Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Rustler Mountain #4

Christmas Valley

Rate this book
When it comes to the Christmas season, Rustler Mountain, Oregon, is as lively as its Wild West past, from its winter wonderland landscape to its weekend festivities, filled with food, music, and sometimes, wild hearts meeting in unexpected romance . . .

A swoony Christmas cowboy romance for fans of Lyla Sage, Elsie Silver, Jessica Peterson, Amy Barry, and Robyn Carr.

No one would blame Cassidy Wilder if she wasn’t a big fan of Christmas, or of Rustler Mountain. After all, her introduction to the town came the Christmas her mother left her on her father’s doorstep. Yet Cassidy grew to love it all, especially her three protective half-brothers. And this Christmas, she’ll have it all too, if she can make one of her lifelong wishes come to marry Dalton Wade.

Sure, Dalton’s had casual affairs over the years, but obviously, with Cassidy he’s too respectful to make the first move. So, she’s finally going to confess her love. There’s just one brooding, tatted bad boy West Hancock. There’s bad blood between the Wilders and the Hancocks but West is about to be Cassidy’s brother-in-law. He’s the total opposite of the man she’s given her heart to. If only he didn’t ignite . . . other parts of her. Worse, he’s got to help her train as a trick rider for the Wild West show.

West is determined to ignore the heat between him and Cassidy. He just wants to get through Christmas and move on to working his own ranch. Still, even if it’s purely lust, it’s powerful. Too powerful for either of them to resist. Trouble is, they seem to understand each other better than anyone else does. Can a winter fling become an evergreen love?

255 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 29, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Maisey Yates

1,294 books3,247 followers
New York Times and USA Today Bestselling author Maisey Yates lives in rural Oregon with her three children and her husband, whose chiseled jaw and arresting features continue to make her swoon. She feels the epic trek she takes several times a day from her office to her coffee maker is a true example of her pioneer spirit. In 2009, at the age of twenty-three Maisey sold her first book.

Since then it’s been a whirlwind of sexy alpha males and happily ever afters, and she wouldn’t have it any other way. Maisey divides her writing time between dark, passionate category romances set just about everywhere on earth and light sexy contemporary romances set practically in her back yard.

She believes that she clearly has the best job in the world.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
105 (39%)
4 stars
100 (37%)
3 stars
51 (18%)
2 stars
10 (3%)
1 star
3 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews
Profile Image for Madison Warner Fairbanks.
3,883 reviews543 followers
October 18, 2026
Christmas Valley by Maisey Yates
Rustler Mountain series #4. Contemporary western, holiday small town romance. Can be read as a standalone but better as part of the series (at least the first book).
It’s Christmas on Rustler Mountain and Cassidy has decided it’s time for her to leave the nest. Sure, Dalton is a bit of a ladies man, but she’s sure that will stop when they get together.
West Hancock sees how Cassidy watches Dalton and doesn’t understand it. Their families are long-time enemies and even he’d be a better choice for her.
Cassidy agrees to ride in the Christmas show this year and practices with West have sparks flying. Do either of them want more and what about her crush on the other man?

🎧 the audiobook is narrated by Jennifer Mack who has performed the full series to-date. The performance is wonderfully rich in emotions, with distinctive voices for the two MC’s. I loved the timing of the audiobook and how the narrator was able to bring the character’s actions and feelings vividly to the listener.

Cassidy is a bit naive but that’s deliberate on her part. She had no interest in romance before now and West is too potent to resist.
A meltingly delicious romance. The chemistry is undeniable between Cassidy and West. I loved her thoughtful consideration at one point, and her acknowledgment that West was the one who stirred her emotions.
There are deeper emotions in the memories of both as the story moves forward but the focus easily swings back to their magnetic connections.

I love this series for the joy and love but also for the history and family. I can’t wait to read more.
An author on auto-buy for me and the love of a feel good romance.

I received a copy of the audiobook from Recorded Books. I purchased the ebook to keep.
Profile Image for Renee.
366 reviews541 followers
October 14, 2026
This is book #4 of the Rustler Mountain series and concentrates on Cassidy Wilder, the youngest sibling of the Wilder family. This was quite a delightful story and had a well done story even though the length was a bit short. While it's not excessively Christmas, it does take place at Christmas which is a bit of full circle thing given her beginning at Rustler Mountain.

What you think you need and what you actually need are often two very different things. Cassie Wilder knew exactly what she needed - to have a home of her own in Rustler Mountain and to marry Dalton Wade. It made sense. She's known him her entire life, he's her brother's best friend, he's kind, and most importantly, he's safe. Along comes West Hancock. He's exactly what she doesn't want. He's broody, he's got a dangerous edge to him, and he's the love 'em and leave 'em type. So why is he suddenly consuming her thoughts?

This was such a fun story. Of course, if you've read the first three books it's better but not 100% necessary also. While not overly Christmas, the story is one of forgiveness (of self and others), acceptance, and love. These are some pretty great themes for a Christmas book. Also, the romance in this book is great!
Profile Image for Liz Morris.
103 reviews59 followers
October 3, 2026
Book 4 in the series and definitely my least favorite. This was perfectly fine but felt very rushed. The characters literally could not talk about anything else other than their collective trauma. Again and again and again. We get it.

The aspect of this series that made it so great was the history of these two rival families and the genealogy studies that the different characters undertook to learn about their relatives. This was quite noticeably absent until the last 10%. I think it was a missed opportunity to really tie a bow on the series.

Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced copy!
Profile Image for Amanda Grace.
907 reviews60 followers
September 17, 2026
Christmas Valley is a fun conclusion to the Rustler Mountain series. Cassidy and West understand each other in a way that goes beyond all the family history and expectations surrounding them, and I really enjoyed watching that connection develop.

West ended up being my favorite part of the book. I really liked seeing him work through his late ADHD diagnosis and the way it shaped how he viewed himself and what he thought he could offer someone. There is a real vulnerability to him, especially in the moments when he admits how much he wants to be taken care of instead of always being the one holding everything together. His relationship with Cassidy brought out a softer side of him, and I loved watching him realize that he was worthy of being loved. Cassidy could come across as a little sheltered at times, but she ended up being a good match for West.

I especially enjoyed their time working together on the Wild West show, and West’s conversations with his parents added some nice depth to his story. There are some fun Christmas touches throughout, although I would have liked even more of that given the setting and the gorgeous cover.

Overall, this was an enjoyable and easy read, and a good way to wrap up the Rustler Mountain series.

Thank you to the publisher for the ARC.

Release Date: September 29, 2026
Profile Image for Meredith.
794 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 26, 2026
Thanks so much to Kensington for the review copy. All opinions are honest and offered voluntarily.

3.25/5 stars

This was a cute small town romance between a sheltered super-sunshine FMC and a wanna-be grump MMC. It was cute and fluffy and a fast easy read. There’s a bit of an age gap, but it’s not super significant to anyone other than the MMC.

This is 4th in a series and I haven’t read the others, but it’s easy to pick up. She has 3 brothers. They’ve all fallen in love and found their women in other small town western tinged romances too.

That being said, my biggest issues are that the FMC was a bit annoying in her naïveté and ultra sunshine attitude and I struggled to feel the Christmas in the holiday novel.

I would recommend this for readers who want to escape with an easy and uncomplicated read.
Profile Image for Elizabeth O'Keefe.
1,173 reviews27 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 28, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️

Thank you to NetGalley for the review copy! 📚✨

The Christmas Valley was a quick, easy read, but unfortunately it didn’t quite grab me the way I was hoping it would. Despite being a Christmas romance, I didn’t really get the super Christmasy feeling I was looking for, and I had a hard time fully connecting with the characters or really buying into their romance.

I also felt like this could easily be read as a standalone, since there’s quite a bit of backstory included at the beginning — much of which is also covered in the first three books. Since I was expecting to jump right into the story, that made the beginning feel a little slower for me.

Overall, it was a good read and an easy one to get through, but it just wasn’t quite the cozy, Christmas romance I was hoping for. 🎄📖
Profile Image for rosesreadsromance .
172 reviews10 followers
September 29, 2026
🐎"(...) You are the most beautiful woman I've ever seen. Because you have something beyond beauty. It's something about the way you're made. The way the sun reflects in your eyes, the way the wind blows through your hair. The way you are when you move, when you walk, when you're on the back of a horse. All those things. They all go together to make you the woman you are. The woman I want." 🐎

“You don’t love someone because they’re perfect; you love them in spite of the fact that they’re not.” — Jodi Picoult 🤍


A really great read! 💖
I absolutely loved Cassidy and West! ❤️
At first, you might think, “Okay, good girl and bad boy… I know where this is going.” But honestly, this story is so much more than that 🥰

As you get to know Cassidy and West and slowly discover their pasts, feelings, fears, and dreams, you realize how much more there is to both of them 🥹 I loved watching their relationship change and grow throughout the story. They not only got to know each other better, but also learned more about themselves along the way 🫶🏻

And their chemistry?! 🔥 The attraction between them was impossible to miss—those sparks were flying! ✨ I loved that they were willing to take a chance on each other, even though they were so different and had completely different plans for the future. They could have walked away, but instead, they decided to see where that chemistry could take them 🥵🤤☺️

I also really loved Cassidy’s relationship with her brothers 💚 The way they look out for her, support her, and always have her back was so sweet. She knows she can count on them no matter what 😍

One small downside for me was the third-person POV. It’s just a personal preference, as I usually connect a little more with stories written in first person. Because of that, it took me a little longer to fully immerse myself in the story 🥺

Recommended for:
🤠 cowboy romance
⚡ enemies to lovers
🚫 forbidden love
😇😈 good girl x bad boy
🏡 small-town romance
🎄 Christmas vibes


📖 Christmas Valley by Maisey Yates (ARC) 🐎🤠❤️‍🔥




⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ (rounded up)
Profile Image for Nova McCormack .
283 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 29, 2026
One thing you have to know about Rustler Mountain is that the Wilders and the Hancocks have been feuding for generations. The feud may be waning, but old tensions don’t die easy, and honestly, that’s how we like it.

Cassidy is the baby sister of the Wilder clan. Coddled, loved, and maybe just a touch (ridiculously) overprotected by her bad boy brothers, she has always craved security and comfort. Left on her brothers’ doorstep at nine, she surrounded herself with the safety they gave her, building herself into the easy, perfect sister. Basically, the complete opposite of the heartbreaker West Hancock.

West is tall, dark, and all kinds of trouble, and he knows it. But something about Cassidy stops him in his tracks. She sees past the persona he has so fiercely built, and what begins as a small fixation quickly grows into full-blown infatuation, bringing him to his knees. Caught up in Cassidy’s bubble, he’ll take anything she is willing to give him, all while struggling with the belief that no matter how much he wants her, he’ll eventually hurt her.

But West brings out something in Cassidy she had never let herself explore. He makes her reckless, showing her a passion and freedom she’d never known and that she doesn’t have to live in the shadows of her own life. Their connection is immediate and insistent, and watching them work through their fears together had me so hopeful.

I really thought the ADHD representation was so well done. It gave West so much dimension and really helped me understand who he was, the way he saw himself, and so much of what drove his choices and motivations. He had spent so much of his life being brushed off and underestimated, and I really loved seeing that part of him given the attention and depth it deserved.

This read had all the fun banter, the hot chemistry, and man, was it hot. But the weight they both carried hit close to home. It was heavy and inspiring, and I honestly ended up crying up a storm of happy tears. I really just loved being back in Rustler Mountain!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Janalyn, the blind reviewer.
5,057 reviews162 followers
November 13, 2026
Christmas Valley is the fourth book in the Russler Mountain romance series by Macy Yates, Cassidy Wilder has for all of her life wanted to marry Dalton Wade but when she agrees to take Jane Hancock‘s place in the Christmas show Jane’s brother Wes says she can only do it if he agrees she got the skills. This is how Cassidy finds herself falling for West who is completely opposite of the man she has been fixated on her whole life but the more they are together the more she finds her thoughts centered around Wes. I want to say this book really has nothing to do with Christmas except for the fact it was set at Christmas time I also want to say I feel like other books we have heard about the abuse of the Wilder children including Cassidy and I hate to say it but I’m getting tired of hearing about it more than once it was mentioned in this book and pass books in the series. Not to mention throughout the whole book all she does is sit and think about how attracted she is to West and that started getting on my last nerve by the time the book ended instead of having that happy Hart filled feeling I was just happy it was over. I usually have this problem with Macy Yates books they’re usually a hit or a miss and this one was definitely a miss. this is something I find really sad because when Macy Yates is at her best her books are so good so I will definitely read the next one in the series I just didn’t like this one others may like it those who do so don’t take my word for it read it yourself. #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,
Profile Image for Goksu.
103 reviews2 followers
October 28, 2026
This was such a cute story! I have to be honest I wasn't sure how their story will unfold knowing how much the FMC had a crush on her brother's best friend for years. I couldn't see myself wanting read her heartbreak and finding someone else in a short book like this. But it was handled SO well! No heartbreak, no humiliation. Just a girl finding out whoever is most convenient doesn't mean the safest option as well. She grew up thinking wanting someone and loving someone has to be completely different things and the MMC unknowingly showed to her two things can be true at once. I also loved without any intention to do so the FMC helped the MMC learn about love. She didn't even need to think about working for his attention and love, they naturally fit together like perfect puzzle pieces. I really liked this book a lot!

Huge thanks to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for the eARC.
Profile Image for Crystal-Rain Love.
Author 43 books139 followers
October 8, 2026
This and the first book in the series are two of the best romance novels ever written and I will not debate this. Austin Wilder and West Hancock are my favorite book boyfriends. And I really didn't even think I'd like West that much but damn. 100% perfection. No notes.
Profile Image for Dark Little Reader.
333 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
September 26, 2026
This was a sweet but spicy romance by Maisey Yates. I enjoyed the banter and flirting between West and Cassidy. My complaint is that I found the ending very abrupt, I would have liked a bit more relationship development there and interaction with her family
Profile Image for Christina.
315 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 9, 2026
Thank you Kensington Books and NetGalley for gifting me an eARC in exchange for a honest review.

I just finished Christmas Valley by Maisey Yates. West and Cassidy have the absolute BEST enemies-to-lovers chemistry, and the cozy, small-town holiday vibes had me hooked from page one. If you love a steamy cowboy romance with tons of heart, you need to read this ASAP! I think the plot could’ve used a little more Christmas vibes, other than that good read.
19 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 3, 2026
🎄✨️ Review Contains Spoilers ✨️🎄

Christmas Valley is, at its heart, a story about love, guilt, family, and the terrifying act of letting yourself be known.

From the opening chapters, the novel hooks readers with a compelling mystery surrounding Butch Hancock and the Wilders. The historical storyline never feels like a gimmick—instead, it becomes a mirror reflecting the struggles of the modern protagonists. The parallels between Butch and West are particularly well executed, showing how both men instinctively cast themselves as villains in their own stories. It's a thoughtful exploration of inherited trauma and self-perception.

The relationship between West and Cassidy is unquestionably the novel's greatest strength. Their chemistry feels authentic from the start, balancing heartfelt vulnerability with genuinely funny moments. The story allows their relationship to develop naturally, from uncertainty and fear to quiet domesticity and finally complete commitment. Small interactions often carry more emotional weight than grand declarations, making the eventual confession of love and spontaneous proposal feel surprisingly earned rather than rushed.

Cassidy stands out as a memorable protagonist. Her humour, impulsiveness, and emotional honesty make her impossible not to root for. West's journey is equally satisfying, particularly as he gradually dismantles the belief that he isn't worthy of love. His conversations with his parents, and the healing that follows, provide some of the novel's most emotionally resonant moments.

The historical narrative reaches its emotional peak through Sarah Martin. Rather than attempting to redeem Butch by ignoring his past, the novel wisely chooses to show that love can exist alongside painful truths. The diaries of Butch and Sarah become the emotional bridge that finally allows West to understand that being loved doesn't require being perfect.

The ending is both chaotic and deeply satisfying. Cassidy blurting out "I love you" the moment West returns home perfectly captures her character, while West's impulsive proposal feels like the inevitable release after a lifetime of emotional repression. The epilogue provides a fitting conclusion, particularly Austin's decision to write his 2nd book, reframing Butch Hancock's legacy not as one defined solely by violence, but by the love that ultimately outshone his darkness. Putting to bed the long awaited family feuds.

Where the novel occasionally stumbles is in its pacing. There are stretches where previous events and emotional beats are revisited repeatedly, slowing the momentum. While the introspection reinforces the themes, some sections feel as though they cover familiar ground without adding enough new insight. Tighter editing could have made an already engaging story even more impactful.
The prose is also somewhat uneven. Although there are flashes of genuinely beautiful writing—particularly in the quieter emotional scenes—it sometimes lacks the polish needed to elevate the strongest moments. Certain passages tell the reader what characters are feeling when the dialogue and actions have already communicated it effectively.

Even with those flaws, Christmas Valley succeeds where it matters most. It creates characters worth investing in, explores difficult emotional themes with sincerity, and delivers an ending that feels hopeful without being sentimental. It's a story about breaking cycles, accepting love despite believing you don't deserve it, and discovering that perhaps the greatest act of courage isn't saving someone else - it's allowing someone to save you.

A moving, character-driven romance wrapped in a generational mystery. While the pacing and occasional repetition prevent it from reaching perfection, its emotional core is strong enough to leave a lasting impression long after the final page.

It's been fun following the story develop - from early character ideas to this ending. The emotional through-line became much clearer as West and Cassidy's relationship, and Butch's legacy, came together.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Get Your Tinsel in a Tangle.
2,397 reviews75 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 24, 2026
Cassidy spent YEARS planning to marry Dalton, and somewhere along the line nobody thought to ask the very important follow-up question... "Based on what?" I kept waiting for someone to pull out a PowerPoint presentation explaining why this man was the love of her life, and the answer basically boiled down to, "Well... he's nice." Meanwhile, West is over there glowering in the corner, teaching her trick riding, trying very hard to pretend chemistry isn't happening, and absolutely fooling no one.

I should say right up front that I jumped into this without reading the first three Rustler Mountain books. You can absolutely follow what's happening, but there were definitely moments where everyone else seemed to have years of shared history and I was the new person at the family Christmas party trying to figure out who was related to whom. It didn't ruin anything, but it did make me feel like I'd shown up halfway through a very entertaining argument.

Cassidy is fascinating because she has spent so much of her life chasing the idea of safety that she mistakes it for love. She was abandoned as a kid, found a family she never expected, and now she's clinging to this picture-perfect future she's been carrying around forever. The problem is... life keeps handing her West instead. And West is about as far from her carefully color-coded life plan as a man can get.

West has the exact personality type that insists he doesn't want forever while quietly building it with his bare hands. This man keeps telling himself he's only interested in keeping things casual while simultaneously acting like someone who would absolutely remember how you take your coffee for the next forty years. Sir. Please be serious.

Watching them rehearse for the Wild West Christmas show was honestly where I had the most fun. There's something deeply entertaining about forcing two people with obvious chemistry to spend hours together doing dangerous stunts while both of them insist they're completely in control. Nobody involved was fooling me. They certainly weren't fooling each other.

What surprised me was how much this ended up being about belonging. Cassidy has spent her whole life trying to earn a place that was already hers. West is trying to convince himself he doesn't need roots while secretly planting them anyway. Somewhere under all the flirting, family drama, cowboy boots, and Christmas lights, that really landed for me. Sometimes the home you're fighting for is already standing right in front of you.

There were stretches early on where I found myself wishing everyone would stop circling the same feelings and just kiss already. Once the story leaned into Cassidy and West instead of the idea of Cassidy and Dalton, everything clicked into place for me. I started having a lot more fun because, honestly, these two made infinitely more sense together than all the carefully laid plans ever did.

I'm also pretty sure Rustler Mountain is the kind of place where absolutely everyone knows your business before you do, and somehow I mean that affectionately. I finished this wanting to go back and meet some of the couples from the earlier books, which feels like a good sign considering I walked into book four completely cold.

This ended up being a cozy cowboy Christmas romance with enough family chaos, slow-burn tension, and holiday sparkle to keep me smiling. It settled into a solid 3.5 stars for me, and next time I'll probably start this series at book one instead of crashing the family reunion halfway through.

Merry Mayhem Prize: For Most Likely to Replace a Carefully Planned Future with One Tattooed Cowboy and a Trick Riding Saddle

And thank you to Kensington Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC. I came for Christmas cowboys and somehow left emotionally invested in a Wild West show, an entire mountain full of family drama, and one spectacularly abandoned life plan.
Profile Image for Heidi Lengenfelder.
685 reviews
October 17, 2026
There is something about a Christmas romance filled with snow, cowboys, complicated families, and two people who absolutely should not be falling for each other that makes for an irresistible holiday read, and Christmas Valley delivers all of that with plenty of heart, heat, and festive charm.

Cassidy Wilder has spent most of her life believing she knows exactly who she wants. Dalton Wade has been the object of her affection for years, and this Christmas, she’s finally ready to stop waiting for him to make the first move and tell him how she feels. It’s a perfectly reasonable plan…until West Hancock gets in the way.

Brooding, tattooed, and firmly on the wrong side of a long-standing family feud, West is pretty much the opposite of the man Cassidy thinks she wants. He’s also about to become part of her extended family, which makes the attraction simmering between them particularly inconvenient. When West begins helping Cassidy train as a trick rider for the Wild West show, proximity has a way of making all those inconvenient feelings impossible to ignore.

I loved the contrast between Cassidy’s longtime idea of love and the connection she develops with West. There’s something incredibly satisfying about watching a character realize that the person she has built up in her imagination might not be the person who truly sees her. West and Cassidy have chemistry from the beginning, but what made their relationship work for me was the emotional connection underneath that attraction. They understand pieces of each other that other people tend to overlook, and their relationship gradually becomes about much more than the fling they try to convince themselves they’re having.

West was especially easy to root for. Beneath the brooding bad-boy exterior is someone carrying his own complicated history and trying to figure out where he belongs. His dynamic with Cassidy has that wonderful combination of tension, vulnerability, banter, and undeniable attraction that makes an opposites-attract romance so much fun.

Rustler Mountain is also a fantastic setting for a Christmas romance. Between the snowy Oregon landscape, Wild West festivities, ranch life, trick riding, family drama, and holiday atmosphere, the town has plenty of personality. Maisey Yates balances the festive elements with deeper themes of belonging, family expectations, old wounds, and realizing that sometimes the life—or person—you thought you wanted isn’t actually the one that makes you happiest.

Christmas Valley is warm, sexy, emotional, and wonderfully festive, with a forbidden-ish romance between two people who make far more sense together than either of them expected. Cassidy may begin Christmas determined to make one lifelong wish come true, but sometimes the best gifts are the ones you never thought to ask for.

A swoony holiday cowboy romance perfect for readers who love opposites attract, family rivalries, forced proximity, small-town Christmas magic, and a brooding tattooed cowboy who turns out to be exactly the right man.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with an advance copy in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Cheri.
2,453 reviews30 followers
September 29, 2026
This was a great wrap-up of the Rustler Mountain series. I love a Christmas romance, and Maisey Yates has a fantastic track record with hers throughout the years. I was looking forward to this one, and it did not disappoint.

The story of Cassidy and West has a lot more trauma than I thought there would be. Which is silly on my part, as I already knew Cassidy was abandoned on her (unknown to her) birth father’s doorstep when she was only nine, only to discover he had died. At least she had three older brothers willing and able to raise her and take care of her. Until she came into their lives, Cassidy’s brothers were wild and always got into trouble, since the town had already labeled them miscreants because of their family name. West was the same. Different family name, same sort of reputation, but he didn’t have brothers to have his back. In fact, it seems nobody ever had West’s back. His parents love him, but are in their own world and aren’t good at being supportive about things they don’t understand. This led to undiagnosed ADHD, which led to trouble in school, and eventually him dropping out.

To put it in simple terms, Cassidy and West are perfect for each other. I love the way their friendship builds, even as they are trying to fight their growing connection. Cassidy is convinced her brother’s best friend is her meant-to-be partner, while West knows he will never be in a relationship. So Cassidy continues to try to deny the chemistry she feels with West. To be fair, she also doesn’t understand the feelings she’s having. And West knows he must leave Cassidy alone so as not to ruin things for his sister, who is now engaged to one of Cassidy’s brothers. The internal struggle is a constant battle for these two. They both feel they cannot be what the other needs, yet they are exactly what the other needs.

Add in the fact that this duo is preparing for West’s family’s Wild West show and have to work very closely together, and this story has a lot of interesting elements. I loved how Cassidy bloomed under West’s tutelage. Not just in her showmanship, but also as an adult. Her brothers have always treated her with kid gloves, which wasn’t fully obvious to Cassidy until she was around West…who didn’t. He knew she was capable and pushed her to stand up for herself. He was never cruel. He could be a jerk, but never cruel. With all their time spent together, Cassidy was seeing firsthand all of the balls West juggled and how hard he worked. On the surface, West is cocky and sure of himself. Cassidy helped him to feel those things on a deeper level.

The way this relationship was erected brick by brick kept me turning pages. I love when the couple doesn’t even realize they are becoming a couple, slowly incorporating into each other’s lives. It’s so organic and real-feeling. This is a wonderful holiday romance that left me with warm fuzzies and a smile.

**I received an ARC of this book courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions expressed in this review are my own and given freely. **
Profile Image for The Lit .
512 reviews36 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 2, 2026
🚨 SPOILER ALERT: READ AT YOUR OWN RISK!
​I am giving Christmas Valley by Maisey Yates an absolute, glowing 5-star review! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
​This festive cowboy romance completely stole my heart from the very first page, making for the ultimate cozy, unputdownable holiday escape on my Kindle screen!
​ARC Disclosure: Thank you to NetGalley and the author for providing an early digital review copy (eARC). All thoughts and reflections shared here are entirely my own.
​The Review
​Christmas Valley delivers a masterful blend of festive small-town charm, deep family dynamics, and a brilliantly structured romance that keeps you completely hooked. Stepping into a well-established world, the narrative perfectly balances a cozy holiday backdrop with complex interpersonal friction. Maisey Yates does an incredible job weaving together a strong sense of community while letting the main characters navigate their intense, personal vulnerabilities. The pacing is absolutely flawless, striking an exquisite balance between lighthearted holiday banter and deep emotional evolution that feels entirely earned. It is a stunning, heartwarming triumph that sets the gold standard for seasonal small-town romance.
​The Good
​So I'm just starting this series on book 4 and I absolutely loved it! Though this can be read like I did, without having read the previous books, it does give spoilers of books 1, 2, and 3—though it only made me want to read them now! In this installment, Cassidy and West take front stage. I'll be honest: I asked for this eARC because the title said "Christmas" and I'm an absolute sucker for Xmas books. This didn't disappoint at all!
​I loved the chemistry and banter between Cass and West, and to be honest, I totally fell for him! The brooding MMC who says he doesn't brood... the one that falls first and harder though he says he will never have a serious relationship... I just loved him from the beginning! Perry was a great sister-in-law to Cass here too, and I loved how Cass is truly grateful for her family. The beginning of each chapter with bits of diaries from the past was a great addition to the story too, and all in all, I just fell for these people! I'm starting the other books asap.
​The Not So Good
​Absolutely nothing could ruin this 5-star joy for me, but sorry, I sort of hated Dalton! I mean... what was that talk? Just... no. That specific interaction definitely had me wanting to shield our main couple, but it only made me root for Cass and West even more!
Profile Image for Rekha O'Sullivan.
1,665 reviews18 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 18, 2026
I have not had a particularly good run with small-town or cowboy romances this year, so believe me when I say that Maisey Yates has restored my faith in the genre with Christmas Valley.

This is the fourth book in the Rustler Mountain series, and after realising I’d somehow missed Lonesome Ridge, I went back and read Jesse Jane Hancock and Flynn Wilder’s story first. I smashed through that in half a day, then spent the other half reading Christmas Valley. I was completely hooked.

This time, we’re following Cassidy Wilder, the youngest of the Wilder siblings. Abandoned by her mother at Rustler Mountain when she was nine years old, on Christmas no less, Cassidy has spent much of her life being protected and somewhat coddled by her three older brothers. Now that they’re all settling down, Cassidy wants happiness of her own, and to her, happiness means stability. Enter her brother’s best friend, Dalton Wade: safe, dependable and exactly the sort of man Cassidy thinks she should want.

Unfortunately for that plan, there’s West Hancock.

West is the town bad boy, part of the Hancock family who run the Wild West show, and trouble with a capital T. When Cassidy begins helping with the show and West trains her in trick riding, the attraction between them becomes increasingly difficult to ignore.

West was easily one of the most compelling characters in the entire series for me. He has ADHD, he knows he is completely fixated on Cassidy, and he’s convinced that if he can just have one night with her, he’ll finally get her out of his system. Meanwhile, Cassidy is determined to pursue the sensible romance she thinks she wants with Dalton.

Naturally, things do not go according to plan.

This brought all the spice, all the swoon and exactly the kind of emotional payoff I want from a romance. Watching Cassidy question what happiness and stability actually mean to her, while West begins to wonder whether what he feels is really just another fixation, made their relationship incredibly satisfying.

I’m genuinely sorry to say goodbye to Rustler Mountain because I’ve grown so fond of these characters. But I cannot wait to see what Maisey Yates does next.

Seriously, Christmas Valley is a great example of just how good small-town and cowboy romance can be when it works.

Five stars. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐
Profile Image for Cathy.
531 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 26, 2026
5 stars!

He couldn’t quite explain it, but there were answers in her to the emptiness inside him.


I’m happy to be back in Rustler Mountain! This is the fourth and last part of the series. And in my opinion, this is the best of the series! This is a sweet and spicy small town romance with lovely little snippets of historical diaries that provide the reader a window to the past.

THE TENSION. Oh, the tension! It was so good!

I loved how West didn’t coddle Cassidy and treat her like a child like everyone else did. She wanted security, safeness, sameness, understandably considering her past. But if everything stays the same, one can’t grow. I loved how West helped Cassidy to grow and be her true self. And Cassidy helped West realize some important things of life too!

West was down bad! He just couldn't to understand why and how, but he had fallen so fast for Cassidy that it was just SO CUTE. He thought that it was because of his ADHD brain - aww, but he just fell in love! Cute cute cute.

I'm AuDHD and I liked the talk about neurodiversity. West had ADHD (and West's mama seemed to be Autistic). I liked how it was talked; it wasn't only bad or good. It produces challenges in one's life, sure, but it also can be strength too.

I was SO HAPPY when there was no stupid conflict. West just realized what he wanted and needed to do, did it and everything was cute, fa-la-la-la-la!

Only thing that bothered me was the ending - I would've loved if we had seen a bit more Cassidy and West together, there could've been an epilogue from their POVs too. But despite that, I loved this book so much.

WHAT TO EXPECT:

Pov: dual, 3rd person
Heat: open doors
Pacing: slowburnish
Communication: healthy communication
Third act:
Ending:

Main characters:
* Age gap
* Alpha Hero
* Boss - employee
* Cowboy
* Good girl - bad boy
* Grumpy - sunshine
* Opposites attract
* Physically very different

What?
* Dirty talk
* Forbidden love
* Forced proximity
* He falls first
* One night stand turned more

Where?
* Small town
* Workplace romance

Drama?
* Difficult past
* Mild love triangle

Other vibes:
* Christmas
* ADHD rep
1,361 reviews35 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 25, 2026
Christmas Valley is the last novel in Maisey Yates' Rustler Mountain series, and it's my favorite novel in the series because who among us hasn't had a long-term secret crush on someone, only to realize later it wasn't love at all? It gets a 5-star rating from this reviewer.

Cassidy, whose sleazy, neglectful mother abandoned her on top of Rustler Mountain, when Cassidy was only 9, and simply left her there alone. not even realizing that Cassidy's father, whom she'd never met, had died. Thankfully, her 3 teenage brothers, who we've met in the previous 3 novels, took her in, cared for, protected and loved her. After the experience of being abandoned, and watching her bothers find their HEA endings, all Cassidy dreamed of was a "snow globe" future--safe, steady and loving with their close family friend, and her not well-hidden secret crush, Dalton. Well, that's all about to change.

Cassidy's sister-in-law, Jessie Jane, will soon be sworn in as Rustler Mountains new mayor, and has to give up doing a trick riding performance in her family's Wild West show, and since she's stretched so thin, Cassidy, also a good rider, volunteers to replace her, which puts her in close contact with Jessie Jane's brother, whose reputation as a love 'em and leave 'em, one night stand, and all-around ne'er do well, and wild man, West, who will have to train Cassidy until he's convinced that she can perform all the required stunt riding maneuvers safely, but what is this sudden sizzle between them?

What follows is one of the most emotionally wrought, angsty novels of self-discovery Ms. Yates has written, as Cassidy and West really get to know and understand one another. As character development and self-realization goes, we get to know these two characters so well that by the end of the novel, you feel as though you've known them personally, and I have to mention that the heat level between these two characters is incendiary. As romance novels go, this one worked for this reader in spades, and I'm happy to recommend it.

I voluntarily read an advanced reader copy of this novel. The opinions stated are my own.
Profile Image for Lacey.
170 reviews1 follower
November 7, 2026
🔎 ARC Book Review

Rustler Mountain #4

@maiseyyates
@kensingtonbooks
@netgalley

Publication Date: September 29th, 2026

My Rating:
🌟 4/5

👀Read if you like
Age Gap
Small Town
Family Feuds

No one would blame Cassidy Wilder if she wasn’t a big fan of Christmas, or of Rustler Mountain. After all, her introduction to the town came the Christmas her mother left her on her father’s doorstep. Yet Cassidy grew to love it all, especially her three protective half-brothers. And this Christmas, she’ll have it all too, if she can make one of her lifelong wishes come true: to marry Dalton Wade.

Sure, Dalton’s had casual affairs over the years, but obviously, with Cassidy he’s too respectful to make the first move. So, she’s finally going to confess her love. There’s just one hitch: brooding, tatted bad boy West Hancock. There’s bad blood between the Wilders and the Hancocks but West is about to be Cassidy’s brother-in-law. He’s the total opposite of the man she’s given her heart to. If only he didn’t ignite . . . other parts of her. Worse, he’s got to help her train as a trick rider for the Wild West show.

🔎 My review
AWW! 🥹❤️ I have thoroughly enjoyed my time in Rustler Mountain, and every time I see another book in this series, I get SO excited! 🤩 Give me small-town romance, cowboy vibes, and characters to fall in love with, and I’m a happy girl! 🤠💕
Just like the others, this one was such a fun story! 🎄✨ While Christmas Valley can be read as a standalone, I definitely think it’s even better if you’ve read the previous books. There’s something special about returning to a town you already love and getting to know more of its people! 🏡📚
I especially loved how Cassidy and West understood each other beyond their family histories and the expectations placed on them. 🥹❤️ They saw each other for who they truly were, rather than who their families expected them to be. And honestly, that kind of connection gets me every time! 🫶💗
Another wonderful visit to Rustler Mountain, and I’m already excited for more! 🤠🎄

Thank you @maiseyyates, @kensingtonbooks
@netgalley for the ARC!

#NetGalley
#ChristmasValley 🎄
#MaiseyYates 📚
#RustlerMountain 🤠
Profile Image for The Sewist's Bookshelf .
738 reviews119 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 28, 2026
⭐ 3
🌶️ 2
🥵 Spicy Chapters: 9, 12, 14, 16, 19
❤️‍🔥 Swoon Factor: 2
👫 Cassidy + West
📚 Tropes/Themes: Age gap, holiday romance, forced proximity, forbidden romance, small town, virgin FMC, forced proximity, family rivalry, ADHD rep
👀 Dual POV 3rd person
💔 Content warnings: past parental abandonment/neglect, family trauma, grief
🎀 Special editions: none

I'm sad that Yates' writing has been so hit or miss for me lately. Maybe I'm just a mood reader when it comes to her books? Usually I really enjoy the introspective monologues but they were just a struggle here. The overarching feeling I have about this book is I needed more from it.

I didn't really get much chemistry between Cassidy and West unfortunately and while there was some characters growth for both of them, it just didn't feel like enough. Maybe that's the point though? But the MCs are both pretty damaged by their pasts/parents that there was a lot of potential there.

And especially with West, I really loved how he was finally able to confront the issues with his parents but it still didn't really feel like much of a resolution beyond "her love healed me", which parallels the journal entries at the beginning of the chapters. Cassidy clearly has trauma to work through but I didn't really see much change with her either.

I wish it had leaned in more to the Christmas part of it being a Christmas romance, and then chapters were really long so there weren't as many journal entries either- plus they switch between Butch and Sarah so there wasn't a satisfying emotional payoff there either. The plot itself is fairly low angst too so that didn't offer much emotional payoff either.

That said, I enjoyed how the epilogue came full circle back to Austin's POV to help finish off the series...but I could've used a check in with the other two couples 😭

I mean, overall the story was enjoyable but like I said, I just wanted MORE
Profile Image for Chelsea.
275 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 8, 2026
'Christmas Valley' gives us the story of Cassidy Wilder, youngest of the Wilder siblings and only girl of the family. Cassidy was abandoned on her brother's doorstep on Christmas morning was she was nine, and her family has never stopped sheltering her, even though she's now a grown woman in her twenties. Cassidy has plans of her own though: get her brother's friend Dalton Wade to realize that they would make a perfect couple and get him to fall for her. When a chance to help her brother's wife presents itself, Cassidy makes a rash offer to take Jessie Jane's spot in the Hancock Wild West show for the Christmas season. The only problem? Cassidy will have to work side by side with the irreverent West Hancock. West has never met a woman that he wanted more than once. He knows that he's not relationship material, so why does Cassie get under his skin so easily? Soon their chemistry is too much to ignore. Cass has to make a decision: continue to pursue Dalton or find out where things might go with West.

This book was the perfect Christmas picture of Rustler Mountain. I loved seeing continuing looks at couples that we grew to know and love in the previous books in the Rustler Mountain series. West and Cassie's chemistry is off the charts hot. I also really loved the ADHD rep in West. His own self-awareness made me really love him all the more, and his slow evolution into a relationship with Cassie was super satisfying to read. I'm really sad that this book probably means the end of reading about the Wilder siblings, but it makes me warm and fuzzy to see them all in amazing relationships. I think that Cassie and West's story may be my favorite of the entire series.

Thank you to NetGalley, Kensington, and Maisey Yates for the eARC of this novel in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Gretchen.
151 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
April 14, 2026
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity ti review the ARC of this book!

4 stars

This book was such a reading journey for me - I never dreamed I would end up giving it 4 stars by the end. If the whole book had been written like the second half (I felt an actual shift in the writing and the story at the literal 50% mark), it would have been a 5-star book. I came into the book not having read the previous three books in the series, so I was not familiar with the cast of characters, but I don’t think that was the issue I had with the start of the book.

The first half felt chaotic. It was a lot of dialog and people and so much happening. Additionally, the writing perspective is third person and alternating chapters are basically in the head of the FMC and MMC. I can’t figure out if the author was trying to depict overly dramatic inner thoughts of these characters or whether the author is just too wordy at times. The FMC is 25 years old but reads as about a 12 year-old. She had a traumatic childhood that mostly ended at age 9 when she was dropped at the door of her (unknown to her, and them) half-brothers. She seems to want people to feel sorry for her over that. And a completely unbelievable aspect is that she is 25 years old, not living any kind of a cloistered life, and she has never kissed anyone.

Then, as I mentioned at the 50% mark, everything smoothed out. The characters were less chaotic and it became an enjoyable typical romance novel. Enemies to lovers (I guess? more like family enemies), forced proximity.

Amazingly seeing how I felt in the first half of the book, I think I will track down the other books in the series.
274 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 29, 2026
Thank you to Kensington and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.

Maisey Yates returns with the fourth novel in the Rustler Mountain series with 'Christmas Valley'. Cassidy Wilder isn't a big fan of Christmas, but this year is going to be different. She is determined to marry Dalton Wade if he would just see her as more than a friend. As they say, the best laid plans often go awry. When her soon to be sister-in-law needs a stand-in for the Hancock Wild West show, Cassidy volunteers. West Hancock, her soon to be brother-in-law is a brooding, tatted bad boy and also her trainer for the trick riding she must perform. There is a spark between them, but Cassidy is committed to the idea of Dalton and what it means to be loved.

West also has a past he would sooner forget and is determined to ignore this spark between them. He is determined to leave the family wild west show and move on to his own ranch. As they agree to this Christmas fling, will they be able to end it or will a Christmas romance be just what their hearts desire?

Cassidy Wilder comes across as childish I believe because of her childhood. Being dropped on her father's doorstep at the age of nine seemed to bring out the protective instincts in her three half brothers who at that stage were running wild as young men. It seems that everyone knows about her crush, including Dalton and he wasn't reciprocating those feelings. She was looking for a HEA with him for safety and to not be left behind. Her half brothers definitely fill the over protective role to a tee. Maisey Yates has a writing style that makes it an easy read that is well paced.



Profile Image for Megan megmakestimetoread .
451 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 15, 2026
This is the fourth novel in the Rustler Mountain series by Maisey Yates. This series had a slightly different tone to each book. The conceit of the Wild West town and the progeny of the OG legends still being shackled by their memory is good. I really like the Hancock family. Jesse Jane's story is in the previous book, Lonesome Ridge, and her elder brother West is seen here. Their parents are very neurodivergent coded (mom- autistic spectrum, dad- ADHD) and there is a sweetness to the family, despite their rough and tumble exteriors.

Cassidy is the youngest member of the Wilder clan. She wears her trauma like a shield, throwing it in people's faces, probably because it has been such a part of her identity within her family. She is so protected, by her brothers, and her own volition, that she fantasizes about life, rather than living it. We have seen her crush on brother's friend Dalton for all 4 books, despite Dalton seeming like a douche if you ask me. In this book we see it is such a childish view of the world- a crush to keep her protected and keep her with her brothers.

West is also dealing with the trauma that comes with his name. He was diagnosed with ADHD late in life and has a lot of shame about his abilities- doing everything to prove to folks that he is worthwhile, while not believing it himself. Yates capital S skirts the line of trauma bonding between these two. But they definitely connect by seeing the truth of one another and not letting the other get away with defining themselves by their worst parts. This was definitely insta-attraction and he falls first and fast, but, in a charming way.

This is a fun and sexy novel for fans of Lyla Sage and the cowboy romance genre. All of the books (except for number 2 which was quite problematic to me) are interesting reads with compelling characters. Yates highlights the BIPOC folks who were left out of the history books (though as side characters). These novels would make great miniseries. 4.25 stars for pure frothy enjoyment. Thanks to net Galley and Kensington Publishing for this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Sarah.
304 reviews56 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 28, 2026
✨ARC Book Review✨

I absolutely loved this novella!

Cassidy has her eyes set on Dalton. She’s known him ever since she was little, and she thinks he’d be the perfect match for her. When she agrees to trick ride for her friend Jessie Jane, she finds herself working directly with West. As they train together, she starts seriously questioning whether she still wants to play it safe or risk her heart on the wildcard, West.

When I was first introduced to West, I just thought he was grumpy, but he never actually said anything out of line. He genuinely cared about Cassidy’s safety while she was performing the tricks, so he agreed to train her. At some point, he notices her crush, and his growing jealousy was absolutely addictive to read. When he finally confronted Cassidy about his feelings, I’m not going to lie, I was already sold on that man. He didn’t care what she wanted from him, he wanted her to choose him.

Cassidy mentally lives in a box. She had a traumatic childhood, so she tries to always make the safe choices, and I completely understand that. No one would blame her for protecting herself. West challenged everything she thought she wanted, making her choose between playing it safe and embracing the raw, undeniable passion she couldn’t ignore.

I absolutely loved this book, and I immediately went to see what else Maisey Yates has written. I’ll definitely be reading more from her!

Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Jennifer Ritter.
1,267 reviews37 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 26, 2026
Christmas Valley is the fourth book in the Rustler Mountain series by Maisey Yates. This novel is centered on Cassidy Wilder, youngest of the siblings and only girl. Now 25, Cassidy sees her brothers all paired off and settled and longs for a relationship of her own. Since a young teen she has fantasized about her brother Flynn’s best friend Dalton Wade, also alone. However, it seems Dalton still sees her as a girl rather than the woman she has become.

While the family is helping out Flynn’s fiancé at the annual Christmas festival, Jessie Jane relates how overwhelmed she is with the transition to take over the mayor’s office in January and doing the Wild West Christmas show at her family’s venue. Wanting to help, Cassidy tells Jessie Jane she would be happy to fill in for her at the show, opening an unexpected path into the Hancock family, once Wilder mortal enemies from the betrayal over 100 years ago.

Before Cassidy begins at the Wild West show, Dalton asks Cassidy to accompany him on an overnight trip to look at some horses he’s interested in. But prior to that trip Cassidy begins working with West Hancock in preparation for the show. As he shows interest and Cassidy gets to know him, conflict arises.

This is a very good story with some powerful messages. The characters are quite well depicted and the eastern Oregon setting is well described. The plot takes unexpected turns exposing the characters thoughts and frailties. I very much enjoyed this book and do recommend it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews