I'm the kind of person, that will pick up a book and buy it, purely for the reason of it having "Tolkien" stamped on it. Everything related to Tolkien, I will surely buy, even if it is to just look good in my bookcase. This book actually fulfills that particular wish. It is a beautiful leather-bound book, and it looks amazing even just to look at.
When one actually reads this book, they will not find an atlas, as this is very much lacking in maps. Instead, there are short snippets, maybe a few paragraphs of information about the various locations covered in here, and a lot of artwork. Now, some of the artwork is beautiful, and I think that is essentially, what makes this book good, but, some of it, I didn't appreciate in the least, and for me, it looked too simple.
I think the accuracy of some of the information in here is definitely questionable, and I have heard that others that have read this have done the same. I think this is a light-hearted book to dip into, but, if you're a die-hard Tolkien fan like me, then don't expect too much from it.