Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Siren

Rate this book
The new novel from acclaimed, three-time instant #1 New York Times–bestselling author Tomi Adeyemi blends shocking contemporary storytelling with a sinister dark academic flair to create a blockbuster about rage, longing, and a woman’s darkness that will leave readers breathless.

Nothing is more intoxicating than power. . .

When Emery steps foot onto Dartmouth’s campus, she knows what she has to keep her scholarship, take her meds, and pray no one ever finds out about the past she left behind.

But that all changes when Emery meets an intoxicating girl named Roux, her disarming stepbrother named Eli, and the mystical band of girls Roux calls “The Sirens.” Each Siren is as beautiful as the last, and their lives on campus are shrouded in extravagance and secret parties. Before the girls became Sirens, they were outcasts, yet under Roux, their wildest dreams come true. When Roux offers Emery the chance to join them, Emery will do whatever it takes to make it in.

Even if it costs Emery her life.

323 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 29, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Tomi Adeyemi

17 books21.8k followers
Tomi Adeyemi is a Nigerian-American writer and creative writing coach based in San Diego, California. Her debut novel, CHILDREN OF BLOOD AND BONE, comes out March 6th, 2018 and the movie is currently in development at Fox with the producers of Twilight and The Maze Runner attached. After graduating Harvard University with an honors degree in English literature, she received a fellowship that allowed her to study West African mythology and culture in Salvador, Brazil. When she’s not working on her novels or watching Scandal, she can be found blogging and teaching creative writing to her 3,500 subscribers at tomiadeyemi.com. Her website has been named one of the 101 best websites for writers by Writer’s Digest.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
91 (14%)
4 stars
155 (25%)
3 stars
221 (36%)
2 stars
96 (15%)
1 star
48 (7%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 230 reviews
4 reviews
Read
February 4, 2026
Does anyone else find it incredibly odd that she used her own face for the cover? Is this a memoir or fiction? The "absolutely true" part and the cover makes me think memoir, but the summary sounds like fiction.

Did she switch to Indie?
Profile Image for Monte Price.
966 reviews2,693 followers
October 3, 2026
At the risk of sounding hyperbolic I don't think I've read a worse book in all my life.

Earlier this year I finally got around to finishing their debut series, The Legacy of Orïsha [ [book:Children of Anguish and Anarchy|68310983] ], and felt that it was the most here damn conclusion we could have received. It was full of new characters and locations that felt shoehorned in to give fans a finale but in such a way that couldn't live up to the five year wait between novels.

Now just a couple years later we have what has been described of the book of Adeyemi's soul, and besties I'm sorry to say that this book is completely devoid of anything. Everything falls flat; the writing, the characters, and the vibes that the book rests upon.

Here we follow Emery as she seeks to reinvent herself as a freshman at Dartmouth only to be seduced by a group of young women known as The Sirens. They might not be a sorority in the traditional sense, but they're the close enough for the purposes of the book. What the streets have called dark academia is just a book set on a college campus; and while it's not unusual for the academia part of this latest marketing trend to be lacking here it is essentially nonexistent. Time is essentially fluid in this novel, but Emery's coursework doesn't matter at all. In fact very little in this novel matters until a character brings something up in dialogue to let the reader know that this thing we never actually saw is something that has happened.

Much like their debut series Adeyemi pens a romance subplot that is essentially instalove with no compelling depth to make the reader even attempt to embrace that decision. It helps of course that there are no other male characters is distract from how lacking Eli is. The fact that there is some sapphic vibes introduced in the way that all books wherein our protagonist is seduced by a mysterious group of women often have does very little to distract from the weird instalove competent of the book either.

All of these characters, though the Sirens in particular, are hardly differentiated from one another. Emery's standout trait is how often she refers to herself as broken and wanting to put her time in a psych ward behind her. The narrative also plays with the idea of whether she is to be believed and if we can rely on what she's saying because of her mental instability.

For some reason this is also a trial book. It makes sense in a way, if we're rushing this pseudo Sorority what is hazing but contemporary trials... but it just falls flat even as the stakes are raised. In part because as the reader I was so disconnected from the bland sameness coming from all the characters. There was also an inevitability that Emery would make it through to the end and so did it matter? At several turns it's clear that Sirens are really only interested in Emery because the Sirens are really just Roux and much like her stepbrother she is drawn to Emery.

Much of this book could have been written off as mediocre. It's really how Adeyemi chose to end the novel that took things to worst book territory. To me that was simply unforgivable for how fucking silly it was. By that point maybe I was wrong for expecting some level of seriousness, but even I couldn't have imagined how unserious things would be.

I truly can't imagine recommending this to anyone. If you are going to ignore my warnings about how bad the book is just known it is an attempt at tackling some actual dark subject matter like assault, simulated school violence, death, and messily handled discussions around mental health.
Profile Image for Zana.
1,069 reviews451 followers
October 11, 2026
Edited: adding excerpts from the author's FMC's poetry because this shit is killing me.

Damn girl who hurt you??? 😬

This would've been a solid 2.5 stars if my eardrums and eyeballs weren't subjected to her fuck ass wannabe Rupi Kaur/Nayyirah Waheed/Tumblr poetry.

Combined with that shitty ass ending, this turned out to be a mid hate read. Amusing at times, but ultimately forgettable.


there was
a

time.

the angels
spoke
to me
so
LOUD-ly.

but

no

one else


could hear.


there was
a boy

i used

to

LOVE.


we met

in

darkness

and

counted

the

STARS.


the angels
told

me


SECRETS.

listen closely.
so


YOU
can
hear.


SHE
was like
the stormy
sea.

like
the dark
clouds

twisting above
the
black tide.

like the faintest glimmers


of the


setting sun,


fighting through


THE coming NIGHT


just to
shine.
Profile Image for h i n d .
452 reviews465 followers
Want to Read
February 8, 2026
intrigued? it's not what i expected, and idk about the cover, but i will be reading
Profile Image for Lee.
246 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
July 21, 2026
2.75-3 range

I quite enjoyed the beginning and ending of this one, though the rest didn't quite land for me.

At the start, I was drawn in by Emery's enigmatic character, her arrival at Dartmouth, and her navigation of those first days as she met roommates, went to (and hated) frats, and found herself lured in by the Sirens. I could definitely feel Emery's desperation to be like them, alive and wild, in a way she feels she hasn't been. I could relate to her wanting college to be a fresh start to remake herself.

I was drawn in by the culty vibes of the Sirens themselves, along with the 'trials' and competition to 'get in' to their group. I think the competition element was my favorite part, and if you want to read about unhinged college hazing, this one is definitely for you!

I also appreciated how Emery's relationship with her mom was highlighted. As someone who also struggled heavily with mental health during college and frequently turned to my mom as my grounding source, I could relate to their connection.

Emery's character definitely changes throughout the story, and it was interesting to see how she fell into the group and mindset; I think she definitely meets her goal of becoming a different version of herself, but even after reading I'm still debating whether it was in a positive direction (which I like - I appreciate having something to think about after!).

The end was definitely surprising, and I really enjoyed how it went in a direction I wasn't expecting! Throughout the whole story, there's a constant mystery surrounding the group of girls, and I was glad to get a sort of 'answer' to who/"what" they are.

That said, I really struggled with the rest of the book. Here are my 'okays':
- While initially drawn in by the mystery of Emery's character herself, I felt like I never got to know her. I always felt like an outsider despite the book being largely character-driven and focused on her POV.
- I found the romance superficial/unbelievable.
- Sometimes the approach to mental health felt off to me. . . almost romanticized??
- I felt that the Sirens were indistinguishable from one another.
- I don't think the 'academia' atmosphere really comes through. Though plot points take place in/on campus property, we don't see Emery going to class much, interacting with other students, etc. Her entire focus seems to be on the Sirens and their trials (which were compelling), but this made it harder for me to reconcile how she's still excelling at school.
- The very end feels a little chopped off. Particularly, the last few sentences introduce an event that made me feel as though the story had come to a close to feeling like it wasn't over; I would have liked a little more clarity and/or an epilogue of some sort (as I believe this is a standalone).

Thanks to the publisher for an early copy to read and review; all opinions are my own.
1 review
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
April 29, 2026
Tomi said this is the best book she's ever written so I can't even blame the publisher the way I did for COAAA.

+ the "poetry" in this book is what you thought was deep when you were 12
+ characters constantly telling the FMC how beautiful she is when it's the author's face on the cover
+ how did Emery make the dean's list when she never reads a book or studies or goes to class? I kept forgetting she was even in college.
+ I get it, Emery is obsessed with the Sirens. They frame a young Black student and have her sent to prison. Emery doesn't care. They sexually assault her best friend and humiliate her so badly she has to leave school. Emery doesn't care. I thought she was going to turn on them and smash the system. But she's too busy getting high and drunk and describing the matching Prada headbands these dumb bitches wear. (was she getting a fee from Prada? she should for the amount of pagetime)
+ I'm not even going to get into the "twist" which came out of nowhere and made no sense.

I have to accept Tomi's first book was a fluke because everything after has been a letdown.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Chlo.
421 reviews52 followers
September 1, 2026
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This was simply put - very bad, in my opinion. I don’t even know where to start.

It is not clear what this book wants to be. On the cover of my arc it says it’s a YA dark academia with a supernatural edge. It contains content way too old for YA, but the characters act like they’re 12. There’s drug taking, drinking, hazing, assault…which should not be marketed as young adult.

The “supernatural edge” line is also a huge spoiler and literally happens right at the end but I was waiting for it the whole time.

There are also next to no features of a dark academia text here. You can’t just set a story at a university and do some hazing and expect it to be classed as dark academia??

Huge gaps of information are missing. Emery makes the deans list despite there being little to no discussion of her going to class or completing assignments.

It’s often not clear what mental state Emery is in. You have no idea whether she has been sleeping regularly or taking her medication until it’s sprung on you out of
Convenience or seemingly as an afterthought.

Psychiatrist appointments are scheduled with no follow ups. I can’t tell if her MH issues are to confuse the reader and have them question what’s real or not, or whether it’s purely to “explain” some of the despicable shit she does.

Side note - one of the things she does is TRULY, TRULY awful and there is seemingly NO self reflection and she gets to continue as she was???

Most of this book truly read like it was written by a teenager, including the ridiculous romance plot line.
The characters barely spoke before exchanging I love yous.

Certain phrases and descriptions are repeated incessantly. Her name, Emery, is mentioned in almost every sentence. “Prada headband”, “Marley twists”, “blue bow”, “flower painted boots”, “the siren”, “white boots”… oh my GOD. They were mentioned so many times I was both convinced that the character never changes her clothes and the author must think I’m stupid.

The poems Emery writes were just so bad I did consider whether they were rage bait at one point.
The use of scattering words across the page to convey her “madness” in the poems was just annoying rather than having an emotional impact. I just found our FMC pathetic.
She was a horrible person, horrible daughter, student, friend…I’m glad that’s all over.
Profile Image for fleshy.
198 reviews52 followers
November 7, 2026
The author screamed "Sasuke!" during an interview, which was so hilarious to me that I had to check out this book. It's fascinating how the author put herself on the cover, and how the main character is routinely praised for her beauty, brilliance, and writing acumen.

I knew I wouldn't like this fairly early on, based on the poor quality of the writing alone, but I kept going, I guess to see how much worse it would get. I got a good laugh out of the "poetry," so there's that. Seriously, refrigerator magnet poetry.

The story is about this girl Emery who goes to Dartmouth and becomes captivated by a group of older girls, particularly their ringleader Roux. Despite being an introvert, and wanting to go to Dartmouth to study writing, Emery quickly abandons her aspirations so that she can join their clique, the Sirens. She believes this will transform her into a different person. I don't know why Emery wants that. She also has an unspecified mental illness, and is neglecting her treatment. Within days of starting college Emery is drinking, smoking weed, and fantasizing about being one of the cool girls.

The plot is largely concerned with Emery going through various trials to join the Sirens. Between these events she composes her shitty poetry, has guilt trips about her mom (who Emery refers to by her first name), and gets crossfaded. Despite her scholarship and dreams of academia, we only see Emery in one class. How she makes it onto the dean's list is the biggest mystery in the book.

The trials that Emery and several other girls participate in are hazing rituals. They drink, they use drugs, they burglarize the campus. One girl gets arrested, another ends up naked on the street. Between these we have brief interludes of Emery wrestling the moral quandary of being part of this culture of voyeurism and cruelty. But, not for long. Any concerns Emery has, any inkling of introspection, is swept away by her really wanting this, for some reason. In her own words,

"She was... a very dangerous girl.
She was... one with the stars."


This was the sort of book where I took issue with everything. Like, Emery sees some lacrosse players passing a football. How does she know they're lacrosse players? They have a football. Wouldn't the assumption be football players? Or when Emery is looking up Roux. How did she know the name was spelled like that? Why not Rue, or Roo? Why would her first guess be Roux? Emery has inexplicable, omniscient knowledge, almost like she is the author.

I didn't buy any of the relationships in the book, they were all underdeveloped. I didn't buy Emery's motivation for wanting to be a Siren . There's no sense of time; the events all seem to take place in the span of two months. Emery never mentions having fall term exams. Stupid sticking point, but Emery refers to the academic term as a "semester." Dartmouth is on a quarter system.

The ending tries to be surreal.

That all of this bullshit was is incredibly disappointing. There is no self-actualization here.

The writing is truly horrible, a middle schooler's idea of depth. There are pointless line breaks which are meant to be emphatic but are instead inelegant, scene breaks in the middle of scenes, trite descriptions, and it is packed with strained similes. The author kept using "blond" instead of "blonde." There is a strange, telescoping POV throughout. Sometimes we are in Emery's head, then the next line will be a distant narrator. The narrative states and restates the obvious. Characters are referred to variously as "the Siren," "the comet," "the Valkyrie," "the pledge." Was an editor involved at any point?

Emery's episodes of psychosis are as clunky as the white Prada headband the Sirens make her wear.

"Emery breathed in as the world turned sapphire green.

Like the color of the old gods.

Like the fires that had never stopped burning.

Like the snakes that slithered out of the abyss.

Emery reached out through the glimmering darkness, wandering through the liminal space that had once been a forest. Skeletal hands rose from the dirt. They laid pomegranate seeds behind every step she took. Empty prescription bottles littered the twisting path in front of her."


Is this supposed to be profound?


After fingering Emery, Eli picks up a photograph taken by his late mother. Dude didn't even wipe off his hand.


"She could feel every time his father’s jaw had collided with his mother’s face."

What the fuck does that mean? Was he headbutting her?


"Their bare-chested fraternity partners stood on opposite sidelines, raising their pom-poms and flouncing in their red-and-white shirts."

Are they bare-chested, or are they wearing shirts? (I'm sure it's supposed to be skirts. There are a number of typos in the book.)


Rue smiled in her ear. ??? You mean against her ear?



I'm not into dark academia, but there was nothing dark nor academic about this. This was drug-induced shenanigans on a college campus, words artlessly cobbled together, with all the depth of a puddle.



=)
Profile Image for Ivana - Diary of Difference.
680 reviews955 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 27, 2026
Wow, just wow... I have so many thoughts about this book...

And talk about an unreliable narrator. I don't even know if everything I read was real, or a fantasy. The ending was so mesmerising and confusing at the same time.
Profile Image for Heather Storm.
16 reviews
Review of advance copy
April 29, 2026
I was instantly enraptured by this book. The MC Emery was instantly relatable to me, with her anxiety and the stories she's been told about herself hit home. 

If you've ever felt that you didn't belong, this book is one for you. It challenges you to understand how far you'll go to belong, to find friends, and consider the consequences.

Additionally, The poetry was brilliant.
Profile Image for I'mogén.
1,469 reviews51 followers
Review of advance copy
July 1, 2026
Read for a super secret project!

I was so excited when I saw this was one of my titles to review, but... I'm not sure I liked it all that much...

Straight away I struggled with getting to know our MC, Emery, because it was apparent that she was trying to move away from her fractured mindset and past, but in turn was hiding information from the reader, which made me constantly feeling like I was missing key information and made it increasingly more difficult to connect to her character and feel grounded in the plot.

Despite being alluring and hypnotic in many ways, I simultaneously couldn't help but think how ridiculous everything was and could feel my face scrunching up in disbelief and irritation.
It would probably work well for a movie, but as a book, despite only being a little over 300 pages, it felt like so much was happening that it felt like a slog to push through, but also that nothing really was happening because I didn't really get the story and felt so disconnected to the book.

In fact, as I was about 2/3rds in, I still had this feeling of confusion about what was going on (that felt like it was being disguised as the mystique and allure of the sirens), if there was going to be more darker magical elements or if it was going to go more down the route of the pressures of the mind in a high achieving school and temptations of power through popularity.
By the end, stuff got weirder and I was still left thinking "what the hell did I read?". Like, things happened but also nothing happened... I couldn't get a grasp on what sort of story this was trying to be.

There were some interesting themes of mental health and the pressures of university life, but I don't feel like they were explored in any meaningful way and the depth just felt kind of forced. There was a lot of drinking and drugs and the general party life and trying to rush for certain circles that felt cultish, but it all still felt very surface level. Despite seeing that care was taken to delve a bit deeper, it just never felt like it was thoroughly pulled off to that effect.

There was a part where the sirens walk into class that really had me thinking of the Twilight scene where Bella first encounters the Cullens. I just visualised it in slow motion and layered over it the details she later looked up.

The only character I actually liked was Eli! I didn't get how his arc was interconnected or, by the end, the point of the strange twist, but he was a character (and Lila, Emery's mum) that I cared about the most.

It's a shame really because the more I write about it, the more I realise how annoyed I'm left feeling about The Sirens... Not sure if I could really recommend it because I don't know who I would recommend to. But it has some cool dark vibes and unlikeable characters that do messed up stuff, if you're into that.

The plot felt lacking and as there was no redeemable aspects to our main characters, I was disappointed to find myself not finding other elements to suck me in to their individual growths.

Pick it up, give it a go & enjoy!
Profile Image for Diana.
180 reviews23 followers
September 8, 2026
disclaimer: this was read and reviewed before publication date as an ARC via NetGalley, thanks to the publisher. i leave this review of my own volition. all thoughts and opinions are my own.

2.5 STARS
(rounded up to 3)

this is not suitable to be marketed for YA. i’ve double-checked and triple-checked to confirm this, and it is so. while it isn’t outright spicy, there are scenes and things happening in the story that crosses a very thin line. sure, the main character and participating characters are of consensual age. but to say this is okay for 14-year-olds to read is something left for parental discretion. aside from a handful of almost sexually explicit scenes, there’s the forcing of taking drugs, under age drinking, and a planned fake shooting. these, imo, are too heavy topics for young minds. so i knocked off one-star.

as for the story itself… i have so many mixed feelings. it gets very dark and covers some traumatic topics concerning mental health. the FMC, Emery, is navigating the biggest change of her life as a new freshman at Dartmouth. despite having only lived such a short life, her mental health isn’t exactly stable. she’s been in a psych ward and has done things in the past that still eats at her, but hopes college will be the opportunity for her to find her place in the world. then, she runs into The Sirens—a small group of girls that Emery finds herself wanting to join. how far will she go and what is she willing to sacrifice to finally fit in?

the pages of poetry peppered throughout the book to showcase Emery’s state of mind was a nice touch. it’s giving the readers an extra insight to her mental chaos. like she’s not quite put together but she’s trying to make sense of herself. Emery also makes a ton of bad choices, despite everything in her warning her not to. it reminds the readers that she’s still young, naive, and just overall lost. she practically commits crimes just to feel like she’s getting pieces of herself out of them.

as for the layer of romance in this, it almost felt like it could do without. but the ending also needed her to care. it’s like that devastating, soul-shattering love. it just felt too fast for how it all happens. just thought it spoke more of infatuation than love, but that’s just me. i do love that Emery finds a friend in Ozlie though. another person who sees her before Emery even sees herself. she deserved Ozlie more than Roux. *side eye*

would i recommend it? depends on the audience. i wouldn’t encourage those who struggle with self-harm to read this, even though some of the writing could be uplifting. it’s readable, just needs a thorough warning before you dive in.
Profile Image for Lauren.
233 reviews4 followers
September 27, 2026
Thank you NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC of Siren!

Unfortunately this was a miss for me. The writing is beautifully done, but the story just wasn’t there for me. It seemed like every decision Emery made was really bad to the point of making me wonder how she got into an Ivy League school. Her essay must have really been something because that girl has no head on her shoulders.

The author narrates this book herself and she does a good job of that. You can see and feel the pride the author has in this book and hope this book finds the audience that will love it. Unfortunately I am not that audience.

Also, SEVEN SLEEPING PILLS? Were you trying to drug him or murder him?!
14 reviews1 follower
October 6, 2026
Because of the reviews I'd seen I was unsure what to expect from this book and was preparing myself to be confused. But it had me hooked from the start. It is really well written and it honestly feels like you are watching a movie. I feel like the author gave the reader just enough information about Emerys time in the psych ward. I didn't need to know more. The story was not about then but Emery's time after this. I also loved the fact that she was wearing marley twists!

I thought the relationships were well written and Eli and Emery's mum always felt like a type of comfort and safety the reader could come back to.
At no point was I confused I feel like the author skillfully took the reader along the journey in an easy and accessible way. I think I was more so shocked at the end but given the title I should have expected it. I'm not one for sad or scary stories. So I definitely struggled to sleep that night. The emotions from the story as well as the moral lessons kind of all hit you at once.

This was a really interesting read and I'm sure this book will find its people.
Profile Image for A H.
110 reviews4 followers
October 26, 2026
I think this is only the second or third book I've ever given a less than 1 ⭐ review to. This was BAD, like really really bad. I LOVE Tomi. The Children of Orïsha books are one of my absolute favorites. This, I don't know wtf this was. The writing is bad, the plot is bad, not a single likeable character or redeeming quality for them or moment. The journal entries are just, out of place and make no sense. And the ending? WTF even WAS that!? I get it but at the same time I don't? Are they all dead people walking around? Are they born again hell minions? I wouldn't recommend this book to my worst enemy.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Whitney Grace.
110 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 10, 2026
First and foremost I want to give a huge thanks to NetGalley for giving me this audiobook ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This book was absolutely not for me. I don’t know enough about the genre of dark academia, but the impression this left on me was largely negative. If anything, this book made me want to do a wellness check on Tomi Adeyemi. I got the audiobook version, so I can’t speak to whether the ebook version has trigger warnings, but this book most certainly needs them. I don’t think this book should be marketed as YA, it’s definitely not that. Even though the protagonist is a freshman in college, what she goes through, what she does, and the events that take place are pretty mature.

The protagonist’s struggle with mental illness is handled in a way that feels disrespectful. And I think the way she is represented will ultimately do more harm than good. There were 2 side characters that I liked, but they weren't really explored, at least not as much as I would have liked.

Maybe this is the author’s way of lashing out. Maybe this is her middle finger to the industry, and an analogy of how fame draws you in, changes you, and ruins your life. Maybe this is a cry for help. And if that’s the case I hope there are people in her life who see her, and support her.

I love Tomi. I also can’t in good conscience recommend this book.
Profile Image for Ricky.
Author 8 books192 followers
February 3, 2026
Tomi Adeyemi is back with something completely different: dark academia in a modern setting at Dartmouth University, following a young woman with well buried mental health issues as she gets involved with the most secret of secret sororities, and their supernatural surprises.

Unsurprisingly, a lot of people have thought this was some kind of autobiography, especially with Adeyemi being her own cover model and audiobook narrator this time around. Not to mention her cutting ties with the Children of Blood and Bone film cast and crew, and declaring she would never allow another film adaptation of her work, though that’s a discussion for another day. (FWIW though I will still see CoBaB in theaters.)

But this book, while very beautifully packaged and hauntingly poetic (seriously, Emery’s poems are a highlight)…I really hope Adeyemi doesn’t plan to leave it as just a standalone. Not with that abrupt ending. But if there’s one thing we’ve learned about Adeyemi over the years, my birthday twin (no kidding, she and I were born on the exact same day) got all the Leo energy, and she’ll do whatever the hell she wants. Just like real Siren would.
Profile Image for Timitra.
1,965 reviews13 followers
October 2, 2026
Rated 2.5 Stars

I was really excited to dive into The Siren because it sounded good but it didn't work for me on many levels. It had its moments but for the most part it was a dud. The characters weren't well drawn nor were the relationships well developed especially the romance. It was lackluster at best. There was a lot of telling rather than showing, lots of contradictions too. The narrative was choppy in places. Even while it irritated me like a siren it lured me into continuing to read it. I kept reading for one reason only to see how it ended only to be annoyed and disappointed by the ending. In this moment I feel regret for finishing it instead of dnfing.



Copy provided by publisher through NetGalley
2 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 23, 2026
As an English teacher, I think the most annoying criticism of a book is when someone says a book is "too YA" or that they won't read something because it is YA. Good writing is good writing no matter the audience. An author, who wields their craft with precision and expertise, can weave a compelling story with complex characters and an intriguing plot. Unfortunately, The Siren carries none of those aforementioned attributes. The writing is juvenile in content and syntax. The character development is implied, but non-existent. The novel is marketed as "dark academia," yet I wonder if the author, a supposed college graduate, actually experienced college, especially since aside from a few outlandish scenes from a freshman seminar, never mentions the actual academia part of college. This novel was petulant, the writing immature, and frankly, the epitome of what I imagine people who hate on novels classified as "YA." While I am a firm believer that there's an audience for every book, this novel is sure to be a disappointment for most
Profile Image for Kera’s Always Reading.
2,253 reviews95 followers
September 25, 2026
While there are aspects of this story I thought were really interesting and creative, I definitely had to push myself to get through it. I never enjoy giving reviews for books I didn't like, but here we are.

I usually like to reserve judgment of an mc until I get to know their motives. With Emery, I couldn't understand why she makes the decisions she makes, and throwing a mental health blanket over it isn't personally believable. Even when alarms are going off in her head, she makes choices that had me scratching my head. I struggled with the believability of the intense draw to the sirens, the romantic aspects, and the overall reason the sirens do what they do. Someone went through something horrible, tragic, and heartbreaking, and the way they conduct themselves after in is direct regard to the protection of one single person above everyone else.

This is my first Tomi Adeyemi novel, but I have always wanted to read this author's work. I just wish that I didn't start with this one.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Leslie aka StoreyBook Reviews.
3,084 reviews214 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 23, 2026
Fantasy can be hit or miss for me, but this one is intriguing. It focuses on a new college student with mental health issues, and her desire to become a part of a secret society. But is it worth it? What will she have to give up in order to join The Sirens?

Emery is a character that, while I can't relate to her situation, I can relate to her desire to be a part of something greater than she is and to make a mark in this world. She has endured a lot, and to make it into Dartmouth is no small feat. She does get stuck with a roommate that thinks she and Emery will be best friends and do everything together. That changes when Emery chooses to not go through sorority recruitment, and is focused on another organization. This is where I have to give the author credit, she does use the Greek organizations that are on the campus. You can imagine I was a bit surprised when I saw my sorority listed, but we are on that campus, so that gave extra weight to the validity of the organizations and her research in providing an accurate representation.

I enjoyed the book up until about 80%. I don't remember the exact point, but the book went sideways for me. Emery has done everything she needed to do to be accepted as the single new member to The Sirens, but then strange things happen. At that point, after certain conversations, I wondered if this was real or in her mind and she was having a delusion in a mental facility. Also, the ending just abruptly ends. I have no idea if there will be another book to explain that ending. 

There is a lot going on in this book, and most of it was very enjoyable because I didn't want to put the book down. I just can't explain, or understand, the end of the book. Others might, and that is why there is a book for everyone.

We give this book 3 paws up.
Profile Image for Jessica.
456 reviews39 followers
September 16, 2026
*Thank you to the publisher for the free copy for review*

Review: The premise of Adeyemi’s latest will certainly draw readers in, but the novel itself may struggle to hold their attention.

“The Siren” follows Emery Coleman, a freshman at Dartmouth College, as she is swept up into the world of a mystical band of girls called “The Sirens.” When Roux, their leader, offers Emery the chance to join them, Emery will do whatever it takes to make it in.

For all intents and purposes, “The Siren” has the makings of a good thriller. Adeyemi skillfully crafts a tense Ivy League environment that places pressure on Emery, the main character, to fit in. With time, it is revealed that her desire to do so stems from having spent time in a psychiatric ward. Her past calls her narration into question, which will keep readers on their toes as they try piece together the true motivation of The Sirens and uncover the mystery shrouding them. Adeyemi incorporates Emery’s actual poetry to showcase her emotional arc as the story progresses.

Unfortunately, issues with pacing and characterization ultimately make this story fall flat. Significant time jumps occur so that the reader’s focus is on the trials Emery must undergo to be inducted into the secret society. These time jumps make it more difficult to get to know the characters when they are not in the midst of high stakes situations and the underlying themes of mental health suffer for it. Additionally, the gaps in the timeline are where relationship development would typically occur. As a result, the romantic subplot involving Emery and Roux’s stepbrother Eli is harder to invest in, their instant attraction practically unbelievable.

The ambiguous resolution will frustrate some and shock others as they recover from Adeyemi’s sinister twists in the final act.

➤ 3 stars

Review cross-posted to:
Book Blog | Bookstagram | Amazon
Profile Image for Sierra| HooksxBooks.
412 reviews18 followers
October 1, 2026
THE SIRENNNNN!!!! OHHH MY GAAHHHH,

This book is my introduction to Tomi Adeyemi, and baby, I had a blast.

Emery gets to Dartmouth battling with her own demons. She gets their and immediately falls in love with Eli and is mesmerized by Roux and the Sirens. Following Emery's experience with rush week and all of the things that come from trying to become a Siren.

Everything she hears from about the Sirens is negative. She's told to steer clear, to run or to try to join another sorority. The Sirens are dangerous.

The end of this story was a shock to the system. I wish there was another book or additional details about how the Sirens work and exist.

I'm still shocked and in awe, and I finished this book last night. The book ended and I just sat there, baffled.


I received this ALC from NetGalley.
Profile Image for Michelle Miller.
185 reviews2 followers
July 31, 2026
I received an ARC for this book.

I really wanted to like this book. I enjoyed the beginning and was intrigued by the ending. Everything in the middle felt rather long winded and frustrating. Spoilers below.

What I liked:

- Tomi Adeyemi is a beautiful writer. She paints beautiful pictures of the gorgeous collegiate backdrop and the world the Sirens inhabit.

- I liked being introduced to Emery and her back story. I initially liked her relationship with her mother and her introduction to this new world. I was intrigued by all that had come before her freshman year in college and was curious to learn more.

- The ending was a page turner and I was anxious to resolve the story and find out the truth behind these Sirens.

What I disliked:

- I didn't learn more about her back story and wished that that part of the story had had more depth. As the reader, I didn't feel like I understood the nuance of what she had been through and how she got to where she was. The pain felt real but the experience felt surface level. I wanted real memories that gave an idea of what Emery experienced, not continuous references to this difficult time in her life.

- I didn't enjoy the romantic relationship formed between Eli and Emery. It formed quickly and lacked a real connection for me. All of a sudden it was love. They didn't even really know each other. And it went up and down all of the time. One day they were together and it was incredible and then she would stop talking to him. I didn't believe their connection. It felt surface level.

- Aside from Roux, the Sirens felt interchangeable to me. I couldn't tell one from the other. I wish there were less of them and we learned more about each. I also didn't understand their appeal. I think that's what felt the most frustrating. I didn't understand Emery's decisions and choices because I didn't understand the appeal of the Sirens. Why was trashing her whole life, becoming this version of herself, pushing away her mother, all worth it to become this new version of herself that she coveted? While I understand it on the surface, it lacked so much depth. On the surface, Emery coveted being someone else only to embrace herself. It just didn't exist for me in the writing why it was so important to her to sacrifice so much and hurt people (or see them get hurt), all to become a Siren. They didn't seem that amazing. Sure they looked great and had great clothes and beautiful residence, but again, surface level. Why was that so important? I put the book down at one point and didn't pick it up for over a week because I hated her decision at one point. A lot of it felt... unsubstantiated for me.

- There were a couple holes that weren't accounted for and that bothered me a bit.

- As a daughter of a single mother, how she treated her pissed me off.

- At various moments, I thought the whole Sirens thing was made up in a severe psychosis from lack of meds. Or she'd wake up in a hospital and she never had met the Sirens or gone to Dartmouth and that was what she would imagine in her catatonic psychosis. I think I would have been intrigued by that ending too.

- Is this a standalone? Because it ended on a cliffhanger and while I don't want to read a second book, I do want to know what happened there.

- I felt a bit confused about the genre. Is it YA? It read YA to me but then there were some spicy inferences. Is it fantasy/sci fi? It didn't feel that way for most of the book but then it does. There are also some religious undertones (which were interesting but I wish was resolved more).

- Finally, while the ending was intriguing, there was also some mystery to what actually happened and who was involved. I was interested reading the end but I wasn't super satisfied about what I read.

Thank you for the arc. I'm curious what others think about it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Elle.
619 reviews45 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 8, 2026
I had the best time reading this!

It follows Emery as she goes to collage for her freshman year. She’s carrying a lot of pain and mental health problems that we come to understand as the story unfolds. The book is full of snippets of her poems that were fantastic is showing us her darkest thoughts and how was she feeling about things. I really loved how it was formatted too as it added a lot to the tone of the story.

Emery doesn’t fit in and after a few attempts at ‘normal’ collage life, she stumbles upon the sirens, a group of powerful, beautiful, confident women. She’s irrevocable drawn to them, in particular their leader, Roux.
She is drawn to the sirens, knowing they have transformed themselves and she wants that. But she’s not the only prospect and initiation will test her boundaries and push her further that she believed she could or should go. The other sirens were admittedly more background characters so we didn’t get much depth to them but Emery and those most important to her were the core of the story so I didn’t mind this at all.

I thoroughly enjoyed my time reading this - I sped through it in two days because I couldn’t put it down! I loved the university setting (though the academia is very much a backdrop), discovering the truth of Emery’s pain, seeing her get drawn to intoxicating power. I never knew what the characters would do next and what exactly they were hiding which is my favourite kind of story. I also liked Emery’s relationship with Eli. Having someone care for her without conditions or expectations was an interesting contrast to Emery’s feelings for Roux.

It’s the kind of story without clear boundaries, consequences, decisions and inevitability blurring together, and won’t be for eveyone but I loved the depth of feeling. Emery isn’t always likeable, she makes some terrible decisions and her obsession with the sirens is backed by nothing more than her past trauma and need for what they have but It felt raw and real, driven by emotion and not logic. The spiral into the siren’s way of life, and the slow dismantling of Emery’s socially acceptable self into her dark heart was captivating (and exactly what I was hoping for based on the cover) was very much the essence of the dark academia genre to me. The ending wasn’t what I expected but fitted well and though its abrupt (intentionally so) and I would have liked to sit in it for longer, it was very impactful and it’s one I’ll be thinking about a while!

Overall a really great read - not sure much aesthetically dark academia but tonally, in regards to character, it hit the perfect spot for me.


Thank you to Bookbreak pan MacMillan for the proof copy. All thoughts are my own.
Profile Image for Skyy Stelivan.
52 reviews2 followers
July 5, 2026
Received an advanced readers copy from Publisher!

Just finished the Arc and WOW! 🤩

We follow the main character Emery as she is starting her freshman year of college. We jump from her writing poems, back to her in present time. She has had mental health problems that we get more information on throughout the book.
Emery is looking for a fresh start and notices a group of girls that seem almost powerful? She is invited to join their “sorority” but does not know whether this is a good thing or trouble is coming. 😬

I loved that we got to see what she was texting in her notebook even though she never shared with anyone else. It really helped move the story along and let the reader feel connected to the moment.

I think this book is unlike anything I have ever read and will be amazing for the girls that feel like they never fit it!

TOMI, You have done it again!! ❤️
Profile Image for Eliie.
4 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
May 24, 2026
Advance Copy Review


The way my head spun with each part! Seeing the MC go through these obstacles and then the final twist is crazy! I can see this adapted into a movie and I hope that manifests!
Profile Image for Bang Bang Books.
581 reviews238 followers
September 24, 2026
Nothing new to see here and didnt understand that ending so I don’t know if I guessed it correctly. If you know, please leave comment.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 230 reviews