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The year is 1604 and Richard and Elizabeth Sheriff are brother and sister who live a quiet life in a small village in Devonshire. That is until one dark night when they are taken away by pirates to be sold to the slave markets of North Africa.
The siblings end up in Venice, Richard is sold to a knife maker to become his apprentice, luckily for him it’s a trade he knows well.
On the other hand Elizabeth caught the eye of the captain and is set to become his bride even if she doesn’t want to.
Both have vowed to find each other no matter the cost, but first they must find a way to survive.
With life at its most desperate, can brother and sister find each other, and at the same time find freedom in this city of ghosts and monsters, and things that are much worse.
This new standalone novel by David Gilman is a wonderful piece of historical fiction.
It’s beautifully written with characters that are both strong and vulnerable. With an atmosphere and setting that takes reader into the heart of Venice.
This is such a heartfelt and emotional story, I found it impossible to put down. It’s truly is an outstanding piece of work.
The siblings end up in Venice, Richard is sold to a knife maker to become his apprentice, luckily for him it’s a trade he knows well.
On the other hand Elizabeth caught the eye of the captain and is set to become his bride even if she doesn’t want to.
Both have vowed to find each other no matter the cost, but first they must find a way to survive.
With life at its most desperate, can brother and sister find each other, and at the same time find freedom in this city of ghosts and monsters, and things that are much worse.
This new standalone novel by David Gilman is a wonderful piece of historical fiction.
It’s beautifully written with characters that are both strong and vulnerable. With an atmosphere and setting that takes reader into the heart of Venice.
This is such a heartfelt and emotional story, I found it impossible to put down. It’s truly is an outstanding piece of work.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The Knife Maker of Venice is a chunk of a book, following the events that befall Richard and Elizabeth, starting with a good punch, before moving somewhat into their future.
It is fraught with peril for our two main characters, although they're far from the only two voices we hear. Richard is almost unbearably headstrong, and gets himself into many scrapes. Elizabeth is far from the naive individual we might originally suspect, although her story is teased out more slowly than Richard's.
What follows is a deeply researched tale of life in the early 1600s, thrusting the reader into the possibly previously unknown world of slavers and what happened to those stolen away from the Devonshire coast.
I listened to the audio book for the novel, and very much enjoyed the narrator as he expertly brought the characters to life.
This does take a while to get going - there is a lot of action in the first third, but much of it takes place on the high seas where the author ensures we all know how miserable the voyage is for the unfortunate abductees.
An engaging read.
It is fraught with peril for our two main characters, although they're far from the only two voices we hear. Richard is almost unbearably headstrong, and gets himself into many scrapes. Elizabeth is far from the naive individual we might originally suspect, although her story is teased out more slowly than Richard's.
What follows is a deeply researched tale of life in the early 1600s, thrusting the reader into the possibly previously unknown world of slavers and what happened to those stolen away from the Devonshire coast.
I listened to the audio book for the novel, and very much enjoyed the narrator as he expertly brought the characters to life.
This does take a while to get going - there is a lot of action in the first third, but much of it takes place on the high seas where the author ensures we all know how miserable the voyage is for the unfortunate abductees.
An engaging read.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This definitely a “bear with it” kind of book at the start. The first 20% is a slow burn introducing the characters, politics and setting and whilst it does important groundwork, it’s not exactly gripping stuff. I did wonder a couple of times when it was actually going to get going.
But once it does… it REALLY does.
As the story unfolds the stakes get higher and higher and suddenly you’re deep in this brutal world of greed, poverty, slavery and survival. The action ramps up massively in the second half and it turns into more of an historical thriller than I expected.
Our protagonist is unbelievably headstrong, the sort of bloke whose mouth is constantly cashing cheques his bank account absolutely cannot cover, but his loyalty and determination to do the right thing makes him very easy to root for.
The second half completely carried this book for me. It became riveting and had me saying “just one more chapter” until I realised it was way past bedtime.
Solid read overall. 4⭐
But once it does… it REALLY does.
As the story unfolds the stakes get higher and higher and suddenly you’re deep in this brutal world of greed, poverty, slavery and survival. The action ramps up massively in the second half and it turns into more of an historical thriller than I expected.
Our protagonist is unbelievably headstrong, the sort of bloke whose mouth is constantly cashing cheques his bank account absolutely cannot cover, but his loyalty and determination to do the right thing makes him very easy to root for.
The second half completely carried this book for me. It became riveting and had me saying “just one more chapter” until I realised it was way past bedtime.
Solid read overall. 4⭐
August 24, 2026
Richard and Elizabeth, brother and sister, lead quiet lives in Totnes, Devon, until their world is shattered when someone from their past takes them aboard his ship to be sold as slaves. They eventually end up in Venice, where Richard becomes an apprentice to a knife maker, while Elizabeth is forced to agree to marry the pirate in order to protect her brother.
This was a wonderful, beautifully written historical novel, filled with strong characters and an atmospheric setting that brings seventeenth century Venice vividly to life. The city is more than just a backdrop; its winding streets, canals and shadows add to the mystery and intrigue, revealing the darker side of this famous city.
The writing is superb and the plotting excellent, with betrayals, secrets and lies keeping a reader guessing, while the twists and turns maintain the tension throughout.
An absolutely first-class historical novel that was compelling, atmospheric and thoroughly enjoyable.
This was a wonderful, beautifully written historical novel, filled with strong characters and an atmospheric setting that brings seventeenth century Venice vividly to life. The city is more than just a backdrop; its winding streets, canals and shadows add to the mystery and intrigue, revealing the darker side of this famous city.
The writing is superb and the plotting excellent, with betrayals, secrets and lies keeping a reader guessing, while the twists and turns maintain the tension throughout.
An absolutely first-class historical novel that was compelling, atmospheric and thoroughly enjoyable.
September 11, 2026
Siblings Richard and Beth Sherriff are captured in a raid on Devon by Barbary pirates. The Captain is a former suitor of Beth and he determines to marry her even as he will sell her friends and neighbours as slaves. As their ship battles to reach Tunis, Richard distinguishes himself and earns a degree of trust. However, betrayal in Tunis leaves Captain Challenor leaving in hurry to get home to Venice. Venice is not the safe haven he hopes for and the displaced Devonians live as slaves.
I really liked this piece of historical fiction. There is not a lot of mention of the piracy and enforced slavery of ordinary English people in the 16th and 17th century but this story puts it front and centre. There are some dark parts but also a fair bit of humour and the research into the lives of the Venetian republic is good. It's a tale of 'daring do' which is pretty unbelievable but is fun in the telling.
I really liked this piece of historical fiction. There is not a lot of mention of the piracy and enforced slavery of ordinary English people in the 16th and 17th century but this story puts it front and centre. There are some dark parts but also a fair bit of humour and the research into the lives of the Venetian republic is good. It's a tale of 'daring do' which is pretty unbelievable but is fun in the telling.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Following a raid by corsair John Challenor, Richard and Elizabeth find themselves aboard a ship sailing towards Tunis where Challenor hopes to sell the men, women and children he has captured as slaves. That’s if they survive the voyage and the terrible conditions below deck. Richard is consigned to the hold with the others but Elizabeth, with whom Challenor is besotted, is taken to his cabin. Surprisingly, he does not force himself upon her, clinging to the hope she will agree to be his wife. Having said that he’s not averse to using her brother as a bargaining chip.
Challenor has made plenty of enemies during his career. Not surprising since he’s no stranger to double-dealing. It leads to some dangerous naval encounters during which it’s only Challenor’s remarkable seamanship that keeps the vessel from being sunk or captured. It’s during one of these encounters that Richard makes a daring rescue unaware that in doing so he is setting in motion a train of events that will come back to haunt him.
The meticulousness of the book’s plotting becomes apparent once the action moves to Venice as we discover the relevance of certain events, some seemingly minor, that occurred earlier in the story.
As Richard and Elizabeth discover, Venice may be beautiful on the outside but it is a cesspit of intrigue, deception and cruelty on the inside. Activities that are officially illegal, such as slavery, persist with a blind eye turned as long as you possess sufficient wealth or influence. Power is the currency of the nobility. People who get in the way simply disappear. There’s a telling moment when Richard learns the true nature of the flickering lights he sees on the lagoon at night.
But at the same time, Venice is a place of superb craftmanship: exquisite glass, delicate lace and skilfully honed knives studded with precious gems. It’s Richard expertise at crafting the latter that brings him to the attention of a wealthy patroness. But he remains a slave, his freedom only to be attained on her death.
The pace really picks up in the final third of the book where the intrigue and deception I mentioned earlier comes to the fore with plenty of twists and turns and some narrow escapes. It’s at this point that relationships formed earlier in the story make the difference between life and death.
I loved Richard’s devotion to his sister, always mindful of his father’s last words to him, but I also admired Elizabeth’s resilience and instinct for survival which is really put to the test towards the end of the book.
The Knife Maker of Venice is a rich tapestry of a historical novel that combines fascinating period detail with thrilling action.
Challenor has made plenty of enemies during his career. Not surprising since he’s no stranger to double-dealing. It leads to some dangerous naval encounters during which it’s only Challenor’s remarkable seamanship that keeps the vessel from being sunk or captured. It’s during one of these encounters that Richard makes a daring rescue unaware that in doing so he is setting in motion a train of events that will come back to haunt him.
The meticulousness of the book’s plotting becomes apparent once the action moves to Venice as we discover the relevance of certain events, some seemingly minor, that occurred earlier in the story.
As Richard and Elizabeth discover, Venice may be beautiful on the outside but it is a cesspit of intrigue, deception and cruelty on the inside. Activities that are officially illegal, such as slavery, persist with a blind eye turned as long as you possess sufficient wealth or influence. Power is the currency of the nobility. People who get in the way simply disappear. There’s a telling moment when Richard learns the true nature of the flickering lights he sees on the lagoon at night.
But at the same time, Venice is a place of superb craftmanship: exquisite glass, delicate lace and skilfully honed knives studded with precious gems. It’s Richard expertise at crafting the latter that brings him to the attention of a wealthy patroness. But he remains a slave, his freedom only to be attained on her death.
The pace really picks up in the final third of the book where the intrigue and deception I mentioned earlier comes to the fore with plenty of twists and turns and some narrow escapes. It’s at this point that relationships formed earlier in the story make the difference between life and death.
I loved Richard’s devotion to his sister, always mindful of his father’s last words to him, but I also admired Elizabeth’s resilience and instinct for survival which is really put to the test towards the end of the book.
The Knife Maker of Venice is a rich tapestry of a historical novel that combines fascinating period detail with thrilling action.
October 6, 2026
My goodness, with all the books I've read in 2026, I did not expect The Knife Maker of Venice to crash through to the number one spot. This is phenomenal. Not only that, the inspiration for the story is the same thing that inspired my own novelette, Rapacious, a few years ago, but David just does it so much better. His characters are so real. And the story breaks your heart in places, while exciting you in others. It is a bit of a tragedy, I mean, the main characters are captured into slavery. However it is a thriller and Lifts hope high in the midst of the suffering. Honestly, grab this book and read it. And grab it as a Christmas present for friends and family, they'll love it too.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Utterly gripping! An absolute thriller. David Gilman is a master storyteller.
The pace is breakneck, the narrative heart-wrenching. The breadth and depth of research is astonishing, the historical detail steely sharp, glistening with gems, studded with iron truths.
Above all, Gilman understands humanity, his characters real, flawed, sometimes twisted. This is a novel that is impossible to put down.
The pace is breakneck, the narrative heart-wrenching. The breadth and depth of research is astonishing, the historical detail steely sharp, glistening with gems, studded with iron truths.
Above all, Gilman understands humanity, his characters real, flawed, sometimes twisted. This is a novel that is impossible to put down.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This book really exposed the dark, gritty underbelly of Venice, its a side that I haven't read much on and I really enjoyed it. This book covers some very dark parts of world history and it doesn't shy away from the true human cost at that point in 17th century Europe. Richard as a character is fascinating, he is flawed (like all of us) but I found his determination and drive really enjoyable and it would be hard not to root for him. I am excited to reas more from this author
Review of advance copy
The Knife Maker of Venice was my first venture into one of Gilman's books so I had absolutely no idea what to expect...
Steeped in history and rich in prose, Gilman's latest offering was deliberately paced, allowing me to fully immerse myself into life in a Jacobean era Venice.
Character driven stakes and a sibling bond drove the story, which in and of itself was quite the poignant adventure. The action was relentless. The atmosphere was dark and decidedly dangerous.
And I loved every single minute!
Steeped in history and rich in prose, Gilman's latest offering was deliberately paced, allowing me to fully immerse myself into life in a Jacobean era Venice.
Character driven stakes and a sibling bond drove the story, which in and of itself was quite the poignant adventure. The action was relentless. The atmosphere was dark and decidedly dangerous.
And I loved every single minute!
August 15, 2026
This was the first book I have read by David Gilman and is a standalone book that is set in 17th Century Venice, and features siblings Richard and Elisabeth Sheriff, who are kidnapped by pirates from their village on the River Dart in Devon. They are kidnapped with the remaining villagers after most of the men, as working fishermen have gone to sea. Before their father died some years earlier, their father asked Richard to always look after his sister, and as the older sibling, she felt a duty to do the same for Richard, as they were one another’s only surviving relative.
The captain of the pirates was a former suitor of Elisabeth’s and intended to make her his wife, irrespective of her own feelings, and he would then sell into slavery the other people he has captured, including Richard. What follows is an epic journey with storms and attacks, and a brief stop in Tunis before they eventually reach Venice. When they arrive in Venice the siblings are separated as Richard is sold to a wealthy widow to work in a forge as an apprentice knife maker, using his existing skills as a trained blacksmith.
I really loved Richard and Elisabeth as characters, and thought their connection as siblings was perfectly balanced as they both fought to find one another after being cruelly separated in Venice. All of the characters in the novel felt real and multi-dimensional, some with a moral code and yet also incredibly flawed, and some with no or few redeeming qualities.
Although the scene setting at the beginning was initially measured, from the capture of the villagers the pace was swift to accelerate, and I found this was an action-packed read that I could not put down. It was clear that the author had researched the era and locations exceptionally well, and with succinct descriptions was able to create images that felt authentic and visually vibrant.
This action packed historical fiction was filled to the brim with piracy, slaves, corruption, death and intrigue, set predominantly in the thriving city of Venice in the early 17th Century. It was an epic novel with a cinematic quality that I hope one day is immortalised in film.
The captain of the pirates was a former suitor of Elisabeth’s and intended to make her his wife, irrespective of her own feelings, and he would then sell into slavery the other people he has captured, including Richard. What follows is an epic journey with storms and attacks, and a brief stop in Tunis before they eventually reach Venice. When they arrive in Venice the siblings are separated as Richard is sold to a wealthy widow to work in a forge as an apprentice knife maker, using his existing skills as a trained blacksmith.
I really loved Richard and Elisabeth as characters, and thought their connection as siblings was perfectly balanced as they both fought to find one another after being cruelly separated in Venice. All of the characters in the novel felt real and multi-dimensional, some with a moral code and yet also incredibly flawed, and some with no or few redeeming qualities.
Although the scene setting at the beginning was initially measured, from the capture of the villagers the pace was swift to accelerate, and I found this was an action-packed read that I could not put down. It was clear that the author had researched the era and locations exceptionally well, and with succinct descriptions was able to create images that felt authentic and visually vibrant.
This action packed historical fiction was filled to the brim with piracy, slaves, corruption, death and intrigue, set predominantly in the thriving city of Venice in the early 17th Century. It was an epic novel with a cinematic quality that I hope one day is immortalised in film.
October 21, 2026
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Great read from beginning to end. Great characters well supported by evocative descriptions of Venice. It’s a meaty read that takes you on quite the journey from piracy on the high seas to the political machinations of Venetian society. Enjoyable throughout and highly recommended.
Great read from beginning to end. Great characters well supported by evocative descriptions of Venice. It’s a meaty read that takes you on quite the journey from piracy on the high seas to the political machinations of Venetian society. Enjoyable throughout and highly recommended.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I have never read a David Gilman book I've regretted, and I can happily say the trend remains with The Knife Maker of Venice. This standalone is a slow burn until it isn't. Can't wait for his next Master of War book. I would've given this a 3.75 if it were available.
August 30, 2026
I think I have read everything written by Gillman and sold on Kindle. I started with the master of war serials. After book 3 I started reading his earlier stuff loved it all. His development of Characters is first rate. I hope find to sequel.
Review of advance copy received from Author
As always a fantastic historical read from David. The storyline is very informative and I learnt so much about both the era and the places the characters visited.
I seriously think that there is the potential for a second book continuing the lives of the main characters.
I seriously think that there is the potential for a second book continuing the lives of the main characters.
September 26, 2026
Never has an historical fiction come so alive for me!!! That this was about 17th century slavers on the Barbary Coast and related sites, with a captured English youth as protagonist, made it an engrossing tale. What a wonderful , meticulously researched read!!!! Thank you David Gilman!!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Did Not Finish
October 4, 2026DNF @ 16%
October 5, 2026
The only Gilman novel to not captivate me.
3⭐️
3⭐️
October 12, 2026
Slow first half. Some interesting moments, but sadly not at the same level as Gilman's Master of War series.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
The Knife Maker of Venice is the first book I've read by the author David Gilman and It definitely didn't disappoint. This was a gripping and a very intriguing and descriptive historical read that is set in 1604.
The historical aspects of the storyline have so much depth and detail, It really had me invested throughout, while the story line starts off at a slowed pace, it gradually builds as you go along giving you that extra suspense as it picks up to a fast pace. The characters were incredibly likable and each stood out in their own way. The family ties and loyalty between Richard and Elizabeth brought that added heartfelt emotion to the storyline.
Overall, this was an incredible read that was full of adventure, action and compelling characters that have you gripped right from the get-go.
The historical aspects of the storyline have so much depth and detail, It really had me invested throughout, while the story line starts off at a slowed pace, it gradually builds as you go along giving you that extra suspense as it picks up to a fast pace. The characters were incredibly likable and each stood out in their own way. The family ties and loyalty between Richard and Elizabeth brought that added heartfelt emotion to the storyline.
Overall, this was an incredible read that was full of adventure, action and compelling characters that have you gripped right from the get-go.
July 31, 2026
This was a bit of a slow burn to begin with, but get to about halfway and it doesn’t stop! The story of a brother and sister who were told by their father to always care for one another, this vow never left them which is evident throughout this novel.
I love any book set in Italy, one of my favourite places, however Venice isn’t somewhere I’ve visited. The descriptions of the city and the inhabitants is just amazing, fully immersed throughout. Both Richard and Elizabeth have a rough start on the journey here and once they arrive, but neither falter or give up. Even when things take an awful turn for the worst.
I really enjoyed this one, once the story picked up I couldn’t put it down. Both endured so much but never stopped looking for the other, a true sibling connection that never wavered.
I love any book set in Italy, one of my favourite places, however Venice isn’t somewhere I’ve visited. The descriptions of the city and the inhabitants is just amazing, fully immersed throughout. Both Richard and Elizabeth have a rough start on the journey here and once they arrive, but neither falter or give up. Even when things take an awful turn for the worst.
I really enjoyed this one, once the story picked up I couldn’t put it down. Both endured so much but never stopped looking for the other, a true sibling connection that never wavered.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Wow, this is certainly an historical thriller that packs several punches!
I confess that this is the first book I have read from this author and that the main pull was the Venetian location. However, this story had me utterly gripped.
It’s something of a slow-burn for the first half of the book, which mainly details time spent at sea and the rampant piracy and slavery that took place between rivals. But once the Falcon arrives first at Tunis and then Venice, the action ramps up in spades.
Regular readers of this blog will know of my intense passion for all things Venice-related, and I found myself utterly engrossed by the undeniably darker historical side of this beautiful city as the plot unravelled.
From pitch-black calli, murderous intentions and the horrors of the pozzi, the Venice of the night is portrayed in graphic detail as honour and vengeance take centre-stage.
The characterisation is strong throughout and I found myself rooting for Richard from the outset; a principled man with a fierce sense of loyalty to his sister Elizabeth, yet hot-headed and impulsive to boot. I thoroughly enjoyed his storyline and emergence as the maestro knife-maker of Venice.
Elizabeth is equally portrayed as a strong female, determined to do what is right by her brother, even if it means sacrificing her own desires and my emotions were truly in turmoil when she was incarcerated and left to endure such torture within the pozzi.
This was one of those books you want to keep reading but don’t want to end; a genuinely fabulous read.
With thanks to the author, Rachel at Random Resources and Head of Zeus publishing for the opportunity to participate in the blog tour for this one.
I confess that this is the first book I have read from this author and that the main pull was the Venetian location. However, this story had me utterly gripped.
It’s something of a slow-burn for the first half of the book, which mainly details time spent at sea and the rampant piracy and slavery that took place between rivals. But once the Falcon arrives first at Tunis and then Venice, the action ramps up in spades.
Regular readers of this blog will know of my intense passion for all things Venice-related, and I found myself utterly engrossed by the undeniably darker historical side of this beautiful city as the plot unravelled.
From pitch-black calli, murderous intentions and the horrors of the pozzi, the Venice of the night is portrayed in graphic detail as honour and vengeance take centre-stage.
The characterisation is strong throughout and I found myself rooting for Richard from the outset; a principled man with a fierce sense of loyalty to his sister Elizabeth, yet hot-headed and impulsive to boot. I thoroughly enjoyed his storyline and emergence as the maestro knife-maker of Venice.
Elizabeth is equally portrayed as a strong female, determined to do what is right by her brother, even if it means sacrificing her own desires and my emotions were truly in turmoil when she was incarcerated and left to endure such torture within the pozzi.
This was one of those books you want to keep reading but don’t want to end; a genuinely fabulous read.
With thanks to the author, Rachel at Random Resources and Head of Zeus publishing for the opportunity to participate in the blog tour for this one.
August 29, 2026
4.5⭐️
This story is all about a brother and sister captured by pirates in the 17th century who are sold into servitude in Venice - not my typical book choice right?! I’m so glad I joined the book tour for this because it was such a surprising and emotive read which I fell more and more in love with. It was such a unique historical fiction where the more I read, the more captivated I felt and for a 500 page book I absolutely flew through it!
The book centred around the relationship between siblings Elizabeth and Richard and their experiences individually as well as their journey to find each other as their paths were taken in different directions. The book was full of intrigue, corruption and acts of desperation with an action packed plot. Although what I loved most was the bond between the siblings and how this was crafted throughout - it captivated you through their time in the UK, on the boat and all that happens in Venice. There are violent, vivid and shocking moments which can feel uncomfortable. This was also alongside stories and relationships that make you feel so connected- the book stirs up so many unexpected emotions which is testament to the writing of David Gilman.
Well researched, interesting and powerful read that I thoroughly enjoyed- definitely a reminder to be open minded and try books you may not initially consider as this one was a really memorable story.
This story is all about a brother and sister captured by pirates in the 17th century who are sold into servitude in Venice - not my typical book choice right?! I’m so glad I joined the book tour for this because it was such a surprising and emotive read which I fell more and more in love with. It was such a unique historical fiction where the more I read, the more captivated I felt and for a 500 page book I absolutely flew through it!
The book centred around the relationship between siblings Elizabeth and Richard and their experiences individually as well as their journey to find each other as their paths were taken in different directions. The book was full of intrigue, corruption and acts of desperation with an action packed plot. Although what I loved most was the bond between the siblings and how this was crafted throughout - it captivated you through their time in the UK, on the boat and all that happens in Venice. There are violent, vivid and shocking moments which can feel uncomfortable. This was also alongside stories and relationships that make you feel so connected- the book stirs up so many unexpected emotions which is testament to the writing of David Gilman.
Well researched, interesting and powerful read that I thoroughly enjoyed- definitely a reminder to be open minded and try books you may not initially consider as this one was a really memorable story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews