What do you think?
Rate this book
The Last Fatal Hour
For Leona Gladney, former woman soldier of the Union Army, life goes on despite the echoes of the battlefield in her heart. Now a suffragist and budding socialite in Brooklyn Heights, she yearns for a literary life and family. But her husband’s business partner embezzles their money and disappears.
The society matrons of Brooklyn Heights turn a gimlet eye on Leona after the suspicious death of a wealthy friend. Leona will do anything to find justice for her friend and clear her own name, but she finds only secrets, seances and murder.
The society matrons of Brooklyn Heights turn a gimlet eye on Leona after the suspicious death of a wealthy friend. Leona will do anything to find justice for her friend and clear her own name, but she finds only secrets, seances and murder.
310 pages, Paperback
Published April 7, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
May 5, 2026
Check out all my reviews at: https://www.avonnalovesgenres.com
THE LAST FATAL HOUR by Jan Matthews is an intriguing historical murder mystery and domestic suspense mash-up set post-Civil War in Brooklyn Heights, New York. This book features a female main character attempting to be an amateur sleuth to clear her name and due to blackmail. She was previously a fighting female soldier in disguise during the Civil War who is now struggling with severe PTSD. This is a standalone fictional historical story that is authentic to the era and society it portrays.
Socialite Leona Gladney has attempted to put her past as a soldier in the Union Army and death of her first husband behind her. Remarried and working on personal literary pursuits, she still has dreams and moments of anxiety over her time in the service. Her anxiety is exacerbated by her husband’s business partner disappearing with their company’s funds.
When the robbery and suspicious death of a wealthy friend and matriarch leaves Leona a suspect, she is determined to uncover the real culprit. What she is not prepared for is a tangled web of seances, lies, deception, and murder.
This is an enlightening as well as maddening story of the legal and political struggles women faced in the 19th century intertwined with the intricately plotted chase of a killer. Leona is a strong character that is more than just her heritage and social status, but even as she tries to fulfill her feminine societal duties, she has an entire previous life she has kept from everyone but her grandfather. While her time as a soldier makes her an unusual protagonist, her life is historically possible. The many uses of laudanum especially involving females throughout this story is not only historically accurate, but also sad. While I suspected the outcome, it is still satisfying and once again brings society’s treatment of women to the forefront.
I highly recommend this intriguing historical mystery and domestic suspense mash-up.
THE LAST FATAL HOUR by Jan Matthews is an intriguing historical murder mystery and domestic suspense mash-up set post-Civil War in Brooklyn Heights, New York. This book features a female main character attempting to be an amateur sleuth to clear her name and due to blackmail. She was previously a fighting female soldier in disguise during the Civil War who is now struggling with severe PTSD. This is a standalone fictional historical story that is authentic to the era and society it portrays.
Socialite Leona Gladney has attempted to put her past as a soldier in the Union Army and death of her first husband behind her. Remarried and working on personal literary pursuits, she still has dreams and moments of anxiety over her time in the service. Her anxiety is exacerbated by her husband’s business partner disappearing with their company’s funds.
When the robbery and suspicious death of a wealthy friend and matriarch leaves Leona a suspect, she is determined to uncover the real culprit. What she is not prepared for is a tangled web of seances, lies, deception, and murder.
This is an enlightening as well as maddening story of the legal and political struggles women faced in the 19th century intertwined with the intricately plotted chase of a killer. Leona is a strong character that is more than just her heritage and social status, but even as she tries to fulfill her feminine societal duties, she has an entire previous life she has kept from everyone but her grandfather. While her time as a soldier makes her an unusual protagonist, her life is historically possible. The many uses of laudanum especially involving females throughout this story is not only historically accurate, but also sad. While I suspected the outcome, it is still satisfying and once again brings society’s treatment of women to the forefront.
I highly recommend this intriguing historical mystery and domestic suspense mash-up.
May 8, 2026
Ms Matthews has created a smart and sympathetic heroine in Leona Gadley, one that you don’t mind following through this well-crafted mystery set in a backdrop of rigid societal mores of post-Civil War America.
Ms. Gadley’s secret past, where she disguises herself as a Union soldier, is used to great effect here, offering a believable psyche—a woman scarred by her war experience. Lapses into that emotional trauma color her present day world and reactions. The combat experience gives her enough confidence to wield a gun and to investigate the sudden death of her dear friend, but when her world starts to crumble, her memories of the war, combined with the loss of her first husband and their child, start to haunt her. Such were the times when people were expected to cope with their phantoms and keep their struggles to themselves. Leona, as a member of the upper class, copes by using the only readily available resources available to a woman back then—laudanum and drink.
This addiction presents an interesting character flaw in Leona, and Matthews uses it to create questions for Leona and the reader. As the story unspools, and the twists and obfuscations compound, we begin to doubt the reliability of fact and Leona’s ability to sort it out.
By the end, one begins to suspect who the culprit is, but the final reveal was a great twist that surprised me and Matthews ties it up neatly in the Epilogue. I hope we will see more of the inimitable Leona Gadley. This has the bones for a great series.
I received an advance review copy for free on BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Read
February 3, 2026The Last Fatal Hour by Jan Matthews is a historical fiction mystery set in Brooklyn Heights after the Civil War. The protagonist is Leona Gadney who was a former soldier during the Civil War for the Union. Her desire after the war was to settle down for a literary life and to raise a family. The story reveals to the reader the struggles of women not only in the 19th century is today's society as well. Even thought the story was set in the late 19th century, there are many aspects of the plot which are relevant for us all today.
Her experience in the Civil War is fundamental to the plot of the story. She was psychological scarred by her experience in the war because she had to disguise herself as a man in order to enlist. She learned how men are so much differently than woman in society. Woman needed to adopt the soldierly habits of drinking, swearing, and smoking in order to assimilate themselves to their fellow soldiers.
Her desire at the end of the war was to return to Brooklyn Heights to start a new life. She married a successful business man and began to ingratiate herself into high society. Unfortunately, during this time her husband's business partner embezzled the company's fund and disappeared. This left her family penniless.
Shortly afterward, a family friend was murdered. Due to circumstantial evidence, Leona became a prime suspect. This is where the murder mystery begins for the reader. Because she has become an outlier in society, she decides to investigate the murder of her friend. The investigation began Leona is now considered a prime suspect and scapegoat for the crime. The investigation is necessary not only to find the killer but to clear her name too.
The author utilizes her story to shout out to the world of the struggles of women not only in the 19th century but today as well. The strength of these women at this time is amazing. Not only were many women enlisting to fight in a war but willing to take this courage and challenge the norms of the day especially in their fight to allow women to vote. Not only the right to vote but to have the rights guaranteed to them by the constitution but denied to them by men. These women need to be applauded because they were willing to sacrifice themselves to cure the injustices of the time. Women continue to struggle for their rights as Jan Matthews writes in this story. Please keep your eyes open to the many different themes in this story and learn the lessons revealed to us in this most intriguing story.
Her experience in the Civil War is fundamental to the plot of the story. She was psychological scarred by her experience in the war because she had to disguise herself as a man in order to enlist. She learned how men are so much differently than woman in society. Woman needed to adopt the soldierly habits of drinking, swearing, and smoking in order to assimilate themselves to their fellow soldiers.
Her desire at the end of the war was to return to Brooklyn Heights to start a new life. She married a successful business man and began to ingratiate herself into high society. Unfortunately, during this time her husband's business partner embezzled the company's fund and disappeared. This left her family penniless.
Shortly afterward, a family friend was murdered. Due to circumstantial evidence, Leona became a prime suspect. This is where the murder mystery begins for the reader. Because she has become an outlier in society, she decides to investigate the murder of her friend. The investigation began Leona is now considered a prime suspect and scapegoat for the crime. The investigation is necessary not only to find the killer but to clear her name too.
The author utilizes her story to shout out to the world of the struggles of women not only in the 19th century but today as well. The strength of these women at this time is amazing. Not only were many women enlisting to fight in a war but willing to take this courage and challenge the norms of the day especially in their fight to allow women to vote. Not only the right to vote but to have the rights guaranteed to them by the constitution but denied to them by men. These women need to be applauded because they were willing to sacrifice themselves to cure the injustices of the time. Women continue to struggle for their rights as Jan Matthews writes in this story. Please keep your eyes open to the many different themes in this story and learn the lessons revealed to us in this most intriguing story.
January 21, 2026
I chose this book because the Era and status intrigued me. I felt as if I was following Leona Gladney's life and actions being high society. I also appreciated her past being a union solider and a woman. A lot it reminds me of the pressure women dealt with being high society and having the perfect household and identity. ( These aren't spoilers)
What gave this a fours star instead of a five was the odd pacing felt off sometimes. Sometimes I couldn't put the arc down waiting for what happened next other times it just felt very slow.
For the unique point of view and nail biting parts I definitely would recommend this book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily thanks to booksirens.
What gave this a fours star instead of a five was the odd pacing felt off sometimes. Sometimes I couldn't put the arc down waiting for what happened next other times it just felt very slow.
For the unique point of view and nail biting parts I definitely would recommend this book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily thanks to booksirens.
Review of advance copy
**This is a review of an ARC I was able to read through book sirens.
This is the kind of story I would have read in a matter of hours pre-motherhood. I was instantly gripped by Matthews' vivid descriptions, everything is so clear it's as if you're just hovering around, watching it all unfold. Reading this story was like trying to unravel a very tangled ball of yarn, any tangle that became unfurled lead to another and another. The ending was impeccable.
I highly suggest you add this to your TBR and look out for future publications.
This is the kind of story I would have read in a matter of hours pre-motherhood. I was instantly gripped by Matthews' vivid descriptions, everything is so clear it's as if you're just hovering around, watching it all unfold. Reading this story was like trying to unravel a very tangled ball of yarn, any tangle that became unfurled lead to another and another. The ending was impeccable.
I highly suggest you add this to your TBR and look out for future publications.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I received a complimentary advanced digital copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Many thanks to Netgalley and the Publishers for this opportunity.
This is a fabulous read. It ticked all the boxes for me; intrigue, murder, embezzlement, jealousy, séances with channelling and infidelity all set at a time when women were beginning to find their voice, the Suffrage movement.
The protagonist, Leona Gladney is an adventurous and brave woman. In defending her beliefs she signed up disguised as a young man to become a soldier during the American Civil War. However, she bears the scars of the experience of having to act as a young man; to assimilate and to take on all aspects of male behaviour as well as experiencing the death of fellow soldiers and friends. The consequences have led to the reliance of laudanum, for which Leona desperately tries to rid herself of having to resort to. She doesn’t fit all that well into society as merely a subservient, obedient and beautiful wife as expected during this time; she is a woman with an opinion and physical ability which causes problems in this new marriage. Following her widowhood and returning to Brooklyn Heights, Leona marries for the second time to a wealthy businessman and her life becomes one of sharp contrast to that of her previous young life. She appears to have the world at her feet, a successful socialite, a fund raiser for the suffrage movement, all seem very positive until her husband’s partner embezzles the company’s funds and disappears. This leads to financial difficulties and tension between her and her new husband who spends late hours at work, even not returning at night.
Early in the read Leona visits an elderly longtime friend of hers, Daphne, where she reveals that she is writing her memoirs of her war experience, the writing helps in overcoming the flash backs, however, to be published she would have to take on a pseudonym, or publish anonymously to avoid societal stigma and her husband would not approve at all. Reading her memoirs sees Daphne becoming upset, her own memories brought to life. When the nurse enters to pour sherry, Leona is furious to see that laudanum is going to be administered and she intervenes. In the disruption, she leaves her memoirs at Daphne’s for which become the subject of blackmail. After her visit, the news comes that Daphne has died. Leona is accused of stealing valuable jewellery and of murdering her. This is all linked to her husband’s failing fortunes and finger pointing by Daphne’s grandson.
Determined to clear her name Leona visits another elderly friend. She needs to find Daphne’s nurse and maid, Winifred, both have disappeared. Leona knows that Daphne’s friend will have information that can help her and in conversation, several things are revealed, that unknown to Leona, Daphne and her friend over the years had visited a spiritualist. Daphne had also told her friend that the family were overdosing her on laudanum and that she had become aware that her grandson was having an affair with her nurse.
From here on the read moves into one of intrigue and danger and has Leona and her friend Ruth investigating events, firstly to find the missing maid Winifred who they hope will be able to reveal more of the events of the night when Daphne was murdered.
The book comes to a conclusion with last few chapters revealing the unidentified serial murderer who has Leona in a precarious and dangerous position.
This is a fabulous read. It ticked all the boxes for me; intrigue, murder, embezzlement, jealousy, séances with channelling and infidelity all set at a time when women were beginning to find their voice, the Suffrage movement.
The protagonist, Leona Gladney is an adventurous and brave woman. In defending her beliefs she signed up disguised as a young man to become a soldier during the American Civil War. However, she bears the scars of the experience of having to act as a young man; to assimilate and to take on all aspects of male behaviour as well as experiencing the death of fellow soldiers and friends. The consequences have led to the reliance of laudanum, for which Leona desperately tries to rid herself of having to resort to. She doesn’t fit all that well into society as merely a subservient, obedient and beautiful wife as expected during this time; she is a woman with an opinion and physical ability which causes problems in this new marriage. Following her widowhood and returning to Brooklyn Heights, Leona marries for the second time to a wealthy businessman and her life becomes one of sharp contrast to that of her previous young life. She appears to have the world at her feet, a successful socialite, a fund raiser for the suffrage movement, all seem very positive until her husband’s partner embezzles the company’s funds and disappears. This leads to financial difficulties and tension between her and her new husband who spends late hours at work, even not returning at night.
Early in the read Leona visits an elderly longtime friend of hers, Daphne, where she reveals that she is writing her memoirs of her war experience, the writing helps in overcoming the flash backs, however, to be published she would have to take on a pseudonym, or publish anonymously to avoid societal stigma and her husband would not approve at all. Reading her memoirs sees Daphne becoming upset, her own memories brought to life. When the nurse enters to pour sherry, Leona is furious to see that laudanum is going to be administered and she intervenes. In the disruption, she leaves her memoirs at Daphne’s for which become the subject of blackmail. After her visit, the news comes that Daphne has died. Leona is accused of stealing valuable jewellery and of murdering her. This is all linked to her husband’s failing fortunes and finger pointing by Daphne’s grandson.
Determined to clear her name Leona visits another elderly friend. She needs to find Daphne’s nurse and maid, Winifred, both have disappeared. Leona knows that Daphne’s friend will have information that can help her and in conversation, several things are revealed, that unknown to Leona, Daphne and her friend over the years had visited a spiritualist. Daphne had also told her friend that the family were overdosing her on laudanum and that she had become aware that her grandson was having an affair with her nurse.
From here on the read moves into one of intrigue and danger and has Leona and her friend Ruth investigating events, firstly to find the missing maid Winifred who they hope will be able to reveal more of the events of the night when Daphne was murdered.
The book comes to a conclusion with last few chapters revealing the unidentified serial murderer who has Leona in a precarious and dangerous position.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This book was one of the best I've read in a long while.
Genre tags: Historical fiction, mystery, set in the post-civil war era, sleuth, crime.
This story starts by introducing you to our strong FMC, giving you a glimpse of her history and quickly taking you on a journey that shows her strength of character whilst the lives of the people she loves, are threatened. I don't want to give too much away so I'll explain why I liked this book so much.
It was a complex story with plenty of drama and mystery, yet I felt it was paced very well and easy to follow. There is always something gripping going on.
You felt like you knew the characters very well and the atmosphere the author created was enveloping. The time period is known for the misogyny and inequalities for women and this was interwoven with confidence and taste.
I loved the strong relationships between some characters and the flashes back to the FMC days as a former women soldier of the union army.
I haven't had a book in a while that has traveled with me whilst doing chores, because I didn't want to miss the time between jobs, that could be spent reading.
I could not fault this book.
Thank you to Netgallery, Jan Matthew's and Coffee&Ink Press for the opportunity to give a truthful review on this ARC. My words are my own (thanks Natasha)
Genre tags: Historical fiction, mystery, set in the post-civil war era, sleuth, crime.
This story starts by introducing you to our strong FMC, giving you a glimpse of her history and quickly taking you on a journey that shows her strength of character whilst the lives of the people she loves, are threatened. I don't want to give too much away so I'll explain why I liked this book so much.
It was a complex story with plenty of drama and mystery, yet I felt it was paced very well and easy to follow. There is always something gripping going on.
You felt like you knew the characters very well and the atmosphere the author created was enveloping. The time period is known for the misogyny and inequalities for women and this was interwoven with confidence and taste.
I loved the strong relationships between some characters and the flashes back to the FMC days as a former women soldier of the union army.
I haven't had a book in a while that has traveled with me whilst doing chores, because I didn't want to miss the time between jobs, that could be spent reading.
I could not fault this book.
Thank you to Netgallery, Jan Matthew's and Coffee&Ink Press for the opportunity to give a truthful review on this ARC. My words are my own (thanks Natasha)
May 8, 2026
While reading this novel, I was drawn into the intricacies that Leona encounters at every turn. As the story progresses, the plot only thickens and more mysteries arise. It quickly becomes apparent there is no simple answer to any of the questions Leona finds herself facing, and the more she searches for the truth, the more lies she uncovers.
Leona is a character I had a hard time connecting with. I admired that she could not sit by and wait for answers, even though many people tell her to leave the investigations alone. To find the truth, she realizes she has to discover it herself, even though others in her society are not happy with her poking her nose in their business. Her past has given her the confidence to stand on her own two feet, to push for what she wants and fight when necessary, but society frowns on women taking such an active interest in matters of murder and injustice.
Leona is a truly complex character. I was on her side even though I disapproved of her choices. I admired her grit and kindness to others. She seems pessimistic and yet, to be fair, she is often on her own in all her challenges. She struggles with ‘Soldier’s heart’ and is drawn back into her traumatic war experiences. These episodes tell us more about Leona even though uncomfortable to read.
Despite the many plot threads of this novel, it is not overly complicated. It can be a little difficult sometimes to keep track of all the characters, for Leona’s world is complex and made up of many people. A few characters seem unnecessary, their presence in the story lasting only a chapter or two, while other characters come back to the forefront of the story. Leona is involved in many different things; her writing and involvement in the suffragette movement are most important and these interests create a well-rounded character, though it might feel as though they simply fill in an already complex plot. The story is believable and the investigations Leona undertakes show her determination. The story contains a great deal of detail.
"The Last Fatal Hour" is an intense and intriguing historical novel of mystery and deception. With its many twists, layered secrets, and complex plot lines, it keeps the reader guessing right up until the final pages. The carefully written mystery and diligent protagonist make it an engaging read. Readers who enjoy historical mysteries filled with secrets and unexpected revelations will enjoy the story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Leona is a character I had a hard time connecting with. I admired that she could not sit by and wait for answers, even though many people tell her to leave the investigations alone. To find the truth, she realizes she has to discover it herself, even though others in her society are not happy with her poking her nose in their business. Her past has given her the confidence to stand on her own two feet, to push for what she wants and fight when necessary, but society frowns on women taking such an active interest in matters of murder and injustice.
Leona is a truly complex character. I was on her side even though I disapproved of her choices. I admired her grit and kindness to others. She seems pessimistic and yet, to be fair, she is often on her own in all her challenges. She struggles with ‘Soldier’s heart’ and is drawn back into her traumatic war experiences. These episodes tell us more about Leona even though uncomfortable to read.
Despite the many plot threads of this novel, it is not overly complicated. It can be a little difficult sometimes to keep track of all the characters, for Leona’s world is complex and made up of many people. A few characters seem unnecessary, their presence in the story lasting only a chapter or two, while other characters come back to the forefront of the story. Leona is involved in many different things; her writing and involvement in the suffragette movement are most important and these interests create a well-rounded character, though it might feel as though they simply fill in an already complex plot. The story is believable and the investigations Leona undertakes show her determination. The story contains a great deal of detail.
"The Last Fatal Hour" is an intense and intriguing historical novel of mystery and deception. With its many twists, layered secrets, and complex plot lines, it keeps the reader guessing right up until the final pages. The carefully written mystery and diligent protagonist make it an engaging read. Readers who enjoy historical mysteries filled with secrets and unexpected revelations will enjoy the story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
The Last Fatal Hour is a historical fiction novel you should definitely check out if you are looking for a story that is filled with mystery, m*rder, gaslighting, and just about any other scandalous element you can think of. I have to admit that after a while not only was I questioning the sanity of the main fmc but also my own sanity. I will also say this book also gives a clear message of the dangers and effects of morphine in the late nineteenth century. I would highly recommend this book to anyone if you are looking for a historical fiction story to keep on your toes.
We are introduced to Leona who despite living a comfortable lifestyle still deals with the struggles of losing her first husband. Her current husband is having a hard time with business ever since his partner ran off with their money. Things get harder to handle when a very good friend of Leona's dies and the circumstances of her death are very peculiar.
Against her better judgement Leona is determined to discover the true culprit. It will be a journey through the darkest part of the community and will include spiritual seances. But will the quest for the truth be enough for Leona or will it cause her own downfall as well.
We are introduced to Leona who despite living a comfortable lifestyle still deals with the struggles of losing her first husband. Her current husband is having a hard time with business ever since his partner ran off with their money. Things get harder to handle when a very good friend of Leona's dies and the circumstances of her death are very peculiar.
Against her better judgement Leona is determined to discover the true culprit. It will be a journey through the darkest part of the community and will include spiritual seances. But will the quest for the truth be enough for Leona or will it cause her own downfall as well.
May 28, 2026
A newlywed society matron’s secret investigation into the mysterious death of an old friend uncovers more than she ever imagined.
The Last Fatal Hour is an excellent new historical mystery by author Jan Matthews and follows the efforts of newlywed Leona Gladney to discover what caused the death of her elderly, longtime friend, society matron Daphne Van Wyn, who died suddenly one night under suspicious circumstances, and her jewelry was stolen. Warned away from involving herself in the police investigation by both the lead detective and her husband, Leona is unable to leave it alone when Daphne’s grandson and heir accuses her of taking the jewelry. Shunned by all of Brooklyn society, her determination to find out what happened the night of Daphne’s death is further cemented when the grandson’s wife approaches her with suspicions that her husband is somehow involved in his grandmother’s death.
Leona Gladney is one of the most intriguing main characters I’ve encountered in forever. The granddaughter of a renowned poet, abolitionist, and Transcendentalist, Leona, at age 17, ran away from her boarding school, disguised herself as a young man, joined the Union Army, and fought alongside regular soldiers until she was discovered after being wounded at Gettysburg. She struggles with what is now called PTSD, suffering moments where she believes she’s back on the battlefield. Her mother’s family comes from the social elite of Boston, who covered for her absence from school and home by claiming she was serving as a nurse for the battlefield wounded. She met, married, and eventually lost her beloved husband, Jack, and their only child. After a period of mourning, she has recently remarried. Her new husband, Brooklyn businessman and widower, Gil Gladney, is charming and quite taken with his wife’s social status. She adds to her household budget by writing essays and reviews for a local paper, but secretly pens a military-adventure series featuring two young soldiers, Ned and Zed, based on boys she served with who come home. She is interested in publishing her wartime memoirs, but anonymously, as she has never revealed that part of her past to her new husband.Gil is a traditionalist in their marriage and does not share his burdens with his new wife easily, such as how bad their current financial situation is since his business partner absconded with all their liquid assets. He does not understand Leona’s strengths or determination to uncover the truth behind Daphne’s death, and spends too much time away from home, working in the city. Throughout the book, I wondered what secrets Gil was keeping from Leona, but I enjoyed their early but infrequent cozy evenings at home together.
Once compelled to take up her own inquiries, Leona makes some major headway in discovering who was behind Daphne’s death, answers seemingly denied to the professional police investigator, Detective Gideon Day. I enjoyed how her friend, Ruth Appelman, insisted on accompanying her on her more questionable forays when she could. But her going alone into the house of the spiritualists had me on the edge of my seat every moment. Major plot twists elevate this historical mystery to a 5-star reading experience for me.I recommend THE LAST FATAL HOUR to readers of historical mysteries.
I voluntarily reviewed this after receiving an Advance Review Copy from the author through Partners in Crime Virtual Book Tours.
May 25, 2026
If you think modern high-society drama is brutal, try surviving it as a former Civil War soldier with a ruined bank account.
If you love a story with a powerhouse female lead, a ton of post-war tension, and a healthy dose of 19th-century creepiness, you need to add this to your TBR list!
The Last Fatal Hour follows Leona Gladney, a former Union Army soldier who is trying her best to transition into a peaceful literary life as a suffragist and budding socialite in Brooklyn Heights. But peace is apparently not on the menu for Leona. First, her husband's business partner embezzles all their money and vanishes. Then, a wealthy friend dies under highly suspicious circumstances, and the judgmental elite of Brooklyn Heights immediately point their fingers at Leona. To clear her name, she has to dive headfirst into a web of dark secrets, shady séances, and murder.
Here is my honest first-person review of why this book absolutely stole my sleeping hours:
🪶 Leona is the Ultimate Badass Protagonist: Leona is complex, elegant, yet incredibly tough. Those flashbacks to her days on the battlefield give her such a grounded, fascinating edge. Watching her navigate a deeply misogynistic society while refusing to be pushed around was incredibly satisfying.
The Atmospheric Séance Vibes: The historical details are top-tier, but the inclusion of the Victorian spiritualism movement and séances added a layer of genuine, chilling menace. The author perfectly captures that eerie balance of desperation and deception that ruled the era.
⏱️The Verdict: The pacing has a few slow moments early on while the intricate pieces of the mystery are being set up, but once it snowballs, it becomes impossible to put down. The ending is brilliantly layered and worth every single page!
✨️Thank you, Partners in Crime Tours and Jan Matthews, for sharing The Last Fatal Hour with me!
If you love a story with a powerhouse female lead, a ton of post-war tension, and a healthy dose of 19th-century creepiness, you need to add this to your TBR list!
The Last Fatal Hour follows Leona Gladney, a former Union Army soldier who is trying her best to transition into a peaceful literary life as a suffragist and budding socialite in Brooklyn Heights. But peace is apparently not on the menu for Leona. First, her husband's business partner embezzles all their money and vanishes. Then, a wealthy friend dies under highly suspicious circumstances, and the judgmental elite of Brooklyn Heights immediately point their fingers at Leona. To clear her name, she has to dive headfirst into a web of dark secrets, shady séances, and murder.
Here is my honest first-person review of why this book absolutely stole my sleeping hours:
🪶 Leona is the Ultimate Badass Protagonist: Leona is complex, elegant, yet incredibly tough. Those flashbacks to her days on the battlefield give her such a grounded, fascinating edge. Watching her navigate a deeply misogynistic society while refusing to be pushed around was incredibly satisfying.
The Atmospheric Séance Vibes: The historical details are top-tier, but the inclusion of the Victorian spiritualism movement and séances added a layer of genuine, chilling menace. The author perfectly captures that eerie balance of desperation and deception that ruled the era.
⏱️The Verdict: The pacing has a few slow moments early on while the intricate pieces of the mystery are being set up, but once it snowballs, it becomes impossible to put down. The ending is brilliantly layered and worth every single page!
✨️Thank you, Partners in Crime Tours and Jan Matthews, for sharing The Last Fatal Hour with me!
May 27, 2026
MY THOUGHTS:
When I opened up this book I intended on just reading the first page, just to get a feel for it. I did not stop reading! I just enjoyed this book so much! I love historical fiction, especially books that take place in the mid to late 1800s. When women were trying to find their way in society but just couldn’t get a hold. Whenever I start reading one, I always feel like I’m “coming home“. I just wanted to wrap myself up in this novel, live in that world and be best friends with Leona. Not only did this book make me feel like I was right there, it made me feel like I wanted to be right there. This book was so beautifully written, real and authentic.
This story certainly amps up a bit halfway through and gets pretty exciting! I was gripping the edge of my seat in fear of what might happen to Leona.
This is a historical mystery. But this book is so much more than that! This book moved me. This book is about loss and grieving, it’s about survival, it’s also about love, and about women’s rights or lack of. It IS a mystery… But it also has all these other things not so hidden within the pages.
"Women are always at the mercy of Men, the Law, and Society's expectation." Leona said.
This really makes me want to reread A Room of One’s Own by Virginia Wolf one of my all-time favorite books. I have been wanting to reread it but this book makes it so much more relevant to reread it now. IYKYK. I guess you are going to have to read that one and this one to fully understand. Both of which I highly recommend!
I voluntarily posted this review after receiving an e-copy of this book from Partners in Crime Tours. Thank You!
When I opened up this book I intended on just reading the first page, just to get a feel for it. I did not stop reading! I just enjoyed this book so much! I love historical fiction, especially books that take place in the mid to late 1800s. When women were trying to find their way in society but just couldn’t get a hold. Whenever I start reading one, I always feel like I’m “coming home“. I just wanted to wrap myself up in this novel, live in that world and be best friends with Leona. Not only did this book make me feel like I was right there, it made me feel like I wanted to be right there. This book was so beautifully written, real and authentic.
This story certainly amps up a bit halfway through and gets pretty exciting! I was gripping the edge of my seat in fear of what might happen to Leona.
This is a historical mystery. But this book is so much more than that! This book moved me. This book is about loss and grieving, it’s about survival, it’s also about love, and about women’s rights or lack of. It IS a mystery… But it also has all these other things not so hidden within the pages.
"Women are always at the mercy of Men, the Law, and Society's expectation." Leona said.
This really makes me want to reread A Room of One’s Own by Virginia Wolf one of my all-time favorite books. I have been wanting to reread it but this book makes it so much more relevant to reread it now. IYKYK. I guess you are going to have to read that one and this one to fully understand. Both of which I highly recommend!
I voluntarily posted this review after receiving an e-copy of this book from Partners in Crime Tours. Thank You!
May 24, 2026
I just finished reading The Last Fatal Hour by Jan Matthews, and it lives up to its title.
The story takes place in New York right after the Civil War, and the author does an excellent job of bringing that era to life. What completely stole the show for me was the main character, Leona, who is a wonderfully complicated heroine. As a former Union Army soldier turned author and suffragist, she has a fascinating blend of strengths and vulnerabilities that make her feel incredibly real and deeply human. Balancing the dark shadows of her past with her modern ambitions for independence, she stands out as a genuinely compelling and intelligent sleuth, despite the concerns of the men in her life. As murders, robberies, and kidnappings start happening, the mystery and intrigue increase by 100%.
The book has a very eerie atmosphere, especially during scenes involving 19th-century spiritualists and séances. The mystery doesn't wrap up in a traditional parlor-room reveal, but instead, Leona uses her military background and sharp wit to completely outmaneuver the Brooklyn Heights socialites and the killer. She wanted to publicly clear her name on her own terms.
The ending does leave a few things up in the air, which left me wondering if the author plans to write a sequel to continue the story.
Overall, it is a well-written and engaging read with an unforgettable heroine. If you love historical mysteries with a great atmosphere and deeply interesting characters, I recommend adding this to your reading list.
***3.5-4 Stars****
The story takes place in New York right after the Civil War, and the author does an excellent job of bringing that era to life. What completely stole the show for me was the main character, Leona, who is a wonderfully complicated heroine. As a former Union Army soldier turned author and suffragist, she has a fascinating blend of strengths and vulnerabilities that make her feel incredibly real and deeply human. Balancing the dark shadows of her past with her modern ambitions for independence, she stands out as a genuinely compelling and intelligent sleuth, despite the concerns of the men in her life. As murders, robberies, and kidnappings start happening, the mystery and intrigue increase by 100%.
The book has a very eerie atmosphere, especially during scenes involving 19th-century spiritualists and séances. The mystery doesn't wrap up in a traditional parlor-room reveal, but instead, Leona uses her military background and sharp wit to completely outmaneuver the Brooklyn Heights socialites and the killer. She wanted to publicly clear her name on her own terms.
The ending does leave a few things up in the air, which left me wondering if the author plans to write a sequel to continue the story.
Overall, it is a well-written and engaging read with an unforgettable heroine. If you love historical mysteries with a great atmosphere and deeply interesting characters, I recommend adding this to your reading list.
***3.5-4 Stars****
May 14, 2026
4.4
*Thank you to Partners in Crime Tours for including me on this tour!!
Embezzlement, shun, labyrinthine…
Leona, disguised as a man, fought for the Union in the Civil War. Now post-war, she lives in Brooklyn Heights with her current husband Gil. She dreams of a family and writing a novel.
A historical mystery tale of PTSD, embezzlement, false personas, threats, and scams. The author very vividly writes about pressures and struggles for 19th Century women. She brings strong images of rigid social norms/standards of the times.
Leona is a strong female character who doesn’t always meet societal expectations. She definitely has a secret past - with this past comes “psychological & emotional distress” caused by her wartime experiences.
Social, legal, and medical obstacles will restrict her actions when she starts sleuthing a friend’s death. Can she solve the case, when the police appear to be stumped?
This mystery had a unique premise as its hook. A fresh, inventive angle that sets it apart from other mysteries.
I was motivated to read more about female soldiers in the Civil War. Of course, exact numbers are unknown. I did read about several notable female soldiers and unique units.
I like reading books with Civil War backgrounds. A nice switch from the numerous books with WWII settings!
*Thank you to Partners in Crime Tours for including me on this tour!!
Embezzlement, shun, labyrinthine…
Leona, disguised as a man, fought for the Union in the Civil War. Now post-war, she lives in Brooklyn Heights with her current husband Gil. She dreams of a family and writing a novel.
A historical mystery tale of PTSD, embezzlement, false personas, threats, and scams. The author very vividly writes about pressures and struggles for 19th Century women. She brings strong images of rigid social norms/standards of the times.
Leona is a strong female character who doesn’t always meet societal expectations. She definitely has a secret past - with this past comes “psychological & emotional distress” caused by her wartime experiences.
Social, legal, and medical obstacles will restrict her actions when she starts sleuthing a friend’s death. Can she solve the case, when the police appear to be stumped?
This mystery had a unique premise as its hook. A fresh, inventive angle that sets it apart from other mysteries.
I was motivated to read more about female soldiers in the Civil War. Of course, exact numbers are unknown. I did read about several notable female soldiers and unique units.
I like reading books with Civil War backgrounds. A nice switch from the numerous books with WWII settings!
May 17, 2026
I am generally not a fan of historical fiction but I liked this one. Granted, I felt the novel started out a bit slow. Matthews pays particular attention to the clothing and other details of the era, something I do not find find compelling. Lovers of historical novels will like that, however. There are also some flashbacks of Leona's time in the Civil War, a young woman pretending to be male so she could fight. Leona's character is developed further as she writes fiction stories and also participates in suffragist meetings.
About half way through, the novel became really interesting to me. There was an exploration of spiritualism at the time. There were also references to the frequent use of laudanum. I liked that Loena read Poe's short stories featuring Dupin to learn how to do a proper investigation. When she starts really investigating, the tension builds. There are some good twists and a suitable amount of suspense at the end.
So I was pleasantly surprised by this historical mystery. History fiction buffs will like it for its attention to detail and mystery lovers will enjoy it too.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book through Partners in Crime Book Tours. My comments are an independent review.
About half way through, the novel became really interesting to me. There was an exploration of spiritualism at the time. There were also references to the frequent use of laudanum. I liked that Loena read Poe's short stories featuring Dupin to learn how to do a proper investigation. When she starts really investigating, the tension builds. There are some good twists and a suitable amount of suspense at the end.
So I was pleasantly surprised by this historical mystery. History fiction buffs will like it for its attention to detail and mystery lovers will enjoy it too.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book through Partners in Crime Book Tours. My comments are an independent review.
Review of advance copy
This was a great book. It started slowly but soon sped up, and I was pleased. The characters were great. Leona had so many aspects to her character and had endured so much, but was so strong. I did not see the ending coming, which is why I loved it so much.
April 14, 2026
3.5/5⭐️
ARC copy provided by NetGalley
Leona Gladney is a society heiress, a suffragette, and secretly a former Union soldier. Following the disappearance of her husbands business partner along with all of their funds, Leona is eyed as a suspect when her close friend mysteriously dies and her jewelry vanishes. Leona takes it upon herself to unravel the mystery before she is next.
I wish this story had focused more on Leona and her time as a Union soldier. While we got brief glimpses through flashbacks, it felt completely underdeveloped and unexplored. While I understand that this is a work of historical fiction I also despise how the struggle with PTSD was presented. The mystery was intriguing and the ultimate reveal was shocking, but overall the pacing on this was a bit strange and lost me at a few points.
ARC copy provided by NetGalley
Leona Gladney is a society heiress, a suffragette, and secretly a former Union soldier. Following the disappearance of her husbands business partner along with all of their funds, Leona is eyed as a suspect when her close friend mysteriously dies and her jewelry vanishes. Leona takes it upon herself to unravel the mystery before she is next.
I wish this story had focused more on Leona and her time as a Union soldier. While we got brief glimpses through flashbacks, it felt completely underdeveloped and unexplored. While I understand that this is a work of historical fiction I also despise how the struggle with PTSD was presented. The mystery was intriguing and the ultimate reveal was shocking, but overall the pacing on this was a bit strange and lost me at a few points.
Review of advance copy
Life has never been particularly easy for Leona Gladney, but she has always managed to fight on and push through any difficulties thrown her way. This time, though, she might have met her match against things outside of her control.
Leona had planned on her life becoming easier after marrying Gil: a nice house, highly esteemed company, and nothing to worry about. But that isn’t necessarily the way things seem to go. She is not used to living the life of a contented married woman, her past holding some dark secrets that push her forward into high-stakes situations and curiosity that cannot be held back.
When a good friend of Leona’s is found dead, suspicions fly uncontrollably. Gossip is rife, and even though the death is pinned on natural causes, Leona cannot shake the feeling that something else is going on. Missing jewellery, staff whose whereabouts are unknown, and a deep feeling of dread push Leona on, determined to learn the truth about what happened to her friend and whether foul play is at hand. But society has turned its gossip onto her, and Leona quickly finds herself cut off from the friends she once held dear, their suspicions and whispers directed at her.
This is a novel of intricate storylines and complex matters. It is not only Daphne Van Wyn’s death that brings about suspicion, but also the matter of the missing jewellery. Leona’s husband had recently been swindled by his business partner, money stolen and lost, and the future of their livelihood hanging in the balance. Leona was a dear friend of Daphne, and with the plight of her husband’s finances widely known, people cannot help but suspect her of taking advantage of Daphne’s trust to gain access to expensive jewellery that could help to solve their financial situation. And yet, despite her innocence, Leona cannot help but feel that something more is going on than meets the eye. For Leona, all signs point to murder, and yet the distinct lack of motive makes it difficult for her to point a finger at anyone in particular. To learn the truth, she must dive deeper, learn more about the circumstances surrounding the death, and try to find out what happened to the staff who have not been seen since that dreadful night.
While reading this novel, I quickly found myself drawn into the careful intricacies that Leona encounters at every turn. As the story progresses, the plot only thickens and more mysteries arise. It quickly becomes apparent that there is no simple answer to any of the questions Leona finds herself facing, and the more she searches for the truth, the more lies she uncovers. I found myself consistently intrigued by this novel as I read, for the plot twists and turns so much that the moment you feel you might understand what is going on, something else happens that throws every assumption to the wind.
Leona is a character I found myself instantly connected to. She simply cannot sit by and wait for answers to find her, despite many people telling her to leave her investigations alone. To find the truth, she quickly realises that she must uncover it herself, but many people are not overly fond of her poking her nose in where it is not welcome. Her past has given her the confidence to stand on her own two feet, to push for what she wants and fight for freedom when necessary, but society frowns on women taking such an active interest in matters of finances, murder, and injustice.
Leona is a truly complex character. She joined the Union Army under a false name and fought under the alias of Private Leo Harrison, her hair cut short to blend in amongst the men. Despite the ghosts of war haunting her dreams and the acrid taste of gunpowder following her into her waking life, her time as a soldier has made her tough. Despite the lasting mental mark that war has left on her, it has given her the confidence to step forth into a difficult situation and be prepared to fight her way out if necessary. She refuses to back down, and this gives her an edge as she pushes forward in her careful investigations. The portrayal of how the war affected Leona is upsetting at times, and I truly felt for her as she struggles to leave the past behind. Reliance on laudanum pushes at Leona’s mind, the urge to reach for a little brown bottle to numb the pain of the past ever present, creating a flawed but sympathetic protagonist who is impossible not to root for.
With Leona being such an independent woman, I found myself consistently frustrated with the people around her. In particular, her husband Gil is not at all fond of Leona’s determination to find out the truth behind Daphne’s death and often becomes angry with her when he learns of her involvement in speaking to different people to try to figure out the truth. Although her investigations do put her in dangerous situations, and he has a right to be concerned for her wellbeing, he often comes across as an incredibly controlling man. With people such as this in Leona’s life, I often found myself more concerned for her when she was at home rather than when she was undercover or asking questions. There are secrets surrounding Leona in every aspect of her life, and the more she delves into the secrets that are clear to her, the more she begins to uncover a deeper and much darker web of lies that stretch far beyond Daphne’s death. This is truly a novel you cannot predict the outcome of, for the truth behind everything is withheld from the reader until the very last few pages and is so unpredictable it will truly leave you reeling.
Despite the many plot threads of this novel, it is not overly complicated to follow. Leona leads the way forward through the narrative, providing explanation where necessary. It can be a little difficult at times to keep track of all the characters, for Leona’s world is complex and made up of many different people. At times, it can feel as though some characters are unnecessary, their presence in the story lasting only a chapter or two before they become irrelevant as the novel progresses. Leona is involved in many different things; her writing and involvement in the suffragette movement are most prevalent, and although all of these additions create a well-rounded character, it can sometimes feel as though they are simply filling out an already complex plot. This is not to say the plot is difficult to follow; the careful investigations Leona undertakes completely capture my attention. However, at times the amount of information can make the story feel a little heavy with detail.
The Last Fatal Hour by Jan Matthews is an intense and intriguing novel of mystery and deception. With its many twists, layered secrets, and complex plotlines, it keeps the reader guessing right up until the final pages. While the number of characters and intertwining threads can occasionally make the story feel dense, the carefully constructed mystery and compelling protagonist make it a thoroughly engaging read. Readers who enjoy historical mysteries filled with intrigue and unexpected revelations will find much to enjoy in this cleverly constructed and absorbing story.
Review by Ellie Yarde
The Coffee Pot Book Club
Leona had planned on her life becoming easier after marrying Gil: a nice house, highly esteemed company, and nothing to worry about. But that isn’t necessarily the way things seem to go. She is not used to living the life of a contented married woman, her past holding some dark secrets that push her forward into high-stakes situations and curiosity that cannot be held back.
When a good friend of Leona’s is found dead, suspicions fly uncontrollably. Gossip is rife, and even though the death is pinned on natural causes, Leona cannot shake the feeling that something else is going on. Missing jewellery, staff whose whereabouts are unknown, and a deep feeling of dread push Leona on, determined to learn the truth about what happened to her friend and whether foul play is at hand. But society has turned its gossip onto her, and Leona quickly finds herself cut off from the friends she once held dear, their suspicions and whispers directed at her.
This is a novel of intricate storylines and complex matters. It is not only Daphne Van Wyn’s death that brings about suspicion, but also the matter of the missing jewellery. Leona’s husband had recently been swindled by his business partner, money stolen and lost, and the future of their livelihood hanging in the balance. Leona was a dear friend of Daphne, and with the plight of her husband’s finances widely known, people cannot help but suspect her of taking advantage of Daphne’s trust to gain access to expensive jewellery that could help to solve their financial situation. And yet, despite her innocence, Leona cannot help but feel that something more is going on than meets the eye. For Leona, all signs point to murder, and yet the distinct lack of motive makes it difficult for her to point a finger at anyone in particular. To learn the truth, she must dive deeper, learn more about the circumstances surrounding the death, and try to find out what happened to the staff who have not been seen since that dreadful night.
While reading this novel, I quickly found myself drawn into the careful intricacies that Leona encounters at every turn. As the story progresses, the plot only thickens and more mysteries arise. It quickly becomes apparent that there is no simple answer to any of the questions Leona finds herself facing, and the more she searches for the truth, the more lies she uncovers. I found myself consistently intrigued by this novel as I read, for the plot twists and turns so much that the moment you feel you might understand what is going on, something else happens that throws every assumption to the wind.
Leona is a character I found myself instantly connected to. She simply cannot sit by and wait for answers to find her, despite many people telling her to leave her investigations alone. To find the truth, she quickly realises that she must uncover it herself, but many people are not overly fond of her poking her nose in where it is not welcome. Her past has given her the confidence to stand on her own two feet, to push for what she wants and fight for freedom when necessary, but society frowns on women taking such an active interest in matters of finances, murder, and injustice.
Leona is a truly complex character. She joined the Union Army under a false name and fought under the alias of Private Leo Harrison, her hair cut short to blend in amongst the men. Despite the ghosts of war haunting her dreams and the acrid taste of gunpowder following her into her waking life, her time as a soldier has made her tough. Despite the lasting mental mark that war has left on her, it has given her the confidence to step forth into a difficult situation and be prepared to fight her way out if necessary. She refuses to back down, and this gives her an edge as she pushes forward in her careful investigations. The portrayal of how the war affected Leona is upsetting at times, and I truly felt for her as she struggles to leave the past behind. Reliance on laudanum pushes at Leona’s mind, the urge to reach for a little brown bottle to numb the pain of the past ever present, creating a flawed but sympathetic protagonist who is impossible not to root for.
With Leona being such an independent woman, I found myself consistently frustrated with the people around her. In particular, her husband Gil is not at all fond of Leona’s determination to find out the truth behind Daphne’s death and often becomes angry with her when he learns of her involvement in speaking to different people to try to figure out the truth. Although her investigations do put her in dangerous situations, and he has a right to be concerned for her wellbeing, he often comes across as an incredibly controlling man. With people such as this in Leona’s life, I often found myself more concerned for her when she was at home rather than when she was undercover or asking questions. There are secrets surrounding Leona in every aspect of her life, and the more she delves into the secrets that are clear to her, the more she begins to uncover a deeper and much darker web of lies that stretch far beyond Daphne’s death. This is truly a novel you cannot predict the outcome of, for the truth behind everything is withheld from the reader until the very last few pages and is so unpredictable it will truly leave you reeling.
Despite the many plot threads of this novel, it is not overly complicated to follow. Leona leads the way forward through the narrative, providing explanation where necessary. It can be a little difficult at times to keep track of all the characters, for Leona’s world is complex and made up of many different people. At times, it can feel as though some characters are unnecessary, their presence in the story lasting only a chapter or two before they become irrelevant as the novel progresses. Leona is involved in many different things; her writing and involvement in the suffragette movement are most prevalent, and although all of these additions create a well-rounded character, it can sometimes feel as though they are simply filling out an already complex plot. This is not to say the plot is difficult to follow; the careful investigations Leona undertakes completely capture my attention. However, at times the amount of information can make the story feel a little heavy with detail.
The Last Fatal Hour by Jan Matthews is an intense and intriguing novel of mystery and deception. With its many twists, layered secrets, and complex plotlines, it keeps the reader guessing right up until the final pages. While the number of characters and intertwining threads can occasionally make the story feel dense, the carefully constructed mystery and compelling protagonist make it a thoroughly engaging read. Readers who enjoy historical mysteries filled with intrigue and unexpected revelations will find much to enjoy in this cleverly constructed and absorbing story.
Review by Ellie Yarde
The Coffee Pot Book Club
Review of advance copy
Thank you for giving me the ARC on Booksirens to read for free in exchange for an honest review!
The civil war 1863 haunts Leona, who had been the soldier Leo then. She starts to write her story down in a memoir, hoping to possibly publish it anonymously. Her old friend and Editor Daphne encourages her. The first pages of the manuscripts are promising in her eyes. But the next day Daphne is found dead in her bed, presumably old age and a weak heart finally got to her, and her families jewelry is missing. And Leona is one of the prime suspects of this theft, because she and her husband are in a financial strife due to their business partner having taken the money and vanished into thin air, leaving them scrambling to secure themselves financially. Leona is set on getting the pages of her manuscript safely back into her hands and find out what truly happened to her good friend Daphne. But Problems hardly every arrive alone. Especially when you go looking.
The start of this book demanded quiet a bit of me to push through. The thematic fields that were opened up were overwhelming and not very clear why they had to be told. In retrospect it makes sense and I appreciate it a lot more. But it doesn't change that the experience was rough and I did consider at 20% to possible dnf due to struggling that much with what I saw and did not enjoy. But I am so glad I continued on and the end was more than rewarding! As an empathic person I must say that my heart bled for Leona and pounded more often than not along with her the further along I was in the story. Making this a good book but also one that demanded a bit of emotional strength from me due to trauma and PTSD, reliving them, being topics that were heavily present in the plot. Shown and presented in a kind and understanding way, making clear how serious these are and not to be hand-waved and how physically taxing they also are in addition to the mental load. This may hit a bit too close to home for some people though.
Personally some sentences read a bit awkward to me but they were few and far in between. As well as the already mentioned rough start to the story. The further I was in the smoother it became to read and sink into the story and fever along, grumbling with Leona about the injustices and hindrances she comes across. Though I also had moments where I thought "But why", I do think some of them can be explained with that she is a traumatized character and so won't be at all times logical, as well as of the time the story play in and what norms society had then. So well done there!
The main character is very well written and the side characters are not neglected at all.
Leona is a woman that has heavy trauma and for more than three lifetimes, and struggles with this but does not give up. Her grandfather is a delight to have and reminds me a bit of my own, making me wish he came earlier to visit her. Gilbert, Leonas husband, is a piece of work and I loved to hate him through it all. I do wish Detective Day would have had more time on the pages though. I feel like I do not know him enough to really form an opinion but I do like what I saw and want more. I can't really say more without giving spoilers that give too much away to my liking and so I will remain quiet.
The Plot has its issue with the start as I said. But the redemption came and was glorious. I love it when I can sleuth along and the reward of being able to guess the answer a few pages before the reveal is a giant plus in my eyes for a well put together plot that does not surprise me out of nowhere with a new information that I should have been given earlier along with the character. I loved it, the reward of being able to say "I was right!" was amazing. The plot does juggle a lot of problems in Leona's life that all happen at once - which is just very realistic - and she, as well as I tried to stay on top of it all.
All in all, I can recommend this book when you like a thrilling murder mystery where the stakes rise higher along with the tension, has a headstrong heroine and also discusses trauma and emotional turmoil of ptsd. Though I do give the warning that it can be heavy to handle.
"Who else here tonight had visited the Frosts and earned entry into their ledger of sin?" Page 167
The civil war 1863 haunts Leona, who had been the soldier Leo then. She starts to write her story down in a memoir, hoping to possibly publish it anonymously. Her old friend and Editor Daphne encourages her. The first pages of the manuscripts are promising in her eyes. But the next day Daphne is found dead in her bed, presumably old age and a weak heart finally got to her, and her families jewelry is missing. And Leona is one of the prime suspects of this theft, because she and her husband are in a financial strife due to their business partner having taken the money and vanished into thin air, leaving them scrambling to secure themselves financially. Leona is set on getting the pages of her manuscript safely back into her hands and find out what truly happened to her good friend Daphne. But Problems hardly every arrive alone. Especially when you go looking.
The start of this book demanded quiet a bit of me to push through. The thematic fields that were opened up were overwhelming and not very clear why they had to be told. In retrospect it makes sense and I appreciate it a lot more. But it doesn't change that the experience was rough and I did consider at 20% to possible dnf due to struggling that much with what I saw and did not enjoy. But I am so glad I continued on and the end was more than rewarding! As an empathic person I must say that my heart bled for Leona and pounded more often than not along with her the further along I was in the story. Making this a good book but also one that demanded a bit of emotional strength from me due to trauma and PTSD, reliving them, being topics that were heavily present in the plot. Shown and presented in a kind and understanding way, making clear how serious these are and not to be hand-waved and how physically taxing they also are in addition to the mental load. This may hit a bit too close to home for some people though.
Personally some sentences read a bit awkward to me but they were few and far in between. As well as the already mentioned rough start to the story. The further I was in the smoother it became to read and sink into the story and fever along, grumbling with Leona about the injustices and hindrances she comes across. Though I also had moments where I thought "But why", I do think some of them can be explained with that she is a traumatized character and so won't be at all times logical, as well as of the time the story play in and what norms society had then. So well done there!
The main character is very well written and the side characters are not neglected at all.
Leona is a woman that has heavy trauma and for more than three lifetimes, and struggles with this but does not give up. Her grandfather is a delight to have and reminds me a bit of my own, making me wish he came earlier to visit her. Gilbert, Leonas husband, is a piece of work and I loved to hate him through it all. I do wish Detective Day would have had more time on the pages though. I feel like I do not know him enough to really form an opinion but I do like what I saw and want more. I can't really say more without giving spoilers that give too much away to my liking and so I will remain quiet.
The Plot has its issue with the start as I said. But the redemption came and was glorious. I love it when I can sleuth along and the reward of being able to guess the answer a few pages before the reveal is a giant plus in my eyes for a well put together plot that does not surprise me out of nowhere with a new information that I should have been given earlier along with the character. I loved it, the reward of being able to say "I was right!" was amazing. The plot does juggle a lot of problems in Leona's life that all happen at once - which is just very realistic - and she, as well as I tried to stay on top of it all.
All in all, I can recommend this book when you like a thrilling murder mystery where the stakes rise higher along with the tension, has a headstrong heroine and also discusses trauma and emotional turmoil of ptsd. Though I do give the warning that it can be heavy to handle.
"Who else here tonight had visited the Frosts and earned entry into their ledger of sin?" Page 167
May 8, 2026
THE LAST FATAL HOUR plunges readers into the world of Leona Gladney, circa 1870, and what a world it is! Leona is a young socialite and granddaughter of a famous poet, she’s married to a handsome businessman, and life is grand – until it isn’t, and Leona's scrambling to save her reputation and life. Author Jan Matthews packs in everything from PTSD to the paranormal in this satisfying historical, domestic suspense mystery.
One of the most fascinating, but infuriating, aspects of the story is the historical element, where the author’s extensive research shines. Matthews highlights the social norms, expectations, and limitations put upon women of those times, and it’s often painful to vicariously experience it (or sadly, commiserate since some of those same challenges persist even today). Pit those standards against our main character Leona, who blatantly (and secretly) bucks the system, and THE LAST FATAL HOUR piques our curiosity and keeps us turning pages.
Speaking of bucking the system, Leona’s backstory of being a soldier who disguised herself as a man is most intriguing. Though this isn’t intended to be the primary storyline, the resulting PTSD she suffers, as well as a battle with addiction to laudanum, are sure to make readers want to explore this part of Leona’s life. It feels like a missed opportunity to not have peeks into the book Leona is writing, Lady Soldier of the Union Army, as a device to learn more about her experience.
There are subplots galore and a wide cast of characters to keep straight. The book feels somewhat like it is part of a series and that readers should already know the characters. There definitely is potential for a prequel, sequel, or spinoff book. Of course, there are some folks that Matthews draws intentionally murky and for others, the author gives enough for readers to know the characters’ hearts, and that’s enough (I’m looking at you, Ruth and Abigail).
As the story progresses, a major plot twist is revealed, which sets the reader thinking and plants seeds for the whodunit element in THE LAST FATAL HOUR . The pace ramps up to an abrupt and uncomfortable ending, but the Epilogue provides some relief, though not all loose ends are tied and new questions are raised. Again, the feeling is that there’s more to come from these characters. I wouldn’t be opposed.
The author’s writing and the bones of THE LAST FATAL HOUR are solid, with some truly unique and engaging subplots. The rich descriptions of period fashion, syntax, and the terminology Matthews uses all lend authenticity to the tale and place readers solidly in the late 1800s. However, there is inconsistent pacing, plot holes that need filling, and more typos and errors than should be in a finished copy. Additional editing would have made a real impact and taken this book to the next level of excellence.
Despite any editorial issues, this book is one to read, and Jan Matthews is an author to watch. Getting lost within the pages THE LAST FATAL HOUR is time well spent and leaves readers with much to ponder.
This review and more special features on Hall Ways Blog.
One of the most fascinating, but infuriating, aspects of the story is the historical element, where the author’s extensive research shines. Matthews highlights the social norms, expectations, and limitations put upon women of those times, and it’s often painful to vicariously experience it (or sadly, commiserate since some of those same challenges persist even today). Pit those standards against our main character Leona, who blatantly (and secretly) bucks the system, and THE LAST FATAL HOUR piques our curiosity and keeps us turning pages.
Speaking of bucking the system, Leona’s backstory of being a soldier who disguised herself as a man is most intriguing. Though this isn’t intended to be the primary storyline, the resulting PTSD she suffers, as well as a battle with addiction to laudanum, are sure to make readers want to explore this part of Leona’s life. It feels like a missed opportunity to not have peeks into the book Leona is writing, Lady Soldier of the Union Army, as a device to learn more about her experience.
There are subplots galore and a wide cast of characters to keep straight. The book feels somewhat like it is part of a series and that readers should already know the characters. There definitely is potential for a prequel, sequel, or spinoff book. Of course, there are some folks that Matthews draws intentionally murky and for others, the author gives enough for readers to know the characters’ hearts, and that’s enough (I’m looking at you, Ruth and Abigail).
As the story progresses, a major plot twist is revealed, which sets the reader thinking and plants seeds for the whodunit element in THE LAST FATAL HOUR . The pace ramps up to an abrupt and uncomfortable ending, but the Epilogue provides some relief, though not all loose ends are tied and new questions are raised. Again, the feeling is that there’s more to come from these characters. I wouldn’t be opposed.
The author’s writing and the bones of THE LAST FATAL HOUR are solid, with some truly unique and engaging subplots. The rich descriptions of period fashion, syntax, and the terminology Matthews uses all lend authenticity to the tale and place readers solidly in the late 1800s. However, there is inconsistent pacing, plot holes that need filling, and more typos and errors than should be in a finished copy. Additional editing would have made a real impact and taken this book to the next level of excellence.
Despite any editorial issues, this book is one to read, and Jan Matthews is an author to watch. Getting lost within the pages THE LAST FATAL HOUR is time well spent and leaves readers with much to ponder.
This review and more special features on Hall Ways Blog.
April 9, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Where Truth Surfaces and Survival Leaves Its Mark
I finished The Last Fatal Hour with the sense that some lives don’t fracture cleanly between past and present—they overlap, bleed into one another, and become impossible to separate no matter how carefully they’re hidden. What begins as a quiet domestic story, shaped by routine and restraint, gradually reveals something far more unsettled—and far more dangerous—beneath the surface.
Leona carries her past with her from the very first page, even when she’s trying to contain it. There’s an early awareness that what she’s lived through hasn’t stayed behind her, and that the act of writing it down isn’t simply reflection—it’s survival. That tension between concealment and expression gives the story its initial pull, because it’s clear the truth exists, even if it isn’t fully spoken yet—and that keeping it buried comes with its own risks.
As the narrative unfolds, that sense of unease doesn’t disappear so much as deepen. Moments of normalcy—conversations, visits, the rhythms of daily life—are threaded with something sharper underneath. Just as things begin to feel steady, something shifts again, whether through loss, suspicion, or the growing sense that someone is moving just out of sight, shaping events in ways not immediately understood. It creates a feeling that stability is always temporary, never quite secure.
What makes it particularly compelling is how Leona navigates the space between who she was and who she’s expected to be. She moves carefully, often holding parts of herself back, aware of how easily perception can turn—and how quickly truth can be used against her. At the same time, there’s a growing recognition that silence is not neutral, and that some of what unfolds around her cannot be entirely separated from her own choices, however well-intentioned they may have been.
There’s also a strong sense that the personal and the external cannot be separated. The unfolding mystery, the social expectations, and the lingering effects of the war all press in at once, but as the story progresses, that pressure becomes more immediate and more deliberate. The danger sharpens, no longer abstract or distant, and the stakes shift from uncertainty to survival.
The pacing works in the novel’s favour. It allows space for reflection without losing momentum, and when the story begins to tighten, it does so with purpose. Each development feels connected, each revelation carrying weight, building toward a conclusion that feels inevitable rather than sudden.
By the end, it feels less like a resolution that restores order, and more like one that acknowledges what cannot be undone. What remains is not neat or uncomplicated, but it is chosen—an acceptance not only of truth, but of consequence, and of the cost of having survived at all.
This is a story where identity is not fixed, but tested under pressure, and where survival demands more than endurance. It asks what it means to live honestly when doing so risks everything—and answers without ever making it easy.
I received a copy of this book from The Coffee Pot Book Club for review consideration.
I finished The Last Fatal Hour with the sense that some lives don’t fracture cleanly between past and present—they overlap, bleed into one another, and become impossible to separate no matter how carefully they’re hidden. What begins as a quiet domestic story, shaped by routine and restraint, gradually reveals something far more unsettled—and far more dangerous—beneath the surface.
Leona carries her past with her from the very first page, even when she’s trying to contain it. There’s an early awareness that what she’s lived through hasn’t stayed behind her, and that the act of writing it down isn’t simply reflection—it’s survival. That tension between concealment and expression gives the story its initial pull, because it’s clear the truth exists, even if it isn’t fully spoken yet—and that keeping it buried comes with its own risks.
As the narrative unfolds, that sense of unease doesn’t disappear so much as deepen. Moments of normalcy—conversations, visits, the rhythms of daily life—are threaded with something sharper underneath. Just as things begin to feel steady, something shifts again, whether through loss, suspicion, or the growing sense that someone is moving just out of sight, shaping events in ways not immediately understood. It creates a feeling that stability is always temporary, never quite secure.
What makes it particularly compelling is how Leona navigates the space between who she was and who she’s expected to be. She moves carefully, often holding parts of herself back, aware of how easily perception can turn—and how quickly truth can be used against her. At the same time, there’s a growing recognition that silence is not neutral, and that some of what unfolds around her cannot be entirely separated from her own choices, however well-intentioned they may have been.
There’s also a strong sense that the personal and the external cannot be separated. The unfolding mystery, the social expectations, and the lingering effects of the war all press in at once, but as the story progresses, that pressure becomes more immediate and more deliberate. The danger sharpens, no longer abstract or distant, and the stakes shift from uncertainty to survival.
The pacing works in the novel’s favour. It allows space for reflection without losing momentum, and when the story begins to tighten, it does so with purpose. Each development feels connected, each revelation carrying weight, building toward a conclusion that feels inevitable rather than sudden.
By the end, it feels less like a resolution that restores order, and more like one that acknowledges what cannot be undone. What remains is not neat or uncomplicated, but it is chosen—an acceptance not only of truth, but of consequence, and of the cost of having survived at all.
This is a story where identity is not fixed, but tested under pressure, and where survival demands more than endurance. It asks what it means to live honestly when doing so risks everything—and answers without ever making it easy.
I received a copy of this book from The Coffee Pot Book Club for review consideration.
April 19, 2026
First and foremost, May I thank the author and the publisher for allowing me to read this novel. The review is mine.
Jan Matthews’ is the author of The Last Fatal Hour, a masterfully layered historical mystery that plunges her readers into the gaslit world of Gilded Age Brooklyn.
Before I dive into the characters and give my thoughts I must confess by saying that the language in this book is so rich that I could at times taste it. This is incredibly rear for me has I have read novels for years and to my knowledge the last time I had felt like this was when I read the novel Wuthering Heights whilst doing my A Levels in Literature.
This language, to me is rear and I hope readers would allow themselves space and time to digest the rich fruits this novel brings.
On this note, the book is not literature but rather a fiction novel with a lot of suspense so I was very surprised to find the language in this book in this particular criteria, rear.
Now, main character is Leona, a dauntless and complex protagonist who served as a woman soldier in the Army—a past that haunts her as she navigates her new life as a budding socialite and suffragist.
As a woman myself, I could personally relate to the traumas that this character placed. I would classify it more has a norm, for any woman to experience the same sort of format of life and it was nice to read something that felt realistic.
The story expertly, blends societal scandal with the supernatural, leading Leona through a dark maze of embezzled fortunes, whispers of seances, and suspicious deaths. Matthews’ meticulous research shines, particularly in the exceptional seance scenes that expose the desperation and cunning of women operating within the era's rigid constraints.
Conclusion: It was a complex story with plenty of drama and mystery, yet I felt it was paced very well and easy to follow bearing in mind the rich literature it entails. There is always something gripping going on. You felt like you knew the characters very well and the atmosphere the author created was enveloping. For readers who crave an intelligent, character-driven mystery with genuine "bite," this novel is a standout gem of 2026.
I will be purchasing a few hard copies once out, to allow my fellows and students to enjoy has much I have.
Jan Matthews’ is the author of The Last Fatal Hour, a masterfully layered historical mystery that plunges her readers into the gaslit world of Gilded Age Brooklyn.
Before I dive into the characters and give my thoughts I must confess by saying that the language in this book is so rich that I could at times taste it. This is incredibly rear for me has I have read novels for years and to my knowledge the last time I had felt like this was when I read the novel Wuthering Heights whilst doing my A Levels in Literature.
This language, to me is rear and I hope readers would allow themselves space and time to digest the rich fruits this novel brings.
On this note, the book is not literature but rather a fiction novel with a lot of suspense so I was very surprised to find the language in this book in this particular criteria, rear.
Now, main character is Leona, a dauntless and complex protagonist who served as a woman soldier in the Army—a past that haunts her as she navigates her new life as a budding socialite and suffragist.
As a woman myself, I could personally relate to the traumas that this character placed. I would classify it more has a norm, for any woman to experience the same sort of format of life and it was nice to read something that felt realistic.
The story expertly, blends societal scandal with the supernatural, leading Leona through a dark maze of embezzled fortunes, whispers of seances, and suspicious deaths. Matthews’ meticulous research shines, particularly in the exceptional seance scenes that expose the desperation and cunning of women operating within the era's rigid constraints.
Conclusion: It was a complex story with plenty of drama and mystery, yet I felt it was paced very well and easy to follow bearing in mind the rich literature it entails. There is always something gripping going on. You felt like you knew the characters very well and the atmosphere the author created was enveloping. For readers who crave an intelligent, character-driven mystery with genuine "bite," this novel is a standout gem of 2026.
I will be purchasing a few hard copies once out, to allow my fellows and students to enjoy has much I have.
Review of advance copy
The Last Fatal Hour immediately intrigued me by its blurb and the era it was set it. I always love a good mystery, and it did not disappoint.
Leona is a strong woman who never stops but somehow is never frustrating to follow, because she thinks, which I can only appreciate. She fights and fends for herself in a world that doesn't take women seriously. In short, she is badass yet elegant, and I love her as a protagonist. That being said (believe me, I could sing praises for Leona all day long), all characters are fleshed out and have the perfect layers of complexity. I did have to take some notes at the beginning as there are quite a few names being dropped (and since it is a mystery, I wanted to remember every person we came across), but looking back it wasn't necessary as the author does a good job at making you realize which characters truly matter.
The only flaw I found was that the pacing had some oddities: while the beginning has some lengths, it is necessary as all the different pieces are falling in place. Then, once the mystery truly kickstarts, it snowballs and the book becomes impossible to put down until there is a sudden stop, which really broke my momentum. I would not let this deter you from picking up this book, however, as the pace does eventually pick up again, and trust me, the ending is worth it. The way the mysteries unravel and how it just keeps going deeper is impeccable. I always love when something small turns out to be so much more, and The Last Fatal Hour truly delivered.
I would recommend it if you like a good mystery that will keep you on edge and if the era calls to you. I will definitely be looking forward for future publications.
I would like to thank BookSirens, Coffee&Ink Press and Jan Matthews for the opportunity to read this ARC. All opinions are my own.
Leona is a strong woman who never stops but somehow is never frustrating to follow, because she thinks, which I can only appreciate. She fights and fends for herself in a world that doesn't take women seriously. In short, she is badass yet elegant, and I love her as a protagonist. That being said (believe me, I could sing praises for Leona all day long), all characters are fleshed out and have the perfect layers of complexity. I did have to take some notes at the beginning as there are quite a few names being dropped (and since it is a mystery, I wanted to remember every person we came across), but looking back it wasn't necessary as the author does a good job at making you realize which characters truly matter.
The only flaw I found was that the pacing had some oddities: while the beginning has some lengths, it is necessary as all the different pieces are falling in place. Then, once the mystery truly kickstarts, it snowballs and the book becomes impossible to put down until there is a sudden stop, which really broke my momentum. I would not let this deter you from picking up this book, however, as the pace does eventually pick up again, and trust me, the ending is worth it. The way the mysteries unravel and how it just keeps going deeper is impeccable. I always love when something small turns out to be so much more, and The Last Fatal Hour truly delivered.
I would recommend it if you like a good mystery that will keep you on edge and if the era calls to you. I will definitely be looking forward for future publications.
I would like to thank BookSirens, Coffee&Ink Press and Jan Matthews for the opportunity to read this ARC. All opinions are my own.
May 29, 2026
Leona Gladney is an interesting character. I’m not exactly sure of the year, but back in Leona’s day women were to be seen and not heard. Leona didn’t subscribe to that notion. She wanted to be an author, but in order to do so she penned as a man, the only way she could have published works. No one knew, not even her husband.
Her husband, Gil, was also an interesting character. He seemed to always be mad at Leona for one reason or another, so much so that he basically ordered her to stay home instead of pursuing her friend’s untimely death and the reasons behind it.
Leona also got herself involved in the Frosts’ lives, they were what you would call spiritualists. The antics this woman pulled just to find out the truth she was seeking … unheard of in her day.
We also are introduced to Leona’s grandfather, Mr. Earl. He seemed to be a stately gentleman and only wanted the best for Leona.
And the McCarthy family, only an older couple. Mrs. McCarthy was Leona and Gil’s house maid, for lack of a better term. Near the end of this tale, she wanted to help Leona in any way she could.
Detective Day. He was in hot pursuit of Leona thinking she committed some bad deeds. Was he ever surprised when the truth was revealed and the way it was revealed.
For me, a historical tale has to have substance, has to be more than just full of facts and statistics. This one did that, it told a story in vivid detail. I could almost see Leona in her disguises going up to the spiritualists’ houses and inserting herself into their meetings just to find out what happened to Daphne. Also, back in Leona’s time, it was unheard of to have a colored friend; she had one in the person of Ruth. Ruth wasn’t a strong character in this tale and I wish she would’ve been; she was a good friend to Leona.
I enjoyed reading about Leona’s adventures in her search for the truth. She came up with some pretty good ideas.
Her husband, Gil, was also an interesting character. He seemed to always be mad at Leona for one reason or another, so much so that he basically ordered her to stay home instead of pursuing her friend’s untimely death and the reasons behind it.
Leona also got herself involved in the Frosts’ lives, they were what you would call spiritualists. The antics this woman pulled just to find out the truth she was seeking … unheard of in her day.
We also are introduced to Leona’s grandfather, Mr. Earl. He seemed to be a stately gentleman and only wanted the best for Leona.
And the McCarthy family, only an older couple. Mrs. McCarthy was Leona and Gil’s house maid, for lack of a better term. Near the end of this tale, she wanted to help Leona in any way she could.
Detective Day. He was in hot pursuit of Leona thinking she committed some bad deeds. Was he ever surprised when the truth was revealed and the way it was revealed.
For me, a historical tale has to have substance, has to be more than just full of facts and statistics. This one did that, it told a story in vivid detail. I could almost see Leona in her disguises going up to the spiritualists’ houses and inserting herself into their meetings just to find out what happened to Daphne. Also, back in Leona’s time, it was unheard of to have a colored friend; she had one in the person of Ruth. Ruth wasn’t a strong character in this tale and I wish she would’ve been; she was a good friend to Leona.
I enjoyed reading about Leona’s adventures in her search for the truth. She came up with some pretty good ideas.
June 2, 2026
Leona Gladney discovered her dear friend Daphne Van Wyn has died under suspicious circumstances and Leona became a suspect. Despite the lead detective and her husband warning to stay out of the investigation, she was determined to find out who murdered her dear friend. Furthermore, Leona was quickly shunned by Brooklyn society, which made it all the more difficult for her to solve her friend’s death and she found herself in serious danger.
There is so much more to this story, including her husband’s claim that his business partner has stolen their money, which added to the plot. There was also great character development and each character added so much depth and intrigue. Including Leona’s grandfather who was a renowned poet. Leona was also a writer and she preferred to write anonymously, which was usually common in those days.
What first captured by attention about this story was that Leona was a former union soldier in the American Civil War. Historically, women were known to have fought in the civil war and they disguised themselves with the uniforms and used male aliases. There were many reasons for them to do so including staying close to their love ones, escaping from whatever life they were running from and so on… I was intrigued to see how Jan Matthews would explore the aftermath of a female soldier’s life post war. Did Leona experience post-traumatic stress? What were the battles like for her? I wanted to know and Matthews portrayed Leona’s experience with vivid realities of war and the struggle of overcoming such a traumatic time.
A wonderfully written historical mystery with many elements weaved in that takes you to time and place. A truly atmospheric mystery.
Stephanie
www.layeredpages.com
I received a review copy from the publishers through NetGalley for an honest review.
There is so much more to this story, including her husband’s claim that his business partner has stolen their money, which added to the plot. There was also great character development and each character added so much depth and intrigue. Including Leona’s grandfather who was a renowned poet. Leona was also a writer and she preferred to write anonymously, which was usually common in those days.
What first captured by attention about this story was that Leona was a former union soldier in the American Civil War. Historically, women were known to have fought in the civil war and they disguised themselves with the uniforms and used male aliases. There were many reasons for them to do so including staying close to their love ones, escaping from whatever life they were running from and so on… I was intrigued to see how Jan Matthews would explore the aftermath of a female soldier’s life post war. Did Leona experience post-traumatic stress? What were the battles like for her? I wanted to know and Matthews portrayed Leona’s experience with vivid realities of war and the struggle of overcoming such a traumatic time.
A wonderfully written historical mystery with many elements weaved in that takes you to time and place. A truly atmospheric mystery.
Stephanie
www.layeredpages.com
I received a review copy from the publishers through NetGalley for an honest review.
May 23, 2026
THE LAST FATAL HOUR
By Jan Matthews
Leona Gladney has secrets. She was a soldier in the Civil War and is currently an author trying to please a new husband and Brooklyn society. When her husband's business partner absconds with their money life gets more difficult. Dealing with her mercurial husband, Leona is also distraught when her good friend Daphne dies and she's accused of stealing her jewelry. Could Daphne's grandson be behind her death? What about those Spiritualists? Leona is determined to clear her name, but is someone just as determined to see her suffer?
Filled with interesting historical detail and unusual characters THE LAST FATAL HOUR captured and held my attention. An adventurous tomboy, Leona is almost too caring. Indeed, her willingness to help others nearly gets her killed. I love her relationship with her grandfather. Along with Mrs. McCarthy and Ruth he is one of my favorite characters. Rich characterizations, a household simmering with stress, and more than one mystery had me quickly turning the pages.
While it didn't exist as a term at the time, some civil war soldiers did suffer from what's now known as post traumatic stress disorder and we see this with Leona's nightmares and flashbacks. It's even more of a challenge as she is unable to share her story freely, not even to the man who's supposed to protect her, her husband. This is also a time when a man who wants to rid himself of a wife can easily have her committed to a "lunatic asylum". A dangerous time to be a woman, and an especially dangerous one for Leona.
A compelling historical mystery THE LAST FATAL HOUR will leave you shocked, angered, and ultimately satisfied.
By Jan Matthews
Leona Gladney has secrets. She was a soldier in the Civil War and is currently an author trying to please a new husband and Brooklyn society. When her husband's business partner absconds with their money life gets more difficult. Dealing with her mercurial husband, Leona is also distraught when her good friend Daphne dies and she's accused of stealing her jewelry. Could Daphne's grandson be behind her death? What about those Spiritualists? Leona is determined to clear her name, but is someone just as determined to see her suffer?
Filled with interesting historical detail and unusual characters THE LAST FATAL HOUR captured and held my attention. An adventurous tomboy, Leona is almost too caring. Indeed, her willingness to help others nearly gets her killed. I love her relationship with her grandfather. Along with Mrs. McCarthy and Ruth he is one of my favorite characters. Rich characterizations, a household simmering with stress, and more than one mystery had me quickly turning the pages.
While it didn't exist as a term at the time, some civil war soldiers did suffer from what's now known as post traumatic stress disorder and we see this with Leona's nightmares and flashbacks. It's even more of a challenge as she is unable to share her story freely, not even to the man who's supposed to protect her, her husband. This is also a time when a man who wants to rid himself of a wife can easily have her committed to a "lunatic asylum". A dangerous time to be a woman, and an especially dangerous one for Leona.
A compelling historical mystery THE LAST FATAL HOUR will leave you shocked, angered, and ultimately satisfied.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Last Fatal Hour is a masterfully woven historical mystery, capturing the spirit of post–Civil War America with remarkable depth and atmosphere. Rather than merely borrowing from the beloved world of Louisa May Alcott, this novel expands upon the era she so vividly portrayed, plunging readers into the shifting social landscape of Reconstruction through a gripping and emotionally layered mystery.
At the heart of the story is Leona—a compelling woman navigating the rigid expectations of high society while quietly wrestling with her own longing for independence. Her internal struggle feels authentic and timeless: the tension between carving out one’s own identity and yearning for the warmth and stability of a family. The author handles this duality with nuance, making her journey as absorbing as the mystery itself.
Equally fascinating is that Leona was a covert former Union soldier whose past lingers like a shadow over the present. Her concealed history adds emotional complexity, enriching the central mystery while deepening the novel’s exploration of loyalty, trauma, and reinvention in a nation still healing from war.
The historical detail is beautifully written without ever overwhelming the plot. The customs, social codes, and unspoken rules of the time are seamlessly embedded in the narrative, heightening both the stakes and the drama. The constraints placed upon women—and the quiet acts of defiance that push against them—are portrayed with sensitivity and strength.
The Last Fatal Hour is for fans of intelligent historical mysteries and character-driven drama.
At the heart of the story is Leona—a compelling woman navigating the rigid expectations of high society while quietly wrestling with her own longing for independence. Her internal struggle feels authentic and timeless: the tension between carving out one’s own identity and yearning for the warmth and stability of a family. The author handles this duality with nuance, making her journey as absorbing as the mystery itself.
Equally fascinating is that Leona was a covert former Union soldier whose past lingers like a shadow over the present. Her concealed history adds emotional complexity, enriching the central mystery while deepening the novel’s exploration of loyalty, trauma, and reinvention in a nation still healing from war.
The historical detail is beautifully written without ever overwhelming the plot. The customs, social codes, and unspoken rules of the time are seamlessly embedded in the narrative, heightening both the stakes and the drama. The constraints placed upon women—and the quiet acts of defiance that push against them—are portrayed with sensitivity and strength.
The Last Fatal Hour is for fans of intelligent historical mysteries and character-driven drama.
Review of advance copy
"A soldier's heart, that's what they call it, my dear. When the battles won't stop."
Before Leona Gladney was Leona Gladney, she was a Union soldier who fought in the war disguised as man. Now, she is trying to build a new life for herself and fit into good society in Boston with her husband Gil, but when a friend is found dead and Leona herself falls under suspicion, she must risk her reputation in order to clear her name. But the closer Leona comes to the truth, the more her investigation becomes a danger to her life, marriage and family.
The Last Fatal Hour is a deeply atmospheric historical mystery with a very interesting premise: the memories of the American Civil War seen through the eyes of a soldier who was a woman disguised as a man. Leona is a woman with the weight of the world on her shoulders, silently battling with the psychological aftermath of the war, while living with the pressure of knowing how devastatingly her reputation and life could be ruined if the truth about her past were revealed.
It is a character-driven story focused on Leona and the way she is constantly treading the delicate balance between independence and rebellion, trying to stay true to herself while navigating a society that found strong women unnatural and punished those who stood out.
Many thanks to BookSirens for this ARC. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Before Leona Gladney was Leona Gladney, she was a Union soldier who fought in the war disguised as man. Now, she is trying to build a new life for herself and fit into good society in Boston with her husband Gil, but when a friend is found dead and Leona herself falls under suspicion, she must risk her reputation in order to clear her name. But the closer Leona comes to the truth, the more her investigation becomes a danger to her life, marriage and family.
The Last Fatal Hour is a deeply atmospheric historical mystery with a very interesting premise: the memories of the American Civil War seen through the eyes of a soldier who was a woman disguised as a man. Leona is a woman with the weight of the world on her shoulders, silently battling with the psychological aftermath of the war, while living with the pressure of knowing how devastatingly her reputation and life could be ruined if the truth about her past were revealed.
It is a character-driven story focused on Leona and the way she is constantly treading the delicate balance between independence and rebellion, trying to stay true to herself while navigating a society that found strong women unnatural and punished those who stood out.
Many thanks to BookSirens for this ARC. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy
I love historical mysteries, so reading "The Last Fatal Hour" was a no brainer and overall, I really enjoyed it. I did find parts of it a bit confusing, but as I read it all became quite clear and even energized an already fast paced story. Leona leads a fairly normal upper middle-class lifestyle. She's on her 2nd marriage to a man she loves but perhaps shouldn't trust and that's just some of the intrigue that graces these pages. Put that with military action flashbacks, murder and robbery and you've got a book you can't put down.
When a dear friend of Leona's is found dead and her grandson instantly blames Leona for the death without any proof in a small community like Brooklyn Heights any negative press could be life shattering, so Leona begins her own investigation that leads to some major revelations she may not be ready for.
The book builds momentum as it goes and by the ending you feel like you stood by Leona the whole time. She's not a perfect character and has her flaws, but decency and what's right were always at the forefront of her actions. Like I said I enjoyed this book very much and would be happy to read more by this author. Happy Reading!
When a dear friend of Leona's is found dead and her grandson instantly blames Leona for the death without any proof in a small community like Brooklyn Heights any negative press could be life shattering, so Leona begins her own investigation that leads to some major revelations she may not be ready for.
The book builds momentum as it goes and by the ending you feel like you stood by Leona the whole time. She's not a perfect character and has her flaws, but decency and what's right were always at the forefront of her actions. Like I said I enjoyed this book very much and would be happy to read more by this author. Happy Reading!
Review of advance copy received from Author
I feel like this book has bursts of greatness mixed with parts that didn't fully make sense. There will be people who will love this book, but I felt like the author had too many plots going on at once. My favorite parts were the flashbacks to Leona's time as a soldier. I wish that we'd gotten the chance to learn more about this time in her life. I'd love to read the memoir that she was supposedly writing.
There are several mysteries going on, but I feel like it was often a little too easy to figure out who had committed the crimes. This book felt really long. It felt like it should be an exciting book, but it dragged in places. The final two chapters were really good. If the whole book had been as exciting as the last two or so chapters, this would have been a great book.
This book does include some swearing. There's no sexual content. There's some behind-the-scenes violence, but you don't see a lot of the page violence.
I got a free ARC from BookSirens, and I left a voluntary review.
There are several mysteries going on, but I feel like it was often a little too easy to figure out who had committed the crimes. This book felt really long. It felt like it should be an exciting book, but it dragged in places. The final two chapters were really good. If the whole book had been as exciting as the last two or so chapters, this would have been a great book.
This book does include some swearing. There's no sexual content. There's some behind-the-scenes violence, but you don't see a lot of the page violence.
I got a free ARC from BookSirens, and I left a voluntary review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews