Fife, Scotland, 1649. From valerian root to milk thistle, Fife has relied on the Blackwood sisters’ natural remedies for a decade. Gardening and grinding an array of flora into desired tonics and salves, the days are calm and they are content in their quiet lives . . . until the bodies start to pile up. Three corpses and one liar, ignite a dozen rumors, thrusting the small town into hysteria. Suspicion poisons and violence erupts as Isla and Elspeth stand accused bana-bhuidseaches. Witches. The mania accelerates with the arrival of John Kincaid, the notorious witch pricker, stirring the townspeople to commit a most heinous act. With nothing left to lose, the sisters swear vengeance and now, ergot fungus, daffodils, and cherry laurel line their aprons as they wield their knowledge of botany like blades. If the mob believes them to be disciples of the devil, the women refuse to disappoint.
5☆ A gruesome death, a woman's last moments before being consumed by flames, is how Brooke started this horror filled historical fiction novel. What makes the story so scary has nothing to do with otherworldly forces but with the horrors people commit when fear of the unknown strikes.
Brooke has an astounding way with words. Her ability to illustrate what her characters think, feel, and sense is so well done that I, as a reader, was able to undergo the experiences with visceral reactions. Brooke's writing is intense and brutal. There were many times I had to stop reading in order to breathe and process the scene, that is how impactful Brooke's writing was for me.
The herbal knowledge Brooke employed is spot on. I appreciated that she researched the medicinal and poisonous uses of the plants used in her tale.
Favorite Words: "It was incredible to imagine all the damage the beautiful flowers could impart. All the ugliness and pain the innocent petals wielded, simply by being underestimated."
I just finished reading Will The Devil Help Me Now? by Caytlyn Brooke, and all I can think is that it was amazing! I'm sad, I'm angry, I feel like I was fighting alongside the sisters! The persecution of women labeled as witches in the 16- and 1700s is shown for what it really was, ignorance and mob mentality that only destroyed innocent families. This is easily one of my all-time favorites, and I know I'll be reading it again and again. Thank you for the emotional roller-coaster, Caytlyn!
This book was incredible. The emotion in each page, the beauty of the writing (I seriously think I said ‘this is my favorite line’ twenty times). When I finished, I just had to sit and process for a long moment. This book is one that will stay with me.
Set in 17th-century Scotland, Brooke's stark, unsparing story traces how fear, grief, and institutional authority can transform care into a punishable offense. In Fife, 1649, sisters Isla and Elspeth Blackwood serve their community as herbal healers, their work trusted until illness, childbirth, and death seed suspicion. As rumor sharpens into accusation and a notorious witch pricker arrives to legitimize fear, the sisters are declared witches and forced beyond every limit of endurance by the watching town.
Brooke’s rendering of period detail is precise and unshowy, grounding the narrative in social hierarchy, medical practice, and the particular precarity of women whose knowledge exists outside sanctioned power. The novel’s greatest strength lies in its restraint. Violence is never sensationalized. It emerges as the natural consequence of collective panic and moral failure. When the sisters’ healing knowledge is finally repurposed as a weapon, the ending arrives with an unsettling sense of inevitability. Brooke offers no easy judgments, only a sobering portrait of collective cruelty and the ease with which righteousness becomes justification. A stunner.
Caytlyn Brooke's mastery of storytelling is on full display once more with the release of her historical fiction novel, Will The Devil Help Me Now?
If ever there was a clear example of the aphorism "call me the villain, but remember the chapter in which you created me," this is it. As Caytlyn shows us through the trials and tribulations of her main characters, rumors, misunderstanding, and a desire to remain with the pack often take precedence over loyalty, honesty, and free thinking. People have always found excuses to proclaim the accused guilty instead of examining the facts.
All the while, Brooke takes you on an emotional ride that both satisfies the reader tenfold and provides a cautionary tale. Don't cross the only people who can save you.
Will the Devil Help Me Now? brought me through so many emotions. From love and joy, to fear, anxiety, anguish, anger, blood lust, and back to love. It was written with a prose that transported me back centuries in time and in a brisk pace that kept me turning page after page not wanting to put it down. Caytlyn captured a wide array of women's strengths including the tender love of mothers and care takers, to their cunning decisiveness when they've been crossed. I'd recommend this story to friends and plan to keep it on my shelf.
I'll need to sit and process the gruesome reality of this book. The author writes with beauty and horror at once, and even when you inevitably know the ending, you're still drawn to read. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐