Cassidy Calloway never expected to go viral for grieving, but in the face of loss, little makes sense, especially when faced with a hit-it-out-of-the-park, over-the-fence, World Series kind of love.
This tropetastic fake dating sports romance is perfect for fans of Alicia Thompson and Tessa Bailey.
When her boyfriend dumps her at her father’s funeral, Cassidy Calloway does what she does best—turns her heartbreak into content. To honor her baseball-loving father—and if she’s being honest, to piss off her ex—she launches a season-long social media experiment to attend nine games with nine dates in honor of her father’s favorite player, number nine, Nate O’Brien.
The Gila Monsters' star pitcher is on the verge of his biggest season yet, and he’s not about to let some influencer-turned-ballpark-spectacle throw him off his game. But when the team starts losing and fans start blaming Cassidy, Nate has bigger problems than his ERA—because the front office wants them to fix the narrative by pretending to date.
With his career on the line and her reputation at stake, Cassidy and Nate must turn their luck around. But the more time they spend together, the harder it gets to pretend they aren’t falling for each other.
And that’s the problem with fake dating. At some point, it starts to feel real.
Jaqueline Snowe lives in Arizona where the "dry heat" really isn't that bad. She prefers drinking coffee all hours of the day and snacking on anything that has peanut butter or chocolate. She is the mother to two dogs who don’t realize they aren’t humans and a = mom to the sweetest boy. She is an avid reader and writer of romances and tends to write about athletes. Her husband works for an MLB team (not a player, lol) so she knows more about baseball than any human ever should.
dnf because i was BORED and literally just did not care even the tiniest bit i'm so sorry. i wouldn't not recommend this, it just didn't click with my brain :((
+ thank you to netgalley & the publisher for an arc! all opinions are my own <3
The best part of this romance was watching all that initial friction slowly turn into something much softer.
Cassidy and Nate had such fun chemistry, and their constant back-and-forth kept the romance lively. Nate took a little time to grow on me, but seeing both of them slowly let their guards down made their relationship really enjoyable.
The emotional side of the story surprised me in the best way. Cassidy’s grief felt like a genuine part of her journey rather than something the romance simply moved past, and I loved how baseball gave her another way to feel connected to her dad. Nate becoming part of that connection, while also learning to open himself up, added so much more meaning to their relationship.
Between the banter, fake-dating chaos, baseball, and all the sweeter moments between them, this was such an easy romance to settle into. The story had plenty of fun, but the way it balanced that with Cassidy’s healing gave it some extra depth.
Overall, this was exactly the kind of easy, swoony sports romance I was in the mood for.
~~~~
A sincere thank you to Jaqueline Snowe, Alcove Press, and NetGalley for the ARC! 🥰📚
I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
This was a surprisingly emotional story about losing someone you love, figuring out who you are afterward, and learning that moving forward doesn't mean leaving them behind.
Cassidy’s boyfriend dumps her AT. HER. FATHER'S. FUNERAL.😭 But Cassidy does what she knows how to do: she turns her heartbreak into content. To honor her baseball loving father and if we're being honest to annoy the hell out of her ex she creates a social media challenge centered around her dad's favorite player, number nine. Nine baseball games. Nine dates. And because the internet loves chaos (I mean don’t we all) the whole thing goes VIRAL.
And BABES…THE BANTER. These two could turn anything into an argument. Nate says something. Cassidy has a comeback. Cassidy says something. Nate has to prove her wrong. And they're staring at each other like: 👀 Oh. 😂
Nate is the grumpy professional baseball pitcher who wants absolutely NOTHING to do with Cassidy's viral social media experiment. Or so he says. Because the team starts struggling, fans start blaming Cassidy, and the front office has an idea: Fake date.
I loved how Nate's protectiveness never came at the expense of Cassidy's independence. He didn't need to rescue her. He just wanted to be there.
🥹 But the grief…Her father is still very much a part of her story. Baseball is connected to him. The number nine is connected to him. And Nate is connected to him in a way Cassidy never expected. I loved that Nate was able to share stories about Cassidy's dad that she had never heard before. He wasn't replacing her father. He wasn't fixing her grief. He was simply giving her another piece of him to hold onto.🥹
There's a beautiful message underneath all the romance…. Healing doesn't mean forgetting. You can miss someone and still laugh. You can grieve and still fall in love. You can carry the people you've lost with you while still building a life they would want you to live. And I thought the book handled that beautifully.
This isn't just a story about two people pretending to date until they accidentally fall in love. It's about a woman who is grieving and trying to figure out who she is after losing one of the most important people in her life. It's about learning that you don't have to stop missing someone to start living again. And it's about finding love when you least expect it. Sometimes the worst day of your life really can lead you to something beautiful.
Cassidy is a content creator and we meet her right after her father has passed. She is at her father’s graveside ceremony when her boyfriend dumps her. At the same gravesite, she meets two members of the local baseball team, of which her father was a huge fan.
In efforts to feel closer to her dad, Cassidy immerses herself into the baseball team by going to games and unexpectedly getting caught up with the broody pitcher Nate O’Brien. Nate is older and feels he has to prove he’s still got it. The team’s PR person proposes Nate & Cassidy fake date, even though they can’t stand each other.
Now, I usually love a fake dating trope. And thrown in sports and I love that too. But I just didn’t love this book. It wasn’t bad but I found Cassidy to be whiny and annoying and Nate to be a jerk. They got less annoying as the novel went on and of course they fell in love, but I didn’t fall in love with it.
Thank you Net Galley, Jaqueline Snowe, & Alcove Press for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
Thank you Negalley for the Advance Reader Copy of this book, in exchange I’ll give my honest review.
This book is one of the truest sports romances I’ve ever read. I loved the fact that the sport wasn’t just a background factor. It mattered. The season, the team, the score. Big social media influencer and baseball player fake date? I’m in! Oh and another one of my favorite tropes, age gap!! This couple had amazing banter and chemistry! Also, I love love loved the grief representation in this book. I LOVED this book and definitely plan on reading more by this author.
Thank you Spotify for the #gifted copy in exchange for an honest review!
Cassidy Calloway’s world begins to crumble after the loss of her father, and when her boyfriend breaks up with her at the funeral, she certainly never expected her grief to go viral. She launches a campaign to attend nine games with nine dates in honor of her father’s favorite player, number nine, Nate O’Brien. Nate himself is on the verge of his biggest season yet, and with his higher than average age for a player, he needs it all to go right. When the team managers get Cassidy and Nate to fake-date as a publicity stunt, it’s not only their reputations at stake: it’s their hearts.
This was my first novel by Jaqueline Snowe and I was NOT disappointed! I’m so on board with a sports romance, and an influencer/baseballer mashup was the perfect premise for a romance. Even better: it has the added tropes of fake dating, grumpy/sunshine, and age gap (12 years is still a gap!). It is a bit of a slow burn, but part of that is allowing Cassidy the space to grieve her father but also to build up the tension between Cassidy and Nate - like watching a World Series game in the bottom of the ninth (or insert some other sports metaphor about patience/payoff here). Narration by Ann Dahlia and Dean Miller perfectly captured the bubbly content creator energy of Cassidy and the brooding “so much is riding on my shoulders” energy of Nate, and honestly this was better than any sports movie could ever be!
Reviewed as part of an #ARC via #NetGalley.
Read this book if you: ⚾️ speak in Yogi Berra quotes 🎥 have strong opinions of Kevin Costner baseball movies 👴🏻love calling your marginally older boyfriend “old man”
I absolutely adored this book. As a content creator, I felt like I was able to relate to some of Cassidy’s struggles on a much smaller scale. The pressure, the planning, the constant feeling like I’ve “lost” time with friends and family for my online hobby just really hit for me.
I also share a strong baseball bond with my dad, so obviously my heart completely shattered for Cassidy as she grieved not only what she once had, but all the things she wished she had done more of. Her character growth was monumental, and Nate was perfectly written for her!
I honestly wasn’t sure if sports romance was “my thing,” but Jaqueline Snowe made it a point to ensure that it clearly is now. Swing and a Kiss is incredibly heartfelt, filled to the brim with banter, and completely knocks the fake dating trope out of the park!
Thank you so much to Alcove Press for providing me with an e-ARC of this book via NetGalley. All opinions are voluntary and entirely my own.
Sometimes it's hard to rate a book 3 stars when it is one that I really did enjoy but at the same time, it is not something that I am obsessed with so I can't justify rating it higher.
This book was that for me. I really enjoyed the storyline, and how the relationship between our main characters evolved over time. The banter and connection kept me entertained while reading but this story is not one that really stands out to me.
As for our main characters, I really liked Cassidy. Her character was much more than what she showed on the surface. Her character evolution throughout the book was great and she really grew from this tragedy. Nate on the other hand was not my favorite in the beginning. I'm sure that's the point but I just didn't really like how he treated Cassidy. I get that he didn't trust her intentions with her social media involving his team, but he was unnecessarily rude to someone who just lost their parent. I did grow to like him over time, but it still kind of bothered me as that was a huge time in her life that he should have showed a bit more compassion for.
The story itself was honestly not bad at all. I did like the flow and thought that the social media influencer x baseball player was a fun trope.
The narration for the audiobook was amazing. I thought that the narrators matched the characters perfectly and it made the story more enjoyable. It was clear and easy to follow along with the story throughout the entire book.
Thank you NetGalley, Jaqueline Snowe and Spotify Audiobooks for the ALC.
I LOVE Jaqueline Snowe so I am bummed this wasn't a 5 star read for me. It wasn't bad but this just was not for me specifically and that is OKAY! Personally, I found the MMC to be too unforgivably cruel in his early interactions with a much younger and grieving FMC. Given his age gap, he should have been much more mature but man did he say unspeakably horrible thing to her!!
I also am not sure if it was due to how early I got this eARC before pub day and maybe more editing happened but there were some inconsistencies that made me feel like the book was rushed. Things like for example he left the coffee shop but then the next chapter he was remembering when SHE left the coffee shop. Or he had a 2 week timeline that suddenly was 7 days with 3 days remaining. I am hoping some of the were caught in later edits because they really took me out of the story.
No worries though, JS is still one of my favorite authors!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC!
What a cute baseball romance from Jaqueline Snowe! Thank you so much to Spotify Audiobooks for the ALC.
Cassidy Calloway is heartbroken over the passing of her dad, a remarkable man who had a hidden career... working for the professional baseball team. She only discovers this at her father's funeral 1. after she's been dumped AT the funeral and 2. when her dad's favorite player, Nate O'Brien, and the team's manager show up to pay their respects.
When Cassidy decides her next move is to honor her dad by going on nine dates at the ballpark, the star pitcher refuses to be distracted by her influencer shenanigans. But when his bad attitude and her spotlight shining on the team, the front office convinces these two to date... fake date.
READ IF YOU LOVE: - baseball romance - fake dating - he's a professional pitcher - she's an influencer with a heart - bickering turned into foreplay - misjudging each other and then having to eat crow - the slow burn chemistry - swoony
THE AUDIOBOOK: Narrated by Ann Dahlia and Dean Miller, this was a fun and easy one to listen to! The bickering between characters really made it fun to listen to!
Swing and a Kiss by Jaqueline Snowe had a fun setup with fake dating, baseball, a grumpy/sunshine dynamic, and two people who seem determined to challenge each other at every opportunity.
I have to admit, the beginning felt a little repetitive, and Cassidy could be a bit much sometimes. I understood her influencer side, but I think seeing more of her vulnerable side with Nate could have balanced her character a little better. Nate definitely brought the grumpy, while Cassidy’s “sunshine” sometimes felt more like stubborn and easily irritated.
I really enjoyed their “Oh yeah? Let me prove you wrong!” dynamic, though. There was definitely some fun tension between them, although once the romance really gets going, it seems to move pretty quickly.
I also liked how grief was handled and how clearly Cassidy’s loss affected her. My biggest frustration was probably the miscommunication. Sometimes I just wanted to yell, “Guys… just TALK!”
Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for providing me with an eARC of this book. As always, all opinions are my own.
A fun and SPICY baseball romance that had a great mix of lighthearted fake dating to more romance between a grumpy pro ball player on a losing streak and an influencer who is grieving her famous baseball player father's death. I liked how Cassidy was able to get under Nate's skin so well, egging him on and getting him to open up. This was good on audio and perfect for fans of authors like Meghan Quinn. Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital and audio copy in exchange for my honest review.
This book was an interesting take into sports romance. And the fake dating argument was pretty good. I know nothing about baseball so I enjoyed to discover the sport a bit (still don't get the rules of the game but I probably never will). The banter between Nate and Cassidy was entertaining and funny but the book has more layers than a basic rom-com : Cassidy's grief of loosing her father was very well portrayed and I felt it in my soul. I enjoyed the book very much.
This was an ARC from NetGalley. This fully leaned into the grump/sunshine trope, but also made the main characters have depth and contradictions. I enjoyed the supporting characters. This is exactly what it set out to be a cute sports romance. I enjoyed it.
Cassie was having a rough time. At her beloved fathers funeral she is unceremoniously dumped by her jerk of a boyfriend. She’s mad, but rather than give the ex the satisfaction, she gets even. She goes on a journey to honor her father and to learn more about him and his love of the game. Then there is Nate, number 9. He was her father’s favorite player and important to her because of that. the problem is that he is openly hostile, rude, and acts like she is the worst and dumbest person on the planet. Turns out that she is his kryptonite and he’s on a losing streak when she’s at the stadium. He’s in need of some positive press and the fans love her and so begins their fake dating to benefit both of them. Lots of verbal sparring that is amusing, snarky and at times, a bit over the top. I like the fake romance to more trope, but did really find there to be a lot of chemistry between them. She does gain some wonderful insight into who her dad was and we do get the ending we read these books for.
I received a copy of this book from Netgalley.com in exchange for a fair and honest review.
Swing and a Kiss was a quick, cute fake-dating sports romance that I overall really enjoyed! Cassidy and Nate were both characters with a surprising amount of depth, and I loved getting to see all of the different layers to them as the story progressed.
I did struggle a little with the social media aspect of Cassidy’s character. I appreciated the reasoning behind it and how her online persona was almost a cover for who she really was. It also made sense why Nate initially viewed her as shallow. However, there were times when her need to film and post felt a little too much for me, especially when it crossed into inappropriate moments. The scene at her dad’s funeral, when her ex broke up with her and she immediately started recording, really gave me the ick.
That said, I absolutely loved watching Nate and Cassidy fall for each other. Their relationship was probably my favorite part of the book, especially the way Cassidy’s relationship with her father influenced their story and brought them closer together. I also really loved Cassidy’s desire to give back and do something meaningful in her father’s honor. It added another layer to her character and showed that there was so much more to her than what she put out on social media.
Overall, this was a fun and sweet sports romance with characters who had more depth than initially meets the eye. I really enjoyed watching Cassidy and Nate find their way to each other!
Thank you to NetGalley, Jacqueline Snowe, and Alcove Press for the eARC!
Swing and a Kiss is a fake dating sports romance by Jaqueline Snowe. Cassidy’s father has just passed away, and her boyfriend dumps her at his funeral. She is a content creator who decides to honor his memory by doing nine dates at nine games for his favorite baseball team, the Gila Monsters. Nate O’Brien is the team pitcher whose game is faltering at the beginning of the season. To help boost fan support, the PR staff for the team asks Cassidy and Nate to fake date. The more time they spend together, the more they realize that there is nothing fake about their feelings for each other.
This book has a cute premise, and I liked the idea of a FMC who is a content creator since it is not a profession often seen in romance novels. I felt for Cassidy, and her grief for her father was an important part of the story. However, there were some inconsistencies with the plot that didn’t really work. Cassidy didn’t know what her Dad’s job was even though they were supposedly close? Also, Nate really intensely hated Cassidy at the beginning of the book, when they were fake dating, and all of a sudden he’s head over heels in love with her? It was a really abrupt shift that didn’t work for me. I also didn’t understand this couple’s issues with the possibility of dating long distance… they made it seem totally impossible when it can work in certain situations.
All in all, the book has some great spicy scenes, and I liked how Nate grew to understand and support Cassidy’s career. I love the grumpy x sunshine trope, but it doesn’t really work if one of the characters truly hates the other. I also really liked Nate’s sister’s role in the story and hope she will get her own book.
Thank you to Alcove Press and NetGalley for an advance reader’s copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Firstly, thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for giving me the opportunity to read this book, especially before its release day. It’s an honor to have opportunities like this!
I liked this, but didn’t love it.
I liked the characters and the storyline. It was a light read with plenty of comic relief, while also approaching a difficult topic such as grief and the way it follows you around. The characters are funny, and there were many lighthearted moments where you could simply enjoy their different personalities and how nicely they bounced off each other. At the same time, we see how grief claws at you even during happy moments, how missing someone who has passed away stays with you every single day.
As for the main characters, I liked seeing them together and watching them navigate their relationship. It went from them being annoyed with each other at first to not being able to stay away from one another. The author managed to show how an influencer and a baseball player can actually have quite a lot in common, even if it seems unlikely at first. They were both very ambitious in their careers and genuinely wanted to give back to their communities. They admired each other first, which I liked, and then it slowly turned into something more. Lust first, and then love.
What I didn’t like was the fact that the possibility of him moving to a different team became such a big problem. Like... long-distance relationships are a thing, and if they liked each other that much, I’m sure they could have made it work for a season-or even half a season. It wouldn’t have been the end of the world. I also didn’t like the whole “I’m letting you go because I love you and this is your dream” thing... He could have both, like?? But okay.
I think this story has potential as the beginning of a series centered around these players. The writing is good, and the heavier subjects were handled well. I liked it, but I didn’t connect with the characters as much as I wish I had. Overall, I enjoyed it, but it wasn’t a favorite.
Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for the ARC of Swing and a Kiss in exchange for my honest review. 💙
This was a fun and easy sports romance with a grumpy-sunshine pairing, fake dating, and an interesting look into the life of a social media influencer. ⚾💕📱
One of the things I appreciated most was Cassidy's career as a content creator. I don't think I've read a romance where the FMC is a full-time social media influencer, so it felt fresh to me. At the beginning of the book, there was a scene where Cassidy had to create and schedule content on the day of her father's funeral. Honestly, it made me really upset at first. I couldn't understand how anyone could think about work during such a heartbreaking moment.
But while I was reading this book, I happened to watch a reel from a content creator explaining how unforgiving social media algorithms can be. Missing uploads can seriously affect your reach and income, especially when it's your full-time job. That completely changed my perspective. It reminded me that being a content creator is a real career with pressures that many of us don't see. I really liked that Jacqueline Snowe gave readers a glimpse into that world instead of treating it as something superficial. 📱✨
As for the romance, it was enjoyable but also very familiar. The fake dating trope is one I've seen quite a lot in sports romances, so there weren't many surprises. Even so, Cassidy and her love interest had good chemistry, and I enjoyed watching their relationship develop. ❤️
This isn't a book that reinvents the genre, but it doesn't need to. It's a light, entertaining romance with likable characters, plenty of sweet moments, and an interesting behind-the-scenes look at influencer life.
Overall, I had a good time with this one. If you're looking for a cozy sports romance with fake dating, grumpy-sunshine vibes, and a heroine with a unique career, Swing and a Kiss is worth checking out. ⚾💛
Entertaining read, kind of, but seriously: This. Book. Needs. An. Editor.
Nate's jaw flexes, clenches, tightens, and ticcs so often I lost count somewhere past twenty. The man communicates almost exclusively through mandible tension. He also calls Cassidy a "menace" so many times it stops being an endearment and starts being a tic the author forgot she'd already used.
Then there's the ex-boyfriend problem. Is he a villain who dumps her at her father's funeral, a soulmate who "really saw her," or in fact just "a little boring"? Cassie can't decide and we get three incompatible readings of the same man, presented each time as stable fact.
Nate's possessive-hero behavior (spiraling about an ankle bracelet, fantasizing about killing whoever gets near his "fucking girl") gets played as swoony rather than examined, which is its own quiet problem. Also: the getting-caught-by-a-waiter-then-discussing-skinny-dipping sex scene? Absolutely bonkers. I WTF'd out loud more than once.
And still. Say what you want about the craft. I finished it, I laughed (sometimes with, sometimes about the writing). And I now understand what FIP means and why a walk-off homerun ends the game. Worth two stars for that alone.
This had a strong start. There were some genuinely funny moments, the banter was strong initially, and I was worried Cassidy was going to be insufferable. Turns out for me, Cassidy is insufferable.
Her grief aside, I found her quite childish. I really rolled my eyes when she played the martyr instead of just having an adult conversation.
Nate needed to be meaner. He changed his mind about her far too quickly, and I never felt like I really got to know him. His teammates honestly had more personality, shout out to Pavin.
The middle dragged for me, and I didn’t feel like there was enough build-up to the first kiss. The writing also felt repetitive, with conversations going in circles.
There were some really sweet moments, particularly the hospital visit, which I loved. But the intimate scenes didn’t work for me, and I never recovered from “brunch daddy.” The ick really stuck.
I really wanted to love this because I’m a sport romance fiend, but unfortunately, it just wasn’t for me in the end.
Thank you to NetGalley & Alcove for the opportunity to read this early review copy.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC!
Unfortunately, this was indeed a swing and a miss for me. I love the concept, and there were some good moments for sure, but for the most part I was eager to be done reading it.
There were several confusing moments that really took me out of the story. I think this book needs several more edits.
✨ The Vibe A fun, trope-filled baseball romance with fake dating, sunshine x grumpy energy, plenty of laughs, and a heartfelt look at grief, healing, and finding joy again.
📚 What the Book Is About (No Spoilers) After being dumped at her father's funeral, Cassidy Calloway channels her heartbreak into something her baseball-loving dad would've appreciated: attending nine baseball games with nine different dates in honor of his favorite player, number nine.
When the experiment unexpectedly goes viral, it catches the attention of Nate O'Brien—the very pitcher whose number inspired the challenge. After the team's losing streak starts getting blamed on Cassidy's growing online presence, the front office comes up with the perfect PR solution: fake dating.
As the lines between pretending and reality begin to blur, Cassidy and Nate discover that maybe the hardest part of fake dating is convincing themselves their feelings aren't real.
🖤 My Reading Experience This book was such a fun read. It combines several of my favorite romance tropes—fake dating, sports romance, sunshine x grumpy, and just enough enemies-to-lovers energy to keep the banter entertaining.
It's the kind of story that's easy to binge because there's always something happening, whether it's a funny interaction, a baseball game, or another moment that slowly brings Cassidy and Nate closer together.
I really liked both main characters. Cassidy was easy to root for, and while Nate definitely wasn't winning any awards for first impressions, he grew on me throughout the story. Once his walls started coming down, I loved seeing the caring side of him emerge.
One thing I especially appreciated was how the book balanced its lighter moments with a more emotional storyline about grief. Despite all the humor and romance, it never forgets that Cassidy is mourning her father. It shows how grief doesn't simply disappear when life moves forward—it lingers, quietly showing up even during moments of happiness. I thought that aspect of the story was handled with a lot of care.
As someone who creates content online full-time myself, I also really connected with Cassidy's experiences as an influencer. The assumptions people make, the judgment, and the tendency to dismiss content creation as "not a real job" all felt very recognizable. That added an extra layer to the story that I personally appreciated.
💭 What Didn't Fully Work for Me While I enjoyed the romance, I do think it developed a little too quickly. Nate spends the beginning of the book insisting that Cassidy represents everything he dislikes, yet after only a handful of interactions, he suddenly becomes incredibly protective and completely invested in her.
I absolutely love a caring MMC, but I would've liked to see more resistance before we got there. Since the book leans into enemies-to-lovers vibes, I wanted a little more lingering annoyance, more tension, and more gradual emotional progression before Nate made that switch.
I also wasn't completely convinced by the conflict surrounding Nate potentially being traded to another team. The story treats it as though it would make a relationship nearly impossible, but I kept thinking... long-distance relationships exist. If these two cared about each other that much, surely they could've made it work for a season—or even half a season. Because of that, the whole "I'm letting you go because I love you" conflict didn't fully land for me.
The side characters also felt fairly underdeveloped. Amanda (Nate's sister) was probably my favorite supporting character, but beyond her, most of Nate's teammates blended together. They fulfilled their role in the story, but I never became particularly invested in them as individuals.
Overall, I think the story could've benefited from a little more depth, both in the romance and in some of its supporting relationships.
🔥 Tropes & Elements - Fake dating - Sports romance - Baseball romance - Sunshine x grumpy - Enemies-to-lovers vibes - Forced proximity - Grief and healing
Baseball knowledge gained: slightly more than before. 😂
🫶 Final Thoughts Swing and a Kiss was exactly what I hoped it would be: a light, entertaining sports romance filled with lovable tropes, funny moments, and plenty of heart.
While I would've loved a slower romantic build-up, stronger side characters, and a conflict that felt a little more convincing, none of that stopped me from genuinely enjoying my time with this book.
It's sweet, easy to read, and does a lovely job balancing romance with a thoughtful exploration of grief and learning how to move forward after loss.
If you're looking for a baseball romance packed with fake dating, sunshine x grumpy chemistry, and a story that's equal parts fun and heartfelt, this is definitely worth picking up.
📢 Disclosure: Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for providing me with an ARC. As always, all thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
5 ⭐️ Tropes: dual POV, fake dating, sports romance, found family, age gap romance, grumpy x sunshine, healing after grief
“Maybe we were meant to meet each other. I hate why it happened, but I have a feeling you were supposed to be in my life.”
This book completely stole my heart. It was so much more than a fake dating sports romance—it was a beautiful story about learning how to live with grief, finding yourself again, and discovering that love can show up when you least expect it.
Cassidy is left heartbroken after losing her dad AND being dumped at his funeral, but through the one thing she and her dad always shared—baseball—she slowly begins to find herself again. What made it even more special was that Nate played for her dad’s favorite team and had been his favorite player, making their connection feel like so much more than coincidence. I ADORED that he was able to share stories about her dad that she had never heard before, giving her another piece of him to hold onto. He didn’t replace her dad or her grief—he helped her stay connected to him while also helping her build a future. Watching her heal while honoring her dad was such an emotional journey, and I loved seeing something born from so much pain become the reason she found a second chance at life… and Nate.
The enemies-to-lovers tension between Cassidy and Nate was EVERYTHING. They couldn’t stand each other at first, but a fake dating PR stunt forces them together, and watching their relationship slowly evolve from annoyance and attraction into something so genuine had me completely hooked. I ate up EVERY single second of it.
Nate was absolutely obsessed in the best way. I loved how patient he was with Cassidy, how protective and possessive he became, and most importantly, how safe he made her feel. He never tried to fix her grief—he just stayed. He let her feel everything while reminding her she didn’t have to carry it alone, and that honestly made me fall in love with him 🥹
“I can handle everything about you, Cassidy. You can give me all your attitude and fears, but never say I can’t handle you. I absolutely can.”
I also loved that Nate had his own journey. He wasn’t just the one helping Cassidy heal—he had spent years convincing himself he didn’t need anyone, avoiding relationships, and keeping people at a distance. Watching Cassidy slowly break down those walls made their relationship feel even more special. She completely snuck past every defense he’d built, and seeing him go from wanting nothing to do with her to not being able to imagine life without her was everything.
“I was pulled to her despite all the reasons I shouldn’t be.”
“one look at her and the noise quieted. She anchored me without even trying.”
Cassidy is seriously such a fun character. I loved how she constantly challenged Nate, gave him a run for his money, and refused to let him have the last word, like literally EVERY single time! 😂 Their banter was TOP TIER and had me smiling so much!
“Watching this man slowly unravel because of me was my new favorite pastime.”
Once they finally started letting each other in, the emotional depth of their relationship was incredible.
“He made me feel safe and seen and desired, a combination I hadn’t felt … ever.”
“this man had healed my soul and helped me rebuild myself.”
And don’t even get me started on Nate when he realized he was completely gone for her 😍🫠
“I grinned, slow and dark, because I knew without a doubt this girl was about to ruin me.”
“I had no idea when it had happened, but one thing was for sure—this whole fake-dating thing with her was starting to not feel fake at all.”
“I had no idea what the hell we were to each other, or if this realistically could be anything, but I knew one thing: Cassidy Calloway had burrowed her way into my life.”
The romance was swoony, emotional, incredibly heartfelt, and hilarious. There were so many laugh out loud moments, plenty that had me kicking my feet, and even a few that made me tear up. Add in Nate’s deliciously dirty mouth, incredible chemistry, and all the fake dating tension, and I was completely sold!
“Weird how the worst day of my life had led me to the best person in my life. Or maybe that was how it was supposed to be.”
This was the perfect balance of humor, romance, and healing, and it reminded me that even after unimaginable loss, happiness can find you again. I loved every single page. This was also my first read by this author and I absolutely adored her writing and her characters! Mark your calendars for September 29, 2026! 🩵
Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to NetGalley and Spotify Audiobooks for providing an advance listening copy.
⭐ 4/5 🎧 4/5 🌶️ 2/5 for experienced spicy-romance readers 🌶️ 3/5 if you’re newer to spice
Swing and a Kiss had so much going for it: baseball, fake dating, grief underneath the rom-com premise, genuinely fun chemistry, and two characters who irritated each other just enough to make watching them fall for each other extremely entertaining.
The baseball also felt like more than sports-romance decoration. There was enough specificity to make it feel integral to the characters and story, while explanations of things like advanced statistics kept it accessible if you don’t happen to spend your free time calculating WAR.
Cassidy’s grief gave the intentionally tropey premise some emotional substance, and I really liked how much backbone she had through most of the book. Nate starts as a wonderfully aggravating grumpy veteran player who has opinions about Cassidy and isn’t shy about sharing them. Watching that antagonism evolve into genuine understanding and attraction was one of my favorite parts.
I also really appreciated the way intimacy was written. Desire felt mutual, both characters had room to communicate what they did and didn’t want, and physical intimacy wasn’t treated as though it only “counted” if it progressed to intercourse. That’s something I don’t see normalized nearly enough in romance.
And then we hit the third-act breakup.
Without spoiling the specifics, the book already had plenty of organic conflict available to these characters, so introducing a breakup that late felt manufactured rather than necessary. More frustratingly, the way responsibility for the conflict and subsequent repair was distributed didn’t entirely match what I had watched happen.
The HEA worked for me because I still believed in the relationship. It just didn’t erase my frustration with how the final conflict was executed.
Ann Dahlia and Dean Miller both gave pleasant performances, and I enjoyed the audiobook overall. I do think this romance would have been even more fun in duet narration, particularly because so much of its appeal comes from the chemistry and back-and-forth between Cassidy and Nate.
Despite my late-book frustration, I had a genuinely good time with the vast majority of Swing and a Kiss. This was a fun, tropey baseball romance with enough emotional and character substance to make the tropes work—and one third-act choice I desperately wanted to eject from the ballpark. 😂
Who Should Listen?
Sports-romance readers who enjoy baseball, fake dating, grumpy heroes, banter, emotional substance underneath a fun premise, and approachable on-page spice. I also think this is a good option for readers beginning to venture into spicier romance: there’s enough on-page intimacy to know you’re reading a spicy romance without it dominating the book.
I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Fake dating, baseball, viral chaos, and a romance that sneaks up somewhere between grief and finding your way forward.
Cassidy Calloway is having what can only be described as a spectacularly terrible time. Her father has died, her boyfriend chooses his funeral to dump her, and suddenly she's trying to figure out how to grieve while the rest of the world keeps moving. So Cassidy does what comes naturally to her: she turns it into content.
Her plan is equal parts heartfelt and slightly unhinged—nine baseball games, nine dates, all in honor of her baseball-loving father and his favorite player, number nine. It's a way to keep her dad close, give herself something to focus on, and, okay, maybe make her ex regret a few life choices along the way.
Then there's Nate O'Brien.
The Gila Monsters' star pitcher has absolutely no interest in Cassidy's viral dating experiment becoming part of his baseball season. But when the team's losing streak collides with the internet's determination to blame Cassidy, the front office comes up with the perfectly reasonable solution: Nate and Cassidy should fake date.
What could possibly go wrong?
Swing and a Kiss takes one of my favorite romance setups—fake dating—and gives it a wonderfully messy, emotional sports-romance twist. Cassidy and Nate don't immediately fit together, which makes watching them slowly discover just how well they actually do fit so satisfying. The public performance forces them together, but it's the quieter moments underneath it that make their relationship work.
I especially loved that Cassidy's grief isn't something the romance magically fixes. Losing her father has changed the shape of her life, and her nine-game experiment becomes about much more than social media attention. It's about holding onto someone she loved while also figuring out who she is in the life that comes afterward. That emotional thread gives the story a tenderness beneath all the banter, baseball, and fake-relationship shenanigans.
And Nate? Watching the reluctant pitcher go from wanting absolutely nothing to do with Cassidy's spectacle to caring very much about the woman behind it is exactly the kind of progression I want from this trope. Their chemistry grows naturally as the lines between publicity and reality get blurrier and blurrier.
There is something irresistible about two people insisting they're only pretending while everyone—including the reader—can see that they've already crossed that line.
Funny, heartfelt, romantic, and grounded by a thoughtful exploration of grief, Swing and a Kiss is about discovering that moving forward doesn't mean leaving the people we've lost behind. Sometimes love shows up while we're still figuring out how to carry everything that came before it.
Honestly, I didn't expect this book to seamlessly evoke so many feelings. It mixes being sweet, beautiful, heart-breakingly sad, and simply fun. It's vulnerable and tender, but also spicy with a bratty flare and comedic breaks.
The characterization was thorough and well-done. Within the first couple chapters, I was especially impressed with how well the FMC was established - she's feisty but kind, and always thinks about a social media angle because that's the thing that occupies most of her time, whether it's convenient or not.
The initial confict is perfection to me, because both sides are equally in the right and wrong at once. I was annoyed with both, but at the same time understood where they were coming from and couldn't wait for that moment when they would start seeing more than just the surface.
A good romance obviously has tension and - preferably - good banter, and this delivered. As a bonus, both things evolved and gained a different flavor once they started learning more about each other, getting more personal. Their chemistry turned into a soft exploration and development of feelings - the kind that you don't really notice until they pierce through your heart and leave you shattered. And, oh my god, the way the heartbreak of quietly letting go was written is pure gold.
I also found the portrayal of grief versus a very public, time-consuming career to be deeply touching. How much are you allowed to show? Can you even break if your brand is being happy? Are you allowed to grieve outside of the spotlight? It's a good reminder that we should all take a step back from work sometimes and actually spend time with our loved ones, because we never know when someone is going to be gone forever. How well do you know the person who you claim is your favorite human?
Simply speaking, this is just an example of good writing, because if I cry at a sports scene and I barely understand the sport, you convinced me to care, and that's the goal.
Oh, and I enjoyed the age jokes. I'm a simple person. They were funny.
I think the only thing I don't like is not even about the book itself but the fact that I had to do some digging to find out who made the cover, because the artist is not publicly acknowledged on social media. She should be, it's georgous.
I'd recommend this to sports romance fans who enjoy bratty FMCs and very possessive MMCs.
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for letting me read the ARC!