What do you think?
Rate this book
The Nightkeeper's Apprentice
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
What worked:
Eilidh joins her aunt and cousin on a barren, rocky island, and readers’ speculation begins with her arrival. She’s told never to enter the lighthouse but isn’t given a reason. Most readers will join Eilidh, as her imagination comes up with many ways to explain why she can’t visit a lighthouse that doesn’t shine a warning light for ships. Adding to the intrigue is the question of what her aunt can possibly be doing in there every day. Readers know that something will happen, making Eilidh eventually break her promise to her aunt and venture into the strange tower. This will change the trajectory of the story.
Two characters contribute to the mystery and an unpredictable course of events. Magnus is Eilidh’s cousin, and he’s fairly quiet for much of the story. He clearly doesn’t want her around and spends much of his time stomping around the house or going off on his own outside. He knows about the lighthouse and its secrets, and he moves about the property as if he’s searching for something. Later, Cam joins the story, and he’s the ghost mentioned in the synopsis. He feels he hasn’t moved on because of unfinished business, but he has no idea what it might be. Ghosts always include a bit of uncertainty. However, Cam infuses some humor as he becomes acquainted with Eilidh.
There’s a simmering conflict behind the scenes between the Finfolk and the Landfolk, though it isn’t clear whether the humans are aware of it. Long ago, all creatures were Finfolk until some discovered a way to live on shore by trading their fins for legs. Eventually, Landfolk forced Finfolk to remain in the ocean, and they then took all the fish and polluted the waters. Finfolk have never forgotten. Sing-In-The-Shallows is infatuated by Landfolk, but she’s angered by their wars and killing. The author inserts pages between some chapters that explain what Sing-In-The-Shallows is doing and what she observes. Readers will remain curious as they discover how she fits into the story. A magical horn emerges as a major conflict, but readers must wait to find out what it means.
What didn’t work as well:
The Finfolks’ current attitude toward Landfolk is unclear. The pages about Sing-In-The-Shallows describe her curiosity about humans and how she helps them in times of need. However, she says the other Finfolk wouldn’t approve of her actions, but they don’t enter the story until the very end. Their feelings are still ambiguous even after that scene.
The final verdict:
Readers under ten years of age can still enjoy this book. It’s reminiscent of Irish selkie stories and creepy water creatures. The mystery of the Nighthouse will keep readers captivated, although readers will predict that Eilidh will make a questionable decision. I recommend you try this book for yourself.
Eilidh joins her aunt and cousin on a barren, rocky island, and readers’ speculation begins with her arrival. She’s told never to enter the lighthouse but isn’t given a reason. Most readers will join Eilidh, as her imagination comes up with many ways to explain why she can’t visit a lighthouse that doesn’t shine a warning light for ships. Adding to the intrigue is the question of what her aunt can possibly be doing in there every day. Readers know that something will happen, making Eilidh eventually break her promise to her aunt and venture into the strange tower. This will change the trajectory of the story.
Two characters contribute to the mystery and an unpredictable course of events. Magnus is Eilidh’s cousin, and he’s fairly quiet for much of the story. He clearly doesn’t want her around and spends much of his time stomping around the house or going off on his own outside. He knows about the lighthouse and its secrets, and he moves about the property as if he’s searching for something. Later, Cam joins the story, and he’s the ghost mentioned in the synopsis. He feels he hasn’t moved on because of unfinished business, but he has no idea what it might be. Ghosts always include a bit of uncertainty. However, Cam infuses some humor as he becomes acquainted with Eilidh.
There’s a simmering conflict behind the scenes between the Finfolk and the Landfolk, though it isn’t clear whether the humans are aware of it. Long ago, all creatures were Finfolk until some discovered a way to live on shore by trading their fins for legs. Eventually, Landfolk forced Finfolk to remain in the ocean, and they then took all the fish and polluted the waters. Finfolk have never forgotten. Sing-In-The-Shallows is infatuated by Landfolk, but she’s angered by their wars and killing. The author inserts pages between some chapters that explain what Sing-In-The-Shallows is doing and what she observes. Readers will remain curious as they discover how she fits into the story. A magical horn emerges as a major conflict, but readers must wait to find out what it means.
What didn’t work as well:
The Finfolks’ current attitude toward Landfolk is unclear. The pages about Sing-In-The-Shallows describe her curiosity about humans and how she helps them in times of need. However, she says the other Finfolk wouldn’t approve of her actions, but they don’t enter the story until the very end. Their feelings are still ambiguous even after that scene.
The final verdict:
Readers under ten years of age can still enjoy this book. It’s reminiscent of Irish selkie stories and creepy water creatures. The mystery of the Nighthouse will keep readers captivated, although readers will predict that Eilidh will make a questionable decision. I recommend you try this book for yourself.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This book has a really evocative setting, both city and island, and sets off at a cracking pace. I really like reading children's fiction because it's, frankly, better edited than most adult fiction and there's not a word goes to waste here. The characters feel real, flawed and funny, not a caricature in sight. Also there's a goofy dog. The plot is really pacy and engaging and (unlike some kids' books) you genuinely don't know how things are going to play out. It's a book with a lot of heart. I also liked the blurry lines between Scottish folklore and original elements and how they interacted with the overall historical setting.
I read it in two nights which is fast for me, a genuinely very enjoyable read for any age.
I read it in two nights which is fast for me, a genuinely very enjoyable read for any age.
Review of advance copy
A spooky, heartfelt story for children of all ages with themes of family, loss and legacy.
Set during WW2 on a remote Scottish island, Eilidh is an evacuee struggling to cope with the absence of her mother and loss of her father.
As she learns more about her heritage and the island’s mysterious lighthouse, she finds herself faced with the opportunity to reunite with her lost father.
But the consequences may prove perilous not just for Eilidh, but the entire world.
Set during WW2 on a remote Scottish island, Eilidh is an evacuee struggling to cope with the absence of her mother and loss of her father.
As she learns more about her heritage and the island’s mysterious lighthouse, she finds herself faced with the opportunity to reunite with her lost father.
But the consequences may prove perilous not just for Eilidh, but the entire world.
Review of advance copy
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
Brilliant book, full of magic and wonder. It captivated me, I couldn't put it down! Highly recommend. (Dylan, age 10)
March 11, 2026
A fabulous little book, ostensibly about magical light and ancient traditions, but really about grief and letting go when the time is right. I laughed, I cried, I devoured it in one sitting.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Enjoyed this. Different perspective on WWII
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews