What do you think?
Rate this book
Eyes of the Unholy a Mafia Romance
In this enemies to lovers mafia romance, a ruthless Irish syndicate enforcer kidnaps a nun who happens to be the mayor’s daughter—only to discover she’s the key to exposing a global human trafficking empire.
God never answered Scarlett’s prayers—so I did.
Lucian
God forgive me for what I’m about to do to the girl praying inside that church.
She’s not just a nun.
She’s the mayor’s daughter—leverage in a cartel war.
A saint.
A symbol.
Easy prey.
But who knew a girl with the face of an angel could be such a demon?
She should have been disposable.
Instead, she became my obsession.
Now everyone who hurt her will answer to me.
Scarlett
Everyone thinks I’m pure.
The quiet little nun on her knees, whispering prayers.
They’re wrong.
I’m far too dirty for salvation.
So when a mafia enforcer drags me from a church on Christmas night, I expect what I’ve learned to survive—brutality.
It should have been the worst moment of my life.
Instead, he handles me as if I’m something precious.
And that terrifies me more than the kidnapping ever could.
Because he kills without remorse, sees everything I try to hide, and when he looks at me, it’s not hunger—it’s something far more dangerous.
The deeper I fall into his world, the uglier the truth becomes.
This isn’t about one city.
Or one cartel.
Or one broken girl.
It’s about presidents, princes, and men rich enough to believe they’re untouchable.
But when he vows to burn the world to keep me alive, can I survive what loving him will cost me?
Eyes of the Unholy is the second installment in the Sin Syndicate mafia romance series, where forced proximity, enemies to lovers tension, and vigilante justice collide as powerful men wage war on the billionaire class profiting from human trafficking.
Can be read as a standalone.
Dual POV • No cliffhanger • HEA guaranteed.
What you can expect from Eyes of the Unholy:
Enemies to Lovers
Forced Proximity
He Would Burn the World for Her
Touch Her and Die
He Falls First
Dangerous Protector
Vigilante Justice
Morally Gray Antihero
Scarred FMC
He Brushes Her Hair
God never answered Scarlett’s prayers—so I did.
Lucian
God forgive me for what I’m about to do to the girl praying inside that church.
She’s not just a nun.
She’s the mayor’s daughter—leverage in a cartel war.
A saint.
A symbol.
Easy prey.
But who knew a girl with the face of an angel could be such a demon?
She should have been disposable.
Instead, she became my obsession.
Now everyone who hurt her will answer to me.
Scarlett
Everyone thinks I’m pure.
The quiet little nun on her knees, whispering prayers.
They’re wrong.
I’m far too dirty for salvation.
So when a mafia enforcer drags me from a church on Christmas night, I expect what I’ve learned to survive—brutality.
It should have been the worst moment of my life.
Instead, he handles me as if I’m something precious.
And that terrifies me more than the kidnapping ever could.
Because he kills without remorse, sees everything I try to hide, and when he looks at me, it’s not hunger—it’s something far more dangerous.
The deeper I fall into his world, the uglier the truth becomes.
This isn’t about one city.
Or one cartel.
Or one broken girl.
It’s about presidents, princes, and men rich enough to believe they’re untouchable.
But when he vows to burn the world to keep me alive, can I survive what loving him will cost me?
Eyes of the Unholy is the second installment in the Sin Syndicate mafia romance series, where forced proximity, enemies to lovers tension, and vigilante justice collide as powerful men wage war on the billionaire class profiting from human trafficking.
Can be read as a standalone.
Dual POV • No cliffhanger • HEA guaranteed.
What you can expect from Eyes of the Unholy:
Enemies to Lovers
Forced Proximity
He Would Burn the World for Her
Touch Her and Die
He Falls First
Dangerous Protector
Vigilante Justice
Morally Gray Antihero
Scarred FMC
He Brushes Her Hair
450 pages, ebook
First published February 25, 2026
110 people are currently reading
322 people want to read
About the author
Evie James
6 books198 followersEvie James writes dark contemporary romance filled with morally gray men, obsessive love, high-stakes danger, and heroines strong enough to survive it all. From mafia worlds built on violence and loyalty to medical romances with deadly underworld ties, her books blend angst, heat, emotional devastation, and hard-won happily-ever-afters.
She writes strong, sassy heroines who know exactly how to push every button on a man and possessive alphas who would burn the world down for their woman.
Connect with her on Instagram (@evie.james.author), Facebook (@evie.james.author) and on TikTok (@evie_james_author).
Find all of her books and sign up for her newsletter on her website: EvieJames.com
A true romantic and animal lover, she’s a Cancer sign to a fault—deeply emotional, fiercely loyal, and guided by intuition. She channels those traits into stories filled with passion, vulnerability, and characters readers can’t forget.
When not writing, she can be found baking, doting on her four dogs, or dreaming up her next emotionally reckless couple.
She'd love for you to read her books!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 135 reviews
Did Not Finish
March 20, 2026Clearly this book is part of a series and I think reading the other books would have helped; but glad I didn’t because apparently there is a 3some with our current MMC in another book (wonderful!!!) and the guy is still smitten with the lady or at least still see her in a friendly way (double wonderful)
I loved the meeting between the MCs I mean fighting in a church was hot.
I found the book was a bit dragging. They met around 6% into the book and the next scene with the two of them is well after 30%… and nothing much happened in between.
But where I couldn’t go on with this book is basically the scene at the s3x club… why would I want to read pages and pages about a character that popped out of nowhere being DP???
So yes if voyeurism and slow burn are your cup of tea give this one a go
I loved the meeting between the MCs I mean fighting in a church was hot.
I found the book was a bit dragging. They met around 6% into the book and the next scene with the two of them is well after 30%… and nothing much happened in between.
But where I couldn’t go on with this book is basically the scene at the s3x club… why would I want to read pages and pages about a character that popped out of nowhere being DP???
So yes if voyeurism and slow burn are your cup of tea give this one a go
February 25, 2026
This book had me in a chokehold! Scarlett was so sweet and strong after everything she had been through. Lucian has my whole heart, he fell hard and fast and worked so hard to make sure Scar knew she could trust and believe in him. I loved everything about this book.. the plot, the characters, the spice, it was all woven together seamlessly and made for such a perfect read!
May 1, 2026
That first encounter between Lucian and Scarlett was amazing and it’ll probably be the scene I forever associate with this book. Unfortunately after that first encounter they didn’t meet again for a while. This made the pacing way too fast for my liking once they did meet again. I felt like I didn’t get to see Lucien and Scarlett’s relationship fully evolve. I would have liked to see a little more development in their relationship outside of the physical aspects especially before they fast tracked into getting married. That being said I think this was still a great time and I enjoyed the writing. I’ll probably check out Evie James other books because this was a fun read.
February 25, 2026
This dark mafia romance was everything! I devoured it! It had everything you would want: love, romance, spice, violence, suspense, chemistry, banter, and awesome MCs.
Lucian was so great; he’s added to my list as one of my favourite book boyfriends. He may have started off with ill intentions, but is redeemed almost instantly with lust at first sight when meeting Scarlett. These two have an explosive first meeting that was epic! Their fight was full of sexual tension and great banter that continued throughout the book. As much as Lucian comes off as some mafia bad guy, underneath that persona he is a loveable, adorable, caring man who would burn the world down for Scarlett. He is patient with her and understanding, and I loved the kindness he showed.
My heart broke for Scarlett. She had such a traumatic past, trying to survive and also hope for a better future. I’m so glad she found that happiness, and it was great to see her learn what she is capable of and embrace her sexuality. I loved Lucian and Scarlett, and when they finally came together it was explosive. I’m also glad they stuck together — no third-act breakup, no conflict. They chose each other, and they were epic.
There were some questions that still needed answering, and I can’t wait for more books in the series to find the answers. Bring on more mafia romance!
Tropes:
🌹 Forced Proximity
🔥 He Would Burn the World for Her
🖤 “Touch Her and Die”
💘 He Falls First
🛡️ Dangerous Protector
⚖️ Vigilante Justice
🌶️ High Heat
🖤 Morally Gray MMC
💔 Scarred FMC
🔫 Dark Mafia Romance
🔎 Romantic Suspense
Spice Rating: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Lucian was so great; he’s added to my list as one of my favourite book boyfriends. He may have started off with ill intentions, but is redeemed almost instantly with lust at first sight when meeting Scarlett. These two have an explosive first meeting that was epic! Their fight was full of sexual tension and great banter that continued throughout the book. As much as Lucian comes off as some mafia bad guy, underneath that persona he is a loveable, adorable, caring man who would burn the world down for Scarlett. He is patient with her and understanding, and I loved the kindness he showed.
My heart broke for Scarlett. She had such a traumatic past, trying to survive and also hope for a better future. I’m so glad she found that happiness, and it was great to see her learn what she is capable of and embrace her sexuality. I loved Lucian and Scarlett, and when they finally came together it was explosive. I’m also glad they stuck together — no third-act breakup, no conflict. They chose each other, and they were epic.
There were some questions that still needed answering, and I can’t wait for more books in the series to find the answers. Bring on more mafia romance!
Tropes:
🌹 Forced Proximity
🔥 He Would Burn the World for Her
🖤 “Touch Her and Die”
💘 He Falls First
🛡️ Dangerous Protector
⚖️ Vigilante Justice
🌶️ High Heat
🖤 Morally Gray MMC
💔 Scarred FMC
🔫 Dark Mafia Romance
🔎 Romantic Suspense
Spice Rating: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
February 25, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Forced Proximity, Fierce Love, and Vigilante Justice what more could you want!
I went into Eyes of the Unholy expecting a steamy mafia romance, but what I got was so much more.
Yes, it has the classic enemies to lovers tension and that delicious forced proximity dynamic where two strong personalities are stuck in the same space and sparks absolutely fly. But this book is layered with emotion and purpose. Scarlett’s journey from silence and survival to strength and agency felt raw and honest. Her trauma isn’t used as shock value—it’s part of her arc, and watching her reclaim herself was powerful.
Lucian is everything you want in a dark hero: intense, controlled, morally gray—but not mindless. The vigilante justice element gives the story real substance. This isn’t just a couple hooking up in a luxury penthouse. There’s a full plot involving political corruption, money laundering, and a sinister monastery network. The stakes feel real, and the consequences matter.
What surprised me most was the emotional honesty. The conversations about trust, therapy, family, and choice grounded the romance in something believable. The love story builds from suspicion and anger into something protective and enduring.
If you’re looking for a mafia romance that balances heat with a full emotional arc, real character growth, and a satisfying resolution that feels earned, this one absolutely delivers.
I went into Eyes of the Unholy expecting a steamy mafia romance, but what I got was so much more.
Yes, it has the classic enemies to lovers tension and that delicious forced proximity dynamic where two strong personalities are stuck in the same space and sparks absolutely fly. But this book is layered with emotion and purpose. Scarlett’s journey from silence and survival to strength and agency felt raw and honest. Her trauma isn’t used as shock value—it’s part of her arc, and watching her reclaim herself was powerful.
Lucian is everything you want in a dark hero: intense, controlled, morally gray—but not mindless. The vigilante justice element gives the story real substance. This isn’t just a couple hooking up in a luxury penthouse. There’s a full plot involving political corruption, money laundering, and a sinister monastery network. The stakes feel real, and the consequences matter.
What surprised me most was the emotional honesty. The conversations about trust, therapy, family, and choice grounded the romance in something believable. The love story builds from suspicion and anger into something protective and enduring.
If you’re looking for a mafia romance that balances heat with a full emotional arc, real character growth, and a satisfying resolution that feels earned, this one absolutely delivers.
April 16, 2026
What you'll get:
🔥 He Falls First
❤️🩹 Scarred FMC
🖤 Morally Grey MMC
🔫 Dark Mafia Romance
😳 Romantic Suspense
This book is packed with some funny banter, violence, suspense, and plenty of spice to go around.
Scarlet has a tragic past and is trying to make her life better and get away from her father. She slowly opens up throughout the story.
Lucian comes off as the bad boy mafia dude with Irish ties. He is a shoot first and ask questions later type of dude. His love is amazing and nothing else compares.
Quotes:
"Don't worry my little bird. I'll keep you safe. I'll mend that wing. I'll protect you and care for you until your last breath -- even if that means I have to let you fly away from me."
"I love you, I'd learned, was easy to say. It was the showing up that mattered. Doing the hard thing when it would be easier to walk away. Words were cheap. Actions were the only thing that meant anything at all."
🔥 He Falls First
❤️🩹 Scarred FMC
🖤 Morally Grey MMC
🔫 Dark Mafia Romance
😳 Romantic Suspense
This book is packed with some funny banter, violence, suspense, and plenty of spice to go around.
Scarlet has a tragic past and is trying to make her life better and get away from her father. She slowly opens up throughout the story.
Lucian comes off as the bad boy mafia dude with Irish ties. He is a shoot first and ask questions later type of dude. His love is amazing and nothing else compares.
Quotes:
"Don't worry my little bird. I'll keep you safe. I'll mend that wing. I'll protect you and care for you until your last breath -- even if that means I have to let you fly away from me."
"I love you, I'd learned, was easy to say. It was the showing up that mattered. Doing the hard thing when it would be easier to walk away. Words were cheap. Actions were the only thing that meant anything at all."
February 21, 2026
Welcome back to the Sin Syndicate. Now it’s time for Lucian’s story! As we have previously met him in Evie’s other books (Eyes on You) Nikolai’s story and The Broken Heroes Trilogy (book 2) Conan’s story. We are thrown back into it. When Lucian has a plan to kidnap the daughter of the mayor of NYC after they went after Lacey, everything hits the fan. Scarlett is not what he was expecting. Hearing that she is a nun and seeing her in person were two different things. She is a fireball of energy. And he soon finds out why.
This story is fast paced, has high heat, and vigilante justice. Lucian will do everything in his power to help protect her. Scarlett soon learns what all that entails. What happens when she finds out the real truth behind her past? Lucian and Scarlett’s story will have you on the edge of your seat. I can’t wait for this series to continue!
Check your trigger warnings.
This story is fast paced, has high heat, and vigilante justice. Lucian will do everything in his power to help protect her. Scarlett soon learns what all that entails. What happens when she finds out the real truth behind her past? Lucian and Scarlett’s story will have you on the edge of your seat. I can’t wait for this series to continue!
Check your trigger warnings.
February 25, 2026
ARC REVIEW
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice:🌶️🌶️🌶️
Evie James you have did it again im so proud of you with the second book it’s a whole masterpiece I appreciate you giving me the opportunity to be on your team and giving me a chance to read your book.
When I tell your the Dark forced Proximity was on point I could even put this book down I was having a whole conversation with my sister while reading it as soon as I got it I had finished within two hours all the tropes was on point the character development had me wanting this book physically. I absolutely love Scarlett she gave the best girl boss energy I have ever seen I still feel bad what happened to her mom but I know her mom would be proud of her. Now for her lame father I would throw this man off the closet Bridge he made me mad at the very beginning like I would drop kick this man off the earth he had to go. Lastly my husband Lucian his chemistry from the very beginning had me hooked I was giggling then had moment want to hit him but he was perfect I can’t wait for more characters like him in the future he was chefs kiss. Happy Release Day.
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice:🌶️🌶️🌶️
Evie James you have did it again im so proud of you with the second book it’s a whole masterpiece I appreciate you giving me the opportunity to be on your team and giving me a chance to read your book.
When I tell your the Dark forced Proximity was on point I could even put this book down I was having a whole conversation with my sister while reading it as soon as I got it I had finished within two hours all the tropes was on point the character development had me wanting this book physically. I absolutely love Scarlett she gave the best girl boss energy I have ever seen I still feel bad what happened to her mom but I know her mom would be proud of her. Now for her lame father I would throw this man off the closet Bridge he made me mad at the very beginning like I would drop kick this man off the earth he had to go. Lastly my husband Lucian his chemistry from the very beginning had me hooked I was giggling then had moment want to hit him but he was perfect I can’t wait for more characters like him in the future he was chefs kiss. Happy Release Day.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Dark. Devoted. Ruthless.
Eyes of the Unholy is the second installment in the Sin Syndicate Series by Evie James, and it absolutely delivers.
If you love mafia romance with an actual plot, emotional depth, and characters that crawl under your skin in the best way, this one belongs on your TBR.
Lucian is the kind of morally gray hero who doesn’t just claim his woman, he reveres her. His devotion is intense, possessive, and unwavering, but it never overshadows Scarlett’s strength.
And Scarlett? She is everything. She’s survived trauma that could have shattered her, yet she rises from it stronger, sharper, and completely unbreakable. Watching her reclaim her power had me fully invested.
The chemistry is electric. The stakes are high. The emotions hit hard.
I genuinely couldn’t decide who I loved more, so honestly, I’ll take them both.
If you’re a mafia romance reader who wants grit, heat, and heart all wrapped into one, this book will not disappoint.
Eyes of the Unholy is the second installment in the Sin Syndicate Series by Evie James, and it absolutely delivers.
If you love mafia romance with an actual plot, emotional depth, and characters that crawl under your skin in the best way, this one belongs on your TBR.
Lucian is the kind of morally gray hero who doesn’t just claim his woman, he reveres her. His devotion is intense, possessive, and unwavering, but it never overshadows Scarlett’s strength.
And Scarlett? She is everything. She’s survived trauma that could have shattered her, yet she rises from it stronger, sharper, and completely unbreakable. Watching her reclaim her power had me fully invested.
The chemistry is electric. The stakes are high. The emotions hit hard.
I genuinely couldn’t decide who I loved more, so honestly, I’ll take them both.
If you’re a mafia romance reader who wants grit, heat, and heart all wrapped into one, this book will not disappoint.
March 9, 2026
I am beyond excited to review Eyes of the Unholy by Evie James! This is one of those stories that digs its claws into you and refuses to let go. I inhaled the over half of the book this weekend.
Eyes of the Unholy by Evie James is the kind of dark romance that pulls you in slowly and then refuses to let you go. The deeper this story goes into the Sin Syndicate world, the more intense and layered everything becomes and I’m honestly loving where it’s heading.
Scarlett’s journey is heartbreaking but powerful. She’s been conditioned to see herself as disposable, yet beneath all that pain is this fierce resilience that refuses to die. Watching her slowly reclaim pieces of herself while navigating such a brutal world made her incredibly easy to root for. And Lucian… he’s the perfect kind of morally gray protector. Ruthless when it comes to the people who hurt her, but unexpectedly gentle with Scarlett in a way that feels deeply earned.
The chemistry between them is electric. The spice is definitely there, bold, emotional, and charged with tension, but what stood out most to me is how much it’s tied to trust and vulnerability. Every intimate moment feels like another layer of Scarlett learning that she deserves to be wanted, protected, and seen. That “burn the world to keep her safe” devotion hit me right in the chest. And the sexy scenes were perfect! I have to say they are my favorite couple. And knowing Evie, I'm sure it's not the last time we see them.
What's great about Evie's books is that they can all be read as a standalone, but together they build something even bigger and more intense. And I have to say, book two is my favorite so far. Watching this story unfold and being part of the team while it all comes to life has been incredibly special.
If you love dark mafia romance with heart, danger, and devotion that borders on obsession, this one absolutely delivers.
Tropes you’ll find:
Forced proximity
“Touch her and die” energy
Dangerous protector
Morally gray MMC
Vigilante justice
Scarred heroine reclaiming her power
He falls first
Huge thanks to Evie for letting me be part of the journey, seeing book 2 come to life was amazing. I cannot wait to see what else she has in store for us. All opinions are my own. 💛
Eyes of the Unholy by Evie James is the kind of dark romance that pulls you in slowly and then refuses to let you go. The deeper this story goes into the Sin Syndicate world, the more intense and layered everything becomes and I’m honestly loving where it’s heading.
Scarlett’s journey is heartbreaking but powerful. She’s been conditioned to see herself as disposable, yet beneath all that pain is this fierce resilience that refuses to die. Watching her slowly reclaim pieces of herself while navigating such a brutal world made her incredibly easy to root for. And Lucian… he’s the perfect kind of morally gray protector. Ruthless when it comes to the people who hurt her, but unexpectedly gentle with Scarlett in a way that feels deeply earned.
The chemistry between them is electric. The spice is definitely there, bold, emotional, and charged with tension, but what stood out most to me is how much it’s tied to trust and vulnerability. Every intimate moment feels like another layer of Scarlett learning that she deserves to be wanted, protected, and seen. That “burn the world to keep her safe” devotion hit me right in the chest. And the sexy scenes were perfect! I have to say they are my favorite couple. And knowing Evie, I'm sure it's not the last time we see them.
What's great about Evie's books is that they can all be read as a standalone, but together they build something even bigger and more intense. And I have to say, book two is my favorite so far. Watching this story unfold and being part of the team while it all comes to life has been incredibly special.
If you love dark mafia romance with heart, danger, and devotion that borders on obsession, this one absolutely delivers.
Tropes you’ll find:
Forced proximity
“Touch her and die” energy
Dangerous protector
Morally gray MMC
Vigilante justice
Scarred heroine reclaiming her power
He falls first
Huge thanks to Evie for letting me be part of the journey, seeing book 2 come to life was amazing. I cannot wait to see what else she has in store for us. All opinions are my own. 💛
March 11, 2026
Honestly I’m just never a huge fan of the Irish (mafia) reads I don’t know why they just aren’t my vibe 🤷🏼♀️
Review of advance copy
4.5 ⭐'s rounded up
Eyes of the Unholy is part of The Sin Syndicate an interconnected standalone series that you do not have to read book one, Eyes on You to follow, but you would be missing out if you did not start there.
The anticipation I had for this book was unreal! It did not disappoint!!! I devoured it in one sitting, I could not put it down. Lucian and Scarlett could not be more perfect! The instant connection, the angst, the story, the chemistry, the spice.. just phenomenal.
Lucian has his Irish accent and touch her and ☠️ vibes. Scarlett is fierce and sass rolled up in a small package.
The story continues with Lachlan....
Eyes of the Unholy is part of The Sin Syndicate an interconnected standalone series that you do not have to read book one, Eyes on You to follow, but you would be missing out if you did not start there.
The anticipation I had for this book was unreal! It did not disappoint!!! I devoured it in one sitting, I could not put it down. Lucian and Scarlett could not be more perfect! The instant connection, the angst, the story, the chemistry, the spice.. just phenomenal.
Lucian has his Irish accent and touch her and ☠️ vibes. Scarlett is fierce and sass rolled up in a small package.
The story continues with Lachlan....
Review of advance copy
this book was everything 🥵😌🔥🔥 you ate and left no crumbs with this book ocean Lucian and Scarlett are so amazing together this book had action, danger and spice all into one this book was a 10 outta 10
March 5, 2026
Evie truly doesn't disappoint with the unhinged, darker souls, and spice with such amazing redemption arcs for every mafia daddy.
Lucian is up front this time and he's become a man of desire and need when a fiery, red headed Scarlett surprises him in every possible way. The true strength and testament hidden beneath the habit disguised as mercy.
Right away this story takes off with a run, not a jog and has fire leading the way! The intention, the initial plan quickly falls through when Lucian experiences something he hasn't in a long time - an unexplainable, aching pull to Scar and what was just a job quickly transformed into obsession, protection and devotion with no restraint and no fear of tainting the soul.
The fight doesn't end and they are fighting against more than they realize as they uncover the truth behind Scarlett's disappearance - why, who, where and what are the questions being asked and she herself is as left in the dark. Scarlett has scars that run deeper than any blade could and she still has strength to fight for life, for breath, for room in a world that the void swallowed up and didn't question it. Lucian, is the spot of light in the dark that she doesn't realize is there to save her from the black, not mock her with the reminder that her light WAS dimmed but not for long.
Quickly, this duo of fire and ice become a team of relentless work to bring down all involved in not just Scarlett's story but others who have disappeared with the right amount of zeros. They have a single goal, a united force of revenge to right the wrongs and bring down the worst of the worst. The Syndicate may be dark, governed by no laws, painted red with dripping ledgers but there's one thing they don't stand for - and they are about to bring it to the damn ground.
Lucian is up front this time and he's become a man of desire and need when a fiery, red headed Scarlett surprises him in every possible way. The true strength and testament hidden beneath the habit disguised as mercy.
Right away this story takes off with a run, not a jog and has fire leading the way! The intention, the initial plan quickly falls through when Lucian experiences something he hasn't in a long time - an unexplainable, aching pull to Scar and what was just a job quickly transformed into obsession, protection and devotion with no restraint and no fear of tainting the soul.
The fight doesn't end and they are fighting against more than they realize as they uncover the truth behind Scarlett's disappearance - why, who, where and what are the questions being asked and she herself is as left in the dark. Scarlett has scars that run deeper than any blade could and she still has strength to fight for life, for breath, for room in a world that the void swallowed up and didn't question it. Lucian, is the spot of light in the dark that she doesn't realize is there to save her from the black, not mock her with the reminder that her light WAS dimmed but not for long.
Quickly, this duo of fire and ice become a team of relentless work to bring down all involved in not just Scarlett's story but others who have disappeared with the right amount of zeros. They have a single goal, a united force of revenge to right the wrongs and bring down the worst of the worst. The Syndicate may be dark, governed by no laws, painted red with dripping ledgers but there's one thing they don't stand for - and they are about to bring it to the damn ground.
February 27, 2026
Amazing 2nd Book!
This is second book in Evie's series and with this being the story of Scarlett and Lucian... WOW!
The story pretty much follows on from Book 1, with Lucian's attempt at kidn@pping Scarlett...
Lucian is the definition of morally grey. He wants to take Scarlett to get back at her Dad, but what he doesn't realise is he is actually unlocking the door of a cage she has been stuffed into.
He is incredibly caring and respectful to Scarlett, with a dark 'touch her and die' vibe - plus he is Irish. What's not to love?
Scarlet, oh Scarlett... Evie DOES NOT write weak female main characters in her books. She is a little spitfire hiding beneath the mask and I loved seeing the real Scarlett and also watching as she and Lucian develops their relationship.
These two were made for each other!
It was also great to see some familiar faces back!
The story itself carries on from Eyes on You (Book 1) and so comes with trigger warnings so please head to Evie's website to give them a read.
With this book, Evie just throws you into the action straight away and it has a much faster pace.
These guys work in the dark and shadows, with their activities not exactly being legal but they have a code (a very deep wide line in the sand) and with powers that be partaking in some truely horrific activites, it is satisfying to know that the Syndicate have taken things into their own hands to make those at the heart... pay.
This part of the story hasn't concluded so I cannot wait to see what else happens and how Evie eventually concludes this running story.
With a formidable guy and a fiesty, smart lady this book is utterly brilliant and comes complete with action, mystery and of course... spice!
Highly recommend!
This is second book in Evie's series and with this being the story of Scarlett and Lucian... WOW!
The story pretty much follows on from Book 1, with Lucian's attempt at kidn@pping Scarlett...
Lucian is the definition of morally grey. He wants to take Scarlett to get back at her Dad, but what he doesn't realise is he is actually unlocking the door of a cage she has been stuffed into.
He is incredibly caring and respectful to Scarlett, with a dark 'touch her and die' vibe - plus he is Irish. What's not to love?
Scarlet, oh Scarlett... Evie DOES NOT write weak female main characters in her books. She is a little spitfire hiding beneath the mask and I loved seeing the real Scarlett and also watching as she and Lucian develops their relationship.
These two were made for each other!
It was also great to see some familiar faces back!
The story itself carries on from Eyes on You (Book 1) and so comes with trigger warnings so please head to Evie's website to give them a read.
With this book, Evie just throws you into the action straight away and it has a much faster pace.
These guys work in the dark and shadows, with their activities not exactly being legal but they have a code (a very deep wide line in the sand) and with powers that be partaking in some truely horrific activites, it is satisfying to know that the Syndicate have taken things into their own hands to make those at the heart... pay.
This part of the story hasn't concluded so I cannot wait to see what else happens and how Evie eventually concludes this running story.
With a formidable guy and a fiesty, smart lady this book is utterly brilliant and comes complete with action, mystery and of course... spice!
Highly recommend!
February 26, 2026
Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Swoon🫦🫦🫦
LMAO 🤣🤣
Tears 🥹🥹🥹
Banter 😉😉😉
Dark Mafia / Forced Proximity / Suspense / HEA
Sin Syndicate #2 - We first met Lucian Byrnes in Book 2 of Broken Heroes and again in Book 1 of Sin Syndicate. He and the other owners of Club Xyst are now part of this elite group to help take down powerful, self-entitled men who remarkably mirror some men in our present-day world. After her mother died, Scarlett Hayes was sent off to Spain to finish school and then join a convent. The men of the Sin Syndicate believe that she could be used to bring down her corrupt father, the Mayor of New York. On Christmas night, while she prays in the local church, Lucian steps in to abduct her, but she is no meek lamb. She fights him off, gets away, and a very surprised Lucian is pissed off at himself. He has one more chance to snag her, and it will reveal a whole new side of her they didn’t expect. This girl has more scars from her past than her own father didn’t know about. Scarlett’s obviously has trust issues, and with Lucian, she may just be able to heal. This was an incredible story of perseverance, courage, and sheer determination. Thank you, Evie, for another wild ride … can’t wait to see what happens with Lachlan.
Spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Swoon🫦🫦🫦
LMAO 🤣🤣
Tears 🥹🥹🥹
Banter 😉😉😉
Dark Mafia / Forced Proximity / Suspense / HEA
Sin Syndicate #2 - We first met Lucian Byrnes in Book 2 of Broken Heroes and again in Book 1 of Sin Syndicate. He and the other owners of Club Xyst are now part of this elite group to help take down powerful, self-entitled men who remarkably mirror some men in our present-day world. After her mother died, Scarlett Hayes was sent off to Spain to finish school and then join a convent. The men of the Sin Syndicate believe that she could be used to bring down her corrupt father, the Mayor of New York. On Christmas night, while she prays in the local church, Lucian steps in to abduct her, but she is no meek lamb. She fights him off, gets away, and a very surprised Lucian is pissed off at himself. He has one more chance to snag her, and it will reveal a whole new side of her they didn’t expect. This girl has more scars from her past than her own father didn’t know about. Scarlett’s obviously has trust issues, and with Lucian, she may just be able to heal. This was an incredible story of perseverance, courage, and sheer determination. Thank you, Evie, for another wild ride … can’t wait to see what happens with Lachlan.
February 25, 2026
oh. my. god.
i was soo excited for lucien's story that i built up so much hype in my mind and man did evie exceed that imaginary hype!!
i honestly dont have the words or even know where to begin this review besides just saying "wow" "omg" and "holy crap this book is amazing". because thats all i have repeated aloud since i finished 😅
evie truly knocked it out of the park with this book. lucien and scarlett's story was everything i never knew i needed in a book. the spice was spicing too 🥵
there is a list of trigger warnings that you never should read first. but if we are being honest, trigger warning lists make me want to read it more.... i dont know what that says about me 😂. but i truly recommend giving this a read!
thank you so so much evie for giving me this incredible opportunity to read this book and for keeping me on your street team for as long as you have (it's going to be hard to get rid of me sorry not sorry😂). but seriously it is such an honor to be apart of your team and i can't wait for everyone to read this masterpiece 🫶🏼🫶🏼
i was soo excited for lucien's story that i built up so much hype in my mind and man did evie exceed that imaginary hype!!
i honestly dont have the words or even know where to begin this review besides just saying "wow" "omg" and "holy crap this book is amazing". because thats all i have repeated aloud since i finished 😅
evie truly knocked it out of the park with this book. lucien and scarlett's story was everything i never knew i needed in a book. the spice was spicing too 🥵
there is a list of trigger warnings that you never should read first. but if we are being honest, trigger warning lists make me want to read it more.... i dont know what that says about me 😂. but i truly recommend giving this a read!
thank you so so much evie for giving me this incredible opportunity to read this book and for keeping me on your street team for as long as you have (it's going to be hard to get rid of me sorry not sorry😂). but seriously it is such an honor to be apart of your team and i can't wait for everyone to read this masterpiece 🫶🏼🫶🏼
Review of advance copy received from Author
What an epic read this was. This book exceeded my expectations. It was everything I could have wanted in a dark mafia romance. The narrative is masterfully crafted. The words flowed effortlessly, drawing you into the story. The main characters Lucian and Scarlett were incredible. I loved how these two are well matched and how they complement one another. I especially loved that Scarlett had this fierceness to her, that she's not to be underestimated. And of course Lucian, I just love that he goes to whatever length he needs to to protect those he cares about. This one really hits the nail on the head. I savored every bit of this story. I highly recommend reading. It won't disappoint. This book is a must-read for anyone that likes forced proximity, vigilante justice, a morally gray MMC, and touch her and die vibes.
A huge thank you to the author for a copy of this. All opinions are my own and freely expressed.
A huge thank you to the author for a copy of this. All opinions are my own and freely expressed.
March 22, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Absolutely obsessed. From the first page I was absolutely hooked. The pacing of this story was perfect. It never felt like it was going too fast or too slow. Lucian had me absolutely swooning. I loved everything about his character and the way he loved Scarlett. Even after everything Scarlett went through she still came out as a woman who knew what she wanted and was strong and capable. Evie James absolutely knows how to write mafia romance that will have you reading the book all in one setting. Cannot wait for more Sin Syndicate books.
Thank you to Evie James for an ARC copy in exchange for a fair and honest review.
Absolutely obsessed. From the first page I was absolutely hooked. The pacing of this story was perfect. It never felt like it was going too fast or too slow. Lucian had me absolutely swooning. I loved everything about his character and the way he loved Scarlett. Even after everything Scarlett went through she still came out as a woman who knew what she wanted and was strong and capable. Evie James absolutely knows how to write mafia romance that will have you reading the book all in one setting. Cannot wait for more Sin Syndicate books.
Thank you to Evie James for an ARC copy in exchange for a fair and honest review.
February 25, 2026
Sometimes the answers to your prayers are in the hands of your enemies.
Lucian is a good man, but he keeps his heart walled up. He prefers to keep his mind focused on business. Unfortunately for him his business includes a feisty, beautiful, red headed nun named Scarlett that’s about to give him a run for his money. She was definitely not what he expected. I’ll let you read the story for yourself, but it’s full of intrigue, trauma bonding, action sequences, healing, spice and love. Mafia romance with a twist. Absolutely love it!
Lucian is a good man, but he keeps his heart walled up. He prefers to keep his mind focused on business. Unfortunately for him his business includes a feisty, beautiful, red headed nun named Scarlett that’s about to give him a run for his money. She was definitely not what he expected. I’ll let you read the story for yourself, but it’s full of intrigue, trauma bonding, action sequences, healing, spice and love. Mafia romance with a twist. Absolutely love it!
February 26, 2026
I have been dying for Lucian and Scarlett's storv it was was everything I could've wanted and more! Lucian was perfectly obsessed with Scarlett and I am convinced that these Sin Syndicate men can do absolutely no wrong. The ending?! Yes baby! Justice is served!!! If you love mafia romance on the darker side then look no further!
February 26, 2026
Let me just start by saying I LOVED THIS BOOK. I think I actually enjoyed it more than the first one? 😱 which is saying something! The pacing was wonderful, the spice was spicy, yet there was still a well thought out plot underneath it all. Lucian is my new book boyfriend and I cannot wait for the next one already! Mafia lover, this one is for you!!
February 26, 2026
Thank you to the author for the ARC copy! I absolutely loved this book from the morally gray MMC to the scarred yet feisty FMC. The action kept me hooked, and the chemistry between them was everything. If you love mafia romance where the MMC falls first, this is definitely a must-read. 🖤🔥
April 5, 2026
• 𝐑𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠 - 5✨
• 𝐑𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐞 𝐃𝐚𝐭𝐞 - February 25, 2026
• 𝐓𝐫𝐨𝐩𝐞𝐬 -
- dark mafia romance
- morally gray hero
- kidnapping turned protector
- forced proximity
- touch her and die
- corrupt politicians & crime conspiracy
- strong heroine growth
• 𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 -
This story follows Scarlett, the daughter of a powerful mayor whose life has always been controlled and hidden behind religious walls. What the world sees is a quiet nun-like girl, but underneath she carries a painful past and dark secrets. When Lucian, an Irish mafia enforcer, tries to kidnap her on Christmas night, everything changes. What begins as a dangerous mission slowly turns into protection, loyalty, and something deeper as they uncover a massive trafficking conspiracy connected to powerful people.
Scarlett’s past honestly broke my heart. She was forced into a life she never chose and treated like a pawn for political power. The pain she carried made her character feel so real. Watching her grow from someone trapped and controlled into someone bold, brave, and determined was one of the most powerful parts of the story. She became strong and fearless, and Lucian was the one person who stood beside her and gave her the safety and support she never had before.
Lucian is the definition of a morally gray hero. Dangerous, protective, and completely devoted once Scarlett becomes his priority. The way he protects her and stands against everyone for her made every scene with him even more intense.
The plot was intense with crime, secrets, and powerful twists, but the emotional growth between the characters made the story even better. I loved the dark atmosphere, the protective hero energy, and Scarlett’s transformation into someone who finally takes control of her life.
This was such a gripping dark romance with suspense, emotion, and a strong heroine who refuses to stay silent.
Thank you hambrightpr for the ARC!
• 𝐑𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐞 𝐃𝐚𝐭𝐞 - February 25, 2026
• 𝐓𝐫𝐨𝐩𝐞𝐬 -
- dark mafia romance
- morally gray hero
- kidnapping turned protector
- forced proximity
- touch her and die
- corrupt politicians & crime conspiracy
- strong heroine growth
• 𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 -
This story follows Scarlett, the daughter of a powerful mayor whose life has always been controlled and hidden behind religious walls. What the world sees is a quiet nun-like girl, but underneath she carries a painful past and dark secrets. When Lucian, an Irish mafia enforcer, tries to kidnap her on Christmas night, everything changes. What begins as a dangerous mission slowly turns into protection, loyalty, and something deeper as they uncover a massive trafficking conspiracy connected to powerful people.
Scarlett’s past honestly broke my heart. She was forced into a life she never chose and treated like a pawn for political power. The pain she carried made her character feel so real. Watching her grow from someone trapped and controlled into someone bold, brave, and determined was one of the most powerful parts of the story. She became strong and fearless, and Lucian was the one person who stood beside her and gave her the safety and support she never had before.
Lucian is the definition of a morally gray hero. Dangerous, protective, and completely devoted once Scarlett becomes his priority. The way he protects her and stands against everyone for her made every scene with him even more intense.
The plot was intense with crime, secrets, and powerful twists, but the emotional growth between the characters made the story even better. I loved the dark atmosphere, the protective hero energy, and Scarlett’s transformation into someone who finally takes control of her life.
This was such a gripping dark romance with suspense, emotion, and a strong heroine who refuses to stay silent.
Thank you hambrightpr for the ARC!
April 10, 2026
I picked this up for the kidnapped nun x ruthless mafia enforcer chaos… and stayed for the emotional warfare that absolutely wrecked me.
This book doesn’t just cross lines—it burns them to ash.
Lucian is the kind of morally gray that makes your brain say run while your heart quietly sets up a welcome party. Ruthless, calculating, built for violence… and yet the way he handles Scarlett? Like she’s something sacred in a world that’s anything but. The duality?? I’m unwell.
And Scarlett?? Don’t let the “quiet nun” act fool you. This girl has layers—sharp, scarred, and far more dangerous than anyone expects. Watching her peel back her own truths while navigating Lucian’s world felt like watching a storm learn how to aim.
The tension? Suffocating.The obsession? FEROCIOUS.The “he would burn the world for her” energy? Fully delivered. No notes.
But what really hit? The deeper plot. This isn’t just mafia politics and power plays—it dives into something darker, uglier, and terrifyingly real. The stakes feel massive, and the villains? The kind that make your skin crawl.
And somehow, in the middle of all that brutality…he brushes her hair.
Yeah. I was done for.
If you love:🖤 Enemies to lovers with bite🖤 Forced proximity that actually forces things🖤 A dangerous man who softens for one person only🖤 A heroine who’s not as innocent as she seems🖤 Justice served with a side of vengeance
Read this immediately.
Lucian didn’t just fall first—he fell like a man already digging graves for anyone who looked at her wrong.
And honestly? I’d let him.
This book doesn’t just cross lines—it burns them to ash.
Lucian is the kind of morally gray that makes your brain say run while your heart quietly sets up a welcome party. Ruthless, calculating, built for violence… and yet the way he handles Scarlett? Like she’s something sacred in a world that’s anything but. The duality?? I’m unwell.
And Scarlett?? Don’t let the “quiet nun” act fool you. This girl has layers—sharp, scarred, and far more dangerous than anyone expects. Watching her peel back her own truths while navigating Lucian’s world felt like watching a storm learn how to aim.
The tension? Suffocating.The obsession? FEROCIOUS.The “he would burn the world for her” energy? Fully delivered. No notes.
But what really hit? The deeper plot. This isn’t just mafia politics and power plays—it dives into something darker, uglier, and terrifyingly real. The stakes feel massive, and the villains? The kind that make your skin crawl.
And somehow, in the middle of all that brutality…he brushes her hair.
Yeah. I was done for.
If you love:🖤 Enemies to lovers with bite🖤 Forced proximity that actually forces things🖤 A dangerous man who softens for one person only🖤 A heroine who’s not as innocent as she seems🖤 Justice served with a side of vengeance
Read this immediately.
Lucian didn’t just fall first—he fell like a man already digging graves for anyone who looked at her wrong.
And honestly? I’d let him.
April 19, 2026
Eyes of the Unholy: A Dark Forced Proximity Mafia Romance
By Evie James
This was my first Evie James book… and I will have to read book 1 for sure, I’m hooked.
This story pulled me in right away. The pacing was strong, and I stayed fully invested the entire time. Dark, gritty, emotional, and with just the right amount of emotional damage.
Scarlett really stood out to me. She’s been through so much, but she’s not broken. She’s resilient, layered, and very human. I loved watching her navigate this world and slowly reclaim her power.
And Lucian… yeah, morally gray, ruthless, built for violence, but with Scarlett, he’s soft for her, almost reverent and that makes him very hard to resist.
If you like when he falls first, when he braids her hair, the Mine, and touch her 💀 energy, you’ll love this!
And this definitely has me curious to go back and read more in the series.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Thank you Hambright for the opportunity to read this early, all opinions are my own.
By Evie James
This was my first Evie James book… and I will have to read book 1 for sure, I’m hooked.
This story pulled me in right away. The pacing was strong, and I stayed fully invested the entire time. Dark, gritty, emotional, and with just the right amount of emotional damage.
Scarlett really stood out to me. She’s been through so much, but she’s not broken. She’s resilient, layered, and very human. I loved watching her navigate this world and slowly reclaim her power.
And Lucian… yeah, morally gray, ruthless, built for violence, but with Scarlett, he’s soft for her, almost reverent and that makes him very hard to resist.
If you like when he falls first, when he braids her hair, the Mine, and touch her 💀 energy, you’ll love this!
And this definitely has me curious to go back and read more in the series.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Thank you Hambright for the opportunity to read this early, all opinions are my own.
April 24, 2026
Okay, I absolutely love this series! I adore Lucian and Scarlett the most so far.
I related to Scarlett so much, especially with the internal struggles she dealt with and the trauma she had experienced. It was so helpful to read about someone who had been through something like that, and they found the love of someone who helped them move forward and heal from that. And I loved that Lucian was able to be that person for her and help her learn to not only love herself, but to trust someone else enough to love them.
The plot in this book was also really good. I enjoyed the suspenseful aspects of It. The way you think you have the whole thing figured out, until something else happens and you had it all wrong.
And can I just say, some of these characters (Delgado and Scarlett's dad) are real pieces of crap, and I hope they get what they deserve in future books.
I'm Soo excited already for the next book just from reading the preview.
I related to Scarlett so much, especially with the internal struggles she dealt with and the trauma she had experienced. It was so helpful to read about someone who had been through something like that, and they found the love of someone who helped them move forward and heal from that. And I loved that Lucian was able to be that person for her and help her learn to not only love herself, but to trust someone else enough to love them.
The plot in this book was also really good. I enjoyed the suspenseful aspects of It. The way you think you have the whole thing figured out, until something else happens and you had it all wrong.
And can I just say, some of these characters (Delgado and Scarlett's dad) are real pieces of crap, and I hope they get what they deserve in future books.
I'm Soo excited already for the next book just from reading the preview.
April 8, 2026
I love a mafia romance with an Irish mmc, it’s just pretty damn hot. The plot was amazing, so many great twists and the characters were stunning. The fmc, Scarlett, is terribly traumatised despite being a nun, and finding out her past was truly shocking and horrifying. I loved her badass personality and how Lucien really brought it out in her. Of course I love some lady napping, and these so much banter and tension between them. This book was also sooo good with the touch her and die trope. Like she’d be like “I hate them” and he’s like “don’t worry I already took care of it”!! I love them so much. Lucien was such a green flag (yes he does try to kidnap her) but literally is such a sweetheart inside. I do admit that I liked the first book better, the plot just felt a little more exciting, but this book had great twists too. I’m really excited for the next book in this series and give this a 4/5
February 21, 2026
5⭐️ 3.5🌶️
❤️dark mafia romance
🖤romantic suspense
❤️ Forced Proximity
🖤Scarred FMC
❤️forced proximity
🖤touch her and ☠️
❤️he falls first
🖤vigilante justice
Evie James has done it again! This book was everything I wanted for Lucian’s story! The way I devoured this book was unreal. The pacing was on point, and I was sucked in immediately. I love how Evie always writes the best FMCs, and Scarlett was no exception. Even though she endured brutal abuse, she was strong and resilient. I absolutely loved her for Lucian! I loved that Lucian fell instantly in love with Scarlett from the moment he laid eyes on her. I could go on forever about how much I loved this book! I can’t wait for more Sin Syndicate books!
❤️dark mafia romance
🖤romantic suspense
❤️ Forced Proximity
🖤Scarred FMC
❤️forced proximity
🖤touch her and ☠️
❤️he falls first
🖤vigilante justice
Evie James has done it again! This book was everything I wanted for Lucian’s story! The way I devoured this book was unreal. The pacing was on point, and I was sucked in immediately. I love how Evie always writes the best FMCs, and Scarlett was no exception. Even though she endured brutal abuse, she was strong and resilient. I absolutely loved her for Lucian! I loved that Lucian fell instantly in love with Scarlett from the moment he laid eyes on her. I could go on forever about how much I loved this book! I can’t wait for more Sin Syndicate books!
March 26, 2026
•Dark, intriguing, sexy, and he falls so hard•
This dark romance grabbed me by the collar and didn’t let go. From the minute I saw the cover, I was intrigued, and this book did not disappoint! Sexy, tattooed and commanding attention, Lucian is a man with a mission. What he doesn’t expect is for his target to capture his thoughts and his heart. Scarlett is beautiful, strong and fiesty, and I love the way her romance with Lucian plays out while they put together pieces of a puzzle of corruption that surprises both of them.
If you like gripping mafia romance, dark and dirty with men who would burn down the world for their love, get into this book (and this series) right now!
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the review copy of Eyes of the Unholy. All opinions are my own.
4.5 stars
This dark romance grabbed me by the collar and didn’t let go. From the minute I saw the cover, I was intrigued, and this book did not disappoint! Sexy, tattooed and commanding attention, Lucian is a man with a mission. What he doesn’t expect is for his target to capture his thoughts and his heart. Scarlett is beautiful, strong and fiesty, and I love the way her romance with Lucian plays out while they put together pieces of a puzzle of corruption that surprises both of them.
If you like gripping mafia romance, dark and dirty with men who would burn down the world for their love, get into this book (and this series) right now!
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the review copy of Eyes of the Unholy. All opinions are my own.
4.5 stars
Displaying 1 - 30 of 135 reviews