Women in the Middle Ages led fascinating and often wildly differing everyday lives, depending on their social class and family situation. Yet their wealth of experience has long been obscured and overshadowed by the experiences of men, with history books often relegating women to a single, catchall chapter, as if their lives formed a unified story.
While a number of medieval women have claimed biographers' attention, they tend to be the exceptional figures who broke the mould. What, then, of the countless others who were not exceptional and who did not blaze a new trail? How did their family lives and the constraints imposed upon them influence the ways in which they lived, worked, rejoiced, grieved and shaped their world?
The Family Lives of Medieval Women turns the spotlight on these women and examines how the concept of family impacted every aspect of their existence, whatever their social class. It draws us into bustling towns and rural villages, into courts and castles, to meet secular women of every standing and learn about their lived experiences. For the first time, the full spectrum of the female familial experience is considered, illuminating the lives of medieval women with the depth, nuance and humanity they have always deserved.
The author discusses medieval women in relation to their families in all walks of life, from princesses to peasants, though naturally there is more information available on the former. There is some interesting information here, but if you have read other books on the subject you probably won’t find much that is new to you. The sources she quotes from are those that have been quoted in most other books on medieval women. She takes on the whole a rathe gloomy view of her subject, you wouldn’t think reading this book that any medieval woman ever got any happiness out of life. And she is inclined to describe the thoughts of people whose thoughts she can’t possibly know. She compares their lot unfavourably to modern women, but then you could do the same for women (and men for that matter) in any era before the 20th century. Modern life is so much more comfortable now than in any past era that there simply isn’t any comparison.
To begin with, I don't think I've ever learned so much from one book - I have endless notes and have fallen down countless rabbit holes since opening the first page. The writing is engaging and I had so many little "oh I never knew that!" moments throughout (I'm sorry to anyone I know irl who will be subjected to a new bank of facts 😌).
The book is divided up by class so we have the full spectrum from Princess and Queens, to noble women and heiresses, and lastly to townswomen and merchants. The book never seeks to pit women of different classes against one another but acknowledges that although their hardships differed, neither life was easy. Noble women lived in physical luxury but had no choice in who they would marry, often being sent to secure political alliances through marriage - potentially never seeing their birth family again. Lower born women had more say in marital affairs and the running of their household but lived lives of hardship with their labour going unnoticed and unacknowledged.
"The pen was in male hands more often than in female ones, and the voices and thoughts of women living in the secular world have been lost."
This is a fantastic book for writers wishing to expand their knowledge on the medieval period and really get a sense for how 'ordinary' women lived. Perfect for anyone seeking to write historical fiction or mould an authentic fantasy world of their own.
Medieval women contained multitudes. This book finally does justice to that.
The Family Lives of Medieval Women is a brilliant addition to accessible nonfiction that shines a light on women’s lives across the classes – a favourite topic of mine!
The expectations placed on medieval women had me making notes and squeaking with interest throughout. I found the tension at the heart of their lives so fascinating: there was an overarching belief that women acting outside their sphere would be transgressive, yet they were still expected to drop everything at a moment’s notice to defend the castle, run the business, or bring in the harvest – only to disappear back into the shadows the moment they were no longer required.
Splitting the book by class was a brilliant move by Hanley. I relished learning about townswomen, artisans and peasants, and was so grateful their experiences made up such a good chunk of the book. There are far fewer primary sources for the lower classes, but there is enough here to paint a vivid picture of lives that deserve to be known.
If you love women’s social history that goes beyond the elite and actually gets into the texture of everyday life, this one belongs on your shelf.
If I'm honest, I don't think I've learned a vast amount from this book that I hadn't heard or read elsewhere, after a life-long interest in history: but this is a well-structured survey of the constrained lives of women in the period. It's also very readable.
I found some of the footnotes over-lengthy and discursive - they often seemed to be snippets which the author had found really interesting but couldn't find a way to work into the main text.
A really solid view of women from various walks of life, looking at lots of specific case studies using quite interesting source material. Would have liked to know a bit more regarding the lives of spinsters and how far women could really avoid marriage/what could happen if they did. But otherwise pretty good read