Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Midnight Curfew

Rate this book
Two rivals from opposing families fight their forbidden attraction to each other in the brand new romance from New York Times bestselling author Penelope Douglas.

Summertime is off-season in southern Florida. Families leave their homes to escape the heat, the streets are empty, and the nights are quiet. Perfect time for a little mischief while the police aren’t looking.

As the middle Jaeger brother, Dallas was often lost in the shuffle growing up. Now a man, he’s prideful of his community on the wrong side of the tracks—Sanoa Bay—and aggressively protective of his land and his inner circle. He’s hungry and ready for a fight.

Callum Ames has a reputation in St. Carmen, the affluent neighborhood abutting Sanoa Bay. The hottest. The most popular. Rich. Powerful. Strong. The one all the women want. After four years away, he’s back, but for all his bravado, he’s got one major he doesn’t want a woman.

Summer is also storm season. Heat, wind, rain…

And a lockdown.

In a desperate bid to impress his influential father, Callum suggests a curfew to hinder their rivals in the Bay.

Unfortunately, the Jaegers don’t like rules.

As Dallas and Callum face off and engage, out for each other's blood, they can't stop the consuming fire between them and the outcome they already see coming...

The storm of the century.

Audible Audio

First published September 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Penelope Douglas

43 books117k followers
Penelope Douglas is a New York Times, USA Today, and Wall Street Journal bestselling author. Their books have been translated into more than twenty languages and include The Fall Away Series, The Devil’s Night Series, and the stand-alones, Misconduct, Punk 57, Birthday Girl, Credence, Tryst Six Venom, and Five Brothers. Please look for The Hellbent Series, coming next.

They live in New England with their husband and daughter.

Would you like to join the reader group? ---> https://www.facebook.com/groups/16198...

Looking for News?
Text DOUGLAS to 603-519-3800 to be alerted when new releases are live!
Website: www.penelopedouglasauthor.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/PenelopeDoug...
Twitter: www.twitter.com/PenDouglas
Pinterest: http://www.pinterest.com/penelopedoug...
Amazon: http://amzn.to/1A8hUBX
Instagram: www.instagram.com/penelope.douglas

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,326 (27%)
4 stars
1,841 (38%)
3 stars
1,080 (22%)
2 stars
331 (6%)
1 star
181 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 904 reviews
Profile Image for Penelope Douglas.
Author 43 books117k followers
finished-writing
September 1, 2026
NOW LIVE!
--> https://bit.ly/MCKindleUS

“Dallas Jaeger will never have more fun—that he’ll regret—than he will tonight.”



Midnight Curfew can read as a standalone, but it is ideal to read Tryst Six Venom and/or Five Brothers first. All three books feature the Jaeger family and are suitable for readers 18+.

Pinterest Moodboard: https://bit.ly/46xUAE2
Spotify: https://bit.ly/4yc2zCE




Thank you so much to everyone who's read and reviewed already!

AMAZON:
US https://bit.ly/MCKindleUS
CA https://bit.ly/canebookamzeng
IT https://bit.ly/itenglamazebook
FR https://bit.ly/frmcebookenglish
DE https://bit.ly/germcebookeng
BR https://bit.ly/brzlebookenglish
ES https://bit.ly/spebookeng

AUDIBLE https://adbl.co/4xPeeXZ
IBOOKS https://bit.ly/3UIyNqz
KOBO https://bit.ly/mckobo
B&N https://bit.ly/mcbarnesandnoble
BAM https://bit.ly/mcbamillion

TOADSTOOL SIGNED EDITIONS https://bit.ly/mctoadstool
TARGET https://bit.ly/mctargetexclusive (endpaper art <3 )
WALMART https://bit.ly/walmartexclusive (letter to readers, book club questions, and a bookmark <3 )
Profile Image for Liana Gold.
636 reviews608 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 17, 2026
⭐️ 3.5 ⭐️ I love whatever Douglas writes. It's a given that her story will be 100% crazy and 100% forbidden. After finishing Five Brothers last night, I'm glad she chose to make this Dallas's story because I seriously couldn't figure him out or why he was such an angry person. He too deserves some love and redemption. So when I began reading Midnight Curfew I knew that its going to be a wild ride.. I just didn't expect so much WARFARE here between the two houses.

What's it about?
This is a story of two rivals from opposing families going head to head as the fire between the M-M consumes them with an outcome they haven't seen coming. In the similar style of Romeo & Juliet, this is a story that was much more than about two people who couldn't stay away. They had a lot of unresolved history that began 5 years prior to the events of this book and ended with a betrayal, shifting their relationship in the 'hate territory' and then eventually a war-like reconciliation that takes place in this book.

This book was dark, perhaps the darkest I've yet read by PD. Sure it's angsty, forbidden and emotionally unhinged. It carried a heavy torch of coercion, obsession and childhood trauma. I was a little surprised the direction it took. I thought it would be more centered on Dallas character, his breakdown and his guilt surrounding his mother's death. There were plenty of strong emotions turning points but I really thought the emotional center from 50% and onwards was Callum and his sister Anna-Katherine. Their relationship was tender, compassionate. She's really the hearts novel and she brought the two men together with the conflict that turned the narrative around.

The problem that I had with this book was the pacing and the writing overall. The book read a bit rough for me.. I mean there was so much sexual content that was over the top. I'm all in for some hot, sexy and spicy scenes but it became very repetitive and the MM romance felt too trope-y. I thought their relationship was build less on emotional built up and more on angry, possessive sex. Their hostility was felt with every interaction and I wanted an emotional resolution more than sexual one. I also thought the book was very chunky and lacked a good plot. Redundency was a huge problem here. The constant antagonism and jealousy was over the top and while that can be true in many relationships, they deserved something different.

PD is known for writing an excellent vulnerable character. I enjoyed the competition between the houses and enjoyed the morally-complicated character dynamic where neither Callum or Dallas were too innocent or too manipulative. They balanced each other well but I overall struggled with their stubbornness. They were so emotionally damaged that at some points they became destructive to each other. I loved seeing their facade crack as they tried to power-balance each other.

Now I really need Iron or Army's story.




Many thanks to NetGalley, Berkley Publishing Group and the author, Penelope Douglas for this early ARC!

Publication: September 1, 2026
Profile Image for d.
19 reviews
Want to Read
December 9, 2025
clayolivia continue to lead me to places I wouldn't even go with a gun
Profile Image for Georgie.
303 reviews6 followers
August 30, 2026
for the love of GOD, can authors PLEASE stop putting multiple MF smut scenes in books specifically labelled as MM or FF. i am so sick of it. 🙄🙄🙄
Profile Image for Duda.
108 reviews14 followers
September 1, 2026
Dnf 5% What the fuck is Penelope Douglas’s obsession with group sex that almost every book of hers seems to have it? And the chapters constantly alternating between the past and present? That’s why I stopped reading her books. I don’t even know why I tried again. LOL
Profile Image for Iryna Saushkina.
50 reviews14 followers
Read
September 6, 2026
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (Rating: 4/5)
"Midnight Curfew" by Penelope Douglas is exactly why we read her books—it is completely chaotic, gloriously toxic, and absolutely impossible to put down.
I spent half this book completely obsessed with the story and the other half wanting to violently shake Dallas and Callum by the shoulders, screaming, “Are you two seriously okay in the head?!” The chemistry between these two is an absolute powder keg. That constant, aggressive "I want to kill you but I also can't keep my hands off you" energy had me in an absolute chokehold. Watching their real, raw vulnerability slowly bleed through all that pure anger and jealousy was everything.
I will admit, some of the drama felt incredibly extra, even by Penelope Douglas standards. A few of their life choices had me rolling my eyes to the back of my head, and the pacing dragged just a tiny bit in places, which is why it’s not a full five-star read for me. But let's be real: if you want a healthy relationship with zero red flags, you are definitely in the wrong place. If you live for dark, steamy enemies-to-lovers, absolutely forbidden dynamics, and two guys with approximately a million emotional problems burning the world down around them, you will completely devour this. 🔥🖤
Profile Image for purlpur.
405 reviews113 followers
September 3, 2026
4⭐️
ітс токсік тааааайм.
окей, за усі фінальні події накину оцінку до четвірки, бо під кінець я прожила весь той самий спектр, що й герої. від повного спустошення, безвиході й тривоги до адреналінових гірок, які почалися далі 😈
а яка помстаааа. просто ауч 🔥🔥
уф, емоційненько було 😎🍿

але здебільшого ця оцінка - за далласа й каллума. між ними дійсно смачнюща хімія та напруга, яка тримає до самого кінця 😮‍💨 ця парочка зайде, якщо ви кайфуєте від токсичних динамік: ось вони жорстоко б'ють одне одного, а вже наступної хвилини віддаються пристрасті. ці постійні емоційні та словесні удари по болючих місцях. таак, саме за цим коктейлем із ворожнечі, ненависті й ревнощів я сюди й прийшла 🙌

і який же контраст створюють їхні поцілунки посеред цього хаосу 🤌
як вони ніжно обціловують усі найчуттєвіші куточки на тілі одне одного 🥹🥰

єдине, хотілося б бачити більше зародження почуттів у флешбеках. кортіло самій прожити цю закоханість каллума «по вуха» в далласа, а не просто чути про неї зі слів. загалом під кінець тема почуттів розкрита так собі 🥲

сам сюжет і ця тривала ворожнеча багатіїв з сімейством єгерів, таємне товариство їбак - це псіхуска в стилі дуглас, яка мною вже не так прикольно сприймається.
плюс книга затягнута. так, через позиціонування її як самостійної треба додатково пояснювати, хто всі ці люди й яка тут розстановка сил, але й без цього в першій частині хотілося викинути половину зайвого тексту.

ну й мабуть, це найрозпусніша книжка дуглас🥇
з першого розділу заявка буде зрозумілою 😶‍🌫️🍆💦
я вже звикла, що в подібних романах таємне товариство - це здебільшого збіговисько багатіїв, які маніакально схиблені на своїй владі, дрочать на себе, на всіх навколо і потурають своїм максимально огидним збоченням. і тут пані дуглас відірвалася на повну в описах сцен в лігві.
якщо колись вона надумає написати історію про героїв, яких згадувала у wolfe room. наприклад, про них "the three men – one under, one behind, and one in her mouth – all look alike, just different ages. her husband, her brother-in-law, and her father-in-law" або інших подібних збоченців.. от тоді це буде дійсно страшна. довіру це обійшло стороною 🌚🤭

p.s. ай, а це бажання мейкона, щоб усі жили в одному будинки. та кудиии. там спробуй вийти в коридор, ванну, кухню, басейн і хтось та їбеться. ще той вуаєрист походу 😁
Profile Image for Irene.
21 reviews
December 6, 2025
dallas and callum are coming home to me I NEED A NOVELLA ABOUT DALLAS PROPOSING TO CALLUM RIGHT NOW
Profile Image for a..
571 reviews143 followers
September 1, 2026
This book being the literary equivalent to a Florida Man headline. Her claiming to love Heated Rivalry was probably the biggest sign this shit was going to be gay slop for straight women. The sex scenes got really tiring to read to the point where I really couldn’t find myself remotely interested in whatever non sexual scenes were happening on page. It just felt like they never had meaningful conversations that didn’t end with their dicks being whipped out. Iron? Prince. I see your Sierra Simone future and it’s a bit dim but let’s see. Aracely please love yourself. You get treated like shit by Army, you fucked his two brothers, and got fingered by his future brother in law. Why would ANYONE want you at their dinner table? Macon not everyone needs to know your wife is horny and won’t get off of you. Iron and Sophia, if PD was real she’d pair the two of you together. I should’ve DNF this but I really thought it would get better. All I got in the end was sex, stealing treasure, and land like this was OBXXX on PornHub.
Profile Image for EmJustReading.
89 reviews19 followers
June 11, 2026
Feels like home to be back in Sanoa Bay with the Jaegers. I loved Tryst Six Venom and Five Brothers, so I was giddy when I heard this book was coming out. Definitely one of my most anticipated reads of the year!

It was intriguing to see how Dallas and Callum interacted and understanding their motives behind choices. Everything was so twisted and so manipulative. Talk about ANGST and power dynamics.

PD did an amazing job writing this so it can be read as a standalone, or part of the Jaeger world. She recapped enough details that you get plenty of understanding about the backstory, but it wasn't too much for the readers who already knew. Note: Beware of the trigger warnings! There were some upsetting situations (but mostly occurring in the past...)

The fact that Dallas was a teacher at Marymount was ironic, and hilarious. This book has a good amount of spice, and after the scene with Aracely, I REALLY want a book focused on her. There was so much tension in these pages, and I loved the part at the end where they inspected the pocket knife. #JusticeForAK (Sophia)

Shoutout to the author and publisher for the ARC
Profile Image for AtenRa.
786 reviews89 followers
September 11, 2026
Midnight Curfew was one of my most anticipated releases of the year. Dallas was by far my favourite character in Five Brothers and the little excerpt of his and Callum’s at the end was sizzling hot and very promising. Unfortunately, I couldn’t have been more disappointed by the end result.

Jump to 5 years after Five Brothers, Dallas is 25 and a teacher at the local high school. Surprisingly, he didn't seem to be the same jaded, aggro asshole he was back then, which I loved. Naturally, he grew up and matured some, although we didn’t get to see it. Don’t get me wrong, he didn’t become straight-laced or anything and he still had an edge to him, but he was now a Philosophy teacher, so that didn’t exactly scream “trouble maker”. That said, I loved Dallas’s character. I loved how broken and lonely he was, even when surrounded by all those people, and I loved the unwavering commitment to his community. As the middle child in a huge family, with tons of baggage and trauma, he felt he was never good enough no matter how much he tried to prove himself. I got all that and more out of Dallas, and I loved reading about him.

I never thought I’d like Callum, and rightfully so, but I did. Another broken boy, but in a completely different way to Dallas. Callum was an ultra privileged white guy who seemed to have unlimited power and pretty much every opportunity in life. Contrary to Dallas though, his family was fucked up and his father was a rapist and an abuser who belittled Callum his whole life. Does that absolve Callum of the shitty things he did? Not necessarily, but we at least got to see his side of things and maybe gain some perspective. Also, let’s not forget that he was 17 and still very much confused about his sexuality when he hooked up with Dallas, so that must have fucked him up too.

So, my problem was not with Dallas or Callum. My problem was with the writing, the plot and its pacing, among other things.

Maybe it was just me, but this didn’t read like a typical PD book. The writing didn’t flow at all and a lot of the time I found it confusing. Dallas and Callum’s voices blended together, and I had to go back to check whose POV I was reading multiple times. Some of the dialogue did not indicate the person talking and context just wasn't there. Sometimes a character would be seen laying down, but then 5 sentences later they were made to look like they were standing up the whole time. I was very confused and I’ve never ever experienced that before with a PD book. I always found her writing flowing easily and her books, even those I didn’t like, were always page turners. With Midnight Curfew I felt like I was reading an ARC, like it was a draft of a book that hadn't been proofread yet.

Now, the romance. I love a slow burn; give me an angsty, slow burn enemies to lovers romance any day.
Midnight Curfew was not it.
Dallas and Callum absolutely hated each other until, at 80%, they very suddenly and abruptly declare their undying love for one another.
😲😲
Neither of them expressed any romantic feelings for the other until then, not even came close. They never even considered it in all the pages of their respective inner monologues. They lusted after each other sure, but that is not enough for them to spurt out “I love you”s after treating each other so horribly. Also, let’s not forget that these guys never really had any history. They got together for a month 5 years ago, they broke up in the worst possible way, and never saw each other until now.
Macon and the rest only knew Asshole Callum Ames, you know, the one who stole their money and almost raped their sister (that one…ooof! I still can’t believe they just blew past it), and for them to risk their hides for Callum just didn’t make any sense. I really loved Dallas and Callum, but that was just stupid writing. I think PD focused too much on the enemies part, she made those two say and do horrible things to each other and then suddenly remembered she had to make them get together. By then it was way too late and unfortunately I didn’t buy into their happy ending at all.
At least it didn’t end with marriage/marriage proposal, which I’m very grateful for.

Also, and I can’t believe I’m saying that about a PD book, the smut wasn’t that great.
There were three FM sex scenes in Midnight Curfew, a marketed MM romance, and I find that outrageous.
All Dallas and Callum did was hate-fuck each other, and while that was fun in the beginning, it got old after a while and I just never got emotionally invested. The scenes at the Den were horrible and completely unnecessary. Araceli continues to be used and abused by all the scumbag men in her world, and I pray she doesn’t end up with Army, another fucktard of a man.

I've never read about a character age-regressing because of trauma before, and I found Sophia’s story very interesting. I would love for her to have her own book though rather than take up half of Midnight Curfew, leaving Dallas and Callum’s relationship underdeveloped.

There is a way to make enemies become lovers slowly and naturally, but this was definitely not it. Dallas and Callum’s characters were so strong and had unlimited potential.
Too bad it was wasted.
Profile Image for &#x1f38b;ara.
408 reviews36 followers
September 2, 2026
I think authors need to do more research and soul searching before treating MM romance like a trend. This did not hit.
Profile Image for Zari.
234 reviews17 followers
October 11, 2026
The angst was sooo good! Spoiler-free review below:

Synopsis & Vibes: This is an MM/bisexual romance following one of the Jaeger siblings and the guy he loves to have hate sex with, especially when the midnight curfew is imposed for the summer in their Florida town. The tension and complicated dynamics between these two were addictive to read. I really enjoyed how real the characters and the world felt by the end. There were even some scenes that felt like they could have taken place in the Devil's Night universe. There's also a lot to unpack around power dynamics, classism, and racism.

Check Triggers: This is TOXIC, highly misogynistic, and potentially triggering, especially the first chapter. The opening chapter is almost as shocking as (if not more shocking than) the one in Five Brothers. If you stick with it though, you do get an explanation.

Thoughts on MM: This is the first MM romance I can remember reading, so now I'm curious about the genre and why it's become so popular. From what I can tell, it seems like a lot of popular MM romances are written by authors who aren't queer men, often for a predominantly female audience. Is that problematic?

In summary, this was toxic, taboo, and all these characters need therapy. Just like basically every other PD book I've read. And yet? I was invested. Again, just like most other PD books I've read. Also the ending may have hinted who the next book might follow.... and if so, I can't wait. Although PD says this can be read as a standalone, I highly recommend reading Five Brothers first.

----
Pre-Read: I DNF'd Tryst Six Venom, I loved Five Brothers, and I have high hopes for this. Full Disclosure: I think this might be my first MM romance?
Profile Image for Ana Campos.
287 reviews45 followers
November 11, 2026
I'm no stranger to toxic relationships in dark romance, and they rarely put me off. But there's a difference between toxicity that makes for compelling fiction and toxicity that's simply unpleasant to read. Unfortunately, this was firmly the latter.

It didn't help that the story was buried beneath so many references to side characters that keeping track of everything became a chore. Nor did I find much to connect with in the protagonists, whose frustratingly immature behavior made it difficult to sympathize with either of them. And despite the romance being built around such an intense shared history, remarkably little time was spent actually exploring that connection. Instead, there was no shortage of sex, including more scenes involving women than I expected from an M/M romance, but too little emotional development to make the relationship convincing to me.

And somehow, with all that going on, I was still bored.

Ultimately, this was far too long for how little it delivered. No amount of darkness can save a romance when the characters leave me completely indifferent, and by the end, I was simply relieved it was over.
Profile Image for Carol (bookish_notes).
1,937 reviews140 followers
May 30, 2026
***Thanks to the publisher for giving me an e-ARC to read and review!***

*reviewed May 30, 2026*

This book is everything I could have wanted for Dallas/Callum!! I made the mistake of going back and re-reading Five Brothers very recently and it made me absolutely FERAL to get my hands on this book and I didn’t know how I was going to wait until September. So massive thanks to Berkley for offering ARCs and giving this to me because I flew through this and loved every second of reading it!! I mostly read books by audiobook nowadays so you can understand the absolutely dedication I have to read this entire book in text and do it so quickly. I was HOOKED. I was highlighting everything as I was reading because this book is just *chef’s kiss* I will need to get my hands on the physical copy!!

I think the author does a good job of actually recapping and explaining relevant events that happened in Tryst Six Venom and Five Brothers so this could work as a standalone if you’re jumping into the universe of Sanoa Bay with this one. BUT I think it would be so much sweeter if you get the build up by reading the other two books first. This book is the author’s first m/m book but it’s still very much a classic Penelope Douglas story.

I think if you’re read them before, the story won’t be a surprise to you at all, but if you’re coming into this because you only read m/m and haven’t read the author, do know that there are sharing scenes with women. I think the opening chapter sets the tone really well (like the start of Five Brothers) so readers know what they’re getting right from the start.

And I would classify these books as dark romance because these would be a better fit promoted to dark romance readers than people who only read contemporary romance.

This is subject to change since it’s coming from an e-ARC, but the content warnings included in this book from the author says: This book deals with emotionally difficult topics, including violence, coercion, discussions of mental illness and suicide, PTSD, discussions of prior sexual abuse of a non-main character, underage sex, and dubious consent.

I would also add the following content warnings (note: these seem to have been added to an early ALC I briefly listened to for this book, so these might all be in the ebook/physical versions of the book now): homophobia, racism, and emotional and physical domestic abuse.

Dallas Jaeger and Callum Ames are toxic for one another and I love how they can stand toe to toe and duke it out. This angst is DELICIOUS and a slow burn for the ages. This book had me wondering just how they’d actually wind up together because it gets super intense.

Remember, it’s been building up to this point where Callum’s father is out to steal Sanoa Bay, the part of the Seminole land that’s been in Dallas’ family for generations. What surprised me is that Garrett Ames wasn’t who we had to worry about the most regarding this, it’s his son Callum. I love that we do get a resolution here and I wonder now what the underlying plot would be if we ever get books for the other brothers in the Jaeger family - Iron, Trace, and Army.

There are some flashback characters but nothing explicit in the flashback chapters. I was wondering how this would go since I just finished reading Devil’s Night and felt like anything could be on the table. Callum is 22 and Dallas is 25 in the present day chapters. This book is told from both their POVs and in first-person.

Dallas is dealing with unresolved trauma and guilt surrounding his mother’s death when he was just 13. And Callum is dealing with the weight of his father’s expectations. His father is also an absolute creep and all around TERRIBLE person.

We see a lot of Liv/Clay and Krisjen/Macon, and they’re all as happy as can be in this book. It’s interesting to see them from outside POVs like Dallas and Callum because Dallas is around Clay and Krisjen a lot more now and he was downright antagonistic about Krisjen in their home for most of 5B. Callum and Krisjen used to hang out all the time in high school, he was ready to marry Clay one day, and he still owes Liv the BIGGEST apology for what his part in what happened in T6V.

We get more hints at Army/Aracely and I need their book so bad!! But why do I think we will get their book last??

We see the return of Jerome Watson (who Krisjen was supposed to marry) and he’s slightly less terrible here? He was a creep in 5B. But I don’t know what to make of him here since most of his interactions are with Callum and he’s…not terrible? But maybe that’s because Milo Price is also back and he should’ve been dumped in the swamp 4 years ago like the guys were about to do before they had a change of heart. Callum is also friends with a guy called Vincent but you don’t have to know much about him.

Callum’s stepsister, Sophia but goes by Anna-Katherine, is two years younger than him and a big presence in his life and I actually like her a lot and wonder if we’ll see more of her in future books and see her getting a HEA (but way down the line of course). She’s extremely traumatized from events that have happened to her in the past. We don’t see anything graphic on the page but we do get a lot of things alluded to, and well, we see what it’s done to her. Do take the content warnings for this book seriously!!

Since writing this review, the audiobook narrators have been revealed and disappointing for me personally, the narrator for Dallas is not Andrew Eiden (Teddy Hamilton) who voiced the character's POV chapters in Five Brothers. So, if you're listening to these books back-to-back, it will be a bit jarring. Instead, his part is voiced by Javi Wilder, who is new-to-me. And the part of Callum is performed by another new-to-me narrator, Shawn K. Jain (although I think the initial narrator listed on websites was an entirely different narrator and they are not the same person using a pseudonym from what I can tell).

I did listen to a bit of the audio available on the Penguin Random House audiobook app where they offer early audiobooks to listen to and review, and the vibe of the performances don't really work for me. Javi Wilder was actually okay as Dallas, but I was expecting something more along the lines of the Tempting Venom audiobook by Rina Kent, which had been narrated by Teddy Hamilton and JF Harding. Shawn K. Jain on 1x speed is…okay… but I never listen to audiobooks at 1x, and at my usual 1.7x and 2x, it's just not the same vibe for Callum for me. No fault to the narrators, but just not casting that worked for me here. This audiobook is also only dual narrated, not duet. Which, usually it's fine. But maybe a bit disappointing when you listen to one and go right into another m/m audiobook where the story and characters give the same vibe but the audiobook production is just not the same.

Other than the disappointment of the audiobook, I actually really did love this book and I feel like I want to re-read the other two books in this universe again!! The downside to reading a book early before publication is that I had no one else to talk to regarding this book. But just know that Dallas/Callum are everything and this book absolutely delivered for me, and it'll definitely be something I re-read by text!
Profile Image for Laurin Jones.
211 reviews639 followers
September 6, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

IN PENELOPE DOUGLAS WE TRUST🗣️🗣️🗣️

THIS is how you write a true enemies to lovers MM romance. the plot, the suspense, the flashbacks, the SPICE?! I was literally gnawing at the bars of my enclosure the entire time. this is exactly why PD is one of my favorite authors. the aura in a Penelope Douglas book is like no other.

this was literally the perfect first pic for our daddy issues book club book eeeeeek!!!

also this YouTube vlog is going to be long af & I’m warning you now the screaming is going to be annoying lmaoooo😭
Profile Image for Kiani.
155 reviews482 followers
Did Not Finish
September 3, 2026
Read 1 chapter & this will never see me ever again
Profile Image for ⋆.˚࿔ Mackayla.
160 reviews6 followers
March 26, 2026
I was in a HUGEEEEE reading slump, so it took me a month to finish this book.
I love their tension, their chemistry. Tbh, Penelope's book is never a letdown.

PENELOPE U NEVER LET ME DOWN ON UR BOOKS. I LOVE U AND I NEED THIS!!!
I'm so so SO EXCITED for Penelope's first-ever MM romance AHHH!!!
Little sister's girlfriend's ex bf? OMG FAWK YES✅✅✅✅✅(Clay's ex)
Spinoff of 5 Brothers for Dallas? ✅
MM romance book for Dallas?✅
Rivals to lovers trope?✅✅✅
OH MY FREAKING GOODNESS GIRL IMMA EAT THIS UP SO BAD😭😭😭💗💗
Profile Image for taylor⁷.
304 reviews431 followers
Read
September 6, 2026
DNF at 50%

i felt like i was being told more than i actually was experiencing it which just made this super boring to me. i’m sad because i love the other books in the Tryst Six world but the writing style of this one was just not for me.
Profile Image for lakshmi.
765 reviews650 followers
September 4, 2026
it just shows that I’m not keeping my priorities straight because what do you mean I didn’t know that one of my favourite authors released an MM romance and it took me 4 days to know that?!?

I love just how much Penelope Douglas stretches my sanity to a point where I’m contemplating everything that I consider the norms too plain. I loved everything about this. It’s such a fun palate cleanser after reading books that’s more mellow 🕊️👀

Dallas and Callum are AMAZING characters. Love books where both the characters are equally morally black and manipulative where everything feels like a game ❤️🚩 Loved the ending twist with Callum showing just how much he’s capable of.

Do not read this if you like a more conventional story because it’s NOT that. It’s anything but that. It’s dark and delicious so perfect for me
Profile Image for mia:).
397 reviews4 followers
September 22, 2026
i’m sorry, but what was that? dallas annoyed me for pretty much the entire book. where was the yearning?? the tension?? i mean, we were grabbing forearms by chapter 3! 😭😳

and why were there so many scenes with women? i love mm romances so much, but this felt like a weird mix of mm/ff/mf/idek. i was genuinely confused about what direction we were going in. i understood dallas’s job in the beginning, and i could even understand why he was such a dick at first, but eventually it just felt annoying and almost… performative.😕

i think my biggest issue was that it felt like dallas and the mmc already had a connection before the book even started, and we were just dropped into the middle of it. i never really got to experience that build-up or feel the tension developing between them. the jealousy tactics were kinda cute at first, but they became so repetitive that they eventually lost the plot? 🙃

i love penelope douglas, and i really did love five brothers, which honestly made this one even more disappointing. i would’ve much rather seen army’s story because i was way more interested in him.

ughhh. i had such high hopes for this, and it just wasn’t it for me. it took me days to finish it because i got so bored. 🥲🙃🫠
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for jes.
116 reviews
March 25, 2026
tw rape, sexual assault, pedophilia, grooming, abuse, homophobia... yeah pd hates women...

not terrible but could've been better- the first half was a little rough for me but the overall story was well done compared to her last couple novels. i feel like there wasn't enough flashbacks to really flesh out the actual romance between the leads. we know they love eo but we don't see it enough imo. everything was sex sex sex and it just felt nauseating to see how miserable and misogynistic all the characters were.

jaegers truly are my family i genuinely hope we get to see them more ❤️ I claylivaracelysophia ily. the men... idgaf about.
Profile Image for Lobenda .
106 reviews
October 28, 2026
it's not necessarily required to read the previous books in the series, but for this one, I think it was essential. even so, I couldn't fully immerse myself in the story because of the excessive number of characters. for god's sake, i'm reading a romance about TWO MEN. there was absolutely no need for so many side characters to take centre stage and monopolise the narrative. it was infuriating. I didn't sign up for a family saga.

okay, okay, fine. this book needs to be read in order and cannot be read as a standalone. I get it. but WHY is there so much emphasis on characters from previous books? it's so unnecessary and an utter waste of pages. at times, I wanted to throw my device across the room out of sheer frustration. I wanted to read about carrot and durex-oh, sorry, see? I don't even remember their actual names because the author spent so much time highlighting other characters (who are apparently the main characters in their own books) that I can barely recall their names now. i'm sure they were great in their respective books, and they belong there, so PLEASE MOVE ON. this book had SO MUCH potential, and it's disappointing to see it squandered like this.

I loved the 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘺 𝘩𝘢𝘥 𝘴𝘰𝘮𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘱𝘢𝘴𝘵, 𝘣𝘶𝘵 𝘯𝘰𝘸 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘺 𝘥𝘦𝘴𝘱𝘪𝘴𝘦 𝘦𝘢𝘤𝘩 𝘰𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳, 𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘶𝘨𝘩 𝘥𝘦𝘦𝘱 𝘥𝘰𝘸𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘺'𝘳𝘦 𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘩𝘰𝘱𝘦𝘭𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘭𝘺 𝘺𝘦𝘢𝘳𝘯𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘰𝘯𝘦 𝘢𝘯𝘰𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 concept. the angst, the unresolved feelings, the emotional baggage, there was so much potential to explore here. yet the author managed to completely and miserably undermine the plot with an overabundance of superfluous characters and inconsequential scenes that did nothing but confuse and frustrate me. i'm sure i'm not the only reader who felt this way. so much of the narrative felt needlessly convoluted when the central romance itself was compelling enough to carry the entire book.

and JESUS CHRIST, how vulgar can a book get? this took 𝘥𝘪𝘳𝘵𝘺 to an entirely different level. not the deliciously filthy, unapologetically depraved kind we enjoy in steamy romance, but the grotesquely vulgar, almost inhuman kind that feels neither sexy nor remotely romantic. some scenes made me question what I was reading. that said, i'm not here to judge anyone's preferences. plenty of books explore this kind of content, and to each their own. this is simply my personal opinion and how I experienced it.

𝗦𝗽𝗼𝗶𝗹𝗲𝗿 𝗮𝗵𝗲𝗮𝗱 ⚠️

BUT OH, i LOVE CALLUM. his soft heart was utterly ruined by dallas, and the sheer depth of his love for him broke me. as much as I resented what callum did to liv, I couldn't help feeling sorry for him, too. he did so much of it to hurt dallas, to provoke him, to get even a fraction of his attention. ☹ he loved that man SO MUCH. some parts were excruciating to read. callum wanted dallas and his attention so desperately that he resorted to extreme measures, and the things dallas said to him just to make him stay away and supposedly protect him were heartbreaking. there was so much pain, longing, and unresolved affection between these two that I couldn't help feeling for them, even when I was frustrated with their choices.

as much as I hated this book for a multitude of reasons, i am absolutely enamoured with the chemistry between callum and dallas. you can hate someone for hurting you, betraying your feelings, and shattering your trust, but that doesn't necessarily erase the love, emotional attachment, or profound bond you once shared. you can resent someone with every fibre of your being and still yearn for them in ways you cannot articulate. and I think that's what made their relationship so compelling to me.

young love is young love, but the love you experience as an adult is something else entirely. it carries a different kind of weight, shaped by time, pain, shared history, and everything you've endured together. some connections leave an indelible mark on you, and no amount of resentment can entirely undo what once existed. the love between callum and dallas captured that feeling in a way I haven't experienced in fiction for quite some time, and I cherished that aspect of their relationship.

so, yeah. a frustrating, convoluted, excessively vulgar read that had me wanting to fling my device across the room, yet somehow managed to make me fall in love with the central couple. the chemistry and emotional intensity between callum and dallas were the only things that truly held my attention. everything else? I honestly couldn't care less. it was neither particularly remarkable nor consistently engaging, and the wasted potential makes it all the more disappointing. the author had something compelling here, and I wish she'd trusted the central romance enough to let it breathe.

Profile Image for Nelle.
21 reviews
May 31, 2026
I was frustrated as hell with Tryst Six Venom that I never finished reading it. But it introduced me to Callum & Dallas, so I was excited to read their story, but what a let down.
I never realized before but is this how PD writes. I find it over the top and i've read like 10 of her books.

I never got the memo that these two are in love. I never got the romance, I never swooned nor felt their yearning and longing for each other, which I was expecting from reading the premise.

I have the same issue with rina kent, these MF romance authors are joining the MM trend, and yet I still felt like I'm reading a mf book. This is one of the reasons I don't read mf romance anymore, the representation of women is horrible. Plus the amount of group sex here is outrageous. I've read more detailed descriptions of their escapades with women than them fucking. There were never enough intimacy moments between the two of them.

I swear I'll never read a mm book written by an mf author again to save me from disappointment.
Profile Image for brittany:).
354 reviews144 followers
Want to Read
May 17, 2026
I love Penelope Douglas downnnnnnn....so I was crying real tears when this arc hit my email this morning😭🖤
Also this is set in the same world as "Tryst Six Venom" and "Five Brothers"
Profile Image for Angela.
1,036 reviews1,601 followers
September 1, 2026
Okay… I’m landing at a 3.75 for this one.

I liked this. I was invested. I absolutely had moments where I was like, “Ohhh okay Penelope, I see what you’re doing.” The tension between Dallas and Callum was probably my favorite part because these two could not simply exist in the same vicinity without making everything approximately 100 times more complicated than it needed to be. I was rather impressed with this being P Doug’s first MM book too!

Now on to the downside… this book is LONG. And unfortunately, I felt the length in places. There were moments where I felt like we were circling the same thing over and over again. Some of the repetition and pacing kept this from being a solid 4 for me.

That being said, I had a good time. It was messy, dramatic, angsty, chaotic, and very much a Penelope Douglas book. And honestly, that’s why I keep returning to her books.

So yeah… 3.75 stars. I liked it. I had fun. I have complaints.

Thank you Berkley Publishing Group for the ARC
Displaying 1 - 30 of 904 reviews