Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

As We Fall Through Time

Rate this book
From the multi-award-winning Claire North comes an extraordinary and epic tale of time travel, betrayal and a love that echoes through the centuries.

In the beginning, the world will end. This is the story of what happens next.

When Cal meets a soldier of the French Revolution, he knows his lover is destined to die. But what is the point of being a time traveller if you can't make a few small tweaks to the course of history? A little paradox here, an alteration there - nothing Cal can't fix, to save the man he loves.

When Fadimatu walks into a museum in 2018, she stumbles upon her own mummified corpse, setting her on the path to a betrayal that has already killed her, and a murder that has not yet come to pass.

And when a sudden rupture in the fabric of history rips through the lives these travellers have built, breaking both past and future, they must reckon with death foretold, love forsaken, and a secret that will shatter time itself.

Fall through history on a thrilling journey of shattered time, broken futures and a love that can never be erased.

412 pages, Kindle Edition

First published October 13, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Claire North

30 books4,573 followers
Claire North is actually Catherine Webb, a Carnegie Medal-nominated young-adult novel author whose first book, Mirror Dreams, was written when they were just 14 years old. They went on to write seven more successful YA novels.

Claire North is a pseudonym for adult fantasy books written by Catherine Webb, who also writes under the pseudonym Kate Griffin.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
153 (29%)
4 stars
211 (40%)
3 stars
119 (22%)
2 stars
29 (5%)
1 star
10 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 224 reviews
Profile Image for Kate Quinn.
Author 45 books46.6k followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
May 5, 2026
Claire North always breaks my brain in the best way. Ferociously smart novel about time travelers, a deadly paradox, and love that crosses oceans of time in a way that Dracula would approve of most heartily.
Profile Image for Courtney  « semi-ia dealing with health nonsense ».
149 reviews154 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
May 7, 2026
This is my fourth book by Claire North and it’s heavily influenced my review, but c’est la vie.

DNF @ 40%

My first book by this author was Slow Gods which I think set me up for a belief about Claire North that may or may not be true. A sweeping, epic space opera that was ambitious and imaginative, I couldn’t wait to see what else they had written, especially with such an extensive bibliography.

The next book I read was The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August which is wildly, insanely different from Slow Gods but still really well done, and I enjoyed it a lot. From there I moved on to Touch and was disappointed to notice almost immediately that it was basically Harry August with the skin of a different scifi concept layered on top.

Now I’ve come to As We Fall Through Time and I’m stunned to find the same thing has happened. In all 3 novels, North has taken an MC with some kind of ability that enables them to exist as an outsider to humanity and the constraints of time/location/whatever else. It shows clearly in all 3 books that North has some sort of higher education in history and geography, and can’t seem to hold back from absolutely lathering books with this knowledge. In every single book they get into this writing loop of just bouncing their MC around endlessly instead of actually telling a story. By whatever chosen method of scifi the book is employing, somewhere in the story the plot is completely abandoned to start a series of bouncing. The MC will be using trains, boats, planes and their method of ability (in this case time travel) to just bounce absolutely everywhere. Start in Berlin, take a train to such and such, stop to time travel a decade forward, take a boat to someplace, time travel a century in the past, take a camel to other place, time travel forward ten years to when they’ve invented XYZ, blah blah blah blah. Meanwhile during all this North is peppering the reader with historical facts about every single location, or method of travel, or dropping tidbits about how the MC has a previously established bank account in such place and it’s now overflowing with money, et cetera.

This was charming the first time I read it. It’s not as charming reading it for the third time. In fact, the third BOOK, and it had already happened multiple times in this book alone by the 40% mark when I became completely and totally bored with it.

I really love how Claire North writes. I easily could have finished this book IF it was the first book of theirs I’d ever read. But sadly it was not, and looking at it, and looking at Slow Gods, I’m left wondering how this severe departure happened to create such an intense space opera, only to return to the status quo for the very next novel. I’m not sure I’ve totally given up on them as an author but I would need to be absolutely sure I wasn’t being lured in to another bounce about novel before I tried again.
Profile Image for Bradley.
Author 9 books5,065 followers
September 14, 2026
I went through several evolutions as I read this, but with one caveat: I've always trusted this author to do right by me, no matter what the subject or genre or weird direction they take me. I just sit back and enjoy the ride.

And this one wasn't my cup of tea for a grand stretch, but I trusted the author and the author didn't lead me astray.

My original complaint? Well, for a time-travel novel, it was truly stuck on the romance bit. This shouldn't be a surprise, going by the title, but it was slow going, eventually evolving into a tragic mystery and then into a more mundane mystery and then into a cataclysmic mystery that eventually resolved into a huge, rather brilliant novel that connected all the pieces together AND rather blew my mind at the climax.

And things that are eventually revealed tickled me seriously. With no spoilers. The PoV changes are what do me in.

I'm still laughing.

And yet, this isn't a comedy. It's about as serious as serious can get and it has the emotional gravity of a very different kind of novel. And I love every moment of it.

Now. After getting through what I thought were the slow parts, the parts I scoffed at, it all comes together, wonderfully, and I even cried.


Ahem. And once again, I'm forced to repeat that I must trust certain authors. Explicitly.
Profile Image for Jamedi.
976 reviews163 followers
October 5, 2026
Review originally on JamReads

Time travel in fiction is tricky, especially if we take into account continuity and paradoxes; however, Claire North decided to embrace paradoxes and changing timelines to create a romantic sci-fi story that is equally ambitious yet intimate, a novel with a lot of heart at its core, a proposal that slowly evolves and embrace bigger stakes as we fall through the multiple timelines.

When Cal meets Oliver, a soldier of the French Revolution, he knows his lover is destined to die. Being a time traveller, he can just make the necessary tweaks to history to keep Oliver alive; small paradoxes can be easily closed, and things can be fixed, a small price to pay for love.
When Fadimatu stumbles upon her own mummified corpse in a museum, a paradox that sets her on a path that simultaneously exists and not; a sudden rupture through the fabric of story that is affecting what all the lives built by the travellers. A rip that will put all the travellers in different paths, desperate journeys in which one of them has their own agenda.

Interestingly, North starts the novel with a relative low stakes setting, focusing on Cal's attempts to keep Oliver alive, that tender romance which also helps to establish how time travel and its quirks work; however, after letting us feel comfortable, North pulls the floor under our feet, with growing stakes while the plot becomes much more complex, even confusing by moments. And you know what? It's brilliant how North plays with the multiple timelines, using the confusion from the paradoxes as a way to make the plot continue; you need to experience it, but seriously, trust the author to pull it all together.

As in Slow Gods, North also takes the opportunity to defy concepts so ingrained in our society like genre, taking a fluid approach that was another of the aspects I really enjoyed in this novel; and we can't forget how climate plays a pivotal role on the whole plot, which is nowadays more relevant than ever.
The pacing was in a sweet spot, starting slow with smaller stakes as we follow Cal-Oliver, but soon growing into bigger stakes as the pacing accelerates, embracing a chaotic approach that really suits this story well.

As We Fall Through Time is the kind of time travel novel that I absolutely love: ambitious and unafraid of embracing complexity; trust the author, and you will get an amazing experience. A really brilliant novel by Claire North.
Profile Image for Jae.
151 reviews9 followers
June 6, 2026
7/10

All I need now is Baran Bo Odar to adapt this into television. Oh but what a fantastic story.

I was enthralled by the writing style from the get go - and if one thought they knew where this was heading simply from the first few chapters - you would most certainly be wrong.

I was a bit disappointed earlier on thinking oh it’s just going to be a romance story - but this is much more. I’d even argue that there was more chemistry between the main character and Bede than with Olivier.

As We Fall Through Time is a story about a time traveller who falls in love with a non-time traveller and follows his quest in doing “everything” he can to be with said person despite time and age - and that “everything” includes the doom of humankind, a timeless friendship and a charming mentor turned enemy.

I was so confused at times, because there is quite a lot of perspective changes. At first I thought the author was breaking the 4th wall - which I kind of did not like, but trust it’s not that, keep reading!!!!! I did get accustomed to the pov changes and eventually also needed up liking it.

Pacing was good, plot was plotting, and characters were annoying and likable and consistent. I think I want a whole ass story for Fadimatu - such a brilliant character.

I also loved the lore of timetraveling - that there’s more to it than just being able to travel time - each traveler had their own individual abilities to it.

My biggest criticism is how are there so few travelers???? The general lack of any sort of authority like the TVA is just unbelievable.

Beyond that this was a solid book - I liked the philosophical intrigue, it was thought provoking, it was sombre and it was atmospheric.
Profile Image for Andrew Smith.
1,305 reviews998 followers
Did Not Finish
October 27, 2026
I received an advance copy from the publisher. Having really enjoyed the author’s previous novel, I was looking forward to this time travel tale. However, I found it extremely confusing and neither the narrative nor the characters managed to draw me in. Ultimately, I purchased an audio version in the hope that it would give me a different (better) experience, but unfortunately, it didn’t.
Profile Image for Janelle.
1,788 reviews374 followers
November 14, 2026
This didn’t really work with me. While I found the time travel and paradoxes that are created interesting, the style is just too waffly and cosy. The first quarter of the book is mostly focused on the main characters romance with a French soldier and the attempts to keep him alive by changing history. The story changes after this early part but the style never does, which really stopped the book from ever becoming a compelling read.
Profile Image for John Langley.
164 reviews6 followers
August 30, 2026
I was excited to see this on NetGalley as an ARC, having read and enjoyed some of Claire North’s novels before. She is inventive and original and has a distinctive and beautiful style of writing. I’m particularly interested in the time-travel genre, and so this was a happy match for me.

The book did not disappoint, though I think it is slightly too long and at times it’s repetitive.

We have here a time-travel story which is contained within a dystopian climate-change scenario. The depiction of the effects of climate-change are graphic and genuinely scary. The time-travel part also has its own emergency in the form of the Paradox to end all paradoxes(!) and which would also extinguish the human race, the planet and all of space-time in the process.

I believe the parallel between these two emergencies is intentional. High alert!

I’m always keen to see two things in time-travel books: one is ‘the mechanism’ (how they travel in time) and the other is the treatment of paradoxes. In this book the ‘mechanism’ is a wonderfully original method involving natural ability on the part of the traveller, and… old walls. I shall say no more, this is delightful and I won’t spoil it for you. The paradoxes are there too, and so many of them! The problem is not ducked - time-travel involves paradoxes, so deal with it! In this book the main characters spend a lot of energy on dealing with the paradoxes that they create for themselves, as well as finding a way out of the major Paradox that’s going to eat everything.

The main characters, Cal, Fadimatu, Olivier, Bede and the ‘witch’ are interesting, but not always completely well-drawn. This is perhaps a consequence of the way the narrative jumps about in time - we have different versions of the characters at different points in the timeline and one of them even becomes a ‘ghost’ of his own uncreated self and has different motivations from his original. It seems we don’t really get to know them very well.

Interestingly, Cal, the main protagonist, is male sometimes, and then female at others. S/he marries twice during the story, both times as a man, once to a man, and once to a woman. I feel there is an opportunity lost here to examine the nature of this gender-fluidity. We don’t get something like Woolf’s Orlando here, it’s different territory…

Cal’s marriage to Harriet, around the time of the English Civil War, is interesting, but undeveloped. This is something like a Time-Travellers Wife story in miniature. I was left wanting to know more.

What we do get a lot of is the descriptions of the Paradox as it opens first as a crack in the ceiling and then larger and larger as it eats Berlin and renders millions of future and past lives null and void. I think this is where the novel is strong (in so far as the writing here is beautifully done) but also where it is a little weak, as we get more of the same at several points in the narrative.

There are some interesting fight sequences where we have characters, particularly Bede, looping back on their own time-line to join the fight as several different versions of themselves. Nicely done, good use of paradox and mechanism but again, you can have too much of a good thing.

Very enjoyable, but not without flaws.

This is my honest review after a full read of an ARC. Thanks to Net Galley and the author.
Profile Image for Alexandra.
206 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 22, 2026
Going into this book, I knew it sounded like something I’d enjoy, but I wasn't prepared for just how deeply it would captivate me. It was absolutely wonderful!

We follow Cal, a time-traveller who falls in love with a non-time-traveller, and what a journey Claire North takes us on. Her writing gripped me from the very first page, expertly weaving timelines together with the charm of Cal’s character and his desperate mission to save the man he loves.

The plot and pacing are flawless. You're dropped straight into the action without relying on heavy info-dumps or massive blocks of world-building. Instead, the universe unfolds naturally over time; the more you read, the more the grand design clicks into place.

While I won't spoil it, the time-travel mechanics were easily my favourite aspect, it's such a fresh, fascinating take on how temporal mechanics could work. The jumping between timelines was thrilling! As a lover of historical fiction, exploring such a vast range of centuries and cultures, whiplashing from 2033 to the 1600s, was an absolute delight.

Claire introduces high-stakes "emergencies" in the form of paradoxes, time loops, and the potential end of the world, creating a palpable sense of doom that made this impossible to put down. The paradox scenes in particular are so vividly described that they feel genuinely terrifying and tense.

I also loved the fluidity of Cal’s character, who manifests as male or female depending on the timeline and situation. The supporting characters, including Bede, Fadimatu, and the witch all play integral roles in the narrative, even if their importance isn't immediately obvious at the start.

I’ve kept this review intentionally vague because this is a story best experienced by simply letting yourself get swept away. It was a gloriously woven tale of love and duty, and I’m so glad I read it.

Thank you to @orbitbooks_uk for the proof copy!
Profile Image for Matthew Galloway.
1,086 reviews53 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
June 15, 2026
I'm going to need a little time to process this one. I just loved it far too much. There's intricate world building and many great twists, but it's also a very tender dreamy book about love, friendship, and grief. I'd say it's one of the best time travel novels I've read and, to me, dipping into always felt like sinking into a dream. Or, I guess, falling through time.

Profile Image for Caroline.
1,068 reviews293 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 4, 2026
The best thing about As We Fall Through Time is its time travel system. It makes you wish you could take part in it, to hurtle through centuries the way Cal does. Time travel, for our characters, can be as incidental or immense as they want it to be. Cal doesn't always travel as a man, their fluidity corresponds beautifully to the way they slip through time—and then the snags begin. Snags like falling in love with the somewhat fatalistic soldier Olivier, who has a thing for throwing himself at lost causes.

If you're thinking this is a romance: No. It's more about contemplating the ethics of time travel, and maybe even the ethics of loving someone, and how far you'd go for them. What would you put their life above? Is completing disrupting a timeline worth it if you're saving the one who matters to you? And what if you find out about a terrible future? Would you do terrible things to prevent it?

It's quite interesting, and the prose backs that up. Stylized—some people will NOT like the way dialogue is conveyed here, but I didn't mind—and lyrical and quite effective at summarizing years of connection in a few pages. Which corresponds well to the ways in which one character's decades could be a week for another.

The relationships and big ideas in the book are complex, but the catch of that pretty prose and the way the novel is structured—dipping in and out of time and places and moments—is that it all felt a bit remote. There was a lot of surface-level beauty, but the depth just didn't quite get there. Or maybe I didn't get to it.

I'd recommend this to sci-fi, time travel fans who'd like something a bit more cerebral—especially if they're looking for a queer lens (I really did love the casual handling of gender in this novel). For me, it wasn't quite visceral enough. But it was well=written.
Profile Image for Karen Mace.
2,569 reviews88 followers
November 2, 2026
If there's ever a book that needs a second read through to fully appreciate it, then this is that book!! I loved the writing and the time travelling antics of the main character, BUT my brain hurts as I struggled to keep up with the twists and turns from about halfway, so I don't think I really 'got it' - but hopefully that will change when I read it again!

Cal is a time traveller, zipping backwards and forwards through time, but falling head over heels with Olivier who he meets in 1789, but there's problems with loving someone who doesn't time travel. And as Cal knows what lies ahead in their future he tries to change history -and we all know that doesn't end well, and the future of humanity itself is under threat due to a paradox he created.

Cal tries, along with Bede and Fadimatu, to fix these changes in the timeline, but their actions cause a split in their own timelines so they often seem to be working against each other at times and it's real race against time for them, and you as a reader, as little timeline changes cause big consequences.

There is a big gear change in 'genre' throughout this book - what starts as a historical romance, soon turns into a complex fast paced time travel saga with so much to digest that I felt as exhausted as the characters while they tried to find the right characters at the right times to affect the future timelines. You sense the frustration and despair of Cal too as he often travels aimlessly not knowing the right thing or right time to be. Definitely enjoyable as a story that gives you a something different to digest!
Profile Image for Isabel.
143 reviews116 followers
October 21, 2026
3.5 stars

As We Fall Through Time is a really ambitious story about time travel, love, and a future shaped by climate catastrophes. It follows Cal, a traveller who falls for Olivier, a French Revolutionary soldier whose death seems fixed in history. As Cal tries to change that fate, the story expands into something much bigger and more complicated, involving fractured timelines, other travellers, and questions about who gets to decide which lives—and futures—are worth saving.

The writing is imaginative and very beautiful. I especially enjoyed the approach to time travel and the emotional core of Cal’s determination to hold on to someone they love. The book broaches the topics of responsibility, grief, identity, and whether knowing the future gives people an obligation to change it. I did find though that the shifting timelines, changing points of view, and increasingly complicated paradoxes could be difficult to follow. Around the middle, the story felt a bit felt slow and somewhat repetitive, and while the dense style will absolutely work for some, I sometimes felt more distant from the characters than I wanted to be.

Overall, it is definitely a very thoughtful and creative story with a strong premise, compelling themes, and an love story at its center—you can never go wrong with that!

Thank you very much to NetGalley and the publisher for an arc of this book!
Profile Image for renkenreads.
532 reviews14 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 28, 2026
4.75

I started this book unsure how I’d feel, but with each page I fell more in love with the idea of this world, and our main character, Cal, a time traveler.

The crux of this story is Cal’s love story, with non-time traveller, Olivier. A mystery unfolds as Olivier disappears suddenly from time, and Cal is left to pick up the pieces… which leads him to fellow time-travelers, and paradoxes galore.

The pacing is fantastic, dropping you straight into the action without overwhelming info-dumps or pages of world-building. Instead, the universe unfolds naturally, and the more you read, the more the bigger picture clicks into place, especially our secret narrator.

I loved being thrown between centuries and cultures….from 2033 to the 1600s and everywhere in between. As a lover of historical fiction, this was so fun. I also LOVED how North uses archives in this book, the focus of its importance for humanity, and what comes after was so heartwarming.

One aspect of this book that I really loved, was Cal’s fluidity, manifesting as male or female depending on the timeline and circumstances, and at no point does it change how those who care about them do so.

Such an inventive take on time travel, with love and humanity imbued in it from 1200s France to 2200s Oslo. Across time, across gender, and across every page of this book I fell more in love with this book.
Profile Image for Kimberly.
1,712 reviews54 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 25, 2026
I started Claire North’s As We Fall Through Time with my coffee and quickly realized this was NOT going to be one of those books I could casually read while half paying attention. Thank you to Orbit Books for the gifted copy. Do you ever read a book where you’re pretty sure you understand what’s happening…and then three pages later you’re questioning everything again?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Cal is a time traveller who falls in love with Olivier, a French soldier during the Revolution. Cal knows Olivier is destined to die, but when you can move through centuries, following the rules and accepting fate suddenly seem a little less reasonable. Surely one tiny change to history couldn’t hurt.

You already know where this is going.

Except I absolutely did not.

What begins as a love story becomes something MUCH bigger, involving paradoxes, fractured timelines, climate disaster, murder, friendship, grief, and the potential end of everything. Then there’s Fadimatu, who walks into a museum in 2018 and discovers her own mummified corpse. That certainly gets your attention.

I loved how creative the time travel felt. Cal moves through the history of objects and places, and every little alteration carries the possibility of creating something far more dangerous. There were moments when I had to reread a paragraph and tell my brain, “Okay, we’re here now. I think.”

And honestly? This one required patience from me. It’s dense, it wanders, and some of the descriptions of the paradoxes went on longer than I needed. But when everything started coming together, I understood why the story had taken such a complicated road.

What stayed with me most wasn’t actually the mechanics of time travel. It was Cal’s refusal to simply accept losing someone he loves. How far would you go if time itself gave you another chance? And at what point does saving one person become too expensive for everyone else?

This was my first Claire North, and she definitely made my brain work overtime.

If you could change one moment in history but had no idea what the consequences would be, what would you choose?
Profile Image for Janie.
Author 6 books1,478 followers
November 3, 2026
Cal, a time traveler from a future where mankind faces extinction of our own making, discovers that other time travelers and the man he loves have disappeared. AS WE FALL THROUGH TIME hurtles along at a relentless pace, snapping back and forth through centuries as Cal tries to locate the origins of the time paradox someone created while trying to save humanity’s future. Claire North’s unparalleled imagination delivers again in this sharply intelligent, mind-bending story filled with plot twists and revelations, incisive commentary on our own era, questions of morality -- and love.
43 reviews1 follower
October 23, 2026
DNF 35%: rambling ennui amounting to nothing, motivated by a one night stand and zero on page chemistry
Profile Image for Peter Baran.
973 reviews67 followers
November 3, 2026
If there has been a theme for time-travel novels over the last decade, I'd definitely say romance would figure. And that's both in the harder sci-fi side to the softer romance side: the unexplained time slips of Outlander are sauce to This Is How You Lose The Time War's gander. As We Fall Through Time impressively starts off as a type of time-slip romance, and uses the familiarity and fondness we have with its characters to then wrap a propulsive sci-fi action mystery around it. It is also rather good at tackling great man theory, anthropocentrism, and what to do if your partner suddenly winks out of time and never existed.

We open as the French Revolution is starting to concern the minor aristocracy and military, with Cal, who we are told is a time-traveller who is looking for an object. In the process, he meets French soldier Olivier with whom he (though he is sometimes a she) inconveniently falls in love. As we come to learn, some people, people born of paradox, who might not have been born or for other reasons, become unstuck in time and if they survive their first few trips, can learn to travel in time. This can be used for great personal gain, as long as one is careful about paradoxes. Generally, time is very forgiving; small things change little. But meet yourself, or fail to complete your own causal loops (spend money without having forst deposited it), you might end up causing a catastrophic paradox that starts to eat time and space itself. You can sometimes sort them out by throwing paradoxical items in them, items which are anachronistic, and have been unstuck themselves. But watch out for the ghosts of what might have been, and the occasional time witch.

A lot happens in As We Fall Through Time, but it is all initially pegged on the affair between Cal and Olivier. As the tale snowballs past their tragic conclusion, we discover a paradox that might destroy the world, in lieu of humanity destroying itself anyway with climate change and other capitalistic crises. And so we have a small story predicating a much larger story, stitched together with a non-linear narrative and non-linear storytelling (as we fill in backstory) which is nevertheless always crystal clear and propulsive to read. It holds tragedy, and it also holds a few lovely big ideas - whilst still being brutally honest about how shitty it is to live in much of history (much here is made of modern transport; if Cal wants to go anywhere, he tends to pop to the 21st century for some fast trains). I'd been told this was good, but it exceeded my expectations, and I'd say run, or slip back in time to get a copy (not too far; it was only just published).
Profile Image for Brian Stabler.
239 reviews17 followers
October 17, 2026
Claire North has once again reminded me why she’s such a fascinating author. As We Fall Through Time is an ambitious, mind-bending mix of time travel, impending apocalypse and a surprisingly tender exploration of love and identity.

I loved the sheer inventiveness of the time-travel concept, particularly the fact that it doesn’t rely on complicated machinery. The rules of this world are wonderfully strange, and the consequences of meddling with time can be downright horrifying. There are some genuinely unsettling moments here, alongside plenty of action and some clever twists that kept me guessing.

At the heart of the story is Cal, whose journey through time is as much about understanding relationships as it is about trying to prevent catastrophe. I particularly liked the development of Cal’s relationship with Harriet, and the way the novel explores the difference between trying to save someone and learning to treat them as an equal. The exploration of gender identity is also woven naturally into the story, while the relationship with Olivier adds another layer of emotional complexity.

There’s plenty going on beneath the surface, too. Climate change, humanity’s capacity for destruction, prejudice and the temptation to reshape history for the greater good all come under scrutiny. It makes for a frequently bleak read, but North balances the darker material with a reminder of what makes life worth fighting for.

This isn't the easiest book to follow. The shifting timelines, multiple versions of characters and increasingly tangled paradoxes demand concentration, and there were times when I had to work to keep track of everything. But I enjoyed the challenge, and the ambitious structure is a big part of what makes the novel so distinctive.

Ultimately, this is a clever, thought-provoking and beautifully written novel that combines big ideas with genuine emotional depth. It won't be for everyone, and I wouldn't necessarily recommend it to anyone looking for straightforward time-travel escapism, but I found it well worth the effort. Claire North at her imaginative best.

Thanks to NetGalley, Orbit and the author for an advance copy.
Profile Image for vic.
481 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 9, 2026
I think I am the exact target audience for this book. I loved every word of it. The narration style in particular really worked for me. I love first person masquerading as third. I also thought the time travel made sense and was interesting, both of which seem like the bare minimum but time travel is so strange that when stories revolve around it, they sometimes have a hard time doing that. The approach it takes to gender was also really interesting, with time travelers all being genderfluid because they are born between possibilities. And the love! This was not a romance, but it was devastatingly romantic and devastatingly hopeful, which are two of my favorite things for a story to be. This is absolutely going to be a book I return to again and again.
Profile Image for BookishKB.
1,596 reviews437 followers
Read
July 5, 2026
⏳💫As We Fall Through Time 💫⏳

📖 Bookish Thoughts

My full review will be shared closer to the publication date.

✨ What to Expect
• Time Travel Romance
• Queer Romance
• Multiple Timelines
• Time Paradoxes
• Star Crossed Lovers
• Epic Sci Fi
_ _ _ _

📅 Pub Date: October 13, 2026
Thank you to Orbit Books and NetGalley for the advanced copy.
Profile Image for Heather.
403 reviews26 followers
October 22, 2026
I have mixed feelings about this book. While I love time travel and beautiful writing, and this story has plenty of both, it didn't quite live up to my expectations. There were moments when I was completely enthralled and thought I had found a new favorite, but there were also stretches where the story dragged and I just wanted to reach the end.

That said, I really enjoyed how the time travel mechanics worked. Cal, along with their fellow travelers, can fall through centuries both forward and backward. Woven together with a romance, time paradoxes, a murder mystery, and several other surprising elements, it makes for a unique and interesting read.
Profile Image for Sue.
305 reviews7 followers
Want to Read
October 13, 2026
I have an uneven relationship with Claire North. I have loved some of her books but others... not so much. Gonna give my friends a chance to weigh in before I commit to this one.
Profile Image for Christina.
37 reviews1 follower
October 31, 2026
I loved this book. Love, time travel, ghosts, the ending of the world. The questions of who do you fight for, how do you fight for them? How far do you go to save the world? Loved it.
6 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 20, 2026
ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for a review.

I really wanted to like this book because I love time travel books but honestly by 50% into the book, I kind of understood the plot but felt like it should have been further advanced at the halfway point. So it is a DNF for me at 50%. Every time I picked it up I was hoping there’d be a plot point to pull me in and keep me reading like other books do, but there never was.

I’ve enjoyed North’s other books but something about this felt aimless and chaotic and all over the place. Perhaps that’s the intention because the main character feels that way, but it didn’t work for me. I felt like there was nothing to focus on really, except following Cal through time.

I liked the writing style and language, but I feel like the focus was more on lyrical and poetic writing than the actual plot. North definitely has a way with words, no doubt. But plot advancement is important too which I feel like took a backseat to the writing style.

Maybe I’ll give this book another shot in the future but I’ve been trying to read it for a couple months but find my mind wandering rather than staying focused.

Thank you NetGalley for providing the opportunity to read the ARC. I hope to return to it one day when I have an itch for time travel.
Profile Image for Cassidy | fictionalcass.
430 reviews19 followers
October 13, 2026
[I received an advance review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley]

After loving Slow Gods by Claire North, I was beyond excited to see this one pop up on my radar. I wasn’t disappointed by this one, and beyond that I was absolutely hooked from the jump. I’m a sucker for a good time travel story, and I think this one may just be my new favorite. North creates such a complex and yet still straightforward understanding of how things function in the world of this book, and I loved the layers that were explored for our time travelers, particularly the details around gender! These nuances of what it means to (physically and philosophically) be a time traveler really pushed this book to the next level.

Part mystery, part adventure, part love story; there’s so much to dig into with this book. It starts out so simple with our protagonist, Cal, doing some (as far as we know) standard time traveler stuff. Cal meets Olivier, they form a romantic entanglement, the rest is history/future/now. Narrated by an unknown observer, we follow Cal across time and space, initially in search of a specific amaranthine but at some points in a bid to protect Olivier from certain death as a soldier. Things get quite messy, and eventually temporal disaster strikes and leaves Cal to pick up the pieces of the mess that has been/has not been made by him.

The worldbuilding details around how time travel worked in this book were exceptional. North throws a lot of information at you, drops the reader directly into the time stream, but with the reflective and fluid nature of the prose it never felt overwhelming. There’s a great balance to the stops and starts of time travel being explained to the reader and naturally discovered just through being immersed in the story. Along with the actual fundamentals of how this all works/doesn’t work (paradoxes are real and they are dangerous!) there’s also the richly detailed layers of real world history and future presented that adds so much depth to the book. Following Cal and occasionally his acquaintance Fadimatu across so many eras was a beautiful, if often quietly heartbreaking, journey.

Along with such a layered world, we’ve also been given the gift of so many layered characters. Cal, Olivier, Fadimatu, and Bede bring so much of themselves to the page and I really enjoyed the way that all of their different outlooks on life and death are presented throughout. Not only is there a slow unfolding of the story through time, it’s a parallel process with the slow unfolding of these characters as well. I was consistently impressed with how North brought so much depth to each of these characters through their interactions, primarily with Cal, but also through Cal’s own journey as well. There was a level of intentionality and care in how they each are presented that really spoke to me.

Thematically, this is a novel that is tackling a lot of different topics but many of them can be broken down to the simple/complex fact of what it means to be human. Where do the boundaries exist when you have the power to skip across every timeline imaginable? North does a great job at digging into a lot of moral complexity without the book ever coming across as preachy or smug, but presented so authentically in the context of how these characters exist and understand the world around them. At the end/beginning/middle of the day, who has the right to determine who lives or dies? All of this is so rich without even digging into the romantic elements of this story that range from yearning to the meaning of sacrifice. Beyond romantic, it’s a story that also very adeptly explores different types of love and what we will do for people that we love (and even some that we don’t).

I could probably continue going on about this book for ages, so I’ll wrap it up here and just say that I absolutely loved every minute of this book and absolutely 100% recommend.
Profile Image for Joe Kessler.
2,562 reviews85 followers
November 20, 2026
This novel reminds me a lot of the TV show 12 Monkeys, another twisty time-travel story that is pretty clever on paper but never quite develops its characters and their relationships enough for me to feel wholly invested in the affair. The plot sees a genderfluid time traveler fall in love with a Napoleonic soldier, who subsequently gets erased from existence by some causal paradox that they're both wrapped up in. (He does linger on as a sort of ghost, so it's not a total fridging.) Following that thread to try and restore him to life inevitably brings the hero even further into the machinations of the eventually-revealed villain, and a mind-bending chase back and forth through history ensues.

This is fun, to an extent! How do you catch a fellow chrononaut who knows that you're coming and is trying to catch you first? The answer involves plenty of imaginative countermeasures and traps within traps, as well as the help of past and future versions of oneself all bouncing around across each other's personal timelines. Sometimes it's even the same person at war with themself, due to a branching fate where one iteration has made a different choice than another and now wants to see the opposite line dead.

If that sounds chaotic, it definitely is, but it's mostly comprehensible, at least by the end. My favorite element here is an intelligent creature from eons hence, whose species evolved out of cockroaches after humanity destroyed itself in a nuclear holocaust, which is an idea that I don't think I've encountered in this genre before. (It's traveled back both for research purposes and to ensure that events aren't changed to such a degree that its civilization doesn't get to rise, which adds a certain welcome dark undercurrent to everything else.)

Ultimately I like this one more than I love it, but it's worth the price of admission, I'd say. Recommended for fans of Steven Moffat's run on Doctor Who, The Time Traveler's Wife, or The Man Who Folded Himself, all of which play in a similar conceptual space.

[Content warning for racism, sexism, violence against children, gun violence, suicide, and gore.]

Like this review? Find more of my writing on:
--https://www.goodreads.com/lesserjoke
--https://letterboxd.com/lesserjoke
--https://lesserjoke.home.blog
Or check out these ways to support me, if you'd like:
--https://ko-fi.com/lesserjoke
--https://patreon.com/lesserjoke
Profile Image for Dan Trefethen.
1,367 reviews95 followers
October 29, 2026
I continue to be astonished at Claire North's range. Every book has a different speculative premise, and every book seems to excel in examining the ramifications of that premise and how the characters react to it. This is North's time travel book, and it's as convoluted as any I've read.

If your head hurt while considering the twists of Heinlein's classic time travel story, '...All You Zombies', this book will make your head spin around. I'm not sure I completely understand the twists, but I'm sure North does.

The premise is that certain people have the ability to travel through time via any object's history - old stone walls provide a great range of options, furniture not so much. Just touching the object allows the traveler the chance to 'fall through time', either forwards or backwards.

Our protagonist, Cal, started as a medieval peasant but was mentored by a seasoned traveler, Bede, and once he became unchained from time Cal developed skills and languages he would never have dreamed of. But he still has the soul of a peasant and took a wife from his time period, to whom he returns periodically. Cal also has the ability to seemingly shift between male and female according to need. Cal develops a relationship with a French officer in the Napoleonic era, and it's this relationship that determines much of Cal's action throughout the book. Cal's interactions with Bede become fraught when it becomes clear that Bede has secretly been trying to manipulate events to affect the future of humanity and has been causing severe ruptures that could destroy everything. Because of course you can't just jump around changing history without upsetting the space-time continuum.

North develops her characters well and makes us care about Cal and the relationships Cal develops. At times Cal seems to regress to the status of a hapless peasant (or maybe just one blinded by love), but we always understand why. I was charmed by the character of Olivier, Cal's French officer. Especially after Olivier dies (see, it's complicated, because time travel.)

There are many time travel books that center loving relationships across time, and many that deal with the nuts and bolts of the concept of time travel. But I don't think I've ever read one that combines the two so well. Yeah, it takes a lot to pack that all in (over 400 pages) but none of it is wasted.
Profile Image for Morgan Johnson.
229 reviews14 followers
October 14, 2026
Thank you to Orbit and Netgalley for the copy to be able to review. All thoughts are my own.

I know I shouldn’t judge a book based on the last one, especially when they are standalone. Truly, I tried not to, but still there was a bit of hope for greater enjoyment at the beginning. This book starts off a bit slowly, so it did take a while to hook me. With a time travel novel, it should be expected that the story might be confusing. In this case, though, we sort of meandered through the time periods, seemingly to deviate from whatever the point of the story was for the first half. I really had no idea what the actual story was supposed to be until the huge event towards the middle. It’s not that this is a horrible decision, just the particular writing style. We really got to sit with the main character, to feel for them and their life.

The concept of how time travel worked was quite intriguing. Firstly, time travelers are born at a ripple in time. An odd occurrence of, well, indecision is not the right word, and neither is paradox, as that is used later; possibility, whether something will happen. Such as our main character's mother, was/was not pregnant and did/did not give birth at that time. It is a lot to follow how that works through words. This sort of distortion of events is what gives individuals the ability to travel through time, though. It is not just people made this way either, but items throughout history are created specially as well, such as the impossible goblin Cal is hunting at the beginning of the story.

Most of the driving factor of the story, though, is the romantic entanglement. Sadly, it is possibly my least favorite part as well. I can’t even put my finger on why either. Maybe it is that I couldn’t feel anything building into the relationship itself. Once the fallout happened, there was a devotion that you could see. The love and attachment that was not easy to let go of as Cal desperately searched through time was evident. This took up a large portion of the book and explained why Cal did several things. However, it still left me feeling like something was missing from their connection.

Full review is up on my Book Blog
Displaying 1 - 30 of 224 reviews