What do you think?
Rate this book
Sweetbitter Song: A Novel
In the quiet of Ithaca two women fall—for each other, for their families, for their kingdoms.
When Melantho, a young slave girl in the kitchens beneath a palace, is chosen one night to meet a visiting king, she believes her fates are finally changing. Instead, she is saved by a young princess who understands her father's cruelty more than anyone, and an unlikely friendship is struck. However, between Melantho's position and the rules of court, obstacles await to wrench them apart until their very trust in each other fractures around them.
But when Melantho is taken to Ithaca to serve while the men are away fighting on foreign shores, a new world opens to her. One where women rule, where friendships are rebuilt, and where a love story is finally able to bloom.
A profound tale of love, identity and defiance, Sweetbitter Song tells a story forgotten by time. This is a story of bravery and hope, celebrating two women who fought to protect their love from a world that tried to deny its very existence.
When Melantho, a young slave girl in the kitchens beneath a palace, is chosen one night to meet a visiting king, she believes her fates are finally changing. Instead, she is saved by a young princess who understands her father's cruelty more than anyone, and an unlikely friendship is struck. However, between Melantho's position and the rules of court, obstacles await to wrench them apart until their very trust in each other fractures around them.
But when Melantho is taken to Ithaca to serve while the men are away fighting on foreign shores, a new world opens to her. One where women rule, where friendships are rebuilt, and where a love story is finally able to bloom.
A profound tale of love, identity and defiance, Sweetbitter Song tells a story forgotten by time. This is a story of bravery and hope, celebrating two women who fought to protect their love from a world that tried to deny its very existence.
Audible Audio
First published March 17, 2026
About the author
Rosie Hewlett
4 books745 followersRosie Hewlett is the Sunday Times Bestselling author of MEDEA and MEDUSA.
Having secured a First Class Honours degree in Classical Literature and Civilisation at the University of Birmingham, Rosie Hewlett has studied Greek mythology in depth and is passionate about unearthing strong female voices within the classical world. Rosie currently lives in Kent with her husband and is now a full-time author spending her days lost inside her favourite stories from mythology.
Rosie's first traditionally published novel, Medea, was an instant Sunday Times bestseller. Her self-published debut novel, Medusa, won the Rubery Book of the Year award in 2021 and is being re-released in hardback for the first time in autumn 2025.
Her brand new book Sweetbitter Song will be publishing in spring 2026.
Having secured a First Class Honours degree in Classical Literature and Civilisation at the University of Birmingham, Rosie Hewlett has studied Greek mythology in depth and is passionate about unearthing strong female voices within the classical world. Rosie currently lives in Kent with her husband and is now a full-time author spending her days lost inside her favourite stories from mythology.
Rosie's first traditionally published novel, Medea, was an instant Sunday Times bestseller. Her self-published debut novel, Medusa, won the Rubery Book of the Year award in 2021 and is being re-released in hardback for the first time in autumn 2025.
Her brand new book Sweetbitter Song will be publishing in spring 2026.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 398 reviews
January 15, 2026
“how could we love each other so greatly and the world still deny us?”
listen i’m still trying to get myself together after that ending. what a gut wrenching story. sweetbitter song is a sapphic retelling of the odyssey in which penelope and melantho are reimagined as childhood companions. an interpretation that would send most homer purists into damn near cardiac arrest but for me was incredibly effective. shake the table up a little bit if you will!
by narrowing the age gap and allowing melantho and penelope to bond as children, hewlett adds a layer of intimacy to their dynamic that feels like a natural extension of their shared girlhood. this choice also lends profound weight to the guilt penelope carries as they grow older and their roles solidify into those of princess and slave. it was at this point in the story that i started to physically ache, just watching them grapple with the severity of their inherited social hierarchies while still harboring affection for one another.
it’s also worth noting that because the story is told through melantho’s perspective, penelope can sometimes feel very distant. this guardedness and restraint are consistent with her status as a princess so it didn’t bother me. if anything it only magnified the yearning and pining. you feel penelope’s devotion to melantho in the small moments and understated protections she offers. even when honesty is impossible, their love is undeniable and hewlett captures that forbidden bond masterfully. i’m tearing up once again just thinking about it.
another highlight for me was the solidarity between the handmaids. i was deeply touched by their care for one another which functioned as a form of quiet resistance, and by the small nook of tenderness the handmaids managed to carve out for themselves despite their circumstances. their playful back and forth also helped lighten the heaviness of the story at times which i was grateful for.
overall, this was a beautiful and devastating read. i don’t think i’m ever getting over it. sincere thanks to the publisher and netgalley for providing this arc in exchange for an honest review. i can’t wait to purchase a physical copy.
October 28, 2025
why are we shipping penelope with her child slave that she raised like a daughter
April 11, 2026
PHEW!! Lord have mercy on me, I went through every emotion possible while reading this. One of the greatest love stories I’ve ever had the pleasure of reading. Full review to come maybe
December 29, 2025
E-ARC from NetGalley
RTC but it’s a no for me 🫤 love some sapphic retailing but this felt like a massive character assassination of all Odyssey characters
RTC but it’s a no for me 🫤 love some sapphic retailing but this felt like a massive character assassination of all Odyssey characters
November 18, 2025
4⭐️
This was a good read but also deeply sad. I do enjoy reading a mythical retelling like this but sometimes I feel like I need recovery time after- like I need to go read a happy rom-com where everyone lives happily ever after and nothing bad happens
This story is centered around Penelope, a princess of Sparta and Melantho, a slave girl serving in the palace. The two strike up a deep friendship as girls that follows them through the tribulations of their lives, from Sparta all the way to the shores of Ithica. Their love and connection only grows, continually drawing them back together.
This story looks to give a different view than the one typically told about these two women- Penelope of course is always remembered as the faithful wife of Odysseus, waiting 20 long years in Ithica for her King's return. Here we have a different story of those years- how Penelope and her handmaidens changed Ithica and kept the throne safe from enemies outside and in.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishing team for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
"Let history have its lies if it means we can have each other."
This was a good read but also deeply sad. I do enjoy reading a mythical retelling like this but sometimes I feel like I need recovery time after- like I need to go read a happy rom-com where everyone lives happily ever after and nothing bad happens
This story is centered around Penelope, a princess of Sparta and Melantho, a slave girl serving in the palace. The two strike up a deep friendship as girls that follows them through the tribulations of their lives, from Sparta all the way to the shores of Ithica. Their love and connection only grows, continually drawing them back together.
This story looks to give a different view than the one typically told about these two women- Penelope of course is always remembered as the faithful wife of Odysseus, waiting 20 long years in Ithica for her King's return. Here we have a different story of those years- how Penelope and her handmaidens changed Ithica and kept the throne safe from enemies outside and in.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishing team for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
March 7, 2026
Heated Rivalry, but sapphic, and instead of losing a hockey match, the stakes are evisceration and having your existence forgotten to history.
March 17, 2026
Thank you to Sourcebooks and NetGalley for the ARC
*sigh*
Alright. So. As someone who unconditionally loves Greek mythology, Greek retelling AND sapphic romances. This was a no for me.
Granted, I understand that “it’s a retelling blah blah blah.” But this just feels very off to me.
Melantho in the original story is significantly younger than Penelope, is raised like a daughter BY Penelope and BETRAYS HER and sleeps with the suitors!!! Now I know you don’t need to be lore accurate but it feels icky to me that she is aged up in this story.
And normally I would be like “ok whatever” but it’s the fact that MELANTHO HERSELF is disgusted by the fact that Odysseus is TWICE Penelope’s age!!!!!
Further more, this felt very Stockholm Syndrome to me. Penelope gets Melantho whipped, gets her best friend branded, splits her brother and his pregnant wife apart, and then asks her to stay with her in Ithaca?? And all the justification is “well it’s hard to be a woman :((((“. I just in no way shape or form felt like this was necessary, realistic, or like made any sense! I just was very annoyed with their relationship.
The dialogue also did not feel realistic to me. Melantho, with every right, is angry at Penelope and her own circumstances. But I never fully understood her character and her morals. One minute she is shy and demure, the next she is all “WOMAN STRONG” and ugh idk.
Also just the assassination of ALL the other characters in this story. ESPECIALLY PENELOPE. A woman who had to ENDURE SO MUCH! Like I just want a retelling from HER perspective. This just wasn’t it unfortunately.
*sigh*
Alright. So. As someone who unconditionally loves Greek mythology, Greek retelling AND sapphic romances. This was a no for me.
Granted, I understand that “it’s a retelling blah blah blah.” But this just feels very off to me.
Melantho in the original story is significantly younger than Penelope, is raised like a daughter BY Penelope and BETRAYS HER and sleeps with the suitors!!! Now I know you don’t need to be lore accurate but it feels icky to me that she is aged up in this story.
And normally I would be like “ok whatever” but it’s the fact that MELANTHO HERSELF is disgusted by the fact that Odysseus is TWICE Penelope’s age!!!!!
Further more, this felt very Stockholm Syndrome to me. Penelope gets Melantho whipped, gets her best friend branded, splits her brother and his pregnant wife apart, and then asks her to stay with her in Ithaca?? And all the justification is “well it’s hard to be a woman :((((“. I just in no way shape or form felt like this was necessary, realistic, or like made any sense! I just was very annoyed with their relationship.
The dialogue also did not feel realistic to me. Melantho, with every right, is angry at Penelope and her own circumstances. But I never fully understood her character and her morals. One minute she is shy and demure, the next she is all “WOMAN STRONG” and ugh idk.
Also just the assassination of ALL the other characters in this story. ESPECIALLY PENELOPE. A woman who had to ENDURE SO MUCH! Like I just want a retelling from HER perspective. This just wasn’t it unfortunately.
Did Not Finish
April 14, 2026I was so excited to read this but I had to DNF at 14%. I do not want to read explicit on page descriptions of . I wish that had been included in the content warnings. I wouldn't have started reading it if I'd known.
May 2, 2026
RANT INCOMINGGGGG
in the years and years I’ve been reading consistently I don’t think a book has ever disappointed me more than this book. this was my most anticipated book of the year. I bought it the day it came out. I never buy books before reading them anymore; I was POSITIVE this would be for me.
boy was I, so so wrong.
let me just get this part out of the way: the book is not badly written, prose wise. this is certainly not even close to the worst book I’ve read in that regard. the pacing is absolutely atrocious but honestly, I can forgive that simply because reimagining a literal epic naturally would be difficult in that regard. my problem with the book is more insidious than that: it’s the whole fucking story.
I cannot in my right mind understand what drove this author to choice Penelope and Malantho as the love interests. not because I have a problem with aging up/rewriting character backstories, but because if you’re going to go through the trouble of completely changing a character to fit a romance… why not make it romantic? why not instead write about Athena/Pallas, Iphis/Ianthe, Sappho/Atthis? hell, why didn’t she just MAKE CHARACTERS UP? jumping through this many hoops to not even provide a semblance of a romantic story is baffling to me.
I promise, hand to the gods, there are MAYBE a total of 20 pages in this book that depict any sort of romantic feelings whatsoever. I am completely baffled by the amount of people who are invested in this book, especially in that regard.
85% of the book is talking about how miserable and angry Melantho is. why is that? well because she’s a SLAVE! yeah! that’s a pretty shit life huh! she is literally (and rightfully so) furious at Penelope for almost the entire book!!!! the only hint of this being sapphic for the first 300 pages is just because Melantho calls her beautiful all the time. HEY! my gay ass has a lot more thoughts when I see a woman than just “she’s so pretty” DUH she’s a woman!
I truly can’t even give credit to this book for discussing themes like slavery, patriarchy, etc because I don’t even think it does it well? it’s extremely surface level and dare I say repetitive. It’s entirely: Malantho angry, slavery bad. dare I say it seemed the author didn’t do any research whatsoever to even attempt to give us literally anything of depth or value. this is a crime seeing as though it truly is the main focus of the book.
and back to the jumping through hoops to fit this “story” I do absolutely agree with other reviewers who say this is a character assassination of The Odyssey. I’m all for a retelling, reimagining, etc but this was just so messy and bad. there wasn’t a single point to why this book was what it was about. it felt like I was watching a toddler try to shove a square wooden block into the circle hole.
at the end of the day, I don’t care that the author completely changed Penelope/Melantho’s dynamic from the original text. I care that it made absolutely no sense and was utterly and completely unconvincing every step of the way.
that’s all.
in the years and years I’ve been reading consistently I don’t think a book has ever disappointed me more than this book. this was my most anticipated book of the year. I bought it the day it came out. I never buy books before reading them anymore; I was POSITIVE this would be for me.
boy was I, so so wrong.
let me just get this part out of the way: the book is not badly written, prose wise. this is certainly not even close to the worst book I’ve read in that regard. the pacing is absolutely atrocious but honestly, I can forgive that simply because reimagining a literal epic naturally would be difficult in that regard. my problem with the book is more insidious than that: it’s the whole fucking story.
I cannot in my right mind understand what drove this author to choice Penelope and Malantho as the love interests. not because I have a problem with aging up/rewriting character backstories, but because if you’re going to go through the trouble of completely changing a character to fit a romance… why not make it romantic? why not instead write about Athena/Pallas, Iphis/Ianthe, Sappho/Atthis? hell, why didn’t she just MAKE CHARACTERS UP? jumping through this many hoops to not even provide a semblance of a romantic story is baffling to me.
I promise, hand to the gods, there are MAYBE a total of 20 pages in this book that depict any sort of romantic feelings whatsoever. I am completely baffled by the amount of people who are invested in this book, especially in that regard.
85% of the book is talking about how miserable and angry Melantho is. why is that? well because she’s a SLAVE! yeah! that’s a pretty shit life huh! she is literally (and rightfully so) furious at Penelope for almost the entire book!!!! the only hint of this being sapphic for the first 300 pages is just because Melantho calls her beautiful all the time. HEY! my gay ass has a lot more thoughts when I see a woman than just “she’s so pretty” DUH she’s a woman!
I truly can’t even give credit to this book for discussing themes like slavery, patriarchy, etc because I don’t even think it does it well? it’s extremely surface level and dare I say repetitive. It’s entirely: Malantho angry, slavery bad. dare I say it seemed the author didn’t do any research whatsoever to even attempt to give us literally anything of depth or value. this is a crime seeing as though it truly is the main focus of the book.
and back to the jumping through hoops to fit this “story” I do absolutely agree with other reviewers who say this is a character assassination of The Odyssey. I’m all for a retelling, reimagining, etc but this was just so messy and bad. there wasn’t a single point to why this book was what it was about. it felt like I was watching a toddler try to shove a square wooden block into the circle hole.
at the end of the day, I don’t care that the author completely changed Penelope/Melantho’s dynamic from the original text. I care that it made absolutely no sense and was utterly and completely unconvincing every step of the way.
that’s all.
December 23, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review. This books was such a good greek retelling and it was from a perspective I have never read from before. Melantho is a character that i wasn’t super familiar with but this story was heartbreaking and empowering all at the same time. This being advertised as a sapphic song of achilles is honestly very accurate and I hope it receives the same hype. With the odyssesy movie releasing soon i implore you to pick this up when you get the change.
November 14, 2025
“Let history have its lies if it means we can have each other.”
Okay so I think it was an absolute fluke that I managed to read this via NetGalley BUT I have been yearning for this book since I discovered its existence and I’m taking it as a sign from the gods. I didn’t think Rosie’s work could get any better but this right here is my favourite 🥹😭
Sweetbitter Song is reclamation and re-imagining of the life’s of the women who’s names may feature in the odyssey, but who’s stories are recorded only as orbiting a man’s legend. It’s a love letter to the intelligent, courageous, kind women whose actions, thoughts and lives were not thought worthy of legends. It’s profoundly moving, painful and hopeful.
The prose is lyrical and poetic, it’s a harsh juxtaposition between the stunning writing and horrifying subject matter that works beautifully to highlight the horror in sharp clarity. It also shines a light on the moments of peace and solace. There’s a rich sense of location and culture, interspersed with traditions and mythological lore
The Penelope we know, is the dutiful wife, living in the shadow of a legendary war and waiting faithfully for 20 years for her husband to return. Melantho is the traitorous handmaiden who betrayed her, siding with the vicious suitors vying for her marriage and throne.
But the history we know was told by men looking to carve their name into legend.
This re-imagining breathes life into the women of the story. Sweetbitter Song is a feminine focused retelling that shows the strength, kindness and innovation of women despite everything stacked against them. It’s a tender, devastating sapphic romance and a story of sisterhood and family.
“We were women forced to play in a game only men could win.”
Melantho and Penelope’s lives have been intertwined since they were children. A tangled, golden thread of girlhood, friendship and love spanning decades.
Women’s lives are pulled with the tides of men’s whims and actions. The women in this story endure a grinding down of their souls and spirit. It’s a tender, tragic, hopeful story. Of seeing the worst in the world and still reaching for something better. This will break your heart, but heal it too.
Melantho meets Penelope as a child. In secret, they become fast friends. Penelope is a princess and Melantho a slave serving her family. This power dynamic doesn’t allow for fraternisation or friendship. As a child Melantho doesn’t fully comprehend her place in the world, but childhood innocent and wonder cannot survive in a world so cruel. Pain and suffering will rip the shroud from her eyes. Given a glimpse of the life others lead, a summer of friendship, no work or fear of punishment. She recognises the cage she calls home now. One violent, life threatening night dashes any illusions she may have had.
The part of the story that explores their childhood is particularly painful. The childlike naivety of the narrator, overlaid with our own understanding is devastating.
Slaves have no control over their lives or bodies. They cannot protect themselves or their family. They are seen as possessions, not people.
“For slaves were not permitted to mourn. There was no space for our pain.”
Melantho is violently forced to recognise that “Slave” is not a family name, it’s an ownership. A denial of life and human experience. You can’t don naivety after it’s been so violently shed. It breeds bitterness.
“Penelope’s betrayal cut me far deeper, opening wounds my body did not recognise, did not know how to heal.”
As a child Melantho resents Penelope, for abandoning her and denying their bond.
When fate brings them together again years later, she tries to hold onto this anger and keep her distance, but they can’t extricate themselves from each other. Even when their efforts to protect each other cause more harm.
Penelope brings Melantho to her marital home of Ithica. Unable to relinquish their bond, but forbidden from acting on it. As they grow together Melantho realises that though Penelope’s station is higher than her own, all this affords her is a more gilded cage. Too much pain changes the lens in which you view the world and Melantho struggles feel anything when it could all be taken away.
“Silent truths will always find a way of being heard”
Penelope and her fellow handmaidens help coax Melantho into finding joy where she can. Choosing happiness a form of rebellion. Together, with their chosen family they navigate a perilous world. Left to carve what little peace and solace can be found from the scraps of a man’s table. But there is joy and love and they work to share this with as many women as they can. Building their own haven.
Their lives are intertwined by chance or fate, but the choices they make keep their futures woven together. Sweetbitter Song is reclamation and re-imagining of the life’s of the women who’s names may feature in the odyssey, but who’s stories are recorded only as orbiting a man’s legend. It’s a love letter to the intelligent, courageous, kind women whose actions, thoughts and lives were not thought worthy of legends. It’s profoundly moving, painful and hopeful.
“Perhaps this too was what it meant to love someone—a willingness to leap into the dark, ready to fly or fall, so long as you did so by their side.”
Okay so I think it was an absolute fluke that I managed to read this via NetGalley BUT I have been yearning for this book since I discovered its existence and I’m taking it as a sign from the gods. I didn’t think Rosie’s work could get any better but this right here is my favourite 🥹😭
Sweetbitter Song is reclamation and re-imagining of the life’s of the women who’s names may feature in the odyssey, but who’s stories are recorded only as orbiting a man’s legend. It’s a love letter to the intelligent, courageous, kind women whose actions, thoughts and lives were not thought worthy of legends. It’s profoundly moving, painful and hopeful.
The prose is lyrical and poetic, it’s a harsh juxtaposition between the stunning writing and horrifying subject matter that works beautifully to highlight the horror in sharp clarity. It also shines a light on the moments of peace and solace. There’s a rich sense of location and culture, interspersed with traditions and mythological lore
The Penelope we know, is the dutiful wife, living in the shadow of a legendary war and waiting faithfully for 20 years for her husband to return. Melantho is the traitorous handmaiden who betrayed her, siding with the vicious suitors vying for her marriage and throne.
But the history we know was told by men looking to carve their name into legend.
This re-imagining breathes life into the women of the story. Sweetbitter Song is a feminine focused retelling that shows the strength, kindness and innovation of women despite everything stacked against them. It’s a tender, devastating sapphic romance and a story of sisterhood and family.
“We were women forced to play in a game only men could win.”
Melantho and Penelope’s lives have been intertwined since they were children. A tangled, golden thread of girlhood, friendship and love spanning decades.
Women’s lives are pulled with the tides of men’s whims and actions. The women in this story endure a grinding down of their souls and spirit. It’s a tender, tragic, hopeful story. Of seeing the worst in the world and still reaching for something better. This will break your heart, but heal it too.
Melantho meets Penelope as a child. In secret, they become fast friends. Penelope is a princess and Melantho a slave serving her family. This power dynamic doesn’t allow for fraternisation or friendship. As a child Melantho doesn’t fully comprehend her place in the world, but childhood innocent and wonder cannot survive in a world so cruel. Pain and suffering will rip the shroud from her eyes. Given a glimpse of the life others lead, a summer of friendship, no work or fear of punishment. She recognises the cage she calls home now. One violent, life threatening night dashes any illusions she may have had.
The part of the story that explores their childhood is particularly painful. The childlike naivety of the narrator, overlaid with our own understanding is devastating.
Slaves have no control over their lives or bodies. They cannot protect themselves or their family. They are seen as possessions, not people.
“For slaves were not permitted to mourn. There was no space for our pain.”
Melantho is violently forced to recognise that “Slave” is not a family name, it’s an ownership. A denial of life and human experience. You can’t don naivety after it’s been so violently shed. It breeds bitterness.
“Penelope’s betrayal cut me far deeper, opening wounds my body did not recognise, did not know how to heal.”
As a child Melantho resents Penelope, for abandoning her and denying their bond.
When fate brings them together again years later, she tries to hold onto this anger and keep her distance, but they can’t extricate themselves from each other. Even when their efforts to protect each other cause more harm.
Penelope brings Melantho to her marital home of Ithica. Unable to relinquish their bond, but forbidden from acting on it. As they grow together Melantho realises that though Penelope’s station is higher than her own, all this affords her is a more gilded cage. Too much pain changes the lens in which you view the world and Melantho struggles feel anything when it could all be taken away.
“Silent truths will always find a way of being heard”
Penelope and her fellow handmaidens help coax Melantho into finding joy where she can. Choosing happiness a form of rebellion. Together, with their chosen family they navigate a perilous world. Left to carve what little peace and solace can be found from the scraps of a man’s table. But there is joy and love and they work to share this with as many women as they can. Building their own haven.
Their lives are intertwined by chance or fate, but the choices they make keep their futures woven together. Sweetbitter Song is reclamation and re-imagining of the life’s of the women who’s names may feature in the odyssey, but who’s stories are recorded only as orbiting a man’s legend. It’s a love letter to the intelligent, courageous, kind women whose actions, thoughts and lives were not thought worthy of legends. It’s profoundly moving, painful and hopeful.
“Perhaps this too was what it meant to love someone—a willingness to leap into the dark, ready to fly or fall, so long as you did so by their side.”
March 26, 2026
The publisher's description says this book "tells a story forgotten by history." Um, no: it's fanfiction shipping an aged-up minor character from The Odyssey and Penelope.
I have my doubts that the author did much research into Bronze Age Mediterranean civilizations because everything reads like a 21st century author phoning in the setting and imposing their mindset on the past.
Skip this and read one of the many translations of The Odyssey instead.
Received via NetGalley.
I have my doubts that the author did much research into Bronze Age Mediterranean civilizations because everything reads like a 21st century author phoning in the setting and imposing their mindset on the past.
Skip this and read one of the many translations of The Odyssey instead.
Received via NetGalley.
March 31, 2026
dude what the fuck
March 20, 2026
— “I will come for you. Her voice echoed through the starless night. A promise, a vow.
Wait for me.” —
Wait for me.” —
March 23, 2026
🤍 Greek Mythology
🏹 Sapphic Love
🤍 Forbidden Romance
🏹 Brutal and Bloodthirsty
🤍 The Odyssey Reimagined
Okay, well, I am going to start this review by saying I am not very well-versed in Greek Mythology. I am not someone who needs new works to be accurate or consistent with the original tales. I do not care about honouring men of the past with their heroic stories and phallus measurements. That said, I feel like the author definitely takes a lot of liberties with this feminist reimagining of "The Odyssey", and personally? I am totally okay with that.
This story is told through the perspective of the slave and handmaiden, Melantho. It chronicles her treacherous upbringing as a slave and her blossoming friendship with Penelope, future queen of Ithaca and wife of Odysseus.
This book is sometimes hard to read, the treatment of women and children is horrific. The treatment of the slaves is terrible. This story isn't just about a friendship or romance, but about class struggles and the abhorrent ownership of women of every class. I appreciated the poignant feminine rage in this story. I loved the sapphic romance spin. The prose itself is beautiful and the story is immensely detailed, despite the sometimes grim subject matter. I love the idea that a lot of the great feats accomplished by men were orchestrated through careful plotting by women.
I did find this a little bit long-winded. It seems like parts of the story were so detailed and then we would skip 5-7 years at a time. For this reason, it took me longer to read than I had anticipated because the overarching conflict isn't apparent until well into the book. I did find some of the character decisions and plot developments frustrating, and in some cases, I would have liked to see more emotional complexity and connection between characters, especially within the romance plotline.
Overall this was a stunning read. It is definitely a must-read for anyone who loves Greek Mythology reimaginings and isn't going to fuss about a story straying from the source material.
Thank you to Netgalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the ARC of this book. All thoughts and feedback contained within this review are my own.
🏹 Sapphic Love
🤍 Forbidden Romance
🏹 Brutal and Bloodthirsty
🤍 The Odyssey Reimagined
Okay, well, I am going to start this review by saying I am not very well-versed in Greek Mythology. I am not someone who needs new works to be accurate or consistent with the original tales. I do not care about honouring men of the past with their heroic stories and phallus measurements. That said, I feel like the author definitely takes a lot of liberties with this feminist reimagining of "The Odyssey", and personally? I am totally okay with that.
This story is told through the perspective of the slave and handmaiden, Melantho. It chronicles her treacherous upbringing as a slave and her blossoming friendship with Penelope, future queen of Ithaca and wife of Odysseus.
This book is sometimes hard to read, the treatment of women and children is horrific. The treatment of the slaves is terrible. This story isn't just about a friendship or romance, but about class struggles and the abhorrent ownership of women of every class. I appreciated the poignant feminine rage in this story. I loved the sapphic romance spin. The prose itself is beautiful and the story is immensely detailed, despite the sometimes grim subject matter. I love the idea that a lot of the great feats accomplished by men were orchestrated through careful plotting by women.
I did find this a little bit long-winded. It seems like parts of the story were so detailed and then we would skip 5-7 years at a time. For this reason, it took me longer to read than I had anticipated because the overarching conflict isn't apparent until well into the book. I did find some of the character decisions and plot developments frustrating, and in some cases, I would have liked to see more emotional complexity and connection between characters, especially within the romance plotline.
Overall this was a stunning read. It is definitely a must-read for anyone who loves Greek Mythology reimaginings and isn't going to fuss about a story straying from the source material.
Thank you to Netgalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the ARC of this book. All thoughts and feedback contained within this review are my own.
March 25, 2026
Truly one of the most beautifully written books I’ve ever had the pleasure of reading. Rosie Hewlett is an artist. The way she writes her female characters is second to none. Penelope and Melantho had me blushing and giggling, two brilliantly written and complex main characters. Hippodamia is an inspiration. Skaris instantly reminded me of Volga from Red Rising therefore love at first sight. Rosie perfectly managed to blend the horror and ugliness of slavery with the hope and love of found family and friendship. God damn it I love women. The y e a r n i n g. Eurymachus can burn in hell. Many tears happened. I think I believe in love again. I cannot wait to see what this incredible writer does next.
I cannot fathom how humanity has sunk so low that slavery has e v e r been a thing deemed acceptable and “normal” by society. In any capacity. At any point in time. Sickening.
“Being underestimated is a woman’s greatest power.”
“As I continued watching my friends, I felt their joy filling me to the brim with a delicious kind of warmth.”
I cannot fathom how humanity has sunk so low that slavery has e v e r been a thing deemed acceptable and “normal” by society. In any capacity. At any point in time. Sickening.
“Being underestimated is a woman’s greatest power.”
“As I continued watching my friends, I felt their joy filling me to the brim with a delicious kind of warmth.”
April 6, 2026
THIS is the Greek Mythology sapphic retelling I’ve been waiting for. This was everything I needed it to be and more. It was beautiful and tragic and the YEARNING. I can’t even write a cohesive review because I’m still reeling from all the feelings this book left me with.
April 3, 2026
me and who
March 18, 2026
I will fall for you over and over again.
I don’t care how, where or when.
No matter how long it’s been, you’re mine. but the sapphic version.
from the moment these two women met each other on page, I knew this story was going to wreck me. how I hate being right.
so much about women, men, class and queerness has evolved yet remained the same from Greek Mythology to today.
Hewlett describes lesbian yearning and love so perfectly, it made my ears ring, my cheeks blush and my feet kick.
if the thought of reading a greek myth retelling intimidates you, please know the language and writing is very accessible. easier to gut you with. :)
Big thank you to Sourcebooks via NetGalley for providing me with an early copy in exchange for an honest review!
I don’t care how, where or when.
No matter how long it’s been, you’re mine. but the sapphic version.
from the moment these two women met each other on page, I knew this story was going to wreck me. how I hate being right.
so much about women, men, class and queerness has evolved yet remained the same from Greek Mythology to today.
Hewlett describes lesbian yearning and love so perfectly, it made my ears ring, my cheeks blush and my feet kick.
if the thought of reading a greek myth retelling intimidates you, please know the language and writing is very accessible. easier to gut you with. :)
Big thank you to Sourcebooks via NetGalley for providing me with an early copy in exchange for an honest review!
March 19, 2026
The tension, the yearning, oh my god.
This was such a beautiful book, it was written amazingly well and I couldn't get enough of this. I ate it up and had such an amazing time with it.
My heart ached reading through this and at points I could barely stand to find out what happened. This was incredible and exactly what I hoped it would be
This was such a beautiful book, it was written amazingly well and I couldn't get enough of this. I ate it up and had such an amazing time with it.
My heart ached reading through this and at points I could barely stand to find out what happened. This was incredible and exactly what I hoped it would be
April 2, 2026
(rounded down from 4.25)
I'll be super up front about not knowing much about the Odyssey (it is simply not my jam), so I don't give a fig about accuracy to the original story or characters. What I do enjoy is an interesting story and sapphic pining, so this was right up my alley. The language is VERY anachronistic, so I'll go out on a limb and say if you're at all bothered by period-incorrect language or not being faithful to the original story, you'll likely not enjoy this.
I, however, did have a good time once I got over the language being fairly modern. The characters behave accurately to their social status and ages and the development of their relationship as a princess (and later queen) and slave girl was believable and engaging. I had a good time and had many feels for these women trying to survive in a time when even a free woman is a possession of her husband and has limited to no power to wield.
A solid read and an engaging primary relationship with the backdrop of the events portrayed in the Odyssey.
I'll be super up front about not knowing much about the Odyssey (it is simply not my jam), so I don't give a fig about accuracy to the original story or characters. What I do enjoy is an interesting story and sapphic pining, so this was right up my alley. The language is VERY anachronistic, so I'll go out on a limb and say if you're at all bothered by period-incorrect language or not being faithful to the original story, you'll likely not enjoy this.
I, however, did have a good time once I got over the language being fairly modern. The characters behave accurately to their social status and ages and the development of their relationship as a princess (and later queen) and slave girl was believable and engaging. I had a good time and had many feels for these women trying to survive in a time when even a free woman is a possession of her husband and has limited to no power to wield.
A solid read and an engaging primary relationship with the backdrop of the events portrayed in the Odyssey.
March 26, 2026
What a mess, although I suppose I'm partially to blame for trusting something I discovered on Instagram that's this poorly titled. The only marginally redeemable qualities are the readable (if regularly purple) prose and the heartfelt romance. Aside from that, it's clear Hewlett is painfully incapable of handling everything else she attempts, especially the commentary on feminism and enslavement. About as much agility and nuance there as a baby with a hammer. Heap on the incessantly repetitive emotional beats, haphazard, opportunistic pacing, and a wide suite of character inconsistencies and plot holes and by Jove ladies and gentlemen we're left with some proper literary sludge! To say this in the same breath as Circe or Song of Achilles is downright insulting to Madeline Miller. Don't fall for the propaganda. I fucking hate BookTok.
November 21, 2025
“i was like icarus and she the sun, her radiance drawing me closer even when i knew how far i had to fall. that was what it felt like to want penelope—a sweet, assured self-destruction.”
the most beautifully devastating book, and by far my favorite read of the year.
sweetbitter song is an exquisite love story that transcends class, power, and time. the novel showcases the beauty of friendship and the curse of loving someone incomprehensively beyond reach. melantho and penelope first meet as children from wildly different backgrounds—penelope, a young princess, and melantho, a slave. but these differences are powerless against the girls’ friendship and feelings that blossom over time.
this story is told from melantho’s perspective. born into slavery and forced to endure a challenging life, melantho's temper refuses to be extinguished, and she perseveres through it all. over the course of her life, penelope’s presence comes and goes like the tide. their relationship evolves and shifts over decades, ranging from enemies to indifference, and so much more.
this review took me a long time to write because it was nearly impossible to articulate my feelings in a precise way. i will never forget this retelling, or the relationship between melantho and penelope illustrated in this gorgeous book. i cannot recommend sweetbitter song enough <3
advanced reader’s copy review - thank you netgalley for the arc!
⭑ ⭑ ⭑ ⭑ ⭑
themes: forbidden love, agency, identity, misogyny, sisterhood, and survival.
content warnings: child abuse, abuse, s*xual ass*ult, r*pe, murder, violence, sexism, character death, torture, misogyny, and slavery.
the most beautifully devastating book, and by far my favorite read of the year.
sweetbitter song is an exquisite love story that transcends class, power, and time. the novel showcases the beauty of friendship and the curse of loving someone incomprehensively beyond reach. melantho and penelope first meet as children from wildly different backgrounds—penelope, a young princess, and melantho, a slave. but these differences are powerless against the girls’ friendship and feelings that blossom over time.
this story is told from melantho’s perspective. born into slavery and forced to endure a challenging life, melantho's temper refuses to be extinguished, and she perseveres through it all. over the course of her life, penelope’s presence comes and goes like the tide. their relationship evolves and shifts over decades, ranging from enemies to indifference, and so much more.
this review took me a long time to write because it was nearly impossible to articulate my feelings in a precise way. i will never forget this retelling, or the relationship between melantho and penelope illustrated in this gorgeous book. i cannot recommend sweetbitter song enough <3
advanced reader’s copy review - thank you netgalley for the arc!
⭑ ⭑ ⭑ ⭑ ⭑
themes: forbidden love, agency, identity, misogyny, sisterhood, and survival.
content warnings: child abuse, abuse, s*xual ass*ult, r*pe, murder, violence, sexism, character death, torture, misogyny, and slavery.
Read
December 1, 2025Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc of Sweetbitter Song!
I'm afraid I'm DNFing this book due to highly triggering content that wasn't indicated in the book description. The book description states that "One summer night, within the palace of Sparta, a young slave girl stumbles across a grey-eyed princess", which is an incredibly euphemistic way to describe the book's opening.
In reality, we spend the first few chapters waiting to see if Penelope's father Icarius will succeed in (spoiler tags for triggering content) the nine-year-old Melantho. This is how Penelope and Melantho come to meet. I found it really harrowing to read those initial chapters, complete with the grief of Melantho's mother and Icarius' horrendous commentary on Melantho as . The book doesn't romanticise this, but I don't have it in me to read the entire book. (Either this is a recurring theme and it will be a highly traumatising read, or it won't come up again which means it would have been included in the book gratuitously.)
I wouldn't normally leave a review of a book I've read so little of, but I think this is the kind of thing that should at least be hinted at in the book description so that readers can make an informed decision before purchasing.
I'm afraid I'm DNFing this book due to highly triggering content that wasn't indicated in the book description. The book description states that "One summer night, within the palace of Sparta, a young slave girl stumbles across a grey-eyed princess", which is an incredibly euphemistic way to describe the book's opening.
In reality, we spend the first few chapters waiting to see if Penelope's father Icarius will succeed in (spoiler tags for triggering content) the nine-year-old Melantho. This is how Penelope and Melantho come to meet. I found it really harrowing to read those initial chapters, complete with the grief of Melantho's mother and Icarius' horrendous commentary on Melantho as . The book doesn't romanticise this, but I don't have it in me to read the entire book. (Either this is a recurring theme and it will be a highly traumatising read, or it won't come up again which means it would have been included in the book gratuitously.)
I wouldn't normally leave a review of a book I've read so little of, but I think this is the kind of thing that should at least be hinted at in the book description so that readers can make an informed decision before purchasing.
Want to Read
February 20, 2026TAKE MY MONEY NOW
May 7, 2026
an okay read over all but ultimately it really is just a very slow, dragged out, frustrating story of women suffering.
firstly I do want to say that I really didn’t like the first 20% of this book. The synopsis of this novel may lead you to believe that the vast majority of it takes place on Ithaca, perhaps even after the Trojan War but that is not exactly the case. The first 20% of the book is the MC’s childhood in Sparta and then majority of the novel is set during the Trojan War, with the latter part flying through the years following it. The part of the book that portrayed Melantho’s childhood was soooo boring to me. It also was very unnecessarily long imo, I suppose it was meant to serve two purposes: first to establish Melantho’s character and second to show us the beginning of Penelope’s and Melantho’s relationship, which at this point in the synopsis is referred to as a "powerful friendship". It fails at both. I do not think the character work in this book is that strong all across the board so the added context of following Melantho’s from her childhood really didn’t add much to her characterisation imo. Much of the important information covered in that part could’ve been interwoven with the later parts of story rather having so much of the page count dedicated to recollecting those childhood days not to mention that we don’t even see Melantho and Penelope interact much in that part, the longest period of time they spend together during which their powerful friendship is formed is nearly entirely glossed over due to a time jump😭
Once we arrive on Ithaca though I will say the story gets definitely better and while I did ultimately enjoy reading it there’s just many flaws here that made it a frustrating read. For one, as I said before the characters really aren’t that well developed, and this includes in particular the other handmaids and Telemachus. While I was fond of them, I really think they should’ve been more developed given that they actually do play a part in the story and are emotionally significant to the MCs. Instead, the author focuses more on Melantho’s brother and Eumaeus. The WHOLE side plot with Melantho and Eumaeus was so annoying to me because it literally was only there for conflict like WHYYYY ARE YOU DOING THIS. Melantho’s brother too was denied any properly consistent characterisation or character development just so he could provide conflict over and over in the book. I’m afraid actually that would be my main issue with this novel, many things that happen in it or the choices the characters make are just obviously just there so the author can create more and more random conflicts to come between the MCs and it just felt artificial to me and did not always make sense.
While I did feel sympathetic to the characters and their relationships, none of them I really felt an emotional connection to. Yes, I wanted Penelope and Melantho to be happy… but truthfully I didn’t really understand how and when exactly they formed their bond. Yes, I did want the handmaids to be well and continue to live in the community they’ve built, but to be completely honest we don’t really see the handmaids interact meaningfully with each other that much and so I didn’t have a strong feeling of the relationships between them. I wish we could’ve seen more of their “blissful” time during the Trojan War for example to really understand what exactly they made of Ithaca and how and how they’ve changed as people as years went on. But instead you just get an immediate time jump so… yeah. There are a lot of those here btw and each of them annoyed me tremendously, which I know may sound contradictory given I said the book is dragged out, but my point is that it spends a lot of time on the wrong things in my opinion. I also forgot to mention that I didn’t particularly like the prose tbh, the writing is completely fine for the most part but nothing phenomenal but at times I really wished it was at least a tad more lyrical and skilled.
anywayyyy while I had issues with the book, clearly, it was quite engaging as it went on and I did ultimately enjoy it so yeah. I don’t regret reading it ultimately but I think I also need to sleep on it.
firstly I do want to say that I really didn’t like the first 20% of this book. The synopsis of this novel may lead you to believe that the vast majority of it takes place on Ithaca, perhaps even after the Trojan War but that is not exactly the case. The first 20% of the book is the MC’s childhood in Sparta and then majority of the novel is set during the Trojan War, with the latter part flying through the years following it. The part of the book that portrayed Melantho’s childhood was soooo boring to me. It also was very unnecessarily long imo, I suppose it was meant to serve two purposes: first to establish Melantho’s character and second to show us the beginning of Penelope’s and Melantho’s relationship, which at this point in the synopsis is referred to as a "powerful friendship". It fails at both. I do not think the character work in this book is that strong all across the board so the added context of following Melantho’s from her childhood really didn’t add much to her characterisation imo. Much of the important information covered in that part could’ve been interwoven with the later parts of story rather having so much of the page count dedicated to recollecting those childhood days not to mention that we don’t even see Melantho and Penelope interact much in that part, the longest period of time they spend together during which their powerful friendship is formed is nearly entirely glossed over due to a time jump😭
Once we arrive on Ithaca though I will say the story gets definitely better and while I did ultimately enjoy reading it there’s just many flaws here that made it a frustrating read. For one, as I said before the characters really aren’t that well developed, and this includes in particular the other handmaids and Telemachus. While I was fond of them, I really think they should’ve been more developed given that they actually do play a part in the story and are emotionally significant to the MCs. Instead, the author focuses more on Melantho’s brother and Eumaeus. The WHOLE side plot with Melantho and Eumaeus was so annoying to me because it literally was only there for conflict like WHYYYY ARE YOU DOING THIS. Melantho’s brother too was denied any properly consistent characterisation or character development just so he could provide conflict over and over in the book. I’m afraid actually that would be my main issue with this novel, many things that happen in it or the choices the characters make are just obviously just there so the author can create more and more random conflicts to come between the MCs and it just felt artificial to me and did not always make sense.
While I did feel sympathetic to the characters and their relationships, none of them I really felt an emotional connection to. Yes, I wanted Penelope and Melantho to be happy… but truthfully I didn’t really understand how and when exactly they formed their bond. Yes, I did want the handmaids to be well and continue to live in the community they’ve built, but to be completely honest we don’t really see the handmaids interact meaningfully with each other that much and so I didn’t have a strong feeling of the relationships between them. I wish we could’ve seen more of their “blissful” time during the Trojan War for example to really understand what exactly they made of Ithaca and how and how they’ve changed as people as years went on. But instead you just get an immediate time jump so… yeah. There are a lot of those here btw and each of them annoyed me tremendously, which I know may sound contradictory given I said the book is dragged out, but my point is that it spends a lot of time on the wrong things in my opinion. I also forgot to mention that I didn’t particularly like the prose tbh, the writing is completely fine for the most part but nothing phenomenal but at times I really wished it was at least a tad more lyrical and skilled.
anywayyyy while I had issues with the book, clearly, it was quite engaging as it went on and I did ultimately enjoy it so yeah. I don’t regret reading it ultimately but I think I also need to sleep on it.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
First ARC! I am unwell.
A beautiful story filled with friendship (and more) and love. Even Penelopes journey shocked me! I loved the idea of how stories can get twisted and retold, and only those who are experiencing it, will know of the truth. It gave me a new grasp and thought into the world of Homer, beautiful. The story of Melantho struck me many times especially, with her brother 😿 I hope to read more amazing and thoughtful books like this in the future!
May they never be forgotten.
A beautiful story filled with friendship (and more) and love. Even Penelopes journey shocked me! I loved the idea of how stories can get twisted and retold, and only those who are experiencing it, will know of the truth. It gave me a new grasp and thought into the world of Homer, beautiful. The story of Melantho struck me many times especially, with her brother 😿 I hope to read more amazing and thoughtful books like this in the future!
May they never be forgotten.
April 21, 2026
tw: doomed yuri
Don’t read this book unless you’re prepared to be shattered. Over. And over. And over again.
Every moment would built you up just to crush you in the next. Repeatedly. Not a single moment to breathe. The second you thought things were good you’d get slapped right in the face and dragged back to reality. Just in this constant tug of war of relief and doom. You could never bask in it for too long. It was emotionally exhausting in the best way. It had me invested from beginning to end. The whole spectrum of emotion was felt. It was truly a full on experience.
Melantho and Penelope. Heartbreaking in the most beautiful way.
- The way they can so easily read each other without saying a word
- The “always”
- The feeling of their names on the others lips
Every moment they had was just filled with dread purely because of how devastating it was to read. Knowing that their future together was uncertain. knowing that it can end at any time. Knowing the world they’re in and how they viewed them. And yet they can’t help but be brought back to each other by some invisible all consuming bond. Even if it made their lives so much harder. Even if it destroyed everything around them. It was doomed from the start but you can’t help but have some hope. Knowing it’s useless but holding onto it regardless. To then not be surprised when everything gets torn apart but it taking it anyways bc it was worth the hurt. Had me bawling and left me broken. And I’d do it again.
Every moment with them was sacred. It’s so fiercely powerful yet soft and delicate. And the writing really brought that feeling to life. Obviously the way the entire thing is written is incredible. the way the prose flows so beautifully, how the world is built up, but especially the way she conveys melanthos thought process. Its simply beautiful the way she captures the yearning. The way they speak, think, look at each other. You can feel how intense it is. how all consuming it is. How inevitable and unavoidable it is. And it makes it even worse every time it’s ripped from them
I’m not one for historical romances or Greek mythology, and yet it had me entranced the entire way through. The conversation around power, sexism, male ego, war, the quiet power of women, how wlw love is viewed differently from every other kind. Even though it’s set in this world so removed from us it reflects so relevantly to today. While worded in that historical tone the content reads so contemporary. It’s really heavy in a lot of different ways and I really appreciated the nuance of it all.
With historical romances the ending always hits just a little bit harder, especially when they’re queer. It’s different from contemporary books because while still fictional, there’s a chance it can be true. That it is possible. in someone’s life. But these are a little more heartbreaking knowing that canonically, historically, physically, it is not true and will never will be true. So sometimes they overcompensate by being so idealistic in their happy ending that it ends up too unrealistic, or it’s too realistic to the point where it just bums you out. I think the ending of this one was done just right. They’re not completely separated for the rest of their lives left unknowing, they get to come back years later, with some of their life still left to live together. We don’t know if or how they figure it out, but we know they find their way back to each other eventually and that’s all the validation I need. the perfect balance of solace and sorrow.
This book is marketed as the greatest love story never told. And how grateful I am to live in the same time where it gets to be.
4.25/5
Don’t read this book unless you’re prepared to be shattered. Over. And over. And over again.
Every moment would built you up just to crush you in the next. Repeatedly. Not a single moment to breathe. The second you thought things were good you’d get slapped right in the face and dragged back to reality. Just in this constant tug of war of relief and doom. You could never bask in it for too long. It was emotionally exhausting in the best way. It had me invested from beginning to end. The whole spectrum of emotion was felt. It was truly a full on experience.
Melantho and Penelope. Heartbreaking in the most beautiful way.
- The way they can so easily read each other without saying a word
- The “always”
- The feeling of their names on the others lips
Every moment they had was just filled with dread purely because of how devastating it was to read. Knowing that their future together was uncertain. knowing that it can end at any time. Knowing the world they’re in and how they viewed them. And yet they can’t help but be brought back to each other by some invisible all consuming bond. Even if it made their lives so much harder. Even if it destroyed everything around them. It was doomed from the start but you can’t help but have some hope. Knowing it’s useless but holding onto it regardless. To then not be surprised when everything gets torn apart but it taking it anyways bc it was worth the hurt. Had me bawling and left me broken. And I’d do it again.
Every moment with them was sacred. It’s so fiercely powerful yet soft and delicate. And the writing really brought that feeling to life. Obviously the way the entire thing is written is incredible. the way the prose flows so beautifully, how the world is built up, but especially the way she conveys melanthos thought process. Its simply beautiful the way she captures the yearning. The way they speak, think, look at each other. You can feel how intense it is. how all consuming it is. How inevitable and unavoidable it is. And it makes it even worse every time it’s ripped from them
I’m not one for historical romances or Greek mythology, and yet it had me entranced the entire way through. The conversation around power, sexism, male ego, war, the quiet power of women, how wlw love is viewed differently from every other kind. Even though it’s set in this world so removed from us it reflects so relevantly to today. While worded in that historical tone the content reads so contemporary. It’s really heavy in a lot of different ways and I really appreciated the nuance of it all.
With historical romances the ending always hits just a little bit harder, especially when they’re queer. It’s different from contemporary books because while still fictional, there’s a chance it can be true. That it is possible. in someone’s life. But these are a little more heartbreaking knowing that canonically, historically, physically, it is not true and will never will be true. So sometimes they overcompensate by being so idealistic in their happy ending that it ends up too unrealistic, or it’s too realistic to the point where it just bums you out. I think the ending of this one was done just right. They’re not completely separated for the rest of their lives left unknowing, they get to come back years later, with some of their life still left to live together. We don’t know if or how they figure it out, but we know they find their way back to each other eventually and that’s all the validation I need. the perfect balance of solace and sorrow.
This book is marketed as the greatest love story never told. And how grateful I am to live in the same time where it gets to be.
4.25/5
March 19, 2026
Thank you to Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley for an eARC of this book!
THIS BOOK DESTROYED ME!!! I devoured every page and read the last 50% in a day...
I will start with the fact that I have not read the Odyssey but I LOVE Greek mythology retellings.
I picked up this book because:
- I love the cover (both versions)
- I have enjoyed the authors other works
- I LOVE sapphic retellings
- I was excited to see a story from Penelope's side of things
From the very beginning I was pulled into the story because we are following Melantho and the story unfold from her eyes. I thought this was a very unique choice and was intrigued to see how the love story would play out.
While I am not familiar with the Odyssey's story of Penelope/Melantho, I really love how Rosie Hewlett had them meet and "grow up" around each other. I thought that their story starting from a young age adds important building blocks as we go through.
I loved learning about Melantho and Penelope's lives before we get to Ithaca. As well as the life they create with the other handmaids in Ithaca as Penelope is Queen.
I got to about 75% through the book and was really surprised I hadn't cried... Then for the last 10% of the book, I sobbed...
I do wish this book had content warnings at the beginning, as some things I should have guessed would happen, and I could handle reading. But would be triggering for others to read, and they start very early. (Things like rape, whipping, abuse, fighting, etc.)
THIS BOOK DESTROYED ME!!! I devoured every page and read the last 50% in a day...
I will start with the fact that I have not read the Odyssey but I LOVE Greek mythology retellings.
I picked up this book because:
- I love the cover (both versions)
- I have enjoyed the authors other works
- I LOVE sapphic retellings
- I was excited to see a story from Penelope's side of things
From the very beginning I was pulled into the story because we are following Melantho and the story unfold from her eyes. I thought this was a very unique choice and was intrigued to see how the love story would play out.
While I am not familiar with the Odyssey's story of Penelope/Melantho, I really love how Rosie Hewlett had them meet and "grow up" around each other. I thought that their story starting from a young age adds important building blocks as we go through.
I loved learning about Melantho and Penelope's lives before we get to Ithaca. As well as the life they create with the other handmaids in Ithaca as Penelope is Queen.
I got to about 75% through the book and was really surprised I hadn't cried... Then for the last 10% of the book, I sobbed...
I do wish this book had content warnings at the beginning, as some things I should have guessed would happen, and I could handle reading. But would be triggering for others to read, and they start very early. (Things like rape, whipping, abuse, fighting, etc.)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 398 reviews