Imposter was a decent book for me. It started off alright but once the plot twists and revelations started coming in, things went a little absurd. There were some redeeming points in terms of some of the character development in this book but overall it was just a bit too much.
Imposter is a story about Seth, an 18 year old community theater actor who gets scouted after his performance as Romeo in Romeo and Juliet for a huge film named Whirlwind. Originally, a celebrity couple (Sabrina Layton and Kris Ellis) were attached to the film but due to their recent break-up, Seth and another novice actress Annaleigh take up the lead roles of the star-crossed couple instead. Whirlwind is a unique film in the way that the actors and actresses are given cameras to film and record their actions on the go, making the film a sort of "scripted reality" where they are given a basic plot and script to follow but ultimately much of the creative input is up to them. As the story progresses, Seth starts to experience the trials of being in Hollywood and realises that there are dark secrets he does not know about the film and its crew.
First, I'll talk about what I liked about this book. There are some interesting characters in this book, Sabrina for instance. Initially, I figured Sabrina was the usual cut-throat bitchy star actress who talks shit about others behind their backs, continually wears a mask to fool others into a sense of trust, etc etc. Her repeated flip-flopping of joining and leaving the cast of the film along with her erratic and destructive behaviour convinced me that she was antagonist of this book and it led me to hate her character. It is revealed later on that Sabrina was struggling with drug addiction which subsequently led to her breakup with Kris. Her struggles on her road to recovery and her support for Seth's cause at the end of the book was a remarkable turnaround for her and it made me do a 180 on how I felt about her character. Similarly, Kris started out looking like a standard entitled jerk, a famous actor who is so full of himself, complete with a posse of supportive jerk bros. When he first apologised for his rude comments about the appearance of an intern, it made me realise I might have made some assumptions too soon. While Kris might have come off brash and intense, he is actually a decent person who tried to get Sabrina off her drug problem and was determined to seek justice for what had happened during the course of filming for Whirlwind. I figured the author was going to play on the standard stereotypes of famous actors and actresses early on in the book so it was refreshing to see these characters become more developed and complicated than simple caricatures of Hollywood.
The pace of the book was good too. I was committed to discovering how the story would end and how everything would be resolved when I started on the second half of the book and it kept me interested all the way till the end.
The main problem I had with this book was its plot. The premise of having an entire movie filmed via headcams of the main actors and actresses was believable. It was billed as an adventurous experiment and it was an indie film after all. What was difficult to believe was the actual plot of the movie that the director and producers had in mind, which was to use the real lives of all the actors and actresses as content for the film. Basically, the whole plot of the movie was revealed to the paparazzi stage by stage, including intimate photographs and whatever content that was taken in private so how did the crew intend to make money on releasing such a film when most of its content is already out there? At various points of the book, various characters mention that celebrity gossip and news will always blow over as the media enter another news cycle and move on to the next story so it doesn't make much sense that a film based on yesterday's gossip news would do well in the box office, especially when all the paparazzi seem to have lost interest in Seth towards the end of the book. To film the cast members in secret and to record all of their actions was entering We Live in Public territory. Seth, Sabrina and Annaleigh signed their contracts agreeing to such recordings but I found it hard to believe that Seth, after reading every page of the contract, did not pick up anything about non-consensual filming or the like and just signed away his right to privacy in that agreement. Also, the content that was being recorded was crazy. It included Annaleigh and Seth having sex in Annaleigh's hotel room and since Annaleigh is only 17, this is pretty much pornography involving a minor that the production crew have on their hands and yet, Annaleigh and her parents were totally fine with that and the film crew threatened Seth with PUBLISHING it as well. That is just insane. Wire-tapping the private phones given to the actors was believable though I am not sure how legal that was. Wire-tapping Annaleigh's personal handphone was a little too convenient to me for the production crew to discover Seth's actions towards the end of the book.
I had a problem with Annaleigh's character as well. One minute she was shy and struggling in the spotlight to hold her own against Sabrina in a press conference, the next she's angry at Seth for knowing about the level of voyeurism the production was operating at while she had known from the very beginning about it. She exploited her father's criminal situation for the media but still played the victim in the whole fiasco. I liked Annaleigh in the beginning, thinking she was a good person struggling in the evil and hypocrisy of Hollywood but in the end, it turns out she fits right in.
This book was intriguing at first and got frustrating towards the end. This book could have taken a couple more steps towards having a more realistic plot. The ambiguous ending might be something some appreciate but I felt that readers deserved to know more about how it all ended in Seth's fight against Whirlwind and not be left hanging at the end. 3/5