A dark, seductive tale of hunger, love, and transformation from the bestselling author of The Death of Jane Lawrence.
The only thing more terrifying than a brood's hunger . . . is its mother's.
Beatrice is a a vampire responsible for nursing newly made fledglings through the first years of their unlife. She nests in an abandoned, isolated warren of office space beneath her patron's skyscraper, where she raises her fledglings—two difficult, hungry children of the night.
But when she takes on a third, the balance ruptures. Her hunger swells beyond control. Her body alters, betraying its purpose, transforming her into something even more monstrous.
Desperate to master herself once more, Beatrice courts a mortal OBGYN who might be able to unravel the secrets of her unnatural anatomy. But soon their connection threatens the secrecy of her vampiric coven as well as the safety and development of her dependent nurslings… and in a world governed by secrecy, even the smallest revelation could prove fatal.
A Macmillan Audio production from St. Martin’s Press
Caitlin Starling is the nationally bestselling author of The Death of Jane Lawrence, the Bram Stoker-nominated The Luminous Dead, and Last To Leave The Room. Her upcoming novels The Starving Saints and The Graceview Patient epitomize her love of genre-hopping horror; her bibliography spans besieged castles, alien caves, and haunted hospitals. Her short fiction has been published by GrimDark Magazine and Neon Hemlock, and her nonfiction has appeared in Nightmare, Uncanny, and Nightfire. Caitlin also works in narrative design, and has been paid to invent body parts. She’s always on the lookout for new ways to inflict insomnia.
Well, I guess I cancel my plans if becoming a vampire really is that stressful for everyone involved. You see, a simple bite is not enough to turn a mortal into an immortal being in Caitlin Starling's Milkteeth. Instead it's a long-winding process of feeding and being-fed-on that takes a sheer endless amount of blood. A new vampire is ever hungry but can't yet digest human blood or meat. If they do anyway they turn into brainless, violent creatures only driven by their hunger and not into the sophisticated beings of immortality and strength that are desired. It's the task of a broodmother to ensure the correct development of the young nurslings, to keep them safe and fed until they have matured. It's the whole life's purpose of the protagonist Beatrice. She spends her immortality in the dark and labyrinthine basement of an office building, always nursing one or two young vampires at a time. But things change when she decides to take on a third nursling, already half ghoulish by the time they meet for the first time. From that point on Beatrice is concerned about the nutrition of her blood and about how she can change her own body to give more. The depicted parallels between motherhood and vampirism were so intriguing to me and I think it quite the unique approach to a supernatural creature that is part of infinite other stories. There is also a very medical side to the plot. Before it's revealed that Beatrice is a vampire herself, we meet her as a normal young mother at a lactation group asking about physical and hormonal changes during the time of breastfeeding. She also kinda gets obsessed with the doctor who answers her questions and I was all ready for a bit of sapphic love, but this relationship really took turns I didn't expect. Apart from that it's more of a calm story. Yes, it's very bloody and violent, but Beatrice is such a steady character that her voice truly shaped the feeling of the story. Her mind is mostly focused on blood and on her nurslings and I can imagine how other readers would be bored by this, but it really made her character special for me. She was such a no-nonsense person. I really liked to read about her, even if her days were monotonous. I also simply love a protagonist who is unapologetically monstrous. She's killing people? Well, that's just what she does, deal with it. I must admit that I was a little confused near the end and I also must admit that I never read a Caitlin Starling book where I wasn't. Maybe it's just her thing. I can totally see why her books are never really that popular, but by now I know that I will always get something unusual with her books. I'm very excited to read more from her.
Huge thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for providing a digital arc in exchange for an honest review.
::Sigh:: As a reader, you will inevitably come across a book you simply do not enjoy. For me, this is that book.
Milkteeth is due for release on October 20, 2026.
This was 304 pages of a vampire broodmother feeding her fledglings/nurslings. Yup, pretty much it. Sure, there are variations of the feedings, and throw in different situations, emotions, positions, and the like, but that's basically it, the whole book. To be honest, it was torture to try to get through. Don't like the title or the cover art either. Why did I request it then you ask? I love vampire stories. And because I have seen Caitlin Starling books all over Goodreads, I have a few on my TBR. I thought, what a great way to try the author out for the first time. Ugh. I was teetering on one or two stars. I'm feeling gracious tonight, so we'll go with two.
Regardless, I still gotta throw out a Thank You to Caitlin Starling, NetGalley, and St. Martin's Press for gifting me this complimentary copy.
MOTHER. A vessel. The caretaker. A monster. Valued but dispensable. Is this what motherhood is like? The author created a strong and impressive parallel between vampirism and parenthood. This is a novel not to be missed.
Milkteeth is a vampire horror novel that focuses on motherhood, bodily transformation and disturbing relationship between a caretaker and the creatures she raises. In this story, our protagonist Beatrice is a vampire known as a broodmother. She is expected to raise and nurse newly created vampires called fledglings during the first year of their life. She starts off with two and volunteers to take on a third.
Gorgeous: is a fledging who is living in a corpse. He wants his maker to return to him. Fortuna: is a fledging, a daughter of Beatrice's vampire mistress. She is alien and ambitious. The third fledging is quite different than the first two and is between a vampire and a ghoul.
But something strange is growing inside of Beatrice. The breastfeedings make Beatrice act and feel different.
Beatrice begins transforming... she becomes hungry. She starts craving flesh.
What is happening to Beatrice and who is she becoming??
FULL REVIEW TO FOLLOW!
Many thanks to NetGalley, St. Martins Press and the author, Caitlin Starling for an early ARC! Many thanks to Macmillan Audio for an early ALC!
I really enjoyed Caitlin’s writing and storytelling in this, I definitely want to go and read more of her work now! This gothic vampire horror was gritty, gory and unsettling. The parallels the author has drawn between parenting/nurturing and vampirism made for such an interesting read. Definitely vampires in a way I haven’t read them before!
I was lucky enough to receive an ARC for blurbing purposes; here's my blurb:
“In 2026, it may seem impossible for any writer to pen a truly unique vampire tale, but Caitlin Starling manages just that with Milkteeth. With its compelling plot, deft writing, and original premise, this novel will quickly seduce you, but be careful: it has teeth."
Thank you Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for an ALC of Milkteeth by Caitlin Starling
🌟4.5🌟
Mother knows best! or does she? What makes a mother? What makes a monster? Is there an actual list of qualifications? When does selflessness turn to selfishness? Can the two coexist at the same time?..Milkteeth shines light on these questions and so many more!.. Inventing its own category of Jawbreaker Reads instead of an Onion..The layers here really are just endless and all explored in this eerily inky setting.. It slowly drags you in like quicksand making absolutely no apologies.. I loved the author's commitment to the theme.. It feels almost as if there's this palpable constant black cloud of mystery that introduces itself on page one and never takes a vacation...It really helps add to the overall darker ambiance of the book.. I'm really happy I got to read this one during spooky season.. It was PERFECT for it!
I especially loved how the author wove very real struggles and vulnerability that every day mothers go through with a character that's portrayed as a "monster".. Vampire or not, Beatrice's struggles are so raw I wouldn't be surprised if they were triggering for some.. Especially If you're a mom, guardian, or caretaker who has been constantly pouring into the cups of others while yours has been dryer than a camels butt for longer than you can remember..This one is going to hit HARD!
One of my personal favorite aspects was the different dynamic of care she gives to each of those she nurtures.. Just one of the many intertwined similarities this book has with motherhood.. This one for me stuck out a little more because it added multiple relatable points at once...It speaks to the strength and attention of a mother's love but also what an exhausting practice it can be.. And how it can definitely lead to one's cup losing high volumes at a rapid rate..We also get to see how, just like in real life the relationship she has between each child morphs as they get older.. Because also similar to us, our characters have this natural curiosity to see if they can become more than what society always told them they had to be.. Including Beatrice, which was another part as equally nice to see as it was sad.. Additionally, I enjoyed seeing how these curiosities our characters have forced the society around them with their old ideals and ways of living to be challenged by their new ones..
The only minor issue with such mystique is that it can make it a little harder to add depth to other areas.. I do wish there was more to the present day story, but as usual only because I was enjoying myself so much..
But, altogether this was a great read that is as dark as it is deep and reminds us..One thing for certain, two things for sure..The strength a mother has for those she's tending is as universal as it is lethal, and it should never be crossed.
"Surely you have had a sense that love is a load-bearing word that contains within it a whole universe of nuance?”
This will be my fifth book by Caitlin Starling, if you also count her novella. She is by far my favorite horror writer, and still I haven’t found the writing to be getting stale. Other than her decision to make every one of her FMCs a default-lesbian, truly every story is unique. And on that topic: I wish so badly I could pick her brain. Why are they always lesbians? Why are the relationships always toxic, and why is there always a twisted power dynamic? The more of her books I read, the more questions I have.
But on to this book in particular. This book focuses on Beatrice, a broodmother, a wet nurse of sorts to fledgling vampires. The concept introduced in this book of how vampires are made and come to be was one I’ve never seen before, which is always fun. Nothing about the way Beatrice lives is glamorous, and as needed as she is by other vampires, she is also considered beneath them.
This book is such an obvious allegory for the struggles of being a young mother that it almost can’t even be called an allegory. I don’t believe Starling wanted her meaning hidden in any way. It was as if she were saying, “here, this is what we live with, and if you find it disgusting, troubling, sad, painful, then ask yourselves why you can confront it here but not in your everyday lives.” And it is! I will be truthful and say I have never been a mother and never will be. But the complicated wealth of feelings shown in this quite twisted novel jumps out of the pages at you, begs you to understand so forcefully that you simply just have no choice.
Outside of the motherhood aspects, and more to the horror aspects: I have seen in the last 3 of Starling’s novels that she is exploring body horror more and more, and now has had two books with at home surgery gone awry. This is not a book for anyone prone to squeamishness, or ghastly descriptions of the insides of the human body.
The book does have a twist that I predicted nearly immediately, and I was annoyed that it was so obvious. However, when it was deployed it was done in such a way that I was still caught off guard and enjoyed the ending. I still think The Luminous Dead carries the title of my favorite in her bibliography, but I enjoyed this book a lot regardless. I think either you’re a fan of her books or you’re not, they’re very weird, but they continue to be my kind of weird.
Much thanks to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for inviting me to read this book and write a review free from any influence outside my own opinions!
Milkteeth is a sort of perverse temptation - a vampiric and cannibalistic tale wrapped in a maternal guise, making for an unsettling read. This story is stark in its violence, the blood and gore so normalised it’s easy to understand the spiralling of events, for what consequences would deter when you’re already so used to pain?
This is my first foray into Caitlin Starling’s work, and the praise for her writing seems apt. This book held a strange allure that comes with being unable to look away from the horrific. Beatrice’s voice proved one you could sympathise with, her maternal instinct one we naturally deem positive. And yet…how twisted that nature can become. And how readily Caitlin Starling dove into the complicated mess of that contrast.
Admittedly this became a touch repetitive, which I go back and forth on how I feel on this. On the one hand, the mundane, languid routine of the basement was emphasised - on the other, the point was made early on. Still, I found myself wanting to return to the story and see when that routine would break, and what the cause of said breaking would be.
I’m certainly eager to try more of Starling’s work - her ideas seem uniquely jarring and I can feel the pull of that uneasy intrigue calling. Milkteeth, at least, is a fantastically dark read.
Vampires, blood, breastfeeding and a whole lot of grotesque horror. Definitely not the combination I would have come up with, but somehow Caitlin Starling makes it work!
Beatrice is a broodmother, responsible for nursing newly turned vampires until they can survive on their own. She already has two fledglings to care for when a third arrives, pushing her well beyond her limits. What follows is a grim, unsettling exploration of vampirism, motherhood, bodily changes and the sacrifices that come with putting everyone else first.
I loved how different this take on vampires was. The connection between breastfeeding and vampirism is bizarre and clever with plenty of disturbing moments to keep things interesting. And trust me, there is NO shortage of blood or gore here! The writing is beautiful, the atmosphere is grimy and claustrophobic, and I found myself completely caught up in Beatrice's world. The ending didn't quite deliver the impact I was hoping for, but I still couldn't put it down.
Thank you Netgalley and the publishers for the opportunity to review this ARC.
I really wanted to love this one, especially given the promise of vampires mixed with a touch of medicine and the medical world, but unfortunately, the overall execution lacked the allure I was hoping for.
That said, I quite enjoyed the narrator’s performance. The story features rich, atmospheric detail and opens with the main character waking up in the deep basement halls of a deserted office building—knowing only hunger, sensing her nest, and unable to remember her own name.
Our lead, Beatrice, frames the narrative as an origin story addressed directly to 'my love' throughout the book, keeping the recipient's exact identity a mystery until the end. Wanting to better understand her body so she can be a better mother/sire, she turns to a doctor for answers.
“I am a thing of nightmares made flesh, but you say I'm beautiful.”
While the concept and lush imagery had strong potential, the pacing and overall plot didn't completely do it for me. Still worth a look if you're drawn to atmospheric, non-traditional vampire tales!
Milkteeth is a unique, bizarre, unsettling and original take on vampires. It involves a "broodmother" named Beatrice who is responsible for nursing newly made vampires (fledglings) for the first years of their lives. When she forms a mortal OBGYN, she is dancing with danger and other vampires begin to feel "concerned". This is a highly imaginative book that contains beautiful writing, vivid descriptions, and horrific scenes.
There is a lot and I mean a lot of talk about feeding the fledglings and positions to feed, the hunger, the blood, the effects on Beatrice, and the connection Beatrice had to her fledglings. I found this section to be a slog and I wanted the book to hurry up and get along with it. This became a bit of a slow burn and I am not a fan of slow burns. They are a painful struggle for me.
What did work was the writing, the descriptions, and the premise of mothering young vampires. I give the author high props for a very original book. It is disturbing on many levels such as the comparison of breast feeding and feeding newly made vampires. It also sinks it's teeth into motherhood, dependence, and the transformation the body goes through!
Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Dear gawd, this story was extremely brutal but in an elegant way. Starling’s writing is so exquisite that it was delivered so well. Still terrifying though.
This is a vampire novel that is really original and I loved that. Trying to explain the premise is hard so I am just going to give you a little breadcrumb.
Beatrice is a vampire who is a “brood mother” who can only be the one to feed new vampires for the first few years of their lives. If they consume mortal blood, it could kill them. It is up to her to hunt and then go back to her lair and feed her brood.
I started reading with the arc and then halfway through, I was approved for the ALC and switched over. The narrator‘s voice was so comforting even during the vicious parts. She did an excellent job.
Let me be clear, this is one of the most brutal books I’ve read this year. It’s ferocious and unrelenting and I absolutely devoured it.
4.5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Out 10/20
Thank you to SMP, Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the gifted copies.
I received this book as an ARC from NetGalley. Thank you to all involved.
I rated this book 4/5 stars ⭐️
Things I liked about this book: 🩸 I love a vampire book and this was a fresh take on it that brought it into the modern world. 🩸this was soooo atmospheric- like underground ,”back room”, dark,filthy, down to the blood soaked carpet. It was so easy to to visualize and so creepy. I loved it. 🩸 The characters- while not necessarily “likeable “ were still interesting and I liked them. 🩸The new (at least to me) vampire lore in the book was cool and easy to follow
This book was fun. I feel at parts it could get a little repetitive but I still was excited to read it. I would recommend it if you’re looking for a modern (or any) vampire tale!
this was my first from Caitlin Starling & i often hear her associated with "weird girl" fiction/horror. while i am one to like the dark, disturbing, & weird, Milkteeth left much to be desired.
on one hand i feel like maybe reading this straight after Coffin Moon was a bit of a disservice, i might have immediately set Milkteeth up to be a bit disappointing in comparison, on the other i was not the biggest fan of the writing style so i'm not convinced that it would have made much of a difference anyway.
in theory i like the different themes woven together throughout the story...womanhood, motherhood, vampirism, some obsession & the gore was done well but the execution was lacking for me. part of it is i like to be able to visualize when i read...visualize people, places or just the overall events taking place. it's not a necessity BUT it does take my reading experiences to the next level, it helps me connect more to the story & the characters, helps me engage more etc. i was not able to visualize MOST of Milkteeth, which resulted in me forgetting chunks of the story, often having to reread sentences & ultimately being bored outside of the gory bits.
the characters all felt distinct but i just didn't connect to any of them enough to care about anyone. i also felt like some of this was repetitive. but maybe i'm just dramatic
i can see why some might enjoy Milkteeth & i can appreciate what the author was trying to do with putting a twist on the lore of vampirism by intertwining it with motherhood, but this has also been done before maybe not exactly the same but still to a degree, so to me there's nothing exciting or new enough happening for this to standout amongst other vampirism books i've read(or even movies i've seen).
Thank you to NetGalley & the publisher for this arc in exchange for an honest review
This is such an unusual and unique spin on vampirism.
Beatrice is a brood mother that takes in newly turned vampires and nurses them until they are ready to go out on their own. She currently cares for two fledglings but when a third is brought to her she worries she won't be able to sustain all three. She decides to attend a lactation class to learn more about the process. Surely breastfeeding a baby is no more different than that of feeding a fledgling. There she meets an OBGYN, Dr. Bajracharya, and the two instantly connect and begin a relationship of sorts. Dr. Bajracharya senses there is something unusual with her latest patient and her curiosity will either lead to her salvation or destruction.
I found Beatrice absolutely fascinating and I loved that she embraced the monster within herself.
Starling's writing is exquisite. She can describe scenes of brutality and horror in the most eloquent of ways. This is a woman that was born to write.
However....
Uniqueness and excellent writing aside, this book lacks any kind of urgency. The plot stagnates. Most of the book is just Beatrice feeding her fledglings in different ways and in different positions. I'll admit that from 50% - 80% this book crawled at such a slow pace I even considered setting it aside. I prefer my vampire novels to be more action forward where you're on the edge of your seat in anticipation.
In the end I am glad I stuck with this because the finale was well done and satisfying.
If the slow pace doesn't scare you off then you'll find plenty to sink your teeth into here. 3 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for my complimentary copy.
In MILKTEETH, Caitlin Starling has come up with a fascinating take on vampire mythology where newborn vampires are essentially in a painful state of transition after they are made. Deformed and helpless, they must feed from a vampire-- known as a broodmother-- before they can manage to hunt and feed on human blood. Beatrice, our narrator, is the broodmother of two vampires, soon to be three, but with the third, she starts to behave more erratically, and take more risks. What starts as motherhood-made-monstrous turns into a slow descent of madness that can only be sated by blood.
This story is relatively short but packs a mean punch. I loved the inevitability of the narration, the depression (is this an allegory for post-partum depression and the lack of support given to new mothers? I did wonder), and the toxic sapphic love story that feels a lot like Frankenstein and his monster, especially with all the anatomical and philosophical elements. I also really loved Beatrice's brood, Gorgeous, Fortunata, and Lu, and how they all had distinct personalities.
If you enjoy queer gothic horror and were an especially big fan of Guillermo del Toro's take on Frankenstein, I think you'll love MILKTEETH. Violence-wise, I will say that this was on the cliff-sharp edge of what I personally can tolerate, and there are big triggers for blood, viscera, and body/medical horror, but it's woven into the story in such a way that it felt more poetic than done for shock-value, which made it easier to stomach. This felt like one of those old vampire stories from the 70s and 80s, when vampires were dangerous and kind of mean, and I loved that.
4.5 stars! (Update: even weeks later I’m still thinking about this one)
The concept of this book is fascinating, and it completely lived up to my expectations. This story is absolutely worth your time, and after I finished it… I couldn’t stop thinking about it. Milkteeth is the perfect amount of unsettling, and thought provoking.
The author did a great job setting up our main character because I really imagined myself in her position. So when all of the changes started to happen to her — the connection made it feel like the mysterious changes were happening to me. And I could really feel her thirst/ hunger and need
The level of detail was perfect for being able to see the settings and character interactions. For example the carpet and the basement setting. But at the same time I struggled to picture the ages for most of the brood (I’m unsure it that’s because I missed a detail, or if it’s supposed to be ambiguous)
This is the first time I’ve really enjoyed something that was written like a letter or a story being told specifically to me (second person-ish) and also the first story with body horror that felt like it was happening to me.
This would be an amazing book club book, because I REALLY want to discuss it
Thank you to the author and publisher for the ARC through NetGalley
A vampire motherhood story that asks: will this postpartum be survivable?
Premise: Beatrice is a vampire broodmother, responsible for nursing new vampires through their first few years after turning. After she takes a third new charge, her body changes and her own hunger swells monstrously. Desperate to regain control, she consults a human Obgyn for help, but this threatens the secrecy her kind depend on, with potentially fatal results.
This felt like NIGHTBITCH x BURY OUR BONES IN THE MIDNIGHT SOIL, which is so fun. I loved the atmosphere and the way the characters were painted. Gorgeous was the most compelling character to me and his arc broke my heart (in a very hopeful, real-love-beats-limerence way). The pacing didn't always work for me, but overall I quite enjoyed this and think fans of Starling's earlier works, especially THE STARVING SAINTS, should absolutely check it out.
I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Stevi Incremona. She's a new-to-me narrator and did a great job both with general narration and dialogue. I enjoyed!
Thanks, NetGalley and Macmillan Audio, for the audio ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for providing an E-ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This was literally just a book about a vampire Broodmother and her experiences rearing them. There is a lot of body horror throughout which makes sense with vampires and their different feelings. However, this was immensely boring. I could not wait for this to be over with. It really could have been a short story. I do not think Caitlin Starling is an author for me as I've tried a couple of other books from her and either DNF'd or gave a low rating. I will try The Luminous Dead as I own it and want to like something from her. However, this is a pass.
when i first started the book i was a little wary because aren’t all vampire stories kind of done to death at this point? but no. caitlin starling made such an interesting and intriguing take on the whole topic that i was instantly sucked into the story. this is truly unlike everything i’ve ever read before (and i’ve read my fair share of vampire stories ever since twilight haha). it had just the right amount of plot, gore, and body horror for me, and it felt really well balanced overall. i also loved the emotional beats throughout the story and the way you could somehow always connect to our narrator. the parallels between vampires and motherhood were also extremely well done and really thought-provoking. it was my first of her novels but definitely not the last, and the characters and story will stay with me for a while. my only critique is that the pacing felt a little off at times and the middle dragged a little.
I cannot explain how viscerally I loved this book. Strange, chilling and just so fucking captivating, i had to drag it out so slowly to get every last drop of pleasure from the story. I am a massive fan of Caitlin Starling and how she writes, it's truly so compelling. The characters are just so FUCKED!! The whole story is FUCKED!
I cannot express how obsessed I am with this book. To write such a strange and truly truly unique take on vampires in the year of our dark lord 2026...i am in AWE. This truly was just deliciously gory and certainly has teeth!! I've never ever seen anything like this and I'd be hard pressed to find something to capture pure female rage, motherhood and the vampire ethos how this did...wow!
🩸 Vampirism + Motherhood 🦷 Female Agency 🩸 Body Horror 🦷 Sapphic Undertones 🩸 Monstrous Women
Honestly, this is one of the weirdest books I've ever read (complimentary), and it's not even my first Caitlin Starling. I love the concept of parasitic motherhood: the almost feral nature of mothering and providing sustenance to an entire human. I feel like, as a mother, this book really freaking goes there—but you don't have to be interested in parenthood to appreciate the caretaking metaphors.
•
Beatrice is a broodmother; she provides sustenance to newly turned vampires (fledglings) as they gain maturity in their unalived state. She has a special bond with each one of her charges and does the impossible by taking on a third charge. However, she soon finds that three is a crowd, and she undergoes extreme changes due to insatiability—causing her monstrous nature to shift and grow.
•
If it sounds weird, that's because it is, in fact, weird. It's a trip. As a mother myself, I found a lot of the parallels Starling draws in this story between nursing fledglings via blood and raising biological children to be sharp-witted. It's not pretty. Beatrice has to grapple with the loss of autonomy and the simultaneous urge to do the absolute best for her charges, while raising them in squalor. The story opens with her attending a breastfeeding group in hopes of understanding more about her own role, alongside memories of a previous life in which she, in fact, mothered a biological child.
It's a very odd, unique, and kind of bonkers concept. There's a lot of visceral gore, and the horror kind of stems from Beatrice being trapped in this role while still wanting to do the best for her charges, who are learning to interpret and interact with the world in a new way. She is basically monitored by a governing authority of vampires, who refuse to provide her with all that she requires while simultaneously expecting her to fulfil her role perfectly—again, with the motherhood metaphors.
I listened to the audiobook, and Stevi Incremona does a fantastic job of capturing all of Beatrice's vulnerability, emotions, and rage.
Honestly, this one will stick with me for a long time. I felt a lot of empathy for Beatrice's situation, and this character-driven story is poignant and clever in its delivery.
•
Thank you to St. Martin's Press for the ARC of this book, and thank you to Macmillan Audio for the ALC. All thoughts and feedback contained within this review are my own.
I never thought about how vampirism could become an allegory for motherhood, and this book is committed to every gory and disturbing detail about it. holy mama
I’m not usually a big vampire girly, but Caitlin Starling nailed it and the narrator was absolutely DIVINE😍 This was such an intriguing and unique vampiric story and I lowkey LOVED the breastfeeding aspect of it 👀 This was also my first book by Starling and I just cannot believe I haven’t read something by her before! I’m OBSESSED with her writing style because it genuinely had me hooked IMMEDIATELY. This book felt like I was reading a classic and felt somewhat poetic in a sense and I loved the little sprinkle of sapphic infatuation that Beatrice was feeling towards Bajracharya. What would come of them was a mystery through the whole story but kept me FULLY invested!
Lastly, I would like to give a HUGE thank you to St. Martins Press and NetGalley for my copies of Milkteeth!
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected pub date: Nov. 10, 2026
Genre: Horror
Synopsis: Beatrice is a broodmother: a vampire responsible for nursing newly made fledglings through the first years of their unlife. She nests in an abandoned, isolated warren of office space beneath her patron's skyscraper, where she raises her fledglings—two difficult, hungry children of the night.But when she takes on a third, the balance ruptures. Desperate to master herself once more, Beatrice courts a mortal OBGYN who might be able to unravel the secrets of her unnatural anatomy. But soon their connection threatens the secrecy of her vampiric coven as well as the safety and development of her dependent nurslings… and in a world governed by secrecy, even the smallest revelation could prove fatal.
Overall: "Milkteeth" gave me Anne Rice vibes right from the start, with its terrifyingly detailed depictions of life as a vampire, told from the broodmother's point of view. Starling's novel is dark, gritty and immersive, detailing the power of a mother's love- even if she's an immortal one. The language is beautiful and gripping and Beatrice is a badass, but the plotline stagnated in parts. Beatrice's relationship with her "children" was detailed throughout most of the story, but the action didn't come until the final chapters although the ending itself definitely made up for the slow pace throughout. "Milkteeth" is ideal for true vampire fans- the gory, vicious kind of vampires- and is definitely an unsettling, spooky season read.
(ARC) 4.5⭐️ ummmm wow? This was as if Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil and A Dowry of Blood had a baby. I seriously enjoyed this. If you like your vampire books a little more serious and true to vampire lore…add this to your TBR immediately. It was creepy, gory, emotional and unsettling. “You’re gonna suffer, but you’re going to be happy about it.” Signing off. Read this.
one of the most unique takes on a vampire story that i’ve read in a while, so refreshing. it felt very much like “interview with a vampire” meets “mommie dearest”, but honestly, i was here for it. at times, it felt very repetitive with the events that were unfolding but then something major would happen and i would be swiftly pulled out of the monotony. not sure how i feel about the ending, wish it was longer and expanded more on certain things but overall, i enjoyed the read.
I received this e-arc from NetGalley in exchange for a fair review.
One of the most unique and fresh takes on vampires I have read in a long time, Milkteeth is a horrific delight.
If you’re at all squeamish, you will want to avoid this one, as it’s full of blood, medical horror, body horror, and cannibalism (kind of). It’s perfect for Halloween!
Unlike the other four Starling books I’ve read - Luminous Dead, Death of Jane Lawrence, Graceview Patient, and Last to Leave the Room - this book does not feature a descent into madness (I was sort of waiting for it, to be honest, and it was a refreshing break in the trend), though it does feature a character stuck in the same place for a long time (and somehow that does not become boring! To understand what I mean, I found Luminous Dead and Graceview Patient both went on a bit long in that front, though Last to Leave the Room is spectacular). What Milkteeth also shares with these others is a unique concept that is super engrossing and does not go where you expect.
Beatrice is a fascinating character. She’s a vampire, as you know from the blurb, but one with a very specific purpose, and she’s essentially a wet nurse - but one who is not supposed to leave the dingy, gross, basement lair where she lives with her charges. She is trapped there, though she’s been sneaking out for a long time.
The living quarters were so disgusting. There are so many descriptions of the filth and the stains - this added to the squeamishness of the story itself, and the overall tone.
What’s also interesting is the deliberate pairing of Beatice’s situation with motherhood. I actually enjoyed breastfeeding my kids, but I know many women who found breastfeeding super challenging, either due to too much supply or not enough, or just because it didn’t work for them. In this way, breastfeeding for them must have felt much like Beatrice in feeding her vampire brood - draining and exhausting.
It also shows the way motherhood - even when you love your baby to bits - can sometimes feel like a trap or that you’re abandoned (again, I was lucky and didn’t experience that, but I know a lot of mothers who did suffer that way in some aspects). I’m not pulling this out of thin air - the fact that a baby is included in the initial scenes of the book felt like this was a deliberate allegory.
That aside, the story was so interesting despite there not being a distinct “plot” (in the sense that Beatrice isn’t trying to escape, for example). We’re rooting for Beatrice, as she’s such an engaging character, but we’re also learning about the way her body works. In fact, that is her main goal: to find a doctor to help her explain WHY she’s able to be a broodmother (only a small percentage of vampires can do this) and how she’s “alive” when she doesn’t eat normal food, et cetera. I found this vastly interesting, myself. That part was very, very fun, as well as when her body starts to undergo a transformation.
The action and horror scenes we get are wonderfully gory and creepy, and the side characters - Lu, Fortunata, Gorgeous - are endearing and, despite sleeping a lot of the time (at least until the last third), have distinct personalities that help drive the plot.
Overall, I really enjoyed this novel, and it shows why I keep going back to Starling’s work!