A fascinating account of the Fifth Crusade, the campaign to conquer Egypt and regain the Holy Land
In 1217, the crusader states were in a highly fragile condition. The Fourth Crusade had failed, and Jerusalem had not been recovered. The crusaders now set their sights on Egypt. If the breadbasket of the Mediterranean could be conquered, long-term Christian control of the Holy Land could be ensured. Led by the rulers of Hungary and Austria, and backed by the Knights Templar and Hospitaller, the Fifth Crusade was launched.
Thomas Smith tells the gripping story of the crusade for Egypt. Looking at a wide range of Christian and Muslim sources, Smith sheds new light on the brutal reality of medieval combat on land and water. We see a dramatic beach landing, the invention of a unique floating siege engine, and the conquest of the crucial port city of Damietta―one of the most famous and successful sieges of the crusades. Smith provides fresh insights into strategy, showing how, despite early victories, foolish decision making meant that the crusaders ultimately snatched defeat from the jaws of victory.
This is narrative history as it should be done: a story that’s as compelling to read as any novel but which is nevertheless deeply grounded in the primary sources with the necessary leavening of later scholarly analysis. It’s not actually an easy balance to pull off but Thomas Smith does so masterfully. He sets his stall out in the very first pages where he reconstructs the Crusader assault on a fortified stone tower squatting in the middle of the River Nile, guarding access to the vital port city of Damietta. Smith vividly brings the battle to life, plunging the reader into the reality of crusading, where knights far from home had to adapt to entirely new conditions and challenges. In this case, they adapted by building floating assault stations, lashing together boats and building siege towers on them to allow their knights direct access to the upper storey of the Ayyubid fort.
But not only does Smith bring these campaigning vignettes to vivid life, he also illuminates the context for the calling of the Fifth Crusade, the reasons for its enthusiastic adoption and the complex preparations necessary to transport thousands of knights and their accompanying logistics across Europe and the Mediterranean. Where Smith really shines, though, is in showing how a campaign that started so well slowly fell apart as the result of a cascade of poor decisions, each of little particular importance but ultimately fatal when they came together in the disastrous decision to march south on Cairo.
If you read just one book about the Fifth Crusade, read this one.
In this history, Thomas Smith tells the surprising story of the Fifth Crusade. This story is surprising to most Westerners because most people in Western countries know very little about this crusade, which aimed to conquer Egypt to undercut Muslim power in the Middle East. If the Crusaders had successfully conquered Egypt, the Crusader states in the Holy Land would no longer have been exposed from the direction of Egypt; at the time, Egypt was one of the major centers of Islamic power.
This is a well-written history, and includes many telling details about this crusade, including the surprising attempt by Saint Francis of Assisi (yes, that Saint Francis) to convert the sultan of Egypt. I appreciate that the author took Christian motivations and practices seriously, including an open-minded explanation of Medieval Christians' interest in apocalyptic texts that seemed to foretell imminent Christian victory over their Muslim rivals. Among other things, I learned that contemporary Christians did not number the Crusades as we do today but rather viewed all of the Crusades as a single movement, a single conflict against Muslims.
One thing I wish the author had given more attention to was the Mongols' approach from the east. The author makes passing references to the Mongols, but could have devoted more space to the Mongol advance, which directly affected the course and outcome of the Fifth Crusade.
I enjoyed this book and recommend it to anyone who wishes to learn more about this campaign, or about the Crusades in general.
This is what I believe the kids would refer to as “a banger” I love historical fiction, which of course you can’t have without historical fact. The Instagram algorithm introduced me to Thomas and his work, possibly as I have been obsessively listening to the “This Is History” podcast by another cracking historian Dan Jones. I knew as soon as I saw the cover, like a cold can of Irn Bru on a hot day I must have it.
It’s a fairly brief, or concise telling of the failed attempt by the Christian forces, to recapture the Holy Land of Jerusalem by seizing Egypt, which they see as the key to victory. Thomas carefully explains who are the key players on both sides, explains the thoughts behind it, how it was funded, how the manpower (and women power) was sought. We learn what was promised to the crusaders, such as remission of sins, and the safety of their property and assets whilst away. We’re introduced to prominent chroniclers of the day, again on both sides and get a little glimpse into what people could do to participate without actually fighting. We also learn about medieval napalm, which I loved.
The writing is an excellent mix of narrative style storytelling, coupled with historical fact and explanations of key sections which I think makes a potentially very dense subject matter, broadly appealing to a wider audience. If like me, you like historical fiction, or even certain fantasy novels (Abercrombie type fantasy) then this could and should appeal to you.
I always struggle with non fiction that reads like a text book, whereas this absolute cracker, vividly retells the tale of this seismic and under represented piece of history. More please.
This one checks all the boxes. The Crusades have always been a fascinating topic for me but I knew nothing about this particular campaign. The author has obviously consulted a wide variety of primary sources for this work. And he writes in a smooth, compelling manner that makes the pages race by and his large cast of historical personages really come to life. An absolute winner.
A brilliant book that completely transformed my understanding of the scale of this Crusade; I hadn’t realized the success achieved was so significant—which makes its collapse all the more regrettable. It’s written in a very lively and engaging way—highly recommended!
Thomas Smith’s The Fifth Crusade is an exceptionally readable and thoroughly researched account of one of the less familiar major crusading expeditions.
One of the book’s greatest strengths is its refusal to treat the crusade’s eventual failure as inevitable. Smith shows how the capture of Damietta created a genuine strategic opportunity and reassesses familiar episodes such as Sultan al-Kāmil’s offer of Jerusalem and the much-maligned leadership of Cardinal Pelagius.
The result is a vivid, persuasive history that combines serious scholarship with narrative momentum without losing sight of the uncertainties and disagreements within the surviving evidence.
An excellent modern introduction to the Fifth Crusade and one I would readily recommend to readers interested in crusading history and the medieval Mediterranean.
Thomas W. Smith’s new book, The Fifth Crusade: A History of the Epic Campaign to Conquer Egypt, was a real treat to read. It strikes a great balance between being informative and having a novel-like writing style, making it an engaging read from start to finish.
Even if you’ve already read a couple of books about the Fifth Crusade, there’s still plenty here to learn. Smith manages to bring fresh insights to a well-known topic while keeping the story moving at a steady pace. If you’re interested in the Crusades and want a history book that never feels dry or overly academic, this is an easy recommendation.
Was fantastic to meet Tom at the book launch in Rugby, and despite hearing him talk about the events of the fifth crusade at that event, I was hooked by the book regardless! The blend of personal narrative, contextual information without information overload, and it clearly being incredibly well sourced without descending into dryness, all made this a fantastic read. A story worth telling, told brilliantly.
I look forward to any future works and will recommend this one to all my history (and Assassin's Creed) loving friends!
An account written almost entirely from the Crusader perspective and within that the papal as opposed to imperial perspective, culminating in the treason of Frederick II who had the cheek to recover Jerusalem with no bloodshed at all.
A very readable narrative history of the epic whirlwind that was the Fifth Crusade. Thomas Smith has written an account of the crusade that is interesting, engrossing and reads like a train. I look forward to more narrative history by his hand.