Romancing the Butch: A lesbian romantic comedy

by Elizabeth Andre

Genres: Lesbian

171 pages, Kindle Edition

Published February 6, 2026

About the author

Elizabeth Andre writes lesbian romance and cozy paranormal mysteries. She is a lesbian in an interracial same-sex marriage living in the Midwest. She hopes you enjoy her stories. She certainly loves writing them.

Reviews

[Nicole · Rating 3 out of 5]

Romancing the Butch is my second read by Elizabeth Andre. Her novels are well written, cleanly edited, and easy to read. This novel provided some laugh-out-loud moments and featured genuine, interesting, and diverse characters. This one-night-to-forever romance between opposites was low in angst and maintained an even pace. There were a couple of side plots that I enjoyed.
I did not feel any chemistry between Shelby and Hannah. They didn't spend a lot of time together on the page, and the sole sex scene was closed-door and recounted after the fact rather than shown. I could not relate to either character (maybe a me thing), although I really liked Shelby. I think that the even pacing and low level of angst also contributed to my lack of investment. It is a quick and easy read, not bad, just not very memorable.
The epilogue is not related to the current story. It sets up the next book, which takes place in the same location.
I am giving this one 3.5 stars, rounded down.
#LasVegas #weddingparty #oppositesattract #butchfemme #onenighttoforever #closeddoor #friendofafriend #socialmediaadbuyer #handyperson #HEA #epilogue
I received a review copy from the author. This is my honest opinion.

[Fran Sappharc · Rating 3 out of 5]

A romantic comedy. The first intimate scene happens off page. That is a deliberate ploy by the writer, I think, so we don’t get a handle on the mains or their relationship. My favourite intimate scenes are the ones where we learn more about the mains, we see them at their most open and vulnerable (often, not always but even then we usually see their internal vulnerability although they are choosing not to share that with the other main at that point…… anyway I digress, again!)
Just over half way and I feel I haven’t got a handle on either the attraction or either main. I have not gelled with this. There are a lot of named characters who only have a walk on role. I think being among so many names, followed by one sentence bio’s, coupled with not feeling I am particularly understanding one of the main/secondary character dynamics. Bits have been shown, we know the groom protected one main from bullies….. but…. I’m just not feeling I’m getting much. Which means the back and forth…. Is she interested or not, gets a bit irksome. 80% in and I’m not sure where the romancing the butch in the title comes from. To be honest, there is some silly stuff that nearly had me smiling but I am assuming the com part in rom com just means no to low angst.
I do not get the significance of the hat….. I really hope there is some explanation! There wasn’t!

[Mary · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was so cute! If you’re looking for a sweet sapphic romance to escape into and put you in a good mood then look no further. Romancing the Butch is a low angst interracial romcom that centers around a Las Vegas wedding party. Our main love interests Shelby and Hannah meet three months before the wedding trip during a dinner date with the newly engaged couple Zack and Whitney. Shelby is Zack’s best friend and soon to be best woman. Hannah is Whitney’s best friend and soon to be maid of honor. Hannah is entranced by Shelby’s brilliant blue eyes but can hardly get a glimpse of them because Shelby is always wearing a hat and looking down. Shelby is shy and there isn’t much conversation between the two during this first meeting.

Three months later they are on this wedding trip together and that’s when they really get to know more about each other. I would consider this a whirlwind romance as the trip is only Thursday through Sunday but the way Elizabeth Andre writes makes it feel more like a slow burn. There were some comical and cringey moments with other wedding guests and captivating side characters that made this a well rounded story and held my interest. This is a sweet romance with a closed door sex scene. I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to anyone looking for a low angst feel good romcom. Thank you Elizabeth Andre for the ARC!

[Mara · Rating 4 out of 5]

Romancing the Butch is a fast-paced, sweet, and funny read.

Hannah and Shelby's friends are convinced that they will be a great match for each other. Their first meeting however doesn't seem promising, and only reinforces the belief Hannah had that their friends are only matchmaking them, because they're both lesbians. The meeting was awkward at best, especially after finding out how different they are from each other.

But Vegas and wedding preparations gave them a second chance at getting to know each other, which went much better than the first one. Now they just have to figure out how to proceed forward. And maybe how to communicate with each other.

The story though quick, was engaging and funny. It was packed with action and laughter, but also had a great dose of sweetness and reflections. The characters are likeable (at least the ones that are supposed to be liked), and the chemistry between MCs is visible. The plot was interesting, and the writing easy to read.

If you're looking for a quick read with low angst, opposites attract, Vegas vibe, then I would definitely recommend to give this book a chance.

Big thank you to the author for giving me an opportunity to read this story. I had a great time.

[Siddie · Rating 4 out of 5]

Hannah is Whitney’s best friend, and at her forthcoming wedding to Zack, Hannah will be her maid of honour. She is looking forward to her friend’s wedding, but Whitney and Zack are trying to matchmake between her and Shelby, which Hannah doesn’t like. Zack’s butch best friend Shelby will be his best woman for the wedding, and when they all arrive in Vegas a few days beforehand, things start between Hannah and Shelby.
There is a very authentic lesbian feel to many of the scenes, but also sometimes a little stilted and difficult to follow. In many places this is a very funny story, like a sitcom (for example the taxi rides and the events at the reception), with some good wordplay (‘lesbianic fun’ - a wonderful word choice!) but overall it’s not a deep or really warm romance. Both main characters are written really well, and I found Shelby so cute, with her shy attitude and cluelessness as to how many women have been flirting with her. Most of the side characters are also good, especially Zack’s obvious adoration for Whitney, and Olly’s unexpected gay romance happening in the background.
A good read with low angst, laughs, and fun.

[diamondinthepages · Rating 4 out of 5]

Romance the Butch by Elizabeth Andre was such a fun, fast-paced, and genuinely cute read.
Thank you to the author for gifting me an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Shelby and Hannah were an absolute joy to watch fall in love. They meet just three months before their best friends’ wedding after said best friends attempt to play matchmaker (as best friends should). What starts as a setup turns into something way more when the wedding ends up being in Vegas… and well, what happens in Vegas might not stay in Vegas…
One night at a club quickly turns into something much bigger, and I loved how effortlessly their connection unfolded. The pacing was quick without feeling rushed, the romance was sweet and satisfying, and the chemistry between Shelby and Hannah made it impossible not to root for them.
This was a really enjoyable sapphic romance that left me smiling, and I’ll absolutely be keeping an eye out for more from Elizabeth Andre.
Highly recommend if you’re in the mood for a light, romantic, Vegas-style “one night leads to forever” love story

[Monna]

“Romancing the Butch” is a lovable romance from Elizabeth Andre. Take two opposites, make them Best Woman and Maid of Honor to their straight best friends, mix them all together and you have Hannah and Shelby in Las Vegas for the nuptials. This is a quick read laced with humor and some crazy secondary characters. Hannah and Shelby aren’t impressed with each other when they meet. Hannah, the extroverted femme, has several preconceived notions about Shelby, the shy butch woman with downcast eyes hiding behind her hat. Both women end up doing some soul searching. You’ll enjoy Shelby’s epiphanies about herself—they’re funny. If you’re a fellow introvert you will nod your head in solidarity.

[Donna Reed · Rating 4 out of 5]

Standout cover and great title. The prologue introduces us to the meeting of the 4 main characters in time for the Los Vegas wedding in 3 months time. We meet a greatbunch of friends
Great introduction  to officiate Madame Sinjin. Loved the female Elvis impersonator idea
What do two lesbians do at a straight wedding in Los Vegas? Yes,  escape to a local lesbian bar.
This is a tale of picking up a shy, naieve, introverted butch at a wedding in Vegas. Great reading with low angst and a smile

[Sarah Taylor · Rating 4 out of 5]

First I want to say thank you for receiving this eARC! This was so freaking cute and I couldn’t put it down. I loved the banter in the beginning and the story kept getting better! It is low angst, opposites attract, Butch/Femme , and rom-com. This book made me kick my feet like a teenager lol. 10/10 would recommend!
Z@@@

Again thank you for this eARC!

[Mx Phoebe · Rating 4 out of 5]

Romancing the Butch is the Valentine escape you need. There are some great lines and some funny moments. Sometimes what happens in Vegas should happen everywhere.

“Thank you, Tulabella Ruby Press, for providing this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.”

[Julie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Romancing the Butch : lesbian romance comedy was fast paced, enjoyable and very funny , a perfect sapphic romance

I received a free ARC copy for review