Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Absent

Rate this book
From award-winning author Rex Ogle, a mixed-format middle grade novel about three boys who skip school, told in verse, prose, and comics.


With a dad in jail and a lack of teachers interested in helping him learn, Manny doesn’t see the point in anything besides skateboarding and writing lyrics. Calvin has so many responsibilities to his father and little brothers that when his bike is stolen, he can’t make it to school on time. And while Liam is studious and wants to become a doctor, he is tormented by bullies and hides out in an unused janitor’s closet instead of going to class. When the boys are thrown together in detention, they realize that they might still have a lot to learn—not just from their teachers, but from each other.

Absent tells the boys’ stories in three distinct Manny’s in verse, Calvin’s as a comic, and Liam’s as a prose journal. Printz Award Honoree and YALSA Nonfiction Award winner Rex Ogle explores school absenteeism in a compelling, entertaining, and utterly distinct novel.

304 pages, Hardcover

Published September 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Rex Ogle

76 books701 followers
Holy moly! I am so humbled and honored for y'all to read my books. Big hugs to all of ya.

Also, check out graphic novels under my pen name REY TERCIERO.

Bio:
REX OGLE is an award-winning author and the writer of nearly a hundred children’s books, comics, graphic novels, and memoirs—most notably Free Lunch, which won the ALA/YALSA award for Excellence in Non-Fiction.

Born and raised (mostly) in Texas, he moved to New York City after college to intern at Marvel Comics before moving over to DC Comics, Scholastic, and Little Brown Young Readers. As an editor, he championed over a dozen NY Times Bestsellers and worked on (and often wrote) major brands such as X-Men, Justice League, Star Wars, LEGO, Power Rangers, Transformers, Minecraft, Assassin’s Creed, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and Neil Patrick Harris’s Magic Misfits.

Rex has written under a lot of pen names, including Trey King, Honest Lee, and Rey Terciero (a nickname given by his Abuela, being Español for “third king”, which is apt since Rex is Latin for “king”, and he is the third “Rex” in his family).

Now, Rex lives in Los Angeles where he writes in his spare time—that is, when he’s not outdoors hiking with his dog Toby, playing MarioKart with friends, or reading.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
291 (43%)
4 stars
285 (42%)
3 stars
88 (13%)
2 stars
9 (1%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 191 reviews
Profile Image for Rod Brown.
8,015 reviews320 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 20, 2026
Rex Ogle was my "it" author of 2025; I crashed through nine of his works last year in prose and graphic novel formats, autobiographical and fictional, original and adaptations. While this middle school book doesn't hit with the same power, it's a solid look at the stresses felt by young adolescents and how friendship and communication can help lighten that load.

Three boys sent to detention for skipping classes alternate narrating -- one in prose, one in verse, and one with comic book pages -- about the anger, bullying, and home responsibilities that brought them here. And over the course of two weeks, while they don't go full Breakfast Club, they do form bonds with each other while working through their individual problems.

It might be a little too pat and tidy in the end, but I felt the format and sympathetic characters made for a quick and enjoyable read even as it juggles some heavy topics.


Disclosure: I received access to a copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.com.
Profile Image for Melanie Dulaney.
2,549 reviews179 followers
July 29, 2026
Rex Ogle, writer of traditional and graphic novel formatted books for middle grades and teens that address issues of poverty, food scarcity, abuse, bullying, absentism, and a whole host of real life and difficult situations in ABSENT.

Skillfully entwined, Ogle’s three main characters, Manny, Liam and Calvin, are all missing school for reasons that soon begin to overlap. Each boy tells his own story through poetry/song lyrics on lined journal pages (Manny), in illustrations and comics on blank paper (Calvin), and on grid paper inside a notebook (Liam). The three come together during 3 weeks of detention and, using notes and taking advantage of the supervising teacher’s naps or trips to the bathroom, begin to find common ground outside of skipping classes and in much more important ways. As they begin to trust one another and share the challenging life circumstances that have resulted in missing school and several caring adults intervene, healing begins.

As in all of Ogle’s previous titles, Absent doesn’t shy away from hard topics. In this case, all of the boys are living in poverty and in a neighborhood filled with struggling families, some who have given up on ever finding better for themselves and their families. Manny lives with his grandparents who work hard in blue collar jobs, his father is in prison after stealing in order to buy food, and his mother abandoned them years ago, leaving him certain that there is no reason for school since no one will ever see past his Hispanic, immigrant background. Liam’s dad is a janitor at the school, has a stepmom who entered the picture sometime after his mother went to prison for drug-related offenses, is being relentlessly bullied by a classmate resulting in severe panic attacks and retreat into a library storage room to avoid his bully. Calvin’s dad works long hours leaving him in charge of younger brothers and most of the household responsibilities and getting them to school generally results in him being late for school and missing the first period art class that is his only real reason for attending at all. The boys’ stories are poignantly relayed and even for those who are not experiencing those exact circumstances, there will be something relatable in each boys’ life.

Hope is scarce in the first sections of ABSENT, but as the boys begin to talk, Manny steps in to physically defend Liam, Liam and Calvin seek out Manny at the skatepark to check on him, and Manny and Liam encourage Calvin in his art, a little light begins to shine. Then Manny’s new language arts teacher gets a look, albeit an invasion of privacy look, at his lyrics and recognizes and encourages his gift in ways that change his view of himself and his possible future. Liam opens up to a listening librarian and finds the courage to talk to his father about his anxiety who responds in a powerful, “What do you need?” way.

Yes, there are some issues that may stand out with adults-A librarian who does not immediately report known and pervasive bullying and facilitates skipping class, a teacher who seeks out a student outside of school, a whole of school personnel who do not notice an exhausted, sweaty student who comes flying onto campus nearly every morning, etc. However, the messages of hope and encouragement to seek out help is there. And it is all presented in a fabulous format that is sure to be appealing to many in grades 5-9.

*Profanity: only a handful of milder curse words but there are acronyms such as WTF and AF that clearly stand for the F-word and the librarian is quite fond of using “frak” as a substitute (with regular references to Battlestar Gallactica)
*Sexual content: none
*Violence: Calvin’s dad gets physical with his boys and his anger is, at times, alarming. Bully Grady shoves kids into walls, tries to force Liam’s head into a toilet, and uses his fists against others as well. None is overly excessive or inappropriate for the target audience.
*Representation: Manny is Hispanic, Calvin is Black and Liam is Caucasian; primary caregiver and older grandparents presented as supportive and loving; most characters are presented as struggling financially
*LBGTQ+: none

Thanks for the print arc, Norton Young Readers and eARC from Edelweiss.
Profile Image for Alicia.
9,331 reviews167 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
May 31, 2026
Manny, Calvin, and Liam are going to be unforgettable for anyone who reads it. As an adult reader, I won't soon forget them but for a teen reader, they are likely their friends or even themselves that they'll see when they read. The beauty of the book? The creativity that Ogle uses to share the story-- three voices with three ways to tell their story: Manny's through verse because he's a poet/lyricist, Calvin's through comics because he's a creator, and Liam's through narrative because he's a studious kid caught up in a serious bullying situation. Either way-- all three of these boys are missing a lot of school. And they end up meeting one another in detention- the more stereotypical kind of detention but slowly come to understand each other.

I will be writing a full blog post about the impact that this book will have. I'm already envisioning ordering tons of copies. I want to read it with teachers. And it solidifies that Ogle needs to visit our school. It's visibility for an invisible issue though I would argue that more attention is being paid especially post-COVID to chronic absenteeism.

Ogle knows what readers want and he's giving it to them in an honest way. One that doesn't shortcut or short change the ways that lead kids to miss school from transportation issues to anxiety to not seeing any reason that he should.

I've known for a while that Ogle is a GOAT. No question about it and when he takes a topic like this and creates Absent, it again celebrates his awareness, his understanding, and how he wants to make it accessible. Hats of to Ogle and Baptiste for this REAL story.
5 reviews
August 23, 2026
Another masterpiece by Rex Ogle. I absolutely loved how each perspective was written in its own format (graphic novel, verse, prose) and even had its own paper type (grid, lined, solid white).
Profile Image for Anna McElhinney.
165 reviews3 followers
August 23, 2026
Read an ARC of this as my school is preparing to do a school wide read next week.

This was…fine. I loved the alternating POVs, especially Calvin’s and the pages they all shared while passing notes.

Since I read this through a lens of having to read this book to my students on the first week of school, parts of it are jarring and feel unnecessary (in this context). I dislike the use of slurs in this book (again, in the context I will be using it for). These boys lives are the reality for so many and I look forward to having kids be able to find themselves in these characters, but at the cost of them feeling ostracized as I read it to them feels heavy.

My school is also using this as a way to combat chronic absenteeism, which seems to be a stretch. One boy skips class because he feels the system won’t let him succeed, to be solved only after reading The Rose That Grew From Concrete. One boy misses the bus everyday caring for his siblings, only to be fixed once his dad looks at his artwork. The third boy skips class because of a bully, the issue only being solved after the bully punches him and gets expelled. These scenarios are so real for many students, but the fixes here are very far fetched and specific.

This book is perfect for what it is, but my lens reading it definitely skewed my thoughts…but that is not the fault of this book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Sam.
881 reviews
June 11, 2026
Manny, Calvin, and Liam are stuck in detention together. On the surface, they appear different, but they realize that they have things in common. I think this is a great book for middle school readers and I could envision my students reading this one. I like that each character has their own thing throughout the book so you can tell who is writing: Manny has poetry, Calvin has art, and Liam journals.
Profile Image for A Dreaming Bibliophile.
780 reviews10 followers
September 13, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley, W. W. Norton & Co. and RBMedia for providing me with advanced copies.

This was a really nice book. I really liked how the reasons behind why some students are struggling were shown in such a human way. The formatting of the book was also very nice, I especially liked the graphic novel parts. The friendship developed between the boys was very wholesome to read about, especially the notes they passed during detention and how they helped each other out. The resolution was also nice, especially in Calvin's case. I do wish the adults around had helped the kids a little more. I enjoyed the illustrations as well, they really brought out the story. I would definitely recommend this to anyone looking for a middle grade book about how absenteeism has a lot more going behind the scenes than what's visible to the eye.

The audiobook was done really well. I was initially sceptical about how an audiobook would be for a graphic novel but this was done really well, even the actual comic parts. The narration showed all the emotions required and provided all the details. It was nice to immersion read, especially Calvin's sections because the illustrations are pretty good.
Profile Image for Jennifer Ingle.
294 reviews2 followers
September 17, 2026
The format of this book is so cool! The story is told from the perspective of 3 characters — Manny, Calvin & Liam — each from their unique form of self expression. Manny writes verse; Calvin draws comics; Liam writes journal entries.

The plot is very predictable, but that’s OK for a middle grade novel. The characters are really special, though, and I think middle school readers will make lots of connections.

This would be a GREAT book to use for instructional purposes in Grades 6ish - 8ish.
Profile Image for Faithe.
484 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
August 17, 2026
Absent by Rex Ogle is a story about three boys who end up in detention after skipping school for various reasons.

Manny, write in lyrics. He doesn't see the point in coming to school anymore, after his favorite teacher quit. Calvin has family responsibilities which lead to him being late everyday and missing his favorite class, art. His story is told through awesome comics. Liam is the most unlikely student to end up in detention. He was hiding from a bully, which led to him missing class. His logic science based brain, helps him write out things, make lists and look up information. The three are in detention after school for three weeks together, and discover they are more alike then anyone would have thought.

I received and advanced copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion and review.

I really like how each boy was represented, both in their personalities and in their writing styles. I appreciate that they all had good reasons to be skipping class, and that all three were likable characters. The teacher in me, absolutely loved this book and the insight it gave about students who may be in similar situations. I would love to add this book to my classroom library, and will be checking out more books from this author as well!

#absent #NetGalley

In stores Sept 1 2026
Profile Image for Tyra Damm.
488 reviews5 followers
October 28, 2026
Three middle-school boys struggle with attendance for three different reasons. When they are thrown together in detention, they discover all they have in common. They are both oppressed and rescued by other kids and adults in their lives, and when the story ends, there's hope that they will one day offer hope to others.
Profile Image for Julia Nash.
454 reviews26 followers
September 26, 2026
3.5 rounded up.
I am not crazy about middle grade novels, but I can appreciate the message. I know this will resonate with a lot of the students at my school. I didn't like the librarian. I think it's uncomfortable when teachers let kids call them by their first name.
Profile Image for Kristen M. .
484 reviews32 followers
November 4, 2026
Rex Ogle delivers again. This book features 3 middle school boys as alternating narrators, with various reasons for being absent from school. They meet in afterschool detention. This books uses a mixed media format and will appeal to many young readers - reminiscent of Wimpy Kid style drawings to convey the story.
Profile Image for Ricki.
Author 2 books115 followers
November 5, 2026
I will read absolutely anything Rex Ogle writes. His newest book is a masterpiece, tackling an issue that is essential to understanding the realities of education today: chronic absenteeism. Educators across the country are grappling with this increasingly troubling challenge, and Ogle brings much-needed attention to an issue that deserves far more conversation. A powerful, timely, and deeply important read.
Profile Image for Betsy Wolf.
403 reviews
June 21, 2026
Review of advance copy received by NetGalley.


“Absent” is the story of the unlikely intersection of the lives of 3 middle school boys. Each boy is facing a challenge that is invisible to most of the adults around them. Through these challenges, Ogle grapples with absentee parents, grandparents raising children, mental health challenges, bullying, anger, fear, and the misunderstandings with the adults in their lives. It’s a lot to tackle, but I believe it will boost empathy in readers and make a lot of students feel seen. Each boy’s perspective is told in a different way, through verse, graphics, and prose, so it is easy to keep track of their voices.

As a teacher it reminded me of times I have been helpless to solve underlying issues our students face, but Ogle uses teachers and librarians in the story to really make a difference and I appreciated that. Even if we can’t fix everything, we can absolutely do all that we can to help.

While this cover and the tone of the book is attractive and would appeal to 8-12, I could not get away with having it in a lower elementary library because of the language. I’d say 5th grade and up, and in Tennessee maybe 6th grade to be safe. Absenteeism is a HUGE issue and Ogle handles it with care.

Profile Image for Michelle.
572 reviews28 followers
Read
June 23, 2026
Author and artist, Rex Ogle, brings the topic of school asenteeism to light using verse, prose, and comics. He does it in such a way that the reader can really get to know each character by how the character communicates their thoughts down on paper. Rex Ogle is a master at bringing the hard topics to life for readers to get to know and understand and see things from a different point of view.

This would be a great read aloud in a middle school classroom. Teacher would be able to have discussions in a safe setting for students to be able to ask questions. Maybe they could coime up with other solutions to help the characters (and maybe their peers) get to school on time. There are many reasons why students don't come to school or are always late when they do. Many of the reasons are out of the students' control too which make it very frustrating for all involved.

A must-read for all and a must-have if you have a Rex Ogle collection or not!!

#RexOgle #Absent #NewRelease #Prose #Verse #Comics #SchoolLibrary #SchoolLibrarians #PublicLibraries #PublicLibrarians #ReadABook #ReadThisBook #Books #Read #MGReads #MGBooks #MGLit #KidLit #UpperElemReads #Edelweiss #Goodreads
Profile Image for Ali.
139 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 8, 2026
E-ARC provided by NetGalley. Rex Ogle combines verse, graphic novel, and first person narrative to bring three preteen boys to life on the page. Recommended for kids who love Jerry Craft's New Kid and the Diary of a Wimpy Kid series, and especially kids with incarcerated parents or other difficulties of poverty.

When each boy is given detention for skipping class, they slowly learn that they aren't that different, and that they can make school a better and safer place if they take the time to care about each other. Each boy also has to find the courage to talk to the adults in their lives that are still around and who want to help- a teacher who sees how smart, yet unmotivated Manny is; a dad, who needs to be reminded that Calvin is still a kid even though Dad relies on him for so much; and a librarian, who provides a safe space and the right words to help Liam get the protection from a bully and the treatment he needs for panic disorder.
Profile Image for Laura Romano.
53 reviews
June 25, 2026
Absent tells the interwoven stories of three middle school boys facing life challenges that most of the adults in their lives can’t see. Manny is living with his grandparents while his father is incarcerated and doesn’t see the point of showing up at school anymore when he’d rather be skating. Calvin is constantly late for school because he’s taking care of his siblings after his mom left. Liam is adjusting to a new family dynamic at home with his dad’s new relationship and facing relentless bullying from another kid at school.

Through a combination of verse, comics, and journal entries, the boys’ stories combine to depict the challenges kids all across the country are facing every day. I think this is a must-read for anyone working with students in any capacity. This story will resonate well with many young readers, whether as a mirror of their own experiences or a window into the challenges their peers are facing.

Thank you to the publisher for the eARC copy via NetGalley.
Profile Image for Dawn.
1,628 reviews13 followers
October 6, 2026
Liam keeps ditching class to avoid a bully. Manny ditches class to skateboard or write rap lyrics. Calvin keeps ditching first period because he has to take his little brothers to school across town. All three get assigned three weeks of detention.

All three tell their stories, in Liam’s journal, Calvin’s, sketch pad, and Manny’s rap notebook. First to us readers, then to each other.

I didn’t like this as much as I thought I would. I wish there had been more of Calvin’s drawings. Also it pivoted quickly to a happy-ish ending. 7th grade +.
Profile Image for Heather Edwards .
887 reviews7 followers
September 7, 2026
This was a really good book. I enjoyed reading the three boys' perspectives of being in detention together and how their school days looked like. I liked reading how each boy had a different style of writing. Liam wrote journal entries, Manny wrote "lyrics" like poetry, and Calvin expressed his thoughts into comics. I really loved the illustrations and writing style. I will definitely pick up another book by this author.
Profile Image for Nicole.
3,966 reviews21 followers
September 19, 2026
This was such a cool book...I really enjoyed it overall. I found the formatting, with a different style for each of the 3 characters we follow, really engaging and immersive. I definitely had one character that I connected to more than the others but I feel like any kid who picks this up will be able to relate to or empathize with at least one of these three characters either because of their own experience or someone they know or something they've seen at school. This felt very realistic and relatable overall. I did feel it dragged a little for me at times but probably just because I had one storyline I was more invested in. Would definitely recommend for middle school age and above.
Profile Image for Yapha.
3,492 reviews106 followers
September 30, 2026
Absent has three main characters whose stories intertwine, and each is told in a different format. Calvin is an artist, and his story is told as a graphic novel. Manny is a skateboarder/poet/rapper and his story is told in verse. Liam wants to be a doctor, and his story is told in prose on graph paper. The three of them were never friends before but end up becoming close when all three are sent to the same after school detention for skipping class. Each has different reasons for missing class, most of which are beyond their control. This is a great book not just for middle grade students to read, but also for their teachers. It is an important reminder that many students have turbulent home lives, which can negatively impact their schoolwork. Powerful and accessible. Highly recommended for grades 5 & up.
Profile Image for Bethany Hall.
1,249 reviews48 followers
August 30, 2026
This was a truly stunning audiobook! Another amazing gem by Rex Ogle - every single boy was going through something that had them struggling. Detention was a way to get them to be friends, and the friendships that came into the fold were beautiful. Liam’s anxiety crushed me. It felt so raw and real. Manny’s pain came through in his rhymes. Calvin’s family life and being the default caregiver after his mother passed? I felt it in my soul. Just a gorgeous book.
Profile Image for Kristi DeJong.
56 reviews1 follower
September 7, 2026
I loved this middle grade book! I listened to it on audio, and the readers were amazing! However, I plan to read it again as a hard copy to see the ways each narrator tells their story (verse, graphic supported) to enjoy it even more! Reg Ogle never disappoints!
Profile Image for Emma.
189 reviews1 follower
November 6, 2026
Three boys struggling in school, all for different reasons, find themselves together in detention. Each boy tells their story in their own way - rap lyrics, journal entries, comic panels.
I really enjoyed this book and think it can be a great conversation starter about being kind and understanding others’ struggles.
The only reason it is not a 5 star read is that the formats may be difficult to follow or comprehend for some students who are not more advanced readers.
Profile Image for Maggie.
733 reviews8 followers
November 17, 2026
I had such a hard time reading FREE LUNCH because it was so sad. This one is just as emotional but less harsh in most places. Kids love it and I loved it!
Profile Image for Deborah Zeman.
1,137 reviews39 followers
May 29, 2026
Thank you Edelweiss for the digital arc!

three boys.three boys. three impossible situations. one detention. 📚😤

manny: dad in jail. teachers who gave up on him. skating and lyrics are the only things that make sense. 🛹🎵

calvin: holding his whole family together. bike stolen. can't get to school on time. doing everything RIGHT and still losing. 😶

liam: wants to be a doctor. brilliant. hiding in a janitor's closet to escape bullies. 💔

the system failed all three of them differently.
detention threw them together anyway. 🤝

turns out the most important lessons
aren't coming from any classroom. 💛

found brotherhood in the most unexpected place. 📚🔥

Another homerun by one of my favorites. Told via prose, Novel in Verse and comics, this story grabbed me right from the start and didn't let me go. All kids are going to love this story, a story of three boys, all in detention for one reason or another, believing that no one "sees" them. I saw each of them. Their vulnerability was written all over the pages through words and pictures. Absenteeism is a large part of students' struggle throughout MS and HS, something that is addressed in this story. And Rex, THANK YOU for showing their librarian in a positive light. With everything we as librarians are going through in Texas, this librarian was a ROCK STAR. There are so many of us like her and it was heartwarming to see that represented in the story. I cannot wait to order 10 copies of this for my HS library! Thank you Edelweiss for the ARC.
Profile Image for Abby Evans.
82 reviews3 followers
August 31, 2026
(Thanks NetGalley for this digital ARC. )
I thought the layout was clever, going between the 3 boys and their own individual styles of art. I think the story captured the turmoil of middle school and the struggle to be yourself still. If you liked this, I'd also suggest Ogle's book "When We Ride".
4.5 due to some of the statistics felt to adult/preachy and didn't match the vibe.
Profile Image for Andrea.
1,041 reviews4 followers
September 15, 2026
Told from the perspective of three boys: a scientist who gets bullied at school, an artist who's been put in charge of all parenting duties for his brothers, and a rapper/poet full of rage and an incarcerated father.

Took a few chapters for me to get into the audiobook, but then I actually really enjoyed it. When I went on Libby to see the ebook I was happy to see that it was illustrated. I will have to check that out too so I can see the images.
Thanks, Libro.fm for the educator copy.

Audiobook Narrator:
Three narrators and they all did a good job with voices. I usually enjoy what Ramón de Ocampo narrates.
Profile Image for Ms. Yingling.
4,724 reviews660 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
June 9, 2026
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus

Things are tough in Iron Hill, and we meet three students who all have problems that many middle schoolers have. Manny doesn't see much of a point to school; he would rather spend his time writing rap lyrics and skateboarding, since he sees his grandparents, who immigrated from Mexico, working hard for little reward, and knows that his father struggled to put food on the table after Manny's mother left, and is now in prison for stealing. Calvin loves to draw, but has little time for this since he has to get his two younger brothers up, dressed, and delivered to school across town, since his single father has to work. He is constantly late, which gets him in trouble with principal Ms. Cho. Liam is a good student, but is bedeviled by Grady, who constantly threatens his with real, physical violence, to the extent that Liam takes refuge in Dana Funkhouser's library, and spends several entire days in a back storage room. All three eventually end up with a three week after school detention stint for truancy, which doesn't make them think school is any more appealing. They do talk to each other, eventually, and find ways to help them see a bit more value in school. Manny is glad to have a new language arts teacher, Ms. Patel, who tells him that he is talented and cares about him, even showing up at the skate park on the weekend to talk to him after he storms out of class when he doesn't want to read his poem out loud. He also fights with his grandparents when they opine that he is really very fortunate. Calvin has a fight with his father after he is forbidden to draw, since it takes attention away from his brothers, and Manny and Liam encourage him to keep up with his art. Liam tries to talk to his father and stepmother, but knows that his father's salary as the custodian at his school won't run to mental health therapy, even though the panic attacks he has are debilitating. Luckily, Ms. Funkhouser is supportive, and even saves him from Grady's abuse and makes sure that Grady is brought to justice. It's impossible for the boys to change their circumstances alone, but when they talk to each other and let other people help, some issues can be resolved.
Strengths: I very much appreciate that Ogle asked teachers what their number one problem at school is; I am not surprised that it is absenteeism. Can't say I have seen any books on the subject. The format is also clever, with Manny's chapters written in verse, Calvin's in a graphic novel format, and Liam's in prose on graph paper. The problems the boys face are realistic, and hard for middle school students to navigate. The fights with families are something that, again, I don't see portrayed as much in fiction. They are MUCH more interesting (and common) than children dealing with grief, although there is a little bit of that as well. While three weeks of after school detention doesn't seem like it would be an effective punishment, it does give the boys a chance to bond and to eventually improve their lots a bit.
Weaknesses: I know that Ogle speaks from his own experience, but he doesn't seem to understand how modern schools work. There are very strict protocols, for many reasons, and Ms. Funkhouser could have improved Liam's life a whole lot sooner if she had immediately informed a school counselor when she knew that Grady was bullying Liam. How can we expect students to "see something, say something" if TEACHERS aren't following the same rule? For a 27 year old, Ms. Funkhouser had some odd cultural references, and she was the modern stereotype of a librarian; tattooed and pierced with brightly colored hair. I can't imagine the trouble I would be in if I let a student play hooky in the library, so I questioned her training and professionalism. We need to know where students are at all times! It also was very risky for Ms. Patel to talk to Manny outside of school.
What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who like Ogle's work or books like Sonnenblick's The Secret Sheriff of Sixth Grade or Korman's The Fort. I will probably purchase a copy, although the last thing I intend to do is to hand it to students who are chronically truant. If they pick it up from a display, that's fine!

Also, this is going to motivate me to start the year with some serious talks about attendance with my advisory group. My school has some good resources, so I want to make sure that if my students are having difficulties making it to school, these issues are addressed. Last year, I did make sure that each student had current contact information on file; this is essential in case a child takes ill or has an accident during the day!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 191 reviews