Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Enchanted Village

Rate this book
A cozy, magical, slice-of-life holiday romance set in a village adjacent to a magic school—if the Dream Harbor series were set at Hogsmeade! I solemnly swear not to fall in love… Silas Birchwood wasn’t sure what to expect when he joined Emberwind Academy as the school’s first non-magical teacher. But he knows he’s found his calling, even if his wand-wielding pupils struggle with the scientific method. Living in Hex Hollow, the quirky village adjacent to the magical school, certainly has its charms—most notably Margaret Nettle, the witch proprietor of The Toasty Owl. Every night, villagers gather in the glow of the fireplace to sip her warming magical drinks. Margaret has devoted her life to running the pub left to her by her beloved mother and grandmother, even if it stings living so close to the magical school that rejected her. When a rival bar opens across the street, Silas is determined to help Margaret save her business. And despite herself, Margaret finds herself warming to the man who can fix anything in her pub—with a smile that melts her grumpy heart. When the secret to her magical drinks is stolen, Margaret fears she’s destroyed her family’s legacy. Can Silas help her see what he’s always known…that the magic was hers all along? Grumpy x sunshine Small-town romance Found family Opposites attract Magical village Baby dragons Magic pub Fish out of water

320 pages, Paperback

First published October 20, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lily Starling

1 book44 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
105 (22%)
4 stars
241 (51%)
3 stars
107 (22%)
2 stars
16 (3%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 229 reviews
Profile Image for Elaine.
1,810 reviews73 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 19, 2026
What a refreshing take on magic and magical realism!

This story takes place in Hex Hollow, a town that boasts a Magic School! And, has just hired it's very first NON-Magical teacher. He happens to be Silas, and he's also the nephew of the Headmaster. He has just received his degree and is very excited to get this opportunity. However, when he arrives to find that his students are all wielding their magic wands easily and without a care in the world as to what happens around them, he realizes the mess he just got himself into!
But, he has also met a beautiful red-haired woman who seems to have captured his heart without even knowing it... and he doesn't even know her name...

As he begins asking around about her, he comes to find that Margaret is a well-known and well-loved member of the community and that she has descended from a long line of gifted witches...
She is now the proprietor of the Toasty Owl Pub, gifted to her from her Mom and Grandmother who used their gifts/skills to make astonishingly tasteful drinks... and, Margaret still has access to the secret garden that her Grandma planted so many years ago... giving her the ability to continue the Pub and the wonderful drinks.

Unfortunately for her, another witch has decided to open a new bar right by hers... and his plan is to take her out in the process. Margaret is a wreck, and is unsure how to proceed... but with the help of her lifetime friend Liza and her new friend, Silas, she is willing to give it a go...

This was whimsical, sweet, sassy, a bit spicy, and very magical!! I loved every minute of the story and was sad for it to end!! Wonderfully done!

#EnchantedVillage by @LilyStarling and narrated beautifully by @KarenCass and @JamesMeunier.

4.75 stars for me, easily rounded up to 5!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟💫💫💫

This one HAS NOT been released yet! Look 👀 for it on 10/20/26!

Thanks so much to #NetGalley, @HarperAudioAdult and @AvonA for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.

You can find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine

Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!!

And as always, thanks for reading along with me! 📚⭐️📖🩷
Profile Image for Peggyzbooksnmusic.
552 reviews19 followers
November 8, 2026
3 stars bumped up to 3.5 stars based on the excellent Audio narration by Karen Cass and James Meunier. Read on Libby Kindle while listening to Libby Audio.
Cute cozy fantasy/romance with a dash of spice set in contemporary England during Christmas holidays. At least I'm assuming it's set in a fictional/fantasy England as the audio narrators have British accents:)
The main character, Margaret, owns a pub that was previously owned by her deceased Mother and Grandmother who were famous witches during their lifetime. Margaret for some reason isn't able to cast spells although she is loved by her friends.
The nearby Acadamy for "Magical People" hires a professor of Science, Silas, who is also not "Magical".
A new pub opens and the owner vows to put Margaret out of business. The plot is somewhat like a Hallmark movie (except with a sex scene) although the author was able to flesh out the characters and keep me interested.
I probably wouldn't have enjoyed this as much if I had not been able to listen to the audio along with reading the e-book.
Liked this quote:
"Grief made so many people run away, not out of cruelty, but because it forced them to confront the things they didn’t want to think about it."
Profile Image for Jen.
386 reviews
October 28, 2026
If Hallmark Christmas movies, magical small towns, mischievous dragons and a grumpy woman falling for a walking green flag sound like your idea of a good time then Enchanted Village is basically your literary cup of Christmas tea ❄️ And yes, there are dragons. 🐲

This is a cozy, low-stakes fantasy romance packed with winter wonderland vibes, Christmas magic, potions and small-town charm to make you want to relocate somewhere snowy and develop a suspiciously festive personality. ☃️ Margaret is our prickly, magical FMC who needs to learn her worth while Silas is the sunshiney, non-magical professor who apparently woke up every morning and chose emotional availability. 💚 Sir, please leave some green flags for the rest of us. 😂

Their slow-burn romance is sweet, heartwarming and occasionally sprinkled with a little seasoning. 😉 Nothing that'll set your Kindle on fire 🔥 but enough spice to keep things interesting. The plot twist is fairly predictable but honestly sometimes we want to see the twist coming and still enjoy the ride. 🤷‍♀️ Not every book needs to emotionally destroy us. Some of us have jobs and laundry. 🧺

The worldbuilding is charming, the magic feels consistent and the supporting cast absolutely earns its place at the table. Liza brings the comedy and Bernie the dragon is basically the scene-stealing little menace we didn't know we needed. Margaret's journey toward accepting help and recognizing her own worth adds a lovely emotional layer without turning this cozy escape into a therapy session. 💕

🎧 Audio: Karen Cass and James Meunier deliver a fantastic dual narration that brings the characters and the cozy atmosphere to life. The performances feel natural, the emotions land and suddenly you're mentally curled up beside a fireplace while snow falls outside. ❄️ Highly recommend listening if audiobooks are your thing!

Enchanted Village is a warm, whimsical, feel-good fantasy romance perfect for anyone craving Christmas magic, a sweet sunshine hero, a slightly grumpy heroine and adorable dragons. It's predictable in places, delightfully cozy overall and exactly the kind of comfort read that makes winter feel a little more magical. ❄️
Profile Image for bookrat_reads.
237 reviews16 followers
November 16, 2026
Enchanted Village is a cozy fantasy full of small town vibes and holiday magic.
Margaret, our slightly grumpy/grieving FMC, is the local pub owner. The pub passed down for generations to women in her has been unchanged. While coming to terms with her mother's death, Margaret learns a new pub is opening in town. Shea terrified that being without magic will be her downfall.
Silas is our MMC. The newest professor at the local magical academy. He's the first non-magical professor. This man is a literal walking green flag. Kind, caring, considerate, good with tools, slightly awkward, and nerdy make for the perfect man.
There were really great secondary characters. The townsfolk were amazing. Even the protagonist comes around. We have magical creatures as well. Dragons, hippogriffs, and kurlops, oh my!
This was such a sweet, whimsical read that was perfect for this time of year. I loved the gradual slow build of Margaret and Silas' relationship. This book had me ready to curl up with a blanket, hot chocolate, and escape to Hex Hollow. I would love to venture back with other stories from the town.
Profile Image for anovelaccount (Kayla).
477 reviews65 followers
October 21, 2026
What a charming little book this is! It is the perfect cozy winter comfort read, complete with dragons and a Hogsmeade-esque village. The stakes are low, and this is a story you can read quickly when you want some Christmas cheer or just a lovely snowy tale.

I wasn’t expecting any, but there is also a little spice in here—easy enough to skip if you’d like. I always think it makes for an entertaining story when the FMC is the grumpy one and the MMC is the “sunshine” one, and that’s what we get here. Despite her sometimes grumpy personality, Margaret is just as lovable as Silas, a non-magical man who also just so happens to be the newest professor at the local academy.

From there, the story deals with Margaret’s feelings of inadequacy, her struggles with the pub, and her pesky growing feelings for Silas. Silas also doubles as a handyman and insists on helping Margaret, even when her dragon is not initially his fan. Speaking of—Bernie was absolutely my favorite part! She’s so sassy and holds everyone up to her draconic expectations. She also unintentionally causes all kinds of mischief for her owner, but she simply cannot be bothered.

Do yourselves a favor and listen to this one in, say, December—you’ll want to snuggle up and read it in one or two sittings. I really enjoyed its coziness and fun cast of characters and creatures!

🎧I am, as always, obsessed with narrators with accents. I am who I am, what can I say?! Karen Cass and James Meunier both nail their respective characters and really felt like they became them. I loved experiencing this world through their voices and I’d definitely recommend the audio of this one!
Profile Image for Leticia (jerseygirlsbookshelf).
635 reviews306 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 25, 2026
”Take me to the place where thoughts run free.”
Enchanted Village has a simple story, but also more. Call it cozy, Heartwarming. Adorable. Giving all the fall and Christmas and holiday vibes.
And magic, which is always a bonus point for me. Because honestly? I feel like I could use some.

”In the time he’d spent living in Hex Hollow—relatively brief as it might have been—Silas had seen his fair share of oddities. (...) And yet, the thing that his mind seemed unable to shake was the woman from yesterday.”
Margaret has lived in Hex Hollow all her life. She knows everyone, and everyone knows her. It’s not that hard because she also runs the only bar in town, which was left to her by her mother and grandmother.

Her days go on usual. Until Silas comes into her life.

”I’m not doing anything because I feel like I have to. I’m doing this because I want to. And there are very few things that will stop me from doing what I want.”
Their meet-cute is, well, cute, and he finds himself drawn to the pretty witch who seems to have a way with magical animals, even the most dangerous ones other people don’t get close to. The witch who is alone most of the time and dealing with feelings of grief and nostalgia I could relate to. The witch who is used to doing everything on her own, and it’s going to take a while to convince her to let him in.

”But for the first time in a very long time, Margaret decided to trust the warmth that Silas had brought into the pub rather than the cold of her own making.”
Like I said, adorable. Silas has no magical powers, but he’s good at doing things the old-fashioned way, so, as an acts-of-service kind of guy, he shows up to help her fix the bar. Even if she tries her best to keep him at arm’s length.
And when another, more modern and shinier, bar comes along and threatens her livelihood and everything she is, he’s there too.

“If you don’t kiss me right this second, I swear to god I’ll find a way to curse you right here.”
They’re very cute together. It’s slow burn, with a moment with a jealous, protective (but I want to pet him!) dragon, an almost moment that gets interrupted, and meddling friends, but they get there.
Please note that this is not a steamy book, so don’t go in expecting all the spice.

“Not alone, remember. We’re together on this.”
As a debut book, I think this accomplished a lot. I think Lily knew the story she wanted to tell, and she did it. I missed a bit more depth to the characters, though, especially Silas. I feel like we know a lot about Margaret and not nearly enough about him.
And the conflict was solved way too easily for me—not to mention I wouldn’t be nearly as forgiving as Margaret was, so there’s that!

”She wasn’t magic. She was stardust incarnate, bursting with brilliant light, and he was the man who was somehow lucky enough to hold her in his hands.”
Another aspect I really liked was the way it dealt with grief. I have no idea if the author is dealing with something like that in her life, but some sentences could have easily come from my own head.
And, as usual, the found family element and the way the town shows up for her.

“You’re the magic, and you always have been.”
I feel like this was a story about learning we all have our own magic. It’s what makes us who we are. Sometimes we just have to let it shine brighter and believe in ourselves.
Profile Image for Madison.
301 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 29, 2026
3 ☆

So this was a pleasant little surprise. The second I saw the character art for this book posted by the author, I knew I needed to read it. The scene scape was just so cozy and warm, and it was time for me to find another cozy fantasy to dream over.

For a debut novel, this was really strong. The author did an incredible job building up the setting with such detailed imagery it planted clear cut visions in your head. The world of Hex Hollow is tranquil and quaintly quirky as it neighbors a magic school. Between following Silas, the first non magical professor at the school, and Margaret, as she runs her grandmother and mothers bar serving magical drinks to local townsfolk and visitors, it nestles in the perfect formulaic atmosphere of what you want in a cozy fantasy.

This is a story ultimately about believing and knowing your own worth even when it feels like you don’t belong. We all have our own kind of magic, and it’s okay if someone else pops into our life to remind us that. It’s about opening up your heart in trusting that refusing isolation is not lack in strength . I will say the moments shared between Margaret and Silas were very sweet. He is the definition of acts of service—between helping tidy and fix things around Margaret’s shop and in the other local businesses there wasn’t a moment where he wasn’t looking out for the lives of others around him.

Individually both Silas and Margaret were relatable and although this is a slow burn, the switch between friends to lovers still almost felt like a jump. Although they spent time together, Margaret was still closed off that by the time they solidified their relationship it still felt like they didn’t know each other quite enough. They went on one date, and I get there was infatuation present, but the connection felt like it needed to be expanded on in other areas than Silas doing things for Margaret. And something I see in a lot of debuts is that a character is drawn from near perfection and has zero flaws and that was definitely the case with Silas. Margaret had more layers that were peeled back to make her more dimensional while Silas just kind of showed up to save the day. This element wasn’t enough to contribute to me not liking the book, but more so doxing a star for it.

The third act I wasn’t overly fond of in terms with how fast things moved and how quickly the resolution was presented. It felt almost thrown in there to check the box of having some sort of main conflict.

Overall I still really enjoyed this and will be something i will recommend to people looking for a cozy winter-esque fantasy. Such a great debut and I’m excited to see what the author brings to the table in the future!
Profile Image for Nina - the book bugling.
274 reviews43 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 17, 2026
Enchanted Village is a whimsical, cozy fantasy full of holiday and magical small town vibes. It follows pub owner Margaret and Silas, the first non-magical professor at the local magic academy.
When Margaret’s beloved family pub, The Toasty Owl, faces a new rival and an uncertain future, she finds an unexpected ally in Silas. He’s a sunshine filled, charmingly awkward MMC with a knack for fixing things. Margaret is more of a closed off, grumpy FMC at first - she's doing her best to protect her family’s legacy and navigate her grief after losing her mother. The magical village of Hex Hollow is absolutely charming! It's filled with cozy traditions, lovable villagers, and adorable magical creatures (Bernie the baby dragon❤️‍🔥). I loved the warmth, found family, gentle exploration of grief, and watching Margaret and Silas find something neither of them was looking for.

This was such a sweet, comforting read that’s perfect for the holiday season. The romance was lovely, with what felt like a natural connection forming between two people from very different worlds. I also listened to the audiobook, and the dual narration made the whole experience even better! The narrators brought a lot of personality, emotion, and charm to the characters, especially during the more heartfelt moments. While I would have liked a little more character development, and wish the resolution to some of the conflicts and the ending wouldn’t have wrapped up quite so quickly, I really enjoyed my time in Hex Hollow. This the kind of story that makes you want to curl up by a fireplace with a magical drink and never leave. I would love to return to the magical, cozy world for more stories!

✨️ Cozy fantasy
❄️ Grumpy-ish x sunshine
✨️ Opposites attract
❄️ Found family
✨️ Magical village
❄️ Family legacy
✨️ Grief and healing
❄️ Baby dragons
✨️ Third person dual POV

Thank you Lily Sterling, Avon, HarperAudio Adult and NetGalley for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Andi.
468 reviews86 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 7, 2026
The coziest holiday fantasy romance. It truly felt like the how the cover looks: warm, charming, and brimming with cheeky dragons.

I was worried this may feel too close to Harry Potter, because there are clearly intentional parallels, but Enchanted Village truly stood on its own. The focus is almost entirely on the pub, instead of the magical school, which really helps differentiate it and emphasizes the cozy atmostphere. The tiny, rambunctious dragons added so much levity and whimsy to the story, too.

I really loved Margaret and Silas together, but I especially loved the relationship between Margaret and Liza - best friends who will do anything for each other always get me :')

The book addresses grief, indentity, and fear in a very raw, honest way, which I appreciated.

The ending felt a bit rushed compared to the rest of the story, and I feel like some characters were FAR too forgiving of others, but I stil had a great time overall.

The audiobook is a nual narration, and the narrators for both Margaret and Silas were great. I had one minor pet peeve: both used British accents, but the writing is clearly American and included phrases non-Americans wouldn't use - which took me out of the story at times. If I had not read both the physical ARC and the ALC, I wouldn't have known the characters should be English, and thus, been irked by this.

If you're looking for a cozy, wintery fantasy romance with a little bit of spice and a lot of charm, you'll enjoy this.

Thank you so much to Avon a for the ARC and LibroFM for the ALC!
Profile Image for Jessica.
539 reviews72 followers
November 4, 2026
Thank you to Avon and Libro.FM for the ALC and finished copy of Enchanted Village by Lily Starling. All opinions are my own.

Enchanted Village is such a fitting name for this novel. This book was set in a cozy small town with sweet characters and a magical atmosphere. I really enjoyed reading it.

The setting is reminiscent of Hogsmeade from the Harry Potter books, but I feel like it was different enough that it made this story unique. I loved how the townspeople supported each other, and it was cool to see the magical creatures that the characters interacted with.

The tone of this book was very sweet, and I liked how the characters really cared about each other. Because this was a cozy fantasy, the conflict was low and less stressful than a lot of books.

I loved the romance and how sweet the friendship was between Margaret and Silas. It was adorable how Silas wanted to fix things for Margaret all the time, and he was obviously so smitten with Margaret.

I also appreciated how Margaret started to work through some of her grief and that she had people to support her. She was also such a sweet character and an animal lover.

I listened to the audiobook, and I loved the narration so much! The accents were great, and it was so easy to listen to. I felt that the narrators fit their characters very well. I would recommend this format.

Overall, I really enjoyed this book and would definitely read more books by this author.
Profile Image for Ann.
185 reviews11 followers
June 9, 2026
ARCQuest: Book 45

"You really don't see it, do you?" Silas asked.
Margaret averted her eyes. She pulled a can of whipped cream from her fridge, added a dollop onto each cup, and dusted each one with gold sugar. "Don't see what?"
"How loved you are, Margaret," he said, her name rolling off his lips. "I can't walk into a store in this village without someone asking about you. This whole place... people light up for you."


Well, this was a cozy little treat! And perfectly timed, too. It’s already Christmas in Jul- er, June. And I’m feeling warm and toasty surrounded by all of this beautiful white… sand…? Okay, so I read this on a hot beach while on a summer vacation. I still enjoyed it, okay!

Margaret is the owner of a pub in a magical village. Silas is new in town. It’s almost Christmas. I’m sure that everything will remain completely platonic, professional, and above board.

I had a lot of fun with Enchanted Village. It took me back to Ye Olden Days, when HP fanfic was a much larger part of my life. I mean that in a positive way, especially since Starling’s world seems a lot more open-minded and accepting. *Cough.* Anyway.

I enjoyed Margaret and Silas as two people who found something in each other that neither one was actively searching for. I appreciate the sort of kismet element of the relationship, considering they come from two different worlds. I don’t really think I would describe this as “grumpy x sunshine” as my ARC claims, but your mileage may vary, I guess. Margaret is guarded, sure, but she’s got a lot on her plate. She does not come across as grumpy to me in the least. All I can say is that insecurity is a beast, and I feel for her distorted world view and sense of self. Now Silas — or Professor Handyman, as I have christened him — is a bonafide golden retriever, and he can be “sunshine” all he wants. I pictured peak romcom Hugh Grant when he was at his most floppy, awkward, charming best, glasses and all.

The creatures were precious (Bernie, my love). Honestly Margaret could have been the school gamekeeper, and I would have been happy. The villagers were all relatively charming, especially with regard to how much everyone cared about Margaret. I did laugh that we mentioned Thanksgiving but skipped neatly over it. I get it, we’re all here for a cozy magic village at Christmastime, and Thanksgiving has Baggage. But it did make me laugh. I wasn’t actually sure where the story was set, and I think giving a touch more information about the location could have helped set the scene better.

I did want a bit more from the story. There is a lot of discussion on grief, which gives the story an emotional element outside of the romance, but I feel like there were a lot of conversations with Margaret resisting any sort of change that didn’t really move the plot forward. There were characters and relationships that I think needed a bit more buildup to understand how everyone ended up as they did by the final page (Imogen, for example), and I feel like some of that development was overlooked in favor of touching again on Margaret’s struggle to let go and move forward with her life.

I also think that things were wrapped up a little too quickly (and nicely). There were so few pages left that I thought this might actually end on a cliffhanger and be the first in a duology/series/what have you. I know this is like a spicier Hallmark Christmas movie set in Hogsmeade, so we want things to end on a happy, kind, tidy note; but certain characters (who will remain nameless for spoiler consideration) really deserved to face much greater consequences than they did. I do not care about the “why.” Liza had the correct energy. It’s okay to be compassionate and forgiving, but letting certain characters off the hook with basically a stern tsk-tsk and a well-meaning finger wag (especially in the last ten pages or so)? I can’t deny that it frustrated me. Maybe if there was a time jump or something, but whatever. I’ve made my peace with it. For the most part, anyway.

Regardless, I enjoyed this novel, and I am interested to see what other stories Starling might dream up. I noticed that Liza is still quite single at the end. *hintnudgecoughwink* Now to see to this cough…
Profile Image for Emmy.
329 reviews1 follower
October 18, 2026
Thanks so much Libro.fm for this gifted audio! The narrators did wonderfully at bringing this whimsical read to life! This was a cute cosy holiday read. I enjoyed how this book interpreted grief and healing. While the book was slow and comfy this was a quick, emotional read.
*Fav Quotes:
~“You can turn into a grief ball anytime, I promise.”
~“Because this was friendship at its core, wasn’t it? Being there for someone in their ugliest, smallest moments.”
~“But that was a part of grief no one liked to say. Things held memories that kept them in place and when they were gone their memories began to slip away too.”
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Laura.
36 reviews
November 9, 2026
4 🌟

What a cosy read!

This book is a magical hallmark movie set in Hogsmeade. It also kind of gave me Legends & Latte’s vibes, with the Toasty Owl and the magical drinks and food.

The romance wasn’t anything special or new but I loved the town and the magic and I was totally immersed. Though I must say the ending fell kind of flat?

Still recommend it if you want to read something easy, cosy, magical and Christmassy!
Profile Image for Missyreadsromantasy.
121 reviews13 followers
June 29, 2026
OK, this was SO cozy and adorable. It felt exactly the way the cover looks — like if a Christmas Hallmark movie took place in Hogsmeade.

Margaret is the third-generation owner of a cozy pub in a magical village. But unlike her mother and grandmother before her, she doesn’t have the same magic to help keep things running smoothly.

Silas was recently hired to teach non-magical studies to students at the village’s magic academy. He develops an interest in Margaret, but her little dragon gets overprotective, doing some significant damage to the pub while chasing him out.

Unfortunately, a competing pub is opening up in the village, just as Margaret has to temporarily close to do the repairs. Luckily, Silas doesn’t scare easily and has a knack for fixing things.

The story just exuded warmth. I wanted to dive inside the pages and be friends with Margaret, Liza, and Silas. I hope there is more magic to come from Hex Hollow!

Thanks to Avon a for the gifted ARC! All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for nicklein.
990 reviews96 followers
October 30, 2026
reading this feels like snuggling into a cozy blanket
Profile Image for Nicole.
272 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 7, 2026
✨️ One sentence review: A sweet romance, a charming magical village, an adorable dragon, and all the cozy feels...what more could you want?

This was such a cute and cozy read! I adored Silas. He's living in a village full of magic without having any magic of his own, but that doesn't stop him from finding ways to help Margaret in some pretty major ways. The romance between them was so sweet, and I loved the grumpy/sunshine dynamic with Margaret being the grumpy one and Silas bringing all the sunshine.

And Bernie! I absolutely loved that little dragon. She wasn't exactly Silas's biggest fan when they first met (she actually attacked him!), so seeing her eventually warm up to him was just the cutest.

Margaret's journey toward self-acceptance was also really well done. It added some extra depth without bogging down the cozy feel of the story. Add in a charming cast of side characters and a town that rallies around Margaret and her tavern, and you have a recipe for a thoroughly enjoyable read.

🎧 I also did a tandem audio and physical read, and the audiobook was fantastic! Karen Cass and James Meunier were wonderful as dual narrators and did a great job bringing the characters to life.

✨️ Would I recommend? Absolutely! If you enjoy cozy reads, sweet romances, and stories that feel like curling up with a cup of tea and putting on a Hallmark movie, this one is for you!

What to expect:
• Cozy Magical Village
• Grumpy x Sunshine
• Non-Magical MMC
• Adorable Dragon Baby
• Found Family Vibes
• Opposites Attract
• Family Legacy
Profile Image for J Christine .
185 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 24, 2026
Cute! Cozy! Sweet read!

This is such a cozy holiday-ish grumpy sunshine story!
I enjoyed the nods and atmosphere that resembled Harry Potter! I could picture the village looking just like Hogsmead!

I love the magical elements that are pure sweet magic (like the pint sized dragon companion who may or may not have an attitude 😏).

I also appreciate the discussions on grief and feel they add depth and meaning to the characters.
I think a little more character growth and us seeing deeper into the heart and souls of the characters would greatly benefit the story. Despite the deeper grief discussions, sometimes the main characters felt somewhat flat. I would have liked to see some things that made each of them uniquely then!

This is a cute and cozy read that is perfect for the winter and the “ber” months!

🎧AUDIOBOOK UPDATE🎧
“Re-read” via audiobook in October and liked the story and narration even more on the second go round!

The dual narration added to the realness and feeling of the characters. Both Margaret’s and Silas’ narrators have English accents, which always enhances my listening experience!

I really liked to hear the grief portions of this story instead of reading those parts. It felt deeper and added emotion to hear the words, to hear the tremors and feeling as those difficult things were discussed.

I mentioned in my initial review that sometimes the characters fell flat. That was also largely remedied in the audio where you feel like you can hear emotions.

Overall, the audio was very good and enhanced the whole experience! 10/10 recommend!
Profile Image for Silvy (silvylinings).
593 reviews189 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 30, 2026
if you’re in the market for a cute, cozy, and nostalgic romp through a quaint, magical village, make sure this is on your holiday TBR!

this is an ARC review! thank you to avon for the chance to read this early!

this has all of the features of a magical hallmark christmas movie: a pint-sized dragon full of sass, a magical hot chocolate that tastes like your childhood, a hot professor with slutty little glasses, and the low-stakes drama of a competitive new bar on the block in an already-cramped village.

wholesome, heartwarming, and easy to read, but it still packs quite a plot-twist punch. a perfect read to beat the heat, especially if you're into slower paced, cozy fantasies, put up your christmas tree on november 1 every year, and need an extra bit of magic in your life.
Profile Image for Get Your Tinsel in a Tangle.
2,402 reviews76 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 16, 2026
Bernie sees Silas Birchwood enter The Toasty Owl, decides this non-magical man with glasses is apparently a threat to national security, and proceeds to chase him around while breathing fire hard enough to wreck the pub. And SILAS apologizes. Sir. You were attacked by a dragon inside a drinking establishment and somehow walked away thinking you had inconvenienced the owner. Margaret should have known right there that this man was going to become a problem because nobody that emotionally well-adjusted belongs in a romance novel.

Margaret Nettle runs The Toasty Owl in Hex Hollow, where magical people are casually wandering around doing magical nonsense while she is descended from generations of witches and somehow got skipped when the magic was handed out. Her grandmother had magic. Her mother had magic. Margaret got customer service, grief, and the ability to make one hell of a drink. The pub is basically her entire emotional support system because it belonged to the women she loved, which means anytime somebody suggests changing so much as a chair, Margaret reacts like they have proposed bulldozing the family cemetery. She is not grumpy so much as permanently one minor inconvenience away from saying, “No, it’s fine,” in a tone that means everybody needs to evacuate.

Then Silas shows up as the first non-magical teacher at Emberwind Academy, where his job is apparently teaching teenage witches and wizards that sometimes you can solve a problem without pointing a wand at it. I would have paid additional money just to watch him explain the scientific method to children who can make it snow indoors. He is so aggressively useful that it becomes suspicious. The pub needs repairs after Bernie’s arson phase? Silas can fix them. Something breaks? Silas has tools. Margaret needs help? Silas is already halfway up a ladder before she has finished insisting she does not need anybody. He has the exact romantic personality type that says “acts of service” and then accidentally renovates your business.

Naturally, Margaret is not having any of this. She has a pub to run. She has a legacy to protect. She has spent years convincing herself that doing absolutely everything alone is the same thing as being fine. Meanwhile Liza, her best friend and a witch who actually knows how to have a personality outside of self-sacrifice, is basically watching Margaret fall in love in real time while Margaret keeps insisting she is simply accepting free carpentry. Everyone in Hex Hollow can see what is happening except Margaret, who apparently needs a signed affidavit before she will admit a man repeatedly repairing your property because he likes you might be flirting.

And then somebody opens a competing bar across the street because apparently even enchanted villages cannot escape small-business warfare. Margaret is already holding The Toasty Owl together with memory, stubbornness, and magical beverages, so of course this feels less like competition and more like somebody showing up to fight her grandmother’s ghost. Then the secret behind her drinks is stolen, and Margaret spirals because she has spent so long believing whatever made The Toasty Owl special belonged to the women who came before her. At that point I wanted to grab her face and say, babe, these people are not coming here because your hot chocolate has good branding. They are coming because YOU know exactly what they need before they do.

That was the part that got me. Margaret is surrounded by people who love her and somehow interprets every bit of that love as something she has to earn by being useful. Her grief has convinced her that carrying everything alone is the respectful way to preserve what her mother and grandmother built. It is not. It is just lonely. Silas sees that immediately, which is why he works so well with her. He is not trying to give her magic or turn her into somebody else. He just keeps quietly pointing out that maybe she is already the thing everyone comes to The Toasty Owl for.

Also, Christmas is absolutely happening here. Snow, magical hot chocolate, twinkle-light energy, holiday village nonsense, cozy pub evenings, the whole enchanted December situation. It feels like the kind of place where somebody could hand you a mug that tastes like your happiest childhood Christmas and then a dragon would knock over the tree. There are enchanted drinks that stay warm, glittering steam, magical creatures wandering around, and an academy nearby where the corridors can literally snow. Hex Hollow understands seasonal commitment.

By the end, everything wraps up a little more neatly than some of these people probably deserve, and I did occasionally want the story to let a conflict sit there being uncomfortable for five additional minutes before everyone hugged it out. I also wanted a little more mess from Silas because this man is suspiciously functional. Margaret is dragging around grief, insecurity, family expectations, and a competitive pub situation, while Silas is over here being tall, handy, emotionally available, and good with dragons despite being SET ON FIRE. Give this man one toxic hobby. Just one.

Three and a half stars for Enchanted Village. I wanted cozy Christmas magic, an enchanted pub, found family, baby dragon chaos, and a woman slowly realizing that being loved is not another job she has to perform correctly, and that is exactly what I got. Margaret stressed me out, Silas made me suspicious by being too competent, Bernie remains innocent of all charges, and I would absolutely spend December in The Toasty Owl as long as someone confirms the fire insurance is current.

Merry Mayhem Prize: For Letting a Baby Dragon Commit Property Damage in the Name of Romantic Due Diligence

Thank you to Avon and Harper Voyager and NetGalley for the ARC. I came for magical Christmas village vibes and left emotionally attached to a pub, a handyman professor, and one tiny dragon who saw a handsome stranger and chose violence. Seasonal perfection.
Profile Image for Emily Anne.
338 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 11, 2026
This book is like a creamy fruit tartlet where you bite into it and all your favorite things folded in creme sauce start to fall out. Think off-brand Hogsmeade with off-brand wizarding school down the road, plus BABY DRAGON, plus hunky romance. Extra bonus for not giving any of my money to that woman who I no longer like. Bottom line: Firstly, I'm going to need to make more friends to recommend this one too. Secondly, where are my second helpings? I'm going to need Lily to start writing the next one. This time with even extra dragon bits.
Profile Image for Hannah ~.
1,657 reviews46 followers
Review of advance copy
August 3, 2026
Bookseller review copy. Quick note to Lily Starling and editors; if it bites/scratches you and you die, that's venomous. Poison is when you die after biting or touching it.

It's a cute holiday romance. Very quick and easy to read. I didn't personally feel as though it did anything interesting with the genre and the plot had some strange pacing, but overall I can see this working well as something uncomplicated to read over the Christmas break. Perfect for fans of Laurie Gilmore.
Profile Image for Bookish Ann.
181 reviews20 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 12, 2026
Enchanted Village by Lily Starling is the ultimate whimsical, magical, cozy fantasy that hits exactly right when the weather is turning and the temperature starts dropping. If you are looking for a story that gives you all the warm feels, a slow burn romance that is completely earned, and a baby dragon named Bernie (that you will desperately want to nuzzle), add this to your TBR immediately.

Margaret is determined to protect her family's legacy at The Toasty Owl, her beloved pub in the quirky magical village of Hex Hollow. Unfortunately, the tavern sits right next to the prestigious magic academy that once rejected her. When a new rival bar opens across the street and threatens her livelihood, Margaret finds an unlikely ally in Silas. As the academy's very first non-magical professor, Silas is pure sunshine, armed with an infectious smile and a fierce determination to help her save the pub.

The atmospheric setting feels like stepping straight into the festive little village of my dreams. The world-building is incredibly charming, filled with cozy traditions, warming magical drinks, and a delightful found family dynamic. This book handles grief with a gentle touch. Margaret’s loss shapes every choice she makes for the pub, and I loved seeing her carry her mother’s legacy forward on her own terms. The grumpy-meets-sunshine romance between Margaret and Silas builds beautifully, balancing out the high stakes of a stolen family secret.

Such a comforting, heartwarming read that proves magic comes in many different forms.

AUDIOBOOK REVIEW:
I paired my read with the audiobook, and it was perfection. The dual narration brought the cozy, whimsical charm of Hex Hollow completely to life. The narrators captured the distinct personalities of Margaret and Silas beautifully, leaning into the grumpy-meets-sunshine banter with flawless comedic timing and rich emotional depth. Every character voice felt distinct and intentional, making the listening experience incredibly immersive. It felt like sitting right by the hearth in The Toasty Owl.
Profile Image for Beth | Bookwyrm.Beth .
495 reviews39 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 12, 2026
Thank you Harper Audio and LibroFM for the gifted audiobook and Avon for the gifted book!

✦ 𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 ✦
This was a short, easy read and undeniably cozy.

The atmosphere was warm and comforting, while the world felt layered with gentle whimsy. I loved how much the narrative leaned into the comfort found by slowing down and appreciating daily rituals, whether that is brewing magical teas, baking, or sharing quiet conversations by a roaring hearth. The pacing was understandable slow, feeling like a leisurely stroll through a slice-of-life.

The main action here comes from the romantic, grumpy-sunshine friction between Margeret and Silas. Their relationship was a beautifully written, low-angst slow-burn built on mutual respect and genuine emotional vulnerability. Silas stands out as the ultimate green-flag, utilizing soft persistence to gently dismantle Margaret’s defensive walls without ever pushing past her boundaries. Their magic user x mundane contrast added a sweet layer to their bond, as Silas's pure awe of Margaret’s witchcraft makes her feel truly seen. It was refreshing to read a partnership entirely devoid of toxic misunderstandings.

Overall, I recommend this if you’re looking for a high-comfort, character-driven escape filled with whimsical charm and emotional depth.


✦ 𝗔𝘂𝗱𝗶𝗼 𝗡𝗼𝘁𝗲𝘀 ✦
This was a duel narration from Karen Cass and James Meunier. I felt that they had great chemistry and did a wonderful job capturing these character’s distinct personalities. Their banter was enhanced by how much these narrators played off of each other. Excellent, quality recording and production. I definitely recommend the audio for this read.

𝙍𝙚𝙖𝙙 𝙞𝙛 𝙮𝙤𝙪 𝙡𝙤𝙫𝙚 𝙨𝙩𝙤𝙧𝙞𝙚𝙨 𝙩𝙝𝙖𝙩 𝙚𝙭𝙥𝙡𝙤𝙧𝙚:
Grumpy x Sunshine
Opposites Attract
Small Town Romance
Cozy Fantasy
Found Family
Trust and Vulnerability


Follow me on Instagram for more bookish content
Profile Image for Sarah P.
268 reviews1 follower
November 2, 2026
Enchanted Village by Lilly Starling is a very cute, witchy autumn‑and‑winter read, full of magic, mischief, romance, and charming magical creatures. It has all the cosy vibes you could want: a welcoming pub, a magical village, and a cast of characters who make you want to settle in with a hot drink and stay awhile.

Margaret owns a pub that has been passed down through generations of her family, from grandmother to mother to daughter. It's the sort of cosy place where the drinks don't just warm you up—they help you remember moments from your life. Margaret is grumpy, guarded, and not always quick to trust, especially after the disappointments she's faced.

Silas is her complete opposite. A non‑wizard professor at the magical academy, he's sunshine personified: kind, optimistic, and endlessly patient. He's also connected to the very school that once rejected Margaret, which adds an extra layer of tension to their relationship.

When a new bar opens in town and threatens everything Margaret has worked for, she and Silas are forced to join forces. What follows is a sweet, magical story filled with community spirit, romance, and plenty of enchanting moments.

A cosy, charming read perfect for autumn evenings, with lovable characters, a touch of whimsy, and just the right amount of magic. 🍂✨📚
Profile Image for Amela.
325 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 18, 2026
Enchanted Village is such a fun cozy fantasy with a slow burn romance. We follow Margaret, a magical bar owner who has a knack for magical creatures, and Silas, a professor at Emberwind magic school, who is distinctly non-magical but very competent and handy. Margaret is very no-nonsense and doesn't like to accept help from others, thinking she has to do everything herself and protect the legacy of the bar that her mother and grandmother left to her, even though she thinks she's somehow inferior because she doesn't have magic.

Throughout this book Margaret finally learns that hey maybe I can accept help and people actually love me, particularly when it comes to a certain professor who loves helping around her bar after her pet dragon, Bernie, torches it. I liked Margaret and Silas' romance a lot because they really take the time to get to know each other and really have all the tension. The setting was also amazing, it was such a fun magical village with great cozy winter/Christmas vibes. Everything felt like a warm cup of hot chocolate while reading.

My only complaint is that the final conflict felt like it resolved a bit too quickly. I would NOT have forgiven certain characters as quickly as Margaret did.

Thank you to NetGalley and Avon and Harper Voyager for the ARC!
Profile Image for Deidre.
651 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 18, 2026
This one's for the Harry Potter fans who've graduated to cozy fantasy romance - Lily Starling has delivered an off-brand Hogsmeade Christmas slow burn!

Silas, a non-magical chemistry teacher and accidental handyman, lands a job as the only non-magical teacher at a magical school. Margaret is the only non-magical member of her family and the owner of the local pub. When a flashy magician opens a rival pub down the street and threatens Margaret's livelihood, Silas and Margaret team up with the rest of the local shopkeepers to save the day. Along the way, friendship turns into a passionate, open-door romance!

This is a story about community, showing up for your people, dealing with grief and rallying around someone when they need you most. Add in cozy shops, magical creatures, plenty of cocoa, and a charming small-town atmosphere, and you've got a recipe for a delightful winter read.

The dual POVs and narration are a HUGE plus, too. You get both sides of the romance, so there's no guessing what either MC is thinking or how they're feeling. The chemistry is right there on the page!

If you're looking for a relaxing magical Christmas romance read with minimal spice, put this one on your TBR!
Profile Image for Beth.
480 reviews8 followers
November 8, 2026
Thank you to Libro.fm for the gifted audiobook and Avon Books for the gifted physical ARC!

This felt like the coziest read, it gave me the feel of being in a Sarah Beth Durst novel, but on a smaller scale where it's a fairly short book. I was also fortunate to immersive read this with an audio from Libro.fm. The narrators Karen Cass and James Meunier were so good, this is a dual narration and it was perfection. They're voices and tone really matched the characters and their chemistry was great.

The story follows a woman, Margaret, who owns a family pub in a small magical town. The small town vibes are so strong and awesome, and with the magic thrown in it's just so fun. And the dragons in this book are essentially cats and I love them so much. The MMC, Silas, is the greenest of flags. He is sweet and caring and really proves his intentions through actions.

If you're wanting a cozy small town romance read with some fantasy thrown in, grab this one! I totally recommend for a sweet time.

*This audio was given by Libro.fm's influencer program and the physical proof was given by Avon Books. All opinions are my own.*
Profile Image for Alexandria Williams.
1,059 reviews83 followers
November 3, 2026
If you could move into a magical little Christmas village, sip enchanted drinks by a fireplace, and befriend a few mischievous baby dragons… would you?

Welcome to a cozy little village where magic is everywhere and the pub is the heart of the community.

Margaret has spent her life protecting the family legacy behind The Toasty Owl. When a rival bar threatens everything she's built, she finds herself needing a little help.

Silas is a non magical professor with a talent for fixing things, an abundance of patience, and a growing soft spot for one very guarded witch.

There's a lovely thread of grief, self worth, family legacy, and learning to accept help woven in the story. 🐉 Bernie sounds like an absolute scene stealer. The romance brings a little spice, but the real charm is in the cozy atmosphere and lovable cast of characters.

If you're craving a magical holiday escape with a sunshine hero, a guarded heroine, and dragons who have their own agenda then add this one to your TBR babes!
Profile Image for Frankie Ness.
1,912 reviews95 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 15, 2026
I should've read this v listened to it. I love the story, I dislike the narrators. I don't know if it's the very stiff, upper lip, British accent, or the voices, or the way they speak. I feel like I'm a kid being read to or they remind me of audiobooks I'd listen to when I was a child.

The story itself is cute, cozy, and every bit the fall/winter vibe. You will enjoy your brief stay at Hex Hollow, it does feel like Hogsmead, and it did make me crave butterbeer and some candy from the Weasley twins. The romance is predictable, but I didn't mind it. This is a good palate cleanser, and a good appetizer for the coming cool weather months.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 229 reviews