What do you think?
Rate this book
A Real Paige Turner
Not yet published
Expected 25 Aug 26A Simon & Schuster audiobook. Simon & Schuster has a great book for every listener.
282 pages, Kindle Edition
Expected publication August 25, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
April 15, 2026
Thank you the author and BookSirens for the gifted ARC!
I picked up A Real Paige Turner after a friend recommended it and introduced me to the author, and I’m so glad I did!
Paige O’Flynn is rebuilding her life after her fiancé leaves her for their real estate agent when Shayne Donovan, the broody new ranch hand, shows up and changes everything. What starts as undeniable chemistry and a slow-burn romance quickly shifts into something much more layered when tragedy strikes Jo and Paige begins to question whether Shayne is exactly who he says he is.
I was not expecting the mystery element and it made this SO addictive. I could not stop turning pages trying to figure it out. This book genuinely had me hooked from start to finish. From the romance, suspense, humor, and just the right amount of chaos, I devoured it. I’m already hoping there’s more coming from this world or these characters.
I picked up A Real Paige Turner after a friend recommended it and introduced me to the author, and I’m so glad I did!
Paige O’Flynn is rebuilding her life after her fiancé leaves her for their real estate agent when Shayne Donovan, the broody new ranch hand, shows up and changes everything. What starts as undeniable chemistry and a slow-burn romance quickly shifts into something much more layered when tragedy strikes Jo and Paige begins to question whether Shayne is exactly who he says he is.
I was not expecting the mystery element and it made this SO addictive. I could not stop turning pages trying to figure it out. This book genuinely had me hooked from start to finish. From the romance, suspense, humor, and just the right amount of chaos, I devoured it. I’m already hoping there’s more coming from this world or these characters.
Review of advance copy
This is a strong debut novel from an author I hope will grow into one I really love.
Paige runs her late grandmother’s bookstore in a small mountain town. She is still nursing the hurt of a breakup when Shayne, the gorgeous cowboy, turns up to work at Paige’s best friend’s ranch. Their attraction is immediate but there is a mystery developing that involves Shayne, the ranch and secrets from the past that may end their relationship before it even begins.
This books is a mashup of a lot of tropes. We have small town, cowboy, mystery/suspense, hero with secrets, heroine recovering her identity after a bad relationship. At times it feels a bit muddled. The beginning leans into a romantic comedy vibe. However the mystery element out ways the humor more and more as the book goes on, making the tone far more serious. By the time we get to the big reveal of the climax and the last minute twist, we are definitely in solid suspense territory.
The romance between Paige and Shayne underdeveloped for me. The time they actually spend talking to each other does not seem equal to the emotional connection that develops. Don’t get me wrong, the sexy stuff is sexy. But their physical chemistry gets a lot more page time than anything else between them.
It is really through her relationship with Jo, her best friend, and Jo’s young daughter that we get to know Paige best. Their long history, constant support for each other and eventual struggle to overcome a very real challenge to their relationship feels like the true love story here with the romance taking a back seat.
Overall, I am glad I read this books and will keep an eye on the author. I hope she learns to hone her story telling a bit because her writing style is charming and shows quite a bit of potential.
Thank you to BookSirens and author Michelle Eileen for the opportunity to read and review an advanced reader copy of this book.
Paige runs her late grandmother’s bookstore in a small mountain town. She is still nursing the hurt of a breakup when Shayne, the gorgeous cowboy, turns up to work at Paige’s best friend’s ranch. Their attraction is immediate but there is a mystery developing that involves Shayne, the ranch and secrets from the past that may end their relationship before it even begins.
This books is a mashup of a lot of tropes. We have small town, cowboy, mystery/suspense, hero with secrets, heroine recovering her identity after a bad relationship. At times it feels a bit muddled. The beginning leans into a romantic comedy vibe. However the mystery element out ways the humor more and more as the book goes on, making the tone far more serious. By the time we get to the big reveal of the climax and the last minute twist, we are definitely in solid suspense territory.
The romance between Paige and Shayne underdeveloped for me. The time they actually spend talking to each other does not seem equal to the emotional connection that develops. Don’t get me wrong, the sexy stuff is sexy. But their physical chemistry gets a lot more page time than anything else between them.
It is really through her relationship with Jo, her best friend, and Jo’s young daughter that we get to know Paige best. Their long history, constant support for each other and eventual struggle to overcome a very real challenge to their relationship feels like the true love story here with the romance taking a back seat.
Overall, I am glad I read this books and will keep an eye on the author. I hope she learns to hone her story telling a bit because her writing style is charming and shows quite a bit of potential.
Thank you to BookSirens and author Michelle Eileen for the opportunity to read and review an advanced reader copy of this book.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I was sucked into this book from the first spicy Page! As someone who typically reads mystery novels, I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed my first foray into the Romance genre. This book is absolutely not one dimensional- and I would even dare to call it a Romance/Mystery.
I especially loved Paige as a character. She's not just a woman searching for a man- she's independent, well-rounded, and shaped by real challenges, using humor as her armor. Her lifelong friendship with Jo added another layer I really appreciated. For many women, your best friend is your most consistent relationship, and that dynamic felt authentic and grounding.
When Paige meets Shayne, the sexy new ranch hand, she instantly feels lust towards him (how could you not- they're in a small town and he sounds HOT), however they aren't immediately naked tousling in a field and I think the slow burn builds tension that absolutely pays off.
I especially loved Paige as a character. She's not just a woman searching for a man- she's independent, well-rounded, and shaped by real challenges, using humor as her armor. Her lifelong friendship with Jo added another layer I really appreciated. For many women, your best friend is your most consistent relationship, and that dynamic felt authentic and grounding.
When Paige meets Shayne, the sexy new ranch hand, she instantly feels lust towards him (how could you not- they're in a small town and he sounds HOT), however they aren't immediately naked tousling in a field and I think the slow burn builds tension that absolutely pays off.
Review of advance copy
3.5 Stars
Congratulations on your debut novel.
I went into this thinking it was going to be a normal cowboy romance until some hints started to show that it was more then just a cowboy romance but has some mystery and twists. I enjoyed the banter and strong friendships shown throughout the book aswell as struggles in real life situations. Did I want to read more towards the end? Yes I have questions and wanted to read more of parts of the book that ended abruptly.
I feel like the story could have gone into more detail of the mystery and backstories of the characters and the change of POV in one chapter kind of through me off as I would have wanted more throughout the entire book. A few spelling errors were noticed throughout the book although overall a fun read and i look forward to watching as the Author writing continues in futures reads.
***I received an ARC of this book and am leaving this review freely Thank you Michelle Eileen and Booksirens for this opportunity**
Congratulations on your debut novel.
I went into this thinking it was going to be a normal cowboy romance until some hints started to show that it was more then just a cowboy romance but has some mystery and twists. I enjoyed the banter and strong friendships shown throughout the book aswell as struggles in real life situations. Did I want to read more towards the end? Yes I have questions and wanted to read more of parts of the book that ended abruptly.
I feel like the story could have gone into more detail of the mystery and backstories of the characters and the change of POV in one chapter kind of through me off as I would have wanted more throughout the entire book. A few spelling errors were noticed throughout the book although overall a fun read and i look forward to watching as the Author writing continues in futures reads.
***I received an ARC of this book and am leaving this review freely Thank you Michelle Eileen and Booksirens for this opportunity**
Review of advance copy received from Author
This book was exactly what I was looking for; an engaging, well-written romance. The plot includes a lot of suspense-both within the romance and the larger suspenseful story that unfolds. An unexpected delight was that the main character has a witty sense of humor. I never expected a romance novel to make me laugh out loud several times. Lastly, I found the title to be quite accurate (and clever) as I devoured this book in two days and was immediately wishing for a sequel!
Review of advance copy received from Author
This book was such a treat! Mind candy! I was sad when it ended and found myself searching for another fun read. Just the right amount of spice an intrigue plus charcacters you can genuinely like! Hoping for a second book to see where these characters go!
Review of advance copy received from Author
A fun read with a twist!
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews