What do you think?
Rate this book
Dual Identities: Living in Meier's Shadow
"[A] beautifully rendered and deeply personal narrative." -Peter Salovey, president emeritus, Yale University
A Faux Photo. A Heavy Burden. Two Lives, Forever Intertwined.
"You hear nothing!" his mother shouts. But like many young children of Holocaust survivors, Arthur hears too much. And his mother, Sally Finkelstein Horwitz, has a lot to say. About heroism and horror. Resilience and remorse. Antisemitism and spineless American Jews.
Hiding in closets or a bathtub, Arthur absorbs the tales she shares with friends and other survivors. One day, seeking to swipe a few bucks, Arthur discovers an iconic Holocaust image of a terrified boy tucked in among the other photos in the sleeves of his mother's wallet. "Who's this?" he demands to know. She insists it's her little brother Meier, who was murdered by the Nazis. But Arthur knows it isn't. The photo further cements his growing understanding that he's been saddled with the responsibility of living two lives-his and the one Meier never had. It's a burden that will shape Arthur's life, family, and media career.
Dual Living in Meier's Shadow removes filters previously inhibiting children of survivors from sharing their own unvarnished growing-up-in-America stories while providing new insights on the impact of intergenerational trauma and the path to coping, healing, reconciliation, and remembrance.
A Faux Photo. A Heavy Burden. Two Lives, Forever Intertwined.
"You hear nothing!" his mother shouts. But like many young children of Holocaust survivors, Arthur hears too much. And his mother, Sally Finkelstein Horwitz, has a lot to say. About heroism and horror. Resilience and remorse. Antisemitism and spineless American Jews.
Hiding in closets or a bathtub, Arthur absorbs the tales she shares with friends and other survivors. One day, seeking to swipe a few bucks, Arthur discovers an iconic Holocaust image of a terrified boy tucked in among the other photos in the sleeves of his mother's wallet. "Who's this?" he demands to know. She insists it's her little brother Meier, who was murdered by the Nazis. But Arthur knows it isn't. The photo further cements his growing understanding that he's been saddled with the responsibility of living two lives-his and the one Meier never had. It's a burden that will shape Arthur's life, family, and media career.
Dual Living in Meier's Shadow removes filters previously inhibiting children of survivors from sharing their own unvarnished growing-up-in-America stories while providing new insights on the impact of intergenerational trauma and the path to coping, healing, reconciliation, and remembrance.
276 pages, Paperback
Published April 28, 2026
About the author
Arthur Myron Horwitz
2 books1 follower Arthur M. Horwitz is a nationally respected journalist, publisher and civic leader whose career is recognized by enshrinement in the Michigan Journalism Hall of Fame and establishment of the Arthur M. Horwitz Collection at the University of Michigan.
Arthur’s writing has appeared in secular and ethnic publications and academic journals. A persuasive and sought-after speaker, he is a frequent guest on affiliate news programs of ABC, NBC, PBS and NPR.
Arthur chaired the Michigan Civil Rights Commission and the board of Detroit/PBS. He
is a graduate of the University of Connecticut and the Yale School of Management.
Arthur’s writing has appeared in secular and ethnic publications and academic journals. A persuasive and sought-after speaker, he is a frequent guest on affiliate news programs of ABC, NBC, PBS and NPR.
Arthur chaired the Michigan Civil Rights Commission and the board of Detroit/PBS. He
is a graduate of the University of Connecticut and the Yale School of Management.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Some years ago, I read Helen Epstein's work on the children of Holocaust survivors, and how they could feel extreme guilt and suffer from PTSD. Thus, I was expecting to read about those things in Arthur M. Horwitz’s book. Turns out, there is little of that in this memoir. This is more a story of a man who handled his mother’s horrors well and did not let such things keep him from having a happy, highly successful life. While at times I felt the book was weighed down with way too many job descriptions and duties, overall, it painted an affecting story of not being defeated by anything.
The author's mother Sala, too, went on to become someone who accomplished much in her lifetime. She was not broken by the Nazis. She never forgot but did not leave behind a legacy of mental problems and defeat. Yes, she repeatedly reminded her son he had to also live the life her little brother never got to live. Yes, she carried a picture in her wallet of a little boy being terrified by Nazis, claiming it was her brother, when it was not. Apparently, though, Mr. Horwitz learned to accommodate his mother’s wishes, without surrendering his own wishes and dreams.
He became a highly successful journalist, editor, publisher and civic leader; fighting not only for Jews, but for others who needed a fighter and defender. Interestingly, the love of his life turned out to be a woman who also had a mother who was a Holocaust survivor. They would go on to create a happy family with children and grandchildren. The Nazis would not wipe out the Jews in the world. Added to that, Mr. Horwitz developed a love for horses and riding as a child, and that love carried over to his adult years. When thinking about the horrors of the Holocaust, what could be more mentally freeing from those horrors than being all alone riding a fast horse across open land in fresh air.
(Note: I received a free e-ARC of this book from NetGalley and the author or publisher.)
The author's mother Sala, too, went on to become someone who accomplished much in her lifetime. She was not broken by the Nazis. She never forgot but did not leave behind a legacy of mental problems and defeat. Yes, she repeatedly reminded her son he had to also live the life her little brother never got to live. Yes, she carried a picture in her wallet of a little boy being terrified by Nazis, claiming it was her brother, when it was not. Apparently, though, Mr. Horwitz learned to accommodate his mother’s wishes, without surrendering his own wishes and dreams.
He became a highly successful journalist, editor, publisher and civic leader; fighting not only for Jews, but for others who needed a fighter and defender. Interestingly, the love of his life turned out to be a woman who also had a mother who was a Holocaust survivor. They would go on to create a happy family with children and grandchildren. The Nazis would not wipe out the Jews in the world. Added to that, Mr. Horwitz developed a love for horses and riding as a child, and that love carried over to his adult years. When thinking about the horrors of the Holocaust, what could be more mentally freeing from those horrors than being all alone riding a fast horse across open land in fresh air.
(Note: I received a free e-ARC of this book from NetGalley and the author or publisher.)
June 18, 2026
Dual Identities: Living in Meier’s Shadow by Arthur Myron Horwitz is a deeply personal and emotionally resonant memoir that explores the long shadow of Holocaust survival and the intergenerational impact of trauma within a family shaped by memory, loss, and inherited responsibility.
At the heart of the book is the author’s childhood experience as the child of a Holocaust survivor, navigating a household shaped by intense emotional history and unfiltered storytelling. Through the voice of his mother, Sally Finkelstein Horwitz, the narrative conveys the weight of survival, remembrance, and unresolved grief, as well as the psychological complexity passed down to the next generation.
One of the book’s most striking elements is its exploration of truth and perception, particularly through the discovery of a Holocaust photograph that becomes central to the author’s evolving understanding of identity and responsibility. This moment serves as a turning point, deepening the memoir’s investigation into memory, authenticity, and the stories families carry forward.
The memoir is especially effective in its portrayal of intergenerational trauma. Rather than treating history as distant, it presents it as an ongoing presence that shapes childhood, family dynamics, and adult identity. The author’s reflections on growing up in the shadow of a symbolic figure add emotional depth and psychological nuance to the narrative.
Beyond its historical context, the book also offers insight into healing, reconciliation, and the process of coming to terms with inherited emotional burdens. It situates personal experience within a broader cultural and historical framework, making it both intimate and socially significant.
Overall, Dual Identities: Living in Meier’s Shadow is a powerful and thought-provoking memoir that will resonate with readers interested in Holocaust history, intergenerational trauma, Jewish family narratives, and deeply personal accounts of identity formation.
At the heart of the book is the author’s childhood experience as the child of a Holocaust survivor, navigating a household shaped by intense emotional history and unfiltered storytelling. Through the voice of his mother, Sally Finkelstein Horwitz, the narrative conveys the weight of survival, remembrance, and unresolved grief, as well as the psychological complexity passed down to the next generation.
One of the book’s most striking elements is its exploration of truth and perception, particularly through the discovery of a Holocaust photograph that becomes central to the author’s evolving understanding of identity and responsibility. This moment serves as a turning point, deepening the memoir’s investigation into memory, authenticity, and the stories families carry forward.
The memoir is especially effective in its portrayal of intergenerational trauma. Rather than treating history as distant, it presents it as an ongoing presence that shapes childhood, family dynamics, and adult identity. The author’s reflections on growing up in the shadow of a symbolic figure add emotional depth and psychological nuance to the narrative.
Beyond its historical context, the book also offers insight into healing, reconciliation, and the process of coming to terms with inherited emotional burdens. It situates personal experience within a broader cultural and historical framework, making it both intimate and socially significant.
Overall, Dual Identities: Living in Meier’s Shadow is a powerful and thought-provoking memoir that will resonate with readers interested in Holocaust history, intergenerational trauma, Jewish family narratives, and deeply personal accounts of identity formation.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I see what the author was trying to do in this memoir, but it felt a little forced to me. If we are speaking of dual identities the balance feels a little off. In reality, the author doesn't have the whole story of his ancestors, nor can he. I think he should have just told his own story and perhaps written another book about the Holocaust and his family's experience.
Thank you to NetGalley for an advance copy of this book. A story that needed telling.
Thank you to NetGalley for an advance copy of this book. A story that needed telling.
June 3, 2026
I'm burnt out on memoirs but this one was incredible! I especially loved it due to the Detroit connection.
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews