What do you think?
Rate this book
Novel Detectives Mystery #2
A Death in the Dark
An assistant athletics coach is found murdered at Redwood Grove High School and all evidence points one way—but the Novel Detectives are about to face their most puzzling case yet.
When beloved local teacher and track coach Josh Bynum stumbles into the Secret Bookcase distressed and with no memory of the previous night, Annie and Fletcher’s instincts tell them something doesn’t add up.
As the duo delve deeper into the tight-knit world of high school athletics, they uncover a web of secrets. Between ambitious parents, suspicious fundraising activities, and a star athlete with a lot to lose, everyone has something to hide.
Annie and Fletcher will need all their investigative skills and the support of their Redwood Grove friends if they’re to solve this mystery. Has Josh been set up? And what if there’s a clever killer somewhere in their beloved hometown, who might decide to target them next?
Perfect for fans of Lauren Elliott, Merryn Allingham and M.C. Beaton, this latest installment in Ellie Alexander’s new series combines small-town charm with a twisty ‘just one more chapter’ mystery that will keep you guessing until the final page.
When beloved local teacher and track coach Josh Bynum stumbles into the Secret Bookcase distressed and with no memory of the previous night, Annie and Fletcher’s instincts tell them something doesn’t add up.
As the duo delve deeper into the tight-knit world of high school athletics, they uncover a web of secrets. Between ambitious parents, suspicious fundraising activities, and a star athlete with a lot to lose, everyone has something to hide.
Annie and Fletcher will need all their investigative skills and the support of their Redwood Grove friends if they’re to solve this mystery. Has Josh been set up? And what if there’s a clever killer somewhere in their beloved hometown, who might decide to target them next?
Perfect for fans of Lauren Elliott, Merryn Allingham and M.C. Beaton, this latest installment in Ellie Alexander’s new series combines small-town charm with a twisty ‘just one more chapter’ mystery that will keep you guessing until the final page.
279 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 21, 2026
269 people are currently reading
294 people want to read
About the author
Ellie Alexander
85 books3,142 followersEllie is a voracious storyteller and a lover of words and all things bookish. She believes that stories have the ability to transport and transform us. With over forty published novels and counting, her goal is to tell stories that provide points of connection, escape, and understanding.
She loves inhabiting someone else’s skin through the pages of a book and is passionate about helping writers find their unique storytelling lens. As a writing teacher and coach, she guides writers in crafting the story they’ve always wanted to tell while navigating the path to publication that’s right for them.
Find out more about Ellie and her books by visiting her website at: http://www.elliealexander.co/ or following her on social media—
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ellie_alexa...
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliealexande...
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/elliealexande...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/elliealexand...
Pinterest:
https://www.pinterest.com/elliealexan...
She loves inhabiting someone else’s skin through the pages of a book and is passionate about helping writers find their unique storytelling lens. As a writing teacher and coach, she guides writers in crafting the story they’ve always wanted to tell while navigating the path to publication that’s right for them.
Find out more about Ellie and her books by visiting her website at: http://www.elliealexander.co/ or following her on social media—
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ellie_alexa...
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliealexande...
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/elliealexande...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/elliealexand...
Pinterest:
https://www.pinterest.com/elliealexan...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 135 reviews
May 1, 2026
(3.75 stars)
Thank you to Storm Publishing for the opportunity to read a review copy of A Death In The Dark by Ellie Alexander. It’s the second book in the Novel Detectives series, which is itself a spin-off of an earlier series featuring the same characters! That being said, I think you’d be okay reading this without having read the prior book(s).
Annie and Fletcher are still running the Secret Bookcase bookstore, but now they have their own detective agency, Novel Detectives. A case comes to them, when a distraught running coach from the local high school comes to their office, with his hands covered in blood. He says he doesn’t know what happened and can they help him figure out why he’s covered in blood!
Their investigation takes them into the world of competitive high school athletics. I enjoyed this aspect quite a bit, being a (former) runner myself, although I never ran back when I was in school. But I’m familiar with track meets and timing chips and warmups and all the technology around running, along with the need to raise funds over and above the usually inadequate school budget. This was an interesting case, with various suspects, once they discover a body. Did the coach, their client, do it or was he being set up and why?
The returning characters are all people I wouldn’t mind spending some time with. I especially liked the high school student who works part-time at the bookstore, Ash. I hope we will see more of him in future installments of this series.
I know this is a cozy mystery series, but I do find that there’s a bit too much description throughout the book - what everyone is wearing, and so forth. I kind of skimmed those descriptions.
As in the Secret Bookcase series, there is a continuing mystery that carries over from book one to this one, and since it’s still not resolved, I imagine we’ll see more about it in the third book in the future.
Thank you to Storm Publishing for the opportunity to read a review copy of A Death In The Dark by Ellie Alexander. It’s the second book in the Novel Detectives series, which is itself a spin-off of an earlier series featuring the same characters! That being said, I think you’d be okay reading this without having read the prior book(s).
Annie and Fletcher are still running the Secret Bookcase bookstore, but now they have their own detective agency, Novel Detectives. A case comes to them, when a distraught running coach from the local high school comes to their office, with his hands covered in blood. He says he doesn’t know what happened and can they help him figure out why he’s covered in blood!
Their investigation takes them into the world of competitive high school athletics. I enjoyed this aspect quite a bit, being a (former) runner myself, although I never ran back when I was in school. But I’m familiar with track meets and timing chips and warmups and all the technology around running, along with the need to raise funds over and above the usually inadequate school budget. This was an interesting case, with various suspects, once they discover a body. Did the coach, their client, do it or was he being set up and why?
The returning characters are all people I wouldn’t mind spending some time with. I especially liked the high school student who works part-time at the bookstore, Ash. I hope we will see more of him in future installments of this series.
I know this is a cozy mystery series, but I do find that there’s a bit too much description throughout the book - what everyone is wearing, and so forth. I kind of skimmed those descriptions.
As in the Secret Bookcase series, there is a continuing mystery that carries over from book one to this one, and since it’s still not resolved, I imagine we’ll see more about it in the third book in the future.
April 30, 2026
4.5⭐
Ellie Alexander's books are always fantastic and I loved this second Novel Detective book. Annie and Fletcher's new client claims to not know why he had blood all over his hands, but they shortly found his assistant coach murdered. There's a number of solid suspects and getting to the solution was a wonderful reading experience.
Ellie Alexander's books are always fantastic and I loved this second Novel Detective book. Annie and Fletcher's new client claims to not know why he had blood all over his hands, but they shortly found his assistant coach murdered. There's a number of solid suspects and getting to the solution was a wonderful reading experience.
March 25, 2026
~thank you to NetGalley & Storm publishing for giving me an arc in exchange for an honest review~
The beginning of the book follows Josh, who is completely confused and unable to remember what happened the night before. He wakes up with blood on his hands and clothes. Throughout the whole book, you start to question… is Josh really innocent or is it all an act? The mystery of the whole novel was very intriguing. I gave it 3 stars solely because some parts were super slow for me and I felt bored. It did pick up towards the end though.
I also didn’t realize this was book 2 in a series so hopefully it doesn’t matter that I didn’t read the first 😬
The beginning of the book follows Josh, who is completely confused and unable to remember what happened the night before. He wakes up with blood on his hands and clothes. Throughout the whole book, you start to question… is Josh really innocent or is it all an act? The mystery of the whole novel was very intriguing. I gave it 3 stars solely because some parts were super slow for me and I felt bored. It did pick up towards the end though.
I also didn’t realize this was book 2 in a series so hopefully it doesn’t matter that I didn’t read the first 😬
April 30, 2026
Great addition to the series! I enjoyed following along with Annie and Fletcher (mostly Annie) as she investigated the murder at the high school. The mystery was well-developed and was the main focus of the book, but this did not lack the trademark community immersion of cozies; I just wanted a little more world-building, which seems to be missing in this one (and overabundant in the Bakeshop series). The continuing mystery with Hal is interesting and I had hoped for more progress in that one as well. Looking forward to the next one.
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the review copy.
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the review copy.
April 30, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for providing me with an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I only discovered the joy that is an Ellie Alexander cozy mystery recently, when I was fortunate enough to be approved for the first book in this series. One book and I was hooked on her writing, the setting, and the characters. Coming across this one meant I automatically requested it, and I’m glad to report that I really enjoyed it as much as the first book.
To start with, the book is set in a quaint, picturesque small town in Northern California. Redwood Grove is the kind of town where you can walk anywhere, which kind of left me wishing that there was a town like that near me. Things are going well for Annie and Fletcher, both with the bookshop and their new detective agency. After their first case in the previous book, they have gotten some more clients, and this book starts them with taking on an unexpected new case: Josh, a local teacher and track coach stumbles into their office covered in blood with no memory of what happened since the track meet the night before.
Since Annie has a degree in criminology and a good relationship with the local bigwig at the police station, since she was Annie’s teacher and knows she is trained well. Naturally, Annie and Fletcher try to get as much information out of Josh as possible, and report this to Dr. Caldwell, head of the local police. Dr. Caldwell happens to be short-handed and asks the Novel Detectives to serve as consultants. So they now have a new case to work on, along with their regular duties at their store, The Secret Bookcase. Fortunately, they have a really great staff who is willing to hold down the fort as Annie and Fletcher investigate.
I really adore the dynamic between Annie and Fletcher, who have been friends for a very long time. They’re the kind of friends where a look is more than enough to convey a thought, and if you’ve ever had a friend like that, you’re going to love these two. Both are quirky in their own way, and their personalities complement each other both as friends and detective partners. Each brings their own strengths to the table and I really liked how they are able to adopt a flexible approach to their investigation—sometimes they both go, and others they practice a divide-and-conquer strategy. It makes for solid investigating, and I loved that they weren’t afraid to lean on their instincts, especially since they have good instincts.
The story itself was one that was easy to lose myself in. It maintained a pretty fast pace, with plenty of twists and turns—some I was able to see coming, and others blindsided me. I also enjoyed getting to see the other hobbies and interests of the main characters outside of reading and being detectives. Annie’s creativity is on display with her seemingly endless supply of fun activities to host at the bookshop, and we get to see her sweet romance with Liam, the owner of the local bar. Fletcher is considering a creative writing program, and I thought it was really cool that he and his girlfriend had a video date and played Chopped against each other. That makes me want to have a Chopped challenge!
Overall, this was a fun story that moved fast and kept me glued to the pages. I love seeing the characters grow in confidence both in their careers and their personal pursuits, as well as in their relationships. The end does leave the reader with a major cliffhanger, but I have full faith that future books in this series will be just as enjoyable as this one is. In the meantime, I’ll be searching for a quaint and quirky little town of my own to move to, since Redwood Grove sounds so awesome.
Bottom line: A read set in the coolest small town, where the mystery takes center stage even with everything else going on, populated with characters you can't help but love.
I only discovered the joy that is an Ellie Alexander cozy mystery recently, when I was fortunate enough to be approved for the first book in this series. One book and I was hooked on her writing, the setting, and the characters. Coming across this one meant I automatically requested it, and I’m glad to report that I really enjoyed it as much as the first book.
To start with, the book is set in a quaint, picturesque small town in Northern California. Redwood Grove is the kind of town where you can walk anywhere, which kind of left me wishing that there was a town like that near me. Things are going well for Annie and Fletcher, both with the bookshop and their new detective agency. After their first case in the previous book, they have gotten some more clients, and this book starts them with taking on an unexpected new case: Josh, a local teacher and track coach stumbles into their office covered in blood with no memory of what happened since the track meet the night before.
Since Annie has a degree in criminology and a good relationship with the local bigwig at the police station, since she was Annie’s teacher and knows she is trained well. Naturally, Annie and Fletcher try to get as much information out of Josh as possible, and report this to Dr. Caldwell, head of the local police. Dr. Caldwell happens to be short-handed and asks the Novel Detectives to serve as consultants. So they now have a new case to work on, along with their regular duties at their store, The Secret Bookcase. Fortunately, they have a really great staff who is willing to hold down the fort as Annie and Fletcher investigate.
I really adore the dynamic between Annie and Fletcher, who have been friends for a very long time. They’re the kind of friends where a look is more than enough to convey a thought, and if you’ve ever had a friend like that, you’re going to love these two. Both are quirky in their own way, and their personalities complement each other both as friends and detective partners. Each brings their own strengths to the table and I really liked how they are able to adopt a flexible approach to their investigation—sometimes they both go, and others they practice a divide-and-conquer strategy. It makes for solid investigating, and I loved that they weren’t afraid to lean on their instincts, especially since they have good instincts.
The story itself was one that was easy to lose myself in. It maintained a pretty fast pace, with plenty of twists and turns—some I was able to see coming, and others blindsided me. I also enjoyed getting to see the other hobbies and interests of the main characters outside of reading and being detectives. Annie’s creativity is on display with her seemingly endless supply of fun activities to host at the bookshop, and we get to see her sweet romance with Liam, the owner of the local bar. Fletcher is considering a creative writing program, and I thought it was really cool that he and his girlfriend had a video date and played Chopped against each other. That makes me want to have a Chopped challenge!
Overall, this was a fun story that moved fast and kept me glued to the pages. I love seeing the characters grow in confidence both in their careers and their personal pursuits, as well as in their relationships. The end does leave the reader with a major cliffhanger, but I have full faith that future books in this series will be just as enjoyable as this one is. In the meantime, I’ll be searching for a quaint and quirky little town of my own to move to, since Redwood Grove sounds so awesome.
Bottom line: A read set in the coolest small town, where the mystery takes center stage even with everything else going on, populated with characters you can't help but love.
April 28, 2026
3.5 stars. Didn't love the story of this one as much.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Murder, secrets, and a quiet little town that clearly has more drama than it lets on… because apparently Redwood Grove doesn’t believe in peaceful afternoons anymore. My name is Michele, and A Death in the Dark by Ellie Alexander completely pulled me back into the world of Annie and Fletcher in the best possible way. Published by Storm Publishing, thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the gifted ARC.
There’s something deliciously chaotic about a mystery that starts with someone literally stumbling into a bookstore covered in blood and claiming they can’t remember what happened. That’s exactly how Annie and Fletcher’s newest case begins, and from that moment on, the story never really lets you relax. Annie and Fletcher run the Secret Bookcase, a charming bookstore that doubles as their detective agency, and honestly it’s one of my favorite cozy mystery settings. Books, coffee nearby, and a mystery waiting to be solved? Sign me up.
When beloved teacher and track coach Josh Bynum arrives desperate and confused, the Novel Detectives quickly realize something isn’t adding up. Soon after, another coach from Redwood Grove High School is found murdered, and suddenly Annie and Fletcher are knee-deep in the complicated world of high school athletics. And let’s just say… the deeper they dig, the messier things get.
What I really enjoyed about this book is how the mystery unfolds layer by layer. At first it feels straightforward, but then you start meeting the parents who take competition a little too seriously, the teachers who seem to be hiding something, suspicious fundraising activities, and a star athlete with a lot riding on the outcome of the season. The tension quietly builds while Annie follows her instincts and Fletcher leans into his logical detective mindset.
Their partnership continues to be one of the highlights of the series. Annie has grown so much as a character. She’s confident, curious, and willing to push boundaries when something doesn’t sit right. Fletcher balances her perfectly with his calm reasoning and slightly Sherlock-style enthusiasm for gadgets and investigative tricks. Watching them work together feels natural and fun, like you’re tagging along on the investigation.
And then there’s Redwood Grove itself. This small town setting brings so much warmth to the story. Between visits to the Secret Bookcase, moments with friends, and Annie’s growing relationship with Liam, the book keeps that cozy atmosphere alive even while darker secrets start coming to the surface. It’s the kind of story that makes you feel comfortable and tense at the same time.
One line really stood out to me while reading:
“Everyone in a small town knows everyone else’s story… or at least the version they want you to believe.”
That quote perfectly captures the heart of this mystery. The deeper Annie and Fletcher look, the more they realize that almost everyone connected to the school has something to hide. Some secrets are small. Others are dangerous. And figuring out which ones matter becomes the real challenge.
The pacing kept me turning pages because every time I thought I had things figured out, another clue appeared that made me second guess everything. That’s exactly what I want from a cozy mystery. I love trying to solve the puzzle alongside the characters, and this one definitely kept me guessing.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
If you love cozy mysteries with bookshop settings, clever amateur sleuths, and a strong sense of community, this series is absolutely for you. Readers who enjoy authors like Lauren Elliott, Merryn Allingham, or M.C. Beaton will feel right at home in Redwood Grove. It’s cozy, smart, and just twisty enough to keep the mystery exciting.
Honestly, I’m already invested in Annie and Fletcher’s detective adventures, and I can’t wait to see what trouble they stumble into next.
Now tell me… when you’re reading a cozy mystery, do you try to solve the case before the characters do, or do you just sit back and enjoy the twists as they come?
#ADeathintheDark #EllieAlexander #NetGalley #StormPublishing #Bookstagram #BookReview #CozyMystery #MysteryReaders #ARCReader #BookCommunity #CurrentlyReading #BookishLife #MysteryBooks
There’s something deliciously chaotic about a mystery that starts with someone literally stumbling into a bookstore covered in blood and claiming they can’t remember what happened. That’s exactly how Annie and Fletcher’s newest case begins, and from that moment on, the story never really lets you relax. Annie and Fletcher run the Secret Bookcase, a charming bookstore that doubles as their detective agency, and honestly it’s one of my favorite cozy mystery settings. Books, coffee nearby, and a mystery waiting to be solved? Sign me up.
When beloved teacher and track coach Josh Bynum arrives desperate and confused, the Novel Detectives quickly realize something isn’t adding up. Soon after, another coach from Redwood Grove High School is found murdered, and suddenly Annie and Fletcher are knee-deep in the complicated world of high school athletics. And let’s just say… the deeper they dig, the messier things get.
What I really enjoyed about this book is how the mystery unfolds layer by layer. At first it feels straightforward, but then you start meeting the parents who take competition a little too seriously, the teachers who seem to be hiding something, suspicious fundraising activities, and a star athlete with a lot riding on the outcome of the season. The tension quietly builds while Annie follows her instincts and Fletcher leans into his logical detective mindset.
Their partnership continues to be one of the highlights of the series. Annie has grown so much as a character. She’s confident, curious, and willing to push boundaries when something doesn’t sit right. Fletcher balances her perfectly with his calm reasoning and slightly Sherlock-style enthusiasm for gadgets and investigative tricks. Watching them work together feels natural and fun, like you’re tagging along on the investigation.
And then there’s Redwood Grove itself. This small town setting brings so much warmth to the story. Between visits to the Secret Bookcase, moments with friends, and Annie’s growing relationship with Liam, the book keeps that cozy atmosphere alive even while darker secrets start coming to the surface. It’s the kind of story that makes you feel comfortable and tense at the same time.
One line really stood out to me while reading:
“Everyone in a small town knows everyone else’s story… or at least the version they want you to believe.”
That quote perfectly captures the heart of this mystery. The deeper Annie and Fletcher look, the more they realize that almost everyone connected to the school has something to hide. Some secrets are small. Others are dangerous. And figuring out which ones matter becomes the real challenge.
The pacing kept me turning pages because every time I thought I had things figured out, another clue appeared that made me second guess everything. That’s exactly what I want from a cozy mystery. I love trying to solve the puzzle alongside the characters, and this one definitely kept me guessing.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
If you love cozy mysteries with bookshop settings, clever amateur sleuths, and a strong sense of community, this series is absolutely for you. Readers who enjoy authors like Lauren Elliott, Merryn Allingham, or M.C. Beaton will feel right at home in Redwood Grove. It’s cozy, smart, and just twisty enough to keep the mystery exciting.
Honestly, I’m already invested in Annie and Fletcher’s detective adventures, and I can’t wait to see what trouble they stumble into next.
Now tell me… when you’re reading a cozy mystery, do you try to solve the case before the characters do, or do you just sit back and enjoy the twists as they come?
#ADeathintheDark #EllieAlexander #NetGalley #StormPublishing #Bookstagram #BookReview #CozyMystery #MysteryReaders #ARCReader #BookCommunity #CurrentlyReading #BookishLife #MysteryBooks
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A Death in the Dark by Ellie Alexander
Synopsis /
An assistant athletics coach is found murdered at Redwood Grove High School and all evidence points one way—but the Novel Detectives are about to face their most puzzling case yet.
When beloved local teacher and track coach Josh Bynum stumbles into the Secret Bookcase distressed and with no memory of the previous night, Annie and Fletcher’s instincts tell them something doesn’t add up.
As the duo delve deeper into the tight-knit world of high school athletics, they uncover a web of secrets. Between ambitious parents, suspicious fundraising activities, and a star athlete with a lot to lose, everyone has something to hide.
Annie and Fletcher will need all their investigative skills and the support of their Redwood Grove friends if they’re to solve this mystery. Has Josh been set up? And what if there’s a clever killer somewhere in their beloved hometown, who might decide to target them next?
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Ellie Alexander for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Another day, another new cosy series, and another new author to tick off my list. All is well.
A Death in the Dark is the second book in the A Novel Detectives Mystery series which features bookstore owner Annie Murray and her business partner, Fletcher Hughes, as they transition from amateur sleuths to professional private investigators.
Situated right in the heart of the misty coastal town of Redwood Grove, and perched above Annie’s bookstore, The Secret Bookcase, the newly established Novel Detectives agency run by Annie and Fletcher is now officially open for business.
When a local Redwood Grove High School assistant athletics coach is found murdered on school grounds, initial suspicions fall heavily in favour of another teacher and track coach, Josh Bynum. It didn't help matters that Josh arrived in a state of distress, at the office of the Novel Detectives, covered in blood with no memory of how or why he was in that condition. Pleading with Annie and Fletcher to help him, the duo begin an investigation. Initially, the evidence is heavily incriminating, but the amateur sleuths rely on their instincts to prove that Josh had been set up.
As the pair work their investigation, they realise they are up against a very clever killer – someone who can (seemingly) shift the focus of their investigation onto others.
Work the problem, Annie. The best thing Fletcher and I could do was remain calm.
To solve this case Annie and Fletcher must decipher a web of secrets which they uncover within Redwood Grove High School's athletic department.
The Secret Bookshop Wins:
🕵️The plot is twisty and unpredictable. I don't really like the term 'page-turner', but I think it's quite fitting in this instance. The author keeps you guessing until the very end with the final reveal.
🕵️The suspects are suitably suspicious and our protagonists are intelligent and likeable.
🕵️One of my favourite characters is Professor Plum, the orange tabby cat. 😺
🕵️The fact that you could read this as a stand-alone is also a plus.
Will definitely go back and read book #1 and am looking forward to reading more by this author.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for April 21, 2026.
Synopsis /
An assistant athletics coach is found murdered at Redwood Grove High School and all evidence points one way—but the Novel Detectives are about to face their most puzzling case yet.
When beloved local teacher and track coach Josh Bynum stumbles into the Secret Bookcase distressed and with no memory of the previous night, Annie and Fletcher’s instincts tell them something doesn’t add up.
As the duo delve deeper into the tight-knit world of high school athletics, they uncover a web of secrets. Between ambitious parents, suspicious fundraising activities, and a star athlete with a lot to lose, everyone has something to hide.
Annie and Fletcher will need all their investigative skills and the support of their Redwood Grove friends if they’re to solve this mystery. Has Josh been set up? And what if there’s a clever killer somewhere in their beloved hometown, who might decide to target them next?
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Ellie Alexander for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Another day, another new cosy series, and another new author to tick off my list. All is well.
A Death in the Dark is the second book in the A Novel Detectives Mystery series which features bookstore owner Annie Murray and her business partner, Fletcher Hughes, as they transition from amateur sleuths to professional private investigators.
Situated right in the heart of the misty coastal town of Redwood Grove, and perched above Annie’s bookstore, The Secret Bookcase, the newly established Novel Detectives agency run by Annie and Fletcher is now officially open for business.
When a local Redwood Grove High School assistant athletics coach is found murdered on school grounds, initial suspicions fall heavily in favour of another teacher and track coach, Josh Bynum. It didn't help matters that Josh arrived in a state of distress, at the office of the Novel Detectives, covered in blood with no memory of how or why he was in that condition. Pleading with Annie and Fletcher to help him, the duo begin an investigation. Initially, the evidence is heavily incriminating, but the amateur sleuths rely on their instincts to prove that Josh had been set up.
As the pair work their investigation, they realise they are up against a very clever killer – someone who can (seemingly) shift the focus of their investigation onto others.
Work the problem, Annie. The best thing Fletcher and I could do was remain calm.
To solve this case Annie and Fletcher must decipher a web of secrets which they uncover within Redwood Grove High School's athletic department.
The Secret Bookshop Wins:
🕵️The plot is twisty and unpredictable. I don't really like the term 'page-turner', but I think it's quite fitting in this instance. The author keeps you guessing until the very end with the final reveal.
🕵️The suspects are suitably suspicious and our protagonists are intelligent and likeable.
🕵️One of my favourite characters is Professor Plum, the orange tabby cat. 😺
🕵️The fact that you could read this as a stand-alone is also a plus.
Will definitely go back and read book #1 and am looking forward to reading more by this author.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for April 21, 2026.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Title: A Death in the Dark
Series: Novel Detectives Mystery #2
Author: Ellie Alexander
Publisher: Storm Publishers
Genre: Cozy Mystery
Pub Date: April 21, 2026
My Rating: 5 Stars.
Pages 363
Story starts when Annie and Fletcher our novel detectives- who have their office in ‘the Secret Bookcase Mystery Bookshop’ hear someone pounding on their door first thing in the morning and he happens to be covered in blood. He tells them he woke up like this and has no memory - last night is blank!
He does remember his name is Josh Bynum and teaches English and is the head coach for the track and cross-country teams at Redwood Grove HS. They mention Ash a Junior at the high school who is a staff member and on the HS track team. He says yes that is why he is there as Ash mentioned your PI agency. Annie and Fletcher don’t like that their Detective Agency is referred to as PI but decided not to make an issue of it right now!
As things get more involved there is talk of cheating on the SAT --- This piqued my interest as I was a HS Guidance Counselor and also an SAT Supervisor and took great pains to make sure there was never any cheating. I fact, att4ended several College Board meeting for Sat Supervisor were there were workshops on the clever ways students tried to cheat. The most common was getting someone else to take the exam in their place.
As our duo dives deeper into the case, they come upon the dangers of high stakes competition and suspicious fundraising activities.
The ending was very exciting confirming that I do love this author and this series! Next is “Murder at the Mansion”’ and there is a sneak preview at the end of this book.
BTW: I am still trying to find a way to include the word Copacetic in a sentence. (I do like that word!)
I love ‘The Secret Staircase series’ so was almost as excited as Annie Murray and partner Fletcher Hughes about the opening of their detective agency above Anne’s beloved bookstore.
In “A Very Novel Murder’ our Novel Detectives took on their first case – investigating the mysterious disappearance of Agatha Christie herself – but soon find themselves on the trail of a potentially perfect murder... They had hopes of finding if Hal Christie indeed is Agatha Christie’s grandson, but that investigation took a backseat -touched upon at the end and once again ibn this story. I have a feeling it is going to be a recurring theme.
When I read A Body at the Book Fair which was #6 and conclusion to The Secret Bookcase series. I was disappointed but was delighted as in Ms. Alexander’s “A Letter From The Author’ that “The Novel Detectives’ series would be launched the end of 2025. SO I was soooo pleased when I got Book #1 in the series.
I just love Detectives Annie and Fletcher.
Want to thank NetGalley and as Ms. Alexander says -the outstanding team at Storm Publishing for granting me this widget.
Publishing Release Date scheduled for April 21, 2026.
Series: Novel Detectives Mystery #2
Author: Ellie Alexander
Publisher: Storm Publishers
Genre: Cozy Mystery
Pub Date: April 21, 2026
My Rating: 5 Stars.
Pages 363
Story starts when Annie and Fletcher our novel detectives- who have their office in ‘the Secret Bookcase Mystery Bookshop’ hear someone pounding on their door first thing in the morning and he happens to be covered in blood. He tells them he woke up like this and has no memory - last night is blank!
He does remember his name is Josh Bynum and teaches English and is the head coach for the track and cross-country teams at Redwood Grove HS. They mention Ash a Junior at the high school who is a staff member and on the HS track team. He says yes that is why he is there as Ash mentioned your PI agency. Annie and Fletcher don’t like that their Detective Agency is referred to as PI but decided not to make an issue of it right now!
As things get more involved there is talk of cheating on the SAT --- This piqued my interest as I was a HS Guidance Counselor and also an SAT Supervisor and took great pains to make sure there was never any cheating. I fact, att4ended several College Board meeting for Sat Supervisor were there were workshops on the clever ways students tried to cheat. The most common was getting someone else to take the exam in their place.
As our duo dives deeper into the case, they come upon the dangers of high stakes competition and suspicious fundraising activities.
The ending was very exciting confirming that I do love this author and this series! Next is “Murder at the Mansion”’ and there is a sneak preview at the end of this book.
BTW: I am still trying to find a way to include the word Copacetic in a sentence. (I do like that word!)
I love ‘The Secret Staircase series’ so was almost as excited as Annie Murray and partner Fletcher Hughes about the opening of their detective agency above Anne’s beloved bookstore.
In “A Very Novel Murder’ our Novel Detectives took on their first case – investigating the mysterious disappearance of Agatha Christie herself – but soon find themselves on the trail of a potentially perfect murder... They had hopes of finding if Hal Christie indeed is Agatha Christie’s grandson, but that investigation took a backseat -touched upon at the end and once again ibn this story. I have a feeling it is going to be a recurring theme.
When I read A Body at the Book Fair which was #6 and conclusion to The Secret Bookcase series. I was disappointed but was delighted as in Ms. Alexander’s “A Letter From The Author’ that “The Novel Detectives’ series would be launched the end of 2025. SO I was soooo pleased when I got Book #1 in the series.
I just love Detectives Annie and Fletcher.
Want to thank NetGalley and as Ms. Alexander says -the outstanding team at Storm Publishing for granting me this widget.
Publishing Release Date scheduled for April 21, 2026.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
5/5 stars: This Alexander's second entry in the Novel Detectives Mystery series, which is a Literary Cozy Mystery that takes place in California. Featuring a trained criminologist, who runs a detective agency above her beloved Agatha Christie-inspired mystery bookshop, and her sleuthing partner as they are hired by a local teacher and track coach to investigate an assistant athletics coach's murder. Unsure of their client, who showed up covered in blood and with no memory of the previous night, the duo will have to delve deep into the tight-knit world of high school athletics. After they uncover a web of secrets, they'll have to sift through ambitious parents, suspicious fundraising activities and a star athlete with a lot to lose to reveal the killer. The partners will need all their skills to solve this mystery before the killer strikes again.
With plenty of twists and turns, Alexander has masterfully crafted a mystery that deftly balances the suspects, clues and red herrings and will leave you pondering the whodunit until the final reveal. Alexander's also included an open-ended secondary mystery: the search for a friend's birth family. Heartfelt and humorous, Alexander's writing and character work are stellar; the characters are well-rounded and complex while remaining incredibly likable with a great secondary cast that's well crafted and uniquely voiced.
• Features Alexander's classic small-town charm sprinkled with plenty of bookish charm.
• For Animal Lovers: MC has a sweet cat and there are a pair of crows who reside on her bookshop's grounds.
While you could read this as a stand-alone, you'll gain so much more by reading the series from the beginning; so be sure to pick up book one, A Very Novel Murder. Just so you know, this series is a spin-off of the Secret Bookcase Mystery series, which starts with The Body in the Bookstore, and features the MC's journey to becoming a private detective. Highly recommend!
I received this eARC thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing in exchange for an honest review. Publishing dates are subject to change.
With plenty of twists and turns, Alexander has masterfully crafted a mystery that deftly balances the suspects, clues and red herrings and will leave you pondering the whodunit until the final reveal. Alexander's also included an open-ended secondary mystery: the search for a friend's birth family. Heartfelt and humorous, Alexander's writing and character work are stellar; the characters are well-rounded and complex while remaining incredibly likable with a great secondary cast that's well crafted and uniquely voiced.
• Features Alexander's classic small-town charm sprinkled with plenty of bookish charm.
• For Animal Lovers: MC has a sweet cat and there are a pair of crows who reside on her bookshop's grounds.
While you could read this as a stand-alone, you'll gain so much more by reading the series from the beginning; so be sure to pick up book one, A Very Novel Murder. Just so you know, this series is a spin-off of the Secret Bookcase Mystery series, which starts with The Body in the Bookstore, and features the MC's journey to becoming a private detective. Highly recommend!
I received this eARC thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing in exchange for an honest review. Publishing dates are subject to change.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Ellie Alexander’s A Death in the Dark, book two in the A Novel Detectives Mystery Series, is an easy, enjoyable cozy mystery that keeps things interesting without feeling too heavy.
This time, Annie and Fletcher are pulled into a case connected to a local high school, and right away you can tell something isn’t adding up. A coach is tied to a murder, but things don’t seem as clear as they look. Because it’s a small town, the situation feels more personal, which makes the mystery more engaging.
Annie is still a strong lead. She follows her instincts and really tries to understand what’s going on instead of jumping to conclusions. Fletcher works well with her, and their partnership is one of the best parts of the book. They balance each other out, and their teamwork feels natural, not forced.
The high school setting adds something new to the story. It brings in pressure from sports, parents, and expectations, which creates a lot of possible reasons for things to go wrong. As Annie and Fletcher dig deeper, it becomes clear that a lot of people are hiding things.
The mystery itself is easy to follow but still keeps you guessing. There are enough suspects and twists to keep it interesting, especially with the question of whether the wrong person is being blamed. That part really keeps the story moving.
The pacing is steady. It doesn’t rush, but it also doesn’t drag. You get time to follow the clues and understand what’s happening, while still wanting to keep reading to see how it all plays out.
The writing is simple and easy to read. The dialogue feels natural, and there’s a nice mix of light moments and suspense. It’s the kind of book you can relax with but still stay fully interested in.
At its core, A Death in the Dark is about not taking things at face value. It shows how easy it is to assume something is true—and how important it is to look a little deeper.
If you like cozy mysteries with strong characters and a small-town feel, this is a good one. It has a similar vibe to The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman and Still Life by Louise Penny.
Final Thoughts:
A Death in the Dark is a solid follow-up with a good mystery and characters you enjoy spending time with. It’s a simple, satisfying read that keeps you guessing without overcomplicating things.
This time, Annie and Fletcher are pulled into a case connected to a local high school, and right away you can tell something isn’t adding up. A coach is tied to a murder, but things don’t seem as clear as they look. Because it’s a small town, the situation feels more personal, which makes the mystery more engaging.
Annie is still a strong lead. She follows her instincts and really tries to understand what’s going on instead of jumping to conclusions. Fletcher works well with her, and their partnership is one of the best parts of the book. They balance each other out, and their teamwork feels natural, not forced.
The high school setting adds something new to the story. It brings in pressure from sports, parents, and expectations, which creates a lot of possible reasons for things to go wrong. As Annie and Fletcher dig deeper, it becomes clear that a lot of people are hiding things.
The mystery itself is easy to follow but still keeps you guessing. There are enough suspects and twists to keep it interesting, especially with the question of whether the wrong person is being blamed. That part really keeps the story moving.
The pacing is steady. It doesn’t rush, but it also doesn’t drag. You get time to follow the clues and understand what’s happening, while still wanting to keep reading to see how it all plays out.
The writing is simple and easy to read. The dialogue feels natural, and there’s a nice mix of light moments and suspense. It’s the kind of book you can relax with but still stay fully interested in.
At its core, A Death in the Dark is about not taking things at face value. It shows how easy it is to assume something is true—and how important it is to look a little deeper.
If you like cozy mysteries with strong characters and a small-town feel, this is a good one. It has a similar vibe to The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman and Still Life by Louise Penny.
Final Thoughts:
A Death in the Dark is a solid follow-up with a good mystery and characters you enjoy spending time with. It’s a simple, satisfying read that keeps you guessing without overcomplicating things.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I’ve got to had it to Annie and Fletcher. When a seemingly confused potential client shows up not only agitated but covered with blood, they don’t even flinch. Instead, they sit him down and start asking questions to gather timely information while trying to calm him. Could Josh have killed his fellow high school track coach and blanked it out of his mind?
While I'll admit to not being too fond of Annie when the original series began, she quickly won me over. Let's face it. She had a lot to work through. She found her niche at the Secret Bookcase and has blossomed into not just a first class bookshop owner but a licensed private detective with Fletcher, he of all things Sherlock, with both still managing to run the bookshop and their Novel Detective practice. The book segues from the tense encounter with the bloody client-to-be to cozy moments in the bookshop and with friends, giving it an interesting vibe. Annie's romance with Liam has also blossomed and, of course, she can't resist popping in and out of friend Pri's coffee shop frequently. I enjoy the regulars, including relative newbie hires at the bookshop, making this a likable, character driven read for me.
Bottom line, this is a fun read with ups and downs and, yes, even lots of bookshop talk in the midst of an investigation. I don't want to reveal much more of the plot and ruin your sleuthing other than to say the suspect list quickly widens. Could seemingly low-key English teacher Josh have actually killed Rob? And, speaking of schools, what is going on there? You'll learn a bit about track events, by the way, ranging from the choice of running shoes to how events are timed. Yet, in the midst of normal, every day life, things are not copacetic, a word Fletcher throws out at Annie. Too bad she didn't listen to him when he also made the suggestion that at the very least she should carry pepper spray. Yep, you guessed it. Annie once again finds herself in danger. And, oh, for long time readers, the side story of Hal's quest to prove his heritage also moves along with some intriguing revelations. Thanks #StormPublishing for introducing me to Annie and allowing me early peeks into how her life as a bookshop owner/private investigator is going.
While I'll admit to not being too fond of Annie when the original series began, she quickly won me over. Let's face it. She had a lot to work through. She found her niche at the Secret Bookcase and has blossomed into not just a first class bookshop owner but a licensed private detective with Fletcher, he of all things Sherlock, with both still managing to run the bookshop and their Novel Detective practice. The book segues from the tense encounter with the bloody client-to-be to cozy moments in the bookshop and with friends, giving it an interesting vibe. Annie's romance with Liam has also blossomed and, of course, she can't resist popping in and out of friend Pri's coffee shop frequently. I enjoy the regulars, including relative newbie hires at the bookshop, making this a likable, character driven read for me.
Bottom line, this is a fun read with ups and downs and, yes, even lots of bookshop talk in the midst of an investigation. I don't want to reveal much more of the plot and ruin your sleuthing other than to say the suspect list quickly widens. Could seemingly low-key English teacher Josh have actually killed Rob? And, speaking of schools, what is going on there? You'll learn a bit about track events, by the way, ranging from the choice of running shoes to how events are timed. Yet, in the midst of normal, every day life, things are not copacetic, a word Fletcher throws out at Annie. Too bad she didn't listen to him when he also made the suggestion that at the very least she should carry pepper spray. Yep, you guessed it. Annie once again finds herself in danger. And, oh, for long time readers, the side story of Hal's quest to prove his heritage also moves along with some intriguing revelations. Thanks #StormPublishing for introducing me to Annie and allowing me early peeks into how her life as a bookshop owner/private investigator is going.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
*Thank you Netgalley for this ARC e-copy*
Could their latest client be a killer? Novel detectives Annie Murray and Fletcher are on the case when a dead body appears at the running track of a local high school. Tension rises as Annie and Fletcher doubt the man, their client, who states he can't remember anything from the evening's events. Covered in blood from the victim and completely unhinged, the man recounts his memories of the days events, but it leaves the detectives wondering who really killed Josh Bynam?
Overall review:
I'm a big fan of Ellie Alexander. What I enjoy most about her cozy mysteries is the small town charm of Redwood Grove, the calm and professional demeanour of Annie, and the cozy vibes from her found family at the mystery bookshop. I've finished all of the series of the Body in a Bookstore. This is book 2 in the Novel Detectives Series which is a continuing series from the first series. While you can read the book as a standalone, it would be worthwhile to read the entire series or listen to the audiobooks which are great!
A few comments on plot:
In Ellie's series, there is an overarching mystery plot, and each individual book has a smaller mystery to uncover not always related to the overaching plot. I will say, I much preferred the plot in the first book in the Novel Detextives Mystery series. The overarching mystery is captivating which involves Hal, the bookshop owner, and his origin story of potentially being related to Agatha Christie. I wanted more of that overarching plot inside this book, but it we didn't learn much with that plotline. Instead, we learned about the mystery of the found body and the politics of the track coach. I didn't care much for the high school politics or the characters that were involved. I found the stakes were very high for what actually happened and questioned the motives behind the murder.
I always enjoy Annie and Liam's dynamic (the love interest) and Fletcher and Annie's camaraderie. Overall, it's a good book, but I think I will wait until book 3 to see how the overarching plot pans out. I also think the audiobook version would suit my reading preferences over an ebook.
Could their latest client be a killer? Novel detectives Annie Murray and Fletcher are on the case when a dead body appears at the running track of a local high school. Tension rises as Annie and Fletcher doubt the man, their client, who states he can't remember anything from the evening's events. Covered in blood from the victim and completely unhinged, the man recounts his memories of the days events, but it leaves the detectives wondering who really killed Josh Bynam?
Overall review:
I'm a big fan of Ellie Alexander. What I enjoy most about her cozy mysteries is the small town charm of Redwood Grove, the calm and professional demeanour of Annie, and the cozy vibes from her found family at the mystery bookshop. I've finished all of the series of the Body in a Bookstore. This is book 2 in the Novel Detectives Series which is a continuing series from the first series. While you can read the book as a standalone, it would be worthwhile to read the entire series or listen to the audiobooks which are great!
A few comments on plot:
In Ellie's series, there is an overarching mystery plot, and each individual book has a smaller mystery to uncover not always related to the overaching plot. I will say, I much preferred the plot in the first book in the Novel Detextives Mystery series. The overarching mystery is captivating which involves Hal, the bookshop owner, and his origin story of potentially being related to Agatha Christie. I wanted more of that overarching plot inside this book, but it we didn't learn much with that plotline. Instead, we learned about the mystery of the found body and the politics of the track coach. I didn't care much for the high school politics or the characters that were involved. I found the stakes were very high for what actually happened and questioned the motives behind the murder.
I always enjoy Annie and Liam's dynamic (the love interest) and Fletcher and Annie's camaraderie. Overall, it's a good book, but I think I will wait until book 3 to see how the overarching plot pans out. I also think the audiobook version would suit my reading preferences over an ebook.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
🎧 Listened in audio
📢 Narrated by Ellen Quay
⏱ Duration: 6 hours
🏷️ Publisher: Storm Publishing
📅 Release Date: April 21, 2026
✨ ARC received via NetGalley
If you’ve read her Secret Bookcase Mystery series, you’ll recognize the rhythm immediately: a contained, book-specific mystery layered over a slow-burn overarching thread. This time, it’s Hal’s Agatha Christie lineage dangling in the background, and I’m already curious how far she’s willing to push that idea. Will she commit and make Hal Agatha's grandson, or keep it tantalizingly vague to avoid stepping on any real-life toes? Either way, I'm invested enough to keep listening.
The central mystery here is easy listening. This is the kind of audiobook you can press play on while folding laundry or commuting and never feel lost. The high school athletics backdrop is cozy mystery comfort food. You've got the overbearing parents, the golden child athlete, the fundraising scandal that smells fishy. It's not groundbreaking, but in a cozy, that's not a bad thing. You don't want disturbing. You want familiar with a twist, and Alexander delivers. Ellen Quay's narration helps; she's got a warm, steady voice that makes this the perfect bedtime listen (in the best way! I mean that as a compliment).
What surprised me most is that I didn’t bounce off this one like I almost did with book one. It’s still low-stakes in terms of emotional intensity, but there’s something comforting about that. It’s familiar, steady, and just twisty enough to keep your brain lightly ticking without demanding full attention.
Would I recommend it?
If you’re in the mood for a cozy mystery that doesn’t demand your full soul (or your full attention span), this works. It’s a “press play and vibe” kind of listen. Ellen Quay's narration is the cherry on top. Not every book needs to blow your mind; sometimes you just need a pleasant escape into small-town murder and literary history. And if you enjoy series with an ongoing thread tying everything together, this one is shaping up nicely.
📢 Narrated by Ellen Quay
⏱ Duration: 6 hours
🏷️ Publisher: Storm Publishing
📅 Release Date: April 21, 2026
✨ ARC received via NetGalley
If you’ve read her Secret Bookcase Mystery series, you’ll recognize the rhythm immediately: a contained, book-specific mystery layered over a slow-burn overarching thread. This time, it’s Hal’s Agatha Christie lineage dangling in the background, and I’m already curious how far she’s willing to push that idea. Will she commit and make Hal Agatha's grandson, or keep it tantalizingly vague to avoid stepping on any real-life toes? Either way, I'm invested enough to keep listening.
The central mystery here is easy listening. This is the kind of audiobook you can press play on while folding laundry or commuting and never feel lost. The high school athletics backdrop is cozy mystery comfort food. You've got the overbearing parents, the golden child athlete, the fundraising scandal that smells fishy. It's not groundbreaking, but in a cozy, that's not a bad thing. You don't want disturbing. You want familiar with a twist, and Alexander delivers. Ellen Quay's narration helps; she's got a warm, steady voice that makes this the perfect bedtime listen (in the best way! I mean that as a compliment).
What surprised me most is that I didn’t bounce off this one like I almost did with book one. It’s still low-stakes in terms of emotional intensity, but there’s something comforting about that. It’s familiar, steady, and just twisty enough to keep your brain lightly ticking without demanding full attention.
Would I recommend it?
If you’re in the mood for a cozy mystery that doesn’t demand your full soul (or your full attention span), this works. It’s a “press play and vibe” kind of listen. Ellen Quay's narration is the cherry on top. Not every book needs to blow your mind; sometimes you just need a pleasant escape into small-town murder and literary history. And if you enjoy series with an ongoing thread tying everything together, this one is shaping up nicely.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Another cozy mystery win from Ellie Alexander! This is the second installment in the Novel Detectives series, and I can confidently say it’s just as strong—if not stronger—than the first.
The story kicks off with a bang when a blood-soaked man stumbles into the Secret Bookcase bookshop, immediately pulling Annie and Fletcher into a new case. Josh, a high school teacher and track coach, claims he has no memory of the night before—but there’s a murder, and all signs seem to point to him. From there, the mystery unfolds into a layered story of greed, pressure, and secrets hiding beneath the surface of Redwood Grove High.
What I continue to love about this series is how Ellie Alexander balances cozy charm with a darker, more suspenseful edge. One minute you’re wrapped up in the warmth of the bookshop and its lovable cast, and the next, the tension creeps in and has you second-guessing everyone. I genuinely didn’t have this one figured out, which always makes a mystery that much more fun.
Annie and Fletcher are such a great duo—I love how naturally they slip into detective mode, even in the most unexpected (and slightly alarming) situations. Annie, especially, has really grown on me. Watching her come into her own—both as a bookshop owner and a detective—has been one of my favorite parts of this series. And the supporting cast (plus those cozy stops at Pri’s coffee shop) just add to the charm.
There’s also a really interesting thread around high school athletics, academic pressure, and the lengths people will go to succeed, which added an extra layer of depth to the mystery.
Overall, this is a cozy, twisty read with heart, strong character development, and just enough danger to keep you flipping pages late into the night. If you loved book one, don’t hesitate—this is a must-read.
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the eARC. I’m already looking forward to book three!
The story kicks off with a bang when a blood-soaked man stumbles into the Secret Bookcase bookshop, immediately pulling Annie and Fletcher into a new case. Josh, a high school teacher and track coach, claims he has no memory of the night before—but there’s a murder, and all signs seem to point to him. From there, the mystery unfolds into a layered story of greed, pressure, and secrets hiding beneath the surface of Redwood Grove High.
What I continue to love about this series is how Ellie Alexander balances cozy charm with a darker, more suspenseful edge. One minute you’re wrapped up in the warmth of the bookshop and its lovable cast, and the next, the tension creeps in and has you second-guessing everyone. I genuinely didn’t have this one figured out, which always makes a mystery that much more fun.
Annie and Fletcher are such a great duo—I love how naturally they slip into detective mode, even in the most unexpected (and slightly alarming) situations. Annie, especially, has really grown on me. Watching her come into her own—both as a bookshop owner and a detective—has been one of my favorite parts of this series. And the supporting cast (plus those cozy stops at Pri’s coffee shop) just add to the charm.
There’s also a really interesting thread around high school athletics, academic pressure, and the lengths people will go to succeed, which added an extra layer of depth to the mystery.
Overall, this is a cozy, twisty read with heart, strong character development, and just enough danger to keep you flipping pages late into the night. If you loved book one, don’t hesitate—this is a must-read.
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the eARC. I’m already looking forward to book three!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A Death in the Dark by Ellie Alexander is the second book in the Novel Detectives mystery series and you can read it as a standalone book, although reading
A Very Novel Murder will introduce you to the main characters. The Secret Bookcase series will give you more insight into these characters.
One morning a blood covered Josh Bynum, Redwood Grove trach coach, comes to the Secret Bookcase, where Annie Murray and Fletcher Hughes have their detective agency, Novel Detectives, housed. He wants them to help him figure out what happened after the track meet the previous night and why he has blood on him. His story is shaky at best, and when they go to the high school and discover the body of the assistant coach, Rob Myers.
Many suspects are given besides Josh: The English department chair, Astrid, the principal, Maureen, the father of the head track star and booster club organizer, Neil, track star, Jillian, and Eddie, a coach from a rival school. There are plenty of shenanigans happening at the school to help solidify suspects, but for me there was only one viable suspect. I think readers will have a fun time sifting through the clues to find the killer.
On a side quest, Hal’s girlfriend Caroline has hired Annie and Fletcher to investigate Hal’s claim of being Agatha Christie’s grandson after finding a piece of jewelry that potentially belonged to Agatha. Caroline is wrong to ask them to invade Hal’s room to look for clues and she should just be upfront with him and tell him she wants to help him find answers.
As always, it is a delight to catch up with Annie’s friend, Pri, coffee shop owner, and boyfriend, Liam, pub owner. Inserting the crows into the story is always fun. These characters are interesting and Ms. Alexander has a way of bringing them to life.
Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
A Very Novel Murder will introduce you to the main characters. The Secret Bookcase series will give you more insight into these characters.
One morning a blood covered Josh Bynum, Redwood Grove trach coach, comes to the Secret Bookcase, where Annie Murray and Fletcher Hughes have their detective agency, Novel Detectives, housed. He wants them to help him figure out what happened after the track meet the previous night and why he has blood on him. His story is shaky at best, and when they go to the high school and discover the body of the assistant coach, Rob Myers.
Many suspects are given besides Josh: The English department chair, Astrid, the principal, Maureen, the father of the head track star and booster club organizer, Neil, track star, Jillian, and Eddie, a coach from a rival school. There are plenty of shenanigans happening at the school to help solidify suspects, but for me there was only one viable suspect. I think readers will have a fun time sifting through the clues to find the killer.
On a side quest, Hal’s girlfriend Caroline has hired Annie and Fletcher to investigate Hal’s claim of being Agatha Christie’s grandson after finding a piece of jewelry that potentially belonged to Agatha. Caroline is wrong to ask them to invade Hal’s room to look for clues and she should just be upfront with him and tell him she wants to help him find answers.
As always, it is a delight to catch up with Annie’s friend, Pri, coffee shop owner, and boyfriend, Liam, pub owner. Inserting the crows into the story is always fun. These characters are interesting and Ms. Alexander has a way of bringing them to life.
Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Death in the Dark by Ellie Alexander is a Novel Detectives mystery. Fletcher and Annie were just beginning their day when a man with bloody hands arrived, claiming he had amnesia and worrying that he had hurt someone. The pair calmed Josh down and made a plan. From there they left the bookstore to go to Josh’s apartment where everything was just as he had told them. They then went to the track field at the high school, and next to the equipment room where they did find a body. It was Rob, the assistant coach. Josh was hysterical. At this point they needed to call the police so Annie dialed Dr. Caldwell. The police arrived shortly along with an ambulance and Dr Caldwell collected the bagged and marked evidence Annie had already collected. Off they went to make a plan. It was not long before Annie was following leads and Fletcher was on the computer doing background research. It wasn’t too long before the entire town knew something had happened at the high school.
Decent mystery and good characters. There is a lot going on in this story beyond this mystery. Pri and Penny are close to opening their winery, Fletcher and Annie at yet to sneak into their boss’s apartment (at his girlfriend’s behest) to search for something that could lead them to proving (or disproving) that he was descended from Agatha Christie, Fletcher’s application to the Sherlock Holmes Institute that summer. Liam, Annie’s pub-owning boyfriend is ever-present both feeding her and worrying about her. The motive for the murder was convoluted and difficult to put together and harder to believe. It was a terrific read, as Alexander’s cozies always are.
I was invited to read A Death in the Dark by Storm Publishing. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #Netgalley #StormPublishing #EllieAlexander #DeathInTheDark
Decent mystery and good characters. There is a lot going on in this story beyond this mystery. Pri and Penny are close to opening their winery, Fletcher and Annie at yet to sneak into their boss’s apartment (at his girlfriend’s behest) to search for something that could lead them to proving (or disproving) that he was descended from Agatha Christie, Fletcher’s application to the Sherlock Holmes Institute that summer. Liam, Annie’s pub-owning boyfriend is ever-present both feeding her and worrying about her. The motive for the murder was convoluted and difficult to put together and harder to believe. It was a terrific read, as Alexander’s cozies always are.
I was invited to read A Death in the Dark by Storm Publishing. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #Netgalley #StormPublishing #EllieAlexander #DeathInTheDark
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Another delightful cosy mystery in the Novel Detective series.
Annie Murray and Fletcher Hughes run The Secret Bookshop in the quaint village of Redwood Grove, the bookshop not only offers books but holds events that bring the whole village together, tempted by coffee and cakes.
Annie, who has a degree in criminology, and Fletcher, an avid Sherlock Homes fan, also run a PI agency, The Novel Detectives and it is The Novel Detective that are needed when high school track coach, Josh Bynam, stumbles into the shop one morning, cover in blood and having no memory of how it got there.
The chief of police, Dr Cardwell, had been Annie's mentor at university and was now her friend, she was more than willing to accept help from Annie and Fletcher, especially when the body of assistant coach, Rob Myers, was found after a brutal attack.
Josh was the main suspect for Rob's murder, his story didn't add up, he was hiding something but was he the killer ? was he set up ? was he shielding someone ?
As this story unfolds the suspects are many, the track running community is cut throat, each runner trying to be the best, some pushed by aggressive parents, wealthy parents who would stop at nothing to bask in the success of their offspring, coaches who fought for the top jobs, school staff who wanted the best for their department, whatever the means.
Annie and Fletcher are determined to solve this mystery and find the killer and with the help of their close knit friends and the equally close knit community, who are all happy to share their gossip, the unwavering support of bar owner Liam, Annie's wonderful boyfriend, they begin to unravel the threads.
This is charming cosy mystery with just the right amount of angst, it has a good storyline and likeable characters.
Thank you Storm Publishing and Net Gallery for this ARC, my review is totally voluntary
Annie Murray and Fletcher Hughes run The Secret Bookshop in the quaint village of Redwood Grove, the bookshop not only offers books but holds events that bring the whole village together, tempted by coffee and cakes.
Annie, who has a degree in criminology, and Fletcher, an avid Sherlock Homes fan, also run a PI agency, The Novel Detectives and it is The Novel Detective that are needed when high school track coach, Josh Bynam, stumbles into the shop one morning, cover in blood and having no memory of how it got there.
The chief of police, Dr Cardwell, had been Annie's mentor at university and was now her friend, she was more than willing to accept help from Annie and Fletcher, especially when the body of assistant coach, Rob Myers, was found after a brutal attack.
Josh was the main suspect for Rob's murder, his story didn't add up, he was hiding something but was he the killer ? was he set up ? was he shielding someone ?
As this story unfolds the suspects are many, the track running community is cut throat, each runner trying to be the best, some pushed by aggressive parents, wealthy parents who would stop at nothing to bask in the success of their offspring, coaches who fought for the top jobs, school staff who wanted the best for their department, whatever the means.
Annie and Fletcher are determined to solve this mystery and find the killer and with the help of their close knit friends and the equally close knit community, who are all happy to share their gossip, the unwavering support of bar owner Liam, Annie's wonderful boyfriend, they begin to unravel the threads.
This is charming cosy mystery with just the right amount of angst, it has a good storyline and likeable characters.
Thank you Storm Publishing and Net Gallery for this ARC, my review is totally voluntary
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A DEATH IN THE DARK is the second book in the Novel Detectives Mysteries. Author Ellie Alexander knows how to start a story off with a bang and reel the reader in for an unputdownable read! She’s created a terrific protagonist in private investigator Annie Murray, along with her partner Fletcher. There’s a strong sense of community on the pages that makes the setting of Redwood Grove inviting. Annie is smart, tenacious, and meticulously runs both the Secret Bookcase bookshop and their private investigation company, Novel Detectives. On top of being a successful businesswoman, I admire how kind she is to her friends and employees, and even to their new client, Josh, who shows up unannounced, bloodstained, with no memory of how he got that way. Annie senses he’s hiding something, yet gives it her all to get to the bottom of why Josh’s assistant coach was murdered and who the culprit is, even after Josh is arrested for the crime.
With determination and skill, Annie and Fletcher dive into the investigation. I enjoy how well they work together, with Annie taking the lead. There are clues for the savvy armchair detective to follow, and plenty of suspects to keep the reader guessing. The author expertly weaves in some information about high school track and athletics, which adds to the authenticity of the storyline. There is also a running subplot thread of a mystery pertaining to the lineage of one of Annie’s dear friends. It’s a fascinating premise that has me waiting to find out the answers. If you enjoy strong characters, an inviting, cozy setting, and an intriguing mystery with a hint of darkness, then you’ll enjoy A Death in the Dark!
I was provided with an advance copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
With determination and skill, Annie and Fletcher dive into the investigation. I enjoy how well they work together, with Annie taking the lead. There are clues for the savvy armchair detective to follow, and plenty of suspects to keep the reader guessing. The author expertly weaves in some information about high school track and athletics, which adds to the authenticity of the storyline. There is also a running subplot thread of a mystery pertaining to the lineage of one of Annie’s dear friends. It’s a fascinating premise that has me waiting to find out the answers. If you enjoy strong characters, an inviting, cozy setting, and an intriguing mystery with a hint of darkness, then you’ll enjoy A Death in the Dark!
I was provided with an advance copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I was so excited to see book 2 in the Novel Detectives Mystery series. This series is sort of a spinoff of A Secret Bookcase Mystery series. Annie owns a bookstore named The Secret Bookcase, which I would love to visit. She has her criminology degree and is quite the sleuth. Since she has already been helping solve cases anyway, she and Fletcher decide to open the Novel Detective Agency above the bookstore.
A bloody man stumbles into the agency one morning with no memories of where the blood came from, and he asks for their help. Most people would run, but Annie and Fletch never even flinched. They just started asking questions, most importantly they had to figure out where the blood came from. It did not take long for this dynamic duo to figure out where the blood came from.
Once they come they find the body of the assistant track coach, the case and mystery goes full steam ahead. As usual, this author does a dynamic job of giving you many suspects to choose from, which is always fun for readers who like to do their own sleuthing. The world of high school athletics, and the drama that goes along with it, are front and center of this story. But even as you learn more about the track team and the school, the author will misdirect you quite frequently.
I adore this mystery series and the characters within it. I am a sucker for a good cozy mystery, and this one is made even more enticing because of all of the book references and the awesome bookstore.
You can never go wrong with this series, or this author for that matter. Armchair sleuths will enjoy trying to solve the mystery as each secret is revealed.
Thank you to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
A bloody man stumbles into the agency one morning with no memories of where the blood came from, and he asks for their help. Most people would run, but Annie and Fletch never even flinched. They just started asking questions, most importantly they had to figure out where the blood came from. It did not take long for this dynamic duo to figure out where the blood came from.
Once they come they find the body of the assistant track coach, the case and mystery goes full steam ahead. As usual, this author does a dynamic job of giving you many suspects to choose from, which is always fun for readers who like to do their own sleuthing. The world of high school athletics, and the drama that goes along with it, are front and center of this story. But even as you learn more about the track team and the school, the author will misdirect you quite frequently.
I adore this mystery series and the characters within it. I am a sucker for a good cozy mystery, and this one is made even more enticing because of all of the book references and the awesome bookstore.
You can never go wrong with this series, or this author for that matter. Armchair sleuths will enjoy trying to solve the mystery as each secret is revealed.
Thank you to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
4.5 stars
This is the second book in the Novel Detectives mystery series which is a spin-off from the Secret Bookcase Mystery series. I've been following new detectives and co-owners of The Secret Bookcase bookstore from the very beginning, but the first couple of chapters give enough backstory that new readers can easily catch up. Annie and Fletcher's latest case starts out in a very dramatic way - a man pounds on their door wanting to hire them and he's covered in blood and says he doesn't know why. After this exciting start, the investigation remains interesting as the detective duo tries to find out what really happened with this track coach and end up uncovering a hotbed of scandals at the local high school.
This series is so good! Annie and Fletcher are good friends and now business partners since they purchased the Agatha Christie themed bookstore from their former boss, Hal, who has retired. Their investigative styles complement each other and they make a great team. This book is focused on the case which I appreciated with just enough scenes with Annie's best friend and her boyfriend, as well as scenes in the bookstore to stay true to the series. It made for a faster-paced book that really kept my interest. I wasn't surprised by who the killer was but that didn't take away from my enjoyment of the book. There is a subplot that will continue onto the next book on a case that Annie and Fletcher are working on that involves Hal. I'm curious to see how this one pans out.
If you've read any of the prior books in this or in the original series, you'll love this one. I also highly recommend it to cozy fans who haven't tried it yet.
I received an advance copy of the ebook from Storm Publishing and NetGalley. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
This is the second book in the Novel Detectives mystery series which is a spin-off from the Secret Bookcase Mystery series. I've been following new detectives and co-owners of The Secret Bookcase bookstore from the very beginning, but the first couple of chapters give enough backstory that new readers can easily catch up. Annie and Fletcher's latest case starts out in a very dramatic way - a man pounds on their door wanting to hire them and he's covered in blood and says he doesn't know why. After this exciting start, the investigation remains interesting as the detective duo tries to find out what really happened with this track coach and end up uncovering a hotbed of scandals at the local high school.
This series is so good! Annie and Fletcher are good friends and now business partners since they purchased the Agatha Christie themed bookstore from their former boss, Hal, who has retired. Their investigative styles complement each other and they make a great team. This book is focused on the case which I appreciated with just enough scenes with Annie's best friend and her boyfriend, as well as scenes in the bookstore to stay true to the series. It made for a faster-paced book that really kept my interest. I wasn't surprised by who the killer was but that didn't take away from my enjoyment of the book. There is a subplot that will continue onto the next book on a case that Annie and Fletcher are working on that involves Hal. I'm curious to see how this one pans out.
If you've read any of the prior books in this or in the original series, you'll love this one. I also highly recommend it to cozy fans who haven't tried it yet.
I received an advance copy of the ebook from Storm Publishing and NetGalley. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
April 30, 2026
📖✨ BOOK REVIEW ✨📖
A Death in the Dark by Ellie Alexander ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 (3.25/5)
thank you to Storm Publishing, NetGalley, and the author for the eARC in exchange for an honest review 💌
summary: An assistant athletics coach is found murdered at Redwood Grove High, and while the evidence seems clear, nothing about the case feels right. When a beloved teacher and track coach turns up with no memory of the night, Annie and Fletcher dig into the tight-knit world of high school athletics, uncovering secrets, suspicious motives, and a web of lies. With a possible setup and a killer still at large, they will need to untangle the truth before it is too late.🏃🏻♂️💨
my review: this was such a cute, cozy mystery 🫖🌧️ it genuinely made me want to curl up with a fuzzy blanket and a hot tea during a thunderstorm. the vibes in this small town were adorable, like i want to live there immediately.🏡
i really loved the main character and her whole bookstore/private detective agency situation. she is absolutely living her best life and i was here for it.🕵🏻♀️📚
that said, my rating is a little lower for a few reasons. cozy mysteries just are not usually my go-to. i tend to crave more chaos, tension, and dread, so this felt a bit too soft for my usual taste, though it was a great palate cleanser.🧼
my biggest issue was the ending. i kept waiting for a bigger twist that never came. while i did go back and forth on who the killer was, some of the misleading clues felt like they were brushed off as coincidences instead of leading somewhere more impactful. it left me feeling like something was missing, and overall a bit unsatisfied.
overall: a quick, fun, super cozy read with lovable characters and charming vibes. perfect if you love cozy mysteries, even if it did not fully hit for me.☕️🔎
A Death in the Dark by Ellie Alexander ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 (3.25/5)
thank you to Storm Publishing, NetGalley, and the author for the eARC in exchange for an honest review 💌
summary: An assistant athletics coach is found murdered at Redwood Grove High, and while the evidence seems clear, nothing about the case feels right. When a beloved teacher and track coach turns up with no memory of the night, Annie and Fletcher dig into the tight-knit world of high school athletics, uncovering secrets, suspicious motives, and a web of lies. With a possible setup and a killer still at large, they will need to untangle the truth before it is too late.🏃🏻♂️💨
my review: this was such a cute, cozy mystery 🫖🌧️ it genuinely made me want to curl up with a fuzzy blanket and a hot tea during a thunderstorm. the vibes in this small town were adorable, like i want to live there immediately.🏡
i really loved the main character and her whole bookstore/private detective agency situation. she is absolutely living her best life and i was here for it.🕵🏻♀️📚
that said, my rating is a little lower for a few reasons. cozy mysteries just are not usually my go-to. i tend to crave more chaos, tension, and dread, so this felt a bit too soft for my usual taste, though it was a great palate cleanser.🧼
my biggest issue was the ending. i kept waiting for a bigger twist that never came. while i did go back and forth on who the killer was, some of the misleading clues felt like they were brushed off as coincidences instead of leading somewhere more impactful. it left me feeling like something was missing, and overall a bit unsatisfied.
overall: a quick, fun, super cozy read with lovable characters and charming vibes. perfect if you love cozy mysteries, even if it did not fully hit for me.☕️🔎
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The cosy elements are stronger in this second book of the series, as we see more focus on the bookstore and the small town community. That’s important to me as a reader. I enjoy cosies and do like small town cosies. But I also enjoy a good mystery. And the main mystery felt a bit underdeveloped. It could have benefited from stronger red herrings and a more engaging puzzle.
But cosies also are about the character journey as they seek to solve the mystery. The journey in this book was good. The two main characters balance each other well and I enjoy their interactions a lot. That’s a huge bonus in a series like this!
In a series, I also like to point out other characters that stood out for me in the book. Josh, Eddie, and Ash were highlights for me, and Ash in particular feels like a character who will likely be explored more in future entries. It’s good to have that supporting character and one-time character base written strongly, as it brings the community alive more.
I know it’s a core part of this series, but I’m still not entirely convinced by Annie and Fletcher running both a bookstore and a detective agency, especially when they also host events. I can’t wrap my head around how they could accomplish everything. I know it’s fiction and I should just go along for the ride. But it does make my brain itch a little!
Overall, this is a readable and pleasant entry in the series. But I want more about the overarching mystery. I find the structure similar to the first series in that respect.
Thanks to Netgalley for providing copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
But cosies also are about the character journey as they seek to solve the mystery. The journey in this book was good. The two main characters balance each other well and I enjoy their interactions a lot. That’s a huge bonus in a series like this!
In a series, I also like to point out other characters that stood out for me in the book. Josh, Eddie, and Ash were highlights for me, and Ash in particular feels like a character who will likely be explored more in future entries. It’s good to have that supporting character and one-time character base written strongly, as it brings the community alive more.
I know it’s a core part of this series, but I’m still not entirely convinced by Annie and Fletcher running both a bookstore and a detective agency, especially when they also host events. I can’t wrap my head around how they could accomplish everything. I know it’s fiction and I should just go along for the ride. But it does make my brain itch a little!
Overall, this is a readable and pleasant entry in the series. But I want more about the overarching mystery. I find the structure similar to the first series in that respect.
Thanks to Netgalley for providing copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A Death in the Dark has that familiar Redwood Grove warmth, but with a slightly darker undercurrent that makes this instalment especially compelling. Annie and Fletcher slip back into their easy rhythm straight away, their instincts sparking the moment Josh Bynum stumbles into the Secret Bookcase — shaken, confused, and with no memory of the night before. It’s a quietly unsettling opening, and it sets the tone for a mystery that feels more tangled and personal than ever.
The investigation pulls them into the world of high‑school athletics, where ambition, pressure, and carefully guarded secrets sit just beneath the surface. Between competitive parents, fundraising that doesn’t quite add up, and a star athlete with everything to lose, the sense that something is being carefully hidden grows with each chapter. I loved the way the clues unfold — gently, steadily — while the small‑town charm remains intact, even as suspicion begins to settle over familiar faces.
There’s a lovely balance here: the comfort of Redwood Grove’s community alongside the creeping fear that a clever killer might be moving among them. Annie and Fletcher’s determination to look past the obvious, especially when the evidence points too neatly in one direction, gives the story its emotional weight. By the time the truth comes into focus, the reveal feels both surprising and satisfyingly earned.
A cozy, twisty mystery with heart, friendship, and just enough darkness to keep you turning pages late into the night.
With thanks to Ellie Alexander, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
The investigation pulls them into the world of high‑school athletics, where ambition, pressure, and carefully guarded secrets sit just beneath the surface. Between competitive parents, fundraising that doesn’t quite add up, and a star athlete with everything to lose, the sense that something is being carefully hidden grows with each chapter. I loved the way the clues unfold — gently, steadily — while the small‑town charm remains intact, even as suspicion begins to settle over familiar faces.
There’s a lovely balance here: the comfort of Redwood Grove’s community alongside the creeping fear that a clever killer might be moving among them. Annie and Fletcher’s determination to look past the obvious, especially when the evidence points too neatly in one direction, gives the story its emotional weight. By the time the truth comes into focus, the reveal feels both surprising and satisfyingly earned.
A cozy, twisty mystery with heart, friendship, and just enough darkness to keep you turning pages late into the night.
With thanks to Ellie Alexander, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
When Annie Murray and Fletcher Hughes opened the Novel Detectives' office on the second floor of the Secret Bookcase, they pictured a stream of intriguing cases—some routine, others involving consulting with Dr. Caldwell, Annie's former criminology professor and now the lead detective on the Redwood Grove police force. They expected some clients would call to schedule appointments, while others might quietly ask at the front desk if Annie or Fletcher were available, or simply wander in to find the private investigator's office on their own. What they didn't expect was the shock of one morning when a new client arrived—a frantic man, his hands and clothing seemingly drenched in blood—a startling and gruesome sight.
I loved the opening of the new case. The author's sensory writing style effortlessly draws readers into the world of the Novel Detectives, evoking every sense. I would never have thought to pair the aromas of pizza and wisteria, but the author's unusual comparisons are so vivid and evocative that I can instantly picture—and almost smell—the scene. Their sensory details make even the most unexpected combinations feel perfectly natural and immersive. The plot is expertly woven, filled with twists, turns, and clever misdirections that kept me turning the pages. Without giving anything away, the resolution is both satisfying and clever, leaving me eagerly awaiting the author's next book—even before this one is officially out.
Thank you to Ellie Alexander, Storm Publishing, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an eARC of this novel.
I loved the opening of the new case. The author's sensory writing style effortlessly draws readers into the world of the Novel Detectives, evoking every sense. I would never have thought to pair the aromas of pizza and wisteria, but the author's unusual comparisons are so vivid and evocative that I can instantly picture—and almost smell—the scene. Their sensory details make even the most unexpected combinations feel perfectly natural and immersive. The plot is expertly woven, filled with twists, turns, and clever misdirections that kept me turning the pages. Without giving anything away, the resolution is both satisfying and clever, leaving me eagerly awaiting the author's next book—even before this one is officially out.
Thank you to Ellie Alexander, Storm Publishing, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an eARC of this novel.
April 19, 2026
Annie and Fletcher are back operating the Novel Detective Agency out of the Secret Bookcase bookshop. A blood covered Josh Bynum comes in asking for help, saying he doesn't remember how he got in this condition. Josh turns out to be the Head Track Coach and English teacher at Redwood Grove High. They end up back at the high school and find the body of the assistant track coach, Did Josh do it? Annie and Fletcher will have to sort out and through the secrets, lies and many suspects. We have a school administrator, the English Department Head (and Josh's boss), a rival coach, a student track star and her father, who is the head of the boosters and fundraising. They don't feel like they are getting the truth out of any of them, including their client Josh.
There is also the underlying story of the mystery of Hal's family and whether he is related to Agatha Christie. His new wife Caroline has secretly hired Annie and Fletcher to find out.
This was one I couldn't put down. I felt like it could have been any of them and was till end deciding on a suspect. They mystery was well crafted; the pace was good. Annie and Fletcher make a good time and have synergy. I do enjoy all the staff at the Secret Bookcase and of course, Liam and Pri. It's nice to see the relationship between characters grow and develop as the series continues.
Thank you to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for the chance to read this book and give my opinion.
There is also the underlying story of the mystery of Hal's family and whether he is related to Agatha Christie. His new wife Caroline has secretly hired Annie and Fletcher to find out.
This was one I couldn't put down. I felt like it could have been any of them and was till end deciding on a suspect. They mystery was well crafted; the pace was good. Annie and Fletcher make a good time and have synergy. I do enjoy all the staff at the Secret Bookcase and of course, Liam and Pri. It's nice to see the relationship between characters grow and develop as the series continues.
Thank you to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for the chance to read this book and give my opinion.
Review of advance copy
I have read several Ellie Alexander series. The Bakeshop series was the first series I read, but then I. began to read the Secret Bookcase Mysteries, which have now been transformed into the Novel Detectives series. These last two series contain the same characters, but with a different focus. The Novel Detectives are Annie and Fletcher as private detectives with their agency--Novel Detectives, located at their bookstore. The case that turns up on their doorstep early one morning Is a track coach, who is covered in blood but claiming he doesn't remember the events of the previous evening and has no idea whose blood covers him. The story behind the blood takes a while to unfold. I do not want to reveal spoilers, though. A Death in the Dark is filled with hints, suggestions, deception, and lies, plus enough twists and turns to keep readers engaged with the story. There are even a few scary monsters in the closet that are meant to distract readers. The plot of A Midsummer Murder holds the readers attention, as do the characters. I had no idea that high school track was so exciting and so deadly. Thank you to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for providing this ADC. This new Novel Detectives works well, with the two main characters engaged in research and interviews, Their abilities complement one another. Although the identity of the villain isn't really a surprise, the story leading to his/her identity makes for a good chase. 3.5 = 4 Stars
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Annie and Fletcher of the Novel Detective agency have a surprise early morning visitor, Redwood Grove High School track coach Josh Bynum. He is covered in blood and says he has no idea what happened, can't remember anything about what happened or whose blood it is. As Annie and Fletcher begin their investigation, they quickly find the body of assistant coach Rob. Now the case gets complicated with many questions and almost as many suspects! Our intrepid heroes question, research and hunt until they find answers, uncovering lots of dirty business as they go.
Meanwhile, Hal and Caroline are visiting wine country, so Annie and Fletcher must rifle through Hal's apartment while they are gone to find the clue to Hal's true ancestry that Caroline is sure is there. A clue is located, but that mystery is yet to be solved!
I completely enjoy this series and it's predecessor, but in this one I was pretty sure I knew who the killer was about half-way through the book, still it was fun to see how Annie put it all together.
Excited to see how the overarching story of Hal's history plays out and how Annie and Fletcher handle it. I would like to see more of Liam, Pri and Penny in future books though. I did miss them.
Thanks to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the chance to read an early copy of this in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Meanwhile, Hal and Caroline are visiting wine country, so Annie and Fletcher must rifle through Hal's apartment while they are gone to find the clue to Hal's true ancestry that Caroline is sure is there. A clue is located, but that mystery is yet to be solved!
I completely enjoy this series and it's predecessor, but in this one I was pretty sure I knew who the killer was about half-way through the book, still it was fun to see how Annie put it all together.
Excited to see how the overarching story of Hal's history plays out and how Annie and Fletcher handle it. I would like to see more of Liam, Pri and Penny in future books though. I did miss them.
Thanks to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the chance to read an early copy of this in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I am really becoming a big fan of this series, and this second book was such an enjoyable continuation.
One of the things I love most is Annie and Fletcher. Their dynamic is just so easy to read, and I always find myself smiling at their interactions. There is something very comforting about returning to these characters, and this book really strengthens that connection.
The mystery itself kept me engaged, and I liked how it slowly unfolded. It has that cozy atmosphere I enjoy, with enough intrigue to keep me interested without feeling overly complicated.
I also really appreciate how this series connects to the earlier Secret Bookcase series. As someone who has read those books, it adds an extra layer of enjoyment and familiarity. You really get a deeper understanding of the characters and their relationships, which makes everything feel more meaningful.
The only reason this is a 4 star read for me is that some parts did feel a bit slow, and I found myself wanting the story to move along a little quicker at times. That said, it still fits the cozy style of the series.
Overall, I really enjoyed this one and will definitely continue with the series. I would absolutely recommend reading the books in order, including the earlier Secret Bookcase series, as you get so much more backstory and connection to the characters.
One of the things I love most is Annie and Fletcher. Their dynamic is just so easy to read, and I always find myself smiling at their interactions. There is something very comforting about returning to these characters, and this book really strengthens that connection.
The mystery itself kept me engaged, and I liked how it slowly unfolded. It has that cozy atmosphere I enjoy, with enough intrigue to keep me interested without feeling overly complicated.
I also really appreciate how this series connects to the earlier Secret Bookcase series. As someone who has read those books, it adds an extra layer of enjoyment and familiarity. You really get a deeper understanding of the characters and their relationships, which makes everything feel more meaningful.
The only reason this is a 4 star read for me is that some parts did feel a bit slow, and I found myself wanting the story to move along a little quicker at times. That said, it still fits the cozy style of the series.
Overall, I really enjoyed this one and will definitely continue with the series. I would absolutely recommend reading the books in order, including the earlier Secret Bookcase series, as you get so much more backstory and connection to the characters.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
It is always a pleasure to return to the Secret Bookcase bookstore with Annie and Fletcher, not to mention their new venture, Novel Detectives. While the partners were both early at the shop to get some work done, neither expected a blood covered man to come to their office asking for them to take him as a client. Josh says he woke up covered in blood with no memory of how he got that way. As they talk him through what he does know, they learn that Josh is a teacher and track coach at the local high school and the last thing he remembers is picking up track equipment and hurdles after a track meet the night before. When they walk him through his apartment and then back to the track field and storage shed, they find a dead body, Josh's assistant coach. What actually happened here? Why is Josh unable to remember? Could he have done the deed, or was it one of several others who had a beef with the young man? Come along as Annie and Fletcher, along with a little help from friends and employees, figure out this twisty mystery! My one wish is that there had been more about the other mystery they have running in the background! Thanks to #Netgally, #StormPublishing, and the author for an opportunity to read. #ADeathintheDark #TheNovelDetectives #EllieAlexander #bookreview #bookideas #retiredreader
Displaying 1 - 30 of 135 reviews