What do you think?
Rate this book
The British Are Coming #6
To Fall in Love at Christmas
A rule-bound heart. A joy-filled pastor. One Christmas that could change everything.
Alice MacPherson came to Idaho with nothing but her nursing skills, her Bible, and the heavy burden of a faith shaped by her father’s endless rules. Raised to believe beauty, celebration, and even Christmas traditions were distractions from true devotion, she expects nothing more from life than hard work and quiet duty.
Reverend Truman Blankenship has spent five years shepherding the people of Gibeon with steady faith and a joyful heart. Especially at Christmastime, he delights in filling the church and parsonage with greenery, laughter, and celebration—traditions that seem to puzzle the serious young nurse more than he cares to admit.
Thrown together in the homes of the sick, in the bustle of the town’s Christmas preparations, and in the laughter of children rehearsing a nativity play, Truman and Alice discover an unexpected attraction. But as Christmas draws near, Alice must confront the demands of her father and the fears and expectations that have shaped her life for far too long.
To Fall in Love at Christmas is a tender Christian historical romance filled with faith, hope, healing, and the joy of hearts transformed by love.
Alice MacPherson came to Idaho with nothing but her nursing skills, her Bible, and the heavy burden of a faith shaped by her father’s endless rules. Raised to believe beauty, celebration, and even Christmas traditions were distractions from true devotion, she expects nothing more from life than hard work and quiet duty.
Reverend Truman Blankenship has spent five years shepherding the people of Gibeon with steady faith and a joyful heart. Especially at Christmastime, he delights in filling the church and parsonage with greenery, laughter, and celebration—traditions that seem to puzzle the serious young nurse more than he cares to admit.
Thrown together in the homes of the sick, in the bustle of the town’s Christmas preparations, and in the laughter of children rehearsing a nativity play, Truman and Alice discover an unexpected attraction. But as Christmas draws near, Alice must confront the demands of her father and the fears and expectations that have shaped her life for far too long.
To Fall in Love at Christmas is a tender Christian historical romance filled with faith, hope, healing, and the joy of hearts transformed by love.
249 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 8, 2026
About the author
Robin Lee Hatcher
162 books3,320 followersRobin Lee Hatcher is the author of over 95 novels and novellas with more than five million copies of her books in print. She is known for her heartwarming and emotionally charged stories of faith, courage, and love. Her numerous awards include the RITA® Award, Christy Award, Carol Award, HOLT Medallion, National Reader’s Choice Award, and the Faith, Hope & Love Reader’s Choice Award, and she is also the recipient of prestigious Lifetime Achievement Awards from both American Christian Fiction Writers and Romance Writers of America®. When not writing, she enjoys being with her family, spending time in the beautiful Idaho outdoors, Bible art journaling, reading books that make her cry, watching romantic movies, and decorative planning. A mother and grandmother, Robin makes her home on the outskirts of Boise, sharing it with a demanding Papillon dog.
Be sure to follow Robin on BookBub so you'll receive new book and special deal alerts:
https://www.bookbub.com/profile/robin...
Be sure to follow Robin on BookBub so you'll receive new book and special deal alerts:
https://www.bookbub.com/profile/robin...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
Read
May 24, 2026Truman took his profession very seriously. He loved his congregation. He served GOD with all his heart. But he felt something was missing. A wife. But who would marry a simple man like him?
Young Alice arrived in town to be Dr. Grant's nurse. She had experience as she worked at a hospital in Calgary, Canada. She had no contact with her father and brothers. Her father was cold and distant. She always felt lacking in his presence. He drained every bit of happiness from her.
Truman and his family demonstrated to Alice the true meaning of family and Christmas.
I enjoyed the book. Truman was a catch. All the mothers with eligible daughters knew that. But did Alice?
Young Alice arrived in town to be Dr. Grant's nurse. She had experience as she worked at a hospital in Calgary, Canada. She had no contact with her father and brothers. Her father was cold and distant. She always felt lacking in his presence. He drained every bit of happiness from her.
Truman and his family demonstrated to Alice the true meaning of family and Christmas.
I enjoyed the book. Truman was a catch. All the mothers with eligible daughters knew that. But did Alice?
Read
May 23, 2026I throughly enjoyed this book. Robin Lee Hatcher writes a book that keeps you waiting to turn to the page with Faith, Hope, Healing and love. Loved her Characters PastorTruman and Alice.
Read
July 13, 2026The audiobook just released, so I have to give it a listen. What a great job Ann Marie Gideon has done, narrating these six books in the series.
July 13, 2026
gets better every time
You won’t be able to put this book down once you start it. It is a wonderful story of love.
You won’t be able to put this book down once you start it. It is a wonderful story of love.
August 18, 2026
Robin Lee Hatcher puts a splash in the holiday season with To Fall in Love at Christmas, the 6th installment of Ms. Hatcher’s The British Are Coming series. To Fall in Love at Christmas tells the story of Gibeon, Idaho’s reverend, Truman Blankenship and new town nurse, Alice MacPherson, in 1897. Canadian-born-and-raised, Alice is thankful for the opportunity to serve the community of Gibeon to the best of her ability. After 6 years of being a Minister, mostly for the people of Gibeon, Truman is happy with his life, but wishes he had a wife to share his life with. Because of their respective lines of work, Alice and Truman are often in the same places. Truman is taken with Gibeon’s new nurse, but senses that something is holding Alice back in life and treads gently. Alice was raised very strictly and to believe the notion that God is full of rules that must be followed to a ‘T’. As Alice gets acclimated to life in Gibeon and it’s people, Alice quickly notices the God that most people believe in in Gibeon is different than what she was raised to believe. Alice is baffled that Gibeon’s Minister is interested in her, but agrees to let Truman court her. As Christmas approaches, Alice and Truman realize their love for one another. When Alice’s Father makes a surprise visit to Gibeon, it could threaten everything Alice has begun to build with God.
I love To Fall in Love at Christmas by Robin Lee Hatcher! Ms. Hatcher wrote To Fall in Love at Christmas in the style that I have come to know and love about a Robin Lee Hatcher book, but with a twist of something that I needed to be reminded of. I loved meeting Truman and Alice! I like how Alice and Truman were different, but in the things that matter, they were on the same page. I really connected with Alice because there was a season in my life where I was taught rigid beliefs in Christianity that, looking back, really didn’t need to be there. I love how Truman took his time getting to know Alice, especially when he saw her Spiritual struggles. I love the conversations that Alice and Truman had about the things of God and how Alice allowed the Lord to work in her life because of them. I also loved how the town of Gibeon fell in love with Alice and how Alice was able to see the difference between how Christians are meant to be and what she was raised to believe. I love how even though Alice got discouraged at times with what she was learning about God, compared to how she was raised to believe about God, she continually sought the Lord for direction. I was very thankful that Truman stood by Alice through it all—it definitely made for a sweet relationship! To me, Alice’s questions and the conversations she had about the things she was pondering about God illustrated an authentic relationship with God, the type of relationship with God that you don’t throw away just because you have doubts and questions because more of His Character is being revealed to you, but the relationship you hold onto no matter the cost. I loved the picturesque Christmas feels that were happening in Gibeon and how Ms. Hatcher depicted the True Meaning of Christmas in the book! I believe To Fall in Love at Christmas is a great read for Christmas that will help us to remember the True Meaning of all! I highly recommend To Fall in Love at Christmas by Robin Lee Hatcher!
Have you read To Fall in Love at Christmas? What did you think of the book?
I would like to thank Robin Lee Hatcher for giving me a copy of To Fall in Love at Christmas to review and for letting me be on the Advance Reviewer Team for To Fall in Love at Christmas. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I love To Fall in Love at Christmas by Robin Lee Hatcher! Ms. Hatcher wrote To Fall in Love at Christmas in the style that I have come to know and love about a Robin Lee Hatcher book, but with a twist of something that I needed to be reminded of. I loved meeting Truman and Alice! I like how Alice and Truman were different, but in the things that matter, they were on the same page. I really connected with Alice because there was a season in my life where I was taught rigid beliefs in Christianity that, looking back, really didn’t need to be there. I love how Truman took his time getting to know Alice, especially when he saw her Spiritual struggles. I love the conversations that Alice and Truman had about the things of God and how Alice allowed the Lord to work in her life because of them. I also loved how the town of Gibeon fell in love with Alice and how Alice was able to see the difference between how Christians are meant to be and what she was raised to believe. I love how even though Alice got discouraged at times with what she was learning about God, compared to how she was raised to believe about God, she continually sought the Lord for direction. I was very thankful that Truman stood by Alice through it all—it definitely made for a sweet relationship! To me, Alice’s questions and the conversations she had about the things she was pondering about God illustrated an authentic relationship with God, the type of relationship with God that you don’t throw away just because you have doubts and questions because more of His Character is being revealed to you, but the relationship you hold onto no matter the cost. I loved the picturesque Christmas feels that were happening in Gibeon and how Ms. Hatcher depicted the True Meaning of Christmas in the book! I believe To Fall in Love at Christmas is a great read for Christmas that will help us to remember the True Meaning of all! I highly recommend To Fall in Love at Christmas by Robin Lee Hatcher!
Have you read To Fall in Love at Christmas? What did you think of the book?
I would like to thank Robin Lee Hatcher for giving me a copy of To Fall in Love at Christmas to review and for letting me be on the Advance Reviewer Team for To Fall in Love at Christmas. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 8, 2026
I’m not prepared to say goodbye again to the folks from The British Are Coming. I guess I didn’t realize that this book was coming soon when I thought I’d finished up the series earlier this year. I probably did know, but well, memory is fading faster than the water going out before a tsunami. But the timing of this book was perfect as it’s super hot right now and I thought I’d do a little Christmas in July this month to maybe feel the cool of snow that comes with Christmas. For all those reasons, and more, Robin Lee Hatcher hit all the right Christmas in July marks with a lot of snow, some super cold, some decent follow-up with some of the previous folks, and Truman. Poor Truman thinks he’s found love so many times just to be beaten out by someone else’s true love.
Let’s talk romance, as we know that’s my favorite topic and, well, the core theme of the book. If I’m being real, this completely vibes of instalove. And while that bothered me, there’s something bigger at play that makes the instalove feel less believable. I can typically forgive the insta vibe in a historical novel, as the life and times were different. Marriage was for life, and life, many times, required a partnership. You found compatibility, and you ran with it. Where my problem lies is with Alice’s trauma. Gravy, that girl has a lot of trauma from her father. I would love to see more about how she works through that, as God can heal, but it still requires personal work to maintain and overcome. She started the courting request by saying yes, but we will not suit, because trauma. It honestly felt too simple for her to go from the life and feels she had to say yes let’s get married tomorrow (OK, not really tomorrow but super quick). And while trauma doesn’t bother me in my stories, it gives a reason that is human, but it does bother me when it’s too easily wrapped up, and you don’t get to feel the resolution.
However, the hidden star here for me is Dilby Marks. First, that name, Dilby, what a name. But second, he’s got a story to tell; I just know it. I mean, he may not belong in this series unless there’s yet another lady from The Continent for him, but he has a story to tell. A rich history of love and loss, but he’s also got a come-to-Jesus moment to come, and I’m all in to read his story. Just my own opinion and a strong hint 😀 Overall, To Fall in Love at Christmas was a perfect July read. I got snow in a heatwave, some Jesus love and redemption, and Truman gets the girl . . . finally! But hint, hint, Dilby.
I was provided a complimentary copy of this book by BookSirens. I was not compensated for this review and all thoughts and opinions expressed are my own. I was not required to write a positive review.
Originally published at https://fizzypopcollection.com/book-r...
Let’s talk romance, as we know that’s my favorite topic and, well, the core theme of the book. If I’m being real, this completely vibes of instalove. And while that bothered me, there’s something bigger at play that makes the instalove feel less believable. I can typically forgive the insta vibe in a historical novel, as the life and times were different. Marriage was for life, and life, many times, required a partnership. You found compatibility, and you ran with it. Where my problem lies is with Alice’s trauma. Gravy, that girl has a lot of trauma from her father. I would love to see more about how she works through that, as God can heal, but it still requires personal work to maintain and overcome. She started the courting request by saying yes, but we will not suit, because trauma. It honestly felt too simple for her to go from the life and feels she had to say yes let’s get married tomorrow (OK, not really tomorrow but super quick). And while trauma doesn’t bother me in my stories, it gives a reason that is human, but it does bother me when it’s too easily wrapped up, and you don’t get to feel the resolution.
However, the hidden star here for me is Dilby Marks. First, that name, Dilby, what a name. But second, he’s got a story to tell; I just know it. I mean, he may not belong in this series unless there’s yet another lady from The Continent for him, but he has a story to tell. A rich history of love and loss, but he’s also got a come-to-Jesus moment to come, and I’m all in to read his story. Just my own opinion and a strong hint 😀 Overall, To Fall in Love at Christmas was a perfect July read. I got snow in a heatwave, some Jesus love and redemption, and Truman gets the girl . . . finally! But hint, hint, Dilby.
I was provided a complimentary copy of this book by BookSirens. I was not compensated for this review and all thoughts and opinions expressed are my own. I was not required to write a positive review.
Originally published at https://fizzypopcollection.com/book-r...
Review of advance copy received from Author
SPOILER ALERT "To Fall in Love at Christmas" had me falling in love with Gibeon, Idaho and remembering how well I loved those who reappeared from Eden's Gate featured in previous books in this series. This book, while the last book in a 6 part series, can be read as a stand alone. Truman's story about finding a match in nurse Alice was endearing, inspiring and made me feel like Christmas in July(or late May when I read an advanced reader copy)!!!! Truman was a man God used to save people spiritually and Alice was used to save people physically. As a fellow nurse, I enjoyed seeing her commitment to order and compassionate care mixed with skillful practice. While an unlikely match it seemed at first, as each page turned, they could not have been better suited to serve alongside one another. When Alice wrestled with voices from her upbringing- namely her own father and his disapproval, yearned for her mom and missed her twin brothers, to how she felt about experiencing joy and decorating, especially at Christmastime, to having dressmaker Nancy make the loveliest green gown with lace, to Truman's parents arriving in Gibeon and being so supportive and falling in love with Alice, to when Dilby joined the Christmas Social and sat alongside Alice and was sober, to when Camden arrived and voiced his contempt, disdainment and disowning of Alice, to Truman fighting for Allice in front of her father and congregation, to their wedding day...I felt the emotion leap from every page. I could envision the green fabric of the dress and the soft sway. I could feel the crispness of the snow and bite in the air; picture the 3 snowmen and the red scarf, and smell Thanksgiving dinner and the beef stew prepared by Chuck at Eden's Gate. A smile crossed my face as Keely let out her exuberance of a new little one and a chuckle escaped as Nora busted Lenny's nose after one too many shoves. Faith was on display where even the pastor displayed steadiness, kindness and "did not shy away from naming sin for what it was, but his gentleness bore witness to a deeper truth. God's grace was for everyone, even the hardest of hearts." Alice learned the true meaning of love in Gibeon and found the friendships and acceptance she always searched for, and I can't help but think Mrs. MacPherson was beaming with pride down from heaven celebrating her daughter's strength and happiness.
I received an Advanced Reader Copy and these views are solely my own.
I received an Advanced Reader Copy and these views are solely my own.
July 3, 2026
“You fought for me.” Wonder filled her voice. “You stood up for me to my father. No one else has done that. Not even my mother. Not the way you did.” “I will always stand up for you, Alice. With anyone. If you will let me.”
Christmas in July? Yes, please!! I absolutely loved this western Christmas story. It’s filled with cozy moments with friends and family, faith, community, and a sweet romance. I loved the themes of God’s love and His healing work.
Truman is gentle, caring, and devoted. His love for the people of Gibeon was evident in everything he did. I loved how he listened, challenged, and encouraged Alice. I loved how he accepted and loved her. And his family! What a delight! Alice is dedicated, intelligent, and kind. Her mental battle of believing her father’s judgmental words or her mother’s loving, faith filled words was heartbreaking at times. I loved the growth and healing she experienced. I loved that she listened to Truman and watched the people of Gibeon. I loved watching her realize that maybe the harsh, strict way she was raised to believe wasn’t the only way to worship and honor God. I loved her gradual softening and the beautiful friendships she had. I loved the honest conversations with Truman and the sweet love they found together.
A few more quotes:
“Isn’t that a wondrous thought?” he continued. “The Almighty, who spoke the stars into being, rejoices over us. Not because we are perfect. Not because we’ve earned it. But because we belong to Him.”
“Gratitude,” he continued, “is not found when life is easy. It is chosen. It is lifted up like a lamp in the dark.”
⛪️ He didn’t serve because it was his job. He served because it was his heart.
Note: This is book 6 in The British Are Coming series. It can definitely be enjoyed as a standalone, a few couples from previous books appear and there are “updates” on others.
This complimentary copy was provided by the author. I was not required to give a positive review, rating and opinions are my own.
Christmas in July? Yes, please!! I absolutely loved this western Christmas story. It’s filled with cozy moments with friends and family, faith, community, and a sweet romance. I loved the themes of God’s love and His healing work.
Truman is gentle, caring, and devoted. His love for the people of Gibeon was evident in everything he did. I loved how he listened, challenged, and encouraged Alice. I loved how he accepted and loved her. And his family! What a delight! Alice is dedicated, intelligent, and kind. Her mental battle of believing her father’s judgmental words or her mother’s loving, faith filled words was heartbreaking at times. I loved the growth and healing she experienced. I loved that she listened to Truman and watched the people of Gibeon. I loved watching her realize that maybe the harsh, strict way she was raised to believe wasn’t the only way to worship and honor God. I loved her gradual softening and the beautiful friendships she had. I loved the honest conversations with Truman and the sweet love they found together.
A few more quotes:
“Isn’t that a wondrous thought?” he continued. “The Almighty, who spoke the stars into being, rejoices over us. Not because we are perfect. Not because we’ve earned it. But because we belong to Him.”
“Gratitude,” he continued, “is not found when life is easy. It is chosen. It is lifted up like a lamp in the dark.”
⛪️ He didn’t serve because it was his job. He served because it was his heart.
Note: This is book 6 in The British Are Coming series. It can definitely be enjoyed as a standalone, a few couples from previous books appear and there are “updates” on others.
This complimentary copy was provided by the author. I was not required to give a positive review, rating and opinions are my own.
July 10, 2026
To Fall in Love at Christmas is the sixth book in The British Are Coming series and is a sweet, thoughtful romance about a young but wise reverend and a capable, kind-hearted nurse with a painful past who find love at Christmastime. Although it seemed like it would be a straightforward romance at first, it unfolded into a deeper, thought-provoking story that gave me all the romantic fireworks while also leaving me reflecting on its themes.
Alice was incredibly relatable. The pain she carried from her past, especially because of her harsh and judgmental father, was portrayed with such honesty that I found myself wondering how she would ever break free from his hold. I also appreciated the way the story explored her struggle between trying to be the good Christian daughter her father expected and becoming the woman she longed to be but scarcely dared to imagine.
Truman was the perfect hero for her. He was bold, kind, wise, and human enough to love Alice with all her fears and past trauma. I especially admired his humility and his willingness to serve everyone in the community without expecting anything in return.
I'm a sucker for small-town romances, and I loved this community. The way the townspeople welcomed Alice made the setting feel warm and inviting, and of course, the small-town gossip was delightful. After all, a reverend and a nurse spending so much time together is bound to get people talking!
It was also a pleasure to spend time again with familiar characters from To Find Where She Belongs, especially William, Roger, Victoria, and of course, Keely. I still can't get over her saying, "Sweet suffering cats." Lol.
It's sad to see this series come to an end, but I truly enjoyed spending time with these characters. If you enjoy small-town romances featuring kind, resilient heroines, thoughtful heroes, and stories about healing, faith, and second chances, with a generous helping of good-natured small-town gossip, I highly recommend this book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Alice was incredibly relatable. The pain she carried from her past, especially because of her harsh and judgmental father, was portrayed with such honesty that I found myself wondering how she would ever break free from his hold. I also appreciated the way the story explored her struggle between trying to be the good Christian daughter her father expected and becoming the woman she longed to be but scarcely dared to imagine.
Truman was the perfect hero for her. He was bold, kind, wise, and human enough to love Alice with all her fears and past trauma. I especially admired his humility and his willingness to serve everyone in the community without expecting anything in return.
I'm a sucker for small-town romances, and I loved this community. The way the townspeople welcomed Alice made the setting feel warm and inviting, and of course, the small-town gossip was delightful. After all, a reverend and a nurse spending so much time together is bound to get people talking!
It was also a pleasure to spend time again with familiar characters from To Find Where She Belongs, especially William, Roger, Victoria, and of course, Keely. I still can't get over her saying, "Sweet suffering cats." Lol.
It's sad to see this series come to an end, but I truly enjoyed spending time with these characters. If you enjoy small-town romances featuring kind, resilient heroines, thoughtful heroes, and stories about healing, faith, and second chances, with a generous helping of good-natured small-town gossip, I highly recommend this book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Received this book as an ARC through BookSirens/author.
Sometimes the quiet stories just sit right with a reader.
A young Pastor has been in the church for six years, and obviously cares for each member of the community, regardless of their attendance at church. He lends his hands and strength to far more than simply the duties of the ministry.
A young woman arrives as the nurse to assist the local Doctor. She is well trained and efficient, but carries the weight of her upbringing — most especially her father’s disapproval of not only her actions, but of herself as a person. It was only her mother’s intervention that allowed her to take her nursing training at all.
With the death of her mother during her training, she had nothing left at home, and buried herself in her duties as a nurse.
Surprising them both, a spark forms between the Pastor and the Nurse, but neither are brave enough to admit it aloud. Her father’s voice in her head threatens to undo all the joy that she sees in the young man, and adding to her pain, a letter arrives from him, demanding she return home.
Will their love be realized or squashed before it is allowed to blossom?
Will all the years of verbal abuse from her father cause her to deny her right to happiness?
Read through the book and reap the benefits of the thoughts that she struggles with as she tries to sort through the truth from the judgement.
Sometimes the quiet stories just sit right with a reader.
A young Pastor has been in the church for six years, and obviously cares for each member of the community, regardless of their attendance at church. He lends his hands and strength to far more than simply the duties of the ministry.
A young woman arrives as the nurse to assist the local Doctor. She is well trained and efficient, but carries the weight of her upbringing — most especially her father’s disapproval of not only her actions, but of herself as a person. It was only her mother’s intervention that allowed her to take her nursing training at all.
With the death of her mother during her training, she had nothing left at home, and buried herself in her duties as a nurse.
Surprising them both, a spark forms between the Pastor and the Nurse, but neither are brave enough to admit it aloud. Her father’s voice in her head threatens to undo all the joy that she sees in the young man, and adding to her pain, a letter arrives from him, demanding she return home.
Will their love be realized or squashed before it is allowed to blossom?
Will all the years of verbal abuse from her father cause her to deny her right to happiness?
Read through the book and reap the benefits of the thoughts that she struggles with as she tries to sort through the truth from the judgement.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I definitely fell in love at Christmas myself! Although this story was the last one in the series, it included updates on the previous couples, and I thoroughly enjoyed that aspect!
At first glance, Truman and Alice would seem complete opposites. Truman is the pastor of the town of Gibeon, Idaho. He loves everyone in the town, he serves everyone whether they attend church or not and even though he's young, he's wise, kind and thoughtful. Alice, on the other hand, grew up in a home that was ruled by the iron fist of her father and taught that there wasn't joy in going to church plus her father felt that she was useless, so she's always tried to blend in and not bring attention to herself. She has become a nurse and loves the work, but her father didn't agree to that vocation either. She wishes her mother was still alive and misses her.
I really enjoyed how Truman brought Alice out of her shell just by "seeing her" and showing her the joy of God's love, especially at Christmas. The townspeople also show Alice the value of friendship and love. It brings to mind how important it is to show people in your own life that they are seen and heard. This was a touching story and one that can be read any time of the year.
At first glance, Truman and Alice would seem complete opposites. Truman is the pastor of the town of Gibeon, Idaho. He loves everyone in the town, he serves everyone whether they attend church or not and even though he's young, he's wise, kind and thoughtful. Alice, on the other hand, grew up in a home that was ruled by the iron fist of her father and taught that there wasn't joy in going to church plus her father felt that she was useless, so she's always tried to blend in and not bring attention to herself. She has become a nurse and loves the work, but her father didn't agree to that vocation either. She wishes her mother was still alive and misses her.
I really enjoyed how Truman brought Alice out of her shell just by "seeing her" and showing her the joy of God's love, especially at Christmas. The townspeople also show Alice the value of friendship and love. It brings to mind how important it is to show people in your own life that they are seen and heard. This was a touching story and one that can be read any time of the year.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I found this to be a refreshing read; gentle hearts and souls helping others while desiring to please God. Truman may be young for a pastor, but he has a heart of gold full of kindness, compassion, and desire to see souls brought to Christ. His friendship with the unlikable Dilby Marks softened the man’s heart toward to Christ more than any harsh words about his sin would have.
Alice is so devoted to serving others and to the Lord but has a heart full of doubts because of her extreme upbringing. Her father was a hard-hearted self-righteous man, and I must admit that I didn’t like him. But Alice’s desire for his salvation and her compassion in dealing with him shows how the love of God can shine through His children.
I was cheering for Truman when Alice accepted his courtship and then was urging her to let him have her heart. It was a great story with lots of Christmas goodness thrown in, especially of how we need Christ in our lives, not just at Christmas. It was a sweet, gentle love story that will stay with you. It is also bittersweet because it is the end of this series but a wonderfully fulfilling conclusion.
I received a complimentary copy from the author and these are my voluntary and honest opinions. I was not required to leave a positive review.
Alice is so devoted to serving others and to the Lord but has a heart full of doubts because of her extreme upbringing. Her father was a hard-hearted self-righteous man, and I must admit that I didn’t like him. But Alice’s desire for his salvation and her compassion in dealing with him shows how the love of God can shine through His children.
I was cheering for Truman when Alice accepted his courtship and then was urging her to let him have her heart. It was a great story with lots of Christmas goodness thrown in, especially of how we need Christ in our lives, not just at Christmas. It was a sweet, gentle love story that will stay with you. It is also bittersweet because it is the end of this series but a wonderfully fulfilling conclusion.
I received a complimentary copy from the author and these are my voluntary and honest opinions. I was not required to leave a positive review.
Review of advance copy
Alice MacPherson leaves home and her demanding father to find her own way using her nursing skills to aid others. She ends up in Gibeon where she meets Rev. Truman Blankenship who has been shepherding the people of Gibeon for five years. He has a more lighthearted way of looking at life’s situations than the serious-minded young nurse has. His method of celebrating Christmas fills the church with greenery and laughter along with a pageant that is not exactly traditional. It surprises Alice, but then she looks closer at what faith and Christmas means to this religious leader, and she comes to see his point of view. And when her father shows up unexpectedly in Gibeon to demand that she honor him and return home to care for him and his house, Truman’s response to her father astonishes her. This Christmas tale is delightful at any time of the year. The two main protagonists are wonderful characters. Their personalities are skillfully developed, as is their growing friendship with each other. Christian beliefs are adeptly and seamlessly woven into the story. The writing is quite good, illustrating how faith combines hope and healing into joy.
I received a free copy of this book through BookSirens and am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received a free copy of this book through BookSirens and am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Reverend Truman Blankenship has been the pastor in Gibeon, a small eastern Idaho town, for the last five years. Truman loves his congregation, praying for them daily and lending a hand where needed. While visiting a sick boy, Truman encounters the new nurse, a very serious Alice MacPherson.
Growing up in a home full of joy during the holidays, Truman wants to share the same with his flock. When the ladies of the church suggest more than a simple Christmas service, they have his full support. Alice, however, was raised in a strict household and taught that celebrating the season was meant to be solemn, not filled with decorations.
To Fall In Love At Christmas is the sixth and final book of The British Are Coming by Robin Lee Hatcher. I loved Truman's story. I don't recall reading many books that show romance through the eyes of a pastor. As with the others in this series, the setting is beautiful. I can't imagine going about everyday activities in that much snow. I'm sad to see it end, but I'm looking forward to seeing what is next from this author.
I received a free copy of this book. I volunteered to read it and write a review.
Growing up in a home full of joy during the holidays, Truman wants to share the same with his flock. When the ladies of the church suggest more than a simple Christmas service, they have his full support. Alice, however, was raised in a strict household and taught that celebrating the season was meant to be solemn, not filled with decorations.
To Fall In Love At Christmas is the sixth and final book of The British Are Coming by Robin Lee Hatcher. I loved Truman's story. I don't recall reading many books that show romance through the eyes of a pastor. As with the others in this series, the setting is beautiful. I can't imagine going about everyday activities in that much snow. I'm sad to see it end, but I'm looking forward to seeing what is next from this author.
I received a free copy of this book. I volunteered to read it and write a review.
July 9, 2026
The inspirational love and joy of God
Alice meets Pastor Truman while nursing a critically ill little boy soon after arriving in Gibeon.
The differences in the outlook of the characters is well-documented: Alice’s lifestyle has been strongly influenced by a strict father who judges light-hearted activities, love and joy as frivolous. Truman’s sermons, on the other hand, reflect his gentle personality, as he preaches about God’s love, grace and acceptance of human faults, resulting in Alice beginning to question everything she has been taught and the sincere offer of gentle love and acceptance by Truman, his family and the community of Gibeon, eventually convince her to believe in a merciful God.
The narrative flows easily with Ms Hatcher’s excellent character portrayal--this reader even accepts Dilby Marks as an individual to be pitied as a victim of circumstance! Although this is part of a series, and characters from previous books are featured, this captivating story is complete in its own right. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Alice meets Pastor Truman while nursing a critically ill little boy soon after arriving in Gibeon.
The differences in the outlook of the characters is well-documented: Alice’s lifestyle has been strongly influenced by a strict father who judges light-hearted activities, love and joy as frivolous. Truman’s sermons, on the other hand, reflect his gentle personality, as he preaches about God’s love, grace and acceptance of human faults, resulting in Alice beginning to question everything she has been taught and the sincere offer of gentle love and acceptance by Truman, his family and the community of Gibeon, eventually convince her to believe in a merciful God.
The narrative flows easily with Ms Hatcher’s excellent character portrayal--this reader even accepts Dilby Marks as an individual to be pitied as a victim of circumstance! Although this is part of a series, and characters from previous books are featured, this captivating story is complete in its own right. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Alice MacPherson came to town with her Bible, her nursing skills, and a heart that knows how to serve faithfully. She is careful. Tender. Capable. Sincere. The kind of woman who has learned to carry much quietly and keep walking forward.
Then Reverend Truman Blankenship steps onto the page with warmth, wisdom, and a shepherd’s heart. Truman’s faith has substance. His joy has Scripture beneath it. His ministry has prayer all through it. Before the day begins, he whispers, “Lord, put a guard over my heart and my mouth today,” and that one prayer told me so much about the man he is.
He wants his words surrendered. His heart guarded. His calling used well for the glory of God.
As a young man, when he recognized the Lord’s call upon his life, “he’d offered that natural ability back to God, determined to use it well, to sharpen it with prayer and study and practice.” That is Truman. A man who takes what God has given and lays it back before Him. And because he has received from the Lord’s abundance, “Now he could bless another because of the abundance.”
This romance is tender, but the tenderness reaches deeper than attraction. It is in the way Truman sees Alice. It is in the way Alice begins to understand joy as something holy and beautiful. It is in the way Christmas fills the town with celebration that keeps pointing back to Christ.
Robin Lee Hatcher gives this story such a lovely spiritual warmth. The Almighty rejoices over His people because they belong to Him. That truth glows through these pages.
Alice’s heart begins opening to a fuller understanding of God’s kindness. Truman’s love grows with patience and honor. The town of Gibeon feels alive with community, service, laughter, illness, prayer, Scripture, and Christmas hope.
I loved the setting.
I loved the characters.
I loved the clear Christian faith.
I loved the way this story holds reverence and gladness together so beautifully.
To Fall in Love at Christmas is a tender Christian historical romance filled with grace, healing, holy joy, and the quiet wonder of being loved by God.
A Christmas story with Scripture in its bones. A romance with prayer in its heartbeat. A reminder that belonging to Christ makes joy shine brighter.
I received a digital ARC of this book from the author via BookSirens. I was not required to write a positive review and was not compensated in any way. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own and reflect my honest evaluation of the writing, content, and narration.
Then Reverend Truman Blankenship steps onto the page with warmth, wisdom, and a shepherd’s heart. Truman’s faith has substance. His joy has Scripture beneath it. His ministry has prayer all through it. Before the day begins, he whispers, “Lord, put a guard over my heart and my mouth today,” and that one prayer told me so much about the man he is.
He wants his words surrendered. His heart guarded. His calling used well for the glory of God.
As a young man, when he recognized the Lord’s call upon his life, “he’d offered that natural ability back to God, determined to use it well, to sharpen it with prayer and study and practice.” That is Truman. A man who takes what God has given and lays it back before Him. And because he has received from the Lord’s abundance, “Now he could bless another because of the abundance.”
This romance is tender, but the tenderness reaches deeper than attraction. It is in the way Truman sees Alice. It is in the way Alice begins to understand joy as something holy and beautiful. It is in the way Christmas fills the town with celebration that keeps pointing back to Christ.
Robin Lee Hatcher gives this story such a lovely spiritual warmth. The Almighty rejoices over His people because they belong to Him. That truth glows through these pages.
Alice’s heart begins opening to a fuller understanding of God’s kindness. Truman’s love grows with patience and honor. The town of Gibeon feels alive with community, service, laughter, illness, prayer, Scripture, and Christmas hope.
I loved the setting.
I loved the characters.
I loved the clear Christian faith.
I loved the way this story holds reverence and gladness together so beautifully.
To Fall in Love at Christmas is a tender Christian historical romance filled with grace, healing, holy joy, and the quiet wonder of being loved by God.
A Christmas story with Scripture in its bones. A romance with prayer in its heartbeat. A reminder that belonging to Christ makes joy shine brighter.
I received a digital ARC of this book from the author via BookSirens. I was not required to write a positive review and was not compensated in any way. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own and reflect my honest evaluation of the writing, content, and narration.
July 10, 2026
I loved this sweet love story set in a frontier town in Idaho. Truman, a young reverend with a small flock, shepherds his congregation with wisdom and love, always willing to lend a helping hand to those in need. Alice is a nurse from Canada who answered an ad from a country doctor in the remote Idaho backcountry. Leaving her medical missionary friends, she is new to the little town of Gibeon. Raised by a harsh and unloving father, Alice has built a shell around her heart. Can these two find love and a HEA?
I really enjoyed the descriptions of the townspeople and felt like they were old friends by the time I finished this book. Alice really resonated with me as she faces her doubts and the hurts frim her childhood upbringing. Truman was tender and lovable and a perfect match for her. From the rambunctious town kids to the gruff old hermit hiding in his house, this town charmed me and I was sad to see the book end. Luckily I have not read the earlier books in the series, so I am off to see what I missed!
I read an advance copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I really enjoyed the descriptions of the townspeople and felt like they were old friends by the time I finished this book. Alice really resonated with me as she faces her doubts and the hurts frim her childhood upbringing. Truman was tender and lovable and a perfect match for her. From the rambunctious town kids to the gruff old hermit hiding in his house, this town charmed me and I was sad to see the book end. Luckily I have not read the earlier books in the series, so I am off to see what I missed!
I read an advance copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Review of advance copy
This is a clean historical romance.
Alice arrives in Gibeon, Idaho as a nurse. Truman is the local reverend. They keep getting thrown together as they are visiting the same people. Her for their physical health and he for their spiritual health. She's always been told by her father the way church should be held and how people should act. Truman is very lighthearted and is approached to hold a Christmas pageant. Alice doesn't agree with that. But can he change her mind? Who is right - Truman or her father?
This was a great book. You could definitely see the different perspectives and the way people think. I liked how the town was for throwing them together. I enjoyed the story line and the way things were done in history at that time. It was the first time reading a book from this author. I'd definitely read her books again.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Alice arrives in Gibeon, Idaho as a nurse. Truman is the local reverend. They keep getting thrown together as they are visiting the same people. Her for their physical health and he for their spiritual health. She's always been told by her father the way church should be held and how people should act. Truman is very lighthearted and is approached to hold a Christmas pageant. Alice doesn't agree with that. But can he change her mind? Who is right - Truman or her father?
This was a great book. You could definitely see the different perspectives and the way people think. I liked how the town was for throwing them together. I enjoyed the story line and the way things were done in history at that time. It was the first time reading a book from this author. I'd definitely read her books again.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This story presents so many contrasts. It contrasts poor vs rich, functional vs dysfunctional families, stern vs loving representation of God, reverence/solemness vs joy in our Christian walk. The people at the center of some of those contrasts are Truman, the minister. and Alice, the new nurse. I liked how their friendship progressed, with walks, snowmen, serving the people in the community together. The preparations for Christmas provides the backdrop for their relationship and Alice's spiritual journey to seeing and experiencing the joy of the Lord. Of course the author always has some twists for you to keep things exciting!
It was nice to get updates on characters from other books in the series, especially since this was the last book in the series.
I have enjoyed the whole series. Each story is unique and enjoyable.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
It was nice to get updates on characters from other books in the series, especially since this was the last book in the series.
I have enjoyed the whole series. Each story is unique and enjoyable.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy
This is a great story! While it is sixth book in the series it can be read as a standalone. However, I did enjoy seeing some characters from previous books. Alice has come to Idaho with nursing skills that she is happy to put to use for the people in her new community. The community is very welcoming and includes a Reverend, Truman, who has spent five years in the community getting to know his congregation and helping where needed. Alice and Truman find themselves crossing each others paths often and form a friendship that grows deeper. While Alice and Truman enjoy each other’s company they both have issues from their pasts that could keep them from finding their happiness and admitting to their feelings. I loved the feel of this town and the way everyone was so caring and willing to lend a hand. I highly recommend this book and this entire series.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 8, 2026
You can’t go wrong with a Robin Lee Hatcher book. To Fall in Love at Christmas is a perfect example of this. It may be hot summer, but the story is good at any time of the year not just Christmas. In fact, the holiday season gets so busy right now - Christmas in July - is the time to relax and enjoy this story of a single Pastor who is not looking love but as he works with a nurse during the holiday season there is a love being built.
Reverend Truman Blankenship is a wonderful, caring pastor who loved the Lord and the life God has given him. Nurse Alice MacPherson had been raised in a legalistic home, so joy was not part of the family’s vocabulary, just duty and work. What a delight to read how Truman shares the joy of the season and of God’s love with Alice. I also enjoy the natural way that their relationship blossomed as they worked together. God is good every day which is a cause of joy that this story is such a great reminder to us all.
Reverend Truman Blankenship is a wonderful, caring pastor who loved the Lord and the life God has given him. Nurse Alice MacPherson had been raised in a legalistic home, so joy was not part of the family’s vocabulary, just duty and work. What a delight to read how Truman shares the joy of the season and of God’s love with Alice. I also enjoy the natural way that their relationship blossomed as they worked together. God is good every day which is a cause of joy that this story is such a great reminder to us all.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Alice is new to Gibeon, ID. She is the new nurse in town. She was raised by a very strict, unloving father. Truman has been the pastor in town for 5 years. He is still very young - 27 - but the town loves him and he loves everyone in town. Alice is surprised by the joy in the town. She is surprised at the townspeople who just accept her. She never felt like she measured up enough for her father. Truman asks to court her, but she's skeptical that they are a match. She is very solemn and strict. He is filled with joy and laughter. As they court, Alice's heart softens and she feels at home. When her father writes to demand she come home to fulfill his duty to him, she is torn. She doesn't want to, but the Lord commands that we obey our parents. Such a really good book.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is my voluntary review of a copy I was given.
The whole course of the story takes about six months, but it doesn't feel rushed. Most of the townspeople are warm and welcoming. Alice is not used to this. She was never good at making friends, always working hard to gain her father's approval, but only earning criticism. She guards her heart. But these people... they take her in as one of their own, including her conversations and plans for upcoming celebrations.
That's where the first bit of conflict shows. She was raised not to celebrate anything joyfully. Life is practical—work and duty with no frivolity. Joy has no place in it.
I love how she comes to take her first steps out of that rigidity and into the start of her HEA.
The whole course of the story takes about six months, but it doesn't feel rushed. Most of the townspeople are warm and welcoming. Alice is not used to this. She was never good at making friends, always working hard to gain her father's approval, but only earning criticism. She guards her heart. But these people... they take her in as one of their own, including her conversations and plans for upcoming celebrations.
That's where the first bit of conflict shows. She was raised not to celebrate anything joyfully. Life is practical—work and duty with no frivolity. Joy has no place in it.
I love how she comes to take her first steps out of that rigidity and into the start of her HEA.
Review of advance copy
This was a delightful, faith filled story. I have not read the others in the series and now want to go back and read the others. Gideon is a delightful community of loving souls. This tale revolves around their young unmarried preacher and the new nurse in town. Alice grew up with a strict father whose idea of Christ was you had to earn your place, no grace for anyone. Love wasn't freely given, there were rules to follow.
Truman was the young reverend and he start to introduce to her how God loves you without any price. God wants to see our joy.
It is an uplifting story with a very strong message. Please read it as it will make you think and increase your faith as well.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Truman was the young reverend and he start to introduce to her how God loves you without any price. God wants to see our joy.
It is an uplifting story with a very strong message. Please read it as it will make you think and increase your faith as well.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is the sixth and last book in Hatcher’s The British Are Coming series. There are updates on each of the other couples in the series sprinkled throughout this book, which is enjoyable, but you do not have to have read the other books to enjoy this one. The love story is sweet and slow, with not too many obstacles and only one shocking plot twist. I enjoyed the fairly relaxing read compared to some books I’ve read recently. The spiritual insights on joy, love, respecting parents, and obedience are great. I enjoyed getting to know the new characters, and wish the series could keep going!
Review of advance copy received from Author
This was such a great story of finding love and acceptance while learning about and accepting the unconditional love of God. It was beautiful to watch Alice overcome the rejection and pain of her past as Truman gently leads her to a deeper relationship with God through his kindness and the Word of God. As she sees real love expressed in families and friends, she finds healing and hope she never thought possible. The one sad part was that her father could not accept her for who she was, but she was freed when she was able to forgive him.
I received a copy of the book from the author as an ARC, but a positive review was not required, and these are my honest thoughts.
I received a copy of the book from the author as an ARC, but a positive review was not required, and these are my honest thoughts.
Review of advance copy
To Fall in Love at Christmas is Book 6 in The British are Coming by Tobin Lee Hatcher. I believe that this author writes excellent Christian fiction. Alice is a nurse who had a very strict father who had many rules on how to live a Christian life. Reverend Truman has the joy of the Lord in his heart and he celebrates Christmas with laughter and joy. I really enjoyed reading this romance. Alice must overcome her father's training and her fears if she is to have a relationship with Truman. I think that this is such a sweet book and a wonderful escape into the pages of an excellent Christian romance. I received an are for free and am leaving my review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
A enjoyable story set in Gibeon, Idaho 1897, with many interesting characters.
Nurse, Alice MacPherson, is practical and organised, doesn't abide nonesense, and has a head full of rules & regulations - something she has needed to survive her life that has had little love & laughter.
Rev Truman Blankenship is a friend to everyone with a genuine caring heart.
Gibeon is a town where people can feel they belong, which Alice begins to experience for the first time in her life,
Alice, feeling she is undeserving of love, experiences
God's love & grace and learns the true meaning of love.
I finished the book feeling that I would love to live in Gibeon and meet these wonderful people.
Nurse, Alice MacPherson, is practical and organised, doesn't abide nonesense, and has a head full of rules & regulations - something she has needed to survive her life that has had little love & laughter.
Rev Truman Blankenship is a friend to everyone with a genuine caring heart.
Gibeon is a town where people can feel they belong, which Alice begins to experience for the first time in her life,
Alice, feeling she is undeserving of love, experiences
God's love & grace and learns the true meaning of love.
I finished the book feeling that I would love to live in Gibeon and meet these wonderful people.
Review of advance copy
This is a well written book. It was sometimes painful to read because Mattie's pain was so intense. She had lost much and it was hard for her to learn she was loved, and to learn to trust again. Wyatt seemed almost too good to be true, taking all the blame and not once expressing anger toward Mattie. It was good seeing the importane of prayer in their lives and that Mattie did have such great friends. Even though the story takes place in two weeks, it felt much longer than that and I thought the book was a bit too long. I was not entirely satisfied by the ending.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Alice becomes a nurse and moves away from her strict, legalistic father. She moves to a small community where people embrace her and accept her for who she is.
She begins to question much of her father's teaching when she is faced with good, loving people who enjoy pleasures of life that were forbidden by her father.
She becomes friends with Truman, the pastor of the local church. As their friendship blossoms Alice is forced to confront some of her previous teachings and beliefs.
Will the old saying "Love conquers all" become true in this story?
I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily. The opinions and comments are entirely my own.
She begins to question much of her father's teaching when she is faced with good, loving people who enjoy pleasures of life that were forbidden by her father.
She becomes friends with Truman, the pastor of the local church. As their friendship blossoms Alice is forced to confront some of her previous teachings and beliefs.
Will the old saying "Love conquers all" become true in this story?
I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily. The opinions and comments are entirely my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews