What do you think?
Rate this book
Letters from Lancaster County #2
When They Met Again: Letters from Lancaster County
It's love at first sight for Adam Slaybaugh, yet while Joanna Grebel finds him attractive and is intrigued when he declares his interest, she's less certain of the potential for a romantic future together. Instead, she proposes they be "just friends," but Adam's not willing to settle for anything less than a romantic relationship. In response, he leaves Lancaster County for Florida, and soon after, Joanna begins courting Jacob Byer--someone she deems a much more suitable match.
When Adam returns to Lancaster County years later to pursue a career in his grandparents' successful home renovation business, he finds Joanna suffering from a broken heart. Misunderstandings and matchmaking schemes begin a tender journey of healing and romance--but is Adam's love enough to finally win Joanna over?
Bestselling Amish romance author Leslie Gould pens a gently humorous and rich romance threaded with heart-deep characters and the traditions of simple Amish life.
When Adam returns to Lancaster County years later to pursue a career in his grandparents' successful home renovation business, he finds Joanna suffering from a broken heart. Misunderstandings and matchmaking schemes begin a tender journey of healing and romance--but is Adam's love enough to finally win Joanna over?
Bestselling Amish romance author Leslie Gould pens a gently humorous and rich romance threaded with heart-deep characters and the traditions of simple Amish life.
500 pages, Library Binding
Published April 1, 2026
About the author
Leslie Gould
76 books615 followersLeslie Gould is the #1 bestselling and Christy Award-winning author of fifty novels. She received her MFA in 2009 and has taught writing on the university level. Leslie enjoys traveling, hiking, and history. She and her husband, Peter, are the parents of four adult children and two grandbabies. Visit her at http://www.lesliegould.com/.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
March 17, 2026
I’m not going to say too much about WHEN THEY MET AGAIN as to not give anything away, but truly, you will love this story if you have the chance to read it! I love how Leslie Gould tells a story and it feels like she is writing directly to me. She kept me engaged from the very first page! Adam Slaybaugh is in love with Joanna the moment he sees her. He never stops loving her, even when she starts dating another man. Adam decides to move to Florida. Eventually he comes back to help his grandparents with their home improvement business. Joanna was hurt by Jacob, who broke up with her twice. It’s very hard for her to trust a man again. She does trust God and asks him for his guidance in making sense of everything that is happening in her life.
WHEN THEY MET AGAIN is the second book in the Letters from Lancaster County. It is not your usual Amish story and it held my interest from the very first page until the last. Author Leslie Gould explores second chance romance, and the importance of circle letters. WHEN THEY MET AGAIN is filled with twists and turns and had me totally invested in all of the characters and their troubles. All of the characters have flaws and I really like how Leslie Gould shows the reader that The Amish, while living plain lives, still have problems and drama.
WHEN THEY MET AGAIN is filled with love, family, forgiveness, history, hope, and faith. Joanna and Adam both have some choices and hard decisions to make and they will break the reader’s hearts. Will Joanna stay in her grandparents home or will she go back? You have to give WHEN THEY MET AGAIN a try to find out! My emotions were all over the place while reading about the tough choices Joanna and Adam had to make and I found myself cheering both of them on, hoping they would find their happy places. Leslie Gould truly knows how to pull her readers in and never lets them go! I can not wait to continue with this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from JustRead Tours. The opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
WHEN THEY MET AGAIN is the second book in the Letters from Lancaster County. It is not your usual Amish story and it held my interest from the very first page until the last. Author Leslie Gould explores second chance romance, and the importance of circle letters. WHEN THEY MET AGAIN is filled with twists and turns and had me totally invested in all of the characters and their troubles. All of the characters have flaws and I really like how Leslie Gould shows the reader that The Amish, while living plain lives, still have problems and drama.
WHEN THEY MET AGAIN is filled with love, family, forgiveness, history, hope, and faith. Joanna and Adam both have some choices and hard decisions to make and they will break the reader’s hearts. Will Joanna stay in her grandparents home or will she go back? You have to give WHEN THEY MET AGAIN a try to find out! My emotions were all over the place while reading about the tough choices Joanna and Adam had to make and I found myself cheering both of them on, hoping they would find their happy places. Leslie Gould truly knows how to pull her readers in and never lets them go! I can not wait to continue with this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from JustRead Tours. The opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
March 6, 2026
3.5 stars personally.
I really enjoyed the first book in this series, but I struggled with getting invested in this one. The prose felt a bit clunky and repetitive for the first half, and I had a hard time connecting with the plot. Once we got past the halfway mark, the moment built and carried through to the end, though, and I did enjoy the messages the author chose to include.
I really liked Joanna as a character. She was very logical and grounded for the most part--she never thought about jumping the fence, but was rather a person of integrity, fully committed to her way of life, and so kind and hardworking. She did a feel a bit petty, especially toward the end, toward Adam, which got annoying because I just wanted our main couple TOGETHER finally.
Adam was a sweetheart. A bit too quick to move away, and at times pushy, but a good man overall. He had such a servant's heart, and his and Joanna's friendship was so sweet to watch blossom. Their first kiss felt kind of out of left field to me, but life can be that way sometimes, I suppose.
And then there were the grandmothers. I liked that they still had issues and struggles themselves and weren't just perfect, sweet, godly (and boring) role models. They made for some interesting additions to the plot with their own drama.
Also, I loved how bookish Adam and Joanna were, and how that played a role in their relationship (passing books like Little Women, Persuasion, and more!). It was especially cute since it's so uncommon in Amish fiction (they aren't really supposed to read ficiton).
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are my honest opinion.
I really enjoyed the first book in this series, but I struggled with getting invested in this one. The prose felt a bit clunky and repetitive for the first half, and I had a hard time connecting with the plot. Once we got past the halfway mark, the moment built and carried through to the end, though, and I did enjoy the messages the author chose to include.
I really liked Joanna as a character. She was very logical and grounded for the most part--she never thought about jumping the fence, but was rather a person of integrity, fully committed to her way of life, and so kind and hardworking. She did a feel a bit petty, especially toward the end, toward Adam, which got annoying because I just wanted our main couple TOGETHER finally.
Adam was a sweetheart. A bit too quick to move away, and at times pushy, but a good man overall. He had such a servant's heart, and his and Joanna's friendship was so sweet to watch blossom. Their first kiss felt kind of out of left field to me, but life can be that way sometimes, I suppose.
And then there were the grandmothers. I liked that they still had issues and struggles themselves and weren't just perfect, sweet, godly (and boring) role models. They made for some interesting additions to the plot with their own drama.
Also, I loved how bookish Adam and Joanna were, and how that played a role in their relationship (passing books like Little Women, Persuasion, and more!). It was especially cute since it's so uncommon in Amish fiction (they aren't really supposed to read ficiton).
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are my honest opinion.
March 23, 2026
When Adam Slaybaugh meets Joanna Grebel, it’s love at first sight. For him, anyway. Unwilling to settle for Joanna’s offer of friendship, he immediately moves from Lancaster County to Pinecraft. Which leaves Joanna to be courted by another man (who, let the record show, I disliked from the beginning). Okay, yes, Adam’s actions are impetuous and, frankly, immature, but there’s still something genuine about him that I could sense right away, a big heart that I knew could love Joanna well if they could both get past his decisions. And Joanna is a wonderful heroine – winsome, kind, smart – it’s easy to see why two guys want to court her. I especially enjoyed her and Adam’s shared love for reading and the nods to classic literature that author Leslie Gould weaves throughout When They Met Again. Their brief reunion during Joanna’s vacation to Pinecraft gave me hope that Adam would find a way out of the friend zone and solidified my belief that he was not only a great guy but the right guy for Joanna. When he returns to Lancaster County and they become coworkers at his grandparents’ business, I eagerly watched them develop a sweet friendship first that naturally allows Joanna to sort out her feelings between Jacob and Adam. With perhaps a little help from Jane Austen…
The highlight of this book for me, though, was the circle of friendships between Adam’s grandmother, Joanna’s grandmothers, and the local bishop’s wife. These ladies have been best friends since they were young, and finding out what they were like during their Rumspringa was really fun. I particularly loved Becky (Adam’s grandmother) and Lu (the grandmother Joanna lives with), though the other two grew dear to me too as the story went on. Lu is the quintessential Amish mammi, the kind you just want to hug and hang out with. Becky is more unique than how we typically see elder Amish women portrayed in fiction, and I loved her business savvy and the way she’s fully committed to her faith but also hasn’t quite done away with her funloving Rumspringa side either. Their friendship is so heartwarming, but I also appreciated that they aren’t meant to be perfect characters. They have fears, they have struggles, they have realistic flaws. And they’re exactly right to support Adam and Joanna on their respective journeys as well. (Unlike Joanna’s father Nehemiah who… oof… is a handful and then some.)
Bottom Line: When They Met Again by Leslie Gould is heartfelt and warm, and the literary nods sprinkled throughout delighted my bookish heart. Adam and Joanna’s journey to happily-ever-after kept me invested from its awkward beginnings to its sweet second chance. (And three cheers for a hero who isn’t afraid to admit he’s a fan of Jane Austen or Little Women!) But I have to say that I loved the friendships among the grandmothers the most, especially the humor, wisdom, and emotional depth they bring to this story and into Adam and Joanna’s life. I also appreciated the exploration of choosing to love people when it’s not easy, whether it’s a difficult family relationship, a gossipy friend, or a young woman who’s got you firmly in the friend zone. All of these elements together make When They Met Again a lovely and gently-written read, whether you’re a fan of Amish fiction or not.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
The highlight of this book for me, though, was the circle of friendships between Adam’s grandmother, Joanna’s grandmothers, and the local bishop’s wife. These ladies have been best friends since they were young, and finding out what they were like during their Rumspringa was really fun. I particularly loved Becky (Adam’s grandmother) and Lu (the grandmother Joanna lives with), though the other two grew dear to me too as the story went on. Lu is the quintessential Amish mammi, the kind you just want to hug and hang out with. Becky is more unique than how we typically see elder Amish women portrayed in fiction, and I loved her business savvy and the way she’s fully committed to her faith but also hasn’t quite done away with her funloving Rumspringa side either. Their friendship is so heartwarming, but I also appreciated that they aren’t meant to be perfect characters. They have fears, they have struggles, they have realistic flaws. And they’re exactly right to support Adam and Joanna on their respective journeys as well. (Unlike Joanna’s father Nehemiah who… oof… is a handful and then some.)
Bottom Line: When They Met Again by Leslie Gould is heartfelt and warm, and the literary nods sprinkled throughout delighted my bookish heart. Adam and Joanna’s journey to happily-ever-after kept me invested from its awkward beginnings to its sweet second chance. (And three cheers for a hero who isn’t afraid to admit he’s a fan of Jane Austen or Little Women!) But I have to say that I loved the friendships among the grandmothers the most, especially the humor, wisdom, and emotional depth they bring to this story and into Adam and Joanna’s life. I also appreciated the exploration of choosing to love people when it’s not easy, whether it’s a difficult family relationship, a gossipy friend, or a young woman who’s got you firmly in the friend zone. All of these elements together make When They Met Again a lovely and gently-written read, whether you’re a fan of Amish fiction or not.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
March 29, 2026
This is a clean, slow burn at its best. Sometimes to the point that I wanted to just yell out, "Is this really going to happen?!?" The story centers on Joanna and Adam, and while it was love at first sight for Adam, Joanna wanted more. She longed for a deeper relationship like she saw with her grandparents.
Joanna really wanted to feel a deeper connection to someone, so she was entirely turned off when Adam asked to court her at their first meeting. I could really appreciate the need to develop a solid friendship before moving forward and really liked that about her. Sometimes, even when we have the best of intentions, we're swayed by good looks and charisma, and that's exactly what happened to Joanna.
Adam clearly had just the opposite reaction. He truly believes in love at first sight, and for him, it is Joanna. Although he does have a tendency to run away when he doesn't get his way, which makes it hard for someone to reciprocate feelings. But being a hard worker and wanting to please his grandparents, he finds himself back at home, and back in front of Joanna. His commitment and deep love for someone who did not feel the same for him made my heart go out to him.
Now the grandparents, that's where things get really fun. Hearing from them, especially Adam's grandmother, Becky, really made the book and kept it flowing. Becky seemed like she was a wild one with a tendency to teeter on the lines of proper Amish ways.
This story felt complete and whole because of the extended timeframe it covered. The emotions came through in a way that made you feel connected to every character. One of the strongest elements was the sense of family, both biological and found. It also highlighted that when you take your time with love, what comes out at the end can last a lifetime or more.
If you love shedding happy tears at the end of the book, you will want to grab this book and start reading now. Overall, a book I could see myself picking up again.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from the author. All opinions are my own.
Joanna really wanted to feel a deeper connection to someone, so she was entirely turned off when Adam asked to court her at their first meeting. I could really appreciate the need to develop a solid friendship before moving forward and really liked that about her. Sometimes, even when we have the best of intentions, we're swayed by good looks and charisma, and that's exactly what happened to Joanna.
Adam clearly had just the opposite reaction. He truly believes in love at first sight, and for him, it is Joanna. Although he does have a tendency to run away when he doesn't get his way, which makes it hard for someone to reciprocate feelings. But being a hard worker and wanting to please his grandparents, he finds himself back at home, and back in front of Joanna. His commitment and deep love for someone who did not feel the same for him made my heart go out to him.
Now the grandparents, that's where things get really fun. Hearing from them, especially Adam's grandmother, Becky, really made the book and kept it flowing. Becky seemed like she was a wild one with a tendency to teeter on the lines of proper Amish ways.
This story felt complete and whole because of the extended timeframe it covered. The emotions came through in a way that made you feel connected to every character. One of the strongest elements was the sense of family, both biological and found. It also highlighted that when you take your time with love, what comes out at the end can last a lifetime or more.
If you love shedding happy tears at the end of the book, you will want to grab this book and start reading now. Overall, a book I could see myself picking up again.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from the author. All opinions are my own.
March 25, 2026
another sweet letters from lancaster county romance!
the moment he met joanna grebel, adam slaybaugh fell for her hard. joanna, on the other hand, approached a romantic relationship more cautiously and proposed friendship instead. years later, they're working together, developing that friendship, and adam's feelings still persist... can he convince her to give him a shot at romance?
as the series suggests, there are letters involved in this friends-to-more romance, and i'm just always a fan of a romance with letters. it's oh so sweet, but there's a little drama, of course—nothing too wild though—with some heartwarming moments of faith, family, and friendship, too.
readers of amish romance are sure to enjoy this trip to lancaster county.
(i received a complimentary copy from the author and/or publisher. i was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions i have expressed are my own.)
considerations:
—language: none
—spice: kisses only
—faith: amish community, consistent christian themes and mentions
—content: heart attack, mention of loss of parent and fire
the moment he met joanna grebel, adam slaybaugh fell for her hard. joanna, on the other hand, approached a romantic relationship more cautiously and proposed friendship instead. years later, they're working together, developing that friendship, and adam's feelings still persist... can he convince her to give him a shot at romance?
as the series suggests, there are letters involved in this friends-to-more romance, and i'm just always a fan of a romance with letters. it's oh so sweet, but there's a little drama, of course—nothing too wild though—with some heartwarming moments of faith, family, and friendship, too.
readers of amish romance are sure to enjoy this trip to lancaster county.
(i received a complimentary copy from the author and/or publisher. i was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions i have expressed are my own.)
considerations:
—language: none
—spice: kisses only
—faith: amish community, consistent christian themes and mentions
—content: heart attack, mention of loss of parent and fire
March 22, 2026
Leslie Gould ‘s When They Met Again was another delightful Amish story from an author whose work I have enjoyed several times. The book is written around an ongoing love story -- or maybe several -- worked into the pages, but at some points figuring out how things will work out is anyone’s guess. Joanna and Adam both have so many directions to go and decisions to make, and finding the right ones certainly makes their lives complicated. Family and friend connections add important and challenging pieces to the puzzle.
There are places where it seems parts of the story are a little disjointed, and the jumping from one element to another can be a little hard to follow. But that causes very little distraction to the story and keeps the many characters and situations moving along to the resolution.
I would recommend When They Met Again to true fans of Amish fiction. I have not had an opportunity to read the other books in this series but would love to enjoy those in the future.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are my own opinion.
There are places where it seems parts of the story are a little disjointed, and the jumping from one element to another can be a little hard to follow. But that causes very little distraction to the story and keeps the many characters and situations moving along to the resolution.
I would recommend When They Met Again to true fans of Amish fiction. I have not had an opportunity to read the other books in this series but would love to enjoy those in the future.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are my own opinion.
March 20, 2026
This was such a fun story! It reminded me a little bit of my own love story, since I thought my husband would only ever be a friend when we first got to know one another. It turns out being friends with your spouse can be a great way to go!
Joanna gets the wrong first impression of Adam, sending her into the arms of Jacob instead. As time passes, and she has more chances to interact with Adam, she finds that all may not be as she originally assumed.
While the story is sweet, I thought the grandma age friend group stole the show! They are delightful, as they matchmake and pray for the young people, learning some valuable lessons along the way. I enjoyed all the characters, but they were especially fun. I loved how Ike and Becky show the beauty of a love that endures over time.
I look forward to reading more books in this series! If you like Amish fiction, I recommend picking this story up!
I received this books from JustRead. This is my honest review.
Joanna gets the wrong first impression of Adam, sending her into the arms of Jacob instead. As time passes, and she has more chances to interact with Adam, she finds that all may not be as she originally assumed.
While the story is sweet, I thought the grandma age friend group stole the show! They are delightful, as they matchmake and pray for the young people, learning some valuable lessons along the way. I enjoyed all the characters, but they were especially fun. I loved how Ike and Becky show the beauty of a love that endures over time.
I look forward to reading more books in this series! If you like Amish fiction, I recommend picking this story up!
I received this books from JustRead. This is my honest review.
Did Not Finish
March 18, 2026Amish fiction is one of my favorite genres, so I usually fit in a few throughout the year. When They Met Again is the second book in the "Letters from Lancaster County" series, and the first one I have read. It seems like it might work as a stand alone.
It's a bit interesting how Joanna is determined she doesn't want anyone to court her, even when Adam is trying to persuade her. But then Jacob comes along...From there, the story takes a few twists and turns.
If you enjoy Amish fiction with a bit of romance, you'll want to add this one to your TBR list.
It's a bit interesting how Joanna is determined she doesn't want anyone to court her, even when Adam is trying to persuade her. But then Jacob comes along...From there, the story takes a few twists and turns.
If you enjoy Amish fiction with a bit of romance, you'll want to add this one to your TBR list.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
4.5 stars. I enjoyed reading this book! I liked the setting and the characters but the love story was a bit frustrating.
Joanna is a wonderful character! She's a hard worker, kind and loyal to those she cares about. Unfortunately she thinks that she is unlovable due to unkind people in her life. Adam is very compassionate. He's also pretty clueless when it comes to wooing women. His awkward attempts lead to a lot of frustration. I do love that he reads classics like Little Women and Persuasion! Mammi Lu and Mammi Becky are my favorites! They are everything that grandmothers should be! They are gentle, kind and always available.
One of my favorite things about reading Amish fiction is the amazing concept of community. The community is available to celebrate the good times and to help in the bad times. When someone is sick, the men and women help out with chores and provide food. The barn raising is a good example. I'd love to see one in person because I've heard that it's extraordinary!
I was provided a complimentary copy of the book from Baker Publishing Group via NetGalley through Interviews and Reviews. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Joanna is a wonderful character! She's a hard worker, kind and loyal to those she cares about. Unfortunately she thinks that she is unlovable due to unkind people in her life. Adam is very compassionate. He's also pretty clueless when it comes to wooing women. His awkward attempts lead to a lot of frustration. I do love that he reads classics like Little Women and Persuasion! Mammi Lu and Mammi Becky are my favorites! They are everything that grandmothers should be! They are gentle, kind and always available.
One of my favorite things about reading Amish fiction is the amazing concept of community. The community is available to celebrate the good times and to help in the bad times. When someone is sick, the men and women help out with chores and provide food. The barn raising is a good example. I'd love to see one in person because I've heard that it's extraordinary!
I was provided a complimentary copy of the book from Baker Publishing Group via NetGalley through Interviews and Reviews. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This story is a beautifully written story about friendship and romance. I have read stories by Leslie Gould before. She is a talented writer. Her work is very engaging and keeps you wanting to know more!
Joanna Grabble is a young woman who comes to live with her grandparents. During this time so many changes happen with her family and herself. She first meets Adam and quickly realizes there is someone else for her. Things don't go the way she hoped and she begins to change for the better.
Adam Slaybaugh is in love with Joanna the moment he sees her. He holds on to his love for her when she starts dating another man and he decides to leave for Florida. Eventually he comes back to help his grandparents with their business.
This story was good and easy to get lost in. I loved the town of characters. I was frustrated with Joanna who never saw what was actually good for her. She was always looking at the worst of every situation. I was also frustrated by some of the characters that worked against the happiness of the story. I just felt frustrated through most of the story. All in all it was good and so was the ending.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Bethany House Publishing through Interviews and Reviews via NetGalley. All opinions are mine alone.*
Joanna Grabble is a young woman who comes to live with her grandparents. During this time so many changes happen with her family and herself. She first meets Adam and quickly realizes there is someone else for her. Things don't go the way she hoped and she begins to change for the better.
Adam Slaybaugh is in love with Joanna the moment he sees her. He holds on to his love for her when she starts dating another man and he decides to leave for Florida. Eventually he comes back to help his grandparents with their business.
This story was good and easy to get lost in. I loved the town of characters. I was frustrated with Joanna who never saw what was actually good for her. She was always looking at the worst of every situation. I was also frustrated by some of the characters that worked against the happiness of the story. I just felt frustrated through most of the story. All in all it was good and so was the ending.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Bethany House Publishing through Interviews and Reviews via NetGalley. All opinions are mine alone.*
April 7, 2026
Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of the book. Opinions expressed are my own.
Note: This review is a bit less thorough than usual, because I ended up reading other books before I had the chance to start writing my review. I then returned to my review draft, after a generous passage of time. While I’m revisiting the book to write the review, my memory is a bit fuzzy.
Spiritual Themes
Trust is a gentle undercurrent in the book, with Joanna looking to the Lord and entrusting her future to Him.
My Review
Leslie Gould’s current series features standalone books that are linked together, not by characters or plot line, but by a similar theme of correspondence by letter. Book one bears a fun likeness to You Got Mail. In When they Met Again, there is some romantic correspondence, but the recurring letters are being exchanged by grandmothers. I have to note that it was a little bit challenging to keep track of who was related to who (as the grandmothers are best friends, and their grandchildren also have interconnected friendships and relationships). With that said, I do appreciate books with multi-generational emphasis, and I liked that the grandmas played such a large role in the story, alongside the younger lead characters.
Much of the plot deals with the relationship between friendship and romance: questioning whether friendship should proceed romantic attachment. Wary of entering into a marriage like her parents’, Joanna is hesitant to begin courting someone that she doesn’t know very well. It’s interesting to see the somewhat ironic development of the relationship: Adam ends up becoming Joanna’s friend, in spite of his deeper desire for romance, while Joanna jumps into a relationship with a different guy that she doesn’t know very well, either.
Treatment of An Accident
This is a small moment I highlighted, but I liked it. After injuring himself, Adam remarks that “it was stupid of [him] to twist [his] ankle.” Joanna points out that, since the fall was unintentional, it doesn’t make sense for Adam to call himself stupid. I think this is a good reminder in general, and it stuck out to me all the more as I was reading this book a few days after I was injured when someone rear-ended me.
Commentary on Courage
I also highlighted a short, but meaningful, excerpt about courage:
You’re courageous when you have no choice but to do the right thing, even when you’re scared. (Loc. 3818 of 4403)
I appreciate this reframing that identifies courage as a decision in the midst of fear. Gould also uses the phrase “scared brave,” which is a solid juxtaposition that sums up this idea.
Priorities
Another brief, but potent line: “They needed the Lord’s love — and to love Him — most of all” (Loc. 4032 of 4403). Even without context, this is a solid takeaway from any book.
Treatment of Literature
Throughout the book, Adam makes a point to connect with Joanna by reading some of the same books that she reads. This lent to some discussions of / references to classic literature, such as Jane Eyre and Sense and Sensibility. While I didn’t enjoy these references as much as I hoped (though, to be fair, I’ve never read Jane Eyre, and it’s been a long time since I read Sense and Sensibility), I could see them appealing to die-hard fans.
It’s also worth noting that it was pretty difficult to trace the relationships between grandmothers and grandchildren — although I did appreciate the overall importance of the grandmothers.
Content Notes
No content notes that I recall.
Recommendation Status
Although I preferred the first book in the series to the second, When They Met Again is a sweet love story that explores the role of friendship in romantic relationships. Recommended to readers who enjoy light Amish fiction, and especially those who also like Jane Eyre.
Note: This review is a bit less thorough than usual, because I ended up reading other books before I had the chance to start writing my review. I then returned to my review draft, after a generous passage of time. While I’m revisiting the book to write the review, my memory is a bit fuzzy.
Spiritual Themes
Trust is a gentle undercurrent in the book, with Joanna looking to the Lord and entrusting her future to Him.
My Review
Leslie Gould’s current series features standalone books that are linked together, not by characters or plot line, but by a similar theme of correspondence by letter. Book one bears a fun likeness to You Got Mail. In When they Met Again, there is some romantic correspondence, but the recurring letters are being exchanged by grandmothers. I have to note that it was a little bit challenging to keep track of who was related to who (as the grandmothers are best friends, and their grandchildren also have interconnected friendships and relationships). With that said, I do appreciate books with multi-generational emphasis, and I liked that the grandmas played such a large role in the story, alongside the younger lead characters.
Much of the plot deals with the relationship between friendship and romance: questioning whether friendship should proceed romantic attachment. Wary of entering into a marriage like her parents’, Joanna is hesitant to begin courting someone that she doesn’t know very well. It’s interesting to see the somewhat ironic development of the relationship: Adam ends up becoming Joanna’s friend, in spite of his deeper desire for romance, while Joanna jumps into a relationship with a different guy that she doesn’t know very well, either.
Treatment of An Accident
This is a small moment I highlighted, but I liked it. After injuring himself, Adam remarks that “it was stupid of [him] to twist [his] ankle.” Joanna points out that, since the fall was unintentional, it doesn’t make sense for Adam to call himself stupid. I think this is a good reminder in general, and it stuck out to me all the more as I was reading this book a few days after I was injured when someone rear-ended me.
Commentary on Courage
I also highlighted a short, but meaningful, excerpt about courage:
You’re courageous when you have no choice but to do the right thing, even when you’re scared. (Loc. 3818 of 4403)
I appreciate this reframing that identifies courage as a decision in the midst of fear. Gould also uses the phrase “scared brave,” which is a solid juxtaposition that sums up this idea.
Priorities
Another brief, but potent line: “They needed the Lord’s love — and to love Him — most of all” (Loc. 4032 of 4403). Even without context, this is a solid takeaway from any book.
Treatment of Literature
Throughout the book, Adam makes a point to connect with Joanna by reading some of the same books that she reads. This lent to some discussions of / references to classic literature, such as Jane Eyre and Sense and Sensibility. While I didn’t enjoy these references as much as I hoped (though, to be fair, I’ve never read Jane Eyre, and it’s been a long time since I read Sense and Sensibility), I could see them appealing to die-hard fans.
It’s also worth noting that it was pretty difficult to trace the relationships between grandmothers and grandchildren — although I did appreciate the overall importance of the grandmothers.
Content Notes
No content notes that I recall.
Recommendation Status
Although I preferred the first book in the series to the second, When They Met Again is a sweet love story that explores the role of friendship in romantic relationships. Recommended to readers who enjoy light Amish fiction, and especially those who also like Jane Eyre.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Adam Slaybaugh is instantly attracted to Joanna Grebel when they meet on the way to a wedding. But Joanna is wary of Adam's interest, and fears he is like her unpredictable and impulsive father. She doesn't believe in love at first sight, and as a reader of classic romances, she knows she wants her true love to be based on friendship first. When she meets Jacob though, her attraction to him is instant. But their relationship is turbulent and rocky.
Then Adam returns to her home town...
I really like Leslie Gould's writing. She creates a lovely environment for her characters. I loved the decades-long friendship circle of Becky, Lu, Elaine and Rhoda. I REALLY love the beautiful relationship between Becky and her husband Ike - not to mention the story of how they met! Joanna's connection with her grandmother Lu is very sweet and not at all in a saccharine way.
I enjoyed reading about the developing friendship circle which Joanna is part of.
I almost cheered for Rhoda when she stood up to her overbearing son's demands at last, and when she realised how much her granddaughter Joanna means to her. It was good too to see the character development of Joanna's distant Mamm.
I could've shaken Joanna a few times though. For someone so kind and perceptive, her reaction to the discovery about her letter-writer seems overly strong. As does her determination to continue to be 'miffed' about it. I honestly couldn't understand that AT ALL.
A good read, overall. I've docked it a star because the ending felt abrupt. I liked the last letter, and would have liked to have a bit more of a rounded conclusion. I felt a bit short-changed with just the final scene on the stairs.
I read a pre-publication version supplied by the publisher. No review was required. All comments and opinions above are entirely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
As the story opens, Joanna and her grandparents were riding with friends of her grandparents and their grandson Adam to a wedding in northwest Pennsylvania about five hours from their home in Lancaster County. Adam was immediately smitten with Joanna and asked if he could court her. Joanna was more flabbergasted by the question than anything else because she knew so very little about him. He had only moved in with his grandparents a week or two earlier, having grown up in a different area. She turned him down and said she would like to become friends. His answer caught her even more off guard when he told her that men and women could not be just friends. I cannot recall ever hearing anyone say such a ridiculous thing and still cannot figure out where he got such a notion. Sadly, another young man came along who was fine with just being friends, and Joanna started going out with him soon after. I think Adam grew to regret he had ever made such a statement. Throughout the story, I believe Joanna and Adam both learned so much about what true friendship really was. Watching their grandparents gave them some inspiring examples of the way friends interact and support each other. I enjoyed the back story of how the two sets of grandparents had met and fallen in love. The story has multiple layers of lessons about friendship, sticking together, and several others. Not only are there lessons of things to nurture friendships, but the author also wove in some lessons of things that should not be done. One that we all have heard from childhood, but that is so easy to slip into, is the bad habit of gossip. Friendship was a major theme throughout the story. It was a joy to see friendships develop, others that were restored, and some were strengthened. I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher. This is my honest review. All opinions are strictly my own. #BHPFiction
March 28, 2026
In When They Met Again it’s love at first sight for him, but it’s lets just be friends from her, until life gives them a second chance. I’m a huge fan of Amish fiction. While I love suspense, I also have a special love for a good romance as well. And a good romance with meddling matchmakers?! Sign me up!
Adam falls for Joanna. It’s love at first sight. But she’s not so sure and deems him into the land of just friends. She starts seeing someone she thinks is a better match, and he moves away.
But then he comes back to help his grandparents with their business. Joanna is nursing a broken heart. Could this be his chance to prove to her that he’s worthy of her love?
Or will he forever be stuck in the friend zone?
I enjoy how this book is about Amish characters, but they’re human. They are flawed individuals, and they all have their own problems. Too often, I think books about the Amish paint too rosy a picture.
Our main characters are book lovers! And they read fiction! And some of the books they read are some of my favourites. That just makes them amazing in my eyes. But I think the grandmothers steal the show. You’ll have to read the book to find out why!
This is the second book in a series. Do you need to read it as a series? If you ask me, the answer is always wholeheartedly yes. If you ask other people, they’ll tell you that you can read this as a standalone if you so choose. But why would you choose that?
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, which I received from JustRead Publicity Tours. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review, nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
Adam falls for Joanna. It’s love at first sight. But she’s not so sure and deems him into the land of just friends. She starts seeing someone she thinks is a better match, and he moves away.
But then he comes back to help his grandparents with their business. Joanna is nursing a broken heart. Could this be his chance to prove to her that he’s worthy of her love?
Or will he forever be stuck in the friend zone?
I enjoy how this book is about Amish characters, but they’re human. They are flawed individuals, and they all have their own problems. Too often, I think books about the Amish paint too rosy a picture.
Our main characters are book lovers! And they read fiction! And some of the books they read are some of my favourites. That just makes them amazing in my eyes. But I think the grandmothers steal the show. You’ll have to read the book to find out why!
This is the second book in a series. Do you need to read it as a series? If you ask me, the answer is always wholeheartedly yes. If you ask other people, they’ll tell you that you can read this as a standalone if you so choose. But why would you choose that?
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, which I received from JustRead Publicity Tours. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review, nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
April 1, 2026
3.25 stars
Even though this is the second book in the series (I haven't read the first yet, but want to), it was one you can read without needing to know the first book (and could be read like a stand-alone, honestly).
This is about Joanna who is living with her grandparents in Lancaster County. She hadn't lived there too long but needed to get away from her family after they lost their home to a fire. She also has some struggles with her parents and really just needed to get some time on her own.
The story takes place over the course of three years. Joanna is 19 and is not ready to have a relationship. She meets Adam, who seems very interested in her and asks her out on a date. She tells him she wants to be his friend, but he doesn't believe it is possible to be friends with someone, especially when he is so interested in her. Yet, shortly afterwards, she meets Jacob, who seems handsome and charming to her. She is drawn to him. It is during her time of courting Jacob, that her friendship begins with Adam. They become close during the next few years, forming memories, even after not really seeing one another for several months.
This story is also about the friendship between older women who are grandmothers of Adam and Joanna (and others too around them). They talk about what their Rumspringa was like and how they want to pray for their grandchildren and the needs they have.
The story was very sweet but sometimes it felt too drawn out and then felt a little rushed at the very end in spots. I feel like I would have liked to have more romance to bud more deeply at parts between the main characters, though I understand why that didn't happen. It was good and had nice themes throughout it. It was a sweet story, and I am glad I read it.
content: talk about someone cheating (not glorified at all) and talk about someone who is pregnant out of wedlock.
Even though this is the second book in the series (I haven't read the first yet, but want to), it was one you can read without needing to know the first book (and could be read like a stand-alone, honestly).
This is about Joanna who is living with her grandparents in Lancaster County. She hadn't lived there too long but needed to get away from her family after they lost their home to a fire. She also has some struggles with her parents and really just needed to get some time on her own.
The story takes place over the course of three years. Joanna is 19 and is not ready to have a relationship. She meets Adam, who seems very interested in her and asks her out on a date. She tells him she wants to be his friend, but he doesn't believe it is possible to be friends with someone, especially when he is so interested in her. Yet, shortly afterwards, she meets Jacob, who seems handsome and charming to her. She is drawn to him. It is during her time of courting Jacob, that her friendship begins with Adam. They become close during the next few years, forming memories, even after not really seeing one another for several months.
This story is also about the friendship between older women who are grandmothers of Adam and Joanna (and others too around them). They talk about what their Rumspringa was like and how they want to pray for their grandchildren and the needs they have.
The story was very sweet but sometimes it felt too drawn out and then felt a little rushed at the very end in spots. I feel like I would have liked to have more romance to bud more deeply at parts between the main characters, though I understand why that didn't happen. It was good and had nice themes throughout it. It was a sweet story, and I am glad I read it.
content: talk about someone cheating (not glorified at all) and talk about someone who is pregnant out of wedlock.
April 17, 2026
When They Met Again is a story about love, forgiveness, second chances, and friendships that endure over time despite imperfections. I appreciated the themes of family, community, and the reminder to be thoughtful before rushing into a relationship.
One element I especially enjoyed was the friendship between the older women and their letters filled with shared prayers. That part of the story was really special and made me hope that I’ll be able to maintain friendships like that into old age. I also liked the ending, particularly the moment when Adam finally stepped up and pursued Joanna in a more intentional way.
But I have to admit I struggled to finish this book. For me, the story didn’t fully hold my interest, and at times the characters felt somewhat immature, which made it difficult to stay engaged with their decisions and relationships. The pacing also felt uneven, with many characters coming and going, which occasionally made the story difficult to follow.
I also found myself wanting more backstory and emotional development, particularly regarding Joanna’s relationship with Jacob. Because the reasoning behind some of her choices wasn’t fully explored, it was difficult for me to understand why she continued to tolerate his behavior. Similarly, I found it surprising that Joanna’s employers—who seemed to care deeply about her—kept Jacob in their employment after the way he treated her.
There were also moments where events felt summarized rather than fully shown, which made some important developments feel rushed.
While this book didn’t work as well for me personally, readers who enjoy Amish romance and stories about second chances may still find something to appreciate here.
Thanks to NetGalley and Bethany House for the complimentary copy. All opinions expressed are my own.
One element I especially enjoyed was the friendship between the older women and their letters filled with shared prayers. That part of the story was really special and made me hope that I’ll be able to maintain friendships like that into old age. I also liked the ending, particularly the moment when Adam finally stepped up and pursued Joanna in a more intentional way.
But I have to admit I struggled to finish this book. For me, the story didn’t fully hold my interest, and at times the characters felt somewhat immature, which made it difficult to stay engaged with their decisions and relationships. The pacing also felt uneven, with many characters coming and going, which occasionally made the story difficult to follow.
I also found myself wanting more backstory and emotional development, particularly regarding Joanna’s relationship with Jacob. Because the reasoning behind some of her choices wasn’t fully explored, it was difficult for me to understand why she continued to tolerate his behavior. Similarly, I found it surprising that Joanna’s employers—who seemed to care deeply about her—kept Jacob in their employment after the way he treated her.
There were also moments where events felt summarized rather than fully shown, which made some important developments feel rushed.
While this book didn’t work as well for me personally, readers who enjoy Amish romance and stories about second chances may still find something to appreciate here.
Thanks to NetGalley and Bethany House for the complimentary copy. All opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
It is easy to see why Leslie Gould is an award-winning author. She writes from the heart and gives readers meaningful stories to enjoy. When They Met Again is a perfect example of this.
This book tells the story of the many friendships a person can have and how those friendships are important. I liked the dynamic between Joanna and Mammi Lu, and also Mammi Becky. I also enjoyed the friendship of the four older ladies and how they helped each other out. I know this is the Amish way, and I think the author does a good job of relaying that to the reader. I also enjoyed the budding friendship between Joanna and Adam. There were places this story took turns that I wasn't expecting, but I like how they all tied together in the end.
I absolutely love Leslie Gould's writing style and the stories she tells. She writes in a way that makes it effortless to read her books. She tells stories that have depth to them. Writing about the Amish has to have its challenges since their lifestyle is different, but Leslie has found a way to write really good and meaningful Amish fiction. Her stories are realistic and authentic, and this makes her books an absolute joy to read.
This book is an excellent choice for fans of Amish fiction. Whether you are a seasoned Amish fiction reader or new to the genre, this is a good book to read. It is the second in the series, but by no means do you have to read the first book to understand what is going on with the characters in this book. I would, however, recommend the first book because it is excellent as well. I would also recommend reading all of Leslie's books because they are just really good reads.
Thank you to the publisher for an advanced copy of this book.
This book tells the story of the many friendships a person can have and how those friendships are important. I liked the dynamic between Joanna and Mammi Lu, and also Mammi Becky. I also enjoyed the friendship of the four older ladies and how they helped each other out. I know this is the Amish way, and I think the author does a good job of relaying that to the reader. I also enjoyed the budding friendship between Joanna and Adam. There were places this story took turns that I wasn't expecting, but I like how they all tied together in the end.
I absolutely love Leslie Gould's writing style and the stories she tells. She writes in a way that makes it effortless to read her books. She tells stories that have depth to them. Writing about the Amish has to have its challenges since their lifestyle is different, but Leslie has found a way to write really good and meaningful Amish fiction. Her stories are realistic and authentic, and this makes her books an absolute joy to read.
This book is an excellent choice for fans of Amish fiction. Whether you are a seasoned Amish fiction reader or new to the genre, this is a good book to read. It is the second in the series, but by no means do you have to read the first book to understand what is going on with the characters in this book. I would, however, recommend the first book because it is excellent as well. I would also recommend reading all of Leslie's books because they are just really good reads.
Thank you to the publisher for an advanced copy of this book.
March 20, 2026
When Joanna Grebel meets Adam Slaybaugh, sparks don’t exactly fly on both sides. Adam is interested in Joanna, but Joanna isn’t quite sure about him as love match material. When Joanna expresses interest in friendship, Adam decides that won’t do. He pretty quickly takes himself out of sight, off to Florida to work construction. Joanna starts courting someone she thinks is a more suitable match, but she learns her judgment may have been a little off. Is there still a chance for a relationship between her and Adam?
I do love a good Amish romance. It took me a bit to get into this one. It didn’t grab me right away, and I couldn’t even really tell you why. It felt slow at first, but it picked up about a third of the way through.
Joanna and Adam were both lovely characters. I sure breathed a sigh of relief when Joanna washed her hands of Jacob. Then I was really rooting for her and Adam to figure things out!
I especially enjoyed how the author worked classic fiction into the story. Books play an important role in Joanna and Adam’s relationship, and I didn’t realize until I started seeing reviews for this book that the Amish don’t really read fiction. I love books where I learn something!
Even though I didn’t feel like the book sucked me in right away, it’s still a lovely second chance romance with very creative use of classic fiction. I enjoyed it, and I’d read more in the series!
Disclaimer: I received a copy of the book from JustRead Publicity Tours. I was not required to leave a review. All opinions here are mine, and I don’t say nice things about books I don’t actually like.
I do love a good Amish romance. It took me a bit to get into this one. It didn’t grab me right away, and I couldn’t even really tell you why. It felt slow at first, but it picked up about a third of the way through.
Joanna and Adam were both lovely characters. I sure breathed a sigh of relief when Joanna washed her hands of Jacob. Then I was really rooting for her and Adam to figure things out!
I especially enjoyed how the author worked classic fiction into the story. Books play an important role in Joanna and Adam’s relationship, and I didn’t realize until I started seeing reviews for this book that the Amish don’t really read fiction. I love books where I learn something!
Even though I didn’t feel like the book sucked me in right away, it’s still a lovely second chance romance with very creative use of classic fiction. I enjoyed it, and I’d read more in the series!
Disclaimer: I received a copy of the book from JustRead Publicity Tours. I was not required to leave a review. All opinions here are mine, and I don’t say nice things about books I don’t actually like.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Amish Fiction is my ultimate favorite genre to read. When They Met Again by Leslie Gould is Book 2 in the Letters from Lancaster County series I really enjoy Leslie Gould's series, and had the opportunity to read Book 1 in this series!
WOW, this storyline is one that immediately had me connected to the story. Joanna Grebel and Adam Slaybaugh are the main characters in this book. Joanna lives with her Grandmother, Mammi Lu, and they have a great relationship. Adam notices Joanna and he is immediately intrigued and wants to be in relationship with Joanna. I really love that Joanna tells Adam she would prefer to remain friends. Adam feels he needs to move from Lancaster County to pursue other interests in Florida. Joanna does date someone else for awhile, but that doesn't work out. Adam eventually returns to Lancaster County to work the Family Business, which Joanna now also works at the Slaybaugh Construction and Renovation Company. I LOVE that when Adam returns he makes it known that he never lost his feelings from Joanna Joanna finally decides to give him a chance and they begin a romantic relationship. Adam sees that Joanna has a broken heart and he is hoping to help her through this part of life by being there for her. Their relationship grows at a perfect pace and the happiness in both of them is a wonderful thing so see. I rarely see "Second Chance Romance" in the Amish Genre, I was thrilled that this was a Second Chance Romance. Joanna and Adam are a sweet couple and their story is a WONDERFUL story! and I am excited for future books in this series!
WOW, this storyline is one that immediately had me connected to the story. Joanna Grebel and Adam Slaybaugh are the main characters in this book. Joanna lives with her Grandmother, Mammi Lu, and they have a great relationship. Adam notices Joanna and he is immediately intrigued and wants to be in relationship with Joanna. I really love that Joanna tells Adam she would prefer to remain friends. Adam feels he needs to move from Lancaster County to pursue other interests in Florida. Joanna does date someone else for awhile, but that doesn't work out. Adam eventually returns to Lancaster County to work the Family Business, which Joanna now also works at the Slaybaugh Construction and Renovation Company. I LOVE that when Adam returns he makes it known that he never lost his feelings from Joanna Joanna finally decides to give him a chance and they begin a romantic relationship. Adam sees that Joanna has a broken heart and he is hoping to help her through this part of life by being there for her. Their relationship grows at a perfect pace and the happiness in both of them is a wonderful thing so see. I rarely see "Second Chance Romance" in the Amish Genre, I was thrilled that this was a Second Chance Romance. Joanna and Adam are a sweet couple and their story is a WONDERFUL story! and I am excited for future books in this series!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
You can't go wrong with a Leslie Gould story.
Joanna has a some personal hurt of feeling not seen nor treated nice.
Adam somewhat direct and impulsive on how he speaks puts her in a not sure if she can trust him. And while he wishes to court her, she wishes to be friends.
When another Amish boy shows up and makes her feel noticed and that they are friends. She says yes to be courted by him only to be hurt twice by him. Joanna believes she can not trust anyone and nobody can love her.
When they see each other again in Florida, Adam and Joanna seem to connect and she feels a friendship growing.
But with ups and downs. Twists and surprises Joanna notices that Adam is always with her. As a friend when she is happy and when she is sad.
I loved the friendship circle that Joanna's grandmother had. And the love between Adam's grandparents. Two things that put this story together. As well, as Joanna realizing that the two things she wishes in life she actually has already.
I enjoyed this story. Adam was a great friend. His attentive attention to Joanna was so sweet. Joanna, was hard worker, despite her fears I believe that's what made her a strong person even when she didn't see it herself.
I also like the way people came together to help Adam's grandparents.
This story has several elements. You will not be disappointed.
I received a ARC from the author publisher. All stated here are my own. I was not required a positive comment.
Joanna has a some personal hurt of feeling not seen nor treated nice.
Adam somewhat direct and impulsive on how he speaks puts her in a not sure if she can trust him. And while he wishes to court her, she wishes to be friends.
When another Amish boy shows up and makes her feel noticed and that they are friends. She says yes to be courted by him only to be hurt twice by him. Joanna believes she can not trust anyone and nobody can love her.
When they see each other again in Florida, Adam and Joanna seem to connect and she feels a friendship growing.
But with ups and downs. Twists and surprises Joanna notices that Adam is always with her. As a friend when she is happy and when she is sad.
I loved the friendship circle that Joanna's grandmother had. And the love between Adam's grandparents. Two things that put this story together. As well, as Joanna realizing that the two things she wishes in life she actually has already.
I enjoyed this story. Adam was a great friend. His attentive attention to Joanna was so sweet. Joanna, was hard worker, despite her fears I believe that's what made her a strong person even when she didn't see it herself.
I also like the way people came together to help Adam's grandparents.
This story has several elements. You will not be disappointed.
I received a ARC from the author publisher. All stated here are my own. I was not required a positive comment.
March 17, 2026
It has been a minute since I read the first book in the Letters from Lancaster County series, so it took me a minute to get my bearings, but once I got the characters situated in my mind, is when this novel really started speaking to me. It didn’t help that I was reading this novel while dealing with a migraine, but honestly, this helped keep my mind off my pain if only for a moment.
While the start was a bit rocky, once I really sat and savored this novel, I really started to enjoy it. The novel is very character-driven and gives us a clear picture of just who these characters are at their core. Both Adam and Joanna are genuinely good people, and I loved seeing them interact and work together and see their friendship blossom over time.
The side characters were a favorite of mine, and the close friendships, particularly with the letter-writing ladies, had my heart. Jacob gave me the ick and for good reason, and sadly, I’ve known a few Jacobs in my life. This “man” made my blood boil, and I hope to see a redemption for him in future installments.
The ending was so sweet and definitely earned. It was very satisfying to see this couple get their happily ever after, and it was the perfect ending to a wunderbaar story.
*I have voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher. All views and opinions expressed are completely honest, and my own.
While the start was a bit rocky, once I really sat and savored this novel, I really started to enjoy it. The novel is very character-driven and gives us a clear picture of just who these characters are at their core. Both Adam and Joanna are genuinely good people, and I loved seeing them interact and work together and see their friendship blossom over time.
The side characters were a favorite of mine, and the close friendships, particularly with the letter-writing ladies, had my heart. Jacob gave me the ick and for good reason, and sadly, I’ve known a few Jacobs in my life. This “man” made my blood boil, and I hope to see a redemption for him in future installments.
The ending was so sweet and definitely earned. It was very satisfying to see this couple get their happily ever after, and it was the perfect ending to a wunderbaar story.
*I have voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher. All views and opinions expressed are completely honest, and my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
An inspirational story of Amish romance set in a tight-knit traditional Amish community . . .
Joanna Grebel lives in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, with her grandmother—Mammi Lu. She helps around the widow's farm by cultivating and cutting flowers for the farm stand on the property and by assisting others in the community.
Later Joanna is employed by an older couple in the community—Becky and Ike Slaybaugh—to work as an assistant in their construction business. The Slaybaughs purchase homes, renovate them, and flip them for a profit. Joanna is gifted at design and has excellent organizational skills. She is tasked with outfitting the homes with cabinets, fixtures, furniture, etc.
One of my favorite elements of this story is the many inspirational Bible Scriptures that are shared between the characters in letters and conversation. The other is the enduring friendship between four of the older characters—Becky, Rhoda, Elaine, and Lu. These four women were friends back in their Rumspringa time when they were teens. They have been there for each other through courtships, marriage, the deaths of children and spouses, and in good times, too.
The story is completely clean in language and content. I received a copy of this book from the publisher through JustRead Publicity Tours. All of my thoughts and opinions shared here are solely my own.
########################
Joanna Grebel lives in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, with her grandmother—Mammi Lu. She helps around the widow's farm by cultivating and cutting flowers for the farm stand on the property and by assisting others in the community.
Later Joanna is employed by an older couple in the community—Becky and Ike Slaybaugh—to work as an assistant in their construction business. The Slaybaughs purchase homes, renovate them, and flip them for a profit. Joanna is gifted at design and has excellent organizational skills. She is tasked with outfitting the homes with cabinets, fixtures, furniture, etc.
One of my favorite elements of this story is the many inspirational Bible Scriptures that are shared between the characters in letters and conversation. The other is the enduring friendship between four of the older characters—Becky, Rhoda, Elaine, and Lu. These four women were friends back in their Rumspringa time when they were teens. They have been there for each other through courtships, marriage, the deaths of children and spouses, and in good times, too.
The story is completely clean in language and content. I received a copy of this book from the publisher through JustRead Publicity Tours. All of my thoughts and opinions shared here are solely my own.
########################
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
"When They Met Again" by Leslie Gould is an engaging narrative. Leslie Gould demonstrates a commendable writing style throughout the work. Her stories are engaging, readable, and feature well-developed characters. I like the relationship Joanna had with her grandmother, Mammi Lu. They were friends as well as grandmother and granddaughter. Mammi Lu and her three friends were a hoot. I enjoyed hearing about their antics while they were on their rumspringa. I also valued the portrayal of the characters as imperfect individuals, each facing their own challenges. I liked the classics that were featured in the story (Little Women is my favorite). I was surprised that Adam read the stories (few men are willing to read Jane Austen). The romance between Joanna and Adam progressed slowly, but it gave them a chance to get to know each other and become friends first. The Amish are known for their strong communal bonds, providing mutual support during both prosperous and challenging times. There was only one thing that I found odd in the story, and it was Joanna’s reaction to the letters Adam left her. It was out of character for such an insightful and caring individual. The second book in the Letters from Lancaster County series was truly heartwarming, and I found When They Met Again to be thoroughly enjoyable.
April 18, 2026
Love at first sight? It's exciting if both people feel the same attraction, but this wasn't the case for Adam and Joanna. He loved her instantly, she believed friendship should come first, and Adam ended up going to Florida to nurse his broken heart. Would Joanna ever know what she had thrown away?
Adam is given a second chance with Joanna when he returns home to Lancaster County to help his grandparents. Her recent pain caused by another man may prevent Joanna from seeing just how special Adam is. I enjoyed the book discussions that became such an important part of their budding relationship. Perhaps friendship is the lasting foundation for true love!
When They Met Again is a sweet romance, but there's so much more! I loved the special friendship of the three grandmothers and the bishop's wife, along with the circle letters they shared. They weren't always what older Amish women are perceived to be, and it appeared that some may have really enjoyed their Rumspringa days! Were these fun friends the encouragement Adam needed to pursue Joanna this second time?
Leslie Gould says that the classic movie When Harry Met Sally inspired this novel. Never fear, this clean romance is perfect for fans of Amish fiction!
I received a complimentary copy from the author and Bethany House. There was no obligation for a positive review.
Adam is given a second chance with Joanna when he returns home to Lancaster County to help his grandparents. Her recent pain caused by another man may prevent Joanna from seeing just how special Adam is. I enjoyed the book discussions that became such an important part of their budding relationship. Perhaps friendship is the lasting foundation for true love!
When They Met Again is a sweet romance, but there's so much more! I loved the special friendship of the three grandmothers and the bishop's wife, along with the circle letters they shared. They weren't always what older Amish women are perceived to be, and it appeared that some may have really enjoyed their Rumspringa days! Were these fun friends the encouragement Adam needed to pursue Joanna this second time?
Leslie Gould says that the classic movie When Harry Met Sally inspired this novel. Never fear, this clean romance is perfect for fans of Amish fiction!
I received a complimentary copy from the author and Bethany House. There was no obligation for a positive review.
March 25, 2026
Sweet and Heartwarming
I always enjoy a good romance, and When They Met Again fits the bill completely.
When Joanna and Adam first meet, Adam is smitten, but Joanna isn't on the same page, and even as they continually end up in each other's company, they remain on different sides of the feelings fence. However, unexpected events enter the mix, causing a shift in their relationship. Some of it is painful, some is entertaining, and some is endearing, which makes for a very touching story.
Along with Joanna and Adam are some wonderful and fun characters, as well as a not-so-likeable character, who add much to their story. The story is further enhanced by strong themes of family, faith, love, and second chances, making it a sweet, enjoyable, and heartwarming read.
Book Quote:
As you go through this difficult time, ... Remember, the one who loves and cares for you the most is leading you. I hope you will find encouragement in His guidance and also in the following verse: For I the Lord thy God will hold thy right hand, saying unto thee, Fear not; I will help thee. Isaiah 41:13
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy of this book. All comments and opinions are entirely my own and voluntary.
I always enjoy a good romance, and When They Met Again fits the bill completely.
When Joanna and Adam first meet, Adam is smitten, but Joanna isn't on the same page, and even as they continually end up in each other's company, they remain on different sides of the feelings fence. However, unexpected events enter the mix, causing a shift in their relationship. Some of it is painful, some is entertaining, and some is endearing, which makes for a very touching story.
Along with Joanna and Adam are some wonderful and fun characters, as well as a not-so-likeable character, who add much to their story. The story is further enhanced by strong themes of family, faith, love, and second chances, making it a sweet, enjoyable, and heartwarming read.
Book Quote:
As you go through this difficult time, ... Remember, the one who loves and cares for you the most is leading you. I hope you will find encouragement in His guidance and also in the following verse: For I the Lord thy God will hold thy right hand, saying unto thee, Fear not; I will help thee. Isaiah 41:13
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy of this book. All comments and opinions are entirely my own and voluntary.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Amish fiction has long been an interesting genre to me. Perhaps it calls me back to a simpler time in my life. Perhaps it is because it is a culture so different from my own. But no matter the culture, some things are the same, such as complicated relationships and all the accompanying emotions!
Joanna, who is a competent young woman in almost anything she does, discovers she can’t trust her own feelings when it comes to some decisions in life. She lives with her widowed grandmother in a tight-knit Amish community and works for a home-renovation business owned by a couple who are like surrogate grandparents to her. The problem is that two young men working there are interested in her. One is the grandson of the owners, and the other is a charmer who wins her heart. It takes 3 years and much heartache for her to see clearly what others have been able to see for a long time.
It is charming the way the author creatively weaves classical literature into the plot. If you are fans of Louisa May Alcott, Jane Austin, Charlotte Brontë, and Lucy Maud Montgomery, you will especially enjoy this book.
Joanna, who is a competent young woman in almost anything she does, discovers she can’t trust her own feelings when it comes to some decisions in life. She lives with her widowed grandmother in a tight-knit Amish community and works for a home-renovation business owned by a couple who are like surrogate grandparents to her. The problem is that two young men working there are interested in her. One is the grandson of the owners, and the other is a charmer who wins her heart. It takes 3 years and much heartache for her to see clearly what others have been able to see for a long time.
It is charming the way the author creatively weaves classical literature into the plot. If you are fans of Louisa May Alcott, Jane Austin, Charlotte Brontë, and Lucy Maud Montgomery, you will especially enjoy this book.
Review of advance copy received from Author
When I pick up a book by Leslie Gould, I know I am in for a good read. When They Met Again did not disappoint. I enjoyed watching Joanna and Adam's relationship grow and mature throughout the book. Although I must admit, sometimes Joanna's actions/feelings were frustrating to me! I enjoy reading stories about the Amish — the bonding and fellowship of their communities. Gould does a wonderful job fleshing out her characters so that the reader truly feels like they are real people with very real struggles and heartaches. Strong friendships and family relationships are a recurring theme throughout the story. I was reminded of the importance of being a compassionate friend, mom, and grandmother-someone who can be trusted. Readers who enjoy stories about family and friends set in the Amish community will not want to miss When They Met Again I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author. I was not required to write a review, and the opinions are my own.
March 19, 2026
These were such fun and interesting characters. You got to meet the older generation and learn some of their histories as well as the younger ones and some of the problems they were facing. I loved Adam right off but Jacob, not so much. But Joanna was attracted to Jacob right off. Love at first sight? Joanna did have a good heart and sense most of the time. She did want to be friends with those she was attracted to so that she could get to know them first before getting serious but does the heart always listen? Another interesting side to the story was Betsy and Ike and their house flipping business. This was my first Amish story with that sideline. This author gave enough background information to make the story interesting and believable. A great passage of time for me!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through the author but was not required to write a review.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through the author but was not required to write a review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Boy meet girl, love at first sight? Maybe, or maybe for only one? Enter another young Amishman, a very handsome fellow, and there is an attraction.
This is a story that takes place in the Amish settlement in Lancaster PA, but we do journey to Pinecraft FL, and hopes that there is a match somewhere here.
I loved how this Pennsylvania community pulls together to help one another, and surprise them. There are health scares, business problems, and relationship problems, but there is so much love for each other and concern, that I felt I wanted to be part of this community, which I was, even if it was just for a little while!
This was a journey that I'm glad I took!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
This is a story that takes place in the Amish settlement in Lancaster PA, but we do journey to Pinecraft FL, and hopes that there is a match somewhere here.
I loved how this Pennsylvania community pulls together to help one another, and surprise them. There are health scares, business problems, and relationship problems, but there is so much love for each other and concern, that I felt I wanted to be part of this community, which I was, even if it was just for a little while!
This was a journey that I'm glad I took!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
March 17, 2026
I enjoyed the first book of the series, so was very happy to receive book 2. It is a touching story of Adam and Joanna. Joanna has had an unfortunate time with Jacob and now she is less trusting to have a relationship. As Joanna and Adam work together and as their friendship grows, it was enjoyable to read about them and grow to appreciate them both. I loved the letter-writers. And there was a line that I especially enjoyed reading and seeing in the story, a quote from Mammi Lu, "It's better to give others a piece of your heart than a piece of your mind. That's what Jesus would do."
A good story, and you won't want to miss it! I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
A good story, and you won't want to miss it! I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews