Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

On Un/Certainty: The Uses of Doubt in Dangerous Times

Rate this book
We live in uncertain times. But what does uncertainty mean for our ability to act?

While politicians, CEOs, and pundits reflexively invoke “uncertain times” to explain everything from pandemic responses to climate inaction, journalist and theorist Natasha Lennard offers a radical intervention. Lennard demonstrates how our obsession with uncertainty masks the violent certainties that dominate our fracturing world. 

On Un/Certainty applies philosophical insight to political practice, offering readers not just analysis but hope—and conceptual tools with which to act. The book tackles contemporary flashpoints through an original philosophical lens, demystifying our constant talk of crisis, polycrisis, and omnicrisis. Lennard examines the way entrenched conceptions of gendered experience are weaponized to harass the most vulnerable. Dissecting the discourse around borders, she reveals their enforcement to be a site of paranoid vigilance and violent property logics, which threaten millions of lives. Lennard addresses head-on the limits to traditional forms of political persuasion and demands that we think anew about how to build more liberatory forms of life.

Drawing on the philosophy of Ludwig Wittgenstein and placing his work alongside thinkers rarely put into conversation, Lennard contends with the nature of certainty, identity, and ideology as we struggle into the future.

176 pages, Hardcover

Published October 13, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Natasha Lennard

5 books26 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
3 (27%)
4 stars
5 (45%)
3 stars
1 (9%)
2 stars
1 (9%)
1 star
1 (9%)
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
Profile Image for Nakedfartbarfer.
288 reviews1 follower
November 3, 2026
This is a quick tract on topics du jour, using the conceptual filter of certainty & uncertainty. I think it also navigates the lexical snares for leftists that lay between merely doing no harm and doing good.

“Conspiracists do not actually question authority or expertise, as they often claim; they discount and reject it… A performance of doubt in which no actual route to knowledge is possible or permitted is not doubt; it simply expresses a certainty.”

The ideal of a “debate” is that of an exercise to increase the understanding of both the audience and the orators, but debates are more often used as a bad-faith spectacle for throwing the ol’ rhetorical haymaker & dunking on one’s opponent, with all conclusions foregone. No uncertainty.

The author examines the ideas of certainty/uncertainty as linguistic constructions (rather than private mental states). She employs the philosopher (& corporal punishment enthusiast) Ludwig Wittgenstein to this end, a fella that I’d studiously managed to avoid since unwittingly reading The Broom of the System.

Wittgenstein is used in this book as a convenient analytic device, and the author cautions against reading this thing to better understand Wittgenstein, so I didn’t feel like I got run over by a beautiful katamari of snowballing logics and prepositions.

As capitalism decays and becomes more inhuman & vicious, it reaches wildly for more & more scapegoats to keep the heat OFF of captains of industry and ON structurally powerless minorities. Lennard makes the case that things that were once certain are necessarily made uncertain, etc..

For example, only a handful of presidents ago, the official editorial stance of the fuggin’ Wall Street Journal was that of open borders. They called for a constitutional amendment to that effect. Such a libertarian amendment would allow for the free movement of trade & cheap labor to the advantage of capitalists.

Nowadays, in order to maintain an immigrant boogeyman, American taxpayers must subsidize militarized borders as well as CoreCivic & GeoGroup to the tune of billions in order to disappear brown people into concentration camps (and worse). This is the new certainty of a “border crisis”, which pretty much all political candidates are required bring to a podium.

This book is probably more affirming than revelatory to anyone who reads & follows US politics, but Natasha Lennard handles it so well that she makes all subject matter feel crucial and like it’s all in her wheelhouse. The angle of un/certainty for the book can feel like a mere pretense to publish some accrued topical columnist expertise, but it doesn’t detract from the insights.
Profile Image for Will.
7 reviews1 follower
November 5, 2026
The sensation of unease is communal. Whether it’s economic, cultural, or political, the expectation of what comes next is murky. This sense of uncertainty could even be understood as permanent on an ever-changing global stage. Yet, as this experience of flux permeates, it is weaponized. As the vicious certainties of genocide, border policing, and transphobia are implemented, any challenges to these violent structures are labeled as radical, illogical, and volatile. The hypocrisy of these claims are clear to those who recognize that structural violence is not a natural occurrence but is instead built and preserved. Natasha Lennard provides a philosophical yet grounded perspective in On Un/Certainty to diagnose how certainty can be manufactured and, hopefully, restructured.

Using the concept of hinges from Ludwig Wittgenstein’s On Certainty, Lennard points to how common understandings of our world often go assumed and unquestioned. This keeps the doors of permission open. Even when these types of common sense are proven false or harmful, consent for conduct based on these certainties is protected as long as these understandings are dominant. Lennard discusses how concepts such as borders, whiteness, and gender binarism all hold deep institutional influence in maintaining certain hierarchies. These all involve a designated Other, who must be controlled in order to guard the privilege of the in-group. The incentives for defending these certainties vary. Border policing serves the interest of borderless capital by cheapening labor while labeling the immigrant as the culprit. Gender binarism allows for cis to be defined as the “correct” performance of gender while asserting that trans folk are a threat to the nuclear family & said family’s relation to labor. Debating these beliefs, which is a common spectacle in the current media environment, is not the vehicle for change. Lennard argues that the world itself must be changed in order for new certainties to become hinges.

If the key to a better world can be forged, it must be forged in the dark. Lennard believes that to build resistance to oppressive structures, this construction must operate in the blind spots of these dominant certainties. Doubt is an effective tool only if it can be deployed. So long as people remain resolved to confront cruel systems, weaknesses and ruptures will be found that these structures could never comprehend. Fear of uncertainty always looms, yet the courage to embrace uncertainty’s positive possibilities will always be its shadow.
Profile Image for Jackie McCarthy.
89 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 26, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an Advance Reader Copy.

"These are unprecedented times." We have been hearing this from politicians, business executives and community leaders since at least 2020. Lennard examines the use and manipulation of uncertainty from a philosophical perspective, asking who or what benefits from a claim of uncertainty, and encourages the reader to interpret "crisis language" critically. Powerful actors can use uncertainty to evade responsibility or impose/maintain injustices. The analogy of certainty as a riverbed that establishes itself through time but can change over time is apt. If change is normal, we can be more rightly skeptical of claims of crisis. Lennard focuses on the US border crisis, the Israel/Gaza war, and trans rights (with some references to AI) as examples of where uncertainty can be manipulated toward specific outcomes. She is clear in her political biases on these issues. The book would have benefitted from more examples of how the manipulation of uncertainty affects more "kitchen table" issues like cost of living, but is a helpful perspective to be more discerning the next time one is faced with the uncertainty claim in political discourse.
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews