Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Their Baby Bro #2

Claiming Baby Bro

Rate this book
“This weekend, you’ll be ours. We’ll use you whenever we want, wherever we want.”

My big brothers and cousin hunted me down, caught me, and used me in the best way possible. Ever since that weekend, I’ve been aching to see them again.

We’re back at the cabin, and this time they’ve promised to find new ways of making me submit to them. But I’m not sure how much of myself I’m willing to give. It’s not just my body on the line anymore...

It’s my heart.

Claiming Baby Bro is a taboo MMMM novella featuring three brothers, a cousin, and the filthy games they play. As part two of the Their Baby Bro series, it should be read after Hunting Baby Bro.

ebook

Published February 6, 2026

4 people are currently reading
195 people want to read

About the author

Ally Avery

7 books161 followers
Ally found her love for reading and writing at a young age. MM romance in particular has been part of her life since her first exposure to late-2000s Shounen Ai.

She likes to write about fierce, damaged boys who need a lot of love, and she doesn’t shy away from dark and taboo topics that some readers might find disturbing.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
66 (46%)
4 stars
55 (39%)
3 stars
18 (12%)
2 stars
1 (<1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
Profile Image for Che Miller.
131 reviews125 followers
February 7, 2026
Very torn between 3 or 4 ⭐️
Book 1 was sooo good, I just knew that we were going to get the same thing but more…. That was not the case (FOR ME!!)
In book one you can tell that there was a lot more feelings and affection towards one brother versus the other two. It didn’t really bother me, because it was still very primal and super spicy… It almost made you forget.
In this one, as the other two showed more feelings towards Baby bro, but he was still very focused on big bro. One thing about me, if we have multiple partners, I like the love to be equal across the board!!!!
The first half of this book was everything, full 5 ⭐️, but the second half was a little irritating. Our bratty little brother very much so became a super Simp in this one. To the point that he wouldn’t even admit that he was uncomfortable or in pain, because he didn’t want to disappoint his brothers/cousin. I didn’t care for the fact that he got all whiny and needy. (A little is great, but there was too much imo)
This book was still SUPER SPICY, but it also focused on the growth of there feelings.
(P.s. I still like and recommend 3 ⭐️ books 😂)
Profile Image for angie_bookrecs.
302 reviews54 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
February 1, 2026
This is the second book in the series, and I need to talk about Jake specifically because that man is an absolute menace and I love him for it!

Mark may be the firm, controlled, terrifyingly dominant one. Shawn may be the sweet, caring heart of the group. But Jake? Jake is chaos. Loud, unhinged, over the top, pushing buttons like it’s his full-time job...and somehow still capable of being unexpectedly soft when it matters most.
He shouldn’t work. On paper, he’s too much. But in practice? He’s perfect for Ty.

What I love most is how different all three of them are. They don’t blur together, and Jake especially stands out because of how wildly he swings between feral energy and genuine affection. One minute he’s making everything worse, the next he’s quietly giving Tyler exactly what he needs.

And Tyler…god. He’s the neediest, sweetest little sub. He craves their attention, their approval, their love, and that desperation for more - more reassurance, more permanence, more of them...runs through the entire book. Watching him try to find his place with three very different Doms is both heartbreaking and addictive.

This book is messy, emotional, taboo, and complicated in the best way. Nothing is easy, nothing is solved, and that lingering question of how they could ever all work together just makes me want the final book even more.

I’m begging for an ending where Tyler finally gets the love and stability he’s been aching for...even if it’s hard-earned. Especially then.

And yes. Jake is still my favorite unhinged fucker. No notes.
Profile Image for Chloe.
421 reviews39 followers
February 12, 2026
Claiming Baby Bro by Ally Avery

❤️ MMMM Taboo (🩸 brothers & cousin)
❤️ 3 Doms X 1 Sub
❤️ Erotic Novella
🔥 Free Use, Humiliation, Praise Kink, Medical Play, Somnophilia, Cock Cage, S*x Toys, DP, Spitroast, Shower S*x, Orgasm Control, Dom/Sub, Dub Con, Facefucking, Cum Play, Rimming, Blindfold, Cock Warming, Pierced 🍆

Overall: ⭐⭐⭐⭐.25
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️.5
Humour: 🤭.5
Intimacy: 🫂🫂🫂.5
Angst: 🥺🥺

First person dual pov 👀

Content Warnings
On page: sub drop, failure to communicate/safeword, dub con, incest
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Ash.
386 reviews68 followers
February 1, 2026
5 ⭐️
5 🌶️🔥

There’s something about Jake gets me. He is feral and delulu for his cousin baby Ty and I’m here for it. Him and Ty’s vulnerable moment at the end ugh 😭

I need Ty to have his hea with his brothers and cousin like yesterday.

I can’t wait for book three!

Profile Image for ashlee ❤.
2,154 reviews121 followers
March 3, 2026
Tyler, Mark, Shawn, + Jake

-mmmm whychoose
-🩸 taboo
-brothers & cousin
-primal play
-free use/degredation
-secret getaways

these were NAUGHTYYYY & NASSTYYYY!! & i loved it v much thank yewww! lol
Profile Image for Kim Reads.
286 reviews53 followers
February 6, 2026
Oh, sometimes it's so good to be bad..

This one was highly anticipated by me, so naturally, I instantly devoured it 🙈

The boys are baaaaack 😏 Tyler, Shawn and Mark are brothers, Jake is their cousin.

They've been together on a trip before where things really got interesting, and the've been back to this cabin with this one, exploring all kinds of stuff together 🤭

I enjoyed the spiciness, but I also majorly enjoyed the vulnerability in this one. There is so much more to it than just the physical chemistry between these boys and I can’t wait for them to explore more of that.

I need more 🥰
Profile Image for Rachel Emily.
4,545 reviews390 followers
February 23, 2026
This is a direct continuation of the first book, so read in order! It's taboo mmmm contemporary romance with some kink and very steamy times.

I'm always up for when emotions come into play, and seeing Ty needing aftercare shows a lot of growth I think. I hope that the third book will continue to expand on them all being vulnerable together.

I'm so on board with this series and cannot wait for the third one lol
Profile Image for Zoë Elias.
75 reviews6 followers
February 6, 2026
I loved Hunting Baby Bro so i knew this would be just as amazing and i was right!

Tyler is just the sweetest and cutest and his brothers and cousin are just hothothot . They are all so perfect for each other and i cannt wait for novella #3 !!!

Jake is so unhinged and i love that! I hope that tylers gets his HEA with all 3 of them cause he deserves it !
Profile Image for Rosetta  Celeste.
131 reviews1 follower
May 10, 2026
There honestly was not much development here aside from the new kink and Tyler getting closer with his cousin. That being said, the smut was definitely more enjoyable than in the first book. I just hope the next book finally dives into the unresolved issue everyone keeps dancing around.
Profile Image for Ashley H.
158 reviews12 followers
Read
February 8, 2026
Again, filthy, funny good time 🤣 lil more emotions in this one but still 🤣👏🏻
Sometimes .. you just gotta read a filthy taboo book haha
Profile Image for Ashley Dead.inside_but_reads.
222 reviews35 followers
February 26, 2026
This is a Tab00 story with 🩸 Brothers and A cousin so if that's not your thing then I suggest you skip this one....and if it is....😈
This is also Book 2 of 3 it picks up right after book 1 so they do need to be read in order and it ends on a HFN no Cliffhangers or anything just open for the next/last story 🖤

🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶

We pick our story up during Thanksgiving break which is when our guys all agreed to meet back up at the cabin. Ty has been a little nervous because there hasn't been a ton of communication between everyone that he was hoping for. He really just wants to know the guys still want him the way he wants all of them. Mark has a plan up his sleeve for this visit though and part of it is the free use of Ty during the stay which Ty is completely down for. This book we also get a bit more insight into Shawn and we get to see more of his caretaker side where Mark was the Dom of the group in the last one. For a Novella this one was packed full of feels! The guys learn the importance of communication when you have a dynamic with 4 people and each of them is more clearly starting to see what they want to outcome of this to be or what they want their future to look like...I KNOW! I'm telling you! FEELS! The underlying plot or message here that home is the people you build it with not necessarily a place just melted my heart and has me hooked on these guys! Gosh I can't wait for the last story now!
Profile Image for Selena.
259 reviews3 followers
February 6, 2026
Reading Hunting Baby Bro was like something you knew would be a bad idea, but you were curious anyway. Now coming back and reading Claiming Baby Bro was like coming back for seconds, because it felt so good to be wrong.

Tyler, Shawn, Mark and Jake are still a fever dream. Something enjoyed in secret. They know they're wrong, but they can't help themselves. But they have to ask themselves if they're okay with only having a few times a year together or if they need more. Especially Tyler is struggling a lot with what that all means and with his fear of being abandoned.

Even though the focus in both Hunting Baby Bro and Claiming Baby Bro is on the taboo relationship, it still gives layers on a personal level. The main conflict in the sequel seems to be the same as in the first novella, but it's valid, because it's only the first time they're meeting since and communication isn't learned in a day.

What you get
- taboo MMMM novella
- sequel to Hunting Baby Bro
- navigating the transition from a fever dream into something real
- learning to communicate your needs

📖 Claiming Baby Bro by Ally Avery
Rating ⭐⭐⭐⭐

#reading #bookstagram #review #mmmmnovella #taboo
Profile Image for Charlotte.s.library.
529 reviews16 followers
February 24, 2026
Oh, it was definitely better than book one. I wish the author would take the time to write a full novel for book 3 instead of a novella. These characters have so much potential and I feel like we should explore that more. It would do them justice to become these 3D characters instead of the 2D version we have now.

Baby Ty showed us another side of him this book, but I feel like all of them did in a way. I STILL love Jake the most and dislike Mark. What almost made me tear up was the vulnerability of Jake when he asked Ty if he wants him there. I guess everyone told him so many times they don't like him... myeah the reason why I was so pissed in book one. I think Jake is in love with Ty and has been from the moment this started, unlike the others.

The dynamic in this book is different than in book one, but welcomed and I liked how it forced them to communicate.

I am exited for book 3 but, as I said, I think it should be longer or not the last in the series.
Profile Image for DarkFayePrincess.
55 reviews5 followers
February 9, 2026
Okay, so I waited a whole MONTH for this one because I pre-ordered straight away!
I absolutely LOVED the first one and this was no different.
It was a pain to wait that long for something so yummie 🤣

Well, I have to say that I liked the first one a bit more but this one was amazing as well. I hope to get a third one as a closing of the series😍

But the boys, omg. They go so well together! I didn't care much for the c*ock-cage, but overall it was darn sexy😈
I liked the fact that we got to know Shawn a bit more here too! The other two often and easily take over and leave him in the shadows.

This one is on the dark taboo side, so be sure to read all the TW's of this one because it's so not for everyone. But are you as crazy as me, then I promise you'll love it😉🖤

❤️ In€est (Brothers & Cousin)
❤️ Free use
❤️ MMMM
❤️ Somno
❤️ Cage & Toys

Spice: 🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Profile Image for Wicked River Reads.
342 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from Goodreads Giveaways
February 3, 2026
I’m already excited for book three and this one hasn’t even been released yet!! I really loved these four together. Each one of them brings something different to their dynamic. Shawn is quiet, observant and methodical, Mark takes on more of a leadership role, Jake is the overly enthusiastic ball of chaos and Ty brings them all together with his sweet yet brattish ways. Is this a book of smutty goodness?! YES! But there are also sweet moments interwoven as they continue to develop and understand their new relationship such as cuddle piles. I would love this to be a 240 page book so we can deep dive a bit more into each character because these novellas are that good! I can’t wait to see what’s next!

🧡ARC REVIEW🖤
Profile Image for Sara Husser.
550 reviews7 followers
February 26, 2026
This was such a fantastic follow-up to Hunting Baby Bro. I like that we get Shawn's POV Ilin this one. The connection and love these four men have for each other is everything! The kink and smut in this one is chef's kiss and so spicy 🔥🔥🔥🔥. Jake will always be my fav out of these men. There is just something about that man that I love. I feel like his relationship with Tyler is something else 🥹🥹. The brothers bond is also fantastic and perfect. I love how needy and clingy Tyler is. He just wants to be claimed and loved. Not just sexually but also in every way. I can't wait for the last installment for these men to get their HEA! Plus I'm hoping that will be in Jake's POV 🥰.
Profile Image for Jkirstyj.
161 reviews1 follower
February 7, 2026
The second book in the series see Ty, mark, Shawn and Jake back at the cabin for thanksgiving, ready to use Ty whenever they want!
Jake is his usual overeager ready to go funny self. Mark is the one in charge and Shawn is the sweet one who just wants to take care of Baby Ty!
Ty loves being their boy to be used but finds he needs more loving.
This story is so hot absolutely love the guys can’t wait for the next book but sad it will be the end.
🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️

What to expect
Taboo (brothers & a cousin)
MMMM
Free use (only between MCs)
Medical play
Somno
🐓cage & toys
Profile Image for Naulee.
115 reviews4 followers
February 6, 2026
5⭐️ 6🌶
If the first novella was hot, the 2nd one is on fire 🔥

Tyler is so freaking precious and needy all at once and he just wants to feel loved still. The little emotional scenes really give me this cozy feeling after all the 🔥❤️‍🔥🔥🌶. I really loved Shawn in this one and that he recognized what Tyler was looking for 🥹.

Once again check your CW: 4x Taboo MMMM brothers/cousin, free use, somno and if thats not your thing move on.
Profile Image for annas.bookcase.
475 reviews10 followers
March 7, 2026
The boys are back in this tabøø MMMM follow up to HBB and while there’s still multi POV I like that while Mark was the big brother focus in the last book this one switches to Shawn. Jake also ends up tugging at my heart strings on this one which I couldn’t have predicted and of course I Tyler always seems to get me emotional. The ending gives me hope that we haven’t seen the last of these boys’ though!
Profile Image for Em G Emtee.
55 reviews
April 18, 2026
Spicy 🌶️ taboo, lake house holiday. The first book was only Mark & Tyler’s POVs, which kinda bothered me bc I like to get in all the MC’s heads. This one has Shawn and Tyler’s POVs, so I’m left to wonder if the next will be Jake & Tyler’s POVs. And maybe if we do share Jake’s POV next, he will actually voice a little more care and concern for Baby Ty that I feel was kind of missing in these first two. Tyler just wants their love, and I want them to actually take him home.
Profile Image for Ebon Embrace.
74 reviews1 follower
February 20, 2026
Yeah, well, there is not so much to say aside from Ally Avery provided the continuation and the smut we didn’t know we needed but definitely did ❤️‍🔥. I really loved seeing the dynamic of these four continue, but also how the emotional component between the males started to develop 🫶, how their life circumstances make them less attentive, and with that, very authentic ✨. And yeah, the smut and tabøø are just next level 🔥🥵😮‍💨🫠. Like, I might need a bigger fan and a box of tissues hot 🔥🧯. I really love the way Ally makes her boys so puppy-like and needy; it’s become absolutely my thing, and I adore these characters 🫠💕.

Summa summarum, this was a very nice k!nky adventure and I loved it ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.

The tropes:
💛 Taboo
💛 Brothers & Cousin

The k!nks:
❤️‍🔥 Cock Cage
❤️‍🔥 Free to Use
❤️‍🔥 Hands Free
❤️‍🔥 Double Penetration
❤️‍🔥 Rimming
❤️‍🔥 Toys
❤️‍🔥 Filming
❤️‍🔥 D/S
❤️‍🔥 Multiple Orgasms
Profile Image for Miruru Shouting.
1,135 reviews2 followers
February 8, 2026
I'm so glad we got a sequel/second novella with our precious four: Tyler, Shawn, Mark, and Jake. Loved everything about it. As always, my only complaint is it's too short. I need 300 more pages please lol
818 reviews3 followers
February 24, 2026
Little bit of a change from book 1 with Tyler's thoughts and attitude. Loved the chemistry they all had still and I also liked that Jake and Shawn got a bit more priority too. Looking forward to the final instalment to see how they make it work.
Profile Image for Rima-Chan.
97 reviews2 followers
March 7, 2026
Second spicy (!!!) MMMM taboo novella about another shared getaway in their cabin.
Basically just spice. A lot of it.
If you like M/M and taboo romance, then this might be something for you. (Read Hunting Baby Bro first)
Profile Image for Michelle Exploringwithchapters.
176 reviews8 followers
March 20, 2026
Taboo brothers and cousin. Book 2. I loved book one because of the praise and tender after care of baby brother Ty.... Good News! Book two matched that same sentiment! Was this dirty? Was this hot? yes. Spicy? Yes. and sweet- unexpectedly sweet! 🫠🫠🫠
Profile Image for Laina Rae.
221 reviews3 followers
February 7, 2026
It might be all smut but I’m lovin’ it. I love how needy Ty is for his brothers/cousin’s love and attention 🩷 I hope they can all end up together in the end and be happy
Profile Image for ender.
50 reviews6 followers
February 23, 2026
i love shawn tbh. he seems so gentle and caring. there is definitely way more feeling in this than the first book. i cannot wait to see what happens with the boys next. ♡
Profile Image for Any Length.
2,266 reviews7 followers
March 14, 2026
seriously hot, well done. Can't wait for the next one.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews