Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Let Me Count the Ways: Opposites attract, low spice but swoon-worthy

Rate this book
It was impulsive of me, sleeping with Theo; he’s a rule-obsessed sheriff who’s SO not my type. Then again, Theo’s got this knack for making me feel seen, heard, and desired…

I’m Emma Jacobs, owner of The Pretty Pinecone, a romance-only bookstore. I can sell you the perfect love story, but I can't seem to write my own happy ending. When a rival bookstore threatens my beloved shop’s survival, I decide to offer wine tastings and poetry nights. There’s just one problem—Theo Baird, Sugar Pine's infuriatingly handsome yet uptight new sheriff. He’s determined to shut me down over every minor infraction.

Good thing that Theo’s good looking, because his personality is desperate need of a glow-up. And yet, no one challenges me the way Theo can. As my Valentine’s Day event approaches, featuring anonymous love confessions and Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s passionate verses, our boundaries begin to blur, and I wonder if maybe I’ve misread Theo all along. But then disaster strikes, and I must decide if I’m brave enough to risk my heart on the most daring venture of all—falling in love.

LET ME COUNT THE WAYS is a sparkling, small-town romance about finding courage in poetry, passion in the unexpected, and the one person who makes breaking the rules worthwhile.

130 pages, Kindle Edition

Published February 3, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Laurel Osterkamp

25 books543 followers
Laurel Osterkamp is the award-winning author of roughly a dozen novels, such as Favorite Daughters and the #1 Amazon bestseller, Beautiful Little Furies. She is obsessed with writing and doesn't know how to stop. In addition to her novels, she has short fiction published in literary journals all over the web, writes a monthly column for Writer's Fun Zone, and runs her website, laurellit.com, with book reviews, lesson plans, and writing advice.

When she's not writing (which is rare) she's often teaching adult ESL or middle school enrichment classes, going running while listening to audiobooks, or educating her daughter about the OG teen soap opera, Beverly Hills 90210. She lives in Minneapolis with a family who loves to argue, and their cats, who love to hiss at each other. Ramona Quimby is her spirit animal.

Follow her on Instagram @laurel_osterkamp.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
20 (32%)
4 stars
18 (29%)
3 stars
18 (29%)
2 stars
5 (8%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews
Profile Image for The Book Nerd's Corner.
882 reviews18 followers
February 28, 2026
A Valentine's Day centered novella that stars a romantic bookstore owner and a rule obsessed sheriff.

Emma Jacobs is the owner of Sugar Pines romance only bookstore, The Pretty Pinecone. Emma spends most of her free time reading romance stories and poetry penned by Elizabeth Barrett Browning, but she needs to do something out of her comfort zone to stir up some hype surrounding the Pretty Pinecone. In honor of Valentine's Day, Emma decides to host an event surrounding poetry and romantic secrets which will be accompanied by a wine tasting. Only one thing is standing her way of the perfect event: Theo Baird. Theo is the hot new sheriff in town who keeps finding infractions that may shut Emma's event down if she can't remedy them in time. As Valentine's Day approaches, Emma finds her heart torn between multiple men and the need to protect her bookstore.

This was another fun novella set in the small town of Sugar Pine, Colorado. It was really fun learning more about this community. We started off with its archeological center, then its theater, and now we venture to its romance bookstore. This one had such a fun romantic vibe that accompanied the reading experience, even though Emma made poor decision after poor decision.

The fact that this one is set around Valentine's Day in a romance only bookstore is so fun. The Illicit Ink event was a great touch, and the idea of getting a bunch of romance readers together to share their romance secrets sounds like a great time.

This book truly felt like an homage to all the romance readers out there who would rather spend their day curled up with a cozy romance than pursuing love themselves. Emma is the living embodiment of a book girlie, so it was fun following her unexpected love story. Her attitude toward the world is a tad jaded, but she is also a romantic at heart, so I found her voice to be very interesting.

The romance itself wasn't my absolute favorite, as I didn't feel the love triangle worked in a story this short. In a story like this, it is obvious that Emma and Theo are going to end up together, so it was a tad odd that there was even another guy in the picture. He was a British poet though, so at least he fit Emma's romantic fantasies well. I guess this subplot added some tension, but it felt a bit like a distraction from the other story elements to me.

Overall, I had a great time with "Let Me Count the Ways." It was fun to return to Sugar Pines (though this one would work great as a stand alone too) and see some familiar faces. This is a perfect read to sit down with on Valentine's Day because it features the holiday and is short and sweet. I didn't love the romance element as much as the other books in this series, but the vibes are impeccable. Emma was a great protagonist, and I hope that readers check out her happily ever after!

Audiobook Note: Jama Smith returns to the world of Sugar Pine to narrate this one. I like the way that they narrated Emma even more than Penny (from "Back to December"), so that was a fun surprise! Smith played Emma so sassy and fierce, which fit her vibe perfectly. I hope that Smith returns for future volumes, because they bring this series to life perfectly!
Profile Image for Getlitwithashleyz.
500 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
February 3, 2026
This was such a phenomenal novella! 💘 When you combine a romance bookstore owner and a sheriff, you know sparks are going to fly—and setting it around Valentine’s Day made it even more perfect.
Emma owns a romance bookstore in a small Colorado town, but when a big bookstore opens right across the street, she finds herself struggling to stay afloat. Enter Theo, the town’s new sheriff. Fresh off a broken engagement, he’s a little jaded when it comes to love… which makes their encounters even more entertaining.
Their chemistry had me smiling the entire time, and I genuinely laughed out loud—especially when Theo catches Emma trying to chop down the tree in front of her store in the middle of the night 🤣 Absolute perfection.
I also loved the Elizabeth Barrett Browning quotes at the beginning of each chapter. They added such a romantic, swoony touch and really enhanced the Valentine’s Day vibes.
Sweet, funny, and full of heart—this novella was a total win for me. 💕📚
Profile Image for Courtney Halverson.
872 reviews54 followers
February 12, 2026
Emma Jacobs, owner of a romance-only bookstore, fights to save her beloved shop when a rival store threatens its survival, only to clash with Theo Baird, the strict but handsome new sheriff determined to enforce every rule. As tensions turn into unexpected chemistry leading up to a Valentine’s Day event, Emma begins to see Theo differently and must decide whether she’s willing to risk her heart for a chance at her own love story.
This was such a sweet read and I am a sucker for any story that involves a book store. The nostalgia was hitting this millennial hard with all the fun references (Twilight, Taylor Swift). There were some laugh out loud moments that had me devouring this book in one sitting. If you are looking for a quick read for Valentine's Day then look no further.
Profile Image for Elizabeth Hubbell.
327 reviews
November 6, 2026
This novella is within a series of 3 full length books. Emma owns a Romance Bookshop. Theo is the new Sheriff in town. There's instant attraction, a big misunderstanding, but it all works out in the end.
Emma was recently dumped by a boyfriend who claimed he just wasn't ready to move forward, then he gets engaged - several weeks later - WTH!! Theo was recruited to the Sheriff's position from a bigger city, and he was more than ready, because he'd just been jilted by his childhood sweetheart. Who then turns around and gets engaged to Theo's cousin. Wow, do they have a lot in common. IT was a good read, and being a novella, I'll definitely being reading it again.
Profile Image for Lindsay .
350 reviews16 followers
February 8, 2026
If you're in the mood for the perfect Valentine’s Day read, look no further! Let Me Count the Ways is a sweet and swoony novella. It is a quick and easy read. Emma is a romance bookstore owner in a small town in Colorado. She's struggling to stay afloat when a big bookstore opens up across the street from her shop. Theo is the town's new sheriff who is fresh off of a broken engagement. He's jaded against love and her whole life is romance. There were funny moments and swoony moments and I couldn't put it down. It's available to read now so check it out in time for Valentine's Day!
Profile Image for Linsey Toney.
780 reviews45 followers
February 15, 2026
Let Me Count the Ways is stand alone novella that I loved. I give this a 4.5! This is why I love grabbing books at random and finding new to me authors. This author did a great job with the story holding my attention, I enjoyed the characters. If you are looking for a quick read, with a dash of spice then I would highly recommend adding this book to your TBR!

without giving too much away
book store owner meets the new sheriff in town.
grumpy sunshine, fake dating, small town romance
863 reviews6 followers
November 11, 2026
3.5* ARC Review
The book opens with the new town sheriff, Theo Baird, entering The Pretty Pinecone, a romance-only bookstore, and meeting its beautiful, quirky owner, Emma Jacobs. Although they seem like complete opposites, a spark ignites in their first conversation. Overall, it was a cute romance, and I enjoyed the characters as they got to know each other.

I received the ARC through a social media post by Pen Pinery, but since the audio was available with Kindle+ I listened to it.
Profile Image for Chapters with Mel.
34 reviews2 followers
February 15, 2026
Let Me Count the Ways is a quick read that’ll have you wanting to open up your own romance bookshop to recommend love stories and host poetry nights, with a handsome sheriff nearby.
My favorite thing about Laurel’s writing is I know I’m gonna get the feel-good falling in love vibes with laughs. Emma is unintentionally hilarious (because I’d too cut down a tree in the middle of the night without a permit if it was blocking my bookshop 😂). Finished this story in two days & highly recommend if you’re wanting to get a glimpse into Sugar Pine Springs.

5 star read for me this Valentines weekend 🩷
Profile Image for Dennis Wayne.
159 reviews
July 12, 2026
Not for me.the mmc was a grumpy closed off sheriff and fmc owned a romance book store,they clearly liked each other and had a something for like page 10 but 3/4 of the book she left him hanging on and dating another guy.in the end she didnt even break it off with the other guy he dumped her and told her to go get her man .
Profile Image for Jen Lewis.
29 reviews
February 14, 2026
Quick read filled with love, romance and guessing

Need a quick read? I read this book in around 2 hours. I love to have books filled with romance, steamy moments and some guessing.
Profile Image for Laura Clasemann.
43 reviews1 follower
March 3, 2026
Loved this short but sweet romance novella! A grumpy x sunshine story set in a small town with lots of Hallmark vibes! A romance bookstore owner, a small town sheriff and chaos bound to happen with Valentine’s Day around the corner.
Profile Image for Piper Brintnall.
706 reviews5 followers
July 16, 2026
Sweet, cute book. It’s definitely a novella, so you don’t get a lot of character or plot development. I guess it all kept my attention enough to read the book. This is a breeze through a book, simple read.
Profile Image for Steph Spone.
1,676 reviews5 followers
November 11, 2026
Emma was super cute in this. She realized that Theo needed some attention. I loved the way they came together and made life and love work. It was a cute romance, a little short for me, but it was good.
Profile Image for Dani.
137 reviews11 followers
February 6, 2026
If you’re looking for a quick, fun Valentine’s read with some spice then I have the novella for you! Let Me Count The Ways by @laurel_osterkamp is the perfect palette cleanser.

I will say novellas can be hit or miss for me. Sometimes they feel rushed, undeveloped, and/or too heavy on the spice. But this book didn’t feel that way at all. I felt like we really got to know Emma and Theo and they developed somewhat of a rapport with each other. I mean don’t get me wrong, it is fast paced, but it didn’t feel forced if that makes sense.

There is also a little mystery, some tension, and times where you will say awwwww and kick your feet. I loved that each chapter started with an Elizabeth Barrett Browning quote. I haven’t read a ton of her works, but really enjoyed seeing them and they tied into the story well.

Laurel sent me a cute PR box that included some fun stickers and Emma’s poetry journal, which you read about in the book.

🩷 Read if You Love🩷

💙 Small Town Romance
🩷 MMC is a Sheriff/FMC owns a romance book store
💙 Poetry specifically Elizabeth Barrett Browning
🩷 Witty Banter
💙 Quirky FMC and side characters
🩷 Opposites attract
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews