When I first heard about the new Rick Riordan series, after ordering the title for the library, I looked around for titles on Viking mythology, knowing perfectly well we didn't have very much and assuming that there would be a demand once the Magnus Chase and the gods of Asgard (Sword of Summer) hit the hold shelves. I found a big book by Napoli and I found this book and ordered both. I've read the Napoli title and was disappointed. She is a feminist, which I absolutely approve of being, but used it to make interjections that were inappropriate. Yes, the Viking myths were NOT pro-women. Considering the times they were created, it would have been pretty odd if they had been. However, considering the times, the Norse were remarkably pro women. Women could hold property which existed nowhere in the Christian world. According to this book, Thor Speaks, women could even go on raids!
I just finished this book, Thor Speaks! It is everything I wanted the library to have. While it looks considerably smaller and shorter than the Napoli title, I think there is actually more information in this title. Napoli and her publishers assumed that the way to reach youth today is to have a bright book with lots of pretty illustrations. A substantial amount is illustrations. The other popular way to reach to youth is to write about a subject using humor. That is the approach Shecter took and it works much better. It is presented as if the god Thor is talking to the audience. The humor works and makes it much more interesting than the Napoli book. If there are any librarians around who haven't ordered yet to fill in their Norse mythology section, and can only order one title, make it this title! Less room on the shelf and a better experience. It covers all the big stories and also has information about the Viking people so there is a nice amount of history as a bonus!