What do you think?
Rate this book
Win a free print copy of this book!
5 days and 13:29:38
100 copies available
U.S. only
Reap & Sow
Not yet published
Expected 6 Oct 26Win a free print copy of this book!
5 days and 13:29:38
100 copies available
U.S. only
A young woman bargains with a demon to save her brothers, only to lose her heart in this slow-burn romantasy about dark magic, unlikely love, and the imperfect beauty of mortality.
The penniless in Blackbridge have only two sell the body or sell the soul. And thanks to Eda Shaw, business is booming.
Indentured to a capricious demon known as Mr. Night, Eda and her brothers arrange illicit Pacts on his behalf, luring the city’s most desperate into trading years of their lives for their deepest desires. When a Pact goes awry and her brothers are arrested, Eda realizes she’ll need an infernal ally of her Kit’rath, a demon with a curious penchant for humanity, an infuriating wit, and is the only being in Blackbridge Mr. Night seems to fear. As they race to rescue her family and save the city from ruin, an undeniable connection sparks between mortal and demon.
But Kit’s help doesn’t come cheap. Now, Eda risks losing her heart to the one who claims her years—and saving herself may prove the steepest cost of all.
Rich with gothic atmosphere, sharp wit, and simmering romantic tension, Reap & Sow is a fantasy debut perfect for fans of Rachel Gillig, Hannah Whitten, and Heather Fawcett.
The penniless in Blackbridge have only two sell the body or sell the soul. And thanks to Eda Shaw, business is booming.
Indentured to a capricious demon known as Mr. Night, Eda and her brothers arrange illicit Pacts on his behalf, luring the city’s most desperate into trading years of their lives for their deepest desires. When a Pact goes awry and her brothers are arrested, Eda realizes she’ll need an infernal ally of her Kit’rath, a demon with a curious penchant for humanity, an infuriating wit, and is the only being in Blackbridge Mr. Night seems to fear. As they race to rescue her family and save the city from ruin, an undeniable connection sparks between mortal and demon.
But Kit’s help doesn’t come cheap. Now, Eda risks losing her heart to the one who claims her years—and saving herself may prove the steepest cost of all.
Rich with gothic atmosphere, sharp wit, and simmering romantic tension, Reap & Sow is a fantasy debut perfect for fans of Rachel Gillig, Hannah Whitten, and Heather Fawcett.
Kindle Edition
Expected publication October 6, 2026
About the author
Charlotte B. Plumb
1 book209 followersCharlotte B. Plumb is a fantasy author living in the UK with her husband, cat, and slightly mad dog. She believes books are the closest anyone can get to real magic, and when she isn't daydreaming about fictional characters, she's at her laptop writing them—if the cat isn’t already sitting on it.
Her debut novel, REAP & SOW, is coming Oct 2026.
Her debut novel, REAP & SOW, is coming Oct 2026.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 118 reviews
May 25, 2026
Review of advanced copy received from Netgalley
I’m elated to announce that this book, one of my most anticipated reads of the year so far, did not disappoint in the slightest. Not only did it not disappoint, it surpassed every single expectation I had of it.
Eda was the kind of character you can’t help but root for. She didn’t always make the wisest decisions, specifically in the beginning, but it was never difficult to see where she was coming from. This girl had me screaming “stopppp” at my phone screen with that one thing she did at the start, not just because she was being a complete idiot, but also because I just didn’t want her to suffer the consequences that were so obviously coming.
Kit’rath is a terrible name. Lucky for him, I love him enough to overlook that. He’s a demon, so that’s already +1000 points, but he’s also hilarious. The moment where he called Tripp and Eda children and sarcastically chastised them for bickering had me laughing out loud. And deep down, surprisingly sensitive for a demon. How fresh that he be the one to see the world with hope and awe while Eda is jaded and bitter.
Don’t get it twisted, he’s also a sassy asshole. So basically he is everything I love in a man—except the hope and awe thing, of course—especially the dark hair, because I can only tolerate so many blonds.
The romance was to die for. Plain and simple. I’m doing my best to avoid spoilers, but I HAVE to mention this one thing:
When he took her to the play, and she mentioned not liking sad endings, and he asked her if she would wish she hadn’t come if the ending would sadden her, but he was obviously talking about their ending? UGH. Literally a PERFECT scene.
I wish I could quote specific moments from the writing, because I loved it and there were so many that would make me squeal if I was a person who squealed. It was deceptively simple—it never tried too hard, wasn’t littered with fancy language, but still managed to be vivid, layered, and PULL ON MY HEARTSTRINGS THE WHOLE TIME.
The world was immersive; it felt lived in rather than a mere backdrop for the events of the story. From the cities to the people to the religion to Kit’s home realm, everything felt fully realized and authentic. I especially enjoyed the details and lore of the faith system. It was quite intriguing, but more importantly, it was incredibly fleshed out.
I loved the nuance in how Eda and her brothers viewed their father. Eda could only see him as a selfish, foolish man who sacrificed his children, while her brothers remembered a time before that, when he was a good dad, and still held so much love for him despite what he did. They mourned a man Eda never knew, and wanted her to do so as well, but she just couldn’t, especially with the way she was essentially groomed by Mr. Night. Their differing perspectives, along with her sentimental attachment to the demon they were indebted to, added so many layers to the grief they each shared and made it feel that much more real.
The ending pt. 1 was absolutely perfect—dare I say I’m obsessed?
ENDING PT. 2 WTF WAS THAT LAST PARAGRAPH? How am I meant to wait for a second book? I shall remain in excruciating. agony until it comes out.
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
thank you to the publisher for the arc♡
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
Me over here waiting for my netgalley request for this to be approved meanwhile it’s been moved to read now god knows how long ago: 🤡🤡
I’m elated to announce that this book, one of my most anticipated reads of the year so far, did not disappoint in the slightest. Not only did it not disappoint, it surpassed every single expectation I had of it.
Eda was the kind of character you can’t help but root for. She didn’t always make the wisest decisions, specifically in the beginning, but it was never difficult to see where she was coming from. This girl had me screaming “stopppp” at my phone screen with that one thing she did at the start, not just because she was being a complete idiot, but also because I just didn’t want her to suffer the consequences that were so obviously coming.
Kit’rath is a terrible name. Lucky for him, I love him enough to overlook that. He’s a demon, so that’s already +1000 points, but he’s also hilarious. The moment where he called Tripp and Eda children and sarcastically chastised them for bickering had me laughing out loud. And deep down, surprisingly sensitive for a demon. How fresh that he be the one to see the world with hope and awe while Eda is jaded and bitter.
Don’t get it twisted, he’s also a sassy asshole. So basically he is everything I love in a man—except the hope and awe thing, of course—especially the dark hair, because I can only tolerate so many blonds.
The romance was to die for. Plain and simple. I’m doing my best to avoid spoilers, but I HAVE to mention this one thing:
When he took her to the play, and she mentioned not liking sad endings, and he asked her if she would wish she hadn’t come if the ending would sadden her, but he was obviously talking about their ending? UGH. Literally a PERFECT scene.
I wish I could quote specific moments from the writing, because I loved it and there were so many that would make me squeal if I was a person who squealed. It was deceptively simple—it never tried too hard, wasn’t littered with fancy language, but still managed to be vivid, layered, and PULL ON MY HEARTSTRINGS THE WHOLE TIME.
The world was immersive; it felt lived in rather than a mere backdrop for the events of the story. From the cities to the people to the religion to Kit’s home realm, everything felt fully realized and authentic. I especially enjoyed the details and lore of the faith system. It was quite intriguing, but more importantly, it was incredibly fleshed out.
I loved the nuance in how Eda and her brothers viewed their father. Eda could only see him as a selfish, foolish man who sacrificed his children, while her brothers remembered a time before that, when he was a good dad, and still held so much love for him despite what he did. They mourned a man Eda never knew, and wanted her to do so as well, but she just couldn’t, especially with the way she was essentially groomed by Mr. Night. Their differing perspectives, along with her sentimental attachment to the demon they were indebted to, added so many layers to the grief they each shared and made it feel that much more real.
The ending pt. 1 was absolutely perfect—dare I say I’m obsessed?
ENDING PT. 2 WTF WAS THAT LAST PARAGRAPH? How am I meant to wait for a second book? I shall remain in excruciating. agony until it comes out.
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
thank you to the publisher for the arc♡
. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁ ⟡ ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.
Me over here waiting for my netgalley request for this to be approved meanwhile it’s been moved to read now god knows how long ago: 🤡🤡
November 17, 2025
Official blurb to come but I LOVED this. Propulsive and twisty and with an absolutely delicious love interest - you’re all not ready!!
May 23, 2026
first 6 star of the year we truly love to see it
Reap & Sow truly shines through in its character work - these characters are so intensely lovable and easy to cheer for. In particular, our MMC, Kit’rath, is an absolute delight. What’s not to love about a cheeky, sassy man who just so happens to be a demon? For my fellow Voidwalker lovers: this man is Antal coded.
This book made me laugh, scream, cry, and gasp, sometimes all within the same page… but that ending was unforgivable, and you can see my exact reaction in the second slide. I am begging, pleading, and screaming for the sequel EXPEDITIOUSLY.
My pitch:
Hidden beneath the shroud of Blackbridge’s piety, desperate citizens deal away years of their life to demons in pursuit of their greatest desires. Eda Shaw understands better than anyone how deep these illicit transactions run. After all, she has a mirror ensconced in her basement capable of summoning one such demon, Mr. Night, having inherited both the mirror and her father’s Pact upon his passing. The Shaws owe Mr. Night human years, and as such, must bring him willing participants eager to sign their lives away.
Desperation breeds impulse and Eda decides to deliver on their debt sooner than later, only to be entrapped by the Blades, an army in service of eliminating demonic presence from Blackbridge, resulting in the capture of her brothers. In a bid to free them, Eda makes a pact of her own with another elusive demon hidden within Blackbridge… But Kit’rath Ansellis is more intriguing than she could ever imagine.
Alas, you don’t always get what you bargain for.
Reap & Sow truly shines through in its character work - these characters are so intensely lovable and easy to cheer for. In particular, our MMC, Kit’rath, is an absolute delight. What’s not to love about a cheeky, sassy man who just so happens to be a demon? For my fellow Voidwalker lovers: this man is Antal coded.
This book made me laugh, scream, cry, and gasp, sometimes all within the same page… but that ending was unforgivable, and you can see my exact reaction in the second slide. I am begging, pleading, and screaming for the sequel EXPEDITIOUSLY.
My pitch:
Hidden beneath the shroud of Blackbridge’s piety, desperate citizens deal away years of their life to demons in pursuit of their greatest desires. Eda Shaw understands better than anyone how deep these illicit transactions run. After all, she has a mirror ensconced in her basement capable of summoning one such demon, Mr. Night, having inherited both the mirror and her father’s Pact upon his passing. The Shaws owe Mr. Night human years, and as such, must bring him willing participants eager to sign their lives away.
Desperation breeds impulse and Eda decides to deliver on their debt sooner than later, only to be entrapped by the Blades, an army in service of eliminating demonic presence from Blackbridge, resulting in the capture of her brothers. In a bid to free them, Eda makes a pact of her own with another elusive demon hidden within Blackbridge… But Kit’rath Ansellis is more intriguing than she could ever imagine.
Alas, you don’t always get what you bargain for.
March 2, 2026
Some stories flirt with darkness. This one signs a contract in blood and asks you to read the fine print.
From the very first chapter, we’re dropped into the gothic gloom with Eda—desperate, determined, and just reckless enough to consider that making a pact with a demon might be a reasonable life choice. She needs to save her two brothers. The stakes? High. The atmosphere? Deliciously shadowed. The moral compass? Slightly… negotiable.
It’s an opening that hooks you by the collar and whispers, “Trust me, darling…” before vanishing into the mist. And yes—you’ll absolutely want more after that first chapter.
Eda’s journey is laced with witches, demons, long-buried truths, and the kind of found family that blooms in the most unexpected (and probably cursed) places. There’s something deeply satisfying about watching her forge new friendships while unravelling secrets that may cost her more than she bargained for. Because really—can you have it all? Salvation, love, power… and no consequences?
Let’s talk about the MMC. Because oh, we must.
He arrives wrapped in shadow and sarcasm, delivering dry, razor-sharp humour that had me laughing out loud more than once. The banter? Immaculate. Effortless. The kind that crackles on the page. And his persistent use of “Darling”? Absolutely swoon-worthy. It’s the verbal equivalent of a gloved hand tipped under your chin—charming, dangerous, and just a little bit mocking.
But make no mistake: in a story about demons, the devil is always in the details.
The magic system hints at rules, loopholes, and the fine print of infernal bargains. You can’t help but read carefully, searching for the catch. Because there is one. There’s always one. The tension doesn’t just come from looming threats—it comes from the creeping suspicion that someone, somewhere, hasn’t read the contract closely enough.
This book revels in its gothic setting: shadowed corridors, whispered truths, morally grey choices, and the intoxicating pull of power at a price. It balances humour with darkness beautifully, allowing moments of levity to slice through the gloom without ever undercutting the stakes.
So the question lingers long after you turn the page:
If you were offered everything you ever wanted… would you check the details?
A wickedly fun, banter-filled, demon-infused tale that proves once again—trusting a devil is easy.
Understanding him? That’s the tricky part.
From the very first chapter, we’re dropped into the gothic gloom with Eda—desperate, determined, and just reckless enough to consider that making a pact with a demon might be a reasonable life choice. She needs to save her two brothers. The stakes? High. The atmosphere? Deliciously shadowed. The moral compass? Slightly… negotiable.
It’s an opening that hooks you by the collar and whispers, “Trust me, darling…” before vanishing into the mist. And yes—you’ll absolutely want more after that first chapter.
Eda’s journey is laced with witches, demons, long-buried truths, and the kind of found family that blooms in the most unexpected (and probably cursed) places. There’s something deeply satisfying about watching her forge new friendships while unravelling secrets that may cost her more than she bargained for. Because really—can you have it all? Salvation, love, power… and no consequences?
Let’s talk about the MMC. Because oh, we must.
He arrives wrapped in shadow and sarcasm, delivering dry, razor-sharp humour that had me laughing out loud more than once. The banter? Immaculate. Effortless. The kind that crackles on the page. And his persistent use of “Darling”? Absolutely swoon-worthy. It’s the verbal equivalent of a gloved hand tipped under your chin—charming, dangerous, and just a little bit mocking.
But make no mistake: in a story about demons, the devil is always in the details.
The magic system hints at rules, loopholes, and the fine print of infernal bargains. You can’t help but read carefully, searching for the catch. Because there is one. There’s always one. The tension doesn’t just come from looming threats—it comes from the creeping suspicion that someone, somewhere, hasn’t read the contract closely enough.
This book revels in its gothic setting: shadowed corridors, whispered truths, morally grey choices, and the intoxicating pull of power at a price. It balances humour with darkness beautifully, allowing moments of levity to slice through the gloom without ever undercutting the stakes.
So the question lingers long after you turn the page:
If you were offered everything you ever wanted… would you check the details?
A wickedly fun, banter-filled, demon-infused tale that proves once again—trusting a devil is easy.
Understanding him? That’s the tricky part.
May 3, 2026
KIT my beloved <3
April 29, 2026
What a delightful book! I have an immense TBR but when I received an ARC of this book at bookcon - it somehow moved to the top of the list and I’m so glad it did.
If you like a gothic vibe, pacts, scheming, and snarky demons with a side of humanity - this is the book for you! The romance develops naturally and is well done and the ending 👀👀👀I can’t wait to see what develops there! I think this is going to be the next book everyone is talking about!
If you like a gothic vibe, pacts, scheming, and snarky demons with a side of humanity - this is the book for you! The romance develops naturally and is well done and the ending 👀👀👀I can’t wait to see what develops there! I think this is going to be the next book everyone is talking about!
June 7, 2026
When I received this copy it jumped ahead of my long tbr! The blurb intrigued me so much and it did not disappoint! It was such a fun read! I loved the banter, slow burn and natural relationship progression. And what a delight Tripp was as a sidekick! It had such a unique storyline and kept me intrigued the whole way through plus it’s a standalone so no cliffhanger!
Thank you to Berkley XO and NetGalley for the early copy of this book.
Thank you to Berkley XO and NetGalley for the early copy of this book.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Wow, this was amazing book. Now time to preorder deluxe edition, because it's gorgeous!
review coming soon
review coming soon
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you, Berkley XO and Penguin Random House UK, for providing me with an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Reap & Sow is the blueprint for a perfect dark romance - with an amazing romance, compelling characters, an addictive writing, and an engaging plot!
From the first chapter, Reap & Sow sets the mood - a dark and mysterious town where sins are rampant, with three siblings desperate to fulfil the bargain their dad made with a demon, whilst not being arrested. I love the immediate bond between the siblings, and how much their dynamic showed through their interaction - all bound to each other and this demon by a deadly deal. I really liked both brothers and Eda - she was young and naive, but she had a good nature and fiercely loved her brothers.
I absolutely love the idea of a family bound to a demon, forced to lure humans to him to sell precious years of their lives. I loved the setting - with demons offering deals to humans illegally and a dangerous religious order lurking, ready to arrest anyone involved. The writing was really good, and I immediately felt attached to the siblings and to the story. I loved Eda so much - she was not a perfect character, she made mistakes, but she learned from them and grew throughout the story, and I loved following her as she tried to make things right.
I LOVED Kit - funny and flirty, full of mischief and bad intentions, but with a heart of gold. He was the perfect MMC, and I just loved him; his humour was everything, and I love how much he came to adore Eda. Their romance was so pure, yet so intense, born of desire, desperation and adoration, and I could not get enough - I love how much they loved each other, despite all the barriers. It felt like two people finding each other, unwilling to let go.
I liked all the characters - from Robin, to Tripp (he was such a funny addition), Lowrie and Ben, and even all the villains - they all brought something interesting to the story, and a lot of them did have some character arc, which I loved.
The story was fast-paced and engaging from the beginning to the end - I did not feel like this book had any slow parts, and I genuinely enjoyed reading every single page. The plot wasn't overly complicated, but it was compelling with high stakes - the siblings' lives, the town's entire future, and thousands of souls at stake.
Highly recommend!
Reap & Sow is the blueprint for a perfect dark romance - with an amazing romance, compelling characters, an addictive writing, and an engaging plot!
From the first chapter, Reap & Sow sets the mood - a dark and mysterious town where sins are rampant, with three siblings desperate to fulfil the bargain their dad made with a demon, whilst not being arrested. I love the immediate bond between the siblings, and how much their dynamic showed through their interaction - all bound to each other and this demon by a deadly deal. I really liked both brothers and Eda - she was young and naive, but she had a good nature and fiercely loved her brothers.
I absolutely love the idea of a family bound to a demon, forced to lure humans to him to sell precious years of their lives. I loved the setting - with demons offering deals to humans illegally and a dangerous religious order lurking, ready to arrest anyone involved. The writing was really good, and I immediately felt attached to the siblings and to the story. I loved Eda so much - she was not a perfect character, she made mistakes, but she learned from them and grew throughout the story, and I loved following her as she tried to make things right.
I LOVED Kit - funny and flirty, full of mischief and bad intentions, but with a heart of gold. He was the perfect MMC, and I just loved him; his humour was everything, and I love how much he came to adore Eda. Their romance was so pure, yet so intense, born of desire, desperation and adoration, and I could not get enough - I love how much they loved each other, despite all the barriers. It felt like two people finding each other, unwilling to let go.
I liked all the characters - from Robin, to Tripp (he was such a funny addition), Lowrie and Ben, and even all the villains - they all brought something interesting to the story, and a lot of them did have some character arc, which I loved.
The story was fast-paced and engaging from the beginning to the end - I did not feel like this book had any slow parts, and I genuinely enjoyed reading every single page. The plot wasn't overly complicated, but it was compelling with high stakes - the siblings' lives, the town's entire future, and thousands of souls at stake.
Highly recommend!
June 12, 2026
Review to come….
March 12, 2026
The one thing I must say before beginning this review is that I’m so grateful to have been able to participate in the Boutique Book Breaks reading retreat at Burley Manor last week. There’s nothing I like better than discovering a new author that I can get behind, especially when they write quality romantasy. This was made even more exciting by the fact that this book will not be released until October of this year so my inner book nerd was definitely very happy. But let’s talk about the book…
The vibes in this new world created by Charlotte Plumb are reminiscent of the gothic feeling of the Shepherd King duology. Wonderful characters, an original magic system and really good world building all combined in a well written tale that leaves you wanting more. Although it took about 80 pages for me to get fully absorbed in the story, once I was, I didn’t want to put it down. Unfortunately, life work and other reading commitments got in the way over the next couple of days, but each time I returned to it, I did so with a renewed sense of pleasure that I would be able to spend my time in the company of characters that I loved.
The main focus was, of course, on Eda. Her quest to save her brothers was the main driving force of the story but it is the involvement of an array of characters that gave this book a wider dimension. None of them are purely ‘white hat’. It is the range of morally grey to absolutely reprehensible (Florian springs to mind) that made “Reap & Sow” such a good read. Of course, the romance between Eda and Kit is one that will satisfy any reader that appreciates the genre. It was brimming with sensual undertones, snark and witty repartee that will have you kicking your feet. And then, of course, there are other notables characters such as Robin and Tripp whom I also loved.
From a romance perspective, this title sits in that nebulous space between YA and adult romantasy. While it included some spice (🌶️), it was well done, not overly graphic, and used to heighten the emotional core of the book (as opposed to being added for purely salacious purposes).
As with all good tales of this type, this one also goes beyond a romantic adventure and explores various themes. With aspects of Dr. Faustus blended with politics, power grabbing mixed with religious zealotry, some heart pumping action, and a clear warning to be ‘careful what you wish for’, it transcends simple escapism - if you choose to read deeper. Or it can be read as a gothic fairytale. The outcome lies in the eye (and mind) of the reader.
I mentioned at the beginning of this review how grateful I was to be able to read this book ahead of its release date. Unfortunately, after having finished it, I discovered a downside: that I will have to wait even longer in order to be able to read the final instalment of this duology. While it did not have a heart stopper of a cliffhanger, it did end on a mysterious note that left me wanting to know more. Maybe the author will take pity on this poor reader and send me the ARC of book 2 when she has finished it? 🤞🏻 Hope springs eternal.
A solid debut novel by an author that I’m looking forward to hearing more from.
5 stars 🤓📚
#charlottebplumb #reapandsow
#booksbooksbooks #books #bookish #bookaddict #bookclubread #reading #bookstagram #booktok #bookreview #booksof2026 #bookdragon #bookworm #lovebooks #bookrecs #booklovers #booklove #booknerd #bibliophile #ilivetoread #passionforbooks #bookish #readingcommunity #bookaddict #bookrecs
#fiction #romance #romantasy #Gothic #gothicfantasy #fantasy
#burleymanor #boutiquebookbreaks #readingretreat #meettheauthor
The vibes in this new world created by Charlotte Plumb are reminiscent of the gothic feeling of the Shepherd King duology. Wonderful characters, an original magic system and really good world building all combined in a well written tale that leaves you wanting more. Although it took about 80 pages for me to get fully absorbed in the story, once I was, I didn’t want to put it down. Unfortunately, life work and other reading commitments got in the way over the next couple of days, but each time I returned to it, I did so with a renewed sense of pleasure that I would be able to spend my time in the company of characters that I loved.
The main focus was, of course, on Eda. Her quest to save her brothers was the main driving force of the story but it is the involvement of an array of characters that gave this book a wider dimension. None of them are purely ‘white hat’. It is the range of morally grey to absolutely reprehensible (Florian springs to mind) that made “Reap & Sow” such a good read. Of course, the romance between Eda and Kit is one that will satisfy any reader that appreciates the genre. It was brimming with sensual undertones, snark and witty repartee that will have you kicking your feet. And then, of course, there are other notables characters such as Robin and Tripp whom I also loved.
From a romance perspective, this title sits in that nebulous space between YA and adult romantasy. While it included some spice (🌶️), it was well done, not overly graphic, and used to heighten the emotional core of the book (as opposed to being added for purely salacious purposes).
As with all good tales of this type, this one also goes beyond a romantic adventure and explores various themes. With aspects of Dr. Faustus blended with politics, power grabbing mixed with religious zealotry, some heart pumping action, and a clear warning to be ‘careful what you wish for’, it transcends simple escapism - if you choose to read deeper. Or it can be read as a gothic fairytale. The outcome lies in the eye (and mind) of the reader.
I mentioned at the beginning of this review how grateful I was to be able to read this book ahead of its release date. Unfortunately, after having finished it, I discovered a downside: that I will have to wait even longer in order to be able to read the final instalment of this duology. While it did not have a heart stopper of a cliffhanger, it did end on a mysterious note that left me wanting to know more. Maybe the author will take pity on this poor reader and send me the ARC of book 2 when she has finished it? 🤞🏻 Hope springs eternal.
A solid debut novel by an author that I’m looking forward to hearing more from.
5 stars 🤓📚
#charlottebplumb #reapandsow
#booksbooksbooks #books #bookish #bookaddict #bookclubread #reading #bookstagram #booktok #bookreview #booksof2026 #bookdragon #bookworm #lovebooks #bookrecs #booklovers #booklove #booknerd #bibliophile #ilivetoread #passionforbooks #bookish #readingcommunity #bookaddict #bookrecs
#fiction #romance #romantasy #Gothic #gothicfantasy #fantasy
#burleymanor #boutiquebookbreaks #readingretreat #meettheauthor
June 18, 2026
4.5 stars
I really really enjoyed this one. It was one I loved picking back up and I had a great time reading. The characters were fun, I really enjoyed the setting, and overall the pacing was well done (only a few points dragged).
For me, the only reason I couldn’t give it a full 5 was the uniqueness of the characters. Yes, they are fun, but they’re pretty much what I expected from a romantasy with a 20yo fmc and a much older demon mmc. Which is fine, I just wish that this story had done something a little different. The plot was unique and the setting enthralling but I wanted more from the characters.
The romance in this was super fun, not necessarily closed door but maybe the door is cracked open? I thought there were sooo many cute moments between our two characters and I put a lot of tabs in my copy because of it 🤭
This could definitely be read as a standalone, and likely will be for me. I do recommend this if you like a slower burn romance and a plot that is intriguing!
I really really enjoyed this one. It was one I loved picking back up and I had a great time reading. The characters were fun, I really enjoyed the setting, and overall the pacing was well done (only a few points dragged).
For me, the only reason I couldn’t give it a full 5 was the uniqueness of the characters. Yes, they are fun, but they’re pretty much what I expected from a romantasy with a 20yo fmc and a much older demon mmc. Which is fine, I just wish that this story had done something a little different. The plot was unique and the setting enthralling but I wanted more from the characters.
The romance in this was super fun, not necessarily closed door but maybe the door is cracked open? I thought there were sooo many cute moments between our two characters and I put a lot of tabs in my copy because of it 🤭
This could definitely be read as a standalone, and likely will be for me. I do recommend this if you like a slower burn romance and a plot that is intriguing!
May 26, 2026
This dark, atmospheric fantasy gave me major ‘The Bear And The Nightingale’ vibes — in the best way.
Eda bargains with a demon to save her brothers. Their relationship is lighter than Bear and the Nightingale, but still fun to watch. I won’t divulge any other plot points here — I’ll just say that while it has other familiar elements to ‘Bear’, it still feels completely unique. The world, conflicts, and characters all stood on their own. So if you like The Bear And The Nightingale, try this.
Also…This is honestly what I was hoping Swordheart would be for me.
Thank you NetGalley and Berkeley XO for this ARC all opinions are my own.
Eda bargains with a demon to save her brothers. Their relationship is lighter than Bear and the Nightingale, but still fun to watch. I won’t divulge any other plot points here — I’ll just say that while it has other familiar elements to ‘Bear’, it still feels completely unique. The world, conflicts, and characters all stood on their own. So if you like The Bear And The Nightingale, try this.
Also…This is honestly what I was hoping Swordheart would be for me.
Thank you NetGalley and Berkeley XO for this ARC all opinions are my own.
June 12, 2026
4.5/5 Stars
More, I need more and desperately. I went into this book a little cautious, weary on the side of maybe this will be your typical romantasy book but it wasn't, it was more then that.
I loved the character's and their development in this book. I saw myself in Eda, willing to risk & do anything for the ones she loved even if it meant making a pact. And I found myself loving Kit, he was such a perfect contrast to Eda's character and they made such a perfect pair for a slow burn love story.
Speaking of the slow burn.. it was perfect. It wasn't too fast, but also wasn't necessarily a dreadful dragging on slow burn that makes you want to rip your hair out.
Thank you to Netgalley and Berkley XO for an e-arc in exchange for an honest review.
More, I need more and desperately. I went into this book a little cautious, weary on the side of maybe this will be your typical romantasy book but it wasn't, it was more then that.
I loved the character's and their development in this book. I saw myself in Eda, willing to risk & do anything for the ones she loved even if it meant making a pact. And I found myself loving Kit, he was such a perfect contrast to Eda's character and they made such a perfect pair for a slow burn love story.
Speaking of the slow burn.. it was perfect. It wasn't too fast, but also wasn't necessarily a dreadful dragging on slow burn that makes you want to rip your hair out.
Thank you to Netgalley and Berkley XO for an e-arc in exchange for an honest review.
May 24, 2026
I read this book in less than 24 hours. Absolutely amazing read. It grips you from the beginning and keeps you bated until the last sentence. Stunning is an understatement. ATE THIS UP! Such good banter, amazing story from start to end. 5+ stars!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I like to thank the publisher for making this free and NetGalley for hosting it.
I also like to say - I don't exactly read a lot of romantasy. I like stories with plot and romance, so I don't go really searching for romantasy. If the plot sounds interesting I'll give it a go.
I am happy to report that Reap and Sow is a fine addition to romantasy books, but there are a couple little hang ups that kept it from getting a full 5 stars.
What really works in this story is the plot and characters: We have our female lead, she is strong-willed, independent, brave, and looking to get out of her debt with a demon who has had her remaining family in a chokehold. They must collect people desperate for something and that person signs away a certain amount of their life in exchange for said desire. But the demon who grants these desires don't always give them a clean gift - it's like the Monkeys Paw. Ask for something and get something not quite what you wanted in the way that you wanted it.
The brothers, the demon, the scheming underground folks and the lofty faith worshipers all have character. Even the two demons! I really liked Mr. Night and how he was written. He is a 100% good-looking villain and a schemer to boot. Our female lead's love interest, Kit, who is also a demon is cheeky, haughty, pompus, sweet, and likeable. He has his faults too - which is nice finding a not so perfect character with their own demons.
So why not 5 stars? Well, for one thing, the romance works but... it feels a little too cheesy. He has been a demon for a while and this girl changes his mind in less than a week or gives him love at first sight? I mean,, I guess? You could debate that he is unlike other demons and that his underlying love for human life (mortal world) is what made the switch, but I felt that he was too instant in his feelings. Then again, if this book is a one-shot in this universe (no sequel in mind) then I guess I can believe it... it just feels too instant for me.
Another thing was that we have an interesting plot of the church against this demonic world. We only get a glimpse of the demonic world from the mirror, and from what Kit and Robin (another character that assists our female lead) speak about that world. If there is a sequel, I really want to see more characters, more stress on Kit returning to the world that he left behind. Unless the whole point was to abandon that world. If not, I felt that his struggle was just ... well, again goes back to the fact that he was willing to face off against the big bad in the end.. because he loved her.. (who he hardly knew for a couple weeks). It just doesn't feel right.
But, in the end, I ate it up. I would *like* there to be a sequel. I hope there is. The author is really good with her characters and world building that if she can't crank out another book or two I'll be sad. However, if you're looking for a one-and-done book (for now), this a solid e
I also like to say - I don't exactly read a lot of romantasy. I like stories with plot and romance, so I don't go really searching for romantasy. If the plot sounds interesting I'll give it a go.
I am happy to report that Reap and Sow is a fine addition to romantasy books, but there are a couple little hang ups that kept it from getting a full 5 stars.
What really works in this story is the plot and characters: We have our female lead, she is strong-willed, independent, brave, and looking to get out of her debt with a demon who has had her remaining family in a chokehold. They must collect people desperate for something and that person signs away a certain amount of their life in exchange for said desire. But the demon who grants these desires don't always give them a clean gift - it's like the Monkeys Paw. Ask for something and get something not quite what you wanted in the way that you wanted it.
The brothers, the demon, the scheming underground folks and the lofty faith worshipers all have character. Even the two demons! I really liked Mr. Night and how he was written. He is a 100% good-looking villain and a schemer to boot. Our female lead's love interest, Kit, who is also a demon is cheeky, haughty, pompus, sweet, and likeable. He has his faults too - which is nice finding a not so perfect character with their own demons.
So why not 5 stars? Well, for one thing, the romance works but... it feels a little too cheesy. He has been a demon for a while and this girl changes his mind in less than a week or gives him love at first sight? I mean,, I guess? You could debate that he is unlike other demons and that his underlying love for human life (mortal world) is what made the switch, but I felt that he was too instant in his feelings. Then again, if this book is a one-shot in this universe (no sequel in mind) then I guess I can believe it... it just feels too instant for me.
Another thing was that we have an interesting plot of the church against this demonic world. We only get a glimpse of the demonic world from the mirror, and from what Kit and Robin (another character that assists our female lead) speak about that world. If there is a sequel, I really want to see more characters, more stress on Kit returning to the world that he left behind. Unless the whole point was to abandon that world. If not, I felt that his struggle was just ... well, again goes back to the fact that he was willing to face off against the big bad in the end.. because he loved her.. (who he hardly knew for a couple weeks). It just doesn't feel right.
But, in the end, I ate it up. I would *like* there to be a sequel. I hope there is. The author is really good with her characters and world building that if she can't crank out another book or two I'll be sad. However, if you're looking for a one-and-done book (for now), this a solid e
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
First of all, thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this sneak peek!
The moment I saw the words gothic fantasy, demons and dangerous bargains, my self control packed its bags and left. My TBR was already crying in the corner, but what’s one more book when demons are involved?
The story follows Eda, who helps her family make deals with a demon named Mr. Black. Which, honestly, already sounds like a career path that should come with hazard pay and free therapy. Things go from “this seems questionable” to “oh no, this is a terrible idea” pretty quickly when a deal goes wrong, her brothers end up in trouble and Eda finds herself tangled up with Kit’rath, a demon so terrifying that even Mr. Black wants absolutely nothing to do with him.
And if there’s one thing I learned from this book, it’s that when someone tells you not to go somewhere alone, you should probably listen. Eda, however, follows the long and honored fantasy tradition of ignoring good advice and thank goodness she does because otherwise we wouldn’t have a story.
The atmosphere in this book was chef’s kiss.
Creepy antique shops? Check.
Suspicious demons? Check.
Constant feeling that something horrible is lurking around the corner waiting to ruin everyone’s day? Double check.
Charlotte B. Plumb did a fantastic job creating a world that felt dark, eerie and just unsettling enough to keep me glued to the pages.
Eda was incredibly easy to root for. She’s brave, stubborn and determined, which unfortunately means she frequently makes decisions that had me thinking, “Girl, please,” while simultaneously cheering her on. It’s a complicated relationship.
Then there’s Kit’rath. Every time he appeared on the page, my attention immediately snapped into focus. He’s mysterious, intimidating, and carries the kind of energy that makes you think, “This is probably a bad idea,” while also desperately wanting to know more.
The mystery surrounding the demons and their bargains kept me hooked throughout. Every answer seemed to come with three new questions and I happily followed the trail deeper into the darkness like a reader with absolutely no survival instincts.
My only small complaint is that the writing felt a little clunky at the beginning. It took me a few chapters to fully settle into the story and I wasn’t immediately connected to everything. But once the atmosphere kicked in and the plot started rolling, I completely forgot about it and got swept away.
Overall, this book gave me exactly what I wanted: creepy vibes, fascinating demons, questionable life choices and enough mystery to keep me turning pages long past my bedtime. If you enjoy gothic fantasy, dangerous bargains, morally gray characters, and stories that make you whisper “just one more chapter” at 2 a.m. before accidentally reading five more, definitely put this one on your radar. I did put it on my TBR; I can’t wait to have the book in my hands.
The moment I saw the words gothic fantasy, demons and dangerous bargains, my self control packed its bags and left. My TBR was already crying in the corner, but what’s one more book when demons are involved?
The story follows Eda, who helps her family make deals with a demon named Mr. Black. Which, honestly, already sounds like a career path that should come with hazard pay and free therapy. Things go from “this seems questionable” to “oh no, this is a terrible idea” pretty quickly when a deal goes wrong, her brothers end up in trouble and Eda finds herself tangled up with Kit’rath, a demon so terrifying that even Mr. Black wants absolutely nothing to do with him.
And if there’s one thing I learned from this book, it’s that when someone tells you not to go somewhere alone, you should probably listen. Eda, however, follows the long and honored fantasy tradition of ignoring good advice and thank goodness she does because otherwise we wouldn’t have a story.
The atmosphere in this book was chef’s kiss.
Creepy antique shops? Check.
Suspicious demons? Check.
Constant feeling that something horrible is lurking around the corner waiting to ruin everyone’s day? Double check.
Charlotte B. Plumb did a fantastic job creating a world that felt dark, eerie and just unsettling enough to keep me glued to the pages.
Eda was incredibly easy to root for. She’s brave, stubborn and determined, which unfortunately means she frequently makes decisions that had me thinking, “Girl, please,” while simultaneously cheering her on. It’s a complicated relationship.
Then there’s Kit’rath. Every time he appeared on the page, my attention immediately snapped into focus. He’s mysterious, intimidating, and carries the kind of energy that makes you think, “This is probably a bad idea,” while also desperately wanting to know more.
The mystery surrounding the demons and their bargains kept me hooked throughout. Every answer seemed to come with three new questions and I happily followed the trail deeper into the darkness like a reader with absolutely no survival instincts.
My only small complaint is that the writing felt a little clunky at the beginning. It took me a few chapters to fully settle into the story and I wasn’t immediately connected to everything. But once the atmosphere kicked in and the plot started rolling, I completely forgot about it and got swept away.
Overall, this book gave me exactly what I wanted: creepy vibes, fascinating demons, questionable life choices and enough mystery to keep me turning pages long past my bedtime. If you enjoy gothic fantasy, dangerous bargains, morally gray characters, and stories that make you whisper “just one more chapter” at 2 a.m. before accidentally reading five more, definitely put this one on your radar. I did put it on my TBR; I can’t wait to have the book in my hands.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you berkley xo and netgalley for this arc.
Reap & Sow • Charlotte B. Plumb
One phrase: demon bargains with a side of heartbreak 🖤
I am so happy to report that one of my most anticipated reads absolutely did NOT disappoint.
Reap & Sow is gothic, witty, romantic, emotional, and so much more layered than I expected. It has demon bargains, stolen years, desperate choices, sibling loyalty, a richly built world, and one infuriating demon who somehow became everything.
Eda Shaw is the kind of FMC you root for even when she is making choices that make you want to yell at your book. She is jaded, stubborn, protective, and deeply shaped by survival. Her life has never really belonged to her, and watching her fight for her brothers, her freedom, and eventually herself made this story hit so hard.
And Kit’rath?
Terrible name. Excellent demon.
He is sarcastic, dramatic, sharp tongued, surprisingly hopeful, and way too easy to love. I loved that he was the demon, but somehow he was also the one who still saw beauty and possibility in the world while Eda had every reason to be bitter. Their dynamic was everything. The banter. The tension. The emotional ache. The way their connection slowly built into something impossible to ignore.
The romance was SO good. Slow burn in the best way, with moments that quietly wreck you instead of screaming for attention. The play scene? Absolutely gorgeous. The kind of scene that makes you pause and stare at the page because you know exactly what is being said underneath the words.
The world building also felt so lived in. Blackbridge, the Pacts, the faith system, Kit’s realm, the desperation of people trading pieces of their lives for desire, all of it felt vivid and fully realized.
But what really got me was the emotional complexity with Eda and her brothers. The way they all viewed their father differently, the grief they carried, the resentment, the love, the damage Mr. Night caused, it all added so much depth.
And that ending?
The first part? Perfect.
The final paragraph? RUDE. Criminal. Emotionally unacceptable.
✨ Tropes and vibes:
🖤 demon bargain
🌙 gothic romantasy
⏳ stolen years
🔥 slow burn romance
😈 sassy demon MMC
🫶 sibling loyalty
🕯 dark magic
💔 grief and survival
📜 dangerous Pacts
🖤 morally complicated choices
🏙 immersive city setting
😭 emotional cliffhanger
📚 Read this if you like:
Rachel Gillig, Hannah Whitten, Heather Fawcett, gothic fantasy, demon romance, sharp banter, morally messy bargains, and slow burns that hurt in the prettiest way.
This was dark, clever, romantic, heartbreaking, and completely worth the emotional damage.
#ReapAndSow #CharlotteBPlumb #RomantasyBooks #FantasyRomance #BookReview
Reap & Sow • Charlotte B. Plumb
One phrase: demon bargains with a side of heartbreak 🖤
I am so happy to report that one of my most anticipated reads absolutely did NOT disappoint.
Reap & Sow is gothic, witty, romantic, emotional, and so much more layered than I expected. It has demon bargains, stolen years, desperate choices, sibling loyalty, a richly built world, and one infuriating demon who somehow became everything.
Eda Shaw is the kind of FMC you root for even when she is making choices that make you want to yell at your book. She is jaded, stubborn, protective, and deeply shaped by survival. Her life has never really belonged to her, and watching her fight for her brothers, her freedom, and eventually herself made this story hit so hard.
And Kit’rath?
Terrible name. Excellent demon.
He is sarcastic, dramatic, sharp tongued, surprisingly hopeful, and way too easy to love. I loved that he was the demon, but somehow he was also the one who still saw beauty and possibility in the world while Eda had every reason to be bitter. Their dynamic was everything. The banter. The tension. The emotional ache. The way their connection slowly built into something impossible to ignore.
The romance was SO good. Slow burn in the best way, with moments that quietly wreck you instead of screaming for attention. The play scene? Absolutely gorgeous. The kind of scene that makes you pause and stare at the page because you know exactly what is being said underneath the words.
The world building also felt so lived in. Blackbridge, the Pacts, the faith system, Kit’s realm, the desperation of people trading pieces of their lives for desire, all of it felt vivid and fully realized.
But what really got me was the emotional complexity with Eda and her brothers. The way they all viewed their father differently, the grief they carried, the resentment, the love, the damage Mr. Night caused, it all added so much depth.
And that ending?
The first part? Perfect.
The final paragraph? RUDE. Criminal. Emotionally unacceptable.
✨ Tropes and vibes:
🖤 demon bargain
🌙 gothic romantasy
⏳ stolen years
🔥 slow burn romance
😈 sassy demon MMC
🫶 sibling loyalty
🕯 dark magic
💔 grief and survival
📜 dangerous Pacts
🖤 morally complicated choices
🏙 immersive city setting
😭 emotional cliffhanger
📚 Read this if you like:
Rachel Gillig, Hannah Whitten, Heather Fawcett, gothic fantasy, demon romance, sharp banter, morally messy bargains, and slow burns that hurt in the prettiest way.
This was dark, clever, romantic, heartbreaking, and completely worth the emotional damage.
#ReapAndSow #CharlotteBPlumb #RomantasyBooks #FantasyRomance #BookReview
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Reap & Sow is everything I want in a gothic romantasy. If you're a fan of the atmospheric darkness of One Dark Window mixed with the charm and whimsy of Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries, then this book absolutely deserves a spot on your TBR.
I was completely hooked from the very first chapter and determined to finish it in less than 24 hours—which I almost did. The story strikes the perfect balance between an engaging fantasy plot and a slow-burn romance that had me eagerly turning pages long into the night.
Eda is a fantastic heroine, fiercely devoted to her brothers and willing to make impossible choices to protect them. The world of Blackbridge is steeped in gothic atmosphere, dark bargains, and dangerous magic, creating a setting that feels both enchanting and unsettling. I especially loved the concept of Pacts and the way the story explores the value of time, mortality, and what people are willing to sacrifice for the things they love.
And then there's Kit'rath. The chemistry between him and Eda is exquisite. Their relationship unfolds gradually, allowing the tension, trust, and affection to build naturally. Every interaction left me wanting more, and the romance felt all the more rewarding because of its slow-burn development.
I also have to give some love to Tripp, who completely stole my heart. He was such a lovable side character, and I found myself looking forward to every scene he appeared in. Sometimes it's the supporting cast that elevates a story from good to unforgettable, and Tripp definitely did that for me.
One thing readers should know going in is that this book is significantly darker than the cozy whimsy its comparisons might suggest. There is graphic violence throughout the story, and there are mentions and descriptions surrounding the death of a young girl that may be difficult for some readers. Please be sure to check the trigger warnings before diving in.
And that ending! I genuinely need answers. The final chapters left me desperately wanting more, and I'm crossing my fingers that a sequel is in the works because there are still so many places this story could go. If there is a book two coming, I'll be first in line to read it.
With its rich gothic atmosphere, compelling characters, sharp wit, dark magic, and beautifully developed romance, Reap & Sow is a standout fantasy that completely captured my attention. This was an easy five-star read for me, and one I'll be recommending to every romantasy reader I know.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I was completely hooked from the very first chapter and determined to finish it in less than 24 hours—which I almost did. The story strikes the perfect balance between an engaging fantasy plot and a slow-burn romance that had me eagerly turning pages long into the night.
Eda is a fantastic heroine, fiercely devoted to her brothers and willing to make impossible choices to protect them. The world of Blackbridge is steeped in gothic atmosphere, dark bargains, and dangerous magic, creating a setting that feels both enchanting and unsettling. I especially loved the concept of Pacts and the way the story explores the value of time, mortality, and what people are willing to sacrifice for the things they love.
And then there's Kit'rath. The chemistry between him and Eda is exquisite. Their relationship unfolds gradually, allowing the tension, trust, and affection to build naturally. Every interaction left me wanting more, and the romance felt all the more rewarding because of its slow-burn development.
I also have to give some love to Tripp, who completely stole my heart. He was such a lovable side character, and I found myself looking forward to every scene he appeared in. Sometimes it's the supporting cast that elevates a story from good to unforgettable, and Tripp definitely did that for me.
One thing readers should know going in is that this book is significantly darker than the cozy whimsy its comparisons might suggest. There is graphic violence throughout the story, and there are mentions and descriptions surrounding the death of a young girl that may be difficult for some readers. Please be sure to check the trigger warnings before diving in.
And that ending! I genuinely need answers. The final chapters left me desperately wanting more, and I'm crossing my fingers that a sequel is in the works because there are still so many places this story could go. If there is a book two coming, I'll be first in line to read it.
With its rich gothic atmosphere, compelling characters, sharp wit, dark magic, and beautifully developed romance, Reap & Sow is a standout fantasy that completely captured my attention. This was an easy five-star read for me, and one I'll be recommending to every romantasy reader I know.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Reap & Sow is everything a dark romance should be: gripping characters, a magnetic romance, and a plot that never lets up.
From its opening pages, the book establishes its atmosphere. It's a shadowy, sin-soaked town where three siblings race against time to honor a pact their father struck with a demon, all while dodging the threat of arrest. The connection between the siblings is immediate and authentic, with every interaction reinforcing how deeply they're tied to one another and to the demon who holds their fate in his hands.
The premise itself is fantastic: a family forced to deliver unsuspecting humans to a demon in exchange for stolen years of life. The world-building shines too, blending illicit demonic bargains with the looming danger of a religious faction determined to hunt down anyone involved. The prose pulls you in instantly, and it's easy to grow attached to the siblings right away. Eda, in particular, stands out. She's young and a little naive, but her warmth and her fierce devotion to her brothers make her impossible not to root for. She's far from flawless; she stumbles, but she learns from those mistakes and evolves over the course of the story, making her journey toward redemption genuinely satisfying to watch.
Then there's Kit: witty, flirtatious, mischievous, and secretly soft-hearted underneath it all. He's a standout male lead, equal parts comic relief and emotional depth, and watching his feelings for Eda deepen is a highlight of the book. Their love story manages to feel both tender and fierce, fueled by longing, desperation, and genuine devotion. Despite every obstacle stacked against them, their bond never feels anything less than inevitable. It reads like two people who've found each other and simply refuse to let go.
The supporting cast adds plenty of texture as well. Robin, Tripp (whose humor is a real delight), Lowrie, and Ben all bring something memorable to the table. Even the antagonists are given depth, with several receiving meaningful arcs of their own rather than being one-dimensional obstacles.
Pacing is another strength. The story moves briskly from start to finish, with no lulls or filler. Every chapter earns its place. The plot, while not overly intricate, is tightly constructed and high-stakes, with the siblings' survival, the town's fate, and countless souls all hanging in the balance.
In short, this is a must-read for fans of dark romance, with characters you'll fall for and a story that doesn't waste a single page.
The book would have been an easy 5 stars for me if it wasn't for the ending. The cliffhanger felt abrupt and unnecessary. I would have preferred a standalone.
From its opening pages, the book establishes its atmosphere. It's a shadowy, sin-soaked town where three siblings race against time to honor a pact their father struck with a demon, all while dodging the threat of arrest. The connection between the siblings is immediate and authentic, with every interaction reinforcing how deeply they're tied to one another and to the demon who holds their fate in his hands.
The premise itself is fantastic: a family forced to deliver unsuspecting humans to a demon in exchange for stolen years of life. The world-building shines too, blending illicit demonic bargains with the looming danger of a religious faction determined to hunt down anyone involved. The prose pulls you in instantly, and it's easy to grow attached to the siblings right away. Eda, in particular, stands out. She's young and a little naive, but her warmth and her fierce devotion to her brothers make her impossible not to root for. She's far from flawless; she stumbles, but she learns from those mistakes and evolves over the course of the story, making her journey toward redemption genuinely satisfying to watch.
Then there's Kit: witty, flirtatious, mischievous, and secretly soft-hearted underneath it all. He's a standout male lead, equal parts comic relief and emotional depth, and watching his feelings for Eda deepen is a highlight of the book. Their love story manages to feel both tender and fierce, fueled by longing, desperation, and genuine devotion. Despite every obstacle stacked against them, their bond never feels anything less than inevitable. It reads like two people who've found each other and simply refuse to let go.
The supporting cast adds plenty of texture as well. Robin, Tripp (whose humor is a real delight), Lowrie, and Ben all bring something memorable to the table. Even the antagonists are given depth, with several receiving meaningful arcs of their own rather than being one-dimensional obstacles.
Pacing is another strength. The story moves briskly from start to finish, with no lulls or filler. Every chapter earns its place. The plot, while not overly intricate, is tightly constructed and high-stakes, with the siblings' survival, the town's fate, and countless souls all hanging in the balance.
In short, this is a must-read for fans of dark romance, with characters you'll fall for and a story that doesn't waste a single page.
The book would have been an easy 5 stars for me if it wasn't for the ending. The cliffhanger felt abrupt and unnecessary. I would have preferred a standalone.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
3.5 rounded up for Tripp carrying the comic relief on his back. This is a fairly solid romantasy with generally good plotting and mostly well-rounded characters. That said, the romance's pacing is off. Eda and Kit don't meet until about 25% into the book and kiss by 60% (but even before this there’s stirrings of big ‘feelings’). Paired with the circumstances, power imbalance, and short time period…ehh, I was a little dubious. (I mean he threatens her on first meeting, so expectations are set for slow burn, no?) I expected a more cynical, world-weary romance but it surprised me with big, earnest declarations of love. I didn't hate it, but I just didn't totally buy it. For me, a top-tier romance needs to be sufficiently compelling or genuinely moving. I would say this one was just kind of enjoyable, but the shaky foundation makes it hard to care as much (it's also imo kinda cheesy).
The finale reminded me of a Spielberg movie (one of the more saccharine ones) with the way all their problems are wrapped up in a neat little bow, and everyone's all smiles after the big dramatic scene. You might say it's cinematic, but more Marvel than arthouse. That's the vibe I was picking up and it's not totally my vibe, but I can't say I had a bad time. (But if I think too much about the last scene with Robin and the entire 50 years aspect that was ultimately ridiculous it sours the end.)
My other big issue is the general tonal inconsistency that repeatedly comes up with the plot and romance. This book is about demons so you can safely expect gore, but sometimes there's this mismatch of a bloody scene followed by something tonally opposite. This can work and occasionally it's not jarring but the tone isn’t quite managed from the outset.
Other quibbles:
• Why is everyone shocked Lich had a mirror? Isn't it established early on that he's fostering Pacts? Did I just miss something?
• The evil priest was a bit of a worn caricature that’s been done better elsewhere.
• A lot of the world-building is basically the Catholic Church Fantasy Edition.
And another thing, regarding that last paragraph. Why? Just why? We could have had it all.
These are my biggest complaints however I seriously doubt they'll be an issue for most people. As a romantasy, this is tightly written enough to stand out among what's on offer these days.
Thanks to NetGalley and Berkley XO for the ARC
The finale reminded me of a Spielberg movie (one of the more saccharine ones) with the way all their problems are wrapped up in a neat little bow, and everyone's all smiles after the big dramatic scene. You might say it's cinematic, but more Marvel than arthouse. That's the vibe I was picking up and it's not totally my vibe, but I can't say I had a bad time. (But if I think too much about the last scene with Robin and the entire 50 years aspect that was ultimately ridiculous it sours the end.)
My other big issue is the general tonal inconsistency that repeatedly comes up with the plot and romance. This book is about demons so you can safely expect gore, but sometimes there's this mismatch of a bloody scene followed by something tonally opposite. This can work and occasionally it's not jarring but the tone isn’t quite managed from the outset.
Other quibbles:
• Why is everyone shocked Lich had a mirror? Isn't it established early on that he's fostering Pacts? Did I just miss something?
• The evil priest was a bit of a worn caricature that’s been done better elsewhere.
• A lot of the world-building is basically the Catholic Church Fantasy Edition.
And another thing, regarding that last paragraph. Why? Just why? We could have had it all.
These are my biggest complaints however I seriously doubt they'll be an issue for most people. As a romantasy, this is tightly written enough to stand out among what's on offer these days.
Thanks to NetGalley and Berkley XO for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
3.5⭐️ rounded up
I liked this book, but I expected to love it because it had all the ingredients for a new favorite: demons, illicit bargains, Victorian London vibes, and forbidden romance. At the same time, despite featuring brutal murders and plenty of spice, some moments felt surprisingly young adult.
The protagonists are wonderfully layered, and I have to give the author credit for that. Eda grows from a naïve young woman sheltered by her brothers into someone willing to make sacrifices for the people she loves. I especially enjoyed her relationship with her brothers, particularly the moment near the end when she reflects on how Ben had been her brother, mother, and father all at once. Eda does not idealize herself either. She acknowledges her mistakes and misconceptions and is not afraid to tell Kit that he has become stuck in his attempts to imitate humanity. Although their romance started as a slow burn, I felt that it progressed a little too quickly in the end, and I wish we had gotten more scenes of them simply getting to know each other.
Kit is not your typical hero who immediately throws himself into danger for the heroine. He enjoys his luxurious, hedonistic lifestyle, and I suspect that, at least a few times early on, he regretted making a deal with Eda. He carries his own trauma and undergoes a meaningful transformation throughout the story as well.
But my absolute favorite character has to be Tripp. It was so refreshing to see a familiar who doesn't immediately adore their master’s love interest, and his banter with Eda is just delightful! Unfortunately, the main villain felt somewhat one-dimensional and almost cartoonish, and the entire storyline surrounding him strongly echoes the Catholic Church and the Inquisition. That is not necessarily a criticism, just an observation.
I was convinced this was a standalone novel, but the last two paragraphs suggest otherwise. Still, the characters do get a HFN ending. That said, I have some questions about how long they will actually stay together. Eda is mortal, after all, so Kit and the author will either have to come up with a solution, or he is destined for a fate as heartbreaking as Robin's.
Overall, it’s a solid story that is absolutely perfect for spooky season.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this ARC
I liked this book, but I expected to love it because it had all the ingredients for a new favorite: demons, illicit bargains, Victorian London vibes, and forbidden romance. At the same time, despite featuring brutal murders and plenty of spice, some moments felt surprisingly young adult.
The protagonists are wonderfully layered, and I have to give the author credit for that. Eda grows from a naïve young woman sheltered by her brothers into someone willing to make sacrifices for the people she loves. I especially enjoyed her relationship with her brothers, particularly the moment near the end when she reflects on how Ben had been her brother, mother, and father all at once. Eda does not idealize herself either. She acknowledges her mistakes and misconceptions and is not afraid to tell Kit that he has become stuck in his attempts to imitate humanity. Although their romance started as a slow burn, I felt that it progressed a little too quickly in the end, and I wish we had gotten more scenes of them simply getting to know each other.
Kit is not your typical hero who immediately throws himself into danger for the heroine. He enjoys his luxurious, hedonistic lifestyle, and I suspect that, at least a few times early on, he regretted making a deal with Eda. He carries his own trauma and undergoes a meaningful transformation throughout the story as well.
But my absolute favorite character has to be Tripp. It was so refreshing to see a familiar who doesn't immediately adore their master’s love interest, and his banter with Eda is just delightful! Unfortunately, the main villain felt somewhat one-dimensional and almost cartoonish, and the entire storyline surrounding him strongly echoes the Catholic Church and the Inquisition. That is not necessarily a criticism, just an observation.
I was convinced this was a standalone novel, but the last two paragraphs suggest otherwise. Still, the characters do get a HFN ending. That said, I have some questions about how long they will actually stay together. Eda is mortal, after all, so Kit and the author will either have to come up with a solution, or he is destined for a fate as heartbreaking as Robin's.
Overall, it’s a solid story that is absolutely perfect for spooky season.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this ARC
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Sneak Peek Book Review: Reap & Sow by Charlotte B. Plumb (First ~80 pages review)
The opening stretch of Reap & Sow is almost entirely about establishing its system and tone, and it commits to that without much hesitation. We are quickly placed inside Eda Shaw’s world, where an antique shop doubles as a front for illegal demon contracts known as Pacts. The book does not spend much time orienting the reader gently; instead, it relies on atmosphere and implication. The result is an immediate sense that this is a structured, transactional kind of magic system where morality has already been normalized into procedure.
Eda is introduced as someone shaped by long familiarity with this system rather than someone discovering it. She is competent, contained, and functional in a way that suggests survival more than personal ambition. In these early pages, she is not yet deeply rounded emotionally, but she works well as a lens through which the reader experiences the rules of this world. The “years as currency” concept and the inherited nature of the family’s involvement in Pacts give the setting its weight, even before the larger plot fully activates.
Mr. Night is the most striking presence in this section. He is framed as an immortal, non-human entity tied to the contract system, and Eda’s family refers to him as a demon within their working vocabulary. The implication that their father entered into a massive, binding agreement with him establishes the central tension of inherited debt and obligation. There is also an early suggestion of conflict between Mr. Night and other similar beings, which hints at a broader hierarchy or ecosystem of power that is only partially visible at this stage.
At this point, the book is still heavily front-loaded with setup rather than payoff. The mechanics of the Pact system, the scale of the family’s debt, and the nature of Mr. Night’s role are all being revealed in fragments rather than fully explained. Character dynamics beyond Eda and Mr. Night have not yet developed much complexity, and the emotional stakes are still mostly implied. What the first 80 pages do well is establish mood, premise, and system clarity. What they have not yet done is fully convert that setup into narrative momentum or deeper character investment.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
The opening stretch of Reap & Sow is almost entirely about establishing its system and tone, and it commits to that without much hesitation. We are quickly placed inside Eda Shaw’s world, where an antique shop doubles as a front for illegal demon contracts known as Pacts. The book does not spend much time orienting the reader gently; instead, it relies on atmosphere and implication. The result is an immediate sense that this is a structured, transactional kind of magic system where morality has already been normalized into procedure.
Eda is introduced as someone shaped by long familiarity with this system rather than someone discovering it. She is competent, contained, and functional in a way that suggests survival more than personal ambition. In these early pages, she is not yet deeply rounded emotionally, but she works well as a lens through which the reader experiences the rules of this world. The “years as currency” concept and the inherited nature of the family’s involvement in Pacts give the setting its weight, even before the larger plot fully activates.
Mr. Night is the most striking presence in this section. He is framed as an immortal, non-human entity tied to the contract system, and Eda’s family refers to him as a demon within their working vocabulary. The implication that their father entered into a massive, binding agreement with him establishes the central tension of inherited debt and obligation. There is also an early suggestion of conflict between Mr. Night and other similar beings, which hints at a broader hierarchy or ecosystem of power that is only partially visible at this stage.
At this point, the book is still heavily front-loaded with setup rather than payoff. The mechanics of the Pact system, the scale of the family’s debt, and the nature of Mr. Night’s role are all being revealed in fragments rather than fully explained. Character dynamics beyond Eda and Mr. Night have not yet developed much complexity, and the emotional stakes are still mostly implied. What the first 80 pages do well is establish mood, premise, and system clarity. What they have not yet done is fully convert that setup into narrative momentum or deeper character investment.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Big thanks to Berkley XO and Netgalley for a copy of Reap & Sow for review purposes. All quotes are from an uncorrected proof and are subject to change.
"I'll take any of it," he'd said. "Your anger, your disgust, your scorn. I despise every moment your eyes aren't on me."
I had such a good time reading this book. Demons, Gothic scenery, religious zealots, and a plot that felt unique and fun.
In this book, demons barter years off a person's life in trade for nearly anything they desire: wealth, status, power, you name it. The years are then added to the demon's life. The Pact is sealed in blood and is irreversible unless the signee kills the demon themselves.
Kit'rath has a penchant for the human world. As the second son to a powerful demon, he has a powerful enemy that he would rather not face. Infernus isn't as different as life in our world. His peers were cruel and unkind. Softhearted demons aren't the norm there. He finds art, music, and human life beautiful. I think Kit should have been an artist himself because he says some really beautiful things to Eda.
"Your whim is my delight and torture." 🥲
Eda spent her whole life repaying her father's debt and then continues to sacrifice herself again, and again, and again. I felt so bad for her for most of the book. Not because she wasn't brave and badass, just because life really kept giving her the short end of the stick. Kit gives her the love she deserves, but he's also taken from her as well. Their relationship is one big conundrum. I adored him and then I was angry with him, on repeat.
As far as intimate scenes go, they were pretty tame. (I read a lot of smutty books, so this is just my opinion.) I wanted a little bit more from it, but I totally understand that this is New Adult, so it's an introduction to more explicit stuff. I like that it's written true to the genre. The yearning and tension were absolutely enough to keep me invested.
The end of this book has me clutching my pearls because what was that last paragraph? I need answers, and I need them now!
"I'll take any of it," he'd said. "Your anger, your disgust, your scorn. I despise every moment your eyes aren't on me."
I had such a good time reading this book. Demons, Gothic scenery, religious zealots, and a plot that felt unique and fun.
In this book, demons barter years off a person's life in trade for nearly anything they desire: wealth, status, power, you name it. The years are then added to the demon's life. The Pact is sealed in blood and is irreversible unless the signee kills the demon themselves.
Kit'rath has a penchant for the human world. As the second son to a powerful demon, he has a powerful enemy that he would rather not face. Infernus isn't as different as life in our world. His peers were cruel and unkind. Softhearted demons aren't the norm there. He finds art, music, and human life beautiful. I think Kit should have been an artist himself because he says some really beautiful things to Eda.
"Your whim is my delight and torture." 🥲
Eda spent her whole life repaying her father's debt and then continues to sacrifice herself again, and again, and again. I felt so bad for her for most of the book. Not because she wasn't brave and badass, just because life really kept giving her the short end of the stick. Kit gives her the love she deserves, but he's also taken from her as well. Their relationship is one big conundrum. I adored him and then I was angry with him, on repeat.
As far as intimate scenes go, they were pretty tame. (I read a lot of smutty books, so this is just my opinion.) I wanted a little bit more from it, but I totally understand that this is New Adult, so it's an introduction to more explicit stuff. I like that it's written true to the genre. The yearning and tension were absolutely enough to keep me invested.
The end of this book has me clutching my pearls because what was that last paragraph? I need answers, and I need them now!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Rating: 4.25⭐️
This book is has that chilling, eerie atmosphere. We’ve got dark gothic world-building, demons, sinister bargains, secrets, a cute romance, and somehow, against all odds, a found family that made me emotional.
The premise alone drew me in. Demons can grant you practically anything you want, but in return they take years from your lifespan to extend their own. The bargain can’t be undone unless you kill the demon involved, which is already horrifying enough. But then the story starts introducing loopholes and technicalities, which made the plot even more gripping.
Eda is exactly the kind of protagonist I love. She’s willing to sacrifice everything for the people she cares about, even if it means handing over years of her own life to do it. Watching her grow from someone naive and gullible into someone braver, stronger, and far more fearless to challenge the horrors around her was one of my favorite parts of the book. And I love the chaotic yet wholesome sibling dynamics between Eda and her brothers.
And look, I don’t think it’s surprising to anyone at this point that I have a thing for cheeky, snarky, morally questionable rage baiter love interests. The idea of a demon who genuinely sees beauty in humanity and music is actually a little suspiciously tailored to my interests if you ask me. And every single time Kit called Eda darling, I SWEAR I dissolved into a puddle.
The romance itself was cute. I really liked their chemistry and dynamic, but I didn’t fully love it because the build-up moved a little too quickly for my slow-burn-loving soul. I wanted just a little more yearning and tension to marinate in the feelings before diving into the romance.
And finally, we got to the ending. I genuinely have no idea if this is a standalone or not, but if it is, I have concerns. Because that was a cliffhanger and I refuse to accept this level of emotional abandonment.
════════════════════════
Thank you to Penguin Random House and NetGalley for the ARC!
This book is has that chilling, eerie atmosphere. We’ve got dark gothic world-building, demons, sinister bargains, secrets, a cute romance, and somehow, against all odds, a found family that made me emotional.
The premise alone drew me in. Demons can grant you practically anything you want, but in return they take years from your lifespan to extend their own. The bargain can’t be undone unless you kill the demon involved, which is already horrifying enough. But then the story starts introducing loopholes and technicalities, which made the plot even more gripping.
Eda is exactly the kind of protagonist I love. She’s willing to sacrifice everything for the people she cares about, even if it means handing over years of her own life to do it. Watching her grow from someone naive and gullible into someone braver, stronger, and far more fearless to challenge the horrors around her was one of my favorite parts of the book. And I love the chaotic yet wholesome sibling dynamics between Eda and her brothers.
And look, I don’t think it’s surprising to anyone at this point that I have a thing for cheeky, snarky, morally questionable rage baiter love interests. The idea of a demon who genuinely sees beauty in humanity and music is actually a little suspiciously tailored to my interests if you ask me. And every single time Kit called Eda darling, I SWEAR I dissolved into a puddle.
The romance itself was cute. I really liked their chemistry and dynamic, but I didn’t fully love it because the build-up moved a little too quickly for my slow-burn-loving soul. I wanted just a little more yearning and tension to marinate in the feelings before diving into the romance.
And finally, we got to the ending. I genuinely have no idea if this is a standalone or not, but if it is, I have concerns. Because that was a cliffhanger and I refuse to accept this level of emotional abandonment.
════════════════════════
Thank you to Penguin Random House and NetGalley for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Reap & Sow gives you a witty gothic Romantasy setting where you can feel the dark gloomy world in Blackbridge out of the pages that made the reading experience more appealing.
This story is perfect for those looking for their new demon Romantasy with slow burn tension and bonus that it’s a standalone!
I enjoyed the premise of the story where our FMC, Eda bargains with a demon in order to save her brothers, as they need to arrange a Pact to bring Mr. Knight his 50 years by autumn harvest or else they will be killed. I also found it interesting where if a demon fails of your wishes, the proposed number of years would be taken away from their lifespan instead.
Mr. Knight is a beautiful demon and ancient. Something about him draws you closer to him but also has your hairs stand up. He trades years of a mortals life for their deepest desires but he also can be terrifying. However, he did portray as a family figure towards Eda.
Then comes into the picture, Kit’rath. An infuriating demon and the only being in Blackbridge that Mr. Knight fears. This man was dangerously hot and mysterious but also charming and loved every second of him in this book and his interactions with Eda.
Their romance evolves in a beautiful way while showing real raw emotions but also lightening up the read with some humor and found family moments which helps balance the story out but keeping you invested in the plot.
Some moments felt a bit off in some chapters where I did tend to lose interest but it does pick back up and once you get to ending. I thought it was enjoyable overall and satisfying to where it will get you thinking if we might potentially get something more in the future! I could see this story expanding into something more!
Thank you so much to Berkley XO and Charlotte for the eARC! I’m so glad I got the chance to read this story and can’t wait for more readers to discover this atmospheric gothic Romantasy soon! 💜
This story is perfect for those looking for their new demon Romantasy with slow burn tension and bonus that it’s a standalone!
I enjoyed the premise of the story where our FMC, Eda bargains with a demon in order to save her brothers, as they need to arrange a Pact to bring Mr. Knight his 50 years by autumn harvest or else they will be killed. I also found it interesting where if a demon fails of your wishes, the proposed number of years would be taken away from their lifespan instead.
Mr. Knight is a beautiful demon and ancient. Something about him draws you closer to him but also has your hairs stand up. He trades years of a mortals life for their deepest desires but he also can be terrifying. However, he did portray as a family figure towards Eda.
Then comes into the picture, Kit’rath. An infuriating demon and the only being in Blackbridge that Mr. Knight fears. This man was dangerously hot and mysterious but also charming and loved every second of him in this book and his interactions with Eda.
Their romance evolves in a beautiful way while showing real raw emotions but also lightening up the read with some humor and found family moments which helps balance the story out but keeping you invested in the plot.
Some moments felt a bit off in some chapters where I did tend to lose interest but it does pick back up and once you get to ending. I thought it was enjoyable overall and satisfying to where it will get you thinking if we might potentially get something more in the future! I could see this story expanding into something more!
Thank you so much to Berkley XO and Charlotte for the eARC! I’m so glad I got the chance to read this story and can’t wait for more readers to discover this atmospheric gothic Romantasy soon! 💜
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you SO much Berkley XO and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!!
.
Easiest 5 stars I’ve given in a long time! Holy moley did I love this!! I didn’t really know what to expect going into Reap & Sow beyond the synopsis sounding interesting, but this blew my socks off!! This sweeping fantasy is filled with ill advised bargains, delectable romance, and twists you won’t see coming!
.
It didn’t take me long to realize I was feral for this story because the plot is plottingggg and the character dynamics are EVERYTHING. Our girl Eda is fiercely loyal and displayed the kind of realistic grit and determination I crave in an FMC. She’s not hopped up on bravado, but pragmatic in her goals and limitations. She often needs help and seeks it out in our favorite cheeky demon, Kit. Fans of Cardan Greenbriar (it’s me, I’m fans) eat your heart out! The banter, the flirtation, the snark…I think it took all of two scenes of him on page for me to write the note “oh no I love him”. I don’t want to give away too much but let’s just say one confession in particular had me screeching in a decibel only dogs can hear!!
.
The storyline itself is insanely addictive, grabbing you by the hand and leading you through the twisted streets of Blackbridge with your heart in your throat. I was completely immersed and deeply invested in the fate of the Shaw siblings. It’s a fast paced adventure that will keep you guessing and had me looking like the starry eyed emoji as I turned each page! Despite my desire to unhinge my jaw and swallow this baby while, I actually slowed down and savored it because I didn’t want the book to end. I was in tears by the final pages and was left gaping at the final entry like a fish. How do I recover from this book? Charlotte what have you done to me?? I am a woman forever changed and I fear I will never shut up about how wildly good this masterful romantasy is!
.
Easiest 5 stars I’ve given in a long time! Holy moley did I love this!! I didn’t really know what to expect going into Reap & Sow beyond the synopsis sounding interesting, but this blew my socks off!! This sweeping fantasy is filled with ill advised bargains, delectable romance, and twists you won’t see coming!
.
It didn’t take me long to realize I was feral for this story because the plot is plottingggg and the character dynamics are EVERYTHING. Our girl Eda is fiercely loyal and displayed the kind of realistic grit and determination I crave in an FMC. She’s not hopped up on bravado, but pragmatic in her goals and limitations. She often needs help and seeks it out in our favorite cheeky demon, Kit. Fans of Cardan Greenbriar (it’s me, I’m fans) eat your heart out! The banter, the flirtation, the snark…I think it took all of two scenes of him on page for me to write the note “oh no I love him”. I don’t want to give away too much but let’s just say one confession in particular had me screeching in a decibel only dogs can hear!!
.
The storyline itself is insanely addictive, grabbing you by the hand and leading you through the twisted streets of Blackbridge with your heart in your throat. I was completely immersed and deeply invested in the fate of the Shaw siblings. It’s a fast paced adventure that will keep you guessing and had me looking like the starry eyed emoji as I turned each page! Despite my desire to unhinge my jaw and swallow this baby while, I actually slowed down and savored it because I didn’t want the book to end. I was in tears by the final pages and was left gaping at the final entry like a fish. How do I recover from this book? Charlotte what have you done to me?? I am a woman forever changed and I fear I will never shut up about how wildly good this masterful romantasy is!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I received an ARC from the publisher while attending the Imaginarium Book Festival.
I was immediately drawn in by the cover art. It’s so beautiful, lovely colors and I love the figure on the black smokey horse riding off. Well done to the cover artist for creating something so stunning. While we all know not to judge a book by its cover, it certainly doesn’t hurt to have a stunner.
I admit when I read the synopsis I was feeling kind of so-so about the book. Demons aren’t normally my thing, and deals gone wrong seemed a little cliché. But I was pleasantly surprised and was immediately hooked.
The story follows Eda as she makes some blunders that land her brothers in a jail cell. Enter Kit, a shape-shifting demon Eda runs to in order to make a deal, all the while owing others left and right. She keeps digging her hole deeper and can’t seem to put the shovel down.
The villain is really on the nose. I couldn’t have picked a better, more believable villain if I’d tried. It was not hard to despise him, and I think most people will recognize a hypocritical, self-riotous villain that could just as easily be real as on the pages of a book.
I won’t spoil anything, but the chemistry between Kit and Eda is strong, and this book is great for those that like a slow burn. I’d rate the spice low-medium for this book. There’s definitely some spicy scenes, and Kit has a hell of a mouth on him at times, but this is not the kind of book where the main characters are locked in the bedroom for the entire book. I’m happy to report there’s an actual plot with layers, and dynamic characters with depth.
I will happily and eagerly await more books from this author, I really enjoy this book and read it in a day. That may not sound impressive to my fellow readers, but with how busy a schedule I keep it’s quite the feat for me. This is one book I highly recommend adding to your TBR list.
I was immediately drawn in by the cover art. It’s so beautiful, lovely colors and I love the figure on the black smokey horse riding off. Well done to the cover artist for creating something so stunning. While we all know not to judge a book by its cover, it certainly doesn’t hurt to have a stunner.
I admit when I read the synopsis I was feeling kind of so-so about the book. Demons aren’t normally my thing, and deals gone wrong seemed a little cliché. But I was pleasantly surprised and was immediately hooked.
The story follows Eda as she makes some blunders that land her brothers in a jail cell. Enter Kit, a shape-shifting demon Eda runs to in order to make a deal, all the while owing others left and right. She keeps digging her hole deeper and can’t seem to put the shovel down.
The villain is really on the nose. I couldn’t have picked a better, more believable villain if I’d tried. It was not hard to despise him, and I think most people will recognize a hypocritical, self-riotous villain that could just as easily be real as on the pages of a book.
I won’t spoil anything, but the chemistry between Kit and Eda is strong, and this book is great for those that like a slow burn. I’d rate the spice low-medium for this book. There’s definitely some spicy scenes, and Kit has a hell of a mouth on him at times, but this is not the kind of book where the main characters are locked in the bedroom for the entire book. I’m happy to report there’s an actual plot with layers, and dynamic characters with depth.
I will happily and eagerly await more books from this author, I really enjoy this book and read it in a day. That may not sound impressive to my fellow readers, but with how busy a schedule I keep it’s quite the feat for me. This is one book I highly recommend adding to your TBR list.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I want to thank Rih from Penguin first for sending me this beautiful proof and for always knowing what I am going to love, because I really did love this book.
Eda and her brothers have spent their lives paying a debt to a demon that their father left behind when he passed. Encouraging desperate people to make a deal with Mr Night in return for years from their lives. And just when they are about to clear this debt, it all goes horribly wrong and Eda is left alone and desperate to make a deal of her own, to save her brothers.
Here enters Kit'rath/Kit, a demon who has been hiding in the human relm for the past twenty years, living in luxury and pretending he is nothing more than human. That changes when Eda finds him and asks him to make a pact with her, a deal he simply can't refuse and now they are working closely together to free her family.
This book is so much more than the pact they make. I feel like both Eda and Kit were searching for something they had never had before and they found it in eachother. These characters had so much depth to them, beneath all the bravado they put out to the world were two people who wanted more. It was incredible to read and I really took my time with it because I almost didn't want it to end.
Kit is HILARIOUS, he's so sassy to Eda and their flirtatious banter is what I craved, but to everyone else he was absolutely ruthless. Then there's Eda, she just wants to save her brothers but along the way she realises she also wants to be seen and heard and believe me when I say Kit sees her, the side he shows her is so beautiful 🥺💜.
Also, I loveeeeeee Tripp, he's so mean but its so funny and I want him in my life.
Loved every moment of this book, but after that last sentence I need book 2 now please Charlotte haha.
Reap and Sow is coming out in October and I'll be recommending this to EVERYONE 💜.
Eda and her brothers have spent their lives paying a debt to a demon that their father left behind when he passed. Encouraging desperate people to make a deal with Mr Night in return for years from their lives. And just when they are about to clear this debt, it all goes horribly wrong and Eda is left alone and desperate to make a deal of her own, to save her brothers.
Here enters Kit'rath/Kit, a demon who has been hiding in the human relm for the past twenty years, living in luxury and pretending he is nothing more than human. That changes when Eda finds him and asks him to make a pact with her, a deal he simply can't refuse and now they are working closely together to free her family.
This book is so much more than the pact they make. I feel like both Eda and Kit were searching for something they had never had before and they found it in eachother. These characters had so much depth to them, beneath all the bravado they put out to the world were two people who wanted more. It was incredible to read and I really took my time with it because I almost didn't want it to end.
Kit is HILARIOUS, he's so sassy to Eda and their flirtatious banter is what I craved, but to everyone else he was absolutely ruthless. Then there's Eda, she just wants to save her brothers but along the way she realises she also wants to be seen and heard and believe me when I say Kit sees her, the side he shows her is so beautiful 🥺💜.
Also, I loveeeeeee Tripp, he's so mean but its so funny and I want him in my life.
Loved every moment of this book, but after that last sentence I need book 2 now please Charlotte haha.
Reap and Sow is coming out in October and I'll be recommending this to EVERYONE 💜.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
My second 6-star read of the year and honestly, it deserved every single one of them.
Reap & Sow completely consumed me. The gothic atmosphere, the demon bargains, the found family, the romance, the twists—everything just worked. This is one of those books where I found myself thinking about it whenever I wasn't reading it.
The standout for me was easily the characters. Eda's determination to save her brothers made her impossible not to root for, and every choice she made felt understandable, even when things got messy. But let's be real: Kit'rath absolutely stole the show.
I am obsessed with this man.
He's sarcastic, charming, infuriating, protective, and somehow manages to be both intimidating and incredibly lovable at the same time. The banter between him and Eda was perfection, and every scene they shared had me grinning like an idiot. Fellow Voidwalker fans, trust me when I say Kit'rath gave me serious Antal vibes.
The romance develops beautifully alongside the story. It never overshadows the plot, but every interaction feels meaningful. Add in the found family elements, morally grey characters, and a magic system built around dangerous bargains, and I was completely hooked.
The gothic vibes were immaculate, and I loved how the story balanced humor, heart, and genuinely emotional moments. One minute I was laughing, the next I was stressed, and then somehow crying a few chapters later.
And that ending?
Charlotte B. Plumb, I just want to talk.
I need the sequel immediately because that cliffhanger was absolutely criminal.
If you love gothic fantasy, demon bargains, witty banter, found family, morally grey characters, and romances that sneak up on you and ruin your life, add Reap & Sow to your TBR right now.
Thank you to Berkley XO and Charlotte B. Plumb for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
My second 6-star read of the year and honestly, it deserved every single one of them.
Reap & Sow completely consumed me. The gothic atmosphere, the demon bargains, the found family, the romance, the twists—everything just worked. This is one of those books where I found myself thinking about it whenever I wasn't reading it.
The standout for me was easily the characters. Eda's determination to save her brothers made her impossible not to root for, and every choice she made felt understandable, even when things got messy. But let's be real: Kit'rath absolutely stole the show.
I am obsessed with this man.
He's sarcastic, charming, infuriating, protective, and somehow manages to be both intimidating and incredibly lovable at the same time. The banter between him and Eda was perfection, and every scene they shared had me grinning like an idiot. Fellow Voidwalker fans, trust me when I say Kit'rath gave me serious Antal vibes.
The romance develops beautifully alongside the story. It never overshadows the plot, but every interaction feels meaningful. Add in the found family elements, morally grey characters, and a magic system built around dangerous bargains, and I was completely hooked.
The gothic vibes were immaculate, and I loved how the story balanced humor, heart, and genuinely emotional moments. One minute I was laughing, the next I was stressed, and then somehow crying a few chapters later.
And that ending?
Charlotte B. Plumb, I just want to talk.
I need the sequel immediately because that cliffhanger was absolutely criminal.
If you love gothic fantasy, demon bargains, witty banter, found family, morally grey characters, and romances that sneak up on you and ruin your life, add Reap & Sow to your TBR right now.
Thank you to Berkley XO and Charlotte B. Plumb for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 118 reviews