Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Triple Overtime #2

Theirs to Keep

Rate this book
I have three rules for my fresh start in Seattle. Rebuild my destroyed reputation, prove my gaslighting ex wrong, and absolutely, under no circumstances, fall for a client.

So naturally, within my first week at the team facility, I've straddled the gorgeous goalie in a supply closet, gotten locked in a sauna with the grumpy captain who looks at me like I'm either his salvation or his worst nightmare, and been carried through hallways by a gentle giant who reads poetry that makes me want to cry into his very broad chest.

I'm a sports psychologist. I fix other people's heads. Mine is supposed to be the functional one.

But Theo makes me laugh until my boundaries blur. Declan sees through every wall and refuses to let me hide. And Milo makes me feel safe in ways I forgot were possible, which is terrifying when you've spent years recovering from a man who weaponized your trust.

Now my ex has followed me to Seattle, threatening everything I'm rebuilding.

Three hockey players have decided I'm worth protecting, and somewhere between emergency sessions and accidental proximity, I've started wondering something dangerous.

What if I don't have to choose?

I came to Seattle for redemption. I didn't expect it to come with three sets of very capable hands, a found family I never knew I needed, and the terrifying possibility that happily ever after might not look anything like I imagined.

251 pages, Kindle Edition

Published January 25, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Riley Keenan

29 books15 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
60 (28%)
4 stars
66 (31%)
3 stars
54 (25%)
2 stars
24 (11%)
1 star
6 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
Profile Image for Jodi Beach.
209 reviews3 followers
May 5, 2026
Another magnificent book📚 by Riley Keenan🔞

Spice level 🌶️🌶️🌶️ (out of 5 🌶️)
No babies👶 were created in the making of this book❌

This is a ❤️‍🔥M/FMM BOOK 👀
📑Another magnificent book📚 by Riley Keenan🔞

📝FAVORITE QUOTES 🤩💬

💬"The snail does not reach the destination," Milo said when he finished. "That is not the point. The point is that the snail🐌 tried. The trying is what matters."

💬Milo appeared at my shoulder a moment later, looming in that way he had that was somehow reassuring rather than intimidating. "The snail persists." "Is that going to be our thing now? Snail🐌 references before big moments?" "It seems thematically appropriate."

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️If📒Book Hangover' was a medical⚕️diagnosis🩻, I’d be in the 🏥 ICU right now. This story hit every single emotional💧note with the precision of a🌍world-class orchestra🎶 .

It has that rare🏖️vacation 🪄magic' where you forget your own name for 200 something pages📑 and then wake up at the end feeling like a brand new person. A TRUE 5-star🌟 experience is supposed to feel like a high-end holiday for your imagination, and this one delivered a first-class ticket🔖.

It has that sense of completion🏁 that is so hard to find where every thread 🪡is tied, every emotion is earned, and you’re left sitting in silence 🤐 for twenty minutes🕔 after the final period just staring👀 at the wall .

It’s that 🪄magical vacation🏝️ vibe where you’re sad it’s over, but you’re so filled with the warmth of the journey that you can’t even be mad at the flight🛩️ home.
378 reviews4 followers
June 6, 2026
This is written as if you're verbally outlining what you want to happen in your book. A lot of off page stuff progressing the story and with nothing happening on page except talking about what happened off page. Like you dropped in at the end of the book, for the entire book.
Nothing offensive. Good bones, really. Would greatly benefit being fleshed out.
181 reviews
October 24, 2026
We start with Vivian's POV. She touches down in Seattle, and immediately, a lot of things are going wrong. She is a psychologist, and she is starting over because her ex tried to ruin her career with a handful of rumors. She meets the managers of the team who tells her that while they are getting better at playing together as a team of newbies and oldies who want one more season there are three in particular who are struggling in the mental health department. Milo is the wall of a human who likes reading. Declan who is very serious and it's all work and no play. Then Theo, the charmer, who is having a full-blown panic attack in a storage closet. Vivian helps Theo out and all three of the guys agree to do sessions with her.
Declan - he is not happy that the team is getting distracted by Vivian. He also does NOT want to do sessions with her. He goes to try out the sauna, and Vivian is there after swimming. Once in, the door gets stuck, and there is an override in about 20 minutes. They basically have their therapy session in the sauna when she starts to sway. Declan learns that she hadn't eaten and she had low blood sugar. Once the door is unstuck, he scoops her up, gets her water and a granola, and leaves before he can start getting emotionally attached. 
Vivian - Milo shows up to his session, and they talk for nearly two hours. Milo opens up, and Vivian learns that he is quite literally a gentle giant. She cries and excuses herself in the hall to have a moment to recollect. Milo asks if he said something to upset her but she tells him that he is a good person and is sad that no one else knows but her now. They exchange photos of their dogs and swap numbers for her to meet his rescue Bertie.
Theo - He has been avoiding doing a therapy session, and when he goes, he uses his jokes to deflect from how he really feels, and Vivian can see that. She asks about his panic attacks and he explains then, Vivian learns that fear sharpens Theo's ability ro be a goalie. When the next practice comes when he misses a few goals the panic sets in and he races to the locker room to have a moment. Vivian follows and helps him get through it. He asks that during games if she is near so he can see her and ground himself that would help.
Vivian - He has been staying at the rink in her office since she didn't have a place and she gets busted by her manager who gives her a key to a place meant for visiting specialists. Once she gets  there she sleeps. It's the next day and she is unpacking when a knock sounds and its Declan he tells her about the water heater that blew and to be mindful. He enters her place to check out her water and then says to run the water and she does via the shower. Declan has mad control issues and says he will wait to make sure she is good since what happened in the sauna. He tells her to eat then he leaves.
Theo - He wakes really early and messages Vivian who messages where she will be sitting for the game. The game time rolls around and he looks for her often between plays. She leaves and messages him where she will be then returns. After the game when she is supporting him he asks what happened. Milo and Declan sense the tension and join in on asking what happened. They walk her to her car and agree that they will figure out what happened.
Vivian - She saw Matt, and is shocked that he has been assigned PR for a couple of the Sirens. Some time has passed and she is busing herself with work in order to forget the anxiety she has been having. She has a therapy session with Milo, and he says he is worried about her and pries her for information. She gives in and spills everything. At the end of their session Milo kisses her. her best friend Garrett shows up and questions how she is actually doing vs how she is actually doing. Garrett takes her to dinner and gets her to talk and she brings up that Matt is there, Garrett is upset. The next day Garrett shows up at her work and is observing her with the hockey players. Garrett notices that 3 of the players are watching her and she is watching them. Garret and her chat more before he goes and he warns her to be careful and to protect herself. Later that day the guys all message her about how she is, her "brother", and Theo is missing her.
Declan - 2 weeks pass and he has had his eye on Matt for most of it to scope him out. The three guys huddle to the locker room to talk about their finding between Matt and Vivian's behavior because of Matt. Milo tells them that he knows the story because she told him. Declan's idea of helping is to confront her and tell her that they know and they are going to help her. She doesn't take the ambush well and she tells them she doesn't need their help. They all leave but Declan goes back and talks to her. She reveals her truths to him. He vows to protect her from Matt and then walks her to her car.
Vivian - At a charity gala Matt tracks her and follows her out to the balcony and basically threatens her by ruining her again if she doesn't get back with him. She stands up for herself and Matt says that she will regret it. She makes it into the restroom and cries. Then she messages the group chat of the guys. They walk her outside and she explains that Matt threatened her. Theo adorably wants to make a punch to Matt look like an accident. Milo says that she will go to his apartment because Matt does not know where he lives. His apartment is literally a library! *Girl you better sign something about safe fraternizing lol and get him!!* Theo knows people in the media and says he will put a word in for any intel about to drop. Declan is complying evidence to use against him through each encounter. Milo lets her sleep on his shoulder. 
Theo - The guys figure out a system that works over the next few weeks to ensure that Vivian is never left alone with Matt. *Okay, i love this so much but why are we not going to leadership and explaining what is happening?!?!* Matt caught on after a handful of weeks and he is getting more angry about not getting Vivian alone. They do a few times a week movie night when they have time. Theo ends up calling his mom and tells her about someone he met. 
Vivian - Declan and her are eating dinner in her office and he kisses her. *Okay.... some of the details on how this lined up doesn't make sense... they were sitting and eating and with a desk between them and now they are standing? He pulls her hip closer? so now standing but when did they rise from their seats?.... needs more clarity.* when they break apart they say what now. Theo finds out they kissed 3 days later when it happens again. *Ugh, hang in there Theo!!* They have a group discussion in the car about being in a 4 person relationship and they all agree to give it a try.
Milo - He makes a shared calendar about the four of them spending time together, work, games, therapy, and more. Vivian is impressed and Theo is wowed but also shocked. In about 3 weeks he has studied the group long enough to figure out what each person needs and how they show their affection and care. They develop code words that they can use in front of people that tell them what the other person(s) need. Everything is going smoothly and Milo is waiting for the shoe to drop. And it does, in the form of Matt going above the team to management and starting the rumors over again. Vivian says it's go time with the plan they had started that involved getting statements, media coverage, etc. Vivian's contract is going under review and she has a meeting about it in a week.
Vivian - Today is the day of the review. Theo comes to pick her and he finally kisses her. At the rink she heads to the meeting but is stopped by the manager who says she has been observing Matt and his behavior for weeks and catalogued it. Along with building a presentation on the players and their stats from the beginning of the season to now. The board takes away Matt's access until they can review further. While she is walking to her Matt stops her and she stands up to him. The guys materialize and stand to defend Vivian. Matt constantly says this isn't over. 
Declan - he is working to figure out how he plays into the escorting detail to ensure that Vivian doesn't run into Matt alone again. Vivian feels suffocated and controlled and she gets snippy at Declan about it and the other guys as well. In the group chat of just the 3 of them they talk about the miscommunication and they all see it and recognize their error. Declan messages Vivian and says he's an idiot, she says come over. Once there he makes a valid point that protection is being done to her not with her and he relates the most because of his ex-wife. They come to a resolution and he stays the night. In the morning, he makes breakfast and it is burnt lol he kisses her. 
Vivian - It's been a couple of days and Milo has come up with an intimate "guide" of sorts for their first group moment... Theo jokes about a positioning table and Milo says he is working on version two LOL They try out the first intimate moment by tending to her first... wink.
Theo - There is a big game coming up, and he is having the anxiety days beforehand and is really feeling it. Everyone is doing their part in helping because they care for him, and he loves knowing that he is being cared for in 3 different directions on different levels of care. his mother calls the night before to check on him and he tells her about their relationship. She is curious but not judgmental. She wants to meet everyone who makes her son happy. It's game time and he feels oddly at peace. He finds Vivian with Declan's mother and some of their other friends 4 rows behind the net. They won the game 5-2!! YAY!!
Milo - Vivian finally meets Bertie and she is in love with him just like he is with her. Milo explains his actual backstory and not one from a clinical view. *How it is space in the book should be a bigger breaker. It looks like a large enter/new paragraph... this is for all the breaks.* A few days go by and the guys are just hanging out without Vivian or talking about her. They are happy with each other and happy with how everything is.
Vivian - An article comes out about her and the team about her getting around with them and she is DEVASTATED. Needing comfort, she takes them all to bed. The next morning, she gets an email about the investigation conclusion. They fire Matt. *I have a bad feeling he will be back...*
Declan - With the threat of Matt gone he feels like he isn't sure what to do because he has constantly been under attack in his relationships. *I think there is an error in this text... Theo is talking about Garrett coming to visit and he says, "We're scouting my sister's brother." Who?!* They prepare for how to answer some of the questions Garrett is going to have then they all head to bed.
Theo - They go to a restaurant and sit down and discuss their relationship dynamic and how everything works between the three of them. Garrett likes them and wants check-ins to make sure they treat her well and she is doing okay. He is happy that he has the three of them and is actually happy.
Vivian - a week passes, She is not used to the safety she feels and Theo comments she is extra jumpy as of late. The guys tend to her in the way they know how. *Ugh, Milo is such an absolute heart throb. I love his character!!* They talk and then end up doing it. Milo wants them to stay and not leave tonight.
Theo - Vivian suggests that they all try to cook together but it doesn't go very well. After dinner it gets brought up that they should look into moving together and Milo has already gotten deep into research about houses they could live in. they arrange a sleeping pattern that works for them 
Vivian - Matt shows up in front of her apartment basically trying to worm his way back into her life. in a more professional way she tells him to kick rocks. She then tells the guys and they come home quickly. then they order food. She believes that she is going to be okay.
Theo - He is having a spiral anxiety attack about this play off game and he texts the group for help. They all come and help in their own way. Game time comes and he does great and they win the layoff. He ends up kissing Vivian in front of some people and then cheek kisses the guys.
Milo - he sits everyone down and discusses basically a 4 way marriage proposal. He reads out his vows that he has for each person and how they matter to him and another for all 3 as a unit. He shows them the wedding bands that are 4 interlocking when together that he had designed for them.
Declan - He helps them slowly go public starting with the team manager, who knew the whole time but didn't say anything because it was ironically making everyone better. They told the team next who was accepting but had questions and playful ribbing. Declan then told his mother who spilled her secrets about the last marriage about not liking the wife and was happy that she is out of his life. She wants to meet the people that make her son happy-happy not performance happy.
Vivian - The goes house shopping and after 7 different showings they finally find the right one for them. They move in and while it's not all sunshine and rainbows they work together and have good communication skills for getting better and making sure their needs are addressed. They have the commitment ceremony *with no indication on how much time has passed* the manager of the team officiates. 
Milo - A year after the ceremony - they are happy living together in their house and live HEA.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Janice M.
53 reviews
January 26, 2026
Theirs to keep is a story about being brave and starting over. It’s about learning to trust when what you’ve known has been lies and gaslighting. Vivian had absolutely no reason to trust any of these men, but I love how they just decided that she was theirs to protect. I loved the growth these characters showed throughout the story. I love how each man has his own thing. A poetry love. A ball of anxiety. A distrust of women. Vivian was able to mend all three.

This quadruple fought so hard for each other and I loved how they stood up to her ex.

If you love:
Why choose
Protectors
Hockey
Past trauma
Found family
A journey to finding love and acceptance

Then this story is one you should definitely give a chance! As my first book by this author I was pleasantly surprised and very much devoured this story in one sitting!
Profile Image for Jenny.
836 reviews12 followers
February 15, 2026
This is NOT your typical why choose hockey romance. Yes, there are 3 hockey players all in a relationship with 1 woman (the new team psychologist) & yes, there are open-door sex scenes... but the focus on mental health is a predominant theme. & I can appreciate that. There are also some incredibly beautiful moments among the quartet,particularly in the last quarter of the book.
That being said, I do feel like the guys are a bit 2 dimensional and described primarily in connection with their mental health issues. And the ethical problem of a psychologist getting romantically involved with her patients is too casually dismissed... but this is fiction & romance so not exactly unexpected.
I'd give 3.5 stars but since GR doesn't provide for that, I round up in fairness to any one who actually writes & publishes a book (something I've not yet accomplished).
🌶🌶🌶
Profile Image for Johanna.
6,913 reviews125 followers
January 25, 2026
'I came to Seattle for redemption. I didn't expect it to come with three sets of very capable hands, a found family I never knew I needed, and the terrifying possibility that happily ever after might not look anything like I imagined.'

What a FANtastic read! Luv'd absolutely everything about this story.

The characters drove the storyline and they were so very appealing and complex and complicated and perfectly steamy together. Plot was intriguing and intense and exciting and well paced. World building was excellent and solidly drawn. Thoroughly enjoyed and highly recommend.

Grab a copy, kick back and enjoy!.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Meg.
7 reviews
June 18, 2026
This was a fairly quick read. I really like the tropes and its focus on mental health but this book is lacking something. I can’t tell you want it is but I didn’t feel things. I didn’t imagine the world this was words out on paper well. I think for some reads this will be great, if you like to lose yourself in mind movies when reading this just doesn’t have the fuel. Also might be worth a second read through and double check your names are right at least three spots where they had the wrong character listed for an action and they can not actively be doing both things it’s impossible, unless somehow this turned in to paranormal and I missed that. Beyond that, not a bad read but also probably north worth the effort of this review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Calie Hurley.
76 reviews1 follower
February 3, 2026
I like a good why choose book. Add hockey even better. My biggest thing was there wasn't really a structure. It felt like her ex kept popping up so randomly and just so out of context. It was all so rushed. I would have like a little more character building. It just jumped so quickly. I like the concept that they all made each want to better for each other but at same it seemed the men leaned on Vivian so much. I also wish there was more Milo content. We barely got any of his point of view. Even though this was a novella I felt like this could have turned into a novel easily with a little more structure. The idea of the book was great though.
Profile Image for Merry Jelks-Emmanuel.
15.8k reviews161 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
January 24, 2026
This story had me all caught up in Vivian and her men right from the beginning. She moved toa new city to get over her gaslighting ex and start anew. Vivian only wanted to focus on her work, but when she connects with three men who has problems of their own, it sets the stage for a unique connection that has them gravitating towards each other and their journey begins only for her ex to follow and start up trouble again. I loved this quadruple as they came together to overcome their challenges.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Barbara.
19.7k reviews8 followers
January 26, 2026
I thoroughly enjoyed this story and was captivated by Vivian’s journey from the start. Her move to a new city to escape her manipulating ex and focus on work provided a great foundation for her unique connection with three men Theo, Declan and Milo. Watching the four of them navigate their personal challenges and unite against her ex’s interference was wonderful. This is an exceptionally well-written book with a compelling storyline, memorable characters, and a very satisfying happy ending. I received a copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for EF Mac.
71 reviews
February 3, 2026
Sweet with a little spice

I loved this story. It was sweet and had good emotional depth and offered a little spice midpoint. The guys are all keepers, well written with distinct personalities and struggles. Theo is a typical goalie in the best way-goofy, sweet, a little crazy but so important. A complex enforcer and and the typical captain with control issues was a perfect mix. The MFC was okay. For me, her character took a back seat to the MMC's. There was growth but her character was dry.
The book was a quick read and a nice break from my typical dark reads.
Profile Image for SBee Reviews.
2,862 reviews86 followers
February 4, 2026
★ ”These ridiculous men had somehow decided that…” ★

“…my wellbeing was a group project.” Leaving her old job and nasty ex behind plants Vivian into a whole different nest of challenges while she treats the three hockey players identified as priority for the newly formed Seattle Sirens team. Her insight is exactly what they needed, and her company was bonus. But when her past catches up to her, it doesn’t take much to convince them that she needs them right back as well. Milo’s extreme research and background steals my heart in this story! Sweet and steamy sport romance!
Profile Image for &.
239 reviews
February 23, 2026
90% of this book is "telling" vs "showing", hence the plot moving at lightspeed. We're told within paragraphs at the start of each chapter how exactly things have been progressing or changing in the dynamic. We don't get very much of scenarios playing out to show character development, aside from some very blatant 'we're a family' moments where they talk about how different things are for them vs their past selves.

Also, none of the boyfriends are boyfriends.

2 stars because some satisfaction at the swift downfall of the ex, plus Milo's research.
Profile Image for Veronica.
282 reviews
March 11, 2026
Wow.

What a positively sweet love story. I love a good RH. I love a good sports story. This one has both.

Love comes in various shapes and forms. Heartbreak comes the same. When four people who have been hurt, lonely, and abused come together, they're either going to come together or bust.

These four people choose everyday to love each other. If you like a strong love that builds stronger, despite the flaws they carry, this one's for you.
Profile Image for Carolyn Meredith.
851 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
January 24, 2026
This is my second book by the author and I enjoyed this one so much more than the first. While there is a lot of drama, it does not have to do with them all working for the same team. That was refreshing. Also, it was more story than steam. I was beginning to wonder if I had accidently grabbed a closed door book. Then the steam hit. Well written with wonderful characters.
Profile Image for Sarah Freilinger.
873 reviews13 followers
January 28, 2026
Choose me

These four people found every way to come together. They fought every step of the way to find a peace. Theo, Declan, and Milo are hockey players that are forced into therapy by their coach, and Vivian is there therapist.
I loved this book. I loved the characters, I loved the story, I loved the realness of the book.
Profile Image for Jazriel.
132 reviews1 follower
May 2, 2026
This was actually pretty good, but I would’ve enjoyed it more had there been a little bit more suspense and I felt like they were getting to political in a sense with this book… I don’t know. I just feel like when you’re having more than one partner. You don’t need to tell the whole team in the whole world and marry all three of them. Maybe that’s just me and my issues but it just felt like everything was about the mental capacity all like I just felt like I needed to go to therapy because everything was just broken down like too much for a book
Profile Image for Alisha Pascual.
445 reviews23 followers
May 7, 2026
This was a pretty good read, I just didn’t like that there were a couple instences where dialouges between two characters sounded and looked like it was copy and pasted both times. There were also a lot of psycological and philosophical aspects which was different from most romance books i’ve read, and it was refreshing, but also I felt like it came up a lot. Besides that I really enjoyed this book. Vivian was a little broken from her previous relationship which changes when she encounters Declan, Milo, and Theo, the Captain, Enforcer, and the Goalie. Declan is very guarded from his past relationship, Milo is misunderstood, and Theo is a deflector. But each of those 4 characters slowly changes and heals with the love and support of each other. It was definitely a beautiful thing. You got to see their true selves emerge and bloom / flourish / thrive. Control with love from Declan, extensive research from Milo, goofy chaos from Theo, and the glue that holds everyone from Vivian.
Profile Image for Macey ONeill.
24 reviews
February 3, 2026
cute but left me wanting more

Short and cute but it seemed rushed and bounced around the timeline where I had to keep looking if I missed something. Some really good moments though.
251 reviews1 follower
May 10, 2026
An extremely cute Why-choose hockey romance!

4.5 stars, rounded up for Goodreads.

I enjoyed all three MMCs and the FMC. Each of the MMCs were distinctive, quirky and compelling. The spice was decent.
20 reviews
June 2, 2026
A book with communication between the characters is a clear 5* review for me! Love the growth and self awareness they all possessed. It was so refreshing to hear
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews