What do you think?
Rate this book
The Monastery of the Damned: From the Ivy League to the French Foreign Legion
Most men fantasize about military life and action. Few ever serve. Even fewer succeed in joining elite combat units. In a world of roughly four billion men, only a few thousand each year dare to take the ultimate leap of faith by joining the most renowned and mysterious military fighting force in the world, the French Foreign Legion. In the attempt to forge himself into a “Renaissance man,” Nicholas Tobias—a young scholar with a promising future at the Anglo-Saxon Academy, a recent convert to Roman Catholicism, and decidedly tall, dark, and melancholy— instead leaves behind his studies in Renaissance history at Princeton to enlist in the French Foreign Legion. This is the story of his journey with the Foreign Legion, sometimes referred to as the “The Monastery of the Damned.”
From his initial days in the French Foreign Legion to his premature honourable discharge twenty months later, Nicholas encounters a series of people, places, and events that profoundly challenge and reshape his worldviews shaped by his upbringing in suburban United States and later at prestigious universities across the US and Europe. This is the story of a young man forever changed not only by the lessons and hardships of life as a legionnaire, but also by his service alongside fellow legionnaires. Originating from over 140 countries, these soldiers collectively form one of the most nationally and culturally diverse organizations in the world.
Deployed to Afghanistan in summer 2009 as part of a French task force, Nicholas steps foot into his first “war zone” with fellow legionnaires. During his six months of operations across various regions of Afghanistan, including in and around Kabul, the realities of modern conflict clash with Nicholas’ romanticized notions of soldiering, warfare, and adventure.
This is the story of a young man as he struggles to reconcile such realities with his unyielding appetite for adventure, endurance, and service. This is the story of a young man who dared— to join the French Foreign Legion.
From his initial days in the French Foreign Legion to his premature honourable discharge twenty months later, Nicholas encounters a series of people, places, and events that profoundly challenge and reshape his worldviews shaped by his upbringing in suburban United States and later at prestigious universities across the US and Europe. This is the story of a young man forever changed not only by the lessons and hardships of life as a legionnaire, but also by his service alongside fellow legionnaires. Originating from over 140 countries, these soldiers collectively form one of the most nationally and culturally diverse organizations in the world.
Deployed to Afghanistan in summer 2009 as part of a French task force, Nicholas steps foot into his first “war zone” with fellow legionnaires. During his six months of operations across various regions of Afghanistan, including in and around Kabul, the realities of modern conflict clash with Nicholas’ romanticized notions of soldiering, warfare, and adventure.
This is the story of a young man as he struggles to reconcile such realities with his unyielding appetite for adventure, endurance, and service. This is the story of a young man who dared— to join the French Foreign Legion.
- GenresBiography
432 pages, Hardcover
Published April 7, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
April 18, 2026
Brought memories, created insight
Very captivating read. It brought back memories and bonding from my time in the USAF. The training was not as difficult as the legion but many similarities. The author's experience and insights about his time in Afghanistan was enlightening and squares with my views. He puts the situation clearly.
I recommend this to people I served with. I'm happy to tell everyone about it.
Very captivating read. It brought back memories and bonding from my time in the USAF. The training was not as difficult as the legion but many similarities. The author's experience and insights about his time in Afghanistan was enlightening and squares with my views. He puts the situation clearly.
I recommend this to people I served with. I'm happy to tell everyone about it.
May 14, 2026
I will always enjoy a coming of age memoir, especially when set in the form of a quest. In this case, the quest to become a man. Leaving Princeton to enlist in the French Foreign Legion is about as bold a road as possible!
The memoir is told through a series of essays, wide-ranging, amusing, reflective, erudite, and pragmatic by turns. The essay format makes it easy to pick up and put down again, though it's engaging enough to read in one or two sittings, as I did while traveling.
Part of the authors's quest - which he claims was not intentional at the outset - is to outgrow his Anglophilia, and unfortunately I thought this element came across less like maturity and more like juvenile transgressivism. To see the faults and veins of weakness in one's own country, culture, and patrimony is part of growing up. To criticize can be a form of service. But the author describes himself violating a cultural taboo on purpose to grow out of his Anglo prejudices. Considering the final words in his acknowledgment are "Lastly, I would honor my father and my mother" - it's hard to accept his sincerity. We may think certain customs of our family or fatherland are silly, or unnecessary, or even short-sighted, but unless it's necessary to violate them for a greater good, they call for our forbearance and respect. Willful violation is a kind of ungrateful self-orphaning. I'm not sure that Tobias ever adequately makes the case that this was necessary, and it sews a dubious thread through his vision of growing up. Perhaps he's still younger than he thinks he is.
Still, stimulating, observant, and filled with wide horizons. Four stars.
The memoir is told through a series of essays, wide-ranging, amusing, reflective, erudite, and pragmatic by turns. The essay format makes it easy to pick up and put down again, though it's engaging enough to read in one or two sittings, as I did while traveling.
Part of the authors's quest - which he claims was not intentional at the outset - is to outgrow his Anglophilia, and unfortunately I thought this element came across less like maturity and more like juvenile transgressivism. To see the faults and veins of weakness in one's own country, culture, and patrimony is part of growing up. To criticize can be a form of service. But the author describes himself violating a cultural taboo on purpose to grow out of his Anglo prejudices. Considering the final words in his acknowledgment are "Lastly, I would honor my father and my mother" - it's hard to accept his sincerity. We may think certain customs of our family or fatherland are silly, or unnecessary, or even short-sighted, but unless it's necessary to violate them for a greater good, they call for our forbearance and respect. Willful violation is a kind of ungrateful self-orphaning. I'm not sure that Tobias ever adequately makes the case that this was necessary, and it sews a dubious thread through his vision of growing up. Perhaps he's still younger than he thinks he is.
Still, stimulating, observant, and filled with wide horizons. Four stars.
Review of advance copy received from Author
A singular memoir of a Foreign Legionnaire who wanted the world's end, but found himself in a different world that “conspired to keep us safe… and largely succeeded.”
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews