1999: Caledon Local 21, or Mr. Bear's Cellar

by Camden Lamont, Slack LaLane, Anonymous

“The year is nineteen-ninety-nine.”

That sentence brings me back to my senior kindergarten class when I was five years old, where we used to read out the date on the blackboard every single day. The year 1999 exists as a stain in my mind, however, as a memory that will not go away no matter how I try to forget it. 1999 marked the year I lost my first tooth, my first time on a plane, and unfortunately the early loss of my childhood innocence.

Genres: Horror, Mystery

Unknown Binding

First published November 14, 2009

Reviews

[Taylor Seiverd]

i listened to this through CreepCast with Wendigoon & Papa Meat.

i throughly enjoyed this. i was kept interested the whole time. this is an OG creepypasta & because of that, it makes it a little more special. the mystery with it was fun. there were a few parts that were either unnecessary or confusing but overall, a really solid story that was posted on Reddit of all places.

[Sabrina Fair]

I was more bored than scared.

[Pilar L.]

*** pretty good creepypasta, a classic. Thanks to Creepcast for narrating this beast. (April 21 2026)

[Tay Za Tun]

Cool start, kinda meh in the middle, ambigious ending. gives off the vibe of a classic creepypasta in the open ended way.

I'd give it about a 4.5, actually not too bad.

[Katie White]

Terrible dad, classic creepy pasta.

[Sura Shealey]

Reread for the nostalgia, I remember staying up all night in middle school after reading this one